Press "Enter" to skip to content

History is alive and personal! | Clare Mulley | TEDxStormontWomen


I’m a biographer with a special interest

I’m a biographer with a special interest in women and war where there is a rich

in women and war where there is a rich

in women and war where there is a rich seam of untold stories but today I’m

seam of untold stories but today I’m

seam of untold stories but today I’m going to be asking the question how the

going to be asking the question how the

going to be asking the question how the past navigated through historical

past navigated through historical

past navigated through historical biography can service to know who we are

biography can service to know who we are

biography can service to know who we are so I’m going to start with the perhaps

so I’m going to start with the perhaps

so I’m going to start with the perhaps surprising statement that I don’t think

surprising statement that I don’t think

surprising statement that I don’t think history is the past I think history is

history is the past I think history is

history is the past I think history is our relationship with the past so I was

our relationship with the past so I was

our relationship with the past so I was delighted when earlier this year Hilary

delighted when earlier this year Hilary

delighted when earlier this year Hilary mantel the Booker prize-winning

mantel the Booker prize-winning

mantel the Booker prize-winning historical novelist said something

historical novelist said something

historical novelist said something similar in her wreath lecture

similar in her wreath lecture

similar in her wreath lecture she said history is no more the past

she said history is no more the past

she said history is no more the past than a birth certificate is a birth or a

than a birth certificate is a birth or a

than a birth certificate is a birth or a script is a performance or a map is a

script is a performance or a map is a

script is a performance or a map is a journey well I agree with that I think

journey well I agree with that I think

journey well I agree with that I think that’s beautiful and I think that

that’s beautiful and I think that

that’s beautiful and I think that perhaps history books are bridges to the

perhaps history books are bridges to the

perhaps history books are bridges to the past I write historical biography

past I write historical biography

past I write historical biography because I understand the world through

because I understand the world through

because I understand the world through people the past isn’t just something

people the past isn’t just something

people the past isn’t just something that happened out there we people make

that happened out there we people make

that happened out there we people make it happen and little takes you back more

it happen and little takes you back more

it happen and little takes you back more authentically through time than hearing

authentically through time than hearing

authentically through time than hearing the voices of people who didn’t know

the voices of people who didn’t know

the voices of people who didn’t know what was going to happen next and so if

what was going to happen next and so if

what was going to happen next and so if history books our bridges to the Past I

history books our bridges to the Past I

history books our bridges to the Past I like to think that historical

like to think that historical

like to think that historical biographies foot bridges to the path

biographies foot bridges to the path

biographies foot bridges to the path personal pathways to give us connections

personal pathways to give us connections

personal pathways to give us connections between past and present lives and

between past and present lives and

between past and present lives and crossing that footbridge you can look

crossing that footbridge you can look

crossing that footbridge you can look across to the past but you travel back

across to the past but you travel back

across to the past but you travel back as a tourist taking your baggage with

as a tourist taking your baggage with

as a tourist taking your baggage with you and you cannot interact with the

you and you cannot interact with the

you and you cannot interact with the people who are there although sometimes

people who are there although sometimes

people who are there although sometimes doing my research on my books I have had

doing my research on my books I have had

doing my research on my books I have had cause to question that when I was

cause to question that when I was

cause to question that when I was writing my second biography it’s about

writing my second biography it’s about

writing my second biography it’s about the life of Christina skarbek a Polish

the life of Christina skarbek a Polish

the life of Christina skarbek a Polish born countess who became the first woman

born countess who became the first woman

born countess who became the first woman to work for Britain as a special agent

to work for Britain as a special agent

to work for Britain as a special agent in the Second World War I was very lucky

in the Second World War I was very lucky

in the Second World War I was very lucky I got to go to Poland to look in the

I got to go to Poland to look in the

I got to go to Poland to look in the archives and I stayed in Warsaw in a

archives and I stayed in Warsaw in a

archives and I stayed in Warsaw in a beautiful apartment in the old town

beautiful apartment in the old town

beautiful apartment in the old town right on the old square belonging to the

right on the old square belonging to the

right on the old square belonging to the son of one of Christina’s lovers and

son of one of Christina’s lovers and

son of one of Christina’s lovers and he’s a Polish count and he said today in

he’s a Polish count and he said today in

he’s a Polish count and he said today in my lovely apartment so I came down in

my lovely apartment so I came down in

my lovely apartment so I came down in the morning and open the front door to

the morning and open the front door to

the morning and open the front door to go out and do my research and I saw an

go out and do my research and I saw an

go out and do my research and I saw an entire ver marked unit from the Second

entire ver marked unit from the Second

entire ver marked unit from the Second World War

World War

World War outside the front door I just thought

outside the front door I just thought

outside the front door I just thought well yeah that’s not right so I shut the

well yeah that’s not right so I shut the

well yeah that’s not right so I shut the door and I took a moment to calm myself

door and I took a moment to calm myself

door and I took a moment to calm myself and then I opened up again and

and then I opened up again and

and then I opened up again and unfortunately they were still there and

unfortunately they were still there and

unfortunately they were still there and now they were quite annoyed as well and

now they were quite annoyed as well and

now they were quite annoyed as well and this Nazi officer got off his motorbike

this Nazi officer got off his motorbike

this Nazi officer got off his motorbike and started running towards me and he

and started running towards me and he

and started running towards me and he was shouting and he had he had a

was shouting and he had he had a

was shouting and he had he had a handheld machine gun with a kind of

handheld machine gun with a kind of

handheld machine gun with a kind of perforated barrel at the end of it and

perforated barrel at the end of it and

perforated barrel at the end of it and he started jabbing it towards my neck at

he started jabbing it towards my neck at

he started jabbing it towards my neck at which point I was nearly in tears it’s

which point I was nearly in tears it’s

which point I was nearly in tears it’s pretty scary stuff and then my friend

pretty scary stuff and then my friend

pretty scary stuff and then my friend Matty egg who had come to translate for

Matty egg who had come to translate for

Matty egg who had come to translate for me came running around the corner he

me came running around the corner he

me came running around the corner he said I am so sorry Claire

said I am so sorry Claire

said I am so sorry Claire I didn’t realize last night when we

I didn’t realize last night when we

I didn’t realize last night when we arrived it was dark and I didn’t see

arrived it was dark and I didn’t see

arrived it was dark and I didn’t see this poster tacked on to the sides of

this poster tacked on to the sides of

this poster tacked on to the sides of the buildings it says please don’t come

the buildings it says please don’t come

the buildings it says please don’t come out of these flats between 8:00 and

out of these flats between 8:00 and

out of these flats between 8:00 and 10:00 in the morning was we’re filming

10:00 in the morning was we’re filming

10:00 in the morning was we’re filming for a world war two TV series and I come

for a world war two TV series and I come

for a world war two TV series and I come out right in the middle of it and ruin

out right in the middle of it and ruin

out right in the middle of it and ruin their take and that’s why they were

their take and that’s why they were

their take and that’s why they were quite cross

quite cross

quite cross and so I suppose because I was a

and so I suppose because I was a

and so I suppose because I was a biographer and I was there yearning to

biographer and I was there yearning to

biographer and I was there yearning to make a connection on my imagination had

make a connection on my imagination had

make a connection on my imagination had left back into the past and in fact on

left back into the past and in fact on

left back into the past and in fact on the carry the spy novelist has said the

the carry the spy novelist has said the

the carry the spy novelist has said the real bridge is imagination but of course

real bridge is imagination but of course

real bridge is imagination but of course I hadn’t really traveled back through

I hadn’t really traveled back through

I hadn’t really traveled back through time because as far as I’m aware you

time because as far as I’m aware you

time because as far as I’m aware you can’t do that and but I had made a real

can’t do that and but I had made a real

can’t do that and but I had made a real emotional connection

emotional connection

emotional connection so if historical biographies are bridges

so if historical biographies are bridges

so if historical biographies are bridges to the past or perhaps Windows I

to the past or perhaps Windows I

to the past or perhaps Windows I I also think they are mirrors to the

I also think they are mirrors to the

I also think they are mirrors to the past and they reflect the preoccupations

past and they reflect the preoccupations

past and they reflect the preoccupations perceptions of the people trying to look

perceptions of the people trying to look

perceptions of the people trying to look through them the British historian dr.

through them the British historian dr.

through them the British historian dr. David Starkey rightly argued in 2009 our

David Starkey rightly argued in 2009 our

David Starkey rightly argued in 2009 our new world has its own set of prejudices

new world has its own set of prejudices

new world has its own set of prejudices its set of distinct lenses and we need

its set of distinct lenses and we need

its set of distinct lenses and we need to be aware of them and I think that’s

to be aware of them and I think that’s

to be aware of them and I think that’s absolutely right but I wear glasses

absolutely right but I wear glasses

absolutely right but I wear glasses today I’m wearing contact lenses and I

today I’m wearing contact lenses and I

today I’m wearing contact lenses and I know that if you’re looking through a

know that if you’re looking through a

know that if you’re looking through a lens it’s actually very hard to see the

lens it’s actually very hard to see the

lens it’s actually very hard to see the glass

glass

glass so dr. Starkey continued to say if you

so dr. Starkey continued to say if you

so dr. Starkey continued to say if you were to do a proper history of Europe

were to do a proper history of Europe

were to do a proper history of Europe before the last five minutes it’s a

before the last five minutes it’s a

before the last five minutes it’s a history of white males because they were

history of white males because they were

history of white males because they were the power players and to pretend

the power players and to pretend

the power players and to pretend anything else is to falsify well this is

anything else is to falsify well this is

anything else is to falsify well this is where I disagree with dr. Starkey

where I disagree with dr. Starkey

where I disagree with dr. Starkey because I think a proper history is

because I think a proper history is

because I think a proper history is actually that whole rich tapestry of all

actually that whole rich tapestry of all

actually that whole rich tapestry of all the people that make up our past I think

the people that make up our past I think

the people that make up our past I think that dr. Starkey could only see other

that dr. Starkey could only see other

that dr. Starkey could only see other people’s other historians perspectives

people’s other historians perspectives

people’s other historians perspectives he couldn’t see his own so of course it

he couldn’t see his own so of course it

he couldn’t see his own so of course it is much harder to recognize your own

is much harder to recognize your own

is much harder to recognize your own perspectives and bias if I look back at

perspectives and bias if I look back at

perspectives and bias if I look back at photographs of myself in the 1980s I’m a

photographs of myself in the 1980s I’m a

photographs of myself in the 1980s I’m a punk I thought I was pretty cool I had

punk I thought I was pretty cool I had

punk I thought I was pretty cool I had long green hair made my own skirts

long green hair made my own skirts

long green hair made my own skirts sometimes walked out of them and now I

sometimes walked out of them and now I

sometimes walked out of them and now I look back and I think well what was I

look back and I think well what was I

look back and I think well what was I wearing what was I thinking I feel like

wearing what was I thinking I feel like

wearing what was I thinking I feel like you know much more confident today I

you know much more confident today I

you know much more confident today I mean I don’t I make better choices but

mean I don’t I make better choices but

mean I don’t I make better choices but of course in a few years time I’ll

of course in a few years time I’ll

of course in a few years time I’ll probably look back at the TED talk video

probably look back at the TED talk video

probably look back at the TED talk video and think yeah but why do I choose to

and think yeah but why do I choose to

and think yeah but why do I choose to wear that give my TED talk

wear that give my TED talk

wear that give my TED talk because fashions change and fashions

because fashions change and fashions

because fashions change and fashions change in the way that we look at the

change in the way that we look at the

change in the way that we look at the world as well we’ve had Marxist

world as well we’ve had Marxist

world as well we’ve had Marxist perspectives and Christian perspectives

perspectives and Christian perspectives

perspectives and Christian perspectives we’ve had several waves of feminist

we’ve had several waves of feminist

we’ve had several waves of feminist perspectives and today our views are

perspectives and today our views are

perspectives and today our views are informed by

informed by

informed by liberal ideologies or various different

liberal ideologies or various different

liberal ideologies or various different extreme isms in 2011 but then British

extreme isms in 2011 but then British

extreme isms in 2011 but then British Education Secretary Michael Gove said

Education Secretary Michael Gove said

Education Secretary Michael Gove said that history in schools ought to be

that history in schools ought to be

that history in schools ought to be taught to celebrate the distinguished

taught to celebrate the distinguished

taught to celebrate the distinguished role of these islands in the history of

role of these islands in the history of

role of these islands in the history of the world well I think that’s history as

the world well I think that’s history as

the world well I think that’s history as propaganda if you like he was trying to

propaganda if you like he was trying to

propaganda if you like he was trying to build a bridge forward through time to

build a bridge forward through time to

build a bridge forward through time to get his ideas solidified and there is

get his ideas solidified and there is

get his ideas solidified and there is nothing new about this Shakespeare was

nothing new about this Shakespeare was

nothing new about this Shakespeare was doing it when he was writing his

doing it when he was writing his

doing it when he was writing his historical plays in his day but in these

historical plays in his day but in these

historical plays in his day but in these days I think we need to be particularly

days I think we need to be particularly

days I think we need to be particularly wary when we have so much fake news

wary when we have so much fake news

wary when we have so much fake news which can easily solidify into plate

which can easily solidify into plate

which can easily solidify into plate history so we must be conscious of our

history so we must be conscious of our

history so we must be conscious of our and other people’s perspectives bias and

and other people’s perspectives bias and

and other people’s perspectives bias and prejudices but lenses if use carefully

prejudices but lenses if use carefully

prejudices but lenses if use carefully can be very useful to bring new insights

can be very useful to bring new insights

can be very useful to bring new insights to our understanding of history as well

to our understanding of history as well

to our understanding of history as well I’m a feminist I have often noticed

I’m a feminist I have often noticed

I’m a feminist I have often noticed writing about women and war that women

writing about women and war that women

writing about women and war that women in the resistance or female special

in the resistance or female special

in the resistance or female special agents are often written about in rather

agents are often written about in rather

agents are often written about in rather romantic terms they’re described as

romantic terms they’re described as

romantic terms they’re described as beautiful and selfless and a lot of

beautiful and selfless and a lot of

beautiful and selfless and a lot of attention is paid to their courage well

attention is paid to their courage well

attention is paid to their courage well they were courageous but they were also

they were courageous but they were also

they were courageous but they were also very competent they were very effective

very competent they were very effective

very competent they were very effective and this isn’t emphasized as much so you

and this isn’t emphasized as much so you

and this isn’t emphasized as much so you know you can be ugly or plain and

know you can be ugly or plain and

know you can be ugly or plain and courageous you can be female and

courageous you can be female and

courageous you can be female and effective Pristina skarbek who I

effective Pristina skarbek who I

effective Pristina skarbek who I mentioned before wasn’t just the first

mentioned before wasn’t just the first

mentioned before wasn’t just the first woman to work as a special agent for

woman to work as a special agent for

woman to work as a special agent for Britain in the war she was also the

Britain in the war she was also the

Britain in the war she was also the longest-serving

longest-serving

longest-serving among her many achievements she secured

among her many achievements she secured

among her many achievements she secured the defection of an entire German

the defection of an entire German

the defection of an entire German garrison on a strategic path in the Alps

garrison on a strategic path in the Alps

garrison on a strategic path in the Alps also saved the lives of many of her male

also saved the lives of many of her male

also saved the lives of many of her male colleagues now Christina worked for an

colleagues now Christina worked for an

colleagues now Christina worked for an organization called SOE

organization called SOE

organization called SOE which stood for the Special Operations

which stood for the Special Operations

which stood for the Special Operations Executive but she was so keen to serve

Executive but she was so keen to serve

Executive but she was so keen to serve that she volunteered early and she

that she volunteered early and she

that she volunteered early and she signed up with an organisation called

signed up with an organisation called

signed up with an organisation called section D before SOE was established now

section D before SOE was established now

section D before SOE was established now the D in Section D

the D in Section D

the D in Section D stands for destruction because they blew

stands for destruction because they blew

stands for destruction because they blew up a lot of bridges and Christina was

up a lot of bridges and Christina was

up a lot of bridges and Christina was involved in a lot of sabotage and it is

involved in a lot of sabotage and it is

involved in a lot of sabotage and it is very tempting here to take a leaf out of

very tempting here to take a leaf out of

very tempting here to take a leaf out of her book and think perhaps sometimes we

her book and think perhaps sometimes we

her book and think perhaps sometimes we need to destroy the old bridges

need to destroy the old bridges

need to destroy the old bridges including the old narrative bridges so

including the old narrative bridges so

including the old narrative bridges so that we can build better ones but

that we can build better ones but

that we can build better ones but actually I think the more bridges you

actually I think the more bridges you

actually I think the more bridges you have the more perspectives the better

have the more perspectives the better

have the more perspectives the better because we can learn something from

because we can learn something from

because we can learn something from everyone that is why we regularly need

everyone that is why we regularly need

everyone that is why we regularly need new biographies of the same subjects not

new biographies of the same subjects not

new biographies of the same subjects not just because we have new information but

just because we have new information but

just because we have new information but because we can bring new perspectives to

because we can bring new perspectives to

because we can bring new perspectives to bear so every generation needs their own

bear so every generation needs their own

bear so every generation needs their own Cleopatra or Elizabeth the first or

Cleopatra or Elizabeth the first or

Cleopatra or Elizabeth the first or Violette Szabo and every biography talks

Violette Szabo and every biography talks

Violette Szabo and every biography talks as much about the context in which it

as much about the context in which it

as much about the context in which it was written

was written

was written as it does about its subject in some

as it does about its subject in some

as it does about its subject in some sense then I’ve often thought of Bagram

sense then I’ve often thought of Bagram

sense then I’ve often thought of Bagram fees as being rather like fairy tales

fees as being rather like fairy tales

fees as being rather like fairy tales which is not to diminish them or say

which is not to diminish them or say

which is not to diminish them or say they’re childlike and in fact Albert

they’re childlike and in fact Albert

they’re childlike and in fact Albert Einstein said if you want your children

Einstein said if you want your children

Einstein said if you want your children to be intelligent read them fairy tales

to be intelligent read them fairy tales

to be intelligent read them fairy tales but not earn biographies and fairy tales

but not earn biographies and fairy tales

but not earn biographies and fairy tales do share certain traits a novelist when

do share certain traits a novelist when

do share certain traits a novelist when they write the book they they act as God

they write the book they they act as God

they write the book they they act as God if you like they create this entire

if you like they create this entire

if you like they create this entire fictional world and there is only one

fictional world and there is only one

fictional world and there is only one version of it their version nothing else

version of it their version nothing else

version of it their version nothing else happens outside of it but biographies

happens outside of it but biographies

happens outside of it but biographies like fairy tales are open to eternal

like fairy tales are open to eternal

like fairy tales are open to eternal retellings nobody owns that story and

retellings nobody owns that story and

retellings nobody owns that story and I’m certainly very suspicious if I hear

I’m certainly very suspicious if I hear

I’m certainly very suspicious if I hear a biographer say I’ve written the

a biographer say I’ve written the

a biographer say I’ve written the definitive biography of someone I

definitive biography of someone I

definitive biography of someone I immediately think well no um but

immediately think well no um but

immediately think well no um but biographies are also the opposite of

biographies are also the opposite of

biographies are also the opposite of fairy tales fairy tales are about

fairy tales fairy tales are about

fairy tales fairy tales are about archetypes the wicked witch the evil

archetypes the wicked witch the evil

archetypes the wicked witch the evil stepmother or the innocent child and by

stepmother or the innocent child and by

stepmother or the innocent child and by our biographies are fundamentally about

our biographies are fundamentally about

our biographies are fundamentally about real people with nuanced complex

real people with nuanced complex

real people with nuanced complex characters not types and in reading

characters not types and in reading

characters not types and in reading biographies we see not just the other

biographies we see not just the other

biographies we see not just the other that intrigues us the female special

that intrigues us the female special

that intrigues us the female special agent the Nazi female test pilot but

agent the Nazi female test pilot but

agent the Nazi female test pilot but also

also

also familiar that connects us when recently

familiar that connects us when recently

familiar that connects us when recently I saw a film a friend had produced

I saw a film a friend had produced

I saw a film a friend had produced called portrait of a soldier about the

called portrait of a soldier about the

called portrait of a soldier about the Warsaw Uprising and a female soldier in

Warsaw Uprising and a female soldier in

Warsaw Uprising and a female soldier in that battle called wonder tragic stuffs

that battle called wonder tragic stuffs

that battle called wonder tragic stuffs cur and I was interested to see this

cur and I was interested to see this

cur and I was interested to see this film because I wanted to know about that

film because I wanted to know about that

film because I wanted to know about that woman’s motivations I wanted to know

woman’s motivations I wanted to know

woman’s motivations I wanted to know about her her inner resources and I

about her her inner resources and I

about her her inner resources and I wanted to know about her actions and the

wanted to know about her actions and the

wanted to know about her actions and the achievements that made her such a

achievements that made her such a

achievements that made her such a heroine but what really struck me in

heroine but what really struck me in

heroine but what really struck me in that film was a little moment when she

that film was a little moment when she

that film was a little moment when she was speaking she said she was looking

was speaking she said she was looking

was speaking she said she was looking forward to getting given her codename

forward to getting given her codename

forward to getting given her codename because she’d always wanted to be called

because she’d always wanted to be called

because she’d always wanted to be called atma which in Polish means soul but they

atma which in Polish means soul but they

atma which in Polish means soul but they looked at her she was quite short and

looked at her she was quite short and

looked at her she was quite short and slightly round and they called her

slightly round and they called her

slightly round and they called her passion which means donut and

passion which means donut and

passion which means donut and immediately I felt a sense of connection

immediately I felt a sense of connection

immediately I felt a sense of connection with this woman it really brought her

with this woman it really brought her

with this woman it really brought her story to life for me so biographies can

story to life for me so biographies can

story to life for me so biographies can provide us with access to the past that

provide us with access to the past that

provide us with access to the past that can be at once different and

can be at once different and

can be at once different and recognizable and often evolving we

recognizable and often evolving we

recognizable and often evolving we cannot change the past but we can engage

cannot change the past but we can engage

cannot change the past but we can engage with it recently I saw an interview with

with it recently I saw an interview with

with it recently I saw an interview with a woman called Eva Moses Kaur

a woman called Eva Moses Kaur

a woman called Eva Moses Kaur she is a survivor from Auschwitz she

she is a survivor from Auschwitz she

she is a survivor from Auschwitz she entered auswitch

entered auswitch

entered auswitch with her family her identical twin

with her family her identical twin

with her family her identical twin sister Miriam and their parents and

sister Miriam and their parents and

sister Miriam and their parents and Miriam and Eva were immediately

Miriam and Eva were immediately

Miriam and Eva were immediately separated from the others they never saw

separated from the others they never saw

separated from the others they never saw their family again they were taken away

their family again they were taken away

their family again they were taken away and they were subjected to medical

and they were subjected to medical

and they were subjected to medical experimentation by the Nazi so called

experimentation by the Nazi so called

experimentation by the Nazi so called dr. Josef Mengele he injected both those

dr. Josef Mengele he injected both those

dr. Josef Mengele he injected both those girls they were 6 years old with clear

girls they were 6 years old with clear

girls they were 6 years old with clear liquids they never knew what they were

liquids they never knew what they were

liquids they never knew what they were and both of the girls became incredibly

and both of the girls became incredibly

and both of the girls became incredibly ill they were fortunate only in that the

ill they were fortunate only in that the

ill they were fortunate only in that the camp was liberated while they were still

camp was liberated while they were still

camp was liberated while they were still alive and both those girls survived the

alive and both those girls survived the

alive and both those girls survived the war decades later Eva was invited to

war decades later Eva was invited to

war decades later Eva was invited to take part in a television documentary

take part in a television documentary

take part in a television documentary about Auschwitz and while she was there

about Auschwitz and while she was there

about Auschwitz and while she was there she met another of the interviewees for

she met another of the interviewees for

she met another of the interviewees for this document

this document

this document three he was a former Nazi and he had

three he was a former Nazi and he had

three he was a former Nazi and he had been a so-called doctor at Auschwitz and

been a so-called doctor at Auschwitz and

been a so-called doctor at Auschwitz and how he meant to respond to him or she

how he meant to respond to him or she

how he meant to respond to him or she did something rather marvellous she

did something rather marvellous she

did something rather marvellous she invited him to go back to Auschwitz with

invited him to go back to Auschwitz with

invited him to go back to Auschwitz with her and there 50 years after the

her and there 50 years after the

her and there 50 years after the liberation of the camp she asked him to

liberation of the camp she asked him to

liberation of the camp she asked him to sign a witness statement saying what he

sign a witness statement saying what he

sign a witness statement saying what he had seen at the camp and then she said

had seen at the camp and then she said

had seen at the camp and then she said she had it in black and white and if she

she had it in black and white and if she

she had it in black and white and if she met a Holocaust denier which she still

met a Holocaust denier which she still

met a Holocaust denier which she still does incredibly she could say look I’ve

does incredibly she could say look I’ve

does incredibly she could say look I’ve got it a written statement so I thought

got it a written statement so I thought

got it a written statement so I thought that was pretty powerful but she went on

that was pretty powerful but she went on

that was pretty powerful but she went on from there she said for 50 years she had

from there she said for 50 years she had

from there she said for 50 years she had felt that she was a victim she had

felt that she was a victim she had

felt that she was a victim she had considered herself as being a victim in

considered herself as being a victim in

considered herself as being a victim in life but now she found she had a power

life but now she found she had a power

life but now she found she had a power she had the power to forgive and so she

she had the power to forgive and so she

she had the power to forgive and so she wrote jaws for herself personally a

wrote jaws for herself personally a

wrote jaws for herself personally a letter to that doctor so-called doctor

letter to that doctor so-called doctor

letter to that doctor so-called doctor she wrote him a letter of personal

she wrote him a letter of personal

she wrote him a letter of personal forgiveness

forgiveness

forgiveness she said we cannot change what happened

she said we cannot change what happened

she said we cannot change what happened that is the tragic part but we can

that is the tragic part but we can

that is the tragic part but we can change how we relate to it so I think we

change how we relate to it so I think we

change how we relate to it so I think we need to be more honest about our very

need to be more honest about our very

need to be more honest about our very subjective relationship with the past

subjective relationship with the past

subjective relationship with the past historical biographies provide very

historical biographies provide very

historical biographies provide very personal footbridges back through time

personal footbridges back through time

personal footbridges back through time and crossing these bridges we can learn

and crossing these bridges we can learn

and crossing these bridges we can learn about the past and we can engage with

about the past and we can engage with

about the past and we can engage with history in new ways most bridges span

history in new ways most bridges span

history in new ways most bridges span fixed points but historical biographies

fixed points but historical biographies

fixed points but historical biographies spend time so they’re sort of built on

spend time so they’re sort of built on

spend time so they’re sort of built on shifting sands and every history or

shifting sands and every history or

shifting sands and every history or biography every text has a context in

biography every text has a context in

biography every text has a context in which it was written and a different one

which it was written and a different one

which it was written and a different one in which it is read and understood

in which it is read and understood

in which it is read and understood history then our relationship with the

history then our relationship with the

history then our relationship with the past is not static it’s not something

past is not static it’s not something

past is not static it’s not something over and done with it’s alive and

over and done with it’s alive and

over and done with it’s alive and ever-changing

ever-changing

ever-changing and historical biographies serves us not

and historical biographies serves us not

and historical biographies serves us not just showing us past lives but in

just showing us past lives but in

just showing us past lives but in showing us how we look at the world who

showing us how we look at the world who

showing us how we look at the world who we are today

we are today

we are today and who we could be thank you very much

and who we could be thank you very much

and who we could be thank you very much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *