Press "Enter" to skip to content

Top 10 Worst Book-to-Film Adaptations


you see my clothes away hearing that

you see my clothes away hearing that your favorite book is being turned into

your favorite book is being turned into

your favorite book is being turned into a movie can either be the best news in

a movie can either be the best news in

a movie can either be the best news in the world or the worst more often than

the world or the worst more often than

the world or the worst more often than not it’s the latter welcome to

not it’s the latter welcome to

not it’s the latter welcome to watchmojo.com and today we’re counting

watchmojo.com and today we’re counting

watchmojo.com and today we’re counting down our picks for the top 10 worst book

down our picks for the top 10 worst book

down our picks for the top 10 worst book to film adaptations for this list we

to film adaptations for this list we

to film adaptations for this list we focused on critically acclaimed or fan

focused on critically acclaimed or fan

focused on critically acclaimed or fan favorite books that were adapted to the

favorite books that were adapted to the

favorite books that were adapted to the screen in order to capitalize on their

screen in order to capitalize on their

screen in order to capitalize on their success but which resulted in

success but which resulted in

success but which resulted in disappointing or flat-out bad movies

disappointing or flat-out bad movies

disappointing or flat-out bad movies we’ve excluded Stephenie Meyer’s

we’ve excluded Stephenie Meyer’s

we’ve excluded Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight and similar entries that we

Twilight and similar entries that we

Twilight and similar entries that we didn’t actually expect to be any good

didn’t actually expect to be any good

didn’t actually expect to be any good like I care you know number 10

like I care you know number 10

like I care you know number 10 Gulliver’s Travels more kissing

Gulliver’s Travels more kissing

Gulliver’s Travels more kissing published in 1726 by Jonathan Swift this

published in 1726 by Jonathan Swift this

published in 1726 by Jonathan Swift this novel is a parody of society’s rules in

novel is a parody of society’s rules in

novel is a parody of society’s rules in the popular travel writing genre and it

the popular travel writing genre and it

the popular travel writing genre and it became an instant classic this movie not

became an instant classic this movie not

became an instant classic this movie not so much

so much

so much oh no diamonds Payne casting Jack Black

oh no diamonds Payne casting Jack Black

oh no diamonds Payne casting Jack Black as a lead is always a gamble and this

as a lead is always a gamble and this

as a lead is always a gamble and this time it didn’t pay off

black relied on potty humor and 3d

black relied on potty humor and 3d effects to carry the movie instead of

effects to carry the movie instead of

effects to carry the movie instead of being a tongue-in-cheek jab at society

being a tongue-in-cheek jab at society

being a tongue-in-cheek jab at society like the book the 2010 film left

like the book the 2010 film left

like the book the 2010 film left audiences feeling like the joke was

audiences feeling like the joke was

audiences feeling like the joke was being played on them Wow yeah what is it

being played on them Wow yeah what is it

being played on them Wow yeah what is it good for say it again go number 9 the

good for say it again go number 9 the

good for say it again go number 9 the Time Traveler’s Wife

Time Traveler’s Wife

Time Traveler’s Wife I have fits I disappear travel through

I have fits I disappear travel through

I have fits I disappear travel through time this was Audrey kniffen Eggers

time this was Audrey kniffen Eggers

time this was Audrey kniffen Eggers debut novel about a time traveler who

debut novel about a time traveler who

debut novel about a time traveler who involuntarily jumps around in time where

involuntarily jumps around in time where

involuntarily jumps around in time where he meets his future wife at different

he meets his future wife at different

he meets his future wife at different points in her life previa from the

points in her life previa from the

points in her life previa from the future as you can imagine the book is

future as you can imagine the book is

future as you can imagine the book is complex heartbreaking and woven with

complex heartbreaking and woven with

complex heartbreaking and woven with rich language and metaphors but the

rich language and metaphors but the

rich language and metaphors but the on-screen version falls flat pity

on-screen version falls flat pity

on-screen version falls flat pity is our one shared enthusiasm the movie

is our one shared enthusiasm the movie

is our one shared enthusiasm the movie manages to leave out many of the books

manages to leave out many of the books

manages to leave out many of the books smaller interesting characters and it’s

smaller interesting characters and it’s

smaller interesting characters and it’s a confusing watch for those who haven’t

a confusing watch for those who haven’t

a confusing watch for those who haven’t read the novel but hey at least the

read the novel but hey at least the

read the novel but hey at least the leads are attractive

number eight Captain Corelli’s Mandolin

number eight Captain Corelli’s Mandolin we refuse to surrender to a nation that

we refuse to surrender to a nation that

we refuse to surrender to a nation that we have defeated in Albania so fuck off

we have defeated in Albania so fuck off

we have defeated in Albania so fuck off not known for a skill with accents

not known for a skill with accents

not known for a skill with accents Nicolas Cage isn’t the most obvious

Nicolas Cage isn’t the most obvious

Nicolas Cage isn’t the most obvious choice to portray a Greek speaking

choice to portray a Greek speaking

choice to portray a Greek speaking Italian soldier but here we are I was

Italian soldier but here we are I was

Italian soldier but here we are I was just about to start Louie de bellas book

just about to start Louie de bellas book

just about to start Louie de bellas book is a sweeping romance and historical

is a sweeping romance and historical

is a sweeping romance and historical tale of a Greek island that’s under

tale of a Greek island that’s under

tale of a Greek island that’s under occupation by the Italians and Germans

occupation by the Italians and Germans

occupation by the Italians and Germans in World War two while the

in World War two while the

in World War two while the cinematography in the film is beautiful

cinematography in the film is beautiful

cinematography in the film is beautiful the movie fails to explain the history

the movie fails to explain the history

the movie fails to explain the history correctly and the attraction between

correctly and the attraction between

correctly and the attraction between cage and Penelope Cruz just isn’t there

also that accent

also that accent captain Antonio Corelli 32 the German

captain Antonio Corelli 32 the German

captain Antonio Corelli 32 the German artillery reporting for duty is

artillery reporting for duty is

artillery reporting for duty is everything I dope do you know number

everything I dope do you know number

everything I dope do you know number seven the bonfire of the vanities

seven the bonfire of the vanities

seven the bonfire of the vanities another one I do father you’ll have an

another one I do father you’ll have an

another one I do father you’ll have an unacceptable situation right up your ass

unacceptable situation right up your ass

unacceptable situation right up your ass Tom Wolfe is one of the 20th century’s

Tom Wolfe is one of the 20th century’s

Tom Wolfe is one of the 20th century’s most celebrated American writers but

most celebrated American writers but

most celebrated American writers but this movie isn’t a calling card for his

this movie isn’t a calling card for his

this movie isn’t a calling card for his work it has its funny side but it it

work it has its funny side but it it

work it has its funny side but it it isn’t fun with a-list actors cast and

isn’t fun with a-list actors cast and

isn’t fun with a-list actors cast and Brian De Palma directing Wolf’s story of

Brian De Palma directing Wolf’s story of

Brian De Palma directing Wolf’s story of greed race and politics should have been

greed race and politics should have been

greed race and politics should have been a success but it was a major major flop

a success but it was a major major flop

a success but it was a major major flop I mean is that the best you can do

I mean is that the best you can do

I mean is that the best you can do the film sanitized the intensity and

the film sanitized the intensity and

the film sanitized the intensity and grittiness of the novel and focused too

grittiness of the novel and focused too

grittiness of the novel and focused too much on making the characters more

much on making the characters more

much on making the characters more likable let me let me explain something

likable let me let me explain something

likable let me let me explain something to you

to you

to you recently Morgan Freeman stated that this

recently Morgan Freeman stated that this

recently Morgan Freeman stated that this movie was the one major nightmare of his

movie was the one major nightmare of his

movie was the one major nightmare of his career

career

career ouch I think when I was in jail pissing

ouch I think when I was in jail pissing

ouch I think when I was in jail pissing my pants

my pants

my pants number six The Scarlet Letter Julia

number six The Scarlet Letter Julia

number six The Scarlet Letter Julia Carey a bastard child in your womb many

Carey a bastard child in your womb many

Carey a bastard child in your womb many high school curricula now include

high school curricula now include

high school curricula now include Nathaniel Hawthorne’s classic tale of

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s classic tale of

Nathaniel Hawthorne’s classic tale of double standards and intolerance if you

double standards and intolerance if you

double standards and intolerance if you do not speak out the name you must wear

do not speak out the name you must wear

do not speak out the name you must wear upon your bodice this symbol

upon your bodice this symbol

upon your bodice this symbol simple fornication but it’s 1995 movie

simple fornication but it’s 1995 movie

simple fornication but it’s 1995 movie adaptation is far from a must-see this

adaptation is far from a must-see this

adaptation is far from a must-see this version is a prime example of what

version is a prime example of what

version is a prime example of what happens when Hollywood tries to make

happens when Hollywood tries to make

happens when Hollywood tries to make source material sexier I look forward to

source material sexier I look forward to

source material sexier I look forward to the hard work governor as we read in

the hard work governor as we read in

the hard work governor as we read in Psalms 92 I will triumph in Oh what’s

Psalms 92 I will triumph in Oh what’s

Psalms 92 I will triumph in Oh what’s with thy hands it’s pretty tough to take

with thy hands it’s pretty tough to take

with thy hands it’s pretty tough to take to me more seriously as a Puritan woman

to me more seriously as a Puritan woman

to me more seriously as a Puritan woman but audiences biggest quarrel with the

but audiences biggest quarrel with the

but audiences biggest quarrel with the film was its dramatically altered ending

no wonder it holds a 14 percent on

no wonder it holds a 14 percent on Rotten Tomatoes

number five the League of Extraordinary

number five the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen not a good cell how can we

Gentlemen not a good cell how can we

Gentlemen not a good cell how can we outrun this Alan Moore is pretty much

outrun this Alan Moore is pretty much

outrun this Alan Moore is pretty much the god of graphic novels so it isn’t a

the god of graphic novels so it isn’t a

the god of graphic novels so it isn’t a surprise that he distanced himself from

surprise that he distanced himself from

surprise that he distanced himself from this weak adaptation anymore like me and

this weak adaptation anymore like me and

this weak adaptation anymore like me and I’ll lose the franchise his graphic

I’ll lose the franchise his graphic

I’ll lose the franchise his graphic novel tells the story of a group of

novel tells the story of a group of

novel tells the story of a group of exceptional people who come together to

exceptional people who come together to

exceptional people who come together to defend the British Empire while the

defend the British Empire while the

defend the British Empire while the movie is merely a grouping of random

movie is merely a grouping of random

movie is merely a grouping of random action sequences I walk a different path

action sequences I walk a different path

action sequences I walk a different path the screen adaptation lacks any real

the screen adaptation lacks any real

the screen adaptation lacks any real character development and its

character development and its

character development and its credibility suffered as a result

credibility suffered as a result

credibility suffered as a result not even Sean Connery could save this

not even Sean Connery could save this

not even Sean Connery could save this one that I know Nigel has done a grand

one that I know Nigel has done a grand

one that I know Nigel has done a grand job reminding me well you look first

job reminding me well you look first

job reminding me well you look first number four Eragon when the plot

number four Eragon when the plot

number four Eragon when the plot revolves around a boy who learns to tame

revolves around a boy who learns to tame

revolves around a boy who learns to tame dragons

it should be easy to create movie magic

it should be easy to create movie magic it’s not right but something was lost in

it’s not right but something was lost in

it’s not right but something was lost in translation between page and screen

translation between page and screen

translation between page and screen there were complications yes so I’ve

there were complications yes so I’ve

there were complications yes so I’ve heard

heard

heard with it’s iffy pacing the film

with it’s iffy pacing the film

with it’s iffy pacing the film adaptation of the Christopher Paolini

adaptation of the Christopher Paolini

adaptation of the Christopher Paolini novel lags on with no direction often

novel lags on with no direction often

novel lags on with no direction often giving the impression it’s trying to be

giving the impression it’s trying to be

giving the impression it’s trying to be the next Lord of the Rings franchise

the next Lord of the Rings franchise

the next Lord of the Rings franchise bump off rave epochs fool

bump off rave epochs fool

bump off rave epochs fool unfortunately for Eragon however it

unfortunately for Eragon however it

unfortunately for Eragon however it lacks the intimate relationships of JRR

lacks the intimate relationships of JRR

lacks the intimate relationships of JRR tolkien series and brings nothing new to

tolkien series and brings nothing new to

tolkien series and brings nothing new to the screen number three The Cat in the

the screen number three The Cat in the

the screen number three The Cat in the Hat

this is one of the most beloved

this is one of the most beloved children’s classics ever but let’s face

children’s classics ever but let’s face

children’s classics ever but let’s face it there’s not much of a story there dr.

it there’s not much of a story there dr.

it there’s not much of a story there dr. Seuss’s book is full of his trademark

Seuss’s book is full of his trademark

Seuss’s book is full of his trademark illustrations and rhymes

illustrations and rhymes

illustrations and rhymes I got nothing I’m not so good with the

I got nothing I’m not so good with the

I got nothing I’m not so good with the rhyming not really no the film on the

rhyming not really no the film on the

rhyming not really no the film on the other hand fills in the stories blanks

other hand fills in the stories blanks

other hand fills in the stories blanks by making up some ridiculous plot points

by making up some ridiculous plot points

by making up some ridiculous plot points and adding potty humor and sexual

and adding potty humor and sexual

and adding potty humor and sexual innuendo into a children’s story between

innuendo into a children’s story between

innuendo into a children’s story between this and How the Grinch Stole Christmas

this and How the Grinch Stole Christmas

this and How the Grinch Stole Christmas Seuss’s widow vowed there would be no

Seuss’s widow vowed there would be no

Seuss’s widow vowed there would be no more live-action adaptations of his work

more live-action adaptations of his work

more live-action adaptations of his work I don’t like you either

I don’t like you either

I don’t like you either number two the Golden Compass there are

number two the Golden Compass there are

number two the Golden Compass there are some things that we best ignore subjects

some things that we best ignore subjects

some things that we best ignore subjects that you why didn’t have a speak about

that you why didn’t have a speak about

that you why didn’t have a speak about what made this children’s series so good

what made this children’s series so good

what made this children’s series so good was the fact that author Philip Pullman

was the fact that author Philip Pullman

was the fact that author Philip Pullman trusted the intelligence of his audience

trusted the intelligence of his audience

trusted the intelligence of his audience that is the truth his book is a

that is the truth his book is a

that is the truth his book is a fantastical epic about a girl growing up

fantastical epic about a girl growing up

fantastical epic about a girl growing up in a world where free will is suppressed

in a world where free will is suppressed

in a world where free will is suppressed though the source material had strong

though the source material had strong

though the source material had strong anti religious undertones the film

anti religious undertones the film

anti religious undertones the film glosses over its complexities to avoid

glosses over its complexities to avoid

glosses over its complexities to avoid upsetting viewers resulting in an action

upsetting viewers resulting in an action

upsetting viewers resulting in an action film with no story and tons of special

film with no story and tons of special

film with no story and tons of special effects the effects were the film’s only

effects the effects were the film’s only

effects the effects were the film’s only high point winning it an Oscar and a

high point winning it an Oscar and a

high point winning it an Oscar and a BAFTA

before we uncover our number one pick

before we uncover our number one pick here are a few honorable mentions surely

here are a few honorable mentions surely

here are a few honorable mentions surely such a travesty has never occurred what

such a travesty has never occurred what

such a travesty has never occurred what a wee but don’t load off the hands God

a wee but don’t load off the hands God

a wee but don’t load off the hands God Almighty you and me and George

Almighty you and me and George

Almighty you and me and George Washington do you have a boyfriend oh I

Washington do you have a boyfriend oh I

Washington do you have a boyfriend oh I know it see I knew you weren’t like

know it see I knew you weren’t like

know it see I knew you weren’t like those other girls

those other girls

those other girls what does say fat people Bronx treasure

number one dune I know sometimes a books

number one dune I know sometimes a books plot is just too complex to be turned

plot is just too complex to be turned

plot is just too complex to be turned into a feature and that was the case

into a feature and that was the case

into a feature and that was the case with this Frank Herbert adaptation

with this Frank Herbert adaptation

with this Frank Herbert adaptation you’ve done a very good job his book is

you’ve done a very good job his book is

you’ve done a very good job his book is a sci-fi classic that tells the story of

a sci-fi classic that tells the story of

a sci-fi classic that tells the story of a young man whose fate is to free his

a young man whose fate is to free his

a young man whose fate is to free his people from the evil house Harkonnen

people from the evil house Harkonnen

people from the evil house Harkonnen family a lot of the key points are there

family a lot of the key points are there

family a lot of the key points are there but David Lynch’s movie version is hard

but David Lynch’s movie version is hard

but David Lynch’s movie version is hard to follow and became a box-office bomb

to follow and became a box-office bomb

to follow and became a box-office bomb not earning back its 40 million dollar

not earning back its 40 million dollar

not earning back its 40 million dollar budget

do you agree with our list yeah which

do you agree with our list yeah which adaptation disappointed you the most for

adaptation disappointed you the most for

adaptation disappointed you the most for more fan approved top 10s published

more fan approved top 10s published

more fan approved top 10s published daily be sure to subscribe to

daily be sure to subscribe to

daily be sure to subscribe to watchmojo.com I just want your extra

watchmojo.com I just want your extra

watchmojo.com I just want your extra time and you can

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *