Press "Enter" to skip to content

Top 10 Critically Acclaimed Video Games That Were Commercial Failures


it’s always a shame when good games

it’s always a shame when good games don’t get there – all right who’s ready

don’t get there – all right who’s ready

don’t get there – all right who’s ready to rock and roll

to rock and roll

to rock and roll welcome to watchmojo.com and today we’ll

welcome to watchmojo.com and today we’ll

welcome to watchmojo.com and today we’ll be counting down our picks for the top

be counting down our picks for the top

be counting down our picks for the top ten critically acclaimed video games

ten critically acclaimed video games

ten critically acclaimed video games that were commercial failures I got big

that were commercial failures I got big

that were commercial failures I got big plans for tech mind this list bears some

plans for tech mind this list bears some

plans for tech mind this list bears some similarities to our top ten overlooked

similarities to our top ten overlooked

similarities to our top ten overlooked video game series which you should also

video game series which you should also

video game series which you should also check out the key difference here is

check out the key difference here is

check out the key difference here is that for this list we’ll be looking

that for this list we’ll be looking

that for this list we’ll be looking specifically at games with high critical

specifically at games with high critical

specifically at games with high critical acclaim that sold fewer than 1 million

acclaim that sold fewer than 1 million

acclaim that sold fewer than 1 million copies during their initial release if

copies during their initial release if

copies during their initial release if you ask me there’s something fishy about

you ask me there’s something fishy about

you ask me there’s something fishy about this

this

this as always we’ll only be selecting one

as always we’ll only be selecting one

as always we’ll only be selecting one game per series but most of these games

game per series but most of these games

game per series but most of these games didn’t manage to get sequels anyway well

didn’t manage to get sequels anyway well

didn’t manage to get sequels anyway well I guess that has some books was off than

I guess that has some books was off than

I guess that has some books was off than me number 10 the Neverhood um hello

me number 10 the Neverhood um hello

me number 10 the Neverhood um hello designed by the creator of earthworm jim

designed by the creator of earthworm jim

designed by the creator of earthworm jim doug to napal the Neverhood was the kind

doug to napal the Neverhood was the kind

doug to napal the Neverhood was the kind of weird and wonderful game that you

of weird and wonderful game that you

of weird and wonderful game that you need to see you in motion

the entire world of the neighborhood and

the entire world of the neighborhood and all the characters in it are

all the characters in it are

all the characters in it are painstakingly modeled in clay making it

painstakingly modeled in clay making it

painstakingly modeled in clay making it one of the most visually interesting

one of the most visually interesting

one of the most visually interesting games of its era but the Neverhood is

games of its era but the Neverhood is

games of its era but the Neverhood is more than just a cool look the animation

more than just a cool look the animation

more than just a cool look the animation brings the whole thing to life and it’s

brings the whole thing to life and it’s

brings the whole thing to life and it’s packed with the sort of crafty puzzles

packed with the sort of crafty puzzles

packed with the sort of crafty puzzles adventure games are known for polio

adventure games are known for polio

adventure games are known for polio number 9 earthbound come on Reggie

number 9 earthbound come on Reggie

number 9 earthbound come on Reggie give us mother 3 how about this instead

even Nintendo pokes fun at all the cult

even Nintendo pokes fun at all the cult status earthbound has earned since its

status earthbound has earned since its

status earthbound has earned since its initial release in 1994 earthbound or

initial release in 1994 earthbound or

initial release in 1994 earthbound or mother 2 as it’s known in Japan is one

mother 2 as it’s known in Japan is one

mother 2 as it’s known in Japan is one of the most unique games in all of

of the most unique games in all of

of the most unique games in all of Nintendo’s already buried catalog

the story begins with a meteor crash

the story begins with a meteor crash landing and our hero Ness meeting a bee

landing and our hero Ness meeting a bee

landing and our hero Ness meeting a bee from the future and from there it

from the future and from there it

from the future and from there it doesn’t get any less weird it’s a very

doesn’t get any less weird it’s a very

doesn’t get any less weird it’s a very very strange game that blends Japanese

very strange game that blends Japanese

very strange game that blends Japanese and North American pop culture and one

and North American pop culture and one

and North American pop culture and one hilarious RPG package number 8 Jet Set

hilarious RPG package number 8 Jet Set

hilarious RPG package number 8 Jet Set Radio just known as jet grind radio in

Radio just known as jet grind radio in

Radio just known as jet grind radio in North America Jet Set Radio is about

North America Jet Set Radio is about

North America Jet Set Radio is about marking your turf and grinding your way

marking your turf and grinding your way

marking your turf and grinding your way to victory

haha this highly stylised game was one

haha this highly stylised game was one of the first to popularize cel-shaded

of the first to popularize cel-shaded

of the first to popularize cel-shaded visuals and remains one of the marquee

visuals and remains one of the marquee

visuals and remains one of the marquee titles from Sega’s ill-fated Dreamcast

from its graphics to its music and its

from its graphics to its music and its fast-paced gameplay Jet Set Radio

fast-paced gameplay Jet Set Radio

fast-paced gameplay Jet Set Radio screams cool

plus the concept is pretty awesome too

plus the concept is pretty awesome too the idea of running around the city

the idea of running around the city

the idea of running around the city tagging buildings and debating the

tagging buildings and debating the

tagging buildings and debating the overzealous police force is even cool

overzealous police force is even cool

overzealous police force is even cool enough make rollerblading look good

one of the best ideas for a steampunk

one of the best ideas for a steampunk universe Skies of Arcadia is about a

universe Skies of Arcadia is about a

universe Skies of Arcadia is about a ragtag group of scallywags who pilot an

ragtag group of scallywags who pilot an

ragtag group of scallywags who pilot an airborne pirate ship blending jars and

airborne pirate ship blending jars and

airborne pirate ship blending jars and keeping an upbeat tempo Skies of Arcadia

keeping an upbeat tempo Skies of Arcadia

keeping an upbeat tempo Skies of Arcadia was an absolutely delightful

was an absolutely delightful

was an absolutely delightful role-playing game that should have been

role-playing game that should have been

role-playing game that should have been able to compete toe-to-toe with other

able to compete toe-to-toe with other

able to compete toe-to-toe with other flagship RPGs but for one reason or

flagship RPGs but for one reason or

flagship RPGs but for one reason or another despite a later release on the

another despite a later release on the

another despite a later release on the Gamecube Skies of Arcadia never found

Gamecube Skies of Arcadia never found

Gamecube Skies of Arcadia never found its audience

at the time Panzer Dragoon was sort of

at the time Panzer Dragoon was sort of like starfox with dragons an arcade

like starfox with dragons an arcade

like starfox with dragons an arcade style shooter with modern visuals to

style shooter with modern visuals to

style shooter with modern visuals to make the action suspenseful

while the visuals might not hold up in

while the visuals might not hold up in 2015

2015

2015 Panzer Dragoon is still a thrilling

Panzer Dragoon is still a thrilling

Panzer Dragoon is still a thrilling tightly designed on Rails shooter that

tightly designed on Rails shooter that

tightly designed on Rails shooter that takes some serious skill to master and

takes some serious skill to master and

takes some serious skill to master and let’s face it it doesn’t get much cooler

let’s face it it doesn’t get much cooler

let’s face it it doesn’t get much cooler than riding a dragon number 5 Beyond

than riding a dragon number 5 Beyond

than riding a dragon number 5 Beyond Good and Evil

Good and Evil

Good and Evil they’re coming quick then jump up all of

they’re coming quick then jump up all of

they’re coming quick then jump up all of the games we’ve listed are great and

the games we’ve listed are great and

the games we’ve listed are great and deserve to sell better than they did but

deserve to sell better than they did but

deserve to sell better than they did but none quite as surprising to see here as

none quite as surprising to see here as

none quite as surprising to see here as Beyond Good and Evil

it has everything a marketable game

it has everything a marketable game should have a flashy name a cool main

should have a flashy name a cool main

should have a flashy name a cool main character and a wicked story here on

character and a wicked story here on

character and a wicked story here on Hillis war has once again reared its

Hillis war has once again reared its

Hillis war has once again reared its ugly head striking the civilian

ugly head striking the civilian

ugly head striking the civilian population set in a dystopian future

population set in a dystopian future

population set in a dystopian future with a fascinating world to explore it’s

with a fascinating world to explore it’s

with a fascinating world to explore it’s a shame that more people didn’t buy this

a shame that more people didn’t buy this

a shame that more people didn’t buy this one because Beyond Good and Evil is

one because Beyond Good and Evil is

one because Beyond Good and Evil is truly an excellent game number 4 Grim

truly an excellent game number 4 Grim

truly an excellent game number 4 Grim Fandango something like this could only

Fandango something like this could only

Fandango something like this could only come from the mind of Tim Schafer

come from the mind of Tim Schafer

come from the mind of Tim Schafer windows Diaz Manny why don’t you at the

windows Diaz Manny why don’t you at the

windows Diaz Manny why don’t you at the poisoning web poisoning grim fandago

poisoning web poisoning grim fandago

poisoning web poisoning grim fandago stars manuel Calavera whose job it is to

stars manuel Calavera whose job it is to

stars manuel Calavera whose job it is to greet the deceased in full death robes

greet the deceased in full death robes

greet the deceased in full death robes and then sell them travel packages to

and then sell them travel packages to

and then sell them travel packages to the afterlife

the afterlife

the afterlife just your appearance it’s a little

just your appearance it’s a little

just your appearance it’s a little intimidating intimidating me but I’m

intimidating intimidating me but I’m

intimidating intimidating me but I’m your friend my name is Manny Calavera

your friend my name is Manny Calavera

your friend my name is Manny Calavera I’m your new travel agent it’s one of

I’m your new travel agent it’s one of

I’m your new travel agent it’s one of the best adventure games around but only

the best adventure games around but only

the best adventure games around but only saw its retail release as the interest

saw its retail release as the interest

saw its retail release as the interest in the genre was slowly dying down God

in the genre was slowly dying down God

in the genre was slowly dying down God is my friend why are you crying

is my friend why are you crying

is my friend why are you crying Maddy Oh daddy they fired me if you’ve

Maddy Oh daddy they fired me if you’ve

Maddy Oh daddy they fired me if you’ve never found out what happens to Manny

never found out what happens to Manny

never found out what happens to Manny during the Day of the Dead a remastered

during the Day of the Dead a remastered

during the Day of the Dead a remastered version just came out on ps4 and PC yeah

version just came out on ps4 and PC yeah

version just came out on ps4 and PC yeah ha yes that’s the ticket

ha yes that’s the ticket

ha yes that’s the ticket the excelsior line number 3 eternal

the excelsior line number 3 eternal

the excelsior line number 3 eternal darkness sanity’s Requiem

eternal darkness is one of a kind it’s a

eternal darkness is one of a kind it’s a survival horror game that flashes

survival horror game that flashes

survival horror game that flashes backwards and forwards in time to piece

backwards and forwards in time to piece

backwards and forwards in time to piece together the history of a centuries-old

together the history of a centuries-old

together the history of a centuries-old haunted mansion it must be some clue in

haunted mansion it must be some clue in

haunted mansion it must be some clue in this old mansion revealing what happened

this old mansion revealing what happened

this old mansion revealing what happened I want answers unlike so many more are

I want answers unlike so many more are

I want answers unlike so many more are games that rely on jump scares eternal

games that rely on jump scares eternal

games that rely on jump scares eternal darkness is filled with larger-than-life

darkness is filled with larger-than-life

darkness is filled with larger-than-life terror that takes its time slowly

terror that takes its time slowly

terror that takes its time slowly building up the coolest aspect of

building up the coolest aspect of

building up the coolest aspect of eternal darkness is the fourth wall

eternal darkness is the fourth wall

eternal darkness is the fourth wall breaking sanity events which mess with

breaking sanity events which mess with

breaking sanity events which mess with your mind both in and out of the game

it’s a shame that eternal darkness

it’s a shame that eternal darkness didn’t perform better because it’s a

didn’t perform better because it’s a

didn’t perform better because it’s a unique brand of storytelling that would

unique brand of storytelling that would

unique brand of storytelling that would be interesting to see today

number two Psychonauts like so many of

number two Psychonauts like so many of the games we’ve seen Psychonauts is an

the games we’ve seen Psychonauts is an

the games we’ve seen Psychonauts is an absolute gem that came out at the wrong

absolute gem that came out at the wrong

absolute gem that came out at the wrong place in time what but don’t you train

place in time what but don’t you train

place in time what but don’t you train Psychonauts here for an almost 10 year

Psychonauts here for an almost 10 year

Psychonauts here for an almost 10 year period 3d platformers were one of the

period 3d platformers were one of the

period 3d platformers were one of the most popular genres and games then all

most popular genres and games then all

most popular genres and games then all of a sudden everyone lost interest and

of a sudden everyone lost interest and

of a sudden everyone lost interest and sadly that’s when Tim Schafer’s

sadly that’s when Tim Schafer’s

sadly that’s when Tim Schafer’s masterpiece

masterpiece

masterpiece Psychonauts hit store shelves isn’t that

Psychonauts hit store shelves isn’t that

Psychonauts hit store shelves isn’t that great what how is that great

great what how is that great

great what how is that great Psychonauts is about a psychic summer

Psychonauts is about a psychic summer

Psychonauts is about a psychic summer camp that’s actually a government

camp that’s actually a government

camp that’s actually a government training facility made to train kids to

training facility made to train kids to

training facility made to train kids to become psychic agents allowing them to

become psychic agents allowing them to

become psychic agents allowing them to enter other people’s minds and see

enter other people’s minds and see

enter other people’s minds and see worlds based on their personalities how

worlds based on their personalities how

worlds based on their personalities how am I gonna find some creepy graveyard in

am I gonna find some creepy graveyard in

am I gonna find some creepy graveyard in this nice normal neighborhood it’s not

this nice normal neighborhood it’s not

this nice normal neighborhood it’s not hard to see why people didn’t jump on

hard to see why people didn’t jump on

hard to see why people didn’t jump on the concept but it was really worth it

the concept but it was really worth it

the concept but it was really worth it for those who did in this psychic dojo

for those who did in this psychic dojo

for those who did in this psychic dojo they make you a hero

get that soldier a bunk before we name

get that soldier a bunk before we name our number one pick here’s a look at

our number one pick here’s a look at

our number one pick here’s a look at some honorable mentions

set in the titular Planescape universe

set in the titular Planescape universe and refining the gameplay of titles like

and refining the gameplay of titles like

and refining the gameplay of titles like Baldur’s Gate torment is a dialogue

Baldur’s Gate torment is a dialogue

Baldur’s Gate torment is a dialogue driven role-playing game that is still

driven role-playing game that is still

driven role-playing game that is still revered for its outstanding script and

revered for its outstanding script and

revered for its outstanding script and world building hey chief you okay you

world building hey chief you okay you

world building hey chief you okay you playing corpse you putting the blinds in

playing corpse you putting the blinds in

playing corpse you putting the blinds in the dusties I thought you were a debtor

the dusties I thought you were a debtor

the dusties I thought you were a debtor for sure torment balls the story of the

for sure torment balls the story of the

for sure torment balls the story of the nameless one an immortal character who’s

nameless one an immortal character who’s

nameless one an immortal character who’s lost the memory of his past lives

it’s not only one of the best pieces of

it’s not only one of the best pieces of videogame fiction but a defining entry

videogame fiction but a defining entry

videogame fiction but a defining entry in the beloved group of infinity Engine

in the beloved group of infinity Engine

in the beloved group of infinity Engine RPGs moving only 20,000 units Planescape

RPGs moving only 20,000 units Planescape

RPGs moving only 20,000 units Planescape torment sold miserably compared to its

torment sold miserably compared to its

torment sold miserably compared to its outstanding critical reception making it

outstanding critical reception making it

outstanding critical reception making it our number one pick do you agree with

our number one pick do you agree with

our number one pick do you agree with our list hi which of these games have

our list hi which of these games have

our list hi which of these games have you bought and played ooh a request for

you bought and played ooh a request for

you bought and played ooh a request for more not so rare top 10s published every

more not so rare top 10s published every

more not so rare top 10s published every day be sure to subscribe to

day be sure to subscribe to

day be sure to subscribe to watchmojo.com there’s one thing I’ve

watchmojo.com there’s one thing I’ve

watchmojo.com there’s one thing I’ve learned is this

learned is this

learned is this nobody knows what’s gonna happen at the

nobody knows what’s gonna happen at the

nobody knows what’s gonna happen at the end of the line might as well enjoy the

end of the line might as well enjoy the

end of the line might as well enjoy the trip

trip

trip you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *