
ladies and gentlemen I’m going to try to convince you of the importance of
convince you of the importance of
convince you of the importance of sustainable agriculture in the
sustainable agriculture in the
sustainable agriculture in the developing world and the importance of
developing world and the importance of
developing world and the importance of reforming the international system of
reforming the international system of
reforming the international system of assistance to sustainable agriculture in
assistance to sustainable agriculture in
assistance to sustainable agriculture in the developing world I’m also going to
the developing world I’m also going to
the developing world I’m also going to try to convince you that it’s important
try to convince you that it’s important
try to convince you that it’s important for you
first the reasons why this is important
first the reasons why this is important of the approximately six and a half
of the approximately six and a half
of the approximately six and a half billion people that live on the planet
billion people that live on the planet
billion people that live on the planet one billion live in extreme poverty and
one billion live in extreme poverty and
one billion live in extreme poverty and ironically three-quarters of those
ironically three-quarters of those
ironically three-quarters of those people live in rural areas dependent on
people live in rural areas dependent on
people live in rural areas dependent on agriculture if you visit them which I
agriculture if you visit them which I
agriculture if you visit them which I have in my 40 years in this business
have in my 40 years in this business
have in my 40 years in this business you will see that their agriculture is
you will see that their agriculture is
you will see that their agriculture is primitive looks very much like their
primitive looks very much like their
primitive looks very much like their grandparents agriculture and in fact in
grandparents agriculture and in fact in
grandparents agriculture and in fact in practically every country in the
practically every country in the
practically every country in the developing world you can find these
developing world you can find these
developing world you can find these people very easily and when you look at
people very easily and when you look at
people very easily and when you look at them you can ask yourself the question
them you can ask yourself the question
them you can ask yourself the question why in the year 2017 are there people
why in the year 2017 are there people
why in the year 2017 are there people that live in such miserable conditions
that live in such miserable conditions
that live in such miserable conditions now a lot of these people turn out if
now a lot of these people turn out if
now a lot of these people turn out if you look at the statistics to be those
you look at the statistics to be those
you look at the statistics to be those who migrate to the cities their
who migrate to the cities their
who migrate to the cities their situation is so desperate in rural areas
situation is so desperate in rural areas
situation is so desperate in rural areas they’re willing to go and live often in
they’re willing to go and live often in
they’re willing to go and live often in very bad conditions in the cities
very bad conditions in the cities
very bad conditions in the cities because those are better conditions than
because those are better conditions than
because those are better conditions than they live in in the countryside did a
they live in in the countryside did a
they live in in the countryside did a lot of these people are also the core of
lot of these people are also the core of
lot of these people are also the core of migrants the people that you see on your
migrants the people that you see on your
migrants the people that you see on your television sets for example migrating
television sets for example migrating
television sets for example migrating from Africa into Europe and often dying
from Africa into Europe and often dying
from Africa into Europe and often dying on the way often come from rural areas
on the way often come from rural areas
on the way often come from rural areas many of the Central Americans that are
many of the Central Americans that are
many of the Central Americans that are coming to the United States come
coming to the United States come
coming to the United States come actually from rural areas desperate they
actually from rural areas desperate they
actually from rural areas desperate they probably don’t want to go to gringo land
probably don’t want to go to gringo land
probably don’t want to go to gringo land they probably would like to stay where
they probably would like to stay where
they probably would like to stay where they are but they can’t because they are
they are but they can’t because they are
they are but they can’t because they are living in terrible condition there’s
living in terrible condition there’s
living in terrible condition there’s another factor to be interested
another factor to be interested
another factor to be interested another factor or reason to be
another factor or reason to be
another factor or reason to be interested in this the world is losing
interested in this the world is losing
interested in this the world is losing each year an area of forest equal to the
each year an area of forest equal to the
each year an area of forest equal to the size of Greece most of that not all of
size of Greece most of that not all of
size of Greece most of that not all of it some is due to logging some is due to
it some is due to logging some is due to
it some is due to logging some is due to urban sprawl but most of it is actually
urban sprawl but most of it is actually
urban sprawl but most of it is actually caused by farmers think about it most of
caused by farmers think about it most of
caused by farmers think about it most of the developing world has very very low
the developing world has very very low
the developing world has very very low productivity growth yet populations are
productivity growth yet populations are
productivity growth yet populations are expanding more agricultural
expanding more agricultural
expanding more agricultural products are being produced how does
products are being produced how does
products are being produced how does that occur when productivity growth is
that occur when productivity growth is
that occur when productivity growth is so low well the statistics now are
so low well the statistics now are
so low well the statistics now are pretty clear it’s occurring by people
pretty clear it’s occurring by people
pretty clear it’s occurring by people moving into forest areas pasture land
moving into forest areas pasture land
moving into forest areas pasture land fragile areas every country in the
fragile areas every country in the
fragile areas every country in the developing world to a greater or lesser
developing world to a greater or lesser
developing world to a greater or lesser extent has this problem
extent has this problem
extent has this problem I don’t know Costa Rica but I bet you
I don’t know Costa Rica but I bet you
I don’t know Costa Rica but I bet you can see it here the burning of forests
can see it here the burning of forests
can see it here the burning of forests the constant battle between those
the constant battle between those
the constant battle between those empowered often government officials or
empowered often government officials or
empowered often government officials or Park Rangers to protect forest areas and
Park Rangers to protect forest areas and
Park Rangers to protect forest areas and fragile areas largely from farmers so
what is it that can be done about this
what is it that can be done about this situation
there’s now a vast literature on this
there’s now a vast literature on this literally hundreds of thousands of
literally hundreds of thousands of
literally hundreds of thousands of articles and books have been written
articles and books have been written
articles and books have been written about why this situation is so
about why this situation is so
about why this situation is so persistent and I’ve tried to summarize
persistent and I’ve tried to summarize
persistent and I’ve tried to summarize those hundreds of thousands of articles
those hundreds of thousands of articles
those hundreds of thousands of articles and books in one slide right here most
and books in one slide right here most
and books in one slide right here most of them find that this situation
of them find that this situation
of them find that this situation persists because government policies in
persists because government policies in
persists because government policies in developing countries are prejudicial
developing countries are prejudicial
developing countries are prejudicial against agriculture most developing
against agriculture most developing
against agriculture most developing countries not all and I’m going to get
countries not all and I’m going to get
countries not all and I’m going to get to the exceptions have policies that
to the exceptions have policies that
to the exceptions have policies that actually discriminate against
actually discriminate against
actually discriminate against agriculture many of them neglect their
agriculture many of them neglect their
agriculture many of them neglect their rural populations in terms of health and
rural populations in terms of health and
rural populations in terms of health and education very difficult to imagine farm
education very difficult to imagine farm
education very difficult to imagine farm productivity farm modernisation
productivity farm modernisation
productivity farm modernisation occurring with people who are illiterate
occurring with people who are illiterate
occurring with people who are illiterate who are uneducated it doesn’t work in
who are uneducated it doesn’t work in
who are uneducated it doesn’t work in any other business it doesn’t work in
any other business it doesn’t work in
any other business it doesn’t work in farming either and that’s largely the
farming either and that’s largely the
farming either and that’s largely the cause or caused by the neglect of
cause or caused by the neglect of
cause or caused by the neglect of governments and finally coincident with
governments and finally coincident with
governments and finally coincident with this neglect is very frequently an
this neglect is very frequently an
this neglect is very frequently an enabling environment for private
enabling environment for private
enabling environment for private investment which is not there private
investment which is not there private
investment which is not there private investors you probably think of them as
investors you probably think of them as
investors you probably think of them as big investors but farmers are
big investors but farmers are
big investors but farmers are businessmen even subsistence farmers and
businessmen even subsistence farmers and
businessmen even subsistence farmers and when the enabling environment for their
when the enabling environment for their
when the enabling environment for their investment whether it’s access to credit
investment whether it’s access to credit
investment whether it’s access to credit or access to technology or access to
or access to technology or access to
or access to technology or access to roads or access to water or access to
roads or access to water or access to
roads or access to water or access to anything is not there they’re not going
anything is not there they’re not going
anything is not there they’re not going to develop their agriculture there’s a
to develop their agriculture there’s a
to develop their agriculture there’s a fourth point and I’m going to
fourth point and I’m going to
fourth point and I’m going to concentrate on that point which is the
concentrate on that point which is the
concentrate on that point which is the fourth point on this slide which is
fourth point on this slide which is
fourth point on this slide which is ineffective agricultural aid let’s talk
ineffective agricultural aid let’s talk
ineffective agricultural aid let’s talk about that for a minute
about that for a minute
about that for a minute now I’ve participated in that aid
now I’ve participated in that aid
now I’ve participated in that aid program as you heard working for the
program as you heard working for the
program as you heard working for the World Bank the United Nations and I’ve
World Bank the United Nations and I’ve
World Bank the United Nations and I’ve worked with USAID the African
worked with USAID the African
worked with USAID the African Development Bank the Food and
Development Bank the Food and
Development Bank the Food and Agriculture Organization even a little
Agriculture Organization even a little
Agriculture Organization even a little bit with the Gates Foundation so I know
bit with the Gates Foundation so I know
bit with the Gates Foundation so I know this business very very well what is
this business very very well what is
this business very very well what is happening here well let’s take a step
happening here well let’s take a step
happening here well let’s take a step back why is there AG cultural aid
back why is there AG cultural aid
back why is there AG cultural aid the reason for that is that the
the reason for that is that the
the reason for that is that the architects of the market-based system
architects of the market-based system
architects of the market-based system that emerged out of World War two were
that emerged out of World War two were
that emerged out of World War two were pretty intelligent they recognized that
pretty intelligent they recognized that
pretty intelligent they recognized that markets don’t benefit everybody and the
markets don’t benefit everybody and the
markets don’t benefit everybody and the response to that in countries at a
response to that in countries at a
response to that in countries at a national level are safety nets of
national level are safety nets of
national level are safety nets of various kinds each country has one or
various kinds each country has one or
various kinds each country has one or most countries have one or two or three
most countries have one or two or three
most countries have one or two or three even my country the United States has
even my country the United States has
even my country the United States has safety nets for those people who are
safety nets for those people who are
safety nets for those people who are left behind but of equal interest was a
left behind but of equal interest was a
left behind but of equal interest was a safety net that was organized
safety net that was organized
safety net that was organized internationally it was to transfer
internationally it was to transfer
internationally it was to transfer resources from those countries that
resources from those countries that
resources from those countries that really benefitted from market-based
really benefitted from market-based
really benefitted from market-based systems like Europe and the United
systems like Europe and the United
systems like Europe and the United States to developing countries and it
States to developing countries and it
States to developing countries and it was called aid billions of dollars have
was called aid billions of dollars have
was called aid billions of dollars have been shifted to developing countries
been shifted to developing countries
been shifted to developing countries through aid and agriculture has been a
through aid and agriculture has been a
through aid and agriculture has been a major recipient of that so it was part
major recipient of that so it was part
major recipient of that so it was part of the equilibrating equilibrating
of the equilibrating equilibrating
of the equilibrating equilibrating revenues and resources and benefits that
revenues and resources and benefits that
revenues and resources and benefits that you find in countries also was mirrored
you find in countries also was mirrored
you find in countries also was mirrored in the international system the problem
in the international system the problem
in the international system the problem is after 50 years of that agricultural
is after 50 years of that agricultural
is after 50 years of that agricultural aid we still have a situation that I
aid we still have a situation that I
aid we still have a situation that I tried to describe to you right in the
tried to describe to you right in the
tried to describe to you right in the beginning massive rural poverty
beginning massive rural poverty
beginning massive rural poverty agriculture which looks very much like
agriculture which looks very much like
agriculture which looks very much like it did 50 years ago ineffective
it did 50 years ago ineffective
it did 50 years ago ineffective agricultural aid this good intention has
agricultural aid this good intention has
agricultural aid this good intention has not worked well let’s look at the other
not worked well let’s look at the other
not worked well let’s look at the other side of this I presented the negative
side of this I presented the negative
side of this I presented the negative picture but there’s also a positive
picture but there’s also a positive
picture but there’s also a positive picture there are countries over longer
picture there are countries over longer
picture there are countries over longer periods of time in the developing world
periods of time in the developing world
periods of time in the developing world that have done pretty well in their
that have done pretty well in their
that have done pretty well in their agriculture and I put some of the stars
agriculture and I put some of the stars
agriculture and I put some of the stars up here China and Vietnam are well known
up here China and Vietnam are well known
up here China and Vietnam are well known Korea’s another tend to be in Asia a
Korea’s another tend to be in Asia a
Korea’s another tend to be in Asia a little bit more than elsewhere Latin
little bit more than elsewhere Latin
little bit more than elsewhere Latin America Chile Peru pretty good actually
America Chile Peru pretty good actually
America Chile Peru pretty good actually right now Peru’s agriculture is growing
right now Peru’s agriculture is growing
right now Peru’s agriculture is growing very fast even in Africa which has had
very fast even in Africa which has had
very fast even in Africa which has had more problems Rwanda Tanzania for a
more problems Rwanda Tanzania for a
more problems Rwanda Tanzania for a little while Ghana Uganda I didn’t put
little while Ghana Uganda I didn’t put
little while Ghana Uganda I didn’t put all the names up here have done well so
all the names up here have done well so
all the names up here have done well so what are the less
what are the less
what are the less out of those places well it’s the mirror
out of those places well it’s the mirror
out of those places well it’s the mirror image of the negative in these countries
image of the negative in these countries
image of the negative in these countries the most obvious thing has been a
the most obvious thing has been a
the most obvious thing has been a heavier public investment in agriculture
heavier public investment in agriculture
heavier public investment in agriculture particularly in China and Vietnam you
particularly in China and Vietnam you
particularly in China and Vietnam you see this public investment these are not
see this public investment these are not
see this public investment these are not pure market-based economies and yet
pure market-based economies and yet
pure market-based economies and yet they’re agriculture has done well and
they’re agriculture has done well and
they’re agriculture has done well and their agriculture is largely private
their agriculture is largely private
their agriculture is largely private incidentally it’s small farmers they’ve
incidentally it’s small farmers they’ve
incidentally it’s small farmers they’ve invested in infrastructure in water in
invested in infrastructure in water in
invested in infrastructure in water in irrigation in technology I’ve visited a
irrigation in technology I’ve visited a
irrigation in technology I’ve visited a city in China that was set up purely for
city in China that was set up purely for
city in China that was set up purely for the purpose of developing agricultural
the purpose of developing agricultural
the purpose of developing agricultural technology with schools that were
technology with schools that were
technology with schools that were attached to that technological
attached to that technological
attached to that technological development the Chinese have been
development the Chinese have been
development the Chinese have been terrific at this but others have been
terrific at this but others have been
terrific at this but others have been pretty good as well secondly an
pretty good as well secondly an
pretty good as well secondly an environment which welcomes private
environment which welcomes private
environment which welcomes private investment in agriculture and in some
investment in agriculture and in some
investment in agriculture and in some cases because you don’t find this
cases because you don’t find this
cases because you don’t find this everywhere substantial effort effort in
everywhere substantial effort effort in
everywhere substantial effort effort in rural education and health and that
rural education and health and that
rural education and health and that forth little point buried down at the
forth little point buried down at the
forth little point buried down at the bottom it’s interesting that is in these
bottom it’s interesting that is in these
bottom it’s interesting that is in these countries where agricultural aid has
countries where agricultural aid has
countries where agricultural aid has been most effective the aid from the
been most effective the aid from the
been most effective the aid from the United Nations and the World Bank to
United Nations and the World Bank to
United Nations and the World Bank to China has been effective the projects
China has been effective the projects
China has been effective the projects they are evaluated is almost universally
they are evaluated is almost universally
they are evaluated is almost universally successful so this clearly some
successful so this clearly some
successful so this clearly some correlations between policies government
correlations between policies government
correlations between policies government policies which are pro agriculture don’t
policies which are pro agriculture don’t
policies which are pro agriculture don’t necessarily have to be market-based it
necessarily have to be market-based it
necessarily have to be market-based it can be public investment in agriculture
can be public investment in agriculture
can be public investment in agriculture or private Chile certainly a private li
or private Chile certainly a private li
or private Chile certainly a private li oriented and Peru as well situation but
oriented and Peru as well situation but
oriented and Peru as well situation but whatever the case or the source of the
whatever the case or the source of the
whatever the case or the source of the investment Pro Agricultural Policy also
investment Pro Agricultural Policy also
investment Pro Agricultural Policy also has made a defective correlation and
has made a defective correlation and
has made a defective correlation and what you find in these countries is that
what you find in these countries is that
what you find in these countries is that governments governments that pay
governments governments that pay
governments governments that pay attention to aid so let me give you two
attention to aid so let me give you two
attention to aid so let me give you two practical cases both the negative and
practical cases both the negative and
practical cases both the negative and then the positive I lived in Kenya for
then the positive I lived in Kenya for
then the positive I lived in Kenya for five years managing agricultural
five years managing agricultural
five years managing agricultural projects for the World Bank in the 1980s
projects for the World Bank in the 1980s
projects for the World Bank in the 1980s and those projects were done
and those projects were done
and those projects were done simultaneously with projects that were
simultaneously with projects that were
simultaneously with projects that were sponsored by other agencies USAID for
sponsored by other agencies USAID for
sponsored by other agencies USAID for example European Commission the Food and
example European Commission the Food and
example European Commission the Food and Agriculture Organization and many NGOs
Agriculture Organization and many NGOs
Agriculture Organization and many NGOs had agriculture projects most of us felt
had agriculture projects most of us felt
had agriculture projects most of us felt that our projects were working but when
that our projects were working but when
that our projects were working but when you added them all together they didn’t
you added them all together they didn’t
you added them all together they didn’t work why one example
work why one example
work why one example Agricultural Extension in the 1980s was
Agricultural Extension in the 1980s was
Agricultural Extension in the 1980s was a big theme of the donors Agricultural
a big theme of the donors Agricultural
a big theme of the donors Agricultural Extension is training farmers to deal
Extension is training farmers to deal
Extension is training farmers to deal with that productivity gap all of these
with that productivity gap all of these
with that productivity gap all of these donors including us in the World Bank
donors including us in the World Bank
donors including us in the World Bank had Agricultural Extension projects with
had Agricultural Extension projects with
had Agricultural Extension projects with different models the Americans had their
different models the Americans had their
different models the Americans had their model the Swedes had a mom the World
model the Swedes had a mom the World
model the Swedes had a mom the World Bank had a model the FAO had a model
Bank had a model the FAO had a model
Bank had a model the FAO had a model what is the result today 30 years later
what is the result today 30 years later
what is the result today 30 years later Kenya
Kenya
Kenya still does not have an Agricultural
still does not have an Agricultural
still does not have an Agricultural Extension system all of those projects
Extension system all of those projects
Extension system all of those projects have disappeared without a trace the
have disappeared without a trace the
have disappeared without a trace the tens of millions of dollars put into
tens of millions of dollars put into
tens of millions of dollars put into them were totally wasted let me give you
them were totally wasted let me give you
them were totally wasted let me give you the positive example with my wife I own
the positive example with my wife I own
the positive example with my wife I own two farms in the Peruvian Amazon
two farms in the Peruvian Amazon
two farms in the Peruvian Amazon producing coffee and cocoa in a little
producing coffee and cocoa in a little
producing coffee and cocoa in a little province called San Martin which is one
province called San Martin which is one
province called San Martin which is one of the poorest provinces in Peru for
of the poorest provinces in Peru for
of the poorest provinces in Peru for those of you know Peru this was famous
those of you know Peru this was famous
those of you know Peru this was famous for coca production for cocaine the
for coca production for cocaine the
for coca production for cocaine the narco trade farmers didn’t benefit very
narco trade farmers didn’t benefit very
narco trade farmers didn’t benefit very much from that narco trade there were
much from that narco trade there were
much from that narco trade there were people who did benefit from it but it
people who did benefit from it but it
people who did benefit from it but it wasn’t the farmers place was
wasn’t the farmers place was
wasn’t the farmers place was impoverished characterized by violence
impoverished characterized by violence
impoverished characterized by violence my wife happy for me and most of her
my wife happy for me and most of her
my wife happy for me and most of her siblings migrated out of the country
siblings migrated out of the country
siblings migrated out of the country looking for opportunity she came to the
looking for opportunity she came to the
looking for opportunity she came to the United States married me what happened
United States married me what happened
United States married me what happened the Peruvian government was serious
the Peruvian government was serious
the Peruvian government was serious about changing this very welcoming
about changing this very welcoming
about changing this very welcoming investment welcoming private investments
investment welcoming private investments
investment welcoming private investments mostly Peruvian but also foreign rural
mostly Peruvian but also foreign rural
mostly Peruvian but also foreign rural infrastructure and they mobilized donors
infrastructure and they mobilized donors
infrastructure and they mobilized donors to assist them in doing this they
to assist them in doing this they
to assist them in doing this they managed the donors today there’s been a
managed the donors today there’s been a
managed the donors today there’s been a transformation in this province there’s
transformation in this province there’s
transformation in this province there’s still a little cocoa production but
still a little cocoa production but
still a little cocoa production but mostly it’s been substituted by rice
mostly it’s been substituted by rice
mostly it’s been substituted by rice cacao for chocolate
cacao for chocolate
cacao for chocolate high-quality cacao coffee and various
high-quality cacao coffee and various
high-quality cacao coffee and various food crops we see infrastructure there
food crops we see infrastructure there
food crops we see infrastructure there assisted by donors the government of
assisted by donors the government of
assisted by donors the government of Peru managed the donors this is a case
Peru managed the donors this is a case
Peru managed the donors this is a case of effective aid so based on that
of effective aid so based on that
of effective aid so based on that experience what can be done well the
experience what can be done well the
experience what can be done well the easiest thing to say is let’s just
easiest thing to say is let’s just
easiest thing to say is let’s just admonish the majority of developing
admonish the majority of developing
admonish the majority of developing country governments to implement
country governments to implement
country governments to implement policies they can take a choice it can
policies they can take a choice it can
policies they can take a choice it can be mark vary market oriented or less
be mark vary market oriented or less
be mark vary market oriented or less market oriented look at the Chinese
market oriented look at the Chinese
market oriented look at the Chinese policy or the Vietnamese or look at
policy or the Vietnamese or look at
policy or the Vietnamese or look at Chile or Peru or look at Rwanda or Ghana
Chile or Peru or look at Rwanda or Ghana
Chile or Peru or look at Rwanda or Ghana or Uganda but admonishment doesn’t work
or Uganda but admonishment doesn’t work
or Uganda but admonishment doesn’t work in my experience I would hope that more
in my experience I would hope that more
in my experience I would hope that more governments duplicate what works and
governments duplicate what works and
governments duplicate what works and reject what doesn’t but that’s pretty
reject what doesn’t but that’s pretty
reject what doesn’t but that’s pretty tough that’s a pipe dream particularly
tough that’s a pipe dream particularly
tough that’s a pipe dream particularly given the situation we are in
given the situation we are in
given the situation we are in remember millions of people living in
remember millions of people living in
remember millions of people living in poverty often risking their lives to
poverty often risking their lives to
poverty often risking their lives to escape it and environmental destruction
escape it and environmental destruction
escape it and environmental destruction if you need an image of an area the size
if you need an image of an area the size
if you need an image of an area the size of Greece every year and with climate
of Greece every year and with climate
of Greece every year and with climate change probably exacerbating this
change probably exacerbating this
change probably exacerbating this situation in the future so let’s move to
situation in the future so let’s move to
situation in the future so let’s move to the aid business is there something that
the aid business is there something that
the aid business is there something that can be done to reform that transfer
can be done to reform that transfer
can be done to reform that transfer mechanism that international transfer
mechanism that international transfer
mechanism that international transfer mechanism that international safety net
mechanism that international safety net
mechanism that international safety net to make it more effective and that’s my
to make it more effective and that’s my
to make it more effective and that’s my idea the idea but behind this TED talk I
idea the idea but behind this TED talk I
idea the idea but behind this TED talk I believe that it can be done many
believe that it can be done many
believe that it can be done many national governments should also reform
national governments should also reform
national governments should also reform their safety nets to make them more
their safety nets to make them more
their safety nets to make them more effective but internationally I believe
effective but internationally I believe
effective but internationally I believe it can be done by reducing the number of
it can be done by reducing the number of
it can be done by reducing the number of institutions providing aid there are 150
institutions providing aid there are 150
institutions providing aid there are 150 institutions in the world which provide
institutions in the world which provide
institutions in the world which provide agricultural aid and given the
agricultural aid and given the
agricultural aid and given the resistance of industrial country
resistance of industrial country
resistance of industrial country taxpayers now to any kind of aid almost
taxpayers now to any kind of aid almost
taxpayers now to any kind of aid almost all of these institutions in fact all of
all of these institutions in fact all of
all of these institutions in fact all of them are under financed many of them
them are under financed many of them
them are under financed many of them have gotten to a situation where up to
have gotten to a situation where up to
have gotten to a situation where up to 50
50
50 their funds don’t go to farmers they go
their funds don’t go to farmers they go
their funds don’t go to farmers they go to maintaining themselves because their
to maintaining themselves because their
to maintaining themselves because their funds are so scarce what comes first for
funds are so scarce what comes first for
funds are so scarce what comes first for them is to pay the salaries of their
them is to pay the salaries of their
them is to pay the salaries of their employees reduce the number of the these
employees reduce the number of the these
employees reduce the number of the these institutions and focus the funding on
institutions and focus the funding on
institutions and focus the funding on the few of them that do well this would
the few of them that do well this would
the few of them that do well this would create a burning platform opportunity to
create a burning platform opportunity to
create a burning platform opportunity to reform internally as well to start
reform internally as well to start
reform internally as well to start pushing projects of the type that work
pushing projects of the type that work
pushing projects of the type that work we after all have 50 years of experience
we after all have 50 years of experience
we after all have 50 years of experience and avoiding the kinds of projects
and avoiding the kinds of projects
and avoiding the kinds of projects unfortunately the majority which turn
unfortunately the majority which turn
unfortunately the majority which turn out to fail overcoming that
out to fail overcoming that
out to fail overcoming that institutional inertia which often
institutional inertia which often
institutional inertia which often characterizes private firms as well but
characterizes private firms as well but
characterizes private firms as well but public enterprises often have this
public enterprises often have this
public enterprises often have this because they don’t have a profit motive
because they don’t have a profit motive
because they don’t have a profit motive that pushes them to do the right thing
that pushes them to do the right thing
that pushes them to do the right thing so the burning platform not just the
so the burning platform not just the
so the burning platform not just the institutional strengthening and
institutional strengthening and
institutional strengthening and reduction but the burning platform is
reduction but the burning platform is
reduction but the burning platform is important and I would maintain that
important and I would maintain that
important and I would maintain that fewer bigger more efficient low or
fewer bigger more efficient low or
fewer bigger more efficient low or overhead institutions learning
overhead institutions learning
overhead institutions learning institutions would be much more
institutions would be much more
institutions would be much more effective as providing this safety net
effective as providing this safety net
effective as providing this safety net now how to accomplish this frankly the
now how to accomplish this frankly the
now how to accomplish this frankly the government’s that own these institutions
government’s that own these institutions
government’s that own these institutions and the people that management manage
and the people that management manage
and the people that management manage them have to recognize the failure of
them have to recognize the failure of
them have to recognize the failure of the system very often when you’re in the
the system very often when you’re in the
the system very often when you’re in the system particularly in the United
system particularly in the United
system particularly in the United Nations people want to do good it’s very
Nations people want to do good it’s very
Nations people want to do good it’s very difficult to recognize the failure of
difficult to recognize the failure of
difficult to recognize the failure of these systems they have to recognize the
these systems they have to recognize the
these systems they have to recognize the need for fundamental reform by
need for fundamental reform by
need for fundamental reform by acknowledging the failure of the current
acknowledging the failure of the current
acknowledging the failure of the current system and another way a technical way
system and another way a technical way
system and another way a technical way of putting this is to push for
of putting this is to push for
of putting this is to push for cost-effectiveness the proxy and public
cost-effectiveness the proxy and public
cost-effectiveness the proxy and public institutions for a profit motive is
institutions for a profit motive is
institutions for a profit motive is cost-effectiveness and these
cost-effectiveness and these
cost-effectiveness and these institutions are the epitome of
institutions are the epitome of
institutions are the epitome of cost-effectiveness so it’s another way
cost-effectiveness so it’s another way
cost-effectiveness so it’s another way of looking at why is this important well
of looking at why is this important well
of looking at why is this important well partly for moral reasons that doesn’t
partly for moral reasons that doesn’t
partly for moral reasons that doesn’t attract everybody this idea of
attract everybody this idea of
attract everybody this idea of correcting market distortions so that
correcting market distortions so that
correcting market distortions so that everybody benefits which requires some
everybody benefits which requires some
everybody benefits which requires some transfer
transfer
transfer from those who benefit the most to those
from those who benefit the most to those
from those who benefit the most to those who benefit not at all
who benefit not at all
who benefit not at all so that’s one thing if you’re interested
so that’s one thing if you’re interested
so that’s one thing if you’re interested in the environment surely improving the
in the environment surely improving the
in the environment surely improving the productivity of farmers so they don’t
productivity of farmers so they don’t
productivity of farmers so they don’t have to cut down the forests to expand
have to cut down the forests to expand
have to cut down the forests to expand their output they can expand the output
their output they can expand the output
their output they can expand the output on the land that they have that’s
on the land that they have that’s
on the land that they have that’s important for environmental reasons as
important for environmental reasons as
important for environmental reasons as well it may be important for you because
well it may be important for you because
well it may be important for you because you don’t want to see your population
you don’t want to see your population
you don’t want to see your population migrate out of your country it’s it’s an
migrate out of your country it’s it’s an
migrate out of your country it’s it’s an embarrassment frankly to have your
embarrassment frankly to have your
embarrassment frankly to have your people wanting to leave to places that
people wanting to leave to places that
people wanting to leave to places that don’t want them and the places that
don’t want them and the places that
don’t want them and the places that receive them look to be less and less
receive them look to be less and less
receive them look to be less and less accommodating so accommodating certainly
accommodating so accommodating certainly
accommodating so accommodating certainly in the United States and Europe this is
in the United States and Europe this is
in the United States and Europe this is the case so their reasons as well Abe
the case so their reasons as well Abe
the case so their reasons as well Abe continues to be needed as this transfer
continues to be needed as this transfer
continues to be needed as this transfer mechanism this social safety net but aid
mechanism this social safety net but aid
mechanism this social safety net but aid this kind of aid needs to be
this kind of aid needs to be
this kind of aid needs to be fundamentally reform to become more
fundamentally reform to become more
fundamentally reform to become more effective and less costly otherwise that
effective and less costly otherwise that
effective and less costly otherwise that safety net will disappear thank you very
safety net will disappear thank you very
safety net will disappear thank you very much
much
much [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment