Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Minority Media Matters | Tianna Mañón | TEDxFlourCity


there isn’t a lot of love for mainstream

there isn’t a lot of love for mainstream media nowadays readers often complain

media nowadays readers often complain

media nowadays readers often complain that not only does it control the

that not only does it control the

that not only does it control the narrative remove voices from the

narrative remove voices from the

narrative remove voices from the discourse but that is also extremely

discourse but that is also extremely

discourse but that is also extremely biased in fact about 20 years ago

biased in fact about 20 years ago

biased in fact about 20 years ago about 55% of Americans actually trusted

about 55% of Americans actually trusted

about 55% of Americans actually trusted their news but today that number is down

their news but today that number is down

their news but today that number is down to about 40% and undoubtedly media

to about 40% and undoubtedly media

to about 40% and undoubtedly media conglomeration contributes directly to

conglomeration contributes directly to

conglomeration contributes directly to this because now more of our news is

this because now more of our news is

this because now more of our news is actually owned by fewer people so in

actually owned by fewer people so in

actually owned by fewer people so in 1980 50 companies owned 90% of our media

1980 50 companies owned 90% of our media

1980 50 companies owned 90% of our media already that’s not that great of a

already that’s not that great of a

already that’s not that great of a number but it just gets worse from there

number but it just gets worse from there

number but it just gets worse from there in about 10 years this is down to just

in about 10 years this is down to just

in about 10 years this is down to just 23 companies and today just fixed

23 companies and today just fixed

23 companies and today just fixed companies own 90% of our media and that

companies own 90% of our media and that

companies own 90% of our media and that includes Comcast some of you may know GE

includes Comcast some of you may know GE

includes Comcast some of you may know GE used to be part of this list but now

used to be part of this list but now

used to be part of this list but now it’s Comcast News Corp disney viacom

it’s Comcast News Corp disney viacom

it’s Comcast News Corp disney viacom Time Warner and CBS and maybe our

Time Warner and CBS and maybe our

Time Warner and CBS and maybe our readers are onto something because when

readers are onto something because when

readers are onto something because when President Obama and President Castro

President Obama and President Castro

President Obama and President Castro went to a ballgame moments after the

went to a ballgame moments after the

went to a ballgame moments after the game concluded this happened and I’m

game concluded this happened and I’m

game concluded this happened and I’m sure some of you can’t hear but

sure some of you can’t hear but

sure some of you can’t hear but basically I can just explain it really

basically I can just explain it really

basically I can just explain it really quickly there is an ESPN broadcast and a

quickly there is an ESPN broadcast and a

quickly there is an ESPN broadcast and a political protester he actually comes on

political protester he actually comes on

political protester he actually comes on and he takes over the broadcast what do

and he takes over the broadcast what do

and he takes over the broadcast what do you believe this day accomplished he

you believe this day accomplished he

you believe this day accomplished he doesn’t do anything

well the safety of bobbly obviously is

well the safety of bobbly obviously is the most important thing and there was a

the most important thing and there was a

the most important thing and there was a protest there right behind him sent it

protest there right behind him sent it

protest there right behind him sent it back to Bob Bob are you okay

back to Bob Bob are you okay

back to Bob Bob are you okay absolutely Carl what we had here a few

absolutely Carl what we had here a few

absolutely Carl what we had here a few moments ago everywhere this a few

moments ago everywhere this a few

moments ago everywhere this a few moments ago in Sports Center I was

moments ago in Sports Center I was

moments ago in Sports Center I was beginning getting the throw from Sports

beginning getting the throw from Sports

beginning getting the throw from Sports Center in Connecticut gentleman jumped

Center in Connecticut gentleman jumped

Center in Connecticut gentleman jumped up next to me I thought it was an error

up next to me I thought it was an error

up next to me I thought it was an error because we’re right here on the street

because we’re right here on the street

because we’re right here on the street we’ve had no problems whatsoever began

we’ve had no problems whatsoever began

we’ve had no problems whatsoever began yelling there were others at least four

yelling there were others at least four

yelling there were others at least four or five other individuals clearly in the

or five other individuals clearly in the

or five other individuals clearly in the dissident class if you will what was

dissident class if you will what was

dissident class if you will what was amazing was the speed of the police

amazing was the speed of the police

amazing was the speed of the police response there were three marked cars it

response there were three marked cars it

response there were three marked cars it came literally out of nowhere unmarked

came literally out of nowhere unmarked

came literally out of nowhere unmarked our plainclothes policemen those also

our plainclothes policemen those also

our plainclothes policemen those also were in uniforms there were a number of

were in uniforms there were a number of

were in uniforms there were a number of these pamphlets thrown up in the air

these pamphlets thrown up in the air

these pamphlets thrown up in the air here and astonishingly as soon as it hit

here and astonishingly as soon as it hit

here and astonishingly as soon as it hit the ground they made several arrests

the ground they made several arrests

the ground they made several arrests they were taken off here dragged off one

they were taken off here dragged off one

they were taken off here dragged off one dissident was taken off police service

dissident was taken off police service

dissident was taken off police service training him by the neck putting him in

training him by the neck putting him in

training him by the neck putting him in a car so they’ve been taken away and

a car so they’ve been taken away and

a car so they’ve been taken away and then the police descended on our

then the police descended on our

then the police descended on our position right here very politely but

position right here very politely but

position right here very politely but immediately scooping up all of these

immediately scooping up all of these

immediately scooping up all of these pamphlets for the rights and liberties

pamphlets for the rights and liberties

pamphlets for the rights and liberties calling for a meeting calling for

calling for a meeting calling for

calling for a meeting calling for reforms in Cuban law for new laws for

reforms in Cuban law for new laws for

reforms in Cuban law for new laws for amnesty having to do with the very clear

amnesty having to do with the very clear

amnesty having to do with the very clear however American reporters focused on

however American reporters focused on

however American reporters focused on Obama and Castro doing the wave in the

Obama and Castro doing the wave in the

Obama and Castro doing the wave in the audience New York Times was one of the

audience New York Times was one of the

audience New York Times was one of the only outlets to do comprehensive

only outlets to do comprehensive

only outlets to do comprehensive coverage as we’re used to and

coverage as we’re used to and

coverage as we’re used to and conservative outlets while they did have

conservative outlets while they did have

conservative outlets while they did have their questions they were more focused

their questions they were more focused

their questions they were more focused on why Obama wasn’t dealing with the

on why Obama wasn’t dealing with the

on why Obama wasn’t dealing with the Brussels attack that had recently

Brussels attack that had recently

Brussels attack that had recently happened so still no focus on Cuba and

happened so still no focus on Cuba and

happened so still no focus on Cuba and locally we’re not without our own faults

locally we’re not without our own faults

locally we’re not without our own faults very few cases of police brutality

very few cases of police brutality

very few cases of police brutality actually make the local news and I think

actually make the local news and I think

actually make the local news and I think that contributes directly to why not

that contributes directly to why not

that contributes directly to why not only are we not on the same page about

only are we not on the same page about

only are we not on the same page about what police brutality is but why we

what police brutality is but why we

what police brutality is but why we don’t agree on what we need to do about

don’t agree on what we need to do about

don’t agree on what we need to do about it and I open mic Rochester where I work

it and I open mic Rochester where I work

it and I open mic Rochester where I work we recently covered the story of a

we recently covered the story of a

we recently covered the story of a protester who charged that the U of R

protester who charged that the U of R

protester who charged that the U of R was complicit in the cover-up of his

was complicit in the cover-up of his

was complicit in the cover-up of his son’s 2011 death and while we were

son’s 2011 death and while we were

son’s 2011 death and while we were unable to corroborate those exact claims

unable to corroborate those exact claims

unable to corroborate those exact claims which we were very open about in our

which we were very open about in our

which we were very open about in our reportage we did discover that testimony

reportage we did discover that testimony

reportage we did discover that testimony given at the trial was actually

given at the trial was actually

given at the trial was actually falsified and this is information that

falsified and this is information that

falsified and this is information that wouldn’t have come out any other way

wouldn’t have come out any other way

wouldn’t have come out any other way because we were actually the only outlet

because we were actually the only outlet

because we were actually the only outlet to give him any platform so I’m kind of

to give him any platform so I’m kind of

to give him any platform so I’m kind of hinting at it now however I really do

hinting at it now however I really do

hinting at it now however I really do believe that investing in minority media

believe that investing in minority media

believe that investing in minority media can be an excellent way to push back on

can be an excellent way to push back on

can be an excellent way to push back on those issues we have with control and

those issues we have with control and

those issues we have with control and bias and I like to dispel almost

bias and I like to dispel almost

bias and I like to dispel almost immediately when I say minority media I

immediately when I say minority media I

immediately when I say minority media I don’t just mean racially minority media

don’t just mean racially minority media

don’t just mean racially minority media although I open like we are a black

although I open like we are a black

although I open like we are a black magazine I believe that it’s just any

magazine I believe that it’s just any

magazine I believe that it’s just any media that is created by and focuses on

media that is created by and focuses on

media that is created by and focuses on a co community so there’s also empty

a co community so there’s also empty

a co community so there’s also empty closet for the LGBT community locally

closet for the LGBT community locally

closet for the LGBT community locally and there’s talkback for teens which

and there’s talkback for teens which

and there’s talkback for teens which focuses on youth and at face value it

focuses on youth and at face value it

focuses on youth and at face value it seems that this news would only benefit

seems that this news would only benefit

seems that this news would only benefit the people it covers however we know

the people it covers however we know

the people it covers however we know that people who are on the outside of

that people who are on the outside of

that people who are on the outside of this community can really benefit from

this community can really benefit from

this community can really benefit from reading it as well they get a very

reading it as well they get a very

reading it as well they get a very genuine and very rare look inside and

genuine and very rare look inside and

genuine and very rare look inside and not only what the people believe the

not only what the people believe the

not only what the people believe the issues are facing their community but

issues are facing their community but

issues are facing their community but even sometimes was solutions they want

even sometimes was solutions they want

even sometimes was solutions they want advocated for so if done correctly

advocated for so if done correctly

advocated for so if done correctly minority media can actually serve as a

minority media can actually serve as a

minority media can actually serve as a way to start a discussion between our

way to start a discussion between our

way to start a discussion between our communities so that we can work together

communities so that we can work together

communities so that we can work together to finally actually address some of the

to finally actually address some of the

to finally actually address some of the issues that are plaguing us and when

issues that are plaguing us and when

issues that are plaguing us and when balance with mainstream news consumption

balance with mainstream news consumption

balance with mainstream news consumption it is a phenomenal way to balance those

it is a phenomenal way to balance those

it is a phenomenal way to balance those biases to fact-check and to just really

biases to fact-check and to just really

biases to fact-check and to just really alter how many perspectives you are

alter how many perspectives you are

alter how many perspectives you are getting so some people already know this

getting so some people already know this

getting so some people already know this but Frederick Douglass actually started

but Frederick Douglass actually started

but Frederick Douglass actually started one of the first black newspapers in the

one of the first black newspapers in the

one of the first black newspapers in the entire nation in this region and I say

entire nation in this region and I say

entire nation in this region and I say that because despite this minority

that because despite this minority

that because despite this minority journalism locally especially racially

journalism locally especially racially

journalism locally especially racially minority journalism is struggling I mean

minority journalism is struggling I mean

minority journalism is struggling I mean if you think print journalism is already

if you think print journalism is already

if you think print journalism is already on its last breath we especially need

on its last breath we especially need

on its last breath we especially need CPR however we know that it’s necessary

CPR however we know that it’s necessary

CPR however we know that it’s necessary it’s not just beneficial communities of

it’s not just beneficial communities of

it’s not just beneficial communities of people across America are looking for

people across America are looking for

people across America are looking for information that allows them to empower

information that allows them to empower

information that allows them to empower themselves as voters and now more and

themselves as voters and now more and

themselves as voters and now more and more we are all asked to make decisions

more we are all asked to make decisions

more we are all asked to make decisions that will impact the daily lives of

that will impact the daily lives of

that will impact the daily lives of people we need to vote on legislation

people we need to vote on legislation

people we need to vote on legislation policies and program that dictates how

policies and program that dictates how

policies and program that dictates how people live

people live

people live journalism provides the first draft of

journalism provides the first draft of

journalism provides the first draft of history and so not only do we have a

history and so not only do we have a

history and so not only do we have a responsibility to be fair and accurate

responsibility to be fair and accurate

responsibility to be fair and accurate I believe journalists have a

I believe journalists have a

I believe journalists have a responsibility to be inclusive as well

responsibility to be inclusive as well

responsibility to be inclusive as well because when we leave out those

because when we leave out those

because when we leave out those perspectives those angles those stories

perspectives those angles those stories

perspectives those angles those stories we are actually constructing an

we are actually constructing an

we are actually constructing an incomplete first draft of this history

incomplete first draft of this history

incomplete first draft of this history of art today Meishan excuse me minority

of art today Meishan excuse me minority

of art today Meishan excuse me minority media is a worthwhile investment because

media is a worthwhile investment because

media is a worthwhile investment because it pushes back again on those issues of

it pushes back again on those issues of

it pushes back again on those issues of control and bias which is clearly

control and bias which is clearly

control and bias which is clearly something that more than half of

something that more than half of

something that more than half of American readers want but more

American readers want but more

American readers want but more importantly it finally allows us to

importantly it finally allows us to

importantly it finally allows us to include perspectives and voices that

include perspectives and voices that

include perspectives and voices that have traditionally been spoken for or

have traditionally been spoken for or

have traditionally been spoken for or left out all together

left out all together

left out all together and not only include them but prioritize

and not only include them but prioritize

and not only include them but prioritize them just as heavily I believe that if

them just as heavily I believe that if

them just as heavily I believe that if our true goal is to be a melting pot we

our true goal is to be a melting pot we

our true goal is to be a melting pot we need to not only vote and live like one

need to not only vote and live like one

need to not only vote and live like one we need to speak and digest our news

we need to speak and digest our news

we need to speak and digest our news like one thank you

like one thank you

like one thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *