Press "Enter" to skip to content

Expendable People | Julie Dostal | TEDxOneonta


so as I thought about this idea worth

so as I thought about this idea worth spreading that I decided to talk about

spreading that I decided to talk about

spreading that I decided to talk about today I came up with several different

today I came up with several different

today I came up with several different titles along the way one was addiction

titles along the way one was addiction

titles along the way one was addiction for sale the other was I’m not my

for sale the other was I’m not my

for sale the other was I’m not my brother’s keeper and the other was harm

brother’s keeper and the other was harm

brother’s keeper and the other was harm for hire and I just had to stop with

for hire and I just had to stop with

for hire and I just had to stop with that one because it sounded like a bad

that one because it sounded like a bad

that one because it sounded like a bad James Bond movie so when I really got

James Bond movie so when I really got

James Bond movie so when I really got down to it what I wanted to talk about

down to it what I wanted to talk about

down to it what I wanted to talk about and what I do want to talk about is

and what I do want to talk about is

and what I do want to talk about is expendable people you see when we use a

expendable people you see when we use a

expendable people you see when we use a known addictive substance to generate

known addictive substance to generate

known addictive substance to generate revenue or as an economic development

revenue or as an economic development

revenue or as an economic development strategy we also make a decision that

strategy we also make a decision that

strategy we also make a decision that there must be expendable people and how

there must be expendable people and how

there must be expendable people and how can I say that well what we know is when

can I say that well what we know is when

can I say that well what we know is when there’s more alcohol we have more car

there’s more alcohol we have more car

there’s more alcohol we have more car crashes higher healthcare costs and more

crashes higher healthcare costs and more

crashes higher healthcare costs and more domestic violence when we have more

domestic violence when we have more

domestic violence when we have more marijuana we have more youth who use

marijuana we have more youth who use

marijuana we have more youth who use more workplace injuries and more people

more workplace injuries and more people

more workplace injuries and more people who drive while intoxicated and when we

who drive while intoxicated and when we

who drive while intoxicated and when we have more opioids we have a higher

have more opioids we have a higher

have more opioids we have a higher addiction rate we have more people who

addiction rate we have more people who

addiction rate we have more people who die from overdose and we have a higher

die from overdose and we have a higher

die from overdose and we have a higher crime rate just ask any policeman these

crime rate just ask any policeman these

crime rate just ask any policeman these are the kinds of things that those of us

are the kinds of things that those of us

are the kinds of things that those of us who work in public health talk about all

who work in public health talk about all

who work in public health talk about all the time and today I would like to take

the time and today I would like to take

the time and today I would like to take us on a little meander through my little

us on a little meander through my little

us on a little meander through my little corner of public health while I try

corner of public health while I try

corner of public health while I try really hard to not be the most annoying

really hard to not be the most annoying

really hard to not be the most annoying kind of fun police

the best way to describe it is this when

the best way to describe it is this when we have more of a known addictive

we have more of a known addictive

we have more of a known addictive substance that’s potentially harmful

substance that’s potentially harmful

substance that’s potentially harmful inject it into the marketplace more

inject it into the marketplace more

inject it into the marketplace more people are going to buy it that’s the

people are going to buy it that’s the

people are going to buy it that’s the point right more people are going to

point right more people are going to

point right more people are going to consume it and then more people are

consume it and then more people are

consume it and then more people are going to experience harm that’s an

going to experience harm that’s an

going to experience harm that’s an equation that we had tried to grow out

equation that we had tried to grow out

equation that we had tried to grow out of through millennia we try to evolve

of through millennia we try to evolve

of through millennia we try to evolve out of it we’ve tried to become more

out of it we’ve tried to become more

out of it we’ve tried to become more enlightened but it really is just an

enlightened but it really is just an

enlightened but it really is just an equation that can’t change more of a

equation that can’t change more of a

equation that can’t change more of a harmful thing equals more harm and when

harmful thing equals more harm and when

harmful thing equals more harm and when I talk about harmful substance

I talk about harmful substance

I talk about harmful substance substances I think that most people

substances I think that most people

substances I think that most people would probably expect me to talk about

would probably expect me to talk about

would probably expect me to talk about the opioid crisis that we’re in the

the opioid crisis that we’re in the

the opioid crisis that we’re in the midst of that wouldn’t be a bad

midst of that wouldn’t be a bad

midst of that wouldn’t be a bad expectation the last time that we got

expectation the last time that we got

expectation the last time that we got numbers was about two weeks ago it was

numbers was about two weeks ago it was

numbers was about two weeks ago it was for 2016 for this further from the

for 2016 for this further from the

for 2016 for this further from the Centers for Disease Control and they

Centers for Disease Control and they

Centers for Disease Control and they report that 64 thousand people died in

report that 64 thousand people died in

report that 64 thousand people died in 2016 from drug overdose sixty-four

2016 from drug overdose sixty-four

2016 from drug overdose sixty-four thousand people let that sink in for me

thousand people let that sink in for me

thousand people let that sink in for me that becomes real when I think about my

that becomes real when I think about my

that becomes real when I think about my County that’s about the size of my

County that’s about the size of my

County that’s about the size of my County and a little more it’s like

County and a little more it’s like

County and a little more it’s like someone took a bomb dropped it in the

someone took a bomb dropped it in the

someone took a bomb dropped it in the middle of the county and wiped out the

middle of the county and wiped out the

middle of the county and wiped out the population and then some around the

population and then some around the

population and then some around the edges

edges

edges we’re losing far too many precious

we’re losing far too many precious

we’re losing far too many precious precious people what most folks don’t

precious people what most folks don’t

precious people what most folks don’t know is that alcohol kills more from the

know is that alcohol kills more from the

know is that alcohol kills more from the same Centers for Disease Control we find

same Centers for Disease Control we find

same Centers for Disease Control we find that 88 thousand people die every year

that 88 thousand people die every year

that 88 thousand people die every year from alcohol-related causes

that’s 88,000 people who what just made

that’s 88,000 people who what just made bad choices I don’t think so

bad choices I don’t think so

bad choices I don’t think so I think it might be because we have all

I think it might be because we have all

I think it might be because we have all collectively been sold a fantasy that

collectively been sold a fantasy that

collectively been sold a fantasy that harm related to alcohol only comes to

harm related to alcohol only comes to

harm related to alcohol only comes to those who can’t or won’t drink

those who can’t or won’t drink

those who can’t or won’t drink responsibly and with that in mind I want

responsibly and with that in mind I want

responsibly and with that in mind I want to talk about one specific alcohol

to talk about one specific alcohol

to talk about one specific alcohol related harm that doesn’t require

related harm that doesn’t require

related harm that doesn’t require over-the-top drinking and that’s female

over-the-top drinking and that’s female

over-the-top drinking and that’s female breast cancer the researchers from the

breast cancer the researchers from the

breast cancer the researchers from the Boston University School of Medicine

Boston University School of Medicine

Boston University School of Medicine took a look at this issue and what they

took a look at this issue and what they

took a look at this issue and what they found was that every year 6000 women die

found was that every year 6000 women die

found was that every year 6000 women die from alcohol-related breast cancer

from alcohol-related breast cancer

from alcohol-related breast cancer alcohol attributed breast cancer 6000

alcohol attributed breast cancer 6000

alcohol attributed breast cancer 6000 women who have probably never been told

women who have probably never been told

women who have probably never been told that there is no known safe amount of

that there is no known safe amount of

that there is no known safe amount of alcohol for females you see alcohol is a

alcohol for females you see alcohol is a

alcohol for females you see alcohol is a group 1 carcinogen that means that it is

group 1 carcinogen that means that it is

group 1 carcinogen that means that it is a known human carcinogen not that it

a known human carcinogen not that it

a known human carcinogen not that it might be not that it could be not that

might be not that it could be not that

might be not that it could be not that it possibly is but it is known to cause

it possibly is but it is known to cause

it possibly is but it is known to cause cancer in humans 7 different kinds of

cancer in humans 7 different kinds of

cancer in humans 7 different kinds of cancer to be specific it’s one of the

cancer to be specific it’s one of the

cancer to be specific it’s one of the most preventable causes of breast cancer

most preventable causes of breast cancer

most preventable causes of breast cancer that we’re aware of

and who talks about prevention who talks

and who talks about prevention who talks to women about prevention as it relates

to women about prevention as it relates

to women about prevention as it relates to alcohol we’re really good in our

to alcohol we’re really good in our

to alcohol we’re really good in our country we’re really good at talking

country we’re really good at talking

country we’re really good at talking about screening early identification

about screening early identification

about screening early identification we’re good at talking about treatment

we’re good at talking about treatment

we’re good at talking about treatment we’re good at talking about cure but why

we’re good at talking about cure but why

we’re good at talking about cure but why don’t we talk about prevention could it

don’t we talk about prevention could it

don’t we talk about prevention could it be that if we did alcohol sales might go

be that if we did alcohol sales might go

be that if we did alcohol sales might go down could it be that if we did it might

down could it be that if we did it might

down could it be that if we did it might expose the companies that make alcohol

expose the companies that make alcohol

expose the companies that make alcohol as companies that see women as

as companies that see women as

as companies that see women as expendable people ladies I hope that

expendable people ladies I hope that

expendable people ladies I hope that your inner feminist will rise to meet me

your inner feminist will rise to meet me

your inner feminist will rise to meet me in this moment and gentlemen if you have

in this moment and gentlemen if you have

in this moment and gentlemen if you have a mom a sister a wife a grandmother an

a mom a sister a wife a grandmother an

a mom a sister a wife a grandmother an aunt a woman that you love you can get

aunt a woman that you love you can get

aunt a woman that you love you can get your feminist on too because what I want

your feminist on too because what I want

your feminist on too because what I want you to know is that the companies that

you to know is that the companies that

you to know is that the companies that make alcohol probably know the research

make alcohol probably know the research

make alcohol probably know the research better than I do they know that there is

better than I do they know that there is

better than I do they know that there is no known safe amount of alcohol for

no known safe amount of alcohol for

no known safe amount of alcohol for female breast tissue and yet we have

female breast tissue and yet we have

female breast tissue and yet we have hard pink lemonade to raise money for

hard pink lemonade to raise money for

hard pink lemonade to raise money for alcohol research we have hard pink cider

alcohol research we have hard pink cider

alcohol research we have hard pink cider that was developed to support the

that was developed to support the

that was developed to support the survivors of breast cancer we have beer

survivors of breast cancer we have beer

survivors of breast cancer we have beer in a really special piece

in a really special piece

in a really special piece can to bring about breast cancer

can to bring about breast cancer

can to bring about breast cancer awareness and during the month of

awareness and during the month of

awareness and during the month of October it’s coming we have countless

October it’s coming we have countless

October it’s coming we have countless pink your drink specials to raise

pink your drink specials to raise

pink your drink specials to raise awareness for breast cancer during

awareness for breast cancer during

awareness for breast cancer during Breast Cancer Awareness Month how is it

Breast Cancer Awareness Month how is it

Breast Cancer Awareness Month how is it then in our culture we accept a company

then in our culture we accept a company

then in our culture we accept a company who makes a cancer-causing product using

who makes a cancer-causing product using

who makes a cancer-causing product using that product to raise money for the

that product to raise money for the

that product to raise money for the victims of the cancer it causes I mean

victims of the cancer it causes I mean

victims of the cancer it causes I mean would we would we support a smoked in

would we would we support a smoked in

would we would we support a smoked in for lung cancer let me move that just a

for lung cancer let me move that just a

for lung cancer let me move that just a bit would we support a bake sale for

bit would we support a bake sale for

bit would we support a bake sale for diabetes

diabetes

diabetes let me move way outside the box would we

let me move way outside the box would we

let me move way outside the box would we support a pig roast for PETA I don’t

support a pig roast for PETA I don’t

support a pig roast for PETA I don’t think so

think so

think so I think there might be pickets and

I think there might be pickets and

I think there might be pickets and protests and letters to the editor and

protests and letters to the editor and

protests and letters to the editor and we would stop it now I get it

we would stop it now I get it

we would stop it now I get it alcohol is lucrative it has a very high

alcohol is lucrative it has a very high

alcohol is lucrative it has a very high profit margin and I want to say right

profit margin and I want to say right

profit margin and I want to say right here and right now that most people who

here and right now that most people who

here and right now that most people who buy a product to support a cause do so

buy a product to support a cause do so

buy a product to support a cause do so with the very best of intentions

with the very best of intentions

with the very best of intentions most people who fundraise using the

most people who fundraise using the

most people who fundraise using the product do so with the very best of

product do so with the very best of

product do so with the very best of intentions there is no disparaging here

intentions there is no disparaging here

intentions there is no disparaging here but when we look under the covers just a

but when we look under the covers just a

but when we look under the covers just a little bit we find corporations who use

little bit we find corporations who use

little bit we find corporations who use the product for revenue and we find

the product for revenue and we find

the product for revenue and we find governments who use the product for an

governments who use the product for an

governments who use the product for an for economic development straight

for economic development straight

for economic development straight jeez who know that those strategies and

jeez who know that those strategies and

jeez who know that those strategies and that revenue puts a significant portion

that revenue puts a significant portion

that revenue puts a significant portion of our population at risk now we have

of our population at risk now we have

of our population at risk now we have this conversation in our culture all the

this conversation in our culture all the

this conversation in our culture all the time and we should about the balance

time and we should about the balance

time and we should about the balance between personal rights and public

between personal rights and public

between personal rights and public health I mean who’s to tell you that you

health I mean who’s to tell you that you

health I mean who’s to tell you that you shouldn’t be able to drink the drink of

shouldn’t be able to drink the drink of

shouldn’t be able to drink the drink of your choice because it’s overshadowed by

your choice because it’s overshadowed by

your choice because it’s overshadowed by the harm that it might cause another

the harm that it might cause another

the harm that it might cause another person I’m here to tell you that it

person I’m here to tell you that it

person I’m here to tell you that it shouldn’t I think you should be able to

shouldn’t I think you should be able to

shouldn’t I think you should be able to drink whatever you want to drink see I’m

drink whatever you want to drink see I’m

drink whatever you want to drink see I’m not the fun police I think the bigger

not the fun police I think the bigger

not the fun police I think the bigger question is this should we support a

question is this should we support a

question is this should we support a revenue generating product or an

revenue generating product or an

revenue generating product or an economic development strategy if it puts

economic development strategy if it puts

economic development strategy if it puts a certain population at risk I think not

a certain population at risk I think not

a certain population at risk I think not supporting those things is different

supporting those things is different

supporting those things is different than taking someone’s right away so how

than taking someone’s right away so how

than taking someone’s right away so how do we tip our culture to become a

do we tip our culture to become a

do we tip our culture to become a society that rejects the need for

society that rejects the need for

society that rejects the need for expendable people I have a couple of

expendable people I have a couple of

expendable people I have a couple of ideas first require that all public

ideas first require that all public

ideas first require that all public policy and all public funding pass the

policy and all public funding pass the

policy and all public funding pass the public health test it really has become

public health test it really has become

public health test it really has become all the rage to use gambling alcohol

all the rage to use gambling alcohol

all the rage to use gambling alcohol marijuana as an economic development

marijuana as an economic development

marijuana as an economic development strategy it’s not too much to ask of our

strategy it’s not too much to ask of our

strategy it’s not too much to ask of our leaders that they look at all of the

leaders that they look at all of the

leaders that they look at all of the potential outcomes for those strategies

potential outcomes for those strategies

potential outcomes for those strategies and what we need to know is if a

and what we need to know is if a

and what we need to know is if a strategy puts a

strategy puts a

strategy puts a certain segments of our population at

certain segments of our population at

certain segments of our population at risk does the good so far outweigh the

risk does the good so far outweigh the

risk does the good so far outweigh the potential harm that it’s worth the risk

potential harm that it’s worth the risk

potential harm that it’s worth the risk that’s the public health test ii be

that’s the public health test ii be

that’s the public health test ii be aware of those fundraising strategies

aware of those fundraising strategies

aware of those fundraising strategies that make you scratch your head I have a

that make you scratch your head I have a

that make you scratch your head I have a few in mind I’m not going to give you

few in mind I’m not going to give you

few in mind I’m not going to give you the names I’m just gonna tell you about

the names I’m just gonna tell you about

the names I’m just gonna tell you about them they’re real because I want to

them they’re real because I want to

them they’re real because I want to protect the well-intended so how about a

protect the well-intended so how about a

protect the well-intended so how about a bar crawl to support mental health how

bar crawl to support mental health how

bar crawl to support mental health how about a wine-tasting to support girls

about a wine-tasting to support girls

about a wine-tasting to support girls fitness and how about a christmas-themed

fitness and how about a christmas-themed

fitness and how about a christmas-themed bar crawl to raise money for domestic

bar crawl to raise money for domestic

bar crawl to raise money for domestic violence yeah they’re real and what do

violence yeah they’re real and what do

violence yeah they’re real and what do you do if a fundraiser makes you scratch

you do if a fundraiser makes you scratch

you do if a fundraiser makes you scratch your head well you can use your awesome

your head well you can use your awesome

your head well you can use your awesome power of persuasion to talk to the

power of persuasion to talk to the

power of persuasion to talk to the people who develop the fundraiser and

people who develop the fundraiser and

people who develop the fundraiser and see if you can’t move them from using a

see if you can’t move them from using a

see if you can’t move them from using a product that might harm the population

product that might harm the population

product that might harm the population they hope to help to some other kind of

they hope to help to some other kind of

they hope to help to some other kind of fundraising and if active activism boy

fundraising and if active activism boy

fundraising and if active activism boy that’s redundant isn’t your thing if

that’s redundant isn’t your thing if

that’s redundant isn’t your thing if that’s not the way that you roll I get

that’s not the way that you roll I get

that’s not the way that you roll I get it then you can simply write a check to

it then you can simply write a check to

it then you can simply write a check to your favorite charity where your money

your favorite charity where your money

your favorite charity where your money will go further anyway and finally how

will go further anyway and finally how

will go further anyway and finally how do we become a culture that rejects the

do we become a culture that rejects the

do we become a culture that rejects the need for expendable people

be compassionate toward those that are

be compassionate toward those that are most vulnerable to the harm one of my

most vulnerable to the harm one of my

most vulnerable to the harm one of my favorite sayings when it’s what I’m

favorite sayings when it’s what I’m

favorite sayings when it’s what I’m talking about this topic is from Laurie

talking about this topic is from Laurie

talking about this topic is from Laurie Lieber and it says holding young people

Lieber and it says holding young people

Lieber and it says holding young people responsible for underage drinking is

responsible for underage drinking is

responsible for underage drinking is like blaming fish for dying in the

like blaming fish for dying in the

like blaming fish for dying in the polluted stream and shouldn’t we feel

polluted stream and shouldn’t we feel

polluted stream and shouldn’t we feel that way about everyone I mean if we’re

that way about everyone I mean if we’re

that way about everyone I mean if we’re going to pollute our environment with

going to pollute our environment with

going to pollute our environment with known addictive substances shouldn’t we

known addictive substances shouldn’t we

known addictive substances shouldn’t we show compassion toward those that

show compassion toward those that

show compassion toward those that succumb to the harm I would posit to you

succumb to the harm I would posit to you

succumb to the harm I would posit to you that people who find themselves in the

that people who find themselves in the

that people who find themselves in the expendable pile never intended to be

expendable pile never intended to be

expendable pile never intended to be there I know this because I was an

there I know this because I was an

there I know this because I was an expendable person I grew up in a family

expendable person I grew up in a family

expendable person I grew up in a family that was riddled with alcoholism and I

that was riddled with alcoholism and I

that was riddled with alcoholism and I had no way of knowing the impact that it

had no way of knowing the impact that it

had no way of knowing the impact that it was going to have on my life but at 25

was going to have on my life but at 25

was going to have on my life but at 25 years sober

years sober

years sober I get it

I do I get it my drinking and the

I do I get it my drinking and the drinking of those around me had

drinking of those around me had

drinking of those around me had far-reaching implications for my life

far-reaching implications for my life

far-reaching implications for my life and in my mid 20s I was a fully addicted

and in my mid 20s I was a fully addicted

and in my mid 20s I was a fully addicted human being there is no shame in being

human being there is no shame in being

human being there is no shame in being vulnerable I can’t tell you how many

vulnerable I can’t tell you how many

vulnerable I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard that the people who

times I’ve heard that the people who

times I’ve heard that the people who experience harm associated with alcohol

experience harm associated with alcohol

experience harm associated with alcohol and other drugs do so by choice and they

and other drugs do so by choice and they

and other drugs do so by choice and they get what they deserve my answer to that

get what they deserve my answer to that

get what they deserve my answer to that is most vulnerability to harm happens

is most vulnerability to harm happens

is most vulnerability to harm happens either genetically or in childhood long

either genetically or in childhood long

either genetically or in childhood long before an adult choice comes into play

we have the opportunity to make a few

we have the opportunity to make a few small changes that are relatively

small changes that are relatively

small changes that are relatively painless to us in order to protect the

painless to us in order to protect the

painless to us in order to protect the most vulnerable and we must do it

most vulnerable and we must do it

most vulnerable and we must do it together we have the opportunity to be

together we have the opportunity to be

together we have the opportunity to be life savers and we have the opportunity

life savers and we have the opportunity

life savers and we have the opportunity to move people from the expendable

to move people from the expendable

to move people from the expendable column to the you matter column and who

column to the you matter column and who

column to the you matter column and who among us doesn’t want to matter thank

among us doesn’t want to matter thank

among us doesn’t want to matter thank you

you

you you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *