Press "Enter" to skip to content

Process of Scientific Discovery | Gregory van der Vink | TEDxCarnegieLake


in thinking about my remarks for today I

in thinking about my remarks for today I went back to some of my former students

went back to some of my former students

went back to some of my former students and I asked them in the courses they’ve

and I asked them in the courses they’ve

and I asked them in the courses they’ve taken with me what were they what were

taken with me what were they what were

taken with me what were they what were the major takeaways what were the things

the major takeaways what were the things

the major takeaways what were the things that they valued the most from from our

that they valued the most from from our

that they valued the most from from our time together and and from my courses it

time together and and from my courses it

time together and and from my courses it was clearly a humbling experience and

was clearly a humbling experience and

was clearly a humbling experience and the results were rather rather

the results were rather rather

the results were rather rather unexpected and it actually made me pivot

unexpected and it actually made me pivot

unexpected and it actually made me pivot and transitioned to give a much

and transitioned to give a much

and transitioned to give a much different talk than I had originally

different talk than I had originally

different talk than I had originally intended when I started sure I in all my

intended when I started sure I in all my

intended when I started sure I in all my courses I I presented the basic tenants

courses I I presented the basic tenants

courses I I presented the basic tenants of science to all the students I even

of science to all the students I even

of science to all the students I even introduced them to kind of the

introduced them to kind of the

introduced them to kind of the excitement of fieldwork and and

excitement of fieldwork and and

excitement of fieldwork and and measurements of the natural environment

measurements of the natural environment

measurements of the natural environment and the various concepts of science and

and the various concepts of science and

and the various concepts of science and how it how it relates to the natural

how it how it relates to the natural

how it how it relates to the natural environment but that wasn’t what they

environment but that wasn’t what they

environment but that wasn’t what they took away from the course what they took

took away from the course what they took

took away from the course what they took away from the course was a different

away from the course was a different

away from the course was a different understanding of science and in fact

understanding of science and in fact

understanding of science and in fact what what they valued the most was an

what what they valued the most was an

what what they valued the most was an understanding of how science is done the

understanding of how science is done the

understanding of how science is done the process of discovery the process of how

process of discovery the process of how

process of discovery the process of how we use science to systematically and

we use science to systematically and

we use science to systematically and critically think about questions and

critically think about questions and

critically think about questions and that it was an iterative process

that it was an iterative process

that it was an iterative process [Music]

[Music]

[Music] typically we have this impression of

typically we have this impression of

typically we have this impression of science and it’s it starts with how I

science and it’s it starts with how I

science and it’s it starts with how I guess science is presented in grade

guess science is presented in grade

guess science is presented in grade school which is this concept or even on

school which is this concept or even on

school which is this concept or even on television this concept of someone in

television this concept of someone in

television this concept of someone in you know in a white lab coat typically

you know in a white lab coat typically

you know in a white lab coat typically with strange shaped glassware always has

with strange shaped glassware always has

with strange shaped glassware always has strange colored fluids in it and and we

strange colored fluids in it and and we

strange colored fluids in it and and we learn this sort of approach of science

learn this sort of approach of science

learn this sort of approach of science where a hypothesis is proposed then we

where a hypothesis is proposed then we

where a hypothesis is proposed then we go out there and we collect data we

go out there and we collect data we

go out there and we collect data we analyze the data and we reach some sort

analyze the data and we reach some sort

analyze the data and we reach some sort of conclusion and that this conclusion

of conclusion and that this conclusion

of conclusion and that this conclusion represents some truth some certainty and

represents some truth some certainty and

represents some truth some certainty and that everyone would agree on it and that

that everyone would agree on it and that

that everyone would agree on it and that experts will agree on it science is not

experts will agree on it science is not

experts will agree on it science is not really done that way

really done that way

really done that way at least the great discoveries of

at least the great discoveries of

at least the great discoveries of science rarely occur through that

science rarely occur through that

science rarely occur through that process they kind of occur through a

process they kind of occur through a

process they kind of occur through a more iterative and creative process

more iterative and creative process

more iterative and creative process there are usually ideas out there and

there are usually ideas out there and

there are usually ideas out there and we’re looking to improve upon them or

we’re looking to improve upon them or

we’re looking to improve upon them or revise them or think of how they can

revise them or think of how they can

revise them or think of how they can explain more of the phenomena that we’re

explain more of the phenomena that we’re

explain more of the phenomena that we’re trying to measure we go when we collect

trying to measure we go when we collect

trying to measure we go when we collect data but the data are messy they’re

data but the data are messy they’re

data but the data are messy they’re ambiguous

ambiguous

ambiguous we can’t go it collect the data we

we can’t go it collect the data we

we can’t go it collect the data we really want so we’re interpreting data

really want so we’re interpreting data

really want so we’re interpreting data we’re using proxy data notice we use

we’re using proxy data notice we use

we’re using proxy data notice we use this expression interpret data we don’t

this expression interpret data we don’t

this expression interpret data we don’t actually analyze data we interpret data

actually analyze data we interpret data

actually analyze data we interpret data and different people looking at the same

and different people looking at the same

and different people looking at the same data can actually arrive at different

data can actually arrive at different

data can actually arrive at different interpretations and typically we don’t

interpretations and typically we don’t

interpretations and typically we don’t have conclusions but we arrive at

have conclusions but we arrive at

have conclusions but we arrive at findings and with these findings we

findings and with these findings we

findings and with these findings we realize that additional work can always

realize that additional work can always

realize that additional work can always be done and this brings us back to the

be done and this brings us back to the

be done and this brings us back to the beginning because then we predict what

beginning because then we predict what

beginning because then we predict what what we should see we predict what new

what we should see we predict what new

what we should see we predict what new data we should find we make up stories

data we should find we make up stories

data we should find we make up stories to explain the data and then we go when

to explain the data and then we go when

to explain the data and then we go when we test those stories in a very

we test those stories in a very

we test those stories in a very iterative and creative process I think

iterative and creative process I think

iterative and creative process I think what this requires is sort of a humble

what this requires is sort of a humble

what this requires is sort of a humble approach to science and that is the

approach to science and that is the

approach to science and that is the sense that we always need to be able to

sense that we always need to be able to

sense that we always need to be able to as we collect data and as we get new

as we collect data and as we get new

as we collect data and as we get new information to do what we – to do what

information to do what we – to do what

information to do what we – to do what we refer to as to entertain an

we refer to as to entertain an

we refer to as to entertain an alternative hypothesis in other words to

alternative hypothesis in other words to

alternative hypothesis in other words to be open-minded in other words to be

be open-minded in other words to be

be open-minded in other words to be willing to change our mind now some of

willing to change our mind now some of

willing to change our mind now some of you may have heard of this

you may have heard of this

you may have heard of this problem-solving principle called Occam’s

problem-solving principle called Occam’s

problem-solving principle called Occam’s razor it’s it’s not clear whether this

razor it’s it’s not clear whether this

razor it’s it’s not clear whether this the attribution is correct or not but

the attribution is correct or not but

the attribution is correct or not but basically Occam’s razor is the idea that

basically Occam’s razor is the idea that

basically Occam’s razor is the idea that if you’re thinking about a problem and

if you’re thinking about a problem and

if you’re thinking about a problem and looking for a solution you should begin

looking for a solution you should begin

looking for a solution you should begin with the solution that is a simplest

with the solution that is a simplest

with the solution that is a simplest solution that explains the data in other

solution that explains the data in other

solution that explains the data in other words you should not unnecessarily add

words you should not unnecessarily add

words you should not unnecessarily add complexity this is often translated into

complexity this is often translated into

complexity this is often translated into the idea that if you see hoof prints on

the idea that if you see hoof prints on

the idea that if you see hoof prints on the ground the first thing you should

the ground the first thing you should

the ground the first thing you should think of should be horses not zebras

think of should be horses not zebras

think of should be horses not zebras idea here is you look for the simplest

idea here is you look for the simplest

idea here is you look for the simplest most likely explanation and if that

most likely explanation and if that

most likely explanation and if that fails then you look at other

fails then you look at other

fails then you look at other alternatives the important concept here

alternatives the important concept here

alternatives the important concept here though is that with Occam’s razor it

though is that with Occam’s razor it

though is that with Occam’s razor it doesn’t necessarily say that the

doesn’t necessarily say that the

doesn’t necessarily say that the simplest solution or the simplest theory

simplest solution or the simplest theory

simplest solution or the simplest theory that satisfies the data is the correct

that satisfies the data is the correct

that satisfies the data is the correct one it says that that is the beginning

one it says that that is the beginning

one it says that that is the beginning that is where you begin the process and

that is where you begin the process and

that is where you begin the process and you then add complexity as needed to

you then add complexity as needed to

you then add complexity as needed to explain the additional data if for

explain the additional data if for

explain the additional data if for example you know in this situation you

example you know in this situation you

example you know in this situation you turn around in the animal that’s that’s

turn around in the animal that’s that’s

turn around in the animal that’s that’s that’s creating those hoofprints happens

that’s creating those hoofprints happens

that’s creating those hoofprints happens to have stripes on it then you may want

to have stripes on it then you may want

to have stripes on it then you may want to think of severs if you go back and

to think of severs if you go back and

to think of severs if you go back and you look at who were some of the most

you look at who were some of the most

you look at who were some of the most famous scientists or some of the ones

famous scientists or some of the ones

famous scientists or some of the ones that we think of da Vinci Edison Albert

that we think of da Vinci Edison Albert

that we think of da Vinci Edison Albert Einstein many of these scientists were

Einstein many of these scientists were

Einstein many of these scientists were known to have very strong or significant

known to have very strong or significant

known to have very strong or significant cases of AD D and the gene associated

cases of AD D and the gene associated

cases of AD D and the gene associated with AD D is actually sometimes referred

with AD D is actually sometimes referred

with AD D is actually sometimes referred to as the Explorers gene and one theory

to as the Explorers gene and one theory

to as the Explorers gene and one theory about this is that having a DD actually

about this is that having a DD actually

about this is that having a DD actually allows people to let go of some of the

allows people to let go of some of the

allows people to let go of some of the pre-existing ideas it allows them to be

pre-existing ideas it allows them to be

pre-existing ideas it allows them to be more intellectually nimble it allows

more intellectually nimble it allows

more intellectually nimble it allows them to be more willing to adopt a new

them to be more willing to adopt a new

them to be more willing to adopt a new hypothesis or a new theory and to let go

hypothesis or a new theory and to let go

hypothesis or a new theory and to let go of the old one the idea is that perhaps

of the old one the idea is that perhaps

of the old one the idea is that perhaps if you can’t you know if you can’t

if you can’t you know if you can’t

if you can’t you know if you can’t remember all the facts of the old theory

remember all the facts of the old theory

remember all the facts of the old theory you’re less you’re more likely to be

you’re less you’re more likely to be

you’re less you’re more likely to be willing to abandon that and adopt the

willing to abandon that and adopt the

willing to abandon that and adopt the new theory this is I had the experience

new theory this is I had the experience

new theory this is I had the experience of of this scene a transition in science

of of this scene a transition in science

of of this scene a transition in science when I first came into geosciences the

when I first came into geosciences the

when I first came into geosciences the prevailing theory right in the 50s and

prevailing theory right in the 50s and

prevailing theory right in the 50s and going into the into the early 60s was

going into the into the early 60s was

going into the into the early 60s was that the earth was essentially like an

that the earth was essentially like an

that the earth was essentially like an apple and that as the earth aged it was

apple and that as the earth aged it was

apple and that as the earth aged it was cooling and shrinking and that cooling

cooling and shrinking and that cooling

cooling and shrinking and that cooling and shrinking caused wrinkles on the

and shrinking caused wrinkles on the

and shrinking caused wrinkles on the surface of the Apple and that explained

surface of the Apple and that explained

surface of the Apple and that explained the mountainside basis

the mountainside basis

the mountainside basis now I think even as a very young child

now I think even as a very young child

now I think even as a very young child first being introduced to this in grade

first being introduced to this in grade

first being introduced to this in grade school I realized that clearly this was

school I realized that clearly this was

school I realized that clearly this was a field that was wide open and that also

a field that was wide open and that also

a field that was wide open and that also in my experience I had never seen a

in my experience I had never seen a

in my experience I had never seen a wrinkled apple to me they were more

wrinkled apple to me they were more

wrinkled apple to me they were more mushy as they got older so anyway we

mushy as they got older so anyway we

mushy as they got older so anyway we accepted that yet in the 1960s the

accepted that yet in the 1960s the

accepted that yet in the 1960s the theory of plate tectonics came along and

theory of plate tectonics came along and

theory of plate tectonics came along and also in all this data was collected that

also in all this data was collected that

also in all this data was collected that indicated that the seafloor was

indicated that the seafloor was

indicated that the seafloor was spreading and that the we had magnetic

spreading and that the we had magnetic

spreading and that the we had magnetic anomalies which were symmetric around

anomalies which were symmetric around

anomalies which were symmetric around the seafloor it indicated that the

the seafloor it indicated that the

the seafloor it indicated that the seafloor was spreading and we developed

seafloor was spreading and we developed

seafloor was spreading and we developed a theory of continental drift and this

a theory of continental drift and this

a theory of continental drift and this completely changed her theory of how the

completely changed her theory of how the

completely changed her theory of how the earth was formed how the earth was

earth was formed how the earth was

earth was formed how the earth was evolved and created a revolution in her

evolved and created a revolution in her

evolved and created a revolution in her sciences that went through the 60s and

sciences that went through the 60s and

sciences that went through the 60s and the 1970s now that there were several

the 1970s now that there were several

the 1970s now that there were several holdouts people who resisted this

holdouts people who resisted this

holdouts people who resisted this because it was a big body of literature

because it was a big body of literature

because it was a big body of literature and all this information that was

and all this information that was

and all this information that was available so how do you accept this new

available so how do you accept this new

available so how do you accept this new theory how do you accept this new idea

theory how do you accept this new idea

theory how do you accept this new idea and abandon so much of what was there

and abandon so much of what was there

and abandon so much of what was there before

Max Planck who won the Nobel Prize in

Max Planck who won the Nobel Prize in Physics approximately a century ago and

Physics approximately a century ago and

Physics approximately a century ago and by any objective assessment was a pretty

by any objective assessment was a pretty

by any objective assessment was a pretty interesting person pointed out that a

interesting person pointed out that a

interesting person pointed out that a new scientific truth does not triumph by

new scientific truth does not triumph by

new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them

convincing its opponents and making them

convincing its opponents and making them see the light but rather because the

see the light but rather because the

see the light but rather because the opponents eventually die and I think

opponents eventually die and I think

opponents eventually die and I think there’s a there’s an important concept

there’s a there’s an important concept

there’s a there’s an important concept here and that is that I think we all

here and that is that I think we all

here and that is that I think we all know certainly any of us who have been

know certainly any of us who have been

know certainly any of us who have been in relationships that you don’t change

in relationships that you don’t change

in relationships that you don’t change someone’s mind by proving them wrong and

someone’s mind by proving them wrong and

someone’s mind by proving them wrong and that there’s always going to be a

that there’s always going to be a

that there’s always going to be a certain amount of outlier opinion that

certain amount of outlier opinion that

certain amount of outlier opinion that that exists but that doesn’t mean that

that exists but that doesn’t mean that

that exists but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t a consensus and that doesn’t

there isn’t a consensus and that doesn’t

there isn’t a consensus and that doesn’t mean that science cannot move forward

mean that science cannot move forward

mean that science cannot move forward what happens is a lot of this opposition

what happens is a lot of this opposition

what happens is a lot of this opposition is then supported through what we call

is then supported through what we call

is then supported through what we call anecdotal information an anecdotal

anecdotal information an anecdotal

anecdotal information an anecdotal information is both interesting and

information is both interesting and

information is both interesting and useful but it’s also dangerous

useful but it’s also dangerous

useful but it’s also dangerous anecdotes are stories and we like these

anecdotes are stories and we like these

anecdotes are stories and we like these stories because they’re easier easy to

stories because they’re easier easy to

stories because they’re easier easy to relate to they’re easier to relate to

relate to they’re easier to relate to

relate to they’re easier to relate to than facts or graphs or numbers or data

than facts or graphs or numbers or data

than facts or graphs or numbers or data the problem with anecdotes is inevitably

the problem with anecdotes is inevitably

the problem with anecdotes is inevitably we cherry pick them we cherry pick them

we cherry pick them we cherry pick them

we cherry pick them we cherry pick them to support our predetermined point of

to support our predetermined point of

to support our predetermined point of view and in science we have the same the

view and in science we have the same the

view and in science we have the same the plural of anecdote is not data we think

plural of anecdote is not data we think

plural of anecdote is not data we think this is a very clever statement

this is a very clever statement

this is a very clever statement it’s Houston a lot of talks it’s a

it’s Houston a lot of talks it’s a

it’s Houston a lot of talks it’s a statement that every scientist knows

statement that every scientist knows

statement that every scientist knows because a bunch of stories and a bunch

because a bunch of stories and a bunch

because a bunch of stories and a bunch of examples do not necessarily

of examples do not necessarily

of examples do not necessarily constitute what we would consider to be

constitute what we would consider to be

constitute what we would consider to be a rigorous analysis the series of

a rigorous analysis the series of

a rigorous analysis the series of anecdotes are not in fact a collection

anecdotes are not in fact a collection

anecdotes are not in fact a collection of data and they can be quite dangerous

of data and they can be quite dangerous

of data and they can be quite dangerous anecdotes are typically what’s used to

anecdotes are typically what’s used to

anecdotes are typically what’s used to support outlier opinions anecdotes are

support outlier opinions anecdotes are

support outlier opinions anecdotes are typically the basis of what we see for

typically the basis of what we see for

typically the basis of what we see for prejudice anecdotes are used to support

prejudice anecdotes are used to support

prejudice anecdotes are used to support creationism and they are the hallmark of

creationism and they are the hallmark of

creationism and they are the hallmark of conspiracy theories so we are anecdotes

conspiracy theories so we are anecdotes

conspiracy theories so we are anecdotes are often often things that we try to

are often often things that we try to

are often often things that we try to avoid so what I’d like to propose here

avoid so what I’d like to propose here

avoid so what I’d like to propose here is that if we’re looking for when we

is that if we’re looking for when we

is that if we’re looking for when we deal with science and in a society where

deal with science and in a society where

deal with science and in a society where increasingly more of our decisions are

increasingly more of our decisions are

increasingly more of our decisions are being based on science and technology

being based on science and technology

being based on science and technology and increasingly in a situation where I

and increasingly in a situation where I

and increasingly in a situation where I don’t think we can afford to wait for

don’t think we can afford to wait for

don’t think we can afford to wait for funerals if we’re looking for truth and

funerals if we’re looking for truth and

funerals if we’re looking for truth and certainty we need to realize that

certainty we need to realize that

certainty we need to realize that findings will always be revised there

findings will always be revised there

findings will always be revised there will never be a hundred percent

will never be a hundred percent

will never be a hundred percent agreement more research can always be

agreement more research can always be

agreement more research can always be done results will be challenged with

done results will be challenged with

done results will be challenged with anecdotal information and yet we have to

anecdotal information and yet we have to

anecdotal information and yet we have to be careful that we don’t allow this to

be careful that we don’t allow this to

be careful that we don’t allow this to be used as an excuse for inaction and

be used as an excuse for inaction and

be used as an excuse for inaction and some people have actually pointed out

some people have actually pointed out

some people have actually pointed out there’s a strange symbiotic relationship

there’s a strange symbiotic relationship

there’s a strange symbiotic relationship where if you’re a policymaker and you

where if you’re a policymaker and you

where if you’re a policymaker and you want to avoid making difficult decisions

want to avoid making difficult decisions

want to avoid making difficult decisions you can call for more research to be

you can call for more research to be

you can call for more research to be done and the scientific community is

done and the scientific community is

done and the scientific community is always anxious to accept additional

always anxious to accept additional

always anxious to accept additional support and can always think of

support and can always think of

support and can always think of additional problems and ways of asking

additional problems and ways of asking

additional problems and ways of asking the question so we have to be careful

the question so we have to be careful

the question so we have to be careful that as this iterative process of

that as this iterative process of

that as this iterative process of science continues we don’t allow that to

science continues we don’t allow that to

science continues we don’t allow that to distract us

distract us

distract us from using science and taking it

from using science and taking it

from using science and taking it advantage of science to make the

advantage of science to make the

advantage of science to make the decisions that we need to make and the

decisions that we need to make and the

decisions that we need to make and the reason why I find this to be valuable

reason why I find this to be valuable

reason why I find this to be valuable and I think this is important is because

and I think this is important is because

and I think this is important is because as we look for those footprints or as we

as we look for those footprints or as we

as we look for those footprints or as we see those footprints we don’t want to

see those footprints we don’t want to

see those footprints we don’t want to allow or we don’t want to lose the

allow or we don’t want to lose the

allow or we don’t want to lose the possibility that those footprints if we

possibility that those footprints if we

possibility that those footprints if we turn around and see an animal and it has

turn around and see an animal and it has

turn around and see an animal and it has this big horn sticking out of its head

this big horn sticking out of its head

this big horn sticking out of its head that we may have in fact found the

that we may have in fact found the

that we may have in fact found the Unicorn

Unicorn

Unicorn and we need to be open to that and

and we need to be open to that and

and we need to be open to that and understand that science is this

understand that science is this

understand that science is this iterative process that it’s a creative

iterative process that it’s a creative

iterative process that it’s a creative process that science is actually more of

process that science is actually more of

process that science is actually more of an art than a science and that if we

an art than a science and that if we

an art than a science and that if we embrace it that way it can lead us to

embrace it that way it can lead us to

embrace it that way it can lead us to new discoveries now what I’m saying is

new discoveries now what I’m saying is

new discoveries now what I’m saying is this won’t necessarily make our lives

this won’t necessarily make our lives

this won’t necessarily make our lives easier but it will make them richer and

easier but it will make them richer and

easier but it will make them richer and I think that it just might also make

I think that it just might also make

I think that it just might also make this world a little bit of a better

this world a little bit of a better

this world a little bit of a better place thank you

place thank you

place thank you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] you

you

you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *