Press "Enter" to skip to content

Where does our information come from? | Paul Davies | TEDxNantwich


why according to my parents this is a

why according to my parents this is a question I asked a lot as a child I like

question I asked a lot as a child I like

question I asked a lot as a child I like to think it was a sense of my thirst for

to think it was a sense of my thirst for

to think it was a sense of my thirst for knowledge

knowledge

knowledge quite an endearing characteristic in a

quite an endearing characteristic in a

quite an endearing characteristic in a child but I’m not sure my parents would

child but I’m not sure my parents would

child but I’m not sure my parents would agree going up in the 1980s in rural

agree going up in the 1980s in rural

agree going up in the 1980s in rural England I had relatively few source of

England I had relatively few source of

England I had relatively few source of information available to me I was

information available to me I was

information available to me I was fortunate I had a an insight appear in

fortunate I had a an insight appear in

fortunate I had a an insight appear in several of the textbooks but once the

several of the textbooks but once the

several of the textbooks but once the knowledge in those books was exhausted

knowledge in those books was exhausted

knowledge in those books was exhausted and knowledge of my parents was

and knowledge of my parents was

and knowledge of my parents was exhausted as well I was often left with

exhausted as well I was often left with

exhausted as well I was often left with an incomplete answer to my latest why

an incomplete answer to my latest why

an incomplete answer to my latest why then came the 25th of December 1990 the

then came the 25th of December 1990 the

then came the 25th of December 1990 the nine year old me would have been at home

nine year old me would have been at home

nine year old me would have been at home in a sea of surely wrapping paper or in

in a sea of surely wrapping paper or in

in a sea of surely wrapping paper or in our latest LEGO creation blissfully

our latest LEGO creation blissfully

our latest LEGO creation blissfully unaware that this day marks an important

unaware that this day marks an important

unaware that this day marks an important step in the journey to the Information

step in the journey to the Information

step in the journey to the Information Age that we now enjoy and the ability

Age that we now enjoy and the ability

Age that we now enjoy and the ability for me to answer practically any why

for me to answer practically any why

for me to answer practically any why question I could conceive of this is the

question I could conceive of this is the

question I could conceive of this is the day that Tim berners-lee crates for the

day that Tim berners-lee crates for the

day that Tim berners-lee crates for the World Wide Web use the first-ever web

World Wide Web use the first-ever web

World Wide Web use the first-ever web browser to access the first web page

browser to access the first web page

browser to access the first web page over the Internet if I was to ask you

over the Internet if I was to ask you

over the Internet if I was to ask you duck quacks echo and if they don’t why

duck quacks echo and if they don’t why

duck quacks echo and if they don’t why not how would you start to answer that

not how would you start to answer that

not how would you start to answer that question without using the web I can see

question without using the web I can see

question without using the web I can see a few of you considering wrestling and

a few of you considering wrestling and

a few of you considering wrestling and irate duck into a tunnel but not

irate duck into a tunnel but not

irate duck into a tunnel but not necessary haffley the web and your

necessary haffley the web and your

necessary haffley the web and your smartphone puts the answer quite

smartphone puts the answer quite

smartphone puts the answer quite literally at your fingertips even here

literally at your fingertips even here

literally at your fingertips even here in a TED talk although if you can resist

in a TED talk although if you can resist

in a TED talk although if you can resist the urge to Google search that right now

the urge to Google search that right now

the urge to Google search that right now it appreciate it

it appreciate it

it appreciate it so Chloe web has changed how we seek out

so Chloe web has changed how we seek out

so Chloe web has changed how we seek out new information it’s gone to this access

new information it’s gone to this access

new information it’s gone to this access to more diverse sources and more detail

to more diverse sources and more detail

to more diverse sources and more detail than ever before but have we given

than ever before but have we given

than ever before but have we given technology too much control over the

technology too much control over the

technology too much control over the information we get to see is there

information we get to see is there

information we get to see is there anything we can do to take back some of

anything we can do to take back some of

anything we can do to take back some of that control now when you’re searching

that control now when you’re searching

that control now when you’re searching it for a new piece of information

it for a new piece of information

it for a new piece of information whether it’s about duck quacks or

whether it’s about duck quacks or

whether it’s about duck quacks or anything else you probably gonna start

anything else you probably gonna start

anything else you probably gonna start with a search engine a search engines

with a search engine a search engines

with a search engine a search engines use complex maths lots of computing

use complex maths lots of computing

use complex maths lots of computing power and massive amount of data to ax

power and massive amount of data to ax

power and massive amount of data to ax the middleman between you and your

the middleman between you and your

the middleman between you and your questions and the building of so

questions and the building of so

questions and the building of so websites out there that might hold the

websites out there that might hold the

websites out there that might hold the answer now the dates they use is not

answer now the dates they use is not

answer now the dates they use is not just from the sites of the information

just from the sites of the information

just from the sites of the information on offer it’s also from you and I don’t

on offer it’s also from you and I don’t

on offer it’s also from you and I don’t just mean what you typed in the first

just mean what you typed in the first

just mean what you typed in the first place I mean things like your location

place I mean things like your location

place I mean things like your location which helps them better answer questions

which helps them better answer questions

which helps them better answer questions like where can I find a good time

like where can I find a good time

like where can I find a good time restaurant no good giving you an answer

restaurant no good giving you an answer

restaurant no good giving you an answer for the middle of Italy

for the middle of Italy

for the middle of Italy if you’re in the middle of London it

if you’re in the middle of London it

if you’re in the middle of London it might also mean things like your

might also mean things like your

might also mean things like your previous searches and the results you

previous searches and the results you

previous searches and the results you clicked on from them which might give

clicked on from them which might give

clicked on from them which might give away things like your favorite sports

away things like your favorite sports

away things like your favorite sports team your religious or maybe political

team your religious or maybe political

team your religious or maybe political views now search image in mirror and use

views now search image in mirror and use

views now search image in mirror and use that information to prioritize

that information to prioritize

that information to prioritize information and news that’s relevant to

information and news that’s relevant to

information and news that’s relevant to you your interests and views now this

you your interests and views now this

you your interests and views now this curation of your search results can lead

curation of your search results can lead

curation of your search results can lead to what’s been referred to as a filter

to what’s been referred to as a filter

to what’s been referred to as a filter bubble where the information you see in

bubble where the information you see in

bubble where the information you see in that first page or two of the results

that first page or two of the results

that first page or two of the results it’s the right answers for you they can

it’s the right answers for you they can

it’s the right answers for you they can make it harder for you to see the bigger

make it harder for you to see the bigger

make it harder for you to see the bigger picture the view from the opposite side

picture the view from the opposite side

picture the view from the opposite side of the political divide or perhaps that

of the political divide or perhaps that

of the political divide or perhaps that little Italian restaurant the outskirts

little Italian restaurant the outskirts

little Italian restaurant the outskirts of town is worth the journey to go and

of town is worth the journey to go and

of town is worth the journey to go and visit

visit

visit it’s challenge here is how do you assess

it’s challenge here is how do you assess

it’s challenge here is how do you assess the impact of that if something’s very

the impact of that if something’s very

the impact of that if something’s very deep in the search results so deep that

deep in the search results so deep that

deep in the search results so deep that it might as well be missing entirely how

it might as well be missing entirely how

it might as well be missing entirely how do you know search engines don’t just

do you know search engines don’t just

do you know search engines don’t just filter results there to make sure you

filter results there to make sure you

filter results there to make sure you find the right information they also do

find the right information they also do

find the right information they also do it to make sure you don’t find the wrong

it to make sure you don’t find the wrong

it to make sure you don’t find the wrong information as fake news made big

information as fake news made big

information as fake news made big headlines in the real news so the web’s

headlines in the real news so the web’s

headlines in the real news so the web’s been challenged to help mitigate some of

been challenged to help mitigate some of

been challenged to help mitigate some of the implications of this worry new trend

the implications of this worry new trend

the implications of this worry new trend a trend that some believe actually had a

a trend that some believe actually had a

a trend that some believe actually had a material impact in the 2016 US

material impact in the 2016 US

material impact in the 2016 US presidential election but even

presidential election but even

presidential election but even well-intentioned initiatives can have

well-intentioned initiatives can have

well-intentioned initiatives can have unintended consequences Google’s recent

unintended consequences Google’s recent

unintended consequences Google’s recent updates to its search algorithms to help

updates to its search algorithms to help

updates to its search algorithms to help weed out fake news I’ve already been

weed out fake news I’ve already been

weed out fake news I’ve already been accused of actually removing some search

accused of actually removing some search

accused of actually removing some search results from some fringe political

results from some fringe political

results from some fringe political websites which strongly refute any

websites which strongly refute any

websites which strongly refute any allegations of being fake news here

allegations of being fake news here

allegations of being fake news here Google is actually acting as an arbiter

Google is actually acting as an arbiter

Google is actually acting as an arbiter of what is a trustworthy news source and

of what is a trustworthy news source and

of what is a trustworthy news source and then censoring legitimate political

then censoring legitimate political

then censoring legitimate political discussion in the hopes of saving us

discussion in the hopes of saving us

discussion in the hopes of saving us from being misinformed a challenge again

from being misinformed a challenge again

from being misinformed a challenge again is how do you assess the impact of that

is how do you assess the impact of that

is how do you assess the impact of that if a search engine chooses to just not

if a search engine chooses to just not

if a search engine chooses to just not show a site in their search results

show a site in their search results

show a site in their search results because they’re trying to save you from

because they’re trying to save you from

because they’re trying to save you from being misinformed how did you know

being misinformed how did you know

being misinformed how did you know suffered the challenge doesn’t end with

suffered the challenge doesn’t end with

suffered the challenge doesn’t end with search engines sorry

search engines sorry

search engines sorry information now more than ever is being

information now more than ever is being

information now more than ever is being presented to you you’ve probably seen

presented to you you’ve probably seen

presented to you you’ve probably seen some today it’s there on your newsfeed

some today it’s there on your newsfeed

some today it’s there on your newsfeed in between that picture of your friends

in between that picture of your friends

in between that picture of your friends family holiday in that funny video of a

family holiday in that funny video of a

family holiday in that funny video of a cat falling over not searched for not

cat falling over not searched for not

cat falling over not searched for not asked for answering a question you

asked for answering a question you

asked for answering a question you hadn’t even asked it’s there because

hadn’t even asked it’s there because

hadn’t even asked it’s there because sites like Facebook and other social

sites like Facebook and other social

sites like Facebook and other social media sites also use big data

media sites also use big data

media sites also use big data complex algorithms to decide what to

complex algorithms to decide what to

complex algorithms to decide what to show you whether it’s the pages from

show you whether it’s the pages from

show you whether it’s the pages from sorry the shares from the pages you

sorry the shares from the pages you

sorry the shares from the pages you follow or perhaps the states the plates

follow or perhaps the states the plates

follow or perhaps the states the plates from your friends because well clearly

from your friends because well clearly

from your friends because well clearly it’s not practical to show you

it’s not practical to show you

it’s not practical to show you everything every states is up that every

everything every states is up that every

everything every states is up that every share because well my popular over they

share because well my popular over they

share because well my popular over they they curate our timelines based on their

they curate our timelines based on their

they curate our timelines based on their very intimate knowledge of us from the

very intimate knowledge of us from the

very intimate knowledge of us from the things we like our friends the things

things we like our friends the things

things we like our friends the things our friends like the groups for members

our friends like the groups for members

our friends like the groups for members off and the content means rats we’ve

off and the content means rats we’ve

off and the content means rats we’ve both on the Facebook itself but also

both on the Facebook itself but also

both on the Facebook itself but also across the websites the ever-present

across the websites the ever-present

across the websites the ever-present like button I think for a second though

like button I think for a second though

like button I think for a second though with this intimate knowledge of us what

with this intimate knowledge of us what

with this intimate knowledge of us what prompts a social media site to show us

prompts a social media site to show us

prompts a social media site to show us something it knows we don’t like or

something it knows we don’t like or

something it knows we don’t like or something’s going to challenge us

something’s going to challenge us

something’s going to challenge us religiously politically socially and if

religiously politically socially and if

religiously politically socially and if a social media site chooses to show us

a social media site chooses to show us

a social media site chooses to show us only the updates from a small group of

only the updates from a small group of

only the updates from a small group of our friends perhaps the ones we interact

our friends perhaps the ones we interact

our friends perhaps the ones we interact with most frequently or a certain group

with most frequently or a certain group

with most frequently or a certain group of pages how do you think back to June

of pages how do you think back to June

of pages how do you think back to June 2016 sorry what I described there is a

2016 sorry what I described there is a

2016 sorry what I described there is a technical incarnation of a very human

technical incarnation of a very human

technical incarnation of a very human tendency to focus on information which

tendency to focus on information which

tendency to focus on information which reinforces our existing views and to

reinforces our existing views and to

reinforces our existing views and to dismiss or ignore information which

dismiss or ignore information which

dismiss or ignore information which challenged it

challenged it

challenged it this digital confirmation bias has led

this digital confirmation bias has led

this digital confirmation bias has led to sites like Facebook being labeled as

to sites like Facebook being labeled as

to sites like Facebook being labeled as an echo chamber as an echo chamber as an

an echo chamber as an echo chamber as an

an echo chamber as an echo chamber as an echo chamber because its ability to

echo chamber because its ability to

echo chamber because its ability to reinforce our existing views our likes

reinforce our existing views our likes

reinforce our existing views our likes based on what they present back to us in

based on what they present back to us in

based on what they present back to us in our news feeds think back to June 2016

our news feeds think back to June 2016

our news feeds think back to June 2016 the result of the brexit referendum how

the result of the brexit referendum how

the result of the brexit referendum how shocked by or sure of that result will

shocked by or sure of that result will

shocked by or sure of that result will you think back to what you saw and heard

you think back to what you saw and heard

you think back to what you saw and heard on social media in the run-up to that

on social media in the run-up to that

on social media in the run-up to that result did it convince you that your

result did it convince you that your

result did it convince you that your side of the argument was going to emerge

side of the argument was going to emerge

side of the argument was going to emerge victorius if that’s a ring of truth to

victorius if that’s a ring of truth to

victorius if that’s a ring of truth to it consider how that echo chamber effect

it consider how that echo chamber effect

it consider how that echo chamber effect might change your boat of decision

might change your boat of decision

might change your boat of decision making the budget referendum saw the

making the budget referendum saw the

making the budget referendum saw the highest turnouts in parts the country

highest turnouts in parts the country

highest turnouts in parts the country with the highest proportion of older

with the highest proportion of older

with the highest proportion of older voters argue with those less likely to

voters argue with those less likely to

voters argue with those less likely to use social media and therefore less

use social media and therefore less

use social media and therefore less likely to be influenced by this

likely to be influenced by this

likely to be influenced by this phenomenon for social media uses though

phenomenon for social media uses though

phenomenon for social media uses though put the echo chamber of so convinced

put the echo chamber of so convinced

put the echo chamber of so convinced them of the result so they decided

them of the result so they decided

them of the result so they decided actually there’s no need to go out and

actually there’s no need to go out and

actually there’s no need to go out and vote at all but that’s even a

vote at all but that’s even a

vote at all but that’s even a possibility highlights the implications

possibility highlights the implications

possibility highlights the implications of curating and filtering the

of curating and filtering the

of curating and filtering the information we get to see and the scenes

information we get to see and the scenes

information we get to see and the scenes we take as a result of it decisions

we take as a result of it decisions

we take as a result of it decisions which might just affect us as

which might just affect us as

which might just affect us as individuals but can have far more wide

individuals but can have far more wide

individuals but can have far more wide reaching implications now the Chinese

reaching implications now the Chinese

reaching implications now the Chinese have described there are technical

have described there are technical

have described there are technical issues that exist not because when

issues that exist not because when

issues that exist not because when intend to mislead or miss inform you

intend to mislead or miss inform you

intend to mislead or miss inform you bash our desire to create a more

bash our desire to create a more

bash our desire to create a more accurate search result or a more

accurate search result or a more

accurate search result or a more relevant timeline there’s a technical

relevant timeline there’s a technical

relevant timeline there’s a technical problems that are challenged to solve

problems that are challenged to solve

problems that are challenged to solve with technical solutions how did you

with technical solutions how did you

with technical solutions how did you tell Google stop being so good answering

tell Google stop being so good answering

tell Google stop being so good answering my questions start throwing in some

my questions start throwing in some

my questions start throwing in some answers I didn’t know I wanted to hear

answers I didn’t know I wanted to hear

answers I didn’t know I wanted to hear or without looking like an incompetent

or without looking like an incompetent

or without looking like an incompetent search engine how’d you tell social

search engine how’d you tell social

search engine how’d you tell social media sites show me everything including

media sites show me everything including

media sites show me everything including things I don’t like the things they’re

things I don’t like the things they’re

things I don’t like the things they’re going to challenge me that might put me

going to challenge me that might put me

going to challenge me that might put me off and coming back to your site so

off and coming back to your site so

off and coming back to your site so these are technical problems that need

these are technical problems that need

these are technical problems that need human solutions we need to take back

human solutions we need to take back

human solutions we need to take back control we need to investigate and dig

control we need to investigate and dig

control we need to investigate and dig deeper into the information we see using

deeper into the information we see using

deeper into the information we see using the skills we have made by developing a

the skills we have made by developing a

the skills we have made by developing a few new ones skills like human curiosity

few new ones skills like human curiosity

few new ones skills like human curiosity can help you seek out alternative

can help you seek out alternative

can help you seek out alternative viewpoints and drive you to actually

viewpoints and drive you to actually

viewpoints and drive you to actually understand them basically skills like

understand them basically skills like

understand them basically skills like mathematics can help you analyze

mathematics can help you analyze

mathematics can help you analyze information that’s used to support an

information that’s used to support an

information that’s used to support an argument and make a case when it comes

argument and make a case when it comes

argument and make a case when it comes to the web

to the web

to the web digital literacy could help you use the

digital literacy could help you use the

digital literacy could help you use the web and it’s tools more effectively to

web and it’s tools more effectively to

web and it’s tools more effectively to get the information you’re looking for

get the information you’re looking for

get the information you’re looking for but I’ll just pick out one skill that I

but I’ll just pick out one skill that I

but I’ll just pick out one skill that I believe can be most useful in dealing

believe can be most useful in dealing

believe can be most useful in dealing with these types of challenges

with these types of challenges

with these types of challenges critical thinking because it’s a skill

critical thinking because it’s a skill

critical thinking because it’s a skill that doesn’t just help with the

that doesn’t just help with the

that doesn’t just help with the information we encounter on the web it

information we encounter on the web it

information we encounter on the web it also helps in our offline lives as well

also helps in our offline lives as well

also helps in our offline lives as well if the ability to develop a healthy

if the ability to develop a healthy

if the ability to develop a healthy skepticism about what we see and pushes

skepticism about what we see and pushes

skepticism about what we see and pushes us to ask more questions it’s a better

us to ask more questions it’s a better

us to ask more questions it’s a better assess the information we’re presented

assess the information we’re presented

assess the information we’re presented with so the views we form or decisions

with so the views we form or decisions

with so the views we form or decisions we take as a result are considered

we take as a result are considered

we take as a result are considered rational informed now southern critical

rational informed now southern critical

rational informed now southern critical thinking is typically only taught in

thinking is typically only taught in

thinking is typically only taught in higher education

higher education

higher education happily though there are many free

happily though there are many free

happily though there are many free resources available on the web to teach

resources available on the web to teach

resources available on the web to teach yourself and others this valuable skill

yourself and others this valuable skill

yourself and others this valuable skill you can find them very easily using your

you can find them very easily using your

you can find them very easily using your search engine the irony of which is not

search engine the irony of which is not

search engine the irony of which is not lost on me now given the relatively

lost on me now given the relatively

lost on me now given the relatively short amount of time we have together

short amount of time we have together

short amount of time we have together today it was never going to be practical

today it was never going to be practical

today it was never going to be practical for me to teach you critical thinking

for me to teach you critical thinking

for me to teach you critical thinking but maybe what I can do is give you some

but maybe what I can do is give you some

but maybe what I can do is give you some simple questions to take away to help

simple questions to take away to help

simple questions to take away to help you think more critically the next time

you think more critically the next time

you think more critically the next time you’re reading something online or

you’re reading something online or

you’re reading something online or perhaps even in the newspaper start with

perhaps even in the newspaper start with

perhaps even in the newspaper start with what what is this article trying to

what what is this article trying to

what what is this article trying to convince me off is it of a preconceived

convince me off is it of a preconceived

convince me off is it of a preconceived notion or the author’s conclusion about

notion or the author’s conclusion about

notion or the author’s conclusion about something are they presenting their case

something are they presenting their case

something are they presenting their case and allowing me to come to my own let’s

and allowing me to come to my own let’s

and allowing me to come to my own let’s consider how how are they trying to

consider how how are they trying to

consider how how are they trying to convince me are they presenting facts

convince me are they presenting facts

convince me are they presenting facts and figures and reputable sources or

and figures and reputable sources or

and figures and reputable sources or they simply playing upon my emotions

they simply playing upon my emotions

they simply playing upon my emotions finally perhaps why why they trying to

finally perhaps why why they trying to

finally perhaps why why they trying to convince me of this view is there a

convince me of this view is there a

convince me of this view is there a political motivation underneath is there

political motivation underneath is there

political motivation underneath is there an axe to grind on behalf of the author

an axe to grind on behalf of the author

an axe to grind on behalf of the author well they’re simply trying to inform

well they’re simply trying to inform

well they’re simply trying to inform their readership what how and why three

their readership what how and why three

their readership what how and why three simple questions today we find ourselves

simple questions today we find ourselves

simple questions today we find ourselves at a point in time where information is

at a point in time where information is

at a point in time where information is more accessible there’s greater

more accessible there’s greater

more accessible there’s greater diversity in depth than ever before so

diversity in depth than ever before so

diversity in depth than ever before so don’t want anyone to leave today being

don’t want anyone to leave today being

don’t want anyone to leave today being scared of using the web and technology

scared of using the web and technology

scared of using the web and technology I’m a passionate technologist and I

I’m a passionate technologist and I

I’m a passionate technologist and I believe that technology has the

believe that technology has the

believe that technology has the potential to open up so many avenues for

potential to open up so many avenues for

potential to open up so many avenues for us and I want people to use technology

us and I want people to use technology

us and I want people to use technology to its fullest extent but clearly it can

to its fullest extent but clearly it can

to its fullest extent but clearly it can be imperfect it’s important that we

be imperfect it’s important that we

be imperfect it’s important that we develop skills to protect ourselves from

develop skills to protect ourselves from

develop skills to protect ourselves from these occasions when it is let’s leave

these occasions when it is let’s leave

these occasions when it is let’s leave me with one final thought I’ve offered

me with one final thought I’ve offered

me with one final thought I’ve offered some insights into the challenge that

some insights into the challenge that

some insights into the challenge that technology can present and based on my

technology can present and based on my

technology can present and based on my background and the fact I’m still in

background and the fact I’m still in

background and the fact I’m still in this TEDx stage you might assume that I

this TEDx stage you might assume that I

this TEDx stage you might assume that I speak from a position of authority and

speak from a position of authority and

speak from a position of authority and the facts and figures that I’ve

the facts and figures that I’ve

the facts and figures that I’ve discussed have been well researched and

discussed have been well researched and

discussed have been well researched and thoroughly reviewed I might also tell

thoroughly reviewed I might also tell

thoroughly reviewed I might also tell you that duck quacks do in fact echo and

you that duck quacks do in fact echo and

you that duck quacks do in fact echo and I might be telling the truth

I might be telling the truth

I might be telling the truth how’d you know thank you

how’d you know thank you

how’d you know thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *