Press "Enter" to skip to content

Third Cultured Muslimah | Sehlah Butt | TEDxStevensonU


good evening ladies and gentlemen how

good evening ladies and gentlemen how are you all doing today that’s good

are you all doing today that’s good

are you all doing today that’s good that’s good so I’m going to talk to you

that’s good so I’m going to talk to you

that’s good so I’m going to talk to you guys about something that happened to me

guys about something that happened to me

guys about something that happened to me five months ago on October 6 at 9:30

five months ago on October 6 at 9:30

five months ago on October 6 at 9:30 p.m. I called home my mother picked up

p.m. I called home my mother picked up

p.m. I called home my mother picked up mama I need to tell you something yeah

mama I need to tell you something yeah

mama I need to tell you something yeah what is it I am NOT coming home oh so

what is it I am NOT coming home oh so

what is it I am NOT coming home oh so you need us to come pick you up no mama

you need us to come pick you up no mama

you need us to come pick you up no mama I’m not coming home I’ve chosen to live

I’m not coming home I’ve chosen to live

I’m not coming home I’ve chosen to live on campus what followed was a litany of

on campus what followed was a litany of

on campus what followed was a litany of accusations and recriminations

accusations and recriminations

accusations and recriminations what are you doing how could you do this

what are you doing how could you do this

what are you doing how could you do this what did we do to you and finally where

what did we do to you and finally where

what did we do to you and finally where did we go wrong what my mother could not

did we go wrong what my mother could not

did we go wrong what my mother could not know was that I had and that I am still

know was that I had and that I am still

know was that I had and that I am still asking myself those same questions my

asking myself those same questions my

asking myself those same questions my name is Ella holla’d but I was born in

name is Ella holla’d but I was born in

name is Ella holla’d but I was born in Pakistan raised as a Muslim and became

Pakistan raised as a Muslim and became

Pakistan raised as a Muslim and became an American these three identities of

an American these three identities of

an American these three identities of myself proscribed codes of conduct tacit

myself proscribed codes of conduct tacit

myself proscribed codes of conduct tacit rules of behavior and frequently

rules of behavior and frequently

rules of behavior and frequently burdensome expectations never had these

burdensome expectations never had these

burdensome expectations never had these three elements of myself been more in

three elements of myself been more in

three elements of myself been more in conflict than now with countless voices

conflict than now with countless voices

conflict than now with countless voices crying out trying to decide what it

crying out trying to decide what it

crying out trying to decide what it means to be a good Muslim or even a real

means to be a good Muslim or even a real

means to be a good Muslim or even a real American whatever country is struggling

American whatever country is struggling

American whatever country is struggling with today

with today

with today I have been struggling with my entire

I have been struggling with my entire

I have been struggling with my entire life how do I claim and honor the

life how do I claim and honor the

life how do I claim and honor the diverse influences of my cultures and

diverse influences of my cultures and

diverse influences of my cultures and decide who I am besides as a Pakistani

decide who I am besides as a Pakistani

decide who I am besides as a Pakistani girl I was expected to go to school to

girl I was expected to go to school to

girl I was expected to go to school to earn a degree however I was never

earn a degree however I was never

earn a degree however I was never supposed to use that degree rather I was

supposed to use that degree rather I was

supposed to use that degree rather I was to marry the man of my parents dreams

to marry the man of my parents dreams

to marry the man of my parents dreams preferably one they had chosen have

preferably one they had chosen have

preferably one they had chosen have children and spend the rest of my life

children and spend the rest of my life

children and spend the rest of my life raising a family and keeping a home I

raising a family and keeping a home I

raising a family and keeping a home I was never supposed to use my degree

was never supposed to use my degree

was never supposed to use my degree build a career or have a personal life

build a career or have a personal life

build a career or have a personal life outside of my home while I do respect

outside of my home while I do respect

outside of my home while I do respect the merit of these responsibilities I

the merit of these responsibilities I

the merit of these responsibilities I can

can

can not accept a culture that believes this

not accept a culture that believes this

not accept a culture that believes this is the only suitable life for a woman

is the only suitable life for a woman

is the only suitable life for a woman besides these limitations they do not

besides these limitations they do not

besides these limitations they do not have their roots in Islam and the Salaam

have their roots in Islam and the Salaam

have their roots in Islam and the Salaam women had the right to marry a spouse of

women had the right to marry a spouse of

women had the right to marry a spouse of their choice so as long as he is a just

their choice so as long as he is a just

their choice so as long as he is a just in righteous man who upholds his

in righteous man who upholds his

in righteous man who upholds his religious obligations ironically enough

religious obligations ironically enough

religious obligations ironically enough Pakistan itself was built on religious

Pakistan itself was built on religious

Pakistan itself was built on religious freedom that freedom to practice

freedom that freedom to practice

freedom that freedom to practice religion without persecution from any

religion without persecution from any

religion without persecution from any other groups nowadays many parts of the

other groups nowadays many parts of the

other groups nowadays many parts of the country uses Islam as a way to justify

country uses Islam as a way to justify

country uses Islam as a way to justify their own heinous acts

their own heinous acts

their own heinous acts unfortunately Haji song is not the only

unfortunately Haji song is not the only

unfortunately Haji song is not the only country to do so again I cannot accept a

country to do so again I cannot accept a

country to do so again I cannot accept a culture that manipulates the idea of

culture that manipulates the idea of

culture that manipulates the idea of Islam for their own oppression on women

Islam for their own oppression on women

Islam for their own oppression on women is there a way for me to claim my

is there a way for me to claim my

is there a way for me to claim my Pakistani heritage while refusing to

Pakistani heritage while refusing to

Pakistani heritage while refusing to accept their lifestyle for women of

accept their lifestyle for women of

accept their lifestyle for women of course I am by birth a Pakistani but I

course I am by birth a Pakistani but I

course I am by birth a Pakistani but I am by choice in American and yet America

am by choice in American and yet America

am by choice in American and yet America has expectations of me as well of course

has expectations of me as well of course

has expectations of me as well of course I have the freedom of religion right but

I have the freedom of religion right but

I have the freedom of religion right but don’t look to Muslim of course I have

don’t look to Muslim of course I have

don’t look to Muslim of course I have the freedom to worship but do you have

the freedom to worship but do you have

the freedom to worship but do you have to pray right now and of course America

to pray right now and of course America

to pray right now and of course America is a melting pot but they just aren’t

is a melting pot but they just aren’t

is a melting pot but they just aren’t like us

like us

like us and I have often felt like the day and

and I have often felt like the day and

and I have often felt like the day and not like the US is there a way for me to

not like the US is there a way for me to

not like the US is there a way for me to claim my American life while silencing

claim my American life while silencing

claim my American life while silencing those who believe I may cause another

those who believe I may cause another

those who believe I may cause another 9/11 the constant in both the Pakistani

9/11 the constant in both the Pakistani

9/11 the constant in both the Pakistani in the American culture was the practice

in the American culture was the practice

in the American culture was the practice of Islam however that did not come easy

of Islam however that did not come easy

of Islam however that did not come easy either like in all religions there are

either like in all religions there are

either like in all religions there are differences among believers on one hand

differences among believers on one hand

differences among believers on one hand I had my family who told who told me how

I had my family who told who told me how

I had my family who told who told me how to dress how to act in how to speak on

to dress how to act in how to speak on

to dress how to act in how to speak on the other hand I had people who asked me

the other hand I had people who asked me

the other hand I had people who asked me why do you oppress yourself take that

why do you oppress yourself take that

why do you oppress yourself take that his Yaba show the world how beautiful

his Yaba show the world how beautiful

his Yaba show the world how beautiful you really are in short I had Muslim

you really are in short I had Muslim

you really are in short I had Muslim brothers and sisters who told me that I

brothers and sisters who told me that I

brothers and sisters who told me that I was either not properly covered or I was

was either not properly covered or I was

was either not properly covered or I was too devout is there a way for me to show

too devout is there a way for me to show

too devout is there a way for me to show my commitment to Islam that does not

my commitment to Islam that does not

my commitment to Islam that does not garner indignation from other Muslims

garner indignation from other Muslims

garner indignation from other Muslims how could I possibly fulfill the

how could I possibly fulfill the

how could I possibly fulfill the expectations of each of these three

expectations of each of these three

expectations of each of these three elements in my life and be who I wanted

elements in my life and be who I wanted

elements in my life and be who I wanted to be the Weasly the weeks leading up to

to be the Weasly the weeks leading up to

to be the Weasly the weeks leading up to that phone call to my mother I struggled

that phone call to my mother I struggled

that phone call to my mother I struggled with the reality I wrestled with the

with the reality I wrestled with the

with the reality I wrestled with the reality that I was not enough not enough

reality that I was not enough not enough

reality that I was not enough not enough of a Pakistani not enough an American

of a Pakistani not enough an American

of a Pakistani not enough an American not enough of a Muslim as I confronted

not enough of a Muslim as I confronted

not enough of a Muslim as I confronted my shortcomings as I tried and tried

my shortcomings as I tried and tried

my shortcomings as I tried and tried again to fulfill those same expectations

again to fulfill those same expectations

again to fulfill those same expectations I was convinced that I was not enough

I was convinced that I was not enough

I was convinced that I was not enough but then I began to hear those around me

but then I began to hear those around me

but then I began to hear those around me they expect me to publish they expect me

they expect me to publish they expect me

they expect me to publish they expect me to have a 4.0 they expect me to solve

to have a 4.0 they expect me to solve

to have a 4.0 they expect me to solve their problems they expect me to pay my

their problems they expect me to pay my

their problems they expect me to pay my own tuition they expect and they expect

own tuition they expect and they expect

own tuition they expect and they expect and they expect rarely did these

and they expect rarely did these

and they expect rarely did these conversations begin with hey do you know

conversations begin with hey do you know

conversations begin with hey do you know what I want really was anyone being

what I want really was anyone being

what I want really was anyone being asked what do you want to do with your

asked what do you want to do with your

asked what do you want to do with your passion your gift or your faith rarely

passion your gift or your faith rarely

passion your gift or your faith rarely was anyone saying anything that meant

was anyone saying anything that meant

was anyone saying anything that meant hey I know what your expectations of me

hey I know what your expectations of me

hey I know what your expectations of me are and I just don’t want to meet them

are and I just don’t want to meet them

are and I just don’t want to meet them in my case no one ever asked me

in my case no one ever asked me

in my case no one ever asked me sella what do you want as a Pakistani as

sella what do you want as a Pakistani as

sella what do you want as a Pakistani as a Muslim as an American and how will you

a Muslim as an American and how will you

a Muslim as an American and how will you use your own expectations to form your

use your own expectations to form your

use your own expectations to form your wider world your own career and most

wider world your own career and most

wider world your own career and most importantly yourself I understand we all

importantly yourself I understand we all

importantly yourself I understand we all have and we all meet expectations others

have and we all meet expectations others

have and we all meet expectations others have of us some reluctantly and others

have of us some reluctantly and others

have of us some reluctantly and others joyfully but when those same

joyfully but when those same

joyfully but when those same expectations smother our individuality

expectations smother our individuality

expectations smother our individuality silence our inner voice or even erode

silence our inner voice or even erode

silence our inner voice or even erode our beliefs it is our duty to question

our beliefs it is our duty to question

our beliefs it is our duty to question those expectations and when I did I

those expectations and when I did I

those expectations and when I did I didn’t know who I was anymore

didn’t know who I was anymore

didn’t know who I was anymore I didn’t know what I expected of myself

I didn’t know what I expected of myself

I didn’t know what I expected of myself and I didn’t know what to do so I gave

and I didn’t know what to do so I gave

and I didn’t know what to do so I gave it some thought actually a lot of

it some thought actually a lot of

it some thought actually a lot of thought and I realized that I expected

thought and I realized that I expected

thought and I realized that I expected myself to take back control of my life

myself to take back control of my life

myself to take back control of my life and I expected myself to make decisions

and I expected myself to make decisions

and I expected myself to make decisions for and

for and

for and by myself deciding to leave my parents

by myself deciding to leave my parents

by myself deciding to leave my parents home was the first the first decision I

home was the first the first decision I

home was the first the first decision I ever made for and by myself because I

ever made for and by myself because I

ever made for and by myself because I had been pushed I had been nudged to

had been pushed I had been nudged to

had been pushed I had been nudged to abide by the expectations of culture

abide by the expectations of culture

abide by the expectations of culture religion and gender I was taught to

religion and gender I was taught to

religion and gender I was taught to honor others I was taught to fit in and

honor others I was taught to fit in and

honor others I was taught to fit in and I was taught to live within very narrow

I was taught to live within very narrow

I was taught to live within very narrow lanes of what was expected of me so I

lanes of what was expected of me so I

lanes of what was expected of me so I knew right then and there I had to free

knew right then and there I had to free

knew right then and there I had to free myself from the environment that had

myself from the environment that had

myself from the environment that had trapped me mentally and emotionally from

trapped me mentally and emotionally from

trapped me mentally and emotionally from being who I wanted to be but I did not

being who I wanted to be but I did not

being who I wanted to be but I did not do it alone I had a lot of help from

do it alone I had a lot of help from

do it alone I had a lot of help from friends who supported me in this

friends who supported me in this

friends who supported me in this decision and I thank them for that as

decision and I thank them for that as

decision and I thank them for that as for my parents well let’s just say

for my parents well let’s just say

for my parents well let’s just say they’re having a hard time adjusting to

they’re having a hard time adjusting to

they’re having a hard time adjusting to my decision but I know by the will of

my decision but I know by the will of

my decision but I know by the will of God they will come around as I end my

God they will come around as I end my

God they will come around as I end my speech I want to say a few things it is

speech I want to say a few things it is

speech I want to say a few things it is time as human beings we learn to choose

time as human beings we learn to choose

time as human beings we learn to choose and make choices for ourselves to

and make choices for ourselves to

and make choices for ourselves to thoughtfully choose through the

thoughtfully choose through the

thoughtfully choose through the expectations we wish to follow and if

expectations we wish to follow and if

expectations we wish to follow and if you have never done so it will feel like

you have never done so it will feel like

you have never done so it will feel like you don’t know who you are you will be

you don’t know who you are you will be

you don’t know who you are you will be so insecure about yourself you will feel

so insecure about yourself you will feel

so insecure about yourself you will feel like a failure I did and yes it does

like a failure I did and yes it does

like a failure I did and yes it does take a while to revive from all this but

take a while to revive from all this but

take a while to revive from all this but what I learned was that I am strong

what I learned was that I am strong

what I learned was that I am strong enough I am capable enough I am

enough I am capable enough I am

enough I am capable enough I am resilient enough to get through this

resilient enough to get through this

resilient enough to get through this hardship today and forever and I expect

hardship today and forever and I expect

hardship today and forever and I expect you will to thank

you will to thank

you will to thank [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *