Press "Enter" to skip to content

What can we do with disruptive children? | Debbie Breeze | TEDxNantwich


in my working life

in my working life I am ignored I’m ridiculed and tested to

I am ignored I’m ridiculed and tested to

I am ignored I’m ridiculed and tested to my limit on a daily basis and yet I love

my limit on a daily basis and yet I love

my limit on a daily basis and yet I love what I do I’m a teacher in a pupil

what I do I’m a teacher in a pupil

what I do I’m a teacher in a pupil referral unit for young people who have

referral unit for young people who have

referral unit for young people who have been permanently excluded from

been permanently excluded from

been permanently excluded from mainstream schools 25 years I work with

mainstream schools 25 years I work with

mainstream schools 25 years I work with all kinds of different young people most

all kinds of different young people most

all kinds of different young people most of whom have challenging behavior and

of whom have challenging behavior and

of whom have challenging behavior and I’m here today to be a voice for them

I’m here today to be a voice for them

I’m here today to be a voice for them because their real needs lying beneath

because their real needs lying beneath

because their real needs lying beneath the behavior

the behavior

the behavior all too often go unseen unheard and I’m

all too often go unseen unheard and I’m

all too often go unseen unheard and I’m mad now these children are easy to

mad now these children are easy to

mad now these children are easy to dislike they challenge our authority as

dislike they challenge our authority as

dislike they challenge our authority as adults they disobey us and disrespect us

adults they disobey us and disrespect us

adults they disobey us and disrespect us they can make us feel out of control and

they can make us feel out of control and

they can make us feel out of control and sometimes scared like we’re failing

sometimes scared like we’re failing

sometimes scared like we’re failing incompetent and powerless in short they

incompetent and powerless in short they

incompetent and powerless in short they can make us feel like they feel and it

can make us feel like they feel and it

can make us feel like they feel and it is unbearable

is unbearable

is unbearable so in our schools we prefer them to go

so in our schools we prefer them to go

so in our schools we prefer them to go away and be someone else’s problem but

away and be someone else’s problem but

away and be someone else’s problem but these are our most vulnerable and

these are our most vulnerable and

these are our most vulnerable and disadvantaged young people in our

disadvantaged young people in our

disadvantaged young people in our society and they need our help and

society and they need our help and

society and they need our help and expertise the most and yet we’re failing

expertise the most and yet we’re failing

expertise the most and yet we’re failing them on a huge scale over the last three

them on a huge scale over the last three

them on a huge scale over the last three years in schools in England we’ve seen a

years in schools in England we’ve seen a

years in schools in England we’ve seen a 40% increase in permanent exclusions 40%

40% increase in permanent exclusions 40%

40% increase in permanent exclusions 40% and in 2016 there are over six and a

and in 2016 there are over six and a

and in 2016 there are over six and a half thousand permanent exclusions and

half thousand permanent exclusions and

half thousand permanent exclusions and the estimated cost of this over the

the estimated cost of this over the

the estimated cost of this over the lifetime of that one group is estimated

lifetime of that one group is estimated

lifetime of that one group is estimated to be over 2 billion pounds what we know

to be over 2 billion pounds what we know

to be over 2 billion pounds what we know about excluded children is that they’re

about excluded children is that they’re

about excluded children is that they’re more likely to live in poverty more

more likely to live in poverty more

more likely to live in poverty more likely to experience abuse and neglect

likely to experience abuse and neglect

likely to experience abuse and neglect at home there’s 7 times as likely to

at home there’s 7 times as likely to

at home there’s 7 times as likely to have a learning difficulty special

have a learning difficulty special

have a learning difficulty special educational need and over half of them

educational need and over half of them

educational need and over half of them are experiencing some form of mental

are experiencing some form of mental

are experiencing some form of mental health related condition

health related condition

health related condition ultimately excluded children go on to

ultimately excluded children go on to

ultimately excluded children go on to make up over 60% of our British prison

make up over 60% of our British prison

make up over 60% of our British prison population and they’re not just other

population and they’re not just other

population and they’re not just other people’s children they could be yours or

people’s children they could be yours or

people’s children they could be yours or they could be mine like the

they could be mine like the

they could be mine like the fifteen-year-old girl who helped to

fifteen-year-old girl who helped to

fifteen-year-old girl who helped to nurse her mum until she went into a

nurse her mum until she went into a

nurse her mum until she went into a hospice who struggled to cope when her

hospice who struggled to cope when her

hospice who struggled to cope when her dad moved his girlfriend into the home

dad moved his girlfriend into the home

dad moved his girlfriend into the home and then one day at school she was

and then one day at school she was

and then one day at school she was walking down the corridor and another

walking down the corridor and another

walking down the corridor and another pupil made a really cruel comment about

pupil made a really cruel comment about

pupil made a really cruel comment about her dying mum and she lashed out and

her dying mum and she lashed out and

her dying mum and she lashed out and found herself permanently excluded not

found herself permanently excluded not

found herself permanently excluded not long after that she went into care and I

long after that she went into care and I

long after that she went into care and I later learned that by the time she was

later learned that by the time she was

later learned that by the time she was 18 she’d become involved in prostitution

18 she’d become involved in prostitution

18 she’d become involved in prostitution I firmly believe that with the right

I firmly believe that with the right

I firmly believe that with the right support her life could have taken a very

support her life could have taken a very

support her life could have taken a very different path just imagine if she’d

different path just imagine if she’d

different path just imagine if she’d been your child what would you have

been your child what would you have

been your child what would you have hoped for her and what would her mum

hoped for her and what would her mum

hoped for her and what would her mum have wanted we human beings are

have wanted we human beings are

have wanted we human beings are wonderfully diverse but our needs are

wonderfully diverse but our needs are

wonderfully diverse but our needs are fundamentally the same and our need for

fundamentally the same and our need for

fundamentally the same and our need for human connection is the most important

human connection is the most important

human connection is the most important dr. brenner Brown says connection is why

dr. brenner Brown says connection is why

dr. brenner Brown says connection is why we’re here

we’re here

we’re here it’s what gives our lives meaning and

it’s what gives our lives meaning and

it’s what gives our lives meaning and purpose and studies have shown that the

purpose and studies have shown that the

purpose and studies have shown that the happiest people have the most positive

happiest people have the most positive

happiest people have the most positive human connections

human connections

human connections so when connections unravel so too does

so when connections unravel so too does

so when connections unravel so too does our ability to cope with everyday life

our ability to cope with everyday life

our ability to cope with everyday life and for children with challenging

and for children with challenging

and for children with challenging behavior they’ve often become

behavior they’ve often become

behavior they’ve often become disconnected

disconnected

disconnected they’ve lost their faith in adults and

they’ve lost their faith in adults and

they’ve lost their faith in adults and any sense of security that they had and

any sense of security that they had and

any sense of security that they had and if they could do well at school they’d

if they could do well at school they’d

if they could do well at school they’d be doing it but there are barriers

be doing it but there are barriers

be doing it but there are barriers standing in the way there are reasons

standing in the way there are reasons

standing in the way there are reasons and then it’s never ever simply that the

and then it’s never ever simply that the

and then it’s never ever simply that the child doesn’t want to but knowing there

child doesn’t want to but knowing there

child doesn’t want to but knowing there are reasons doesn’t help our mainstream

are reasons doesn’t help our mainstream

are reasons doesn’t help our mainstream teachers in their incredibly difficult

teachers in their incredibly difficult

teachers in their incredibly difficult jobs challenging behavior in our

jobs challenging behavior in our

jobs challenging behavior in our classrooms creates anxiety

classrooms creates anxiety

classrooms creates anxiety causes disruption to learning and

causes disruption to learning and

causes disruption to learning and together with workload it’s one of the

together with workload it’s one of the

together with workload it’s one of the main reasons teachers give for their own

main reasons teachers give for their own

main reasons teachers give for their own mental health related absence and

mental health related absence and

mental health related absence and ultimately why some teachers leave the

ultimately why some teachers leave the

ultimately why some teachers leave the profession altogether and this is where

profession altogether and this is where

profession altogether and this is where the ideas and approaches and expertise

the ideas and approaches and expertise

the ideas and approaches and expertise that staff use and pupil Referral Units

that staff use and pupil Referral Units

that staff use and pupil Referral Units and other alternative provision could be

and other alternative provision could be

and other alternative provision could be so useful if it was extended and

so useful if it was extended and

so useful if it was extended and utilized in mainstream schools what my

utilized in mainstream schools what my

utilized in mainstream schools what my colleagues and I know is that without a

colleagues and I know is that without a

colleagues and I know is that without a significant relationship we can’t

significant relationship we can’t

significant relationship we can’t achieve a single thing these children

achieve a single thing these children

achieve a single thing these children won’t like us and respect doesn’t do as

won’t like us and respect doesn’t do as

won’t like us and respect doesn’t do as we say simply because we’re adults and

we say simply because we’re adults and

we say simply because we’re adults and teachers adults have often let them down

teachers adults have often let them down

teachers adults have often let them down so we have to prove ourselves worthy of

so we have to prove ourselves worthy of

so we have to prove ourselves worthy of their trust we have to earn it

their trust we have to earn it

their trust we have to earn it now fortunately for society as a whole

now fortunately for society as a whole

now fortunately for society as a whole most children follow rules but it’s been

most children follow rules but it’s been

most children follow rules but it’s been shown time and again that children with

shown time and again that children with

shown time and again that children with challenging behavior follow people first

challenging behavior follow people first

challenging behavior follow people first unreal second put simply if they like us

unreal second put simply if they like us

unreal second put simply if they like us they’ll feel safe and if they feel safe

they’ll feel safe and if they feel safe

they’ll feel safe and if they feel safe they’ll relax and if they relax they’re

they’ll relax and if they relax they’re

they’ll relax and if they relax they’re more likely to comply and to learn I’ve

more likely to comply and to learn I’ve

more likely to comply and to learn I’ve asked countless pupils young people what

asked countless pupils young people what

asked countless pupils young people what you think makes a good teacher and their

you think makes a good teacher and their

you think makes a good teacher and their responses are typically the same they

responses are typically the same they

responses are typically the same they say things like the ones that restrict

say things like the ones that restrict

say things like the ones that restrict but that you can still have a laugh with

but that you can still have a laugh with

but that you can still have a laugh with or the ones that seem interested in

or the ones that seem interested in

or the ones that seem interested in getting to know you or ones that treat

getting to know you or ones that treat

getting to know you or ones that treat you like you’re a human being I asked

you like you’re a human being I asked

you like you’re a human being I asked one young man and my pupil referral unit

one young man and my pupil referral unit

one young man and my pupil referral unit this question recently and he said I

never thought about that before miss

never thought about that before miss just give me a sec I gave him a sec and

just give me a sec I gave him a sec and

just give me a sec I gave him a sec and I waited and eventually he said right

I waited and eventually he said right

I waited and eventually he said right get on to this miss I think that teaches

get on to this miss I think that teaches

get on to this miss I think that teaches good teachers are ones that you can have

good teachers are ones that you can have

good teachers are ones that you can have like a high you know like a proper bond

like a high you know like a proper bond

like a high you know like a proper bond with do you know what I mean

with do you know what I mean

with do you know what I mean I told him I knew exactly what he meant

I told him I knew exactly what he meant

I told him I knew exactly what he meant so is it possible for mainstream

so is it possible for mainstream

so is it possible for mainstream teachers to build connections with

teachers to build connections with

teachers to build connections with challenging pupils I believe this

challenging pupils I believe this

challenging pupils I believe this requires a shift in thinking towards a

requires a shift in thinking towards a

requires a shift in thinking towards a greater sense of collective

greater sense of collective

greater sense of collective responsibility for these children now

responsibility for these children now

responsibility for these children now many of us know that our current

many of us know that our current

many of us know that our current educational environment does nothing to

educational environment does nothing to

educational environment does nothing to encourage this schools are primarily

encourage this schools are primarily

encourage this schools are primarily rewarded on academic results they’re

rewarded on academic results they’re

rewarded on academic results they’re actually incentivized to exclude pupils

actually incentivized to exclude pupils

actually incentivized to exclude pupils Ofsted inspections make no separate

Ofsted inspections make no separate

Ofsted inspections make no separate judgment about outcomes for children

judgment about outcomes for children

judgment about outcomes for children with special needs and those with

with special needs and those with

with special needs and those with challenging behavior and newly qualified

challenging behavior and newly qualified

challenging behavior and newly qualified teachers often report for they’re

teachers often report for they’re

teachers often report for they’re unprepared for how to teach these

unprepared for how to teach these

unprepared for how to teach these children but there are things that

children but there are things that

children but there are things that teachers can do in the meantime the

teachers can do in the meantime the

teachers can do in the meantime the teacher and author Paul Dix says it’s

teacher and author Paul Dix says it’s

teacher and author Paul Dix says it’s the small stuff it’s the daily acts of

the small stuff it’s the daily acts of

the small stuff it’s the daily acts of care

care

care it’s the perpetual generosity of spirit

it’s the perpetual generosity of spirit

it’s the perpetual generosity of spirit and the interest you show in their daily

and the interest you show in their daily

and the interest you show in their daily lives that matters most small things

lives that matters most small things

lives that matters most small things that can have a huge impact and we

that can have a huge impact and we

that can have a huge impact and we shouldn’t underestimate the ripple

shouldn’t underestimate the ripple

shouldn’t underestimate the ripple effect that one positive teacher pupil

effect that one positive teacher pupil

effect that one positive teacher pupil relationship can have there is nothing

relationship can have there is nothing

relationship can have there is nothing more beautiful to me than hearing one

more beautiful to me than hearing one

more beautiful to me than hearing one pupil I’ve spent some time with say

pupil I’ve spent some time with say

pupil I’ve spent some time with say quietly to another pupil that struggling

quietly to another pupil that struggling

quietly to another pupil that struggling to settle nah bro leave it out this is

to settle nah bro leave it out this is

to settle nah bro leave it out this is sound

collective responsibility is where it

collective responsibility is where it starts but if we want pupils with

starts but if we want pupils with

starts but if we want pupils with challenging behavior to learn how to

challenging behavior to learn how to

challenging behavior to learn how to behave we have to teach them explicitly

behave we have to teach them explicitly

behave we have to teach them explicitly and not just expect them to get it and

and not just expect them to get it and

and not just expect them to get it and this is where restorative approaches to

this is where restorative approaches to

this is where restorative approaches to behavior can be so useful now these are

behavior can be so useful now these are

behavior can be so useful now these are not hugging our alternatives are the

not hugging our alternatives are the

not hugging our alternatives are the opposite end of the bring back the birch

opposite end of the bring back the birch

opposite end of the bring back the birch argument rather they are tried and

argument rather they are tried and

argument rather they are tried and tested approaches designed to reinforce

tested approaches designed to reinforce

tested approaches designed to reinforce relationships and they explicitly teach

relationships and they explicitly teach

relationships and they explicitly teach missing skills like how to reflect on

missing skills like how to reflect on

missing skills like how to reflect on consequences like how to develop empathy

consequences like how to develop empathy

consequences like how to develop empathy and a conscience and they instill in

and a conscience and they instill in

and a conscience and they instill in pupils the expectation that reparation

pupils the expectation that reparation

pupils the expectation that reparation needs to happen detentions timeout

needs to happen detentions timeout

needs to happen detentions timeout exclusions and isolation do none of this

exclusions and isolation do none of this

exclusions and isolation do none of this and we’ve got plenty of evidence now

and we’ve got plenty of evidence now

and we’ve got plenty of evidence now that shows that our current systems of

that shows that our current systems of

that shows that our current systems of punishments and sanctions are

punishments and sanctions are

punishments and sanctions are ineffective with challenging pupils the

ineffective with challenging pupils the

ineffective with challenging pupils the head teacher and author John Ithorian

head teacher and author John Ithorian

head teacher and author John Ithorian says a fixed-term exclusions that they

says a fixed-term exclusions that they

says a fixed-term exclusions that they are in action masquerading as action

are in action masquerading as action

are in action masquerading as action they make us feel like we’re doing

they make us feel like we’re doing

they make us feel like we’re doing something when we’re doing nothing of

something when we’re doing nothing of

something when we’re doing nothing of the sort

the sort

the sort it is respite it is not improvement so

it is respite it is not improvement so

it is respite it is not improvement so we need a new way forward if we’re going

we need a new way forward if we’re going

we need a new way forward if we’re going to meet the needs of the most vulnerable

to meet the needs of the most vulnerable

to meet the needs of the most vulnerable and disadvantaged pupils in our society

and disadvantaged pupils in our society

and disadvantaged pupils in our society because while the world is full of

because while the world is full of

because while the world is full of tragic stories that were helpless to do

tragic stories that were helpless to do

tragic stories that were helpless to do anything about we can do something about

anything about we can do something about

anything about we can do something about outcomes for these children so let’s

outcomes for these children so let’s

outcomes for these children so let’s take collective responsibility and let’s

take collective responsibility and let’s

take collective responsibility and let’s make connections let’s share our

make connections let’s share our

make connections let’s share our expertise and integrate the best ideas

expertise and integrate the best ideas

expertise and integrate the best ideas we should question and challenge an

we should question and challenge an

we should question and challenge an inspection system and a culture that

inspection system and a culture that

inspection system and a culture that ignores them how can that be right and

ignores them how can that be right and

ignores them how can that be right and we should never forget that children

we should never forget that children

we should never forget that children with challenging behavior are just

with challenging behavior are just

with challenging behavior are just children doing their best to deal with

children doing their best to deal with

children doing their best to deal with what life is handed to them without any

what life is handed to them without any

what life is handed to them without any of our adult skills and if they could

of our adult skills and if they could

of our adult skills and if they could tell you what they need they would

tell you what they need they would

tell you what they need they would probably say

probably say

probably say something like don’t be scared of me

something like don’t be scared of me

something like don’t be scared of me please don’t give up on me make me feel

please don’t give up on me make me feel

please don’t give up on me make me feel I’m important and give me hope that

I’m important and give me hope that

I’m important and give me hope that things can and will get better please

things can and will get better please

things can and will get better please see past my behavior it’s not who I

see past my behavior it’s not who I

see past my behavior it’s not who I really am so I’m joining with them today

really am so I’m joining with them today

really am so I’m joining with them today in their challenging behavior to try to

in their challenging behavior to try to

in their challenging behavior to try to get their needs met or be in a more

get their needs met or be in a more

get their needs met or be in a more socially appropriate way and I invite

socially appropriate way and I invite

socially appropriate way and I invite you to do the same the only difference

you to do the same the only difference

you to do the same the only difference between all of us and the children I

between all of us and the children I

between all of us and the children I speak on behalf of is luck education and

speak on behalf of is luck education and

speak on behalf of is luck education and opportunities like this one let’s make a

opportunities like this one let’s make a

opportunities like this one let’s make a difference thank you

difference thank you

difference thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *