Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why it matters how we kill | Robert Gallimore | TEDxTauntonSchool


[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

if you don’t then it’s Michael Fallon

if you don’t then it’s Michael Fallon he’s our defense secretary and he is

he’s our defense secretary and he is

he’s our defense secretary and he is about to authorize the awarding of

about to authorize the awarding of

about to authorize the awarding of medals to drone pilots to people who sit

medals to drone pilots to people who sit

medals to drone pilots to people who sit in safe boxes in chairs akin to any

in safe boxes in chairs akin to any

in safe boxes in chairs akin to any gamers might be familiar with and

gamers might be familiar with and

gamers might be familiar with and control predator unmanned aerial

control predator unmanned aerial

control predator unmanned aerial vehicles that fire Hellfire missiles and

vehicles that fire Hellfire missiles and

vehicles that fire Hellfire missiles and kill people on the Queen’s behalf his

kill people on the Queen’s behalf his

kill people on the Queen’s behalf his desire to award the medals which I’m

desire to award the medals which I’m

desire to award the medals which I’m almost a hundred percent sure will

almost a hundred percent sure will

almost a hundred percent sure will happen will be much strengthened by

happen will be much strengthened by

happen will be much strengthened by today’s news that the White Widow am

today’s news that the White Widow am

today’s news that the White Widow am unfortunate lady from the margins of

unfortunate lady from the margins of

unfortunate lady from the margins of society nails but he got sucked into

society nails but he got sucked into

society nails but he got sucked into Isis has been killed this morning by one

Isis has been killed this morning by one

Isis has been killed this morning by one of these strikes I was gonna bolster the

of these strikes I was gonna bolster the

of these strikes I was gonna bolster the picture with the Daily Mail has now gone

picture with the Daily Mail has now gone

picture with the Daily Mail has now gone live with pictures inside the cabin and

live with pictures inside the cabin and

live with pictures inside the cabin and also pictures of the strike a little

also pictures of the strike a little

also pictures of the strike a little gruesome and it will also show now look

gruesome and it will also show now look

gruesome and it will also show now look at the Daily Mail online

I’m not sure these people deserve medals

I’m not sure these people deserve medals I’m not sure these people need medals

I’m not sure these people need medals

I’m not sure these people need medals they might need some talking therapy

they might need some talking therapy

they might need some talking therapy some psychotherapy maybe even a

some psychotherapy maybe even a

some psychotherapy maybe even a psychiatrist but medals I think not this

psychiatrist but medals I think not this

psychiatrist but medals I think not this chat general Rupert Jones he’s in charge

chat general Rupert Jones he’s in charge

chat general Rupert Jones he’s in charge of Britain’s anti-isis anti-terror

of Britain’s anti-isis anti-terror

of Britain’s anti-isis anti-terror activity in the Levant widely mainly

activity in the Levant widely mainly

activity in the Levant widely mainly Syria obviously and I caught a phrase he

Syria obviously and I caught a phrase he

Syria obviously and I caught a phrase he said an interview the other day he said

said an interview the other day he said

said an interview the other day he said War is hell war is hell as well as

War is hell war is hell as well as

War is hell war is hell as well as prisons let’s get rocked out by sort of

prisons let’s get rocked out by sort of

prisons let’s get rocked out by sort of macho sword soldiers and I thought to

macho sword soldiers and I thought to

macho sword soldiers and I thought to myself yeah war is hell for the people

myself yeah war is hell for the people

myself yeah war is hell for the people of Syria

of Syria

of Syria tragically war is hell for the people of

tragically war is hell for the people of

tragically war is hell for the people of Isis rightly what war is not how is for

Isis rightly what war is not how is for

Isis rightly what war is not how is for you or any of the people you command

now old soldiers have always always

now old soldiers have always always always complained about how easy the

always complained about how easy the

always complained about how easy the current wars are we get in the way back

current wars are we get in the way back

current wars are we get in the way back then machine and we say I was tougher

then machine and we say I was tougher

then machine and we say I was tougher then mainly because our hair was thicker

then mainly because our hair was thicker

then mainly because our hair was thicker or waists with thinner and it was

or waists with thinner and it was

or waists with thinner and it was tougher then you know people in the

tougher then you know people in the

tougher then you know people in the Falklands would say how easy it was in

Falklands would say how easy it was in

Falklands would say how easy it was in Afghanistan people from Korea would have

Afghanistan people from Korea would have

Afghanistan people from Korea would have said how easy the Falklands were because

said how easy the Falklands were because

said how easy the Falklands were because when world war ii would have said how

when world war ii would have said how

when world war ii would have said how easy career was and so on and so on and

easy career was and so on and so on and

easy career was and so on and so on and so on but I actually think something

so on but I actually think something

so on but I actually think something really serious is changing now because

really serious is changing now because

really serious is changing now because when I commissioned in 1997 1997 was a

when I commissioned in 1997 1997 was a

when I commissioned in 1997 1997 was a unique year 1997 was the first year that

unique year 1997 was the first year that

unique year 1997 was the first year that a British soldier had not been killed in

a British soldier had not been killed in

a British soldier had not been killed in action since 1967

action since 1967

action since 1967 General Sir Michael Rose in our speech

General Sir Michael Rose in our speech

General Sir Michael Rose in our speech pointed this out our parents were there

pointed this out our parents were there

pointed this out our parents were there he pointed out that he felt a lot more

he pointed out that he felt a lot more

he pointed out that he felt a lot more would be dying soon

would be dying soon

would be dying soon my mother particularly like that as I

my mother particularly like that as I

my mother particularly like that as I remember but since 1997 British soldiers

remember but since 1997 British soldiers

remember but since 1997 British soldiers have died every year in conflict they

have died every year in conflict they

have died every year in conflict they have died in increasing numbers reaching

have died in increasing numbers reaching

have died in increasing numbers reaching really a sort of crescendo of 2009 when

really a sort of crescendo of 2009 when

really a sort of crescendo of 2009 when nearly 200 British soldiers were killed

nearly 200 British soldiers were killed

nearly 200 British soldiers were killed in action over account of the year then

in action over account of the year then

in action over account of the year then something changed 2013

something changed 2013

something changed 2013 nobody soldier killed 2014 they believe

nobody soldier killed 2014 they believe

nobody soldier killed 2014 they believe soldier killed 2015 no British soldier

soldier killed 2015 no British soldier

soldier killed 2015 no British soldier killed 2016 no British soldier killed

killed 2016 no British soldier killed

killed 2016 no British soldier killed 2017 I hope no British soldier killed

2017 I hope no British soldier killed

2017 I hope no British soldier killed but we are still meeting out an enormous

but we are still meeting out an enormous

but we are still meeting out an enormous amount of hurt to the enemies of Her

amount of hurt to the enemies of Her

amount of hurt to the enemies of Her Majesty we are still doing a lot of

Majesty we are still doing a lot of

Majesty we are still doing a lot of killing and this is a paradigm shift

killing and this is a paradigm shift

killing and this is a paradigm shift where the risk in war is almost so

where the risk in war is almost so

where the risk in war is almost so non-existent that the warfare has become

non-existent that the warfare has become

non-existent that the warfare has become so asymmetric that pressing the trigger

so asymmetric that pressing the trigger

so asymmetric that pressing the trigger is a safe almost risk-free option now

is a safe almost risk-free option now

is a safe almost risk-free option now this would appear to be Whiggish

this would appear to be Whiggish

this would appear to be Whiggish progress but I would moot it’s actually

progress but I would moot it’s actually

progress but I would moot it’s actually slightly worrying you think I’d be sick

slightly worrying you think I’d be sick

slightly worrying you think I’d be sick to say I’m wishing for more of this what

to say I’m wishing for more of this what

to say I’m wishing for more of this what orden so wonderfully called men coming

orden so wonderfully called men coming

orden so wonderfully called men coming back and cold hermetically sealed boxes

back and cold hermetically sealed boxes

back and cold hermetically sealed boxes it’s worrying I think that ordinance had

it’s worrying I think that ordinance had

it’s worrying I think that ordinance had been increasingly popular now again the

been increasingly popular now again the

been increasingly popular now again the harbinger of the second world war is

harbinger of the second world war is

harbinger of the second world war is being reread more and more in these

being reread more and more in these

being reread more and more in these years but anyway I’m not saying I want

years but anyway I’m not saying I want

years but anyway I’m not saying I want to see this at more brides Morton more

to see this at more brides Morton more

to see this at more brides Morton more I’m just observing that the absence of

I’m just observing that the absence of

I’m just observing that the absence of this while we do so much killing is odd

this while we do so much killing is odd

this while we do so much killing is odd I think we’ve always accepted this is a

I think we’ve always accepted this is a

I think we’ve always accepted this is a well my favorite ever Private Eye car

well my favorite ever Private Eye car

well my favorite ever Private Eye car seems shocked soldier dies in war I

seems shocked soldier dies in war I

seems shocked soldier dies in war I think we’ve always accepted like the

think we’ve always accepted like the

think we’ve always accepted like the tango warfare is something that requires

tango warfare is something that requires

tango warfare is something that requires – you know we can’t just have it one way

– you know we can’t just have it one way

– you know we can’t just have it one way and that participation as a as somebody

and that participation as a as somebody

and that participation as a as somebody who takes part in war involves sacrifice

who takes part in war involves sacrifice

who takes part in war involves sacrifice but hang on if we can get rid of people

but hang on if we can get rid of people

but hang on if we can get rid of people as horrendous as this if we have the

as horrendous as this if we have the

as horrendous as this if we have the ability to kill such awful agents of

ability to kill such awful agents of

ability to kill such awful agents of evil without any risk to the stout

evil without any risk to the stout

evil without any risk to the stout yeoman and soon-to-be stout yo women of

yeoman and soon-to-be stout yo women of

yeoman and soon-to-be stout yo women of this country by means of this or indeed

this country by means of this or indeed

this country by means of this or indeed this in the middle of the night surely

this in the middle of the night surely

this in the middle of the night surely that must be a good thing but I find the

that must be a good thing but I find the

that must be a good thing but I find the decree of detachment disturbing such

decree of detachment disturbing such

decree of detachment disturbing such dicks distant we are prepared to

dicks distant we are prepared to

dicks distant we are prepared to prosecute the ultimate sanction more

prosecute the ultimate sanction more

prosecute the ultimate sanction more readily and with less moral

readily and with less moral

readily and with less moral interrogation than if we had skin in the

interrogation than if we had skin in the

interrogation than if we had skin in the game now I think the soldier is unique

game now I think the soldier is unique

game now I think the soldier is unique everybody has a balance how willing you

everybody has a balance how willing you

everybody has a balance how willing you are to kill how willing you are to be

are to kill how willing you are to be

are to kill how willing you are to be killed most people unfortunately we look

killed most people unfortunately we look

killed most people unfortunately we look deep in our souls would probably be

deep in our souls would probably be

deep in our souls would probably be prepared to take a life before sacrifice

prepared to take a life before sacrifice

prepared to take a life before sacrifice their own except it’s the way we are the

their own except it’s the way we are the

their own except it’s the way we are the soldier is quite unique every morning he

soldier is quite unique every morning he

soldier is quite unique every morning he goes out and the two things are probably

goes out and the two things are probably

goes out and the two things are probably in about equilibrium

in about equilibrium

in about equilibrium chance I might get it today chance I

chance I might get it today chance I

chance I might get it today chance I might have to give it to somebody today

might have to give it to somebody today

might have to give it to somebody today and that that strange balance LEDs that

and that that strange balance LEDs that

and that that strange balance LEDs that lends a certain integrity to warfare

lends a certain integrity to warfare

lends a certain integrity to warfare which actually prevents the whole thing

which actually prevents the whole thing

which actually prevents the whole thing coming into a slaughter which I think it

coming into a slaughter which I think it

coming into a slaughter which I think it could become if you just do it from an

could become if you just do it from an

could become if you just do it from an armchair miles away second piece of

armchair miles away second piece of

armchair miles away second piece of popular culture there may be less

popular culture there may be less

popular culture there may be less popular than the Game of Thrones

popular than the Game of Thrones

popular than the Game of Thrones fantastic fantastic Ken Loach film The

fantastic fantastic Ken Loach film The

fantastic fantastic Ken Loach film The Wind That Shakes the barley it’s a

Wind That Shakes the barley it’s a

Wind That Shakes the barley it’s a particularly horrific scene

particularly horrific scene

particularly horrific scene Cillian Murphy on the left there who is

Cillian Murphy on the left there who is

Cillian Murphy on the left there who is in the IRA during that insurgency

in the IRA during that insurgency

in the IRA during that insurgency against the British he’s having to kill

against the British he’s having to kill

against the British he’s having to kill this young man on the right the young

this young man on the right the young

this young man on the right the young man on the right is an informant

man on the right is an informant

man on the right is an informant he’s known him since he was four years

he’s known him since he was four years

he’s known him since he was four years old but they cannot have informers

old but they cannot have informers

old but they cannot have informers undermining the IRA at this stage of the

undermining the IRA at this stage of the

undermining the IRA at this stage of the insurgency silly Murphy like any other

insurgency silly Murphy like any other

insurgency silly Murphy like any other good leader he takes on the

good leader he takes on the

good leader he takes on the responsibility he’s the one who has to

responsibility he’s the one who has to

responsibility he’s the one who has to carry out this execution it’s a deeply

carry out this execution it’s a deeply

carry out this execution it’s a deeply disturbing and moving scene but the bit

disturbing and moving scene but the bit

disturbing and moving scene but the bit that strikes on it for me as he comes

that strikes on it for me as he comes

that strikes on it for me as he comes back he turns to one of his fellow other

back he turns to one of his fellow other

back he turns to one of his fellow other revolution and easy

revolution and easy

revolution and easy and he goes Jesus I hope this island

and he goes Jesus I hope this island

and he goes Jesus I hope this island we’re fighting for is worth it now why I

we’re fighting for is worth it now why I

we’re fighting for is worth it now why I take that as an example is we as a

take that as an example is we as a

take that as an example is we as a society need to be near there needs to

society need to be near there needs to

society need to be near there needs to be a proximity to the most visceral

be a proximity to the most visceral

be a proximity to the most visceral elements of warfare its essentials as

elements of warfare its essentials as

elements of warfare its essentials as those who experience it can relay it to

those who experience it can relay it to

those who experience it can relay it to those upon whose behalf it is carried

those upon whose behalf it is carried

those upon whose behalf it is carried out and constantly constantly questioned

out and constantly constantly questioned

out and constantly constantly questioned whether the juice is worth the squeeze

whether the juice is worth the squeeze

whether the juice is worth the squeeze you can’t do that from an armchair in

you can’t do that from an armchair in

you can’t do that from an armchair in High Wycombe you have to be there the

High Wycombe you have to be there the

High Wycombe you have to be there the other reason I choose this is in the

other reason I choose this is in the

other reason I choose this is in the film

film

film Cillian Murphy is it plays a young

Cillian Murphy is it plays a young

Cillian Murphy is it plays a young doctor or young trainee doctor and he’s

doctor or young trainee doctor and he’s

doctor or young trainee doctor and he’s the son of the local doctor and I say it

the son of the local doctor and I say it

the son of the local doctor and I say it rather selfishly if we are going to go

rather selfishly if we are going to go

rather selfishly if we are going to go and kill people we need to be prepared

and kill people we need to be prepared

and kill people we need to be prepared to sacrifice sons of GPS from Rutland

to sacrifice sons of GPS from Rutland

to sacrifice sons of GPS from Rutland that’s what I am NOT a particularly

that’s what I am NOT a particularly

that’s what I am NOT a particularly special soldier not a particularly good

special soldier not a particularly good

special soldier not a particularly good soldier the

soldier the

soldier the accidental the ordinary we must be

accidental the ordinary we must be

accidental the ordinary we must be prepared to risk them not just those

prepared to risk them not just those

prepared to risk them not just those people who through their the fact we’re

people who through their the fact we’re

people who through their the fact we’re special forces we don’t have to name if

special forces we don’t have to name if

special forces we don’t have to name if we’re going to get hit doing some of

we’re going to get hit doing some of

we’re going to get hit doing some of it’s worthwhile we need to know about

it’s worthwhile we need to know about

it’s worthwhile we need to know about the grief of that family that normal

the grief of that family that normal

the grief of that family that normal family who are like us

family who are like us

family who are like us the final point the myth the myth of the

the final point the myth the myth of the

the final point the myth the myth of the expert of this and if you can hold your

expert of this and if you can hold your

expert of this and if you can hold your nose long enough and you dip into the

nose long enough and you dip into the

nose long enough and you dip into the Daily Mail you will read about this

Daily Mail you will read about this

Daily Mail you will read about this unbelievable Hellfire missile that

unbelievable Hellfire missile that

unbelievable Hellfire missile that stopped to the traffic like turn left

stopped to the traffic like turn left

stopped to the traffic like turn left hit the White Widow goodnight nobody

hit the White Widow goodnight nobody

hit the White Widow goodnight nobody else hurt it doesn’t work like that to

else hurt it doesn’t work like that to

else hurt it doesn’t work like that to brief had sex I’ve experienced or other

brief had sex I’ve experienced or other

brief had sex I’ve experienced or other unfortunately when I was hanging around

unfortunately when I was hanging around

unfortunately when I was hanging around fighting with Afghan soldiers and Apache

fighting with Afghan soldiers and Apache

fighting with Afghan soldiers and Apache pilot made a mistake and locked on to us

pilot made a mistake and locked on to us

pilot made a mistake and locked on to us and basically gave us the whole nine

and basically gave us the whole nine

and basically gave us the whole nine yards not a single one of us was hurt

yards not a single one of us was hurt

yards not a single one of us was hurt its miles away it’s not that accurate

its miles away it’s not that accurate

its miles away it’s not that accurate sometimes they latch on to other things

sometimes they latch on to other things

sometimes they latch on to other things another time we went to attack a

another time we went to attack a

another time we went to attack a building where we were getting a lot of

building where we were getting a lot of

building where we were getting a lot of stick from we were still getting a

stick from we were still getting a

stick from we were still getting a little bit of stick from it the absolute

little bit of stick from it the absolute

little bit of stick from it the absolute obvious call was to drop a precision

obvious call was to drop a precision

obvious call was to drop a precision borne it it was in the middle of nowhere

borne it it was in the middle of nowhere

borne it it was in the middle of nowhere there was no other collateral damage

there was no other collateral damage

there was no other collateral damage something in my water said no we

something in my water said no we

something in my water said no we attacked at the normal way fought

attacked at the normal way fought

attacked at the normal way fought through it in the basement of it 15

through it in the basement of it 15

through it in the basement of it 15 women and children tied up because

women and children tied up because

women and children tied up because however accurate that is they can get

however accurate that is they can get

however accurate that is they can get cleverer than that and then that’s

cleverer than that and then that’s

cleverer than that and then that’s collateral damage they that they can use

collateral damage they that they can use

collateral damage they that they can use this stuff is not magic it’s not magic

this stuff is not magic it’s not magic

this stuff is not magic it’s not magic so my conclusion is the broad sunlit

so my conclusion is the broad sunlit

so my conclusion is the broad sunlit uplands or the Utopia of war is not a

uplands or the Utopia of war is not a

uplands or the Utopia of war is not a war where there are no friendly forces

war where there are no friendly forces

war where there are no friendly forces casualty it’s actually no war but if war

casualty it’s actually no war but if war

casualty it’s actually no war but if war there must be civilized nations must be

there must be civilized nations must be

there must be civilized nations must be prepared to risk their blood as well as

prepared to risk their blood as well as

prepared to risk their blood as well as their treasure thank you very much for

their treasure thank you very much for

their treasure thank you very much for listening

listening

listening you

you

you [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *