Press "Enter" to skip to content

UNHELPFUL THINKING | Professor Patrick McGhee | TEDxUniversityofBolton


I want to introduce you to five

I want to introduce you to five characters

characters

characters Chloe is recovering from depression she

Chloe is recovering from depression she

Chloe is recovering from depression she lost her job about a year ago applied

lost her job about a year ago applied

lost her job about a year ago applied for another job and got the job and they

for another job and got the job and they

for another job and got the job and they wanted to get promoted and didn’t get

wanted to get promoted and didn’t get

wanted to get promoted and didn’t get promoted and things got pretty bad for

promoted and things got pretty bad for

promoted and things got pretty bad for her but she’s recovering

Susan is a student and she is the first

Susan is a student and she is the first in her family to go to university her

in her family to go to university her

in her family to go to university her grades are good but a little bit

grades are good but a little bit

grades are good but a little bit variable and her critters think she’s

variable and her critters think she’s

variable and her critters think she’s great and huge potential and she’s

great and huge potential and she’s

great and huge potential and she’s thinking of dropping out thinking of

thinking of dropping out thinking of

thinking of dropping out thinking of leaving University and abandoning her

leaving University and abandoning her

leaving University and abandoning her objective of becoming a bio chemist

objective of becoming a bio chemist

objective of becoming a bio chemist Rachel and Raymond are married moved to

Rachel and Raymond are married moved to

Rachel and Raymond are married moved to a new city about a year ago Rachel and

a new city about a year ago Rachel and

a new city about a year ago Rachel and Raymond both got new jobs that’s why

Raymond both got new jobs that’s why

Raymond both got new jobs that’s why they moved to the same city and it

they moved to the same city and it

they moved to the same city and it hasn’t gone well they don’t think things

hasn’t gone well they don’t think things

hasn’t gone well they don’t think things are right and they’re thinking of

are right and they’re thinking of

are right and they’re thinking of leaving bob owns a large trading company

leaving bob owns a large trading company

leaving bob owns a large trading company there’s a lot of work with charities and

there’s a lot of work with charities and

there’s a lot of work with charities and social enterprises and he is not

social enterprises and he is not

social enterprises and he is not sleeping at night because he doesn’t

sleeping at night because he doesn’t

sleeping at night because he doesn’t know whether to get involved in a

know whether to get involved in a

know whether to get involved in a takeover or not they’re all true stories

takeover or not they’re all true stories

takeover or not they’re all true stories but fictional characters based on real

but fictional characters based on real

but fictional characters based on real experiences things I’ve seen over the

experiences things I’ve seen over the

experiences things I’ve seen over the years all of these situations individual

years all of these situations individual

years all of these situations individual mental health running companies around

mental health running companies around

mental health running companies around charities students at university

charities students at university

charities students at university marriages are also like things in the

marriages are also like things in the

marriages are also like things in the media we hear nowadays distress and

media we hear nowadays distress and

media we hear nowadays distress and challenge and things not going well but

challenge and things not going well but

challenge and things not going well but individuals and couples and

individuals and couples and

individuals and couples and organizations dealing with those

organizations dealing with those

organizations dealing with those challenges improving thriving and

challenges improving thriving and

challenges improving thriving and recovering but it’s not easy when we

recovering but it’s not easy when we

recovering but it’s not easy when we look at it it looks very different in

look at it it looks very different in

look at it it looks very different in those different contexts

my proposition is their understanding

my proposition is their understanding the way in which individuals recover

the way in which individuals recover

the way in which individuals recover from depression and from anxiety helps

from depression and from anxiety helps

from depression and from anxiety helps us understand other forms of unhappiness

us understand other forms of unhappiness

us understand other forms of unhappiness and other forms of distress and how to

and other forms of distress and how to

and other forms of distress and how to improve the life situation of other

improve the life situation of other

improve the life situation of other individuals and of couples and yes of

individuals and of couples and yes of

individuals and of couples and yes of organizations and society in general as

organizations and society in general as

organizations and society in general as well let’s look at depression the

well let’s look at depression the

well let’s look at depression the clinical evidence is very clear that

clinical evidence is very clear that

clinical evidence is very clear that although each individual person is

although each individual person is

although each individual person is different and each individual’s

different and each individual’s

different and each individual’s experience of depression is different

experience of depression is different

experience of depression is different and although there are multiple complex

and although there are multiple complex

and although there are multiple complex immediate and long-term causes of the

immediate and long-term causes of the

immediate and long-term causes of the press of episodes that the best way of

press of episodes that the best way of

press of episodes that the best way of healthy a person who is depressed is to

healthy a person who is depressed is to

healthy a person who is depressed is to work out with them what is maintaining

work out with them what is maintaining

work out with them what is maintaining their depression it would be good to

their depression it would be good to

their depression it would be good to know what kind of caused it but we all

know what kind of caused it but we all

know what kind of caused it but we all react in different ways to negative life

react in different ways to negative life

react in different ways to negative life events but when that reaction becomes

events but when that reaction becomes

events but when that reaction becomes extremely intensive and recurs and

extremely intensive and recurs and

extremely intensive and recurs and maintains itself then clearly there’s

maintains itself then clearly there’s

maintains itself then clearly there’s something we can do we can focus not on

something we can do we can focus not on

something we can do we can focus not on the cause but on the activities which

the cause but on the activities which

the cause but on the activities which are maintaining that type of depression

depression is a vicious circle amongst

depression is a vicious circle amongst much else when we are feeling low when

much else when we are feeling low when

much else when we are feeling low when our mood is bad because of what’s called

our mood is bad because of what’s called

our mood is bad because of what’s called mood congruence effects when we are

mood congruence effects when we are

mood congruence effects when we are feeling sad we are more likely to

feeling sad we are more likely to

feeling sad we are more likely to remember sad information from the past

remember sad information from the past

remember sad information from the past when we think about the future we’re

when we think about the future we’re

when we think about the future we’re more likely to think about negative

more likely to think about negative

more likely to think about negative possibilities there and that makes us

possibilities there and that makes us

possibilities there and that makes us stop doing things

stop doing things

stop doing things it makes us much less active because we

it makes us much less active because we

it makes us much less active because we don’t want to see what is out there we

don’t want to see what is out there we

don’t want to see what is out there we expect it to be bad

expect it to be bad

expect it to be bad Chloe was like this when Chloe was

Chloe was like this when Chloe was

Chloe was like this when Chloe was interviewed for a job and didn’t get

interviewed for a job and didn’t get

interviewed for a job and didn’t get promotion two or three of her what

promotion two or three of her what

promotion two or three of her what colleagues also didn’t get promoted and

colleagues also didn’t get promoted and

colleagues also didn’t get promoted and for a week I saw they all felt pretty

for a week I saw they all felt pretty

for a week I saw they all felt pretty fed up it was a really golden

fed up it was a really golden

fed up it was a really golden opportunity

opportunity

opportunity kostik chance to get promoted enough a

kostik chance to get promoted enough a

kostik chance to get promoted enough a growing company close to friends felt

growing company close to friends felt

growing company close to friends felt fine after a month and shook it off

fine after a month and shook it off

fine after a month and shook it off because some people do that in different

because some people do that in different

because some people do that in different ways but Chloe didn’t ploy thought about

ways but Chloe didn’t ploy thought about

ways but Chloe didn’t ploy thought about the fact that this probably meant that

the fact that this probably meant that

the fact that this probably meant that company felt amid a mistake when it

company felt amid a mistake when it

company felt amid a mistake when it hired her

hired her

hired her Chloe felt that everyone in her area

Chloe felt that everyone in her area

Chloe felt that everyone in her area would know that she was feeling rejected

would know that she was feeling rejected

would know that she was feeling rejected Chloe felt that in the future if she

Chloe felt that in the future if she

Chloe felt that in the future if she applied for any more promotions she

applied for any more promotions she

applied for any more promotions she would also get turned down these are

would also get turned down these are

would also get turned down these are aspects of unhelpful thinking this is

aspects of unhelpful thinking this is

aspects of unhelpful thinking this is not about right and wrong this is not

not about right and wrong this is not

not about right and wrong this is not about saying to someone you’re thinking

about saying to someone you’re thinking

about saying to someone you’re thinking the wrong things it’s about helping

the wrong things it’s about helping

the wrong things it’s about helping individuals understand how they can look

individuals understand how they can look

individuals understand how they can look at their environment and used it their

at their environment and used it their

at their environment and used it their best intellectual ability their best

best intellectual ability their best

best intellectual ability their best knowledge to make the decisions are

knowledge to make the decisions are

knowledge to make the decisions are right for them but when you’re not at

right for them but when you’re not at

right for them but when you’re not at your best the bias is kick in when we

your best the bias is kick in when we

your best the bias is kick in when we are not feeling well we see things in a

are not feeling well we see things in a

are not feeling well we see things in a more negative way seem with anxiety when

more negative way seem with anxiety when

more negative way seem with anxiety when we’re feeling anxious we start to

we’re feeling anxious we start to

we’re feeling anxious we start to cognitively look for more threats

cognitively look for more threats

cognitively look for more threats evolution recurrent means that in the

evolution recurrent means that in the

evolution recurrent means that in the past that was a strong defensive

past that was a strong defensive

past that was a strong defensive mechanism because if there was a

mechanism because if there was a

mechanism because if there was a possibility of being attacked then you

possibility of being attacked then you

possibility of being attacked then you wanted to make sure that you were not

wanted to make sure that you were not

wanted to make sure that you were not attacked there were no gray areas people

attacked there were no gray areas people

attacked there were no gray areas people suffering from anxiety tend to

suffering from anxiety tend to

suffering from anxiety tend to significantly overestimate the

significantly overestimate the

significantly overestimate the probability of pending negative events

probability of pending negative events

probability of pending negative events they also significantly overestimate the

they also significantly overestimate the

they also significantly overestimate the consequences of those events they also

consequences of those events they also

consequences of those events they also significantly underestimate their

significantly underestimate their

significantly underestimate their ability to cope with those negative

ability to cope with those negative

ability to cope with those negative effects if there were to materialize

effects if there were to materialize

effects if there were to materialize they also interestingly significantly

they also interestingly significantly

they also interestingly significantly underestimate the ability of other

underestimate the ability of other

underestimate the ability of other people to cope with their own negative

people to cope with their own negative

people to cope with their own negative events the way we feel about things

events the way we feel about things

events the way we feel about things particularly the way we feel about

particularly the way we feel about

particularly the way we feel about ourselves impact and how we think about

ourselves impact and how we think about

ourselves impact and how we think about things and that’s what creates the

things and that’s what creates the

things and that’s what creates the vicious circle

vicious circle

vicious circle the low mood or anxiety generates

the low mood or anxiety generates

the low mood or anxiety generates certain types of thoughts and not others

certain types of thoughts and not others

certain types of thoughts and not others those thoughts effectively validate our

those thoughts effectively validate our

those thoughts effectively validate our feelings about the feelings that we have

feelings about the feelings that we have

feelings about the feelings that we have so it’s not a system of feelings that is

so it’s not a system of feelings that is

so it’s not a system of feelings that is perpetuating the negative experience

perpetuating the negative experience

perpetuating the negative experience it’s thinking about the situation and

it’s thinking about the situation and

it’s thinking about the situation and how that drives further feelings to many

how that drives further feelings to many

how that drives further feelings to many people around the world and in this

people around the world and in this

people around the world and in this country suffer from depression and

country suffer from depression and

country suffer from depression and anxiety and most of them aren’t getting

anxiety and most of them aren’t getting

anxiety and most of them aren’t getting the support that they require one aspect

the support that they require one aspect

the support that they require one aspect of tackling this is around cognitive

of tackling this is around cognitive

of tackling this is around cognitive therapy it seeks to alleviate

therapy it seeks to alleviate

therapy it seeks to alleviate psychological stresses by correcting

psychological stresses by correcting

psychological stresses by correcting faulty conceptions and self signals so

faulty conceptions and self signals so

faulty conceptions and self signals so faulty conceptions about the world and

faulty conceptions about the world and

faulty conceptions about the world and self signals taking from your own body

self signals taking from your own body

self signals taking from your own body you feel your hands shaking so you think

you feel your hands shaking so you think

you feel your hands shaking so you think this must be a threatening situation by

this must be a threatening situation by

this must be a threatening situation by correcting your own ease beliefs we can

correcting your own ease beliefs we can

correcting your own ease beliefs we can Lourdes excess of reactions I like to

Lourdes excess of reactions I like to

Lourdes excess of reactions I like to put it like this though everyone in the

put it like this though everyone in the

put it like this though everyone in the room thinks I’m dumb right now sort

room thinks I’m dumb right now sort

room thinks I’m dumb right now sort everyone in the world ever we all have

everyone in the world ever we all have

everyone in the world ever we all have that experience from time to time at

that experience from time to time at

that experience from time to time at some point in our lives we just think we

some point in our lives we just think we

some point in our lives we just think we are the dumbest person in room because

are the dumbest person in room because

are the dumbest person in room because we’ve said one thing that wasn’t quite

we’ve said one thing that wasn’t quite

we’ve said one thing that wasn’t quite right and yet the chances are that no

right and yet the chances are that no

right and yet the chances are that no inherited or didn’t see it’s been the

inherited or didn’t see it’s been the

inherited or didn’t see it’s been the wrong thing and if it did think it was

wrong thing and if it did think it was

wrong thing and if it did think it was imperfect it’s not going to make them

imperfect it’s not going to make them

imperfect it’s not going to make them think of you as being the dumbest person

think of you as being the dumbest person

think of you as being the dumbest person that just won’t take it we all do it but

that just won’t take it we all do it but

that just won’t take it we all do it but if you’re depressed or anxious you’re

if you’re depressed or anxious you’re

if you’re depressed or anxious you’re more likely to do than any other time in

more likely to do than any other time in

more likely to do than any other time in your life but understanding those

your life but understanding those

your life but understanding those processes I think can be applied more

processes I think can be applied more

processes I think can be applied more generally to make sure that we can

generally to make sure that we can

generally to make sure that we can connect with those systems which

connect with those systems which

connect with those systems which perpetuate a bad situation be it in

perpetuate a bad situation be it in

perpetuate a bad situation be it in terms of mental health education working

terms of mental health education working

terms of mental health education working with a charity or in a relationship I

with a charity or in a relationship I

with a charity or in a relationship I want to go through some of the specifics

want to go through some of the specifics

want to go through some of the specifics of aspects of unhelpful thinking styles

of aspects of unhelpful thinking styles

of aspects of unhelpful thinking styles these are all if you will mental errors

these are all if you will mental errors

these are all if you will mental errors that

that

that that we do all of us very regularly

that we do all of us very regularly

that we do all of us very regularly which mean that we are not making a full

which mean that we are not making a full

which mean that we are not making a full understanding of the world around us and

understanding of the world around us and

understanding of the world around us and our future in a way that’s going to be

our future in a way that’s going to be

our future in a way that’s going to be helpful to us and I want to emphasize we

helpful to us and I want to emphasize we

helpful to us and I want to emphasize we all do this very regularly in different

all do this very regularly in different

all do this very regularly in different parts of our lives

parts of our lives

parts of our lives but when an individual or a marriage or

but when an individual or a marriage or

but when an individual or a marriage or a company or a national conversation is

a company or a national conversation is

a company or a national conversation is in a bad place with bad feelings bad

in a bad place with bad feelings bad

in a bad place with bad feelings bad attitudes bad and by which we negative

attitudes bad and by which we negative

attitudes bad and by which we negative and restrictive ideas it generates ways

and restrictive ideas it generates ways

and restrictive ideas it generates ways of thinking which perpetuates the bad

of thinking which perpetuates the bad

of thinking which perpetuates the bad atmosphere that triggered it in the

atmosphere that triggered it in the

atmosphere that triggered it in the first place

first place

first place all or nothing thinking this is when we

all or nothing thinking this is when we

all or nothing thinking this is when we walk around thinking that either things

walk around thinking that either things

walk around thinking that either things are fantastic or awful

are fantastic or awful

are fantastic or awful some people have it just more entirely

some people have it just more entirely

some people have it just more entirely others have almost all the lives I am

others have almost all the lives I am

others have almost all the lives I am either perfect or I’m a failure and I

either perfect or I’m a failure and I

either perfect or I’m a failure and I want to find out which I am by going to

want to find out which I am by going to

want to find out which I am by going to university now that kind of binary

university now that kind of binary

university now that kind of binary opposition is very dangerous of course

opposition is very dangerous of course

opposition is very dangerous of course and it’s also false but at any number of

and it’s also false but at any number of

and it’s also false but at any number of shades of grey between those two

shades of grey between those two

shades of grey between those two possibilities susan has that susan was

possibilities susan has that susan was

possibilities susan has that susan was told by people around her in her

told by people around her in her

told by people around her in her community and in her school in our

community and in her school in our

community and in her school in our school that she probably isn’t the right

school that she probably isn’t the right

school that she probably isn’t the right sub-material to go to university there

sub-material to go to university there

sub-material to go to university there was a risk that you she would fail

was a risk that you she would fail

was a risk that you she would fail others said knowledge you’ve got

others said knowledge you’ve got

others said knowledge you’ve got tremendous potential it will be hard but

tremendous potential it will be hard but

tremendous potential it will be hard but you will be a success you will achieve

you will be a success you will achieve

you will be a success you will achieve all sorts of things now for all kinds of

all sorts of things now for all kinds of

all sorts of things now for all kinds of reasons

reasons

reasons susan incorporates this is what who’s

susan incorporates this is what who’s

susan incorporates this is what who’s right am i a failure you shouldn’t be at

right am i a failure you shouldn’t be at

right am i a failure you shouldn’t be at university or are my broom

if you live your life under

if you live your life under all-or-nothing thinking every waking

all-or-nothing thinking every waking

all-or-nothing thinking every waking moment is like walking along the edge of

moment is like walking along the edge of

moment is like walking along the edge of a flesh

a flesh

a flesh walking along the edge of a cliff and

walking along the edge of a cliff and

walking along the edge of a cliff and every feeling you have about the future

every feeling you have about the future

every feeling you have about the future is a feeling about what it feels like

is a feeling about what it feels like

is a feeling about what it feels like after you have fallen he would want to

after you have fallen he would want to

after you have fallen he would want to live their lives along a cliff edge it’s

live their lives along a cliff edge it’s

live their lives along a cliff edge it’s true for people who suffer from

true for people who suffer from

true for people who suffer from depression it’s often true of students

depression it’s often true of students

depression it’s often true of students in education it’s true of marriages it’s

in education it’s true of marriages it’s

in education it’s true of marriages it’s true of companies overgeneralization

true of companies overgeneralization

true of companies overgeneralization this is where we extrapolate

this is where we extrapolate

this is where we extrapolate inappropriately from one instance to a

inappropriately from one instance to a

inappropriately from one instance to a much bigger set of ideas about the world

much bigger set of ideas about the world

much bigger set of ideas about the world around us in evolutionary terms if you

around us in evolutionary terms if you

around us in evolutionary terms if you eat some berries and they made you sick

eat some berries and they made you sick

eat some berries and they made you sick you wouldn’t just avoid that particular

you wouldn’t just avoid that particular

you wouldn’t just avoid that particular location you probably would avoid the

location you probably would avoid the

location you probably would avoid the whole hillside because you couldn’t

whole hillside because you couldn’t

whole hillside because you couldn’t afford to take risks but nowadays you

afford to take risks but nowadays you

afford to take risks but nowadays you meet the new person in your workplace at

meet the new person in your workplace at

meet the new person in your workplace at your new job and they seem unfriendly

your new job and they seem unfriendly

your new job and they seem unfriendly and you think this must be an unfriendly

and you think this must be an unfriendly

and you think this must be an unfriendly company the first shooter you meet seems

company the first shooter you meet seems

company the first shooter you meet seems to be really quite demanding and

to be really quite demanding and

to be really quite demanding and challenging you think they’re all going

challenging you think they’re all going

challenging you think they’re all going to be like that for better or worse you

to be like that for better or worse you

to be like that for better or worse you might look outside your window it’s a

might look outside your window it’s a

might look outside your window it’s a bit like this you look outside your

bit like this you look outside your

bit like this you look outside your window you see a yellow umbrella you

window you see a yellow umbrella you

window you see a yellow umbrella you think oh my goodness all the other

think oh my goodness all the other

think oh my goodness all the other umbrellas are going to be yellow too it

umbrellas are going to be yellow too it

umbrellas are going to be yellow too it must be where your yellow umbrella was

must be where your yellow umbrella was

must be where your yellow umbrella was tried day what am I going to do I don’t

tried day what am I going to do I don’t

tried day what am I going to do I don’t have a yellow umbrella but of course

have a yellow umbrella but of course

have a yellow umbrella but of course it’s not like that but when we are not

it’s not like that but when we are not

it’s not like that but when we are not our best we are blinkered we filter out

our best we are blinkered we filter out

our best we are blinkered we filter out all the things which are going to give

all the things which are going to give

all the things which are going to give them more balanced point of view

them more balanced point of view

them more balanced point of view labeling Susan’s label herself she

labeling Susan’s label herself she

labeling Susan’s label herself she labeled herself as a failing student

despite evidence to the contrary so

despite evidence to the contrary so she’s not depressed and she’s unlikely

she’s not depressed and she’s unlikely

she’s not depressed and she’s unlikely to become sore though too many students

to become sore though too many students

to become sore though too many students experience depression and anxiety across

experience depression and anxiety across

experience depression and anxiety across the period of their education and

the period of their education and

the period of their education and subsequently but she’s just becoming

subsequently but she’s just becoming

subsequently but she’s just becoming pessimistic and if you’ll allow now one

pessimistic and if you’ll allow now one

pessimistic and if you’ll allow now one of the biggest challenges you’ve got

of the biggest challenges you’ve got

of the biggest challenges you’ve got isn’t managing time because you’ll get

isn’t managing time because you’ll get

isn’t managing time because you’ll get the hang of that and it’s not about

the hang of that and it’s not about

the hang of that and it’s not about navigating the complexity of the

navigating the complexity of the

navigating the complexity of the syllabus because it’s written to help

syllabus because it’s written to help

syllabus because it’s written to help you and you’ll get good tuition

you and you’ll get good tuition

you and you’ll get good tuition the biggest danger if you learner is

the biggest danger if you learner is

the biggest danger if you learner is pessimism because it will drive your

pessimism because it will drive your

pessimism because it will drive your perceptions of other things and you will

perceptions of other things and you will

perceptions of other things and you will start to filter right the things that

start to filter right the things that

start to filter right the things that make you optimistic it will fuel itself

make you optimistic it will fuel itself

make you optimistic it will fuel itself it is a vicious circle there are many

it is a vicious circle there are many

it is a vicious circle there are many other things disqualifying the positive

other things disqualifying the positive

other things disqualifying the positive I mentioned earlier this is where Amelia

I mentioned earlier this is where Amelia

I mentioned earlier this is where Amelia student gets a good mark but they say

student gets a good mark but they say

student gets a good mark but they say well so one off the question on the exam

well so one off the question on the exam

well so one off the question on the exam paper was actually really quite easy be

paper was actually really quite easy be

paper was actually really quite easy be mark I got was a reflection of the fact

mark I got was a reflection of the fact

mark I got was a reflection of the fact I happen to be quite interesting that in

I happen to be quite interesting that in

I happen to be quite interesting that in that area anyway and I spent all week we

that area anyway and I spent all week we

that area anyway and I spent all week we can’t looking at it so it’s not a fair

can’t looking at it so it’s not a fair

can’t looking at it so it’s not a fair summary of me I’m a feeling to do

summary of me I’m a feeling to do

summary of me I’m a feeling to do jumping to conclusions catastrophizing

jumping to conclusions catastrophizing

jumping to conclusions catastrophizing jump into conclusions is when we think

jump into conclusions is when we think

jump into conclusions is when we think we can read the minds of other people

we can read the minds of other people

we can read the minds of other people Susan thinks this she thinks not only

Susan thinks this she thinks not only

Susan thinks this she thinks not only that she is a failing student but

that she is a failing student but

that she is a failing student but because she jumped into conclusions and

because she jumped into conclusions and

because she jumped into conclusions and catastrophizing how her thoughts are I’m

catastrophizing how her thoughts are I’m

catastrophizing how her thoughts are I’m a failing student and everybody knows it

a failing student and everybody knows it

a failing student and everybody knows it everybody knows it and she’s wrong

everybody knows it and she’s wrong

everybody knows it and she’s wrong people don’t think she’s a failing

people don’t think she’s a failing

people don’t think she’s a failing student

student

student so one of the other ones emotion like

so one of the other ones emotion like

so one of the other ones emotion like reasoning this is when we have a feeling

reasoning this is when we have a feeling

reasoning this is when we have a feeling and we say well that tells me about the

and we say well that tells me about the

and we say well that tells me about the world people say trust you’ve got

world people say trust you’ve got

world people say trust you’ve got interesting well maybe depends in the

interesting well maybe depends in the

interesting well maybe depends in the context but trust me a gut feeling

context but trust me a gut feeling

context but trust me a gut feeling doesn’t have ears or eyes it’s getting

doesn’t have ears or eyes it’s getting

doesn’t have ears or eyes it’s getting its information from your mind and if

its information from your mind and if

its information from your mind and if your mind is filtered then you’re going

your mind is filtered then you’re going

your mind is filtered then you’re going to get the wrong balance of information

to get the wrong balance of information

to get the wrong balance of information and your gut feeling is not to be relied

and your gut feeling is not to be relied

and your gut feeling is not to be relied upon always ask ourselves what feeling

upon always ask ourselves what feeling

upon always ask ourselves what feeling do I have right now and what thinking

do I have right now and what thinking

do I have right now and what thinking has led to that particular feeling and

has led to that particular feeling and

has led to that particular feeling and the things I’ve been thinking about are

the things I’ve been thinking about are

the things I’ve been thinking about are they balanced and fair am i using all

they balanced and fair am i using all

they balanced and fair am i using all the evidence

the evidence

the evidence am i subjecting myself to discounting

am i subjecting myself to discounting

am i subjecting myself to discounting the positives am i subjecting myself to

the positives am i subjecting myself to

the positives am i subjecting myself to filtering out all the positive

filtering out all the positive

filtering out all the positive information am i subjecting myself to

information am i subjecting myself to

information am i subjecting myself to all-or-nothing thinking sure the most

all-or-nothing thinking sure the most

all-or-nothing thinking sure the most setting high standards and

setting high standards and

setting high standards and personalization when we go around all

personalization when we go around all

personalization when we go around all the times and I must do this and I must

the times and I must do this and I must

the times and I must do this and I must get that and I should do that and I

get that and I should do that and I

get that and I should do that and I shouldn’t take that it’s like a voice in

shouldn’t take that it’s like a voice in

shouldn’t take that it’s like a voice in our heads constantly criticizing us so

our heads constantly criticizing us so

our heads constantly criticizing us so we start to walk away from all the

we start to walk away from all the

we start to walk away from all the things they can get through the

things they can get through the

things they can get through the difficult times and personalization

difficult times and personalization

difficult times and personalization something has gone wrong and it’s my

something has gone wrong and it’s my

something has gone wrong and it’s my fault often things haven’t gone wrong

fault often things haven’t gone wrong

fault often things haven’t gone wrong and if they have it’s probably not your

and if they have it’s probably not your

and if they have it’s probably not your fault not in any simple sense so let’s

fault not in any simple sense so let’s

fault not in any simple sense so let’s think about how this what’s in terms of

think about how this what’s in terms of

think about how this what’s in terms of education I’ve been in some research

education I’ve been in some research

education I’ve been in some research recently in terms of what I’m calling

recently in terms of what I’m calling

recently in terms of what I’m calling study thinking errors profile which is

study thinking errors profile which is

study thinking errors profile which is to say each individual learner be there

to say each individual learner be there

to say each individual learner be there school college university or doing

school college university or doing

school college university or doing advanced professional exams has a

advanced professional exams has a

advanced professional exams has a tendency towards engaging in different

tendency towards engaging in different

tendency towards engaging in different aspects of those 10 unhelpful thinking

aspects of those 10 unhelpful thinking

aspects of those 10 unhelpful thinking styles everyone has a little bit and

styles everyone has a little bit and

styles everyone has a little bit and even if they’re not using it it’s not

even if they’re not using it it’s not

even if they’re not using it it’s not changing our the feel about things it’s

changing our the feel about things it’s

changing our the feel about things it’s there and I think the first step is to

there and I think the first step is to

there and I think the first step is to help us understand and to help

help us understand and to help

help us understand and to help individuals understand what their own

individuals understand what their own

individuals understand what their own profile is because it points out your

profile is because it points out your

profile is because it points out your Achilles heel when it comes to difficult

Achilles heel when it comes to difficult

Achilles heel when it comes to difficult circumstances we’re all going to meet

circumstances we’re all going to meet

circumstances we’re all going to meet difficult challenges

difficult challenges

difficult challenges lives and some things are quite bad and

lives and some things are quite bad and

lives and some things are quite bad and we respond this with disappointment is

we respond this with disappointment is

we respond this with disappointment is fine it’s being alive it’s being human

fine it’s being alive it’s being human

fine it’s being alive it’s being human we can call but if we have negative

we can call but if we have negative

we can call but if we have negative thinking styles there’s a risk a real

thinking styles there’s a risk a real

thinking styles there’s a risk a real risk that we maintain the vicious circle

risk that we maintain the vicious circle

risk that we maintain the vicious circle the first tactic is to find out what our

the first tactic is to find out what our

the first tactic is to find out what our profile is and the early results don’t

profile is and the early results don’t

profile is and the early results don’t finally do support that aspect a lot of

finally do support that aspect a lot of

finally do support that aspect a lot of what still to do in relationships Rachel

what still to do in relationships Rachel

what still to do in relationships Rachel and Raymond what are interesting things

and Raymond what are interesting things

and Raymond what are interesting things about unhelpful thinking spouses most of

about unhelpful thinking spouses most of

about unhelpful thinking spouses most of the research literature focuses on how

the research literature focuses on how

the research literature focuses on how one person may have a certain bias I

one person may have a certain bias I

one person may have a certain bias I said a certain mental tendency for all

said a certain mental tendency for all

said a certain mental tendency for all of nothing thinking or for

of nothing thinking or for

of nothing thinking or for catastrophizing and that’s true and

catastrophizing and that’s true and

catastrophizing and that’s true and individuals in a relationship you can

individuals in a relationship you can

individuals in a relationship you can have one person who’s more about

have one person who’s more about

have one person who’s more about catastrophizing and another person who’s

catastrophizing and another person who’s

catastrophizing and another person who’s more about all or nothing thinking and

more about all or nothing thinking and

more about all or nothing thinking and that’s that’s fine it’s interests me to

that’s that’s fine it’s interests me to

that’s that’s fine it’s interests me to come together but what I think isn’t

come together but what I think isn’t

come together but what I think isn’t really been looked at in the clinical

really been looked at in the clinical

really been looked at in the clinical literature or in the research literature

literature or in the research literature

literature or in the research literature quite so much and I think it’s important

quite so much and I think it’s important

quite so much and I think it’s important that we do look at this is the fact that

that we do look at this is the fact that

that we do look at this is the fact that some of those unhelpful thinking styles

some of those unhelpful thinking styles

some of those unhelpful thinking styles have two or more components for example

have two or more components for example

have two or more components for example personalization has two of components

personalization has two of components

personalization has two of components number one that something bad has

number one that something bad has

number one that something bad has happened and number two that it’s my

happened and number two that it’s my

happened and number two that it’s my fault

fault

fault also emotion LED reasoning I feel

also emotion LED reasoning I feel

also emotion LED reasoning I feel anxious is the first component that

anxious is the first component that

anxious is the first component that means this must be a threatening

means this must be a threatening

means this must be a threatening environment

environment

environment the second component my proposition here

the second component my proposition here

the second component my proposition here is the in relationships particularly

is the in relationships particularly

is the in relationships particularly when maybe they’re not going

when maybe they’re not going

when maybe they’re not going straightforwardly like when Raymond and

straightforwardly like when Raymond and

straightforwardly like when Raymond and ritual moved house I can imagine a

ritual moved house I can imagine a

ritual moved house I can imagine a situation where Raymond says to his

situation where Raymond says to his

situation where Raymond says to his partner I feel really nervous at what

partner I feel really nervous at what

partner I feel really nervous at what when we have these meetings first

when we have these meetings first

when we have these meetings first important emotional reaction rachel says

important emotional reaction rachel says

important emotional reaction rachel says well it must be a very threatening

well it must be a very threatening

well it must be a very threatening environment for you then on the row and

environment for you then on the row and

environment for you then on the row and the wind have got to that conclusion but

the wind have got to that conclusion but

the wind have got to that conclusion but they contribute in this tangle of

they contribute in this tangle of

they contribute in this tangle of thinking the different components

thinking the different components

thinking the different components required so dealing with each individual

required so dealing with each individual

required so dealing with each individual to help them understand wouldn’t get

to help them understand wouldn’t get

to help them understand wouldn’t get there as a couple too far but I think

there as a couple too far but I think

there as a couple too far but I think understanding that what is the sharing

understanding that what is the sharing

understanding that what is the sharing what it is that the

what it is that the

what it is that the collaboratively creating is an unhelpful

collaboratively creating is an unhelpful

collaboratively creating is an unhelpful thinking style in the media we have had

thinking style in the media we have had

thinking style in the media we have had a lot recently about fake news websites

a lot recently about fake news websites

a lot recently about fake news websites etc to publish news articles which still

etc to publish news articles which still

etc to publish news articles which still damaged even long after Ethiopian short

damaged even long after Ethiopian short

damaged even long after Ethiopian short contained factually incorrect

contained factually incorrect

contained factually incorrect information but I think we missed the

information but I think we missed the

information but I think we missed the fact that newspapers and websites used

fact that newspapers and websites used

fact that newspapers and websites used forms of unhelpful thinking cells to get

forms of unhelpful thinking cells to get

forms of unhelpful thinking cells to get us to adopt a certain position for

us to adopt a certain position for

us to adopt a certain position for example all-or-nothing thinking and

example all-or-nothing thinking and

example all-or-nothing thinking and let’s say an immigration debate which

let’s say an immigration debate which

let’s say an immigration debate which has those binary those of us and them

has those binary those of us and them

has those binary those of us and them good and bad which side are you on in

good and bad which side are you on in

good and bad which side are you on in business what I’ve done consultancy for

business what I’ve done consultancy for

business what I’ve done consultancy for private public and other types of

private public and other types of

private public and other types of companies

companies

companies I do see examples of unhelpful thinking

I do see examples of unhelpful thinking

I do see examples of unhelpful thinking styles again clearly individual people

styles again clearly individual people

styles again clearly individual people like Bob’s company working with

like Bob’s company working with

like Bob’s company working with charities very closely individual people

charities very closely individual people

charities very closely individual people in business at all levels are human

in business at all levels are human

in business at all levels are human beings and they have different types of

beings and they have different types of

beings and they have different types of unhelpful thinking styles but companies

unhelpful thinking styles but companies

unhelpful thinking styles but companies also can have a thinking style involves

also can have a thinking style involves

also can have a thinking style involves business two major Directors one was

business two major Directors one was

business two major Directors one was risk averse the other was risk

risk averse the other was risk

risk averse the other was risk enterprising their voices were strong

enterprising their voices were strong

enterprising their voices were strong and they drawing those other voices that

and they drawing those other voices that

and they drawing those other voices that company for a long time felt just like

company for a long time felt just like

company for a long time felt just like all-or-nothing thinking that binary

all-or-nothing thinking that binary

all-or-nothing thinking that binary dominated the company and they lost

dominated the company and they lost

dominated the company and they lost their way but I don’t think never

their way but I don’t think never

their way but I don’t think never realized that what was going on they saw

realized that what was going on they saw

realized that what was going on they saw as two points of view and had to make a

as two points of view and had to make a

as two points of view and had to make a decision so what can we do let’s think

decision so what can we do let’s think

decision so what can we do let’s think about the fact that we have to look at

about the fact that we have to look at

about the fact that we have to look at ourselves in the mirror

ourselves in the mirror

ourselves in the mirror and look at the world around us through

and look at the world around us through

and look at the world around us through our available lenses let’s think about

our available lenses let’s think about

our available lenses let’s think about education in terms of assessment and

education in terms of assessment and

education in terms of assessment and feedback we’ve got to change your

feedback we’ve got to change your

feedback we’ve got to change your thinking about it we’ve got to innovate

thinking about it we’ve got to innovate

thinking about it we’ve got to innovate in order to educate I think this ironic

in order to educate I think this ironic

in order to educate I think this ironic that when students get feedback on

that when students get feedback on

that when students get feedback on essays or projects we give students just

essays or projects we give students just

essays or projects we give students just enough information to trigger their

enough information to trigger their

enough information to trigger their unhelpful thinking styles but not enough

unhelpful thinking styles but not enough

unhelpful thinking styles but not enough information to help

information to help

information to help deal with it because I think student

deal with it because I think student

deal with it because I think student support from this point of view is more

support from this point of view is more

support from this point of view is more than just those important things of

than just those important things of

than just those important things of empathizing providing general support

empathizing providing general support

empathizing providing general support and maybe additional targeted skills

and maybe additional targeted skills

and maybe additional targeted skills development it becomes really

development it becomes really

development it becomes really interesting but becomes asking students

interesting but becomes asking students

interesting but becomes asking students okay you got fifty five how do you feel

okay you got fifty five how do you feel

okay you got fifty five how do you feel about that and they’ll tell you and say

about that and they’ll tell you and say

about that and they’ll tell you and say well what thinking got you to that point

well what thinking got you to that point

well what thinking got you to that point and they’ll come out well because I know

and they’ll come out well because I know

and they’ll come out well because I know that everyone else in the class got more

that everyone else in the class got more

that everyone else in the class got more than fifty five really yeah because the

than fifty five really yeah because the

than fifty five really yeah because the tutor said that everyone had done really

tutor said that everyone had done really

tutor said that everyone had done really well that’s not necessarily true

well that’s not necessarily true

well that’s not necessarily true Suzy’s had this problem she labels

Suzy’s had this problem she labels

Suzy’s had this problem she labels herself as a failing student and when

herself as a failing student and when

herself as a failing student and when she gets a good grade she thinks well

she gets a good grade she thinks well

she gets a good grade she thinks well that doesn’t really count I just

that doesn’t really count I just

that doesn’t really count I just happened to get a good question if you

happened to get a good question if you

happened to get a good question if you sit down with Suzy it’s quite

sit down with Suzy it’s quite

sit down with Suzy it’s quite straightforward you can show her that

straightforward you can show her that

straightforward you can show her that she been doing really well that she’s on

she been doing really well that she’s on

she been doing really well that she’s on course for what she wants her life

course for what she wants her life

course for what she wants her life ambitions become a biochemist she needs

ambitions become a biochemist she needs

ambitions become a biochemist she needs a 2-1 to get to do the masters or the

a 2-1 to get to do the masters or the

a 2-1 to get to do the masters or the PhD and she’s well on course for that

PhD and she’s well on course for that

PhD and she’s well on course for that she been thinking about the wrong way

the other big thing we can do is look at

the other big thing we can do is look at ourselves we must be careful not to

ourselves we must be careful not to

ourselves we must be careful not to collude in the unhelpful thinking styles

collude in the unhelpful thinking styles

collude in the unhelpful thinking styles of others and this happens all the time

of others and this happens all the time

of others and this happens all the time in clinical practice and in education

in clinical practice and in education

in clinical practice and in education and in businesses people try to be nice

and in businesses people try to be nice

and in businesses people try to be nice by only giving a positive feedback or

by only giving a positive feedback or

by only giving a positive feedback or giving a positive story which has its

giving a positive story which has its

giving a positive story which has its place don’t get me wrong they’re far too

place don’t get me wrong they’re far too

place don’t get me wrong they’re far too much criticism and negativity for its

much criticism and negativity for its

much criticism and negativity for its own sake but the question is this the

own sake but the question is this the

own sake but the question is this the question is this how do we help

question is this how do we help

question is this how do we help individuals and couples and companies

individuals and couples and companies

individuals and couples and companies and people engage in the national debate

and people engage in the national debate

and people engage in the national debate in terms of the news understand what

in terms of the news understand what

in terms of the news understand what thinking got them to their position none

thinking got them to their position none

thinking got them to their position none of that is easy it’s quite hard but it’s

of that is easy it’s quite hard but it’s

of that is easy it’s quite hard but it’s definitely worthwhile and I hope I

definitely worthwhile and I hope I

definitely worthwhile and I hope I shared that with you today to convince

shared that with you today to convince

shared that with you today to convince you of that thank you very much indeed

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *