Press "Enter" to skip to content

Fighting Racism: What Law Has To Do? | Aleksandra Gliszczyńska–Grabias | TEDxCollegeofEuropeNatolin


um good afternoon everyone my name is

um good afternoon everyone my name is Alexandra

Alexandra

Alexandra and I confess I have borrowed or stolen

and I confess I have borrowed or stolen

and I confess I have borrowed or stolen the title of my speech from the great

the title of my speech from the great

the title of my speech from the great Tina Turner

Tina Turner

Tina Turner so it’s fighting racism what’s love got

so it’s fighting racism what’s love got

so it’s fighting racism what’s love got to do with it so when we think of the

to do with it so when we think of the

to do with it so when we think of the history of the world and humankind we

history of the world and humankind we

history of the world and humankind we come across phenomenon that are so

come across phenomenon that are so

come across phenomenon that are so closely linked to human suffering and

closely linked to human suffering and

closely linked to human suffering and that are there with us since agents

that are there with us since agents

that are there with us since agents since forever so these are Wars war

since forever so these are Wars war

since forever so these are Wars war crimes genocide crimes against humanity

crimes genocide crimes against humanity

crimes genocide crimes against humanity hunger cruel treatment of humans by

hunger cruel treatment of humans by

hunger cruel treatment of humans by humans torture and also racism becomes

humans torture and also racism becomes

humans torture and also racism becomes one of this phenomenon racism and one of

one of this phenomenon racism and one of

one of this phenomenon racism and one of its particular forms which is

its particular forms which is

its particular forms which is anti-semitism that is being called the

anti-semitism that is being called the

anti-semitism that is being called the longest hatred and some ten years ago I

longest hatred and some ten years ago I

longest hatred and some ten years ago I decided to combine my legal expertise to

decided to combine my legal expertise to

decided to combine my legal expertise to combine my education and my passion for

combine my education and my passion for

combine my education and my passion for Human Rights and to start fighting

Human Rights and to start fighting

Human Rights and to start fighting against racism with the tools of law I

against racism with the tools of law I

against racism with the tools of law I guess any talk on braving the impossible

guess any talk on braving the impossible

guess any talk on braving the impossible shouldn’t start with a depressing or

shouldn’t start with a depressing or

shouldn’t start with a depressing or discouraging statement but unfortunately

discouraging statement but unfortunately

discouraging statement but unfortunately here it is racism anti-semitism

here it is racism anti-semitism

here it is racism anti-semitism xenophobia will never be defeated or

xenophobia will never be defeated or

xenophobia will never be defeated or eliminated fully the fight against them

eliminated fully the fight against them

eliminated fully the fight against them is more like Don Quixote fight against

is more like Don Quixote fight against

is more like Don Quixote fight against windmills so you can only try but I

windmills so you can only try but I

windmills so you can only try but I would like to tell you today why I still

would like to tell you today why I still

would like to tell you today why I still believe this is the fight worth taking

believe this is the fight worth taking

believe this is the fight worth taking all efforts and commitment for me it all

all efforts and commitment for me it all

all efforts and commitment for me it all started when I first met professor Alvin

started when I first met professor Alvin

started when I first met professor Alvin Rosenfeld a world-class expert in

Rosenfeld a world-class expert in

Rosenfeld a world-class expert in Holocaust literature at one of the

Holocaust literature at one of the

Holocaust literature at one of the academic conferences and he said that

academic conferences and he said that

academic conferences and he said that when he looked at me and he listened to

when he looked at me and he listened to

when he looked at me and he listened to me he saw a deep compassion for the Jews

me he saw a deep compassion for the Jews

me he saw a deep compassion for the Jews that perished during the Holocaust and a

that perished during the Holocaust and a

that perished during the Holocaust and a sense of core responsibility for what

sense of core responsibility for what

sense of core responsibility for what had happened to them and this was true I

had happened to them and this was true I

had happened to them and this was true I have always felt this way but it just

have always felt this way but it just

have always felt this way but it just struck me that someone else could also

struck me that someone else could also

struck me that someone else could also notice this

notice this

notice this and some months later I attended the

and some months later I attended the

and some months later I attended the lecture given by a Harvard professor

lecture given by a Harvard professor

lecture given by a Harvard professor root visa and the lecture was entitled

root visa and the lecture was entitled

root visa and the lecture was entitled what are we going to do with

what are we going to do with

what are we going to do with anti-semitism no seriously what and the

anti-semitism no seriously what and the

anti-semitism no seriously what and the way professor visa spoke about fighting

way professor visa spoke about fighting

way professor visa spoke about fighting anti-semitism how passionate she was

anti-semitism how passionate she was

anti-semitism how passionate she was about it was so enlightening and

about it was so enlightening and

about it was so enlightening and inspiring for me in so many regards and

inspiring for me in so many regards and

inspiring for me in so many regards and today I’m sure that both professor

today I’m sure that both professor

today I’m sure that both professor visioned professor Rosa Rosenfeld

visioned professor Rosa Rosenfeld

visioned professor Rosa Rosenfeld inspired me and gave me courage to turn

inspired me and gave me courage to turn

inspired me and gave me courage to turn the inner sorrow and pain that I truly

the inner sorrow and pain that I truly

the inner sorrow and pain that I truly felt into action against the evil that

felt into action against the evil that

felt into action against the evil that caused his feelings and so I decided to

caused his feelings and so I decided to

caused his feelings and so I decided to combine this growing urge to do

combine this growing urge to do

combine this growing urge to do something about it to do something about

something about it to do something about

something about it to do something about anti-semitism racism with my legal

anti-semitism racism with my legal

anti-semitism racism with my legal background and since then I have been

background and since then I have been

background and since then I have been trying to break the impossible but now

trying to break the impossible but now

trying to break the impossible but now comes the controversial part that

comes the controversial part that

comes the controversial part that everyone is waiting for the law doesn’t

everyone is waiting for the law doesn’t

everyone is waiting for the law doesn’t work I mean the law doesn’t work the way

work I mean the law doesn’t work the way

work I mean the law doesn’t work the way it should when it comes to the phenomena

it should when it comes to the phenomena

it should when it comes to the phenomena that are so closely linked to human

that are so closely linked to human

that are so closely linked to human feelings because you can force someone

feelings because you can force someone

feelings because you can force someone to stop stealing with the tools of law

to stop stealing with the tools of law

to stop stealing with the tools of law but you are not able to stop someone

but you are not able to stop someone

but you are not able to stop someone from hating another person because of

from hating another person because of

from hating another person because of that person’s color of the skin religion

that person’s color of the skin religion

that person’s color of the skin religion or national or ethnic origin this is

or national or ethnic origin this is

or national or ethnic origin this is much more complicated and demanding but

much more complicated and demanding but

much more complicated and demanding but we shouldn’t give up I truly believe in

we shouldn’t give up I truly believe in

we shouldn’t give up I truly believe in the social responsibility of law and if

the social responsibility of law and if

the social responsibility of law and if we agree that the system of legal norms

we agree that the system of legal norms

we agree that the system of legal norms and in particularly this part of the

and in particularly this part of the

and in particularly this part of the system that belongs to the body of

system that belongs to the body of

system that belongs to the body of criminal law has been established as a

criminal law has been established as a

criminal law has been established as a kind of demarcation line between this

kind of demarcation line between this

kind of demarcation line between this what is acceptable and this what is not

what is acceptable and this what is not

what is acceptable and this what is not acceptable and condemned in a given

acceptable and condemned in a given

acceptable and condemned in a given society or community then I argued that

society or community then I argued that

society or community then I argued that racism should be punished and condemned

racism should be punished and condemned

racism should be punished and condemned on an equal footing as stealing reckless

on an equal footing as stealing reckless

on an equal footing as stealing reckless driving or or fraud

driving or or fraud

driving or or fraud what is more I perceive racism as much

what is more I perceive racism as much

what is more I perceive racism as much more socially harmful than many other

more socially harmful than many other

more socially harmful than many other crimes that are traditionally being

crimes that are traditionally being

crimes that are traditionally being included in criminal codes

included in criminal codes

included in criminal codes second I think that there must be limits

second I think that there must be limits

second I think that there must be limits to free speech no genocide in the modern

to free speech no genocide in the modern

to free speech no genocide in the modern history of the world would have been

history of the world would have been

history of the world would have been possible without being preceded by

possible without being preceded by

possible without being preceded by hateful words and of course Nazi

hateful words and of course Nazi

hateful words and of course Nazi anti-semitic propaganda is just a

anti-semitic propaganda is just a

anti-semitic propaganda is just a classic well-known example here but they

classic well-known example here but they

classic well-known example here but they also think about Rwanda about genocide

also think about Rwanda about genocide

also think about Rwanda about genocide and war crimes that took place during

and war crimes that took place during

and war crimes that took place during Balkan war where the hatred has been

Balkan war where the hatred has been

Balkan war where the hatred has been there has been spread for years before

there has been spread for years before

there has been spread for years before the actual killing started I also negate

the actual killing started I also negate

the actual killing started I also negate the concept of free marketplace of ideas

the concept of free marketplace of ideas

the concept of free marketplace of ideas were all are free to express themselves

were all are free to express themselves

were all are free to express themselves freely even the most hateful manner and

freely even the most hateful manner and

freely even the most hateful manner and their ideas compete in a way and the

their ideas compete in a way and the

their ideas compete in a way and the winning idea is the one that gains the

winning idea is the one that gains the

winning idea is the one that gains the largest support of the listeners I

largest support of the listeners I

largest support of the listeners I simply don’t believe that haters in this

simply don’t believe that haters in this

simply don’t believe that haters in this case racists and their victims are

case racists and their victims are

case racists and their victims are equals in this kind of competition all

equals in this kind of competition all

equals in this kind of competition all research results clearly proof that

research results clearly proof that

research results clearly proof that those targeted by hateful speech racist

those targeted by hateful speech racist

those targeted by hateful speech racist hateful speech are more likely to stay

hateful speech are more likely to stay

hateful speech are more likely to stay quiet to suffer in silence just in order

quiet to suffer in silence just in order

quiet to suffer in silence just in order to avoid further attacks they are

to avoid further attacks they are

to avoid further attacks they are vulnerable they don’t fight back and

vulnerable they don’t fight back and

vulnerable they don’t fight back and this is crucially important to help them

this is crucially important to help them

this is crucially important to help them so for me racism anti-semitism

so for me racism anti-semitism

so for me racism anti-semitism xenophobia Islamophobia homophobia these

xenophobia Islamophobia homophobia these

xenophobia Islamophobia homophobia these are not ideas or views they are all

are not ideas or views they are all

are not ideas or views they are all hatred and I don’t discuss with haters

hatred and I don’t discuss with haters

hatred and I don’t discuss with haters third facing and fighting racism demands

third facing and fighting racism demands

third facing and fighting racism demands being radical sometimes as Elie Wiesel a

being radical sometimes as Elie Wiesel a

being radical sometimes as Elie Wiesel a great writer and Holocaust survivor and

great writer and Holocaust survivor and

great writer and Holocaust survivor and the peace Nobel Prize winner said we

the peace Nobel Prize winner said we

the peace Nobel Prize winner said we must take sides neutrality helps the

must take sides neutrality helps the

must take sides neutrality helps the oppressor never the victim and you can’t

oppressor never the victim and you can’t

oppressor never the victim and you can’t compromise here so you are not on good

compromise here so you are not on good

compromise here so you are not on good terms with colleagues who claim that

terms with colleagues who claim that

terms with colleagues who claim that upper tide headed good side – and you

upper tide headed good side – and you

upper tide headed good side – and you don’t perceive Holocaust denial it’s

don’t perceive Holocaust denial it’s

don’t perceive Holocaust denial it’s just another opinion of someone who

just another opinion of someone who

just another opinion of someone who claims that the Jews invented the great

claims that the Jews invented the great

claims that the Jews invented the great lie of gas chambers and you don’t laugh

lie of gas chambers and you don’t laugh

lie of gas chambers and you don’t laugh at

at

at even slightly racist jokes and you get

even slightly racist jokes and you get

even slightly racist jokes and you get out of a taxi

out of a taxi

out of a taxi even if already very late for work if a

even if already very late for work if a

even if already very late for work if a driver makes taxi driver makes a

driver makes taxi driver makes a

driver makes taxi driver makes a homophobic remark and then immediately

homophobic remark and then immediately

homophobic remark and then immediately you call the taxi company to complain

you call the taxi company to complain

you call the taxi company to complain it seems obvious and easy but it’s not

it seems obvious and easy but it’s not

it seems obvious and easy but it’s not it’s demanding it’s even stressful

it’s demanding it’s even stressful

it’s demanding it’s even stressful because you need to be constantly aware

because you need to be constantly aware

because you need to be constantly aware and constantly ready and willing to

and constantly ready and willing to

and constantly ready and willing to fight back to respond but it’s worth the

fight back to respond but it’s worth the

fight back to respond but it’s worth the effort really it is so maybe something

effort really it is so maybe something

effort really it is so maybe something positive now so what are the benefits of

positive now so what are the benefits of

positive now so what are the benefits of fighting racism I’m a lawyer and in line

fighting racism I’m a lawyer and in line

fighting racism I’m a lawyer and in line with all unfair exaggerated stereotypes

with all unfair exaggerated stereotypes

with all unfair exaggerated stereotypes associated with this profession I’m

associated with this profession I’m

associated with this profession I’m really interested in gaining as much as

really interested in gaining as much as

really interested in gaining as much as possible and winning the cases so what

possible and winning the cases so what

possible and winning the cases so what do we gain by fighting racism I will

do we gain by fighting racism I will

do we gain by fighting racism I will claim that we gain actually everything

claim that we gain actually everything

claim that we gain actually everything that really matters because first we

that really matters because first we

that really matters because first we help the victims of human rights

help the victims of human rights

help the victims of human rights violations second we prove that human

violations second we prove that human

violations second we prove that human solidarity really exists and third maybe

solidarity really exists and third maybe

solidarity really exists and third maybe most importantly we protect ourselves

most importantly we protect ourselves

most importantly we protect ourselves and the societies we live in from the

and the societies we live in from the

and the societies we live in from the keynesian plaque of hatred that poisons

keynesian plaque of hatred that poisons

keynesian plaque of hatred that poisons Souls hearts and minds and by standing

Souls hearts and minds and by standing

Souls hearts and minds and by standing firm against racism we also respond to

firm against racism we also respond to

firm against racism we also respond to the powerful call of never again that

the powerful call of never again that

the powerful call of never again that referred to the Holocaust but has never

referred to the Holocaust but has never

referred to the Holocaust but has never been fulfilled and so we are saving the

been fulfilled and so we are saving the

been fulfilled and so we are saving the world I know it sounds pretentious but I

world I know it sounds pretentious but I

world I know it sounds pretentious but I really believe it’s true so if I were to

really believe it’s true so if I were to

really believe it’s true so if I were to advise anyone on how to try because it’s

advise anyone on how to try because it’s

advise anyone on how to try because it’s just possible to try to brave the

just possible to try to brave the

just possible to try to brave the impossible in case of fighting racism

impossible in case of fighting racism

impossible in case of fighting racism this is what I would list as the most

this is what I would list as the most

this is what I would list as the most important things first

important things first

important things first be aware know the history and know

be aware know the history and know

be aware know the history and know current developments so this way you

current developments so this way you

current developments so this way you will be able to fight racism not only

will be able to fight racism not only

will be able to fight racism not only because you feel it’s right to do so but

because you feel it’s right to do so but

because you feel it’s right to do so but also because you will know how

also because you will know how

also because you will know how devastating its consequences are its

devastating its consequences are its

devastating its consequences are its social moral legal consequences our

social moral legal consequences our

social moral legal consequences our second be careful with those who

second be careful with those who

second be careful with those who I’m definitely not a racist not a

I’m definitely not a racist not a

I’m definitely not a racist not a homophobe not an anti-semite god forbid

homophobe not an anti-semite god forbid

homophobe not an anti-semite god forbid but there is no place for commas here

but there is no place for commas here

but there is no place for commas here just a full stop I’m not a racist full

just a full stop I’m not a racist full

just a full stop I’m not a racist full stop then react always react to quote

stop then react always react to quote

stop then react always react to quote Elie Wiesel once again indifference is

Elie Wiesel once again indifference is

Elie Wiesel once again indifference is the epitome of evil and this is very

the epitome of evil and this is very

the epitome of evil and this is very simple just imagine for a second you are

simple just imagine for a second you are

simple just imagine for a second you are a target of hatred just because the

a target of hatred just because the

a target of hatred just because the color of your skin and there is

color of your skin and there is

color of your skin and there is absolutely no one to stand by your side

absolutely no one to stand by your side

absolutely no one to stand by your side to help you

to help you

to help you this just demands human action I think

this just demands human action I think

this just demands human action I think we all burn this moral obligation to act

we all burn this moral obligation to act

we all burn this moral obligation to act and help in such situations and for me

and help in such situations and for me

and help in such situations and for me this obligation just doubles or triples

this obligation just doubles or triples

this obligation just doubles or triples even for lawyers then know the law and

even for lawyers then know the law and

even for lawyers then know the law and how and when to use it we tend to think

how and when to use it we tend to think

how and when to use it we tend to think that legal actions legal steps are

that legal actions legal steps are

that legal actions legal steps are reserved for true or serious crimes only

reserved for true or serious crimes only

reserved for true or serious crimes only but at least in the European system of

but at least in the European system of

but at least in the European system of human rights protections there are laws

human rights protections there are laws

human rights protections there are laws against hate speech racist hate speech

against hate speech racist hate speech

against hate speech racist hate speech racist hate crimes so in the situation

racist hate crimes so in the situation

racist hate crimes so in the situation that someone disseminates in public

that someone disseminates in public

that someone disseminates in public booklets with the theories of the hero

booklets with the theories of the hero

booklets with the theories of the hero he of racists or pictures ethnic

he of racists or pictures ethnic

he of racists or pictures ethnic minorities as subhumans the law demands

minorities as subhumans the law demands

minorities as subhumans the law demands action then be engaged know that there

action then be engaged know that there

action then be engaged know that there are hundreds of NGOs wonderful NGOs

are hundreds of NGOs wonderful NGOs

are hundreds of NGOs wonderful NGOs acting against racism try to help them

acting against racism try to help them

acting against racism try to help them maybe just by signing their petitions it

maybe just by signing their petitions it

maybe just by signing their petitions it really means a lot it’s crucial and

really means a lot it’s crucial and

really means a lot it’s crucial and lastly become passionate I more and more

lastly become passionate I more and more

lastly become passionate I more and more often come to the conclusion that what

often come to the conclusion that what

often come to the conclusion that what really matters is compassion and if you

really matters is compassion and if you

really matters is compassion and if you will feel this way towards another

will feel this way towards another

will feel this way towards another person towards the victim of human

person towards the victim of human

person towards the victim of human rights violations then you will never be

rights violations then you will never be

rights violations then you will never be hesitating to act thank you very much

hesitating to act thank you very much

hesitating to act thank you very much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *