Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why is education still isolated from the real world? | Petar Buha | TEDxUNYP


just like many of you I finished my

just like many of you I finished my university studies not so long ago I was

university studies not so long ago I was

university studies not so long ago I was happy full of energy and eager to prove

happy full of energy and eager to prove

happy full of energy and eager to prove myself and to the world the value that I

myself and to the world the value that I

myself and to the world the value that I can create in society but pretty much as

can create in society but pretty much as

can create in society but pretty much as soon as I have joined the company I was

soon as I have joined the company I was

soon as I have joined the company I was very disappointed turned out that pretty

very disappointed turned out that pretty

very disappointed turned out that pretty much none of the skills and the

much none of the skills and the

much none of the skills and the knowledge that I have gained during my

knowledge that I have gained during my

knowledge that I have gained during my university studies was applicable in the

university studies was applicable in the

university studies was applicable in the real world I felt betrayed I felt upset

real world I felt betrayed I felt upset

real world I felt betrayed I felt upset and I took it upon myself to go back to

and I took it upon myself to go back to

and I took it upon myself to go back to school this time as a lecturer to

school this time as a lecturer to

school this time as a lecturer to hopefully provide the students with some

hopefully provide the students with some

hopefully provide the students with some more applicable skills something they

more applicable skills something they

more applicable skills something they will surely need it also got me thinking

will surely need it also got me thinking

will surely need it also got me thinking why is there such a disconnection

why is there such a disconnection

why is there such a disconnection between the real world and education

between the real world and education

between the real world and education before we go into details it is

before we go into details it is

before we go into details it is important to define the terms while the

important to define the terms while the

important to define the terms while the real world can be essentially understood

real world can be essentially understood

real world can be essentially understood as everything apart from education

as everything apart from education

as everything apart from education education itself is a bit harder to

education itself is a bit harder to

education itself is a bit harder to define so let me bore you with the

define so let me bore you with the

define so let me bore you with the definition for a minute

definition for a minute

definition for a minute education is a structured system of

education is a structured system of

education is a structured system of facilitating the acquisition of

facilitating the acquisition of

facilitating the acquisition of knowledge skills values beliefs and

knowledge skills values beliefs and

knowledge skills values beliefs and habits now notice the last three values

habits now notice the last three values

habits now notice the last three values beliefs and habits while we all

beliefs and habits while we all

beliefs and habits while we all understand it intrinsically that when

understand it intrinsically that when

understand it intrinsically that when you go to school you will learn how to

you go to school you will learn how to

you go to school you will learn how to spell or that you will learn how to

spell or that you will learn how to

spell or that you will learn how to integrate we also learn that hard work

integrate we also learn that hard work

integrate we also learn that hard work pays off we learn to get up in the

pays off we learn to get up in the

pays off we learn to get up in the morning every day and we learn that you

morning every day and we learn that you

morning every day and we learn that you should do unto others that you would as

should do unto others that you would as

should do unto others that you would as you would have them do unto you

you would have them do unto you

you would have them do unto you why is there such a disconnection if

why is there such a disconnection if

why is there such a disconnection if there is such a big difference who came

there is such a big difference who came

there is such a big difference who came up with the system why is it set up this

up with the system why is it set up this

up with the system why is it set up this way

way

way why does education work the way it does

why does education work the way it does

why does education work the way it does and it turns out that the educational

and it turns out that the educational

and it turns out that the educational system as we know it is not something

system as we know it is not something

system as we know it is not something that has been painstakingly

that has been painstakingly

that has been painstakingly instructed by the foremost experts it is

instructed by the foremost experts it is

instructed by the foremost experts it is something that we have inherited so to

something that we have inherited so to

something that we have inherited so to truly understand education we must look

truly understand education we must look

truly understand education we must look at its history so let us go back a few

at its history so let us go back a few

at its history so let us go back a few thousand years to the hunter and

thousand years to the hunter and

thousand years to the hunter and gatherer times in those days work was

gatherer times in those days work was

gatherer times in those days work was very skill intensive very knowledge

very skill intensive very knowledge

very skill intensive very knowledge intensive but it was not so labor

intensive but it was not so labor

intensive but it was not so labor intensive you had to know how to throw a

intensive you had to know how to throw a

intensive you had to know how to throw a spear you had to know which berries to

spear you had to know which berries to

spear you had to know which berries to pick but you did not need to do this for

pick but you did not need to do this for

pick but you did not need to do this for the whole day in fact you would kill a

the whole day in fact you would kill a

the whole day in fact you would kill a large animal bring it back to the tribe

large animal bring it back to the tribe

large animal bring it back to the tribe and they would be taken care of for at

and they would be taken care of for at

and they would be taken care of for at least a few days in those times also

least a few days in those times also

least a few days in those times also there was no distinction between work

there was no distinction between work

there was no distinction between work and fun because work was fun and

and fun because work was fun and

and fun because work was fun and children would have fun and they would

children would have fun and they would

children would have fun and they would play and they would imitate what their

play and they would imitate what their

play and they would imitate what their parents do they would learn how to do

parents do they would learn how to do

parents do they would learn how to do their work this way you can for example

their work this way you can for example

their work this way you can for example think of lion cubs play fighting yes

think of lion cubs play fighting yes

think of lion cubs play fighting yes they are having fun but they are at the

they are having fun but they are at the

they are having fun but they are at the same time learning a very useful skill

same time learning a very useful skill

same time learning a very useful skill which they will need later in life then

which they will need later in life then

which they will need later in life then times have changed and we have come to

times have changed and we have come to

times have changed and we have come to the agricultural era where suddenly work

the agricultural era where suddenly work

the agricultural era where suddenly work was no longer so skill intensive or so

was no longer so skill intensive or so

was no longer so skill intensive or so knowledge intensive after all you did

knowledge intensive after all you did

knowledge intensive after all you did not need to worry about fifty different

not need to worry about fifty different

not need to worry about fifty different berries if you only had the one that you

berries if you only had the one that you

berries if you only had the one that you were growing but they became very labor

were growing but they became very labor

were growing but they became very labor intensive you had to work hard every day

intensive you had to work hard every day

intensive you had to work hard every day people would slave away sometimes quite

people would slave away sometimes quite

people would slave away sometimes quite literally in the fields and they brought

literally in the fields and they brought

literally in the fields and they brought their children alongside to help

their children alongside to help

their children alongside to help moreover the qualities which were

moreover the qualities which were

moreover the qualities which were required before which were seen as

required before which were seen as

required before which were seen as virtues that is creativity or

virtues that is creativity or

virtues that is creativity or willfulness became problematic the most

willfulness became problematic the most

willfulness became problematic the most important quality would be obedience an

important quality would be obedience an

important quality would be obedience an obedient child was a good child the same

obedient child was a good child the same

obedient child was a good child the same way that an obedient person was a good

way that an obedient person was a good

way that an obedient person was a good person and who would not be obedient

person and who would not be obedient

person and who would not be obedient would be severely punished

would be severely punished

would be severely punished this system was in place

this system was in place

this system was in place for hundreds of years essentially up

for hundreds of years essentially up

for hundreds of years essentially up until the industrial era people would no

until the industrial era people would no

until the industrial era people would no longer work the entire day in a field

longer work the entire day in a field

longer work the entire day in a field now they will be working the whole day

now they will be working the whole day

now they will be working the whole day at a factory with the changing nature of

at a factory with the changing nature of

at a factory with the changing nature of work have changed the requirements

work have changed the requirements

work have changed the requirements people needed knowledge people needed to

people needed knowledge people needed to

people needed knowledge people needed to know how to do the work and in order to

know how to do the work and in order to

know how to do the work and in order to combat this need for knowledge

combat this need for knowledge

combat this need for knowledge most states have begun implementing

most states have begun implementing

most states have begun implementing universal education where the state

universal education where the state

universal education where the state would take away the child from their

would take away the child from their

would take away the child from their parents from their employment and try to

parents from their employment and try to

parents from their employment and try to impart in them the knowledge that they

impart in them the knowledge that they

impart in them the knowledge that they would need in those times however when

would need in those times however when

would need in those times however when the system was being set up the states

the system was being set up the states

the system was being set up the states did not just think about the knowledge

did not just think about the knowledge

did not just think about the knowledge which would be required in the future

which would be required in the future

which would be required in the future they have essentially try to

they have essentially try to

they have essentially try to indoctrinate the children into becoming

indoctrinate the children into becoming

indoctrinate the children into becoming a good citizen in the future now if you

a good citizen in the future now if you

a good citizen in the future now if you want to indoctrinate someone how will

want to indoctrinate someone how will

want to indoctrinate someone how will you do it you’ll force them to memorize

you do it you’ll force them to memorize

you do it you’ll force them to memorize long passages without understanding you

long passages without understanding you

long passages without understanding you would test them on their memory how they

would test them on their memory how they

would test them on their memory how they did you would you would punish them

did you would you would punish them

did you would you would punish them severely if they did not perform as

severely if they did not perform as

severely if they did not perform as expected and then you would make them do

expected and then you would make them do

expected and then you would make them do this whole thing all over again now does

this whole thing all over again now does

this whole thing all over again now does this sound familiar

this sound familiar

this sound familiar today the times have changed we no

today the times have changed we no

today the times have changed we no longer use physical punishment in

longer use physical punishment in

longer use physical punishment in schools but at the same time the school

schools but at the same time the school

schools but at the same time the school curriculum has expanded tremendously

curriculum has expanded tremendously

curriculum has expanded tremendously while adults spend or eight nine hours a

while adults spend or eight nine hours a

while adults spend or eight nine hours a day in the office

day in the office

day in the office children spend six hours a day in school

children spend six hours a day in school

children spend six hours a day in school for decades

work is no longer fun but school is

work is no longer fun but school is neither in fact school is seen as

neither in fact school is seen as

neither in fact school is seen as children’s work as something to prepare

children’s work as something to prepare

children’s work as something to prepare you for the future so while the adults

you for the future so while the adults

you for the future so while the adults are sitting in the office for eight

are sitting in the office for eight

are sitting in the office for eight hours bored out of their mind

hours bored out of their mind

hours bored out of their mind children are sitting in the classrooms

children are sitting in the classrooms

children are sitting in the classrooms for six hours bored out of their mind in

for six hours bored out of their mind in

for six hours bored out of their mind in this way school teaches them that it is

this way school teaches them that it is

this way school teaches them that it is okay now is this system really useful is

okay now is this system really useful is

okay now is this system really useful is this really going to provide you with

this really going to provide you with

this really going to provide you with the knowledge that you need well let me

the knowledge that you need well let me

the knowledge that you need well let me ask you do you do what

ask you do you do what

ask you do you do what you have studied I know that I don’t

you have studied I know that I don’t

you have studied I know that I don’t none really and why is this well how can

none really and why is this well how can

none really and why is this well how can school prepare you for something that

school prepare you for something that

school prepare you for something that you will need 20 years from now how can

you will need 20 years from now how can

you will need 20 years from now how can we predict which jobs will be required

we predict which jobs will be required

we predict which jobs will be required in the future yes are simple we can’t in

in the future yes are simple we can’t in

in the future yes are simple we can’t in fact look at the number of managers over

fact look at the number of managers over

fact look at the number of managers over the last hundred years one hundred years

the last hundred years one hundred years

the last hundred years one hundred years ago there may be six percent of managers

ago there may be six percent of managers

ago there may be six percent of managers or proprietors or officials today the

or proprietors or officials today the

or proprietors or officials today the number is song around 14 yet let me ask

number is song around 14 yet let me ask

number is song around 14 yet let me ask you 50 years ago who would have heard of

you 50 years ago who would have heard of

you 50 years ago who would have heard of a business school 20 years ago who would

a business school 20 years ago who would

a business school 20 years ago who would have heard of an entrepreneurship course

have heard of an entrepreneurship course

have heard of an entrepreneurship course no one every mother is overjoyed when

no one every mother is overjoyed when

no one every mother is overjoyed when her daughter tells her mom when I grow

her daughter tells her mom when I grow

her daughter tells her mom when I grow up I want to be a doctor it considered

up I want to be a doctor it considered

up I want to be a doctor it considered the proportion of doctors in today’s

the proportion of doctors in today’s

the proportion of doctors in today’s society it is and it has been the same

society it is and it has been the same

society it is and it has been the same for the last hundred years around 0.5%

for the last hundred years around 0.5%

for the last hundred years around 0.5% but at the same time consider the number

but at the same time consider the number

but at the same time consider the number of nurses and health care technicians

of nurses and health care technicians

of nurses and health care technicians their numbers have increased

their numbers have increased

their numbers have increased tremendously now let me ask you which

tremendously now let me ask you which

tremendously now let me ask you which one do you think is more likely to

one do you think is more likely to

one do you think is more likely to provide you with the job security

provide you with the job security

provide you with the job security consider professionals technicians you

consider professionals technicians you

consider professionals technicians you know people who in general have problems

know people who in general have problems

know people who in general have problems explaining what they do to their parents

explaining what they do to their parents

explaining what they do to their parents 100 years ago maybe 5 percent today 25

100 years ago maybe 5 percent today 25

100 years ago maybe 5 percent today 25 who could have predicted this growth

who could have predicted this growth

who could have predicted this growth this is incredible but unfortunately not

this is incredible but unfortunately not

this is incredible but unfortunately not all professions do as well in the 1920s

all professions do as well in the 1920s

all professions do as well in the 1920s if you thought that going into

if you thought that going into

if you thought that going into agriculture would have been a great idea

agriculture would have been a great idea

agriculture would have been a great idea provided with a job security you would

provided with a job security you would

provided with a job security you would be considered smart but yet by 1950s

be considered smart but yet by 1950s

be considered smart but yet by 1950s this was no longer the case and by 1970s

this was no longer the case and by 1970s

this was no longer the case and by 1970s good you would have been happy to have a

good you would have been happy to have a

good you would have been happy to have a job to retire from at all there is a

job to retire from at all there is a

job to retire from at all there is a popular sentiment

popular sentiment

popular sentiment going around these days which says that

going around these days which says that

going around these days which says that liberal arts majors are useless and you

liberal arts majors are useless and you

liberal arts majors are useless and you know what in terms of marketable skills

know what in terms of marketable skills

know what in terms of marketable skills marketable knowledge I’m inclined to

marketable knowledge I’m inclined to

marketable knowledge I’m inclined to agree at the same time remember that

agree at the same time remember that

agree at the same time remember that education gives you more provides you

education gives you more provides you

education gives you more provides you with values beliefs habits

with values beliefs habits

with values beliefs habits and these are the things where liberal

and these are the things where liberal

and these are the things where liberal arts majors excel we live in a

arts majors excel we live in a

arts majors excel we live in a globalized society today understanding

globalized society today understanding

globalized society today understanding of culture is more important than ever

of culture is more important than ever

of culture is more important than ever an American person might need to

an American person might need to

an American person might need to understand that their Indian colleague

understand that their Indian colleague

understand that their Indian colleague has a different set of values German

has a different set of values German

has a different set of values German needs to understand that being on time

needs to understand that being on time

needs to understand that being on time means something different in Italy but

means something different in Italy but

means something different in Italy but this cultural understanding is not

this cultural understanding is not

this cultural understanding is not something which you will learn in a

something which you will learn in a

something which you will learn in a trade school I’m speaking from

trade school I’m speaking from

trade school I’m speaking from experience when I say that technical

experience when I say that technical

experience when I say that technical skills are easy to pick up three years

skills are easy to pick up three years

skills are easy to pick up three years ago I did not know a thing about Excel

ago I did not know a thing about Excel

ago I did not know a thing about Excel today I teach it two years ago if you

today I teach it two years ago if you

today I teach it two years ago if you told me I’d be programming I would have

told me I’d be programming I would have

told me I’d be programming I would have laughed but today I create solutions

laughed but today I create solutions

laughed but today I create solutions which are useful to the client

which are useful to the client

which are useful to the client and which they pay good money for

and which they pay good money for

and which they pay good money for however it took me five years of

however it took me five years of

however it took me five years of education of Business Economics and

education of Business Economics and

education of Business Economics and International Studies to become the

International Studies to become the

International Studies to become the person I am today do I know all the

person I am today do I know all the

person I am today do I know all the answers no but I know how to ask the

answers no but I know how to ask the

answers no but I know how to ask the right questions don’t believe me

right questions don’t believe me

right questions don’t believe me consider mr. Brian Chesky the founder of

consider mr. Brian Chesky the founder of

consider mr. Brian Chesky the founder of Airbnb he majored in fine arts consider

Airbnb he majored in fine arts consider

Airbnb he majored in fine arts consider perhaps mr. Stewart Butterfield

perhaps mr. Stewart Butterfield

perhaps mr. Stewart Butterfield co-founder of Flickr founder of slack

co-founder of Flickr founder of slack

co-founder of Flickr founder of slack his majors philosophy consider miss

his majors philosophy consider miss

his majors philosophy consider miss Susan Wojcicki current CEO of YouTube

Susan Wojcicki current CEO of YouTube

Susan Wojcicki current CEO of YouTube one of the first employees of Google her

one of the first employees of Google her

one of the first employees of Google her majors history and literature and of

majors history and literature and of

majors history and literature and of course we have mr. Jack Ma the founder

course we have mr. Jack Ma the founder

course we have mr. Jack Ma the founder of Alibaba perhaps the second largest

of Alibaba perhaps the second largest

of Alibaba perhaps the second largest online marketplace in the world internet

online marketplace in the world internet

online marketplace in the world internet evangelist in China his manger was

evangelist in China his manger was

evangelist in China his manger was simply English language now that we know

simply English language now that we know

simply English language now that we know that the qualities which create for a

that the qualities which create for a

that the qualities which create for a good businessperson are not something

good businessperson are not something

good businessperson are not something that University will provide we can ask

that University will provide we can ask

that University will provide we can ask ourselves why do we need university

ourselves why do we need university

ourselves why do we need university education at all how come that still at

education at all how come that still at

education at all how come that still at any job ad it says at least some college

any job ad it says at least some college

any job ad it says at least some college required Michael spends world renowned

required Michael spends world renowned

required Michael spends world renowned economists Nobel Prize laureate has

economists Nobel Prize laureate has

economists Nobel Prize laureate has answered this question for us he came up

answered this question for us he came up

answered this question for us he came up with the signalling theory in the nine

with the signalling theory in the nine

with the signalling theory in the nine in 70s and not to bore you with the

in 70s and not to bore you with the

in 70s and not to bore you with the details but he essentially said that the

details but he essentially said that the

details but he essentially said that the value of university education is not in

value of university education is not in

value of university education is not in the skills and the knowledge that you

the skills and the knowledge that you

the skills and the knowledge that you gain it tells a lot about you as a

gain it tells a lot about you as a

gain it tells a lot about you as a person you prove that you are smart

person you prove that you are smart

person you prove that you are smart enough to get into the university you

enough to get into the university you

enough to get into the university you prove you’re not going to give up half

prove you’re not going to give up half

prove you’re not going to give up half way because you did not drop out of the

way because you did not drop out of the

way because you did not drop out of the university and it shows that you’re able

university and it shows that you’re able

university and it shows that you’re able to work hard enough and do independent

to work hard enough and do independent

to work hard enough and do independent research to finish the university can we

research to finish the university can we

research to finish the university can we then say the university education will

then say the university education will

then say the university education will ensure success in life now the answer is

ensure success in life now the answer is

ensure success in life now the answer is yes but not in the way that you might

yes but not in the way that you might

yes but not in the way that you might think university education provides you

think university education provides you

think university education provides you besides the actual knowledge with many

besides the actual knowledge with many

besides the actual knowledge with many learning experiences that you might not

learning experiences that you might not

learning experiences that you might not be able to get otherwise

be able to get otherwise

be able to get otherwise it teaches you to think in a productive

it teaches you to think in a productive

it teaches you to think in a productive way it provides you with many social

way it provides you with many social

way it provides you with many social experiences that you probably would not

experiences that you probably would not

experiences that you probably would not have had otherwise

have had otherwise

have had otherwise and it broadens your horizons so that

and it broadens your horizons so that

and it broadens your horizons so that you see what is beyond your little town

you see what is beyond your little town

you see what is beyond your little town where you came from success is not

where you came from success is not

where you came from success is not determined by your GPA success is

determined by your GPA success is

determined by your GPA success is determined by your intelligence very by

determined by your intelligence very by

determined by your intelligence very by your emotional intelligence by our

your emotional intelligence by our

your emotional intelligence by our perseverance by your grit and all of

perseverance by your grit and all of

perseverance by your grit and all of these can be learned in a university

these can be learned in a university

these can be learned in a university however you have to go out and get it

however you have to go out and get it

however you have to go out and get it you have to remember that you are in

you have to remember that you are in

you have to remember that you are in control

control

control you have to want to learn to learn and

you have to want to learn to learn and

you have to want to learn to learn and once you want this nothing can stop you

once you want this nothing can stop you

once you want this nothing can stop you not today

not today

not today Frank Zappa once famously said if you

Frank Zappa once famously said if you

Frank Zappa once famously said if you want to get late go to college if you

want to get late go to college if you

want to get late go to college if you want education go to library

want education go to library

want education go to library let me follow this up with a little

let me follow this up with a little

let me follow this up with a little addition of my own if you want to learn

addition of my own if you want to learn

addition of my own if you want to learn something today go to the Internet

something today go to the Internet

something today go to the Internet there are numerous applications websites

there are numerous applications websites

there are numerous applications websites platforms which have been developed in

platforms which have been developed in

platforms which have been developed in conjunction with today’s research about

conjunction with today’s research about

conjunction with today’s research about education which make your education

education which make your education

education which make your education experience much much better than a

experience much much better than a

experience much much better than a standard lecture type setting you have

standard lecture type setting you have

standard lecture type setting you have applications that teach you language and

applications that teach you language and

applications that teach you language and reward you for taking the time every day

reward you for taking the time every day

reward you for taking the time every day to practice for 10 minutes you have

to practice for 10 minutes you have

to practice for 10 minutes you have entire platforms where you can go and

entire platforms where you can go and

entire platforms where you can go and zoom in on the one skill on the one bit

zoom in on the one skill on the one bit

zoom in on the one skill on the one bit of knowledge that you want and learn it

of knowledge that you want and learn it

of knowledge that you want and learn it you do not have to go through hundreds

you do not have to go through hundreds

you do not have to go through hundreds of books but as you did before you have

of books but as you did before you have

of books but as you did before you have entire platforms dedicated to providing

entire platforms dedicated to providing

entire platforms dedicated to providing you with information on demand no longer

you with information on demand no longer

you with information on demand no longer do you need to go through hundreds of

do you need to go through hundreds of

do you need to go through hundreds of books hoping one of them might have the

books hoping one of them might have the

books hoping one of them might have the answer now you can just go out there get

answer now you can just go out there get

answer now you can just go out there get it learn it and continue on with your

it learn it and continue on with your

it learn it and continue on with your life and if you are a fan of U of

life and if you are a fan of U of

life and if you are a fan of U of University lectures today you can get

University lectures today you can get

University lectures today you can get top grade recordings with the notes

top grade recordings with the notes

top grade recordings with the notes completely for free

completely for free

completely for free now I may not know a lot but I do know

now I may not know a lot but I do know

now I may not know a lot but I do know one thing and again I speak from

one thing and again I speak from

one thing and again I speak from experience if you’re currently studying

experience if you’re currently studying

experience if you’re currently studying get a job if you’re working consider

get a job if you’re working consider

get a job if you’re working consider going back to school my educational

going back to school my educational

going back to school my educational experience has been incredibly improved

experience has been incredibly improved

experience has been incredibly improved the moment I started working because I

the moment I started working because I

the moment I started working because I was able to recognize the skills that I

was able to recognize the skills that I

was able to recognize the skills that I can learn in University and I was able

can learn in University and I was able

can learn in University and I was able to differentiate the knowledge which

to differentiate the knowledge which

to differentiate the knowledge which might be useful one day from the

might be useful one day from the

might be useful one day from the knowledge that I just need to pass the

knowledge that I just need to pass the

knowledge that I just need to pass the test most importantly remember it is up

test most importantly remember it is up

test most importantly remember it is up to you you have to decide what you want

to you you have to decide what you want

to you you have to decide what you want to learn and you have to go out there

to learn and you have to go out there

to learn and you have to go out there and get it thank

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *