Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why it’s rational to be emotional | Bella Heesom | TEDxNewnham


I’ve got a question for you do you think

I’ve got a question for you do you think you’re clever be honest my answers yes I

you’re clever be honest my answers yes I

you’re clever be honest my answers yes I think I’m clever don’t get me wrong when

think I’m clever don’t get me wrong when

think I’m clever don’t get me wrong when I was a student at Cambridge in that

I was a student at Cambridge in that

I was a student at Cambridge in that context I was distinctly average I’m not

context I was distinctly average I’m not

context I was distinctly average I’m not a genius I am quite a quick thinker next

a genius I am quite a quick thinker next

a genius I am quite a quick thinker next question are you proud of that whether

question are you proud of that whether

question are you proud of that whether you think you’re clever or you don’t are

you think you’re clever or you don’t are

you think you’re clever or you don’t are you proud of that fact my answer is yes

you proud of that fact my answer is yes

you proud of that fact my answer is yes again and I don’t think I’m alone

again and I don’t think I’m alone

again and I don’t think I’m alone Society encourages us to celebrate

Society encourages us to celebrate

Society encourages us to celebrate academic achievement when I was offered

academic achievement when I was offered

academic achievement when I was offered that place at Cambridge people

that place at Cambridge people

that place at Cambridge people congratulated me we perceive intellect

congratulated me we perceive intellect

congratulated me we perceive intellect as valuable new question do you think

as valuable new question do you think

as valuable new question do you think you’re emotional now before I answer

you’re emotional now before I answer

you’re emotional now before I answer this one I’m gonna rewind 10 years here

this one I’m gonna rewind 10 years here

this one I’m gonna rewind 10 years here in 2008 my answer is a hard no I am NOT

in 2008 my answer is a hard no I am NOT

in 2008 my answer is a hard no I am NOT an emotional person it takes a minimum

an emotional person it takes a minimum

an emotional person it takes a minimum of half an hour of violins for a film to

of half an hour of violins for a film to

of half an hour of violins for a film to make me cry I’m very slow to anger and

make me cry I’m very slow to anger and

make me cry I’m very slow to anger and even when I do I just go disturbingly

even when I do I just go disturbingly

even when I do I just go disturbingly still and calm I’m really level-headed

still and calm I’m really level-headed

still and calm I’m really level-headed final question whether you think you’re

final question whether you think you’re

final question whether you think you’re emotional or you don’t are you proud of

emotional or you don’t are you proud of

emotional or you don’t are you proud of that again in 2008 my answer is a big

that again in 2008 my answer is a big

that again in 2008 my answer is a big yes I was really proud of being a

yes I was really proud of being a

yes I was really proud of being a logical person

logical person

logical person I even subscribed to the idea that I

I even subscribed to the idea that I

I even subscribed to the idea that I wasn’t like other girls because I wasn’t

wasn’t like other girls because I wasn’t

wasn’t like other girls because I wasn’t some infuriating mass of uncontrollable

some infuriating mass of uncontrollable

some infuriating mass of uncontrollable emotions you could rely on me to be

emotions you could rely on me to be

emotions you could rely on me to be reasonable and rational now spoiler

reasonable and rational now spoiler

reasonable and rational now spoiler alert other girls are awesome feelings

alert other girls are awesome feelings

alert other girls are awesome feelings are your friends and I was wrong so why

are your friends and I was wrong so why

are your friends and I was wrong so why did I think this way again society

did I think this way again society

did I think this way again society sanctions they value judgment when was

sanctions they value judgment when was

sanctions they value judgment when was the last time you were congratulated on

the last time you were congratulated on

the last time you were congratulated on having a really good cry

having a really good cry

having a really good cry well it’s more likely that you will have

well it’s more likely that you will have

well it’s more likely that you will have been shamed for expressing emotion to

been shamed for expressing emotion to

been shamed for expressing emotion to get emotional is to be irrational to

get emotional is to be irrational to

get emotional is to be irrational to lose your right to be taken seriously to

lose your right to be taken seriously to

lose your right to be taken seriously to be listened to

be listened to

be listened to alright don’t get emotional don’t pay

alright don’t get emotional don’t pay

alright don’t get emotional don’t pay any attention to her she’s just upset

any attention to her she’s just upset

any attention to her she’s just upset calm down dear this idea goes all the

calm down dear this idea goes all the

calm down dear this idea goes all the way back to the ancient Greeks when I

way back to the ancient Greeks when I

way back to the ancient Greeks when I was studying philosophy I read Plato’s

was studying philosophy I read Plato’s

was studying philosophy I read Plato’s Republic in which he puts forward his

Republic in which he puts forward his

Republic in which he puts forward his tripartite theory of the soul according

tripartite theory of the soul according

tripartite theory of the soul according to Plato our psyche is made up of three

to Plato our psyche is made up of three

to Plato our psyche is made up of three distinct parts reason the rational part

distinct parts reason the rational part

distinct parts reason the rational part which is the source of understanding

which is the source of understanding

which is the source of understanding appetite which is the source of physical

appetite which is the source of physical

appetite which is the source of physical desires for things like food and sex and

desires for things like food and sex and

desires for things like food and sex and spirit which is the source of emotion

spirit which is the source of emotion

spirit which is the source of emotion and the motivation for action

and the motivation for action

and the motivation for action according to Plato in a good person

according to Plato in a good person

according to Plato in a good person reason is in control he used the analogy

reason is in control he used the analogy

reason is in control he used the analogy of a charioteer holding the reins of two

of a charioteer holding the reins of two

of a charioteer holding the reins of two horses reason is the charioteer and

horses reason is the charioteer and

horses reason is the charioteer and appetite and spirit for the horses well

appetite and spirit for the horses well

appetite and spirit for the horses well they’re good servants they pull the

they’re good servants they pull the

they’re good servants they pull the chariot along but they must be directed

chariot along but they must be directed

chariot along but they must be directed by reason reason is holding the reins

by reason reason is holding the reins

by reason reason is holding the reins and the whip the message is clear our

and the whip the message is clear our

and the whip the message is clear our rational thoughts are superior to our

rational thoughts are superior to our

rational thoughts are superior to our emotions I related to this picture of

emotions I related to this picture of

emotions I related to this picture of the mind and it served me well in my

the mind and it served me well in my

the mind and it served me well in my studies and in my life my reason was a

studies and in my life my reason was a

studies and in my life my reason was a formidable weapon I could fight anyone

formidable weapon I could fight anyone

formidable weapon I could fight anyone in anything with my razor-sharp logic

in anything with my razor-sharp logic

in anything with my razor-sharp logic and it made me feel secure I was

and it made me feel secure I was

and it made me feel secure I was standing on a solid foundation

standing on a solid foundation

standing on a solid foundation unshakeable and then the earth shifted

unshakeable and then the earth shifted

unshakeable and then the earth shifted beneath my feet and slipped away leaving

beneath my feet and slipped away leaving

beneath my feet and slipped away leaving me in freefall one sunny day in August

me in freefall one sunny day in August

me in freefall one sunny day in August of 2010 I called my dad Pete to check in

of 2010 I called my dad Pete to check in

of 2010 I called my dad Pete to check in he had just found out that he had an

he had just found out that he had an

he had just found out that he had an inoperable brain tumor that was going to

inoperable brain tumor that was going to

inoperable brain tumor that was going to kill him my world exploded a little bit

kill him my world exploded a little bit

kill him my world exploded a little bit it turns out in the face of actual real

it turns out in the face of actual real

it turns out in the face of actual real life death reason is pretty useless you

life death reason is pretty useless you

life death reason is pretty useless you can’t argue with death I could barely

can’t argue with death I could barely

can’t argue with death I could barely comprehend

comprehend

comprehend it death was unimaginable impossible but

it death was unimaginable impossible but

it death was unimaginable impossible but my dad did die two months after that

my dad did die two months after that

my dad did die two months after that phone call my emotion crashed through me

phone call my emotion crashed through me

phone call my emotion crashed through me like a tidal wave it washed away

like a tidal wave it washed away

like a tidal wave it washed away everything in its path reason didn’t

everything in its path reason didn’t

everything in its path reason didn’t stand a chance it was drowned the scale

stand a chance it was drowned the scale

stand a chance it was drowned the scale and depth of my emotion was a shock to

and depth of my emotion was a shock to

and depth of my emotion was a shock to me I mean of course you’d expect it to

me I mean of course you’d expect it to

me I mean of course you’d expect it to be upsetting your dad dying but it was

be upsetting your dad dying but it was

be upsetting your dad dying but it was physically painful maybe I could have

physically painful maybe I could have

physically painful maybe I could have avoided this pain by shutting down

avoided this pain by shutting down

avoided this pain by shutting down emotionally but I’m so glad I didn’t I

emotionally but I’m so glad I didn’t I

emotionally but I’m so glad I didn’t I allowed myself to feel the full

allowed myself to feel the full

allowed myself to feel the full magnitude of my agony at this kind

magnitude of my agony at this kind

magnitude of my agony at this kind curious lovely man ceasing to exist and

curious lovely man ceasing to exist and

curious lovely man ceasing to exist and that also allowed me to feel immense

that also allowed me to feel immense

that also allowed me to feel immense gratitude for the fact that he had

gratitude for the fact that he had

gratitude for the fact that he had existed and he had loved me and I him in

existed and he had loved me and I him in

existed and he had loved me and I him in order to feel the good things you have

order to feel the good things you have

order to feel the good things you have to expose yourself to the risk of

to expose yourself to the risk of

to expose yourself to the risk of feeling shit things if you love someone

feeling shit things if you love someone

feeling shit things if you love someone you’ve got a lot to lose and if you’ve

you’ve got a lot to lose and if you’ve

you’ve got a lot to lose and if you’ve got a lot to lose you’re vulnerable but

got a lot to lose you’re vulnerable but

got a lot to lose you’re vulnerable but if you’ve got nothing to lose

if you’ve got nothing to lose

if you’ve got nothing to lose you’ve got nothing so if you’re

you’ve got nothing so if you’re

you’ve got nothing so if you’re vulnerable you’re lucky so was it

vulnerable you’re lucky so was it

vulnerable you’re lucky so was it irrational for me to get emotional about

irrational for me to get emotional about

irrational for me to get emotional about my dad’s death

my dad’s death

my dad’s death of course not it was vital emotion is

of course not it was vital emotion is

of course not it was vital emotion is the key to human connection what’s more

the key to human connection what’s more

the key to human connection what’s more important than connecting with the other

important than connecting with the other

important than connecting with the other humans we share this planet with so why

humans we share this planet with so why

humans we share this planet with so why didn’t I prize my emotions as highly as

didn’t I prize my emotions as highly as

didn’t I prize my emotions as highly as I prized my intellect

I prized my intellect

I prized my intellect well my intellect was a form of

well my intellect was a form of

well my intellect was a form of self-defense those emotions were painful

self-defense those emotions were painful

self-defense those emotions were painful and I well you might assume that I would

and I well you might assume that I would

and I well you might assume that I would have learnt my lesson and realized that

have learnt my lesson and realized that

have learnt my lesson and realized that it was worth going through that pain but

it was worth going through that pain but

it was worth going through that pain but I made the mistake of thinking that I’ve

I made the mistake of thinking that I’ve

I made the mistake of thinking that I’ve done it once and that was enough

done it once and that was enough

done it once and that was enough so two years after my dad died I got

so two years after my dad died I got

so two years after my dad died I got another phone call my mom Yasmine who

another phone call my mom Yasmine who

another phone call my mom Yasmine who had suffered from chronic degenerate

had suffered from chronic degenerate

had suffered from chronic degenerate multiple sclerosis ever since I could

multiple sclerosis ever since I could

multiple sclerosis ever since I could remember had been admitted into hospital

remember had been admitted into hospital

remember had been admitted into hospital with pneumonia there was a chance she

with pneumonia there was a chance she

with pneumonia there was a chance she wouldn’t survive the night I was afraid

wouldn’t survive the night I was afraid

wouldn’t survive the night I was afraid so what happened

so what happened

so what happened my reason kicked right back in to

my reason kicked right back in to

my reason kicked right back in to protect me I had done this before I was

protect me I had done this before I was

protect me I had done this before I was an expert at losing a parent I mean she

an expert at losing a parent I mean she

an expert at losing a parent I mean she would obviously die there’s no point

would obviously die there’s no point

would obviously die there’s no point battling that but I could fight grief

battling that but I could fight grief

battling that but I could fight grief all guns blazing I had no desire to

all guns blazing I had no desire to

all guns blazing I had no desire to spend another two months crying thank

spend another two months crying thank

spend another two months crying thank you very much no I was armed and I was

you very much no I was armed and I was

you very much no I was armed and I was ready death would not get me again my

ready death would not get me again my

ready death would not get me again my mum died a week before Christmas we had

mum died a week before Christmas we had

mum died a week before Christmas we had the funeral in January and the following

the funeral in January and the following

the funeral in January and the following evening I went to the theater and I

evening I went to the theater and I

evening I went to the theater and I bumped into a friend from drama school

bumped into a friend from drama school

bumped into a friend from drama school he asked me how my Christmas had been

he asked me how my Christmas had been

he asked me how my Christmas had been and I told him it had been a quiet one

and I told him it had been a quiet one

and I told him it had been a quiet one no point ruining a perfectly lovely

no point ruining a perfectly lovely

no point ruining a perfectly lovely evening with depressing details my

evening with depressing details my

evening with depressing details my ability to control my emotions has been

ability to control my emotions has been

ability to control my emotions has been compared to a superpower you see my mum

compared to a superpower you see my mum

compared to a superpower you see my mum was the strongest person I knew she was

was the strongest person I knew she was

was the strongest person I knew she was a black disabled lesbian single mother

a black disabled lesbian single mother

a black disabled lesbian single mother she grew up in a combination of abusive

she grew up in a combination of abusive

she grew up in a combination of abusive family homes children’s care homes and

family homes children’s care homes and

family homes children’s care homes and foster homes

foster homes

foster homes she went to about 30 different schools

she went to about 30 different schools

she went to about 30 different schools and yet somehow she taught herself to

and yet somehow she taught herself to

and yet somehow she taught herself to read and eventually earned herself a

read and eventually earned herself a

read and eventually earned herself a place at Cambridge

place at Cambridge

place at Cambridge she was formidable I always wanted to be

she was formidable I always wanted to be

she was formidable I always wanted to be as strong as her and I conflated

as strong as her and I conflated

as strong as her and I conflated strength with a lack of emotion to me to

strength with a lack of emotion to me to

strength with a lack of emotion to me to be overwhelmed with emotion was to be

be overwhelmed with emotion was to be

be overwhelmed with emotion was to be weak and that was something I would

weak and that was something I would

weak and that was something I would never be I needed so much to be strong I

never be I needed so much to be strong I

never be I needed so much to be strong I didn’t let myself feel so time for

didn’t let myself feel so time for

didn’t let myself feel so time for another spoiler alert that brooch didn’t

another spoiler alert that brooch didn’t

another spoiler alert that brooch didn’t work I stuck with it for about a year

work I stuck with it for about a year

work I stuck with it for about a year until my unacknowledged guilt at failing

until my unacknowledged guilt at failing

until my unacknowledged guilt at failing to properly mourn for my mom or really

to properly mourn for my mom or really

to properly mourn for my mom or really honor her memory gave me nightmares

honor her memory gave me nightmares

honor her memory gave me nightmares luckily for me I discovered another form

luckily for me I discovered another form

luckily for me I discovered another form of release I started to write I would

of release I started to write I would

of release I started to write I would sit at my little desk in the window with

sit at my little desk in the window with

sit at my little desk in the window with my notebook and my pen and I would dive

my notebook and my pen and I would dive

my notebook and my pen and I would dive headfirst into the murky waters

headfirst into the murky waters

headfirst into the murky waters my grief I would sit with the agony and

my grief I would sit with the agony and

my grief I would sit with the agony and with the beauty and shape them into

with the beauty and shape them into

with the beauty and shape them into words and cover the paper in my insides

words and cover the paper in my insides

words and cover the paper in my insides and I made another discovery not only is

and I made another discovery not only is

and I made another discovery not only is emotion the key to human connection it’s

emotion the key to human connection it’s

emotion the key to human connection it’s also at the root of my creativity I

also at the root of my creativity I

also at the root of my creativity I create from a place of unknowing my

create from a place of unknowing my

create from a place of unknowing my creative process is an emotional

creative process is an emotional

creative process is an emotional exploration of questions that logic

exploration of questions that logic

exploration of questions that logic alone cannot answer now I was able to

alone cannot answer now I was able to

alone cannot answer now I was able to literally make peace with my mum’s death

literally make peace with my mum’s death

literally make peace with my mum’s death through writing a play about my

through writing a play about my

through writing a play about my experience of grief

experience of grief

experience of grief so how why because in writing

so how why because in writing

so how why because in writing I found a context in which my emotions

I found a context in which my emotions

I found a context in which my emotions were valuable instead of trying to

were valuable instead of trying to

were valuable instead of trying to control them I tried to express them as

control them I tried to express them as

control them I tried to express them as vividly as possible

vividly as possible

vividly as possible I don’t expect you all to write a play

I don’t expect you all to write a play

I don’t expect you all to write a play but you can create a space for your

but you can create a space for your

but you can create a space for your emotions in your own way it could be

emotions in your own way it could be

emotions in your own way it could be music or meditation or running or

music or meditation or running or

music or meditation or running or painting it doesn’t really matter as

painting it doesn’t really matter as

painting it doesn’t really matter as long as you let them out when I started

long as you let them out when I started

long as you let them out when I started performing the play written I made

performing the play written I made

performing the play written I made another discovery emotion is the key to

another discovery emotion is the key to

another discovery emotion is the key to cultivating empathy I made myself

cultivating empathy I made myself

cultivating empathy I made myself vulnerable on stage I exposed the

vulnerable on stage I exposed the

vulnerable on stage I exposed the shadowy shameful messy emotions and a

shadowy shameful messy emotions and a

shadowy shameful messy emotions and a magical thing happened audiences didn’t

magical thing happened audiences didn’t

magical thing happened audiences didn’t turn away in horror and disgust I was an

turn away in horror and disgust I was an

turn away in horror and disgust I was an ostracized instead person after person

ostracized instead person after person

ostracized instead person after person quoted my words back to me in

quoted my words back to me in

quoted my words back to me in recognition they felt seen and so did I

recognition they felt seen and so did I

recognition they felt seen and so did I you see when you make yourself

you see when you make yourself

you see when you make yourself vulnerable you’re making an offer an

vulnerable you’re making an offer an

vulnerable you’re making an offer an offer of human connection again you may

offer of human connection again you may

offer of human connection again you may not fancy sharing your deepest darkest

not fancy sharing your deepest darkest

not fancy sharing your deepest darkest secrets onstage with hundreds of

secrets onstage with hundreds of

secrets onstage with hundreds of strangers and that’s fine each their own

strangers and that’s fine each their own

strangers and that’s fine each their own but maybe you could think of your

but maybe you could think of your

but maybe you could think of your vulnerability as a precious gift and you

vulnerability as a precious gift and you

vulnerability as a precious gift and you could try and find at least one

could try and find at least one

could try and find at least one a person to share it with because it

a person to share it with because it

a person to share it with because it will almost certainly bring you closer

will almost certainly bring you closer

will almost certainly bring you closer together and make you feel less alone

together and make you feel less alone

together and make you feel less alone you know I’m not going to lie to you I

you know I’m not going to lie to you I

you know I’m not going to lie to you I still control my emotions I’m very good

still control my emotions I’m very good

still control my emotions I’m very good at it and I’m still a rational person

at it and I’m still a rational person

at it and I’m still a rational person I’m still quite proud of it but having

I’m still quite proud of it but having

I’m still quite proud of it but having evaluated all of the evidence my reason

evaluated all of the evidence my reason

evaluated all of the evidence my reason has realized that my emotions are not

has realized that my emotions are not

has realized that my emotions are not the enemy my emotions don’t make me

the enemy my emotions don’t make me

the enemy my emotions don’t make me stupid in fact my emotions are what make

stupid in fact my emotions are what make

stupid in fact my emotions are what make my life worth living

yes to be emotional is to be vulnerable

yes to be emotional is to be vulnerable but to be vulnerable isn’t to be weak to

but to be vulnerable isn’t to be weak to

but to be vulnerable isn’t to be weak to be vulnerable is to be alive thank you

be vulnerable is to be alive thank you

be vulnerable is to be alive thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *