Press "Enter" to skip to content

We need to rethink our privilege? | Q&A with Mariam Veiszadeh | TEDxYouth@Sydney


[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

now my you started your TED talk

now my you started your TED talk actually with a personal story when you

actually with a personal story when you

actually with a personal story when you were working as a lawyer and you meant

were working as a lawyer and you meant

were working as a lawyer and you meant client for the first time I was

client for the first time I was

client for the first time I was wondering if you could share that story

wondering if you could share that story

wondering if you could share that story with our audience and then maybe talk

with our audience and then maybe talk

with our audience and then maybe talk about why that moment was a sort of

about why that moment was a sort of

about why that moment was a sort of light bulb for you or set off a light

light bulb for you or set off a light

light bulb for you or set off a light bulb that you knew you wanted to work in

bulb that you knew you wanted to work in

bulb that you knew you wanted to work in this area in terms of that story I have

this area in terms of that story I have

this area in terms of that story I have many stories trust me it so I was

many stories trust me it so I was

many stories trust me it so I was reflecting on the fact that early on in

reflecting on the fact that early on in

reflecting on the fact that early on in my career as a corporate lawyer I had

my career as a corporate lawyer I had

my career as a corporate lawyer I had this one particular interstate client

this one particular interstate client

this one particular interstate client and of course being the Chatterbox that

and of course being the Chatterbox that

and of course being the Chatterbox that I am I you know had spent months

I am I you know had spent months

I am I you know had spent months building rapport with her over the phone

building rapport with her over the phone

building rapport with her over the phone and over email and I was the lead

and over email and I was the lead

and over email and I was the lead advisor on her matter and so she’d

advisor on her matter and so she’d

advisor on her matter and so she’d spoken to me you know a lasagne not the

spoken to me you know a lasagne not the

spoken to me you know a lasagne not the phone but then we finally got to meet

phone but then we finally got to meet

phone but then we finally got to meet face-to-face and so I’ve walked into the

face-to-face and so I’ve walked into the

face-to-face and so I’ve walked into the meeting room and I said hello and she

meeting room and I said hello and she

meeting room and I said hello and she kind of gave me some look and she said

kind of gave me some look and she said

kind of gave me some look and she said ah you must work for Miriam and

obviously I wasn’t smuggling and

obviously I wasn’t smuggling and watermelon back then so but I guess the

watermelon back then so but I guess the

watermelon back then so but I guess the point was that she the voice that she

point was that she the voice that she

point was that she the voice that she had heard on the phone didn’t correspond

had heard on the phone didn’t correspond

had heard on the phone didn’t correspond to this person that was standing in

to this person that was standing in

to this person that was standing in front of her and yeah it was just I’ve

front of her and yeah it was just I’ve

front of her and yeah it was just I’ve felt you know it kind of killed my

felt you know it kind of killed my

felt you know it kind of killed my confidence a little bit because she

confidence a little bit because she

confidence a little bit because she assumed I was someone else and and

assumed I was someone else and and

assumed I was someone else and and particularly that the voice that she’d

particularly that the voice that she’d

particularly that the voice that she’d heard didn’t seem to correspond as

heard didn’t seem to correspond as

heard didn’t seem to correspond as someone who looked like me and so I

someone who looked like me and so I

someone who looked like me and so I found myself losing a little bit of

found myself losing a little bit of

found myself losing a little bit of confidence again having to work really

confidence again having to work really

confidence again having to work really hard to build that rapport and then

hard to build that rapport and then

hard to build that rapport and then having to kind of explain who I am and

having to kind of explain who I am and

having to kind of explain who I am and and then doubting myself and I think the

and then doubting myself and I think the

and then doubting myself and I think the thing to reflect on is that minority

thing to reflect on is that minority

thing to reflect on is that minority groups in something like up to 30% of

groups in something like up to 30% of

groups in something like up to 30% of their time worrying about how to fit in

their time worrying about how to fit in

their time worrying about how to fit in so that’s a lot of wasted productivity a

so that’s a lot of wasted productivity a

so that’s a lot of wasted productivity a lot of wasted energy

lot of wasted energy

lot of wasted energy about what

about what

about what c’est second-guessing yourself

c’est second-guessing yourself

c’est second-guessing yourself questioning how you’re speaking you know

questioning how you’re speaking you know

questioning how you’re speaking you know what’s coming out of your mouth because

what’s coming out of your mouth because

what’s coming out of your mouth because you want to make a particular impression

you want to make a particular impression

you want to make a particular impression and so I guess the point for me

and so I guess the point for me

and so I guess the point for me in that moment was people do make

in that moment was people do make

in that moment was people do make assumptions and and stereotype others

assumptions and and stereotype others

assumptions and and stereotype others and it’s not only unhealthy from their

and it’s not only unhealthy from their

and it’s not only unhealthy from their perspective but also from the person

perspective but also from the person

perspective but also from the person who’s on the receiving end so you were

who’s on the receiving end so you were

who’s on the receiving end so you were trained and you were working as a

trained and you were working as a

trained and you were working as a corporate lawyer and then now you work

corporate lawyer and then now you work

corporate lawyer and then now you work as a diversity inclusion in in

as a diversity inclusion in in

as a diversity inclusion in in corporations and big companies and I

corporations and big companies and I

corporations and big companies and I guess your experience is about well

guess your experience is about well

guess your experience is about well having such an understanding of how much

having such an understanding of how much

having such an understanding of how much of a waste of time or having to worry

of a waste of time or having to worry

of a waste of time or having to worry about all of that sort of stuff is what

about all of that sort of stuff is what

about all of that sort of stuff is what are some of the other like ramifications

are some of the other like ramifications

are some of the other like ramifications or the other sort of downfalls of this

or the other sort of downfalls of this

or the other sort of downfalls of this lack of diversity or this sort of lack

lack of diversity or this sort of lack

lack of diversity or this sort of lack of inclusion in the workforce how does

of inclusion in the workforce how does

of inclusion in the workforce how does that play out

that play out

that play out um I think ensuring that you’ve got

um I think ensuring that you’ve got

um I think ensuring that you’ve got diversity at every level so I’m not just

diversity at every level so I’m not just

diversity at every level so I’m not just talking entry-level but in particular

talking entry-level but in particular

talking entry-level but in particular into leadership levels it’s actually

into leadership levels it’s actually

into leadership levels it’s actually produces diversity of thought and that

produces diversity of thought and that

produces diversity of thought and that from a business perspective is

from a business perspective is

from a business perspective is incredible

incredible

incredible we need that we’re you know we’re facing

we need that we’re you know we’re facing

we need that we’re you know we’re facing a changing economy we’ve got the gig

a changing economy we’ve got the gig

a changing economy we’ve got the gig economy things are operating differently

economy things are operating differently

economy things are operating differently to how they used to to be innovative you

to how they used to to be innovative you

to how they used to to be innovative you need to have the diversity of thought

need to have the diversity of thought

need to have the diversity of thought and that comes about from having general

and that comes about from having general

and that comes about from having general diversity and it’s about then

diversity and it’s about then

diversity and it’s about then acknowledging the barriers that exists

acknowledging the barriers that exists

acknowledging the barriers that exists all diverse minority groups and why

all diverse minority groups and why

all diverse minority groups and why they’re not moving through the ranks a

they’re not moving through the ranks a

they’re not moving through the ranks a lot of those you know research and just

lot of those you know research and just

lot of those you know research and just insights that we have that at an entry

insights that we have that at an entry

insights that we have that at an entry level lots of corporations are

level lots of corporations are

level lots of corporations are incredibly diverse I’m talking every

incredibly diverse I’m talking every

incredibly diverse I’m talking every diversity stream but as you start to

diversity stream but as you start to

diversity stream but as you start to move through the ranks of leadership

move through the ranks of leadership

move through the ranks of leadership it’s not reflected and it’s you know

it’s not reflected and it’s you know

it’s not reflected and it’s you know that diversity is not reflected and so

that diversity is not reflected and so

that diversity is not reflected and so you’re missing out on several aspects

you’re missing out on several aspects

you’re missing out on several aspects one it’s the morale and the right thing

one it’s the morale and the right thing

one it’s the morale and the right thing to do to make sure that everybody has an

to do to make sure that everybody has an

to do to make sure that everybody has an equitable opportunity to move ahead but

equitable opportunity to move ahead but

equitable opportunity to move ahead but to there’s plenty of studies that prove

to there’s plenty of studies that prove

to there’s plenty of studies that prove that diversity

that diversity

that diversity at a board level and leadership level

at a board level and leadership level

at a board level and leadership level produces innovative results and is

produces innovative results and is

produces innovative results and is really good for your bottom line so it’s

really good for your bottom line so it’s

really good for your bottom line so it’s you know it makes business sense so on

you know it makes business sense so on

you know it makes business sense so on that I mean you mentioned that there’s a

that I mean you mentioned that there’s a

that I mean you mentioned that there’s a lot of space I suppose for diversity and

lot of space I suppose for diversity and

lot of space I suppose for diversity and people are trying to work on that more

people are trying to work on that more

people are trying to work on that more and that you’re seeing that say at maybe

and that you’re seeing that say at maybe

and that you’re seeing that say at maybe at the entry level but that when you

at the entry level but that when you

at the entry level but that when you look at our TVs or you look at

look at our TVs or you look at

look at our TVs or you look at university professors or you look at

university professors or you look at

university professors or you look at isn’t a CEOs or you look at you know

isn’t a CEOs or you look at you know

isn’t a CEOs or you look at you know pretty much at every level Australia

pretty much at every level Australia

pretty much at every level Australia isn’t a very well that that diversity of

isn’t a very well that that diversity of

isn’t a very well that that diversity of Australia isn’t represented on that sort

Australia isn’t represented on that sort

Australia isn’t represented on that sort of visible top tier of our country

of visible top tier of our country

of visible top tier of our country mm-hmm something that you said that

mm-hmm something that you said that

mm-hmm something that you said that really struck me is kind of terrifying

really struck me is kind of terrifying

really struck me is kind of terrifying was that a lot of our decisions that we

was that a lot of our decisions that we

was that a lot of our decisions that we make and especially decisions that get

make and especially decisions that get

make and especially decisions that get made in the workforce are actually

made in the workforce are actually

made in the workforce are actually subconscious and I was wondering if that

subconscious and I was wondering if that

subconscious and I was wondering if that was that a connection that you have

was that a connection that you have

was that a connection that you have drawn that the fact that we

drawn that the fact that we

drawn that the fact that we subconsciously kind of self-selecting

subconsciously kind of self-selecting

subconsciously kind of self-selecting that or something huh

that or something huh

that or something huh yeah so I spoke about unconscious bias

yeah so I spoke about unconscious bias

yeah so I spoke about unconscious bias in particular and and that you know I

in particular and and that you know I

in particular and and that you know I was Eric Kandel it was Nobel Peace Prize

was Eric Kandel it was Nobel Peace Prize

was Eric Kandel it was Nobel Peace Prize recipient and said that up to 90 percent

recipient and said that up to 90 percent

recipient and said that up to 90 percent of the brains function is actually

of the brains function is actually

of the brains function is actually unconscious and so I guess the point I

unconscious and so I guess the point I

unconscious and so I guess the point I want to make is that having unconscious

want to make is that having unconscious

want to make is that having unconscious thoughts isn’t necessarily always a bad

thoughts isn’t necessarily always a bad

thoughts isn’t necessarily always a bad thing it you know for example when

thing it you know for example when

thing it you know for example when you’re driving you know the first few

you’re driving you know the first few

you’re driving you know the first few times you put a lot of conscious effort

times you put a lot of conscious effort

times you put a lot of conscious effort into learning and you concentrate and

into learning and you concentrate and

into learning and you concentrate and then after a while you can literally do

then after a while you can literally do

then after a while you can literally do it with your eyes closed although I

it with your eyes closed although I

it with your eyes closed although I don’t recommend it but the point is it

don’t recommend it but the point is it

don’t recommend it but the point is it becomes unconscious right and so so the

becomes unconscious right and so so the

becomes unconscious right and so so the brain does have a lot of shortcuts and

brain does have a lot of shortcuts and

brain does have a lot of shortcuts and that’s not necessarily a bad thing but

that’s not necessarily a bad thing but

that’s not necessarily a bad thing but if those shortcuts that your brain has

if those shortcuts that your brain has

if those shortcuts that your brain has learned over time and it starts at a

learned over time and it starts at a

learned over time and it starts at a really young age

really young age

really young age if those shortcuts all those rules are

if those shortcuts all those rules are

if those shortcuts all those rules are wrong or have bias or prejudice in it

wrong or have bias or prejudice in it

wrong or have bias or prejudice in it then it’s really hard to untie it’s like

then it’s really hard to untie it’s like

then it’s really hard to untie it’s like learning driving of rules incorrectly

learning driving of rules incorrectly

learning driving of rules incorrectly and you’ve been doing it for years and

and you’ve been doing it for years and

and you’ve been doing it for years and then you have to worry your brain not to

then you have to worry your brain not to

then you have to worry your brain not to do that and that’s the thing about

do that and that’s the thing about

do that and that’s the thing about unconscious bias right unconscious

unconscious bias right unconscious

unconscious bias right unconscious thoughts aren’t always a bad thing but

thoughts aren’t always a bad thing but

thoughts aren’t always a bad thing but if you’re if you’re associating you’ve

if you’re if you’re associating you’ve

if you’re if you’re associating you’ve got these unconscious associations with

got these unconscious associations with

got these unconscious associations with certain things like for example whether

certain things like for example whether

certain things like for example whether it’s gender so you have all these gender

it’s gender so you have all these gender

it’s gender so you have all these gender stereotypes that you’ve grown up with

stereotypes that you’ve grown up with

stereotypes that you’ve grown up with that you don’t even think about you know

that you don’t even think about you know

that you don’t even think about you know that can be a negative thing if you’ve

that can be a negative thing if you’ve

that can be a negative thing if you’ve got all these associations around race

got all these associations around race

got all these associations around race for example that can be a negative thing

for example that can be a negative thing

for example that can be a negative thing and that’s it comes out when you are in

and that’s it comes out when you are in

and that’s it comes out when you are in the recruitment process for example or

the recruitment process for example or

the recruitment process for example or you are making decisions and so you know

you are making decisions and so you know

you are making decisions and so you know you’re you referenced earlier about the

you’re you referenced earlier about the

you’re you referenced earlier about the top ranks of leadership and how we’re

top ranks of leadership and how we’re

top ranks of leadership and how we’re not necessarily seeing that diversity

not necessarily seeing that diversity

not necessarily seeing that diversity and you’ve got to do and think about

and you’ve got to do and think about

and you’ve got to do and think about over the last you know historically how

over the last you know historically how

over the last you know historically how did we get to this point where that

did we get to this point where that

did we get to this point where that diversity isn’t reflected there and then

diversity isn’t reflected there and then

diversity isn’t reflected there and then I think the element of unconscious and

I think the element of unconscious and

I think the element of unconscious and perhaps conscious bias comes into it a

perhaps conscious bias comes into it a

perhaps conscious bias comes into it a lot of work that you’re doing I think we

lot of work that you’re doing I think we

lot of work that you’re doing I think we are especially the young people in the

are especially the young people in the

are especially the young people in the audience going to be very happy that you

audience going to be very happy that you

audience going to be very happy that you know you’ve forged ahead and tried to

know you’ve forged ahead and tried to

know you’ve forged ahead and tried to make these changes because you mentioned

make these changes because you mentioned

make these changes because you mentioned a study that it’s quite old I think now

a study that it’s quite old I think now

a study that it’s quite old I think now but maybe 10 or 15 years ago there was a

but maybe 10 or 15 years ago there was a

but maybe 10 or 15 years ago there was a study right that was the exact same CV

study right that was the exact same CV

study right that was the exact same CV and they just changed the names at the

and they just changed the names at the

and they just changed the names at the top they did it with men and women and I

top they did it with men and women and I

top they did it with men and women and I think there was a Western Asian sounding

think there was a Western Asian sounding

think there was a Western Asian sounding name and a Middle Eastern sounding name

name and a Middle Eastern sounding name

name and a Middle Eastern sounding name and Asian or Middle Eastern you’ll have

and Asian or Middle Eastern you’ll have

and Asian or Middle Eastern you’ll have to correct me with you know is that you

to correct me with you know is that you

to correct me with you know is that you had to the same resume had to get a

had to the same resume had to get a

had to the same resume had to get a submitted you know 50% more or something

submitted you know 50% more or something

submitted you know 50% more or something interview that’s right and they did it

interview that’s right and they did it

interview that’s right and they did it with indigenous names as well and they

with indigenous names as well and they

with indigenous names as well and they also trialed it with Italian names as

also trialed it with Italian names as

also trialed it with Italian names as well and what they found was the Asian

well and what they found was the Asian

well and what they found was the Asian sounding names had to apply 68% more

sounding names had to apply 68% more

sounding names had to apply 68% more times to get the same number of call

times to get the same number of call

times to get the same number of call backs as an Anglo Saxon sounding name

backs as an Anglo Saxon sounding name

backs as an Anglo Saxon sounding name and then if you had a Middle Eastern

and then if you had a Middle Eastern

and then if you had a Middle Eastern sounding name 64% more times and then if

sounding name 64% more times and then if

sounding name 64% more times and then if you had an indigenous name it’s 35% more

you had an indigenous name it’s 35% more

you had an indigenous name it’s 35% more times

times

times I think even an Italian name was 12%

I think even an Italian name was 12%

I think even an Italian name was 12% discrimination and so this kind of like

discrimination and so this kind of like

discrimination and so this kind of like unconscious decisions where we think

unconscious decisions where we think

unconscious decisions where we think that person is not right for that job or

that person is not right for that job or

that person is not right for that job or yeah I mean it could be in an

yeah I mean it could be in an

yeah I mean it could be in an unconscious component it could be a

unconscious component it could be a

unconscious component it could be a conscious bias but the reality back when

conscious bias but the reality back when

conscious bias but the reality back when this study was done was that those

this study was done was that those

this study was done was that those individuals with those names had to try

individuals with those names had to try

individuals with those names had to try harder and so the reality was they would

harder and so the reality was they would

harder and so the reality was they would have note that they weren’t getting

have note that they weren’t getting

have note that they weren’t getting callbacks but when you do this research

callbacks but when you do this research

callbacks but when you do this research in that way and you submit the exact

in that way and you submit the exact

in that way and you submit the exact same Rashmi so you can’t even say it’s

same Rashmi so you can’t even say it’s

same Rashmi so you can’t even say it’s not because you don’t have merit because

not because you don’t have merit because

not because you don’t have merit because they were the same resumes the same

they were the same resumes the same

they were the same resumes the same qualifications and same education and so

qualifications and same education and so

qualifications and same education and so the reality is that we know bias exists

the reality is that we know bias exists

the reality is that we know bias exists and that some of these fires is a lot

and that some of these fires is a lot

and that some of these fires is a lot more prominent when it comes to certain

more prominent when it comes to certain

more prominent when it comes to certain races and particularly gender as well we

races and particularly gender as well we

races and particularly gender as well we know that um so then you know how do you

know that um so then you know how do you

know that um so then you know how do you change that howdy and I’m hoping that if

change that howdy and I’m hoping that if

change that howdy and I’m hoping that if they’ve replicated the study today that

they’ve replicated the study today that

they’ve replicated the study today that that hopefully it wouldn’t be as bad but

that hopefully it wouldn’t be as bad but

that hopefully it wouldn’t be as bad but this is where something that that the

this is where something that that the

this is where something that that the industry is trying is anonymous

industry is trying is anonymous

industry is trying is anonymous recruitment where we actually strip away

recruitment where we actually strip away

recruitment where we actually strip away all those personal identifiers so we’ll

all those personal identifiers so we’ll

all those personal identifiers so we’ll strip away the agenda for example we’ll

strip away the agenda for example we’ll

strip away the agenda for example we’ll strip away the name and we’ll strip away

strip away the name and we’ll strip away

strip away the name and we’ll strip away things that indicate where someone has

things that indicate where someone has

things that indicate where someone has been brought up for example so address

been brought up for example so address

been brought up for example so address and school details and those kind of

and school details and those kind of

and school details and those kind of things and when you really remove all

things and when you really remove all

things and when you really remove all those things that people have no choice

those things that people have no choice

those things that people have no choice but to judge you purely based on merit

but to judge you purely based on merit

but to judge you purely based on merit they can’t look at your name and say

they can’t look at your name and say

they can’t look at your name and say this person might you know make an

this person might you know make an

this person might you know make an assumption about your name or make an

assumption about your name or make an

assumption about your name or make an assumption about a gender or your

assumption about a gender or your

assumption about a gender or your upbringing based on where you live so

upbringing based on where you live so

upbringing based on where you live so when you strip that away you create a

when you strip that away you create a

when you strip that away you create a true system in which you can actually

true system in which you can actually

true system in which you can actually enable a meritocracy but I would argue

enable a meritocracy but I would argue

enable a meritocracy but I would argue that under the current system that’s not

that under the current system that’s not

that under the current system that’s not always there because as human beings we

always there because as human beings we

always there because as human beings we all have biases we all have prejudices

all have biases we all have prejudices

all have biases we all have prejudices and a lot of what we’re exposed to day

and a lot of what we’re exposed to day

and a lot of what we’re exposed to day to day feeds those assumptions and those

to day feeds those assumptions and those

to day feeds those assumptions and those biases and you this is where I think we

biases and you this is where I think we

biases and you this is where I think we need intervention to help change that

need intervention to help change that

need intervention to help change that and you mentioned intervention I mean

and you mentioned intervention I mean

and you mentioned intervention I mean quotas and things like that have been a

quotas and things like that have been a

quotas and things like that have been a growing part of recruitment for

growing part of recruitment for

growing part of recruitment for universities and for for jobs as you

universities and for for jobs as you

universities and for for jobs as you mentioned before as well so

mentioned before as well so

mentioned before as well so I mean our quotas the answer I mean

I mean our quotas the answer I mean

I mean our quotas the answer I mean there’s always this counter-argument

there’s always this counter-argument

there’s always this counter-argument about inequality and how you have to

about inequality and how you have to

about inequality and how you have to apply inequality to attain equality you

apply inequality to attain equality you

apply inequality to attain equality you know by giving people who might not have

know by giving people who might not have

know by giving people who might not have had the chance before to have the chance

had the chance before to have the chance

had the chance before to have the chance they might have have to step over

they might have have to step over

they might have have to step over somebody who has more merit how would

somebody who has more merit how would

somebody who has more merit how would you kind of argue that you know that you

you kind of argue that you know that you

you kind of argue that you know that you need to sort of treat an inequality

need to sort of treat an inequality

need to sort of treat an inequality problem with inequality yes so I guess

problem with inequality yes so I guess

problem with inequality yes so I guess when we talk about quotas I specifically

when we talk about quotas I specifically

when we talk about quotas I specifically say that and part of my talk was about

say that and part of my talk was about

say that and part of my talk was about targets in particular rather than quotas

targets in particular rather than quotas

targets in particular rather than quotas targets are aspirational we you know in

targets are aspirational we you know in

targets are aspirational we you know in in the sense that you’ll have a women in

in the sense that you’ll have a women in

in the sense that you’ll have a women in leadership target for example gender

leadership target for example gender

leadership target for example gender diversity target all targets for other

diversity target all targets for other

diversity target all targets for other diversity streams and the reason I say

diversity streams and the reason I say

diversity streams and the reason I say that and I know what you’re getting at

that and I know what you’re getting at

that and I know what you’re getting at around that sort of is a positive

around that sort of is a positive

around that sort of is a positive discrimination and the thing is I would

discrimination and the thing is I would

discrimination and the thing is I would argue that positive discrimination has

argue that positive discrimination has

argue that positive discrimination has existed for ever right and if you think

existed for ever right and if you think

existed for ever right and if you think about it from this perspective

about it from this perspective

about it from this perspective historically who are the guys who who

historically who are the guys who who

historically who are the guys who who are the persons that are in the top

are the persons that are in the top

are the persons that are in the top ranks of society whether it’s sort of in

ranks of society whether it’s sort of in

ranks of society whether it’s sort of in Australia or in other Western countries

Australia or in other Western countries

Australia or in other Western countries and the reality is that you know if you

and the reality is that you know if you

and the reality is that you know if you were to pose these questions to those

were to pose these questions to those

were to pose these questions to those individuals because sometimes it is

individuals because sometimes it is

individuals because sometimes it is those individuals who come up with this

those individuals who come up with this

those individuals who come up with this but what about international men’s day

but what about international men’s day

but what about international men’s day you know and things very bad and I sort

you know and things very bad and I sort

you know and things very bad and I sort of say to them and of course this is not

of say to them and of course this is not

of say to them and of course this is not across the board and I don’t want to

across the board and I don’t want to

across the board and I don’t want to stereotype but someone who poses that

stereotype but someone who poses that

stereotype but someone who poses that argument and I’ve had it ask people have

argument and I’ve had it ask people have

argument and I’ve had it ask people have asked me I sort of say well what if you

asked me I sort of say well what if you

asked me I sort of say well what if you didn’t get your job on merit what if

didn’t get your job on merit what if

didn’t get your job on merit what if just possibly you got your job because

just possibly you got your job because

just possibly you got your job because your male Anglo Saxon cisgender and

your male Anglo Saxon cisgender and

your male Anglo Saxon cisgender and straight what if and that you could

straight what if and that you could

straight what if and that you could argue that’s positive discrimination you

argue that’s positive discrimination you

argue that’s positive discrimination you can argue that historically the system

can argue that historically the system

can argue that historically the system has had a preference for individuals

has had a preference for individuals

has had a preference for individuals that tick those boxes because if we had

that tick those boxes because if we had

that tick those boxes because if we had a true meritocracy then you would see

a true meritocracy then you would see

a true meritocracy then you would see more diversity at but

more diversity at but

more diversity at but because the current status quo assumes a

because the current status quo assumes a

because the current status quo assumes a few things it assumes that women don’t

few things it assumes that women don’t

few things it assumes that women don’t have merit because if women had merit

have merit because if women had merit

have merit because if women had merit there’d be more of them at the top it

there’d be more of them at the top it

there’d be more of them at the top it also assumes that culturally diverse

also assumes that culturally diverse

also assumes that culturally diverse people don’t have merit because again if

people don’t have merit because again if

people don’t have merit because again if they did there wouldn’t be more of them

they did there wouldn’t be more of them

they did there wouldn’t be more of them at the top so either those are

at the top so either those are

at the top so either those are completely absurd conclusions and they

completely absurd conclusions and they

completely absurd conclusions and they are you know it’s so that’s how I kind

are you know it’s so that’s how I kind

are you know it’s so that’s how I kind of answer that you know what if and what

of answer that you know what if and what

of answer that you know what if and what we know is a merit or the concept of

we know is a merit or the concept of

we know is a merit or the concept of merit isn’t really what we think it is

merit isn’t really what we think it is

merit isn’t really what we think it is and you do need to create the foundation

and you do need to create the foundation

and you do need to create the foundation to create a true meritocracy because you

to create a true meritocracy because you

to create a true meritocracy because you know I wish we existed in the world

know I wish we existed in the world

know I wish we existed in the world where we didn’t have to worry about

where we didn’t have to worry about

where we didn’t have to worry about positive or negative discrimination

positive or negative discrimination

positive or negative discrimination where we didn’t have to worry about

where we didn’t have to worry about

where we didn’t have to worry about quotas or targets but in as I mentioned

quotas or targets but in as I mentioned

quotas or targets but in as I mentioned in my um when I take my den to the exit

in my um when I take my den to the exit

in my um when I take my den to the exit ok I kind of ended it with because there

ok I kind of ended it with because there

ok I kind of ended it with because there are lots of people who like cringe when

are lots of people who like cringe when

are lots of people who like cringe when you say the word targets a little here

you say the word targets a little here

you say the word targets a little here we go they think it’s sort of you know

we go they think it’s sort of you know

we go they think it’s sort of you know like it’s at a superficial level that I

like it’s at a superficial level that I

like it’s at a superficial level that I am NOT asking you know people to put

am NOT asking you know people to put

am NOT asking you know people to put photos of diverse certain people on

photos of diverse certain people on

photos of diverse certain people on their websites it’s got to be real

their websites it’s got to be real

their websites it’s got to be real diversity that creates diversity of

diversity that creates diversity of

diversity that creates diversity of thought but people who mount this

thought but people who mount this

thought but people who mount this argument against targets I sort of say

argument against targets I sort of say

argument against targets I sort of say to them well you know that famous quote

to them well you know that famous quote

to them well you know that famous quote the definition of insanity is doing the

the definition of insanity is doing the

the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and

same thing over and over again and

same thing over and over again and expecting different bloody results and

expecting different bloody results and

expecting different bloody results and the reality is we have been doing you

the reality is we have been doing you

the reality is we have been doing you know you can’t do the same thing and

know you can’t do the same thing and

know you can’t do the same thing and expect things to change if people say

expect things to change if people say

expect things to change if people say well of you if you got married you’ll

well of you if you got married you’ll

well of you if you got married you’ll get to the top well studies have proven

get to the top well studies have proven

get to the top well studies have proven that those who have merit aren’t getting

that those who have merit aren’t getting

that those who have merit aren’t getting to the top because those barriers in

to the top because those barriers in

to the top because those barriers in place so that’s why we have to try

place so that’s why we have to try

place so that’s why we have to try something different and that’s how I

something different and that’s how I

something different and that’s how I mount the case the business case and the

mount the case the business case and the

mount the case the business case and the moral case for why I think targets are

moral case for why I think targets are

moral case for why I think targets are required that’s all we have time for we

required that’s all we have time for we

required that’s all we have time for we could talk about this all day

could talk about this all day

could talk about this all day thank you so much for joining us John

thank you so much for joining us John

thank you so much for joining us John Masada is everybody

Masada is everybody

Masada is everybody I didn’t fall I’m as America thanks so

I didn’t fall I’m as America thanks so

I didn’t fall I’m as America thanks so much

much

much [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *