Press "Enter" to skip to content

Is the universe a product of thermodynamic evolution? | Todd Hylton | TEDxSanDiego


[Music]

[Music] so good evening everyone

so good evening everyone

so good evening everyone so in 1967 Richard Brautigan published a

so in 1967 Richard Brautigan published a

so in 1967 Richard Brautigan published a poem and it was titled all watched over

poem and it was titled all watched over

poem and it was titled all watched over by machines of loving grace and he

by machines of loving grace and he

by machines of loving grace and he suggested a future in which our

suggested a future in which our

suggested a future in which our technologies our machines had such

technologies our machines had such

technologies our machines had such understanding that they would care for

understanding that they would care for

understanding that they would care for us and relieve us from the struggles of

us and relieve us from the struggles of

us and relieve us from the struggles of our everyday life so today I we’re again

our everyday life so today I we’re again

our everyday life so today I we’re again fascinated by a future with machines you

fascinated by a future with machines you

fascinated by a future with machines you know things like artificially

know things like artificially

know things like artificially intelligent computers and self-driving

intelligent computers and self-driving

intelligent computers and self-driving cars and robots it seems to me though

cars and robots it seems to me though

cars and robots it seems to me though that that hope for machines that would

that that hope for machines that would

that that hope for machines that would take care of us has been in large part

take care of us has been in large part

take care of us has been in large part taken over by fear that machines might

taken over by fear that machines might

taken over by fear that machines might replace us or even destroy us so in this

replace us or even destroy us so in this

replace us or even destroy us so in this talk I want to address these hopes and

talk I want to address these hopes and

talk I want to address these hopes and fears for our technologies but to do

fears for our technologies but to do

fears for our technologies but to do that I’ve got to tackle some really

that I’ve got to tackle some really

that I’ve got to tackle some really tough questions questions like is the

tough questions questions like is the

tough questions questions like is the world a machine and how do things come

world a machine and how do things come

world a machine and how do things come to exist and can we build technologies

to exist and can we build technologies

to exist and can we build technologies that understand the world all by

that understand the world all by

that understand the world all by themselves now I’ve spent the last ten

themselves now I’ve spent the last ten

themselves now I’ve spent the last ten years rearranging my brain trying to

years rearranging my brain trying to

years rearranging my brain trying to answer these questions and I’m going to

answer these questions and I’m going to

answer these questions and I’m going to spend the next 10 minutes trying to

spend the next 10 minutes trying to

spend the next 10 minutes trying to rearrange yours so hang on

rearrange yours so hang on

rearrange yours so hang on so the first I’m going to talk about

so the first I’m going to talk about

so the first I’m going to talk about what it is to be a machine so I think

what it is to be a machine so I think

what it is to be a machine so I think there are two things that make machines

there are two things that make machines

there are two things that make machines different from us and from what we

different from us and from what we

different from us and from what we typically think of as the natural world

typically think of as the natural world

typically think of as the natural world the first thing is that machines are

the first thing is that machines are

the first thing is that machines are essentially the sum of their parts and

essentially the sum of their parts and

essentially the sum of their parts and by that I mean we can take machines

by that I mean we can take machines

by that I mean we can take machines apart into pieces but we can also put

apart into pieces but we can also put

apart into pieces but we can also put the pieces back together and recover the

the pieces back together and recover the

the pieces back together and recover the entire machine this also means that we

entire machine this also means that we

entire machine this also means that we can replace broken parts and that we can

can replace broken parts and that we can

can replace broken parts and that we can make copies of machines by putting

make copies of machines by putting

make copies of machines by putting together similar kinds of parts now this

together similar kinds of parts now this

together similar kinds of parts now this is very much unlike us we are indeed

is very much unlike us we are indeed

is very much unlike us we are indeed made of many parts but we can’t simply

made of many parts but we can’t simply

made of many parts but we can’t simply remove and replace them and we can’t

remove and replace them and we can’t

remove and replace them and we can’t make copies of ourselves either a car

make copies of ourselves either a car

make copies of ourselves either a car losing a headlight and a person losing

losing a headlight and a person losing

losing a headlight and a person losing an eye aren’t the same thing

an eye aren’t the same thing

an eye aren’t the same thing now the second difference is that

now the second difference is that

now the second difference is that machines are connected to the world

machines are connected to the world

machines are connected to the world through us my car drives because I Drive

through us my car drives because I Drive

through us my car drives because I Drive it my phone makes a call because I call

it my phone makes a call because I call

it my phone makes a call because I call somebody

somebody

somebody everything that machines know about the

everything that machines know about the

everything that machines know about the world they know because we have built it

world they know because we have built it

world they know because we have built it or designed it into them again this is

or designed it into them again this is

or designed it into them again this is very much unlike us we know about the

very much unlike us we know about the

very much unlike us we know about the world because we’re deeply embedded in

world because we’re deeply embedded in

world because we’re deeply embedded in it and we change as it changes and we

it and we change as it changes and we

it and we change as it changes and we could say the same thing about all

could say the same thing about all

could say the same thing about all living things my dog knows all about his

living things my dog knows all about his

living things my dog knows all about his world without any help from me so I

world without any help from me so I

world without any help from me so I think in everyday life most of us

think in everyday life most of us

think in everyday life most of us realized that we’re not machines right

realized that we’re not machines right

realized that we’re not machines right real life is just too complicated and

real life is just too complicated and

real life is just too complicated and too unpredictable to be a machine as

too unpredictable to be a machine as

too unpredictable to be a machine as almost any family gathering would

almost any family gathering would

almost any family gathering would instantly confirm and we actually get

instantly confirm and we actually get

instantly confirm and we actually get into trouble when we try to describe the

into trouble when we try to describe the

into trouble when we try to describe the world sorry about that as a kind of

world sorry about that as a kind of

world sorry about that as a kind of machine speaking of machines so we get

machine speaking of machines so we get

machine speaking of machines so we get into trouble and so here’s a story to

into trouble and so here’s a story to

into trouble and so here’s a story to sort of illustrate what I mean so

sort of illustrate what I mean so

sort of illustrate what I mean so suppose that you and I want to go out

suppose that you and I want to go out

suppose that you and I want to go out and we want to build a forest on a

and we want to build a forest on a

and we want to build a forest on a barren plot of land and so we might look

barren plot of land and so we might look

barren plot of land and so we might look at a real forest and see there are trees

at a real forest and see there are trees

at a real forest and see there are trees and so then we might make things that

and so then we might make things that

and so then we might make things that look like trees out of plastic and put

look like trees out of plastic and put

look like trees out of plastic and put them in the ground with concrete and I

them in the ground with concrete and I

them in the ground with concrete and I might say hey you know that Forest has a

might say hey you know that Forest has a

might say hey you know that Forest has a stream so then we might dig a ditch and

stream so then we might dig a ditch and

stream so then we might dig a ditch and pump water through the ditch

pump water through the ditch

pump water through the ditch and you might decide that what we really

and you might decide that what we really

and you might decide that what we really need is to make leaves out of fabric and

need is to make leaves out of fabric and

need is to make leaves out of fabric and attach them to the trees with actuators

attach them to the trees with actuators

attach them to the trees with actuators that release them in the fall and of

that release them in the fall and of

that release them in the fall and of course this is a terrible idea

course this is a terrible idea

course this is a terrible idea it’s a ridiculous idea right everybody

it’s a ridiculous idea right everybody

it’s a ridiculous idea right everybody knows that if you want to build a forest

knows that if you want to build a forest

knows that if you want to build a forest you need seeds and water and air and

you need seeds and water and air and

you need seeds and water and air and sunlight in time for a forest to grow so

sunlight in time for a forest to grow so

sunlight in time for a forest to grow so that the point is that a forest is an

that the point is that a forest is an

that the point is that a forest is an evolved entity that’s intimately

evolved entity that’s intimately

evolved entity that’s intimately connected with its an environment and it

connected with its an environment and it

connected with its an environment and it cannot be assembled from a collection of

cannot be assembled from a collection of

cannot be assembled from a collection of parts so a forest isn’t a machine

parts so a forest isn’t a machine

parts so a forest isn’t a machine so given this simple story though you

so given this simple story though you

so given this simple story though you might be surprised to hear how much we

might be surprised to hear how much we

might be surprised to hear how much we want to describe the world as a machine

want to describe the world as a machine

want to describe the world as a machine and as an example the pinnacle of

and as an example the pinnacle of

and as an example the pinnacle of scientific achievement is the

scientific achievement is the

scientific achievement is the description of some part of the universe

description of some part of the universe

description of some part of the universe as a simple mechanistic formula

as a simple mechanistic formula

as a simple mechanistic formula something like Newton’s famous law that

something like Newton’s famous law that

something like Newton’s famous law that says force equals mass times

says force equals mass times

says force equals mass times acceleration you see the great thing

acceleration you see the great thing

acceleration you see the great thing about machines is that because they’re

about machines is that because they’re

about machines is that because they’re disconnected from the world and because

disconnected from the world and because

disconnected from the world and because they’re essentially a collection of

they’re essentially a collection of

they’re essentially a collection of parts they’re simple

parts they’re simple

parts they’re simple and they’re easy to predict what they’re

and they’re easy to predict what they’re

and they’re easy to predict what they’re gonna do but if we you know take this

gonna do but if we you know take this

gonna do but if we you know take this love of simple things to its logical

love of simple things to its logical

love of simple things to its logical extreme we come to the idea of a

extreme we come to the idea of a

extreme we come to the idea of a universe that’s completely mechanistic

universe that’s completely mechanistic

universe that’s completely mechanistic and when we do that we also arrive at

and when we do that we also arrive at

and when we do that we also arrive at the conclusion that we need a

the conclusion that we need a

the conclusion that we need a supernatural entity to create it just

supernatural entity to create it just

supernatural entity to create it just like a machine needs an engineer a

like a machine needs an engineer a

like a machine needs an engineer a mechanistic universe needs a creator now

mechanistic universe needs a creator now

mechanistic universe needs a creator now in my experience this idea that the

in my experience this idea that the

in my experience this idea that the world some kind of machine is actually

world some kind of machine is actually

world some kind of machine is actually really common even among scientists so

really common even among scientists so

really common even among scientists so curiously I find that like some

curiously I find that like some

curiously I find that like some religious fundamentalists some

religious fundamentalists some

religious fundamentalists some scientists are actually creationists

scientists are actually creationists

scientists are actually creationists although maybe they don’t see it that

although maybe they don’t see it that

although maybe they don’t see it that way

way

way but the idea that the universe is a

but the idea that the universe is a

but the idea that the universe is a machine is not what science actually

machine is not what science actually

machine is not what science actually tells us if the universe were a machine

tells us if the universe were a machine

tells us if the universe were a machine then science would come up with simple

then science would come up with simple

then science would come up with simple formulas that describe everything even

formulas that describe everything even

formulas that describe everything even large complicated things but this isn’t

large complicated things but this isn’t

large complicated things but this isn’t what science finds what we find are

what science finds what we find are

what science finds what we find are enormous numbers of specialized

enormous numbers of specialized

enormous numbers of specialized descriptions of the various parts of the

descriptions of the various parts of the

descriptions of the various parts of the universe that aren’t simple we only find

universe that aren’t simple we only find

universe that aren’t simple we only find simple descriptions when we look at

simple descriptions when we look at

simple descriptions when we look at simple things and this is how we get

simple things and this is how we get

simple things and this is how we get things like Newton’s laws so to say it

things like Newton’s laws so to say it

things like Newton’s laws so to say it differently science shows that we can

differently science shows that we can

differently science shows that we can take the universe apart into pieces and

take the universe apart into pieces and

take the universe apart into pieces and describe the pieces but we can’t put the

describe the pieces but we can’t put the

describe the pieces but we can’t put the pieces back together into a simple

pieces back together into a simple

pieces back together into a simple understanding of what the universe is so

understanding of what the universe is so

understanding of what the universe is so science shows that the universe isn’t a

science shows that the universe isn’t a

science shows that the universe isn’t a machine but if the universe isn’t the

machine but if the universe isn’t the

machine but if the universe isn’t the machine and what is it so the house that

machine and what is it so the house that

machine and what is it so the house that I grew up in in Virginia had rain

I grew up in in Virginia had rain

I grew up in in Virginia had rain gutters and downspouts two concrete

gutters and downspouts two concrete

gutters and downspouts two concrete blocks on the ground that channelled

blocks on the ground that channelled

blocks on the ground that channelled water away from the house and when I was

water away from the house and when I was

water away from the house and when I was a kid I used to run around and turn over

a kid I used to run around and turn over

a kid I used to run around and turn over these concrete blocks to see what was

these concrete blocks to see what was

these concrete blocks to see what was underneath and I remembered this really

underneath and I remembered this really

underneath and I remembered this really well because there were all these bugs

well because there were all these bugs

well because there were all these bugs underneath there you know really

underneath there you know really

underneath there you know really weird-looking stuff like centipedes and

weird-looking stuff like centipedes and

weird-looking stuff like centipedes and pill bugs and more

pill bugs and more

pill bugs and more and their larvae and carcasses and I was

and their larvae and carcasses and I was

and their larvae and carcasses and I was always fascinated because the bugs were

always fascinated because the bugs were

always fascinated because the bugs were doing things and I thought how do they

doing things and I thought how do they

doing things and I thought how do they know what to do why are they there why

know what to do why are they there why

know what to do why are they there why is there a world under this concrete

is there a world under this concrete

is there a world under this concrete block and who could possibly care enough

block and who could possibly care enough

block and who could possibly care enough about them to create them and though I

about them to create them and though I

about them to create them and though I couldn’t really say so say why at the

couldn’t really say so say why at the

couldn’t really say so say why at the time you know these bugs under the mud

time you know these bugs under the mud

time you know these bugs under the mud in the mud really bugged me and and they

in the mud really bugged me and and they

in the mud really bugged me and and they they bugged me because I you know I came

they bugged me because I you know I came

they bugged me because I you know I came to understand that I feared that I might

to understand that I feared that I might

to understand that I feared that I might not be that much different right how did

not be that much different right how did

not be that much different right how did I come to exist how do I know what I how

I come to exist how do I know what I how

I come to exist how do I know what I how do I know what I know why do I do what I

do I know what I know why do I do what I

do I know what I know why do I do what I do and more recently as I dress the

do and more recently as I dress the

do and more recently as I dress the problems of you know can we build

problems of you know can we build

problems of you know can we build technologies that know about the world

technologies that know about the world

technologies that know about the world all by themselves the same questions

all by themselves the same questions

all by themselves the same questions come up right how should such a

come up right how should such a

come up right how should such a technology come to exist how should

technology come to exist how should

technology come to exist how should these technologies know what they know

these technologies know what they know

these technologies know what they know or know what to do so in a mechanistic

or know what to do so in a mechanistic

or know what to do so in a mechanistic universe the answers to these questions

universe the answers to these questions

universe the answers to these questions are simple but they’re not very

are simple but they’re not very

are simple but they’re not very satisfying you know the answer is that

satisfying you know the answer is that

satisfying you know the answer is that the Creator made it this way and this

the Creator made it this way and this

the Creator made it this way and this mechanistic universe is evidently

mechanistic universe is evidently

mechanistic universe is evidently incorrect both in our personal

incorrect both in our personal

incorrect both in our personal experience and sort of in the broad

experience and sort of in the broad

experience and sort of in the broad efforts of science but I think we cling

efforts of science but I think we cling

efforts of science but I think we cling to it nonetheless at least in part

to it nonetheless at least in part

to it nonetheless at least in part because we can’t explain how things come

because we can’t explain how things come

because we can’t explain how things come to exist so I would like to offer a non

to exist so I would like to offer a non

to exist so I would like to offer a non mechanistic anti supernatural

mechanistic anti supernatural

mechanistic anti supernatural evolutionary worldview of how things

evolutionary worldview of how things

evolutionary worldview of how things come to exist I propose that the

come to exist I propose that the

come to exist I propose that the universe is uncaused and complete in and

universe is uncaused and complete in and

universe is uncaused and complete in and of itself and that it began with a

of itself and that it began with a

of itself and that it began with a featureless singularity of pure

featureless singularity of pure

featureless singularity of pure potential a Big Bang I propose that the

potential a Big Bang I propose that the

potential a Big Bang I propose that the universe derives from the pouring out of

universe derives from the pouring out of

universe derives from the pouring out of this potential into the creation the

this potential into the creation the

this potential into the creation the evolution and the existence of

evolution and the existence of

evolution and the existence of everything in the universe I propose

everything in the universe I propose

everything in the universe I propose that this thermodynamic evolution is not

that this thermodynamic evolution is not

that this thermodynamic evolution is not a question of mechanization it’s a

a question of mechanization it’s a

a question of mechanization it’s a question of self-consistency I propose

question of self-consistency I propose

question of self-consistency I propose that causation the idea that one thing

that causation the idea that one thing

that causation the idea that one thing follows another in time is the result of

follows another in time is the result of

follows another in time is the result of evolution and not the other way around I

propose that the universe fits together

propose that the universe fits together because it derives from a common origin

because it derives from a common origin

because it derives from a common origin and evolves under a common principle I

and evolves under a common principle I

and evolves under a common principle I propose that every aspect of our lives

propose that every aspect of our lives

propose that every aspect of our lives reflects this thermodynamic evolution

reflects this thermodynamic evolution

reflects this thermodynamic evolution our birth our development our thinking

our birth our development our thinking

our birth our development our thinking our interaction with others our

our interaction with others our

our interaction with others our interaction with the environment our

interaction with the environment our

interaction with the environment our technologies our evolution as a species

technologies our evolution as a species

technologies our evolution as a species and our death so simply put I propose

and our death so simply put I propose

and our death so simply put I propose that existence derives from

that existence derives from

that existence derives from thermodynamic evolution now some of you

thermodynamic evolution now some of you

thermodynamic evolution now some of you may have heard of the second law of

may have heard of the second law of

may have heard of the second law of thermodynamics the idea that the entropy

thermodynamics the idea that the entropy

thermodynamics the idea that the entropy of the universe which has to do with the

of the universe which has to do with the

of the universe which has to do with the distribution and disorder of energy is

distribution and disorder of energy is

distribution and disorder of energy is always increasing so the idea of

always increasing so the idea of

always increasing so the idea of thermodynamic evolution is exactly this

thermodynamic evolution is exactly this

thermodynamic evolution is exactly this except it adds the requirement that an

except it adds the requirement that an

except it adds the requirement that an organization must emerge for that to

organization must emerge for that to

organization must emerge for that to happen so in everyday language though

happen so in everyday language though

happen so in everyday language though thermodynamic evolution is simply the

thermodynamic evolution is simply the

thermodynamic evolution is simply the idea that organizations spontaneously

idea that organizations spontaneously

idea that organizations spontaneously emerge in order to use energy in the

emerge in order to use energy in the

emerge in order to use energy in the environment for example so wood is a

environment for example so wood is a

environment for example so wood is a kind of concentrated chemical energy

kind of concentrated chemical energy

kind of concentrated chemical energy that when we burn it with oxygen

that when we burn it with oxygen

that when we burn it with oxygen releases heat broadly into the

releases heat broadly into the

releases heat broadly into the environment but in order for that to

environment but in order for that to

environment but in order for that to happen

happen

happen an organization has to emerge a fire in

an organization has to emerge a fire in

an organization has to emerge a fire in this case that connects the oxygen to

this case that connects the oxygen to

this case that connects the oxygen to the wood at high temperature now the

the wood at high temperature now the

the wood at high temperature now the oxygen and the wood don’t cause the fire

oxygen and the wood don’t cause the fire

oxygen and the wood don’t cause the fire in a mechanistic sense only in the sense

in a mechanistic sense only in the sense

in a mechanistic sense only in the sense that they create a thermodynamic

that they create a thermodynamic

that they create a thermodynamic such that a fire can emerge if the

such that a fire can emerge if the

such that a fire can emerge if the conditions are right as another example

conditions are right as another example

conditions are right as another example I am made up of atoms but the atoms of

I am made up of atoms but the atoms of

I am made up of atoms but the atoms of which I may don’t cause my existence

which I may don’t cause my existence

which I may don’t cause my existence energy in the environment in a complex

energy in the environment in a complex

energy in the environment in a complex process of thermodynamic evolution

process of thermodynamic evolution

process of thermodynamic evolution enable the atoms that are me to come

enable the atoms that are me to come

enable the atoms that are me to come together and the same can be said of

together and the same can be said of

together and the same can be said of human organizations like businesses so

human organizations like businesses so

human organizations like businesses so businesses are collections of people and

businesses are collections of people and

businesses are collections of people and assets but these people and assets

assets but these people and assets

assets but these people and assets aren’t a machine that causes the

aren’t a machine that causes the

aren’t a machine that causes the business to exist

business to exist

business to exist businesses evolve in a complex

businesses evolve in a complex

businesses evolve in a complex environment and extract energy from

environment and extract energy from

environment and extract energy from there from the environment to do that

now the reason that the people and the

now the reason that the people and the assets fit in the business the reason

assets fit in the business the reason

assets fit in the business the reason that the atoms in my body fit together

that the atoms in my body fit together

that the atoms in my body fit together the reason that trees fit within the

the reason that trees fit within the

the reason that trees fit within the forest is that they evolved together so

forest is that they evolved together so

forest is that they evolved together so things that don’t evolve together don’t

things that don’t evolve together don’t

things that don’t evolve together don’t fit together

fit together

fit together that’s where expressions like fish out

that’s where expressions like fish out

that’s where expressions like fish out of water come from so you would think we

of water come from so you would think we

of water come from so you would think we would have figured this out by now but

would have figured this out by now but

would have figured this out by now but we haven’t figured it out yet if I look

we haven’t figured it out yet if I look

we haven’t figured it out yet if I look back you know on my childhood you know

back you know on my childhood you know

back you know on my childhood you know the bugs and the mud I would say that

the bugs and the mud I would say that

the bugs and the mud I would say that you know no computer no phone no robot

you know no computer no phone no robot

you know no computer no phone no robot could survive under a concrete block or

could survive under a concrete block or

could survive under a concrete block or anywhere in the real world on its own

anywhere in the real world on its own

anywhere in the real world on its own the problem with our technologies today

the problem with our technologies today

the problem with our technologies today is that they can’t evolve to fit into

is that they can’t evolve to fit into

is that they can’t evolve to fit into their own environments they only evolve

their own environments they only evolve

their own environments they only evolve if we do it for them that’s why you get

if we do it for them that’s why you get

if we do it for them that’s why you get constant software updates on your phones

constant software updates on your phones

constant software updates on your phones and your computers so the net of all

and your computers so the net of all

and your computers so the net of all this is that if our machines are doing

this is that if our machines are doing

this is that if our machines are doing good or bad things for us today it’s our

good or bad things for us today it’s our

good or bad things for us today it’s our fault

fault

fault all right we’re the one doing the

all right we’re the one doing the

all right we’re the one doing the evolution for them I think however that

evolution for them I think however that

evolution for them I think however that were on the cusp of being able to build

were on the cusp of being able to build

were on the cusp of being able to build electronic systems that can evolve

so the interesting thing about

so the interesting thing about electronic systems today is that the

electronic systems today is that the

electronic systems today is that the basic elements things like transistors

basic elements things like transistors

basic elements things like transistors have important things in common with the

have important things in common with the

have important things in common with the basic elements of biochemistry things

basic elements of biochemistry things

basic elements of biochemistry things like proteins so transistors and

like proteins so transistors and

like proteins so transistors and proteins are roughly the same size they

proteins are roughly the same size they

proteins are roughly the same size they can both be configured to form complex

can both be configured to form complex

can both be configured to form complex networks and the energies and the

networks and the energies and the

networks and the energies and the temperatures that matter in the

temperatures that matter in the

temperatures that matter in the formation of those networks are

formation of those networks are

formation of those networks are comparable and for these reasons I think

comparable and for these reasons I think

comparable and for these reasons I think that we can build electronic systems

that we can build electronic systems

that we can build electronic systems that spontaneously evolved complex

that spontaneously evolved complex

that spontaneously evolved complex networks in response to electrical

networks in response to electrical

networks in response to electrical potentials in their environment now we

potentials in their environment now we

potentials in their environment now we don’t know how to do this yet and we’re

don’t know how to do this yet and we’re

don’t know how to do this yet and we’re really not even trying and I think the

really not even trying and I think the

really not even trying and I think the reason we’re not trying is we’re stuck

reason we’re not trying is we’re stuck

reason we’re not trying is we’re stuck with a largely unrecognized mechanistic

with a largely unrecognized mechanistic

with a largely unrecognized mechanistic world view that prevents us from knowing

world view that prevents us from knowing

world view that prevents us from knowing what it is we should try to do so what

what it is we should try to do so what

what it is we should try to do so what we do instead is we build bigger

we do instead is we build bigger

we do instead is we build bigger machines and we program them now someday

machines and we program them now someday

machines and we program them now someday we’re going to get this figured out

we’re going to get this figured out

we’re going to get this figured out though we are going to build systems I

though we are going to build systems I

though we are going to build systems I call these things thermodynamic

call these things thermodynamic

call these things thermodynamic computers by the way and someday we’re

computers by the way and someday we’re

computers by the way and someday we’re going to figure this out we’re going to

going to figure this out we’re going to

going to figure this out we’re going to figure out how to do this and we’re

figure out how to do this and we’re

figure out how to do this and we’re going to build technologies that aren’t

going to build technologies that aren’t

going to build technologies that aren’t machines that can evolve in the world on

machines that can evolve in the world on

machines that can evolve in the world on their own and when we do that they’re

their own and when we do that they’re

their own and when we do that they’re going to evil they’re going to grow up

going to evil they’re going to grow up

going to evil they’re going to grow up in environments that we curate they’re

in environments that we curate they’re

in environments that we curate they’re going to be more like our kids than our

going to be more like our kids than our

going to be more like our kids than our computers which should be interesting

computers which should be interesting

computers which should be interesting actually so it is actually maybe

actually so it is actually maybe

actually so it is actually maybe possible that they could learn enough

possible that they could learn enough

possible that they could learn enough about us of not learn enough about us to

about us of not learn enough about us to

about us of not learn enough about us to actually care for us as individuals and

actually care for us as individuals and

actually care for us as individuals and so perhaps this vision that Brautigan

so perhaps this vision that Brautigan

so perhaps this vision that Brautigan had five decades ago of technologies of

had five decades ago of technologies of

had five decades ago of technologies of loving grace is actually possible

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *