Press "Enter" to skip to content

When Ethics are Lost | Francine Edwards | TEDxDover


kind of intimidating following your boss

kind of intimidating following your boss so I’m excited to be here this is a

so I’m excited to be here this is a

so I’m excited to be here this is a historical event at our college and so

historical event at our college and so

historical event at our college and so I’m just excited to be able to share my

I’m just excited to be able to share my

I’m just excited to be able to share my thoughts on citizen journalism social

thoughts on citizen journalism social

thoughts on citizen journalism social media and ethics so let’s begin so the

media and ethics so let’s begin so the

media and ethics so let’s begin so the 60s and the 70s were time in which we

60s and the 70s were time in which we

60s and the 70s were time in which we saw a lot of challenges and a lot of

saw a lot of challenges and a lot of

saw a lot of challenges and a lot of struggles we saw the fight for civil

struggles we saw the fight for civil

struggles we saw the fight for civil rights and equality and we saw a

rights and equality and we saw a

rights and equality and we saw a transformation from segregation to

transformation from segregation to

transformation from segregation to desegregation and the revolution was

desegregation and the revolution was

desegregation and the revolution was televised it was televised and what we

televised it was televised and what we

televised it was televised and what we saw on TV was the truth it was valued

saw on TV was the truth it was valued

saw on TV was the truth it was valued and the people who were delivering that

and the people who were delivering that

and the people who were delivering that truth were news anchors who were pillars

truth were news anchors who were pillars

truth were news anchors who were pillars of our communities so fast forward to

of our communities so fast forward to

of our communities so fast forward to the 90s because if you look at the

the 90s because if you look at the

the 90s because if you look at the picture the 80s weren’t really good for

picture the 80s weren’t really good for

picture the 80s weren’t really good for me had a jheri curl was kind of awkward

me had a jheri curl was kind of awkward

me had a jheri curl was kind of awkward but the 90s is when i had my mind and my

but the 90s is when i had my mind and my

but the 90s is when i had my mind and my heart set on a career in journalism I

heart set on a career in journalism I

heart set on a career in journalism I attended James Madison University I had

attended James Madison University I had

attended James Madison University I had gone there for yearbook camps for two

gone there for yearbook camps for two

gone there for yearbook camps for two summers and I was going to be the next

summers and I was going to be the next

summers and I was going to be the next Barbara Walters I used to tell people

Barbara Walters I used to tell people

Barbara Walters I used to tell people that all the time young people google

that all the time young people google

that all the time young people google her I used to tell people I was going to

her I used to tell people I was going to

her I used to tell people I was going to be the next Barbara Walters well the

be the next Barbara Walters well the

be the next Barbara Walters well the Barbara Walters and the Dan Rather’s and

Barbara Walters and the Dan Rather’s and

Barbara Walters and the Dan Rather’s and the Maureen bunions of the world have

the Maureen bunions of the world have

the Maureen bunions of the world have been replaced by muckraker calm at anna

been replaced by muckraker calm at anna

been replaced by muckraker calm at anna homes and by everyday people citizen

homes and by everyday people citizen

homes and by everyday people citizen journalists who take to social media to

journalists who take to social media to

journalists who take to social media to provide commentary about everything from

provide commentary about everything from

provide commentary about everything from politics to education to parenting to

politics to education to parenting to

politics to education to parenting to food to the bundle of hair that I’m

food to the bundle of hair that I’m

food to the bundle of hair that I’m buying everything that you can imagine

buying everything that you can imagine

buying everything that you can imagine is some of our fellow citizen

is some of our fellow citizen

is some of our fellow citizen journalists do so without fact-checking

journalists do so without fact-checking

journalists do so without fact-checking without a moral compass and without fair

without a moral compass and without fair

without a moral compass and without fair and balanced reporting and so I’m not

and balanced reporting and so I’m not

and balanced reporting and so I’m not here to you know put a label on citizen

here to you know put a label on citizen

here to you know put a label on citizen journalism or put a label on social

journalism or put a label on social

journalism or put a label on social media because there’s utility and both

media because there’s utility and both

media because there’s utility and both but what I’m here to do is to kind of

but what I’m here to do is to kind of

but what I’m here to do is to kind of shed some light on the need and the fact

shed some light on the need and the fact

shed some light on the need and the fact that there has to be a threat of ethics

that there has to be a threat of ethics

that there has to be a threat of ethics because so many people place value on

because so many people place value on

because so many people place value on social media and the content that we

social media and the content that we

social media and the content that we crave or that

crave or that

crave or that get from social media and so citizen

get from social media and so citizen

get from social media and so citizen journalism that term it came about as a

journalism that term it came about as a

journalism that term it came about as a result of the democratization of the

result of the democratization of the

result of the democratization of the digital media area and so what we see is

digital media area and so what we see is

digital media area and so what we see is more access to being able to share and

more access to being able to share and

more access to being able to share and communicate with folks the freedom to do

communicate with folks the freedom to do

communicate with folks the freedom to do it over a medium that is designed for

it over a medium that is designed for

it over a medium that is designed for entertainment purposes but when you

entertainment purposes but when you

entertainment purposes but when you think about when you think about citizen

think about when you think about citizen

think about when you think about citizen journalism you have to think like is it

journalism you have to think like is it

journalism you have to think like is it something that’s just new or has it been

something that’s just new or has it been

something that’s just new or has it been around and for me probably the most

around and for me probably the most

around and for me probably the most significant or prominent instances of

significant or prominent instances of

significant or prominent instances of citizen journalism was the videotapes

citizen journalism was the videotapes

citizen journalism was the videotapes beating of rodney king so one person’s

beating of rodney king so one person’s

beating of rodney king so one person’s video sent to mainstream media not only

video sent to mainstream media not only

video sent to mainstream media not only changed California but it changed the

changed California but it changed the

changed California but it changed the world forever so what does social media

world forever so what does social media

world forever so what does social media due to that landscape well social media

due to that landscape well social media

due to that landscape well social media gives everyday people the opportunity to

gives everyday people the opportunity to

gives everyday people the opportunity to hide behind a veil to produce content

hide behind a veil to produce content

hide behind a veil to produce content that has both local and national and

that has both local and national and

that has both local and national and global significance but there’s no

global significance but there’s no

global significance but there’s no credibility or there’s no sanctions

credibility or there’s no sanctions

credibility or there’s no sanctions attached to what they’re doing whether

attached to what they’re doing whether

attached to what they’re doing whether it’s factual right wrong good or bad and

it’s factual right wrong good or bad and

it’s factual right wrong good or bad and so I think that when you look at the

so I think that when you look at the

so I think that when you look at the landscape it’s important for us to ask

landscape it’s important for us to ask

landscape it’s important for us to ask them questions journalists have a code

them questions journalists have a code

them questions journalists have a code of ethics that they have to follow and

of ethics that they have to follow and

of ethics that they have to follow and this code of ethics is not anything that

this code of ethics is not anything that

this code of ethics is not anything that you sign off on contractually as a

you sign off on contractually as a

you sign off on contractually as a journalist is something that you abide

journalist is something that you abide

journalist is something that you abide by and for everyday people that are

by and for everyday people that are

by and for everyday people that are producing news or that used social media

producing news or that used social media

producing news or that used social media landscape to produce news like I said

landscape to produce news like I said

landscape to produce news like I said there aren’t any sanctions but think

there aren’t any sanctions but think

there aren’t any sanctions but think about some things I want to share some

about some things I want to share some

about some things I want to share some stories so Jaison Blair was a rising

stories so Jaison Blair was a rising

stories so Jaison Blair was a rising star in the world of journalism and in

star in the world of journalism and in

star in the world of journalism and in 2003 he was working for the York Times

2003 he was working for the York Times

2003 he was working for the York Times and they launched an investigation and

and they launched an investigation and

and they launched an investigation and found that out of 76 articles 33 of

found that out of 76 articles 33 of

found that out of 76 articles 33 of those articles contain instances of

those articles contain instances of

those articles contain instances of plagiarism fabrication or pure unethical

plagiarism fabrication or pure unethical

plagiarism fabrication or pure unethical behavior and what about brian williams

behavior and what about brian williams

behavior and what about brian williams who had to retract a story in which he

who had to retract a story in which he

who had to retract a story in which he shared that he was in a helicopter that

shared that he was in a helicopter that

shared that he was in a helicopter that was hit by enemy ground fire well he was

was hit by enemy ground fire well he was

was hit by enemy ground fire well he was covering the news in iraq and it hasn’t

covering the news in iraq and it hasn’t

covering the news in iraq and it hasn’t been a year since NBC severed ties with

been a year since NBC severed ties with

been a year since NBC severed ties with billy bush as a result of some

billy bush as a result of some

billy bush as a result of some inappropriate audio that was leaked to

inappropriate audio that was leaked to

inappropriate audio that was leaked to the media so I share these examples to

the media so I share these examples to

the media so I share these examples to drive home the point these three

drive home the point these three

drive home the point these three journalists their careers were impacted

journalists their careers were impacted

journalists their careers were impacted and probably one of the things that they

and probably one of the things that they

and probably one of the things that they lost was their credibility your news

lost was their credibility your news

lost was their credibility your news value as journalists but everyday

value as journalists but everyday

value as journalists but everyday citizens like you and me we take to this

citizens like you and me we take to this

citizens like you and me we take to this entertainment medium and we can talk

entertainment medium and we can talk

entertainment medium and we can talk about anything that we want to we can

about anything that we want to we can

about anything that we want to we can create threads of angry chatter we can

create threads of angry chatter we can

create threads of angry chatter we can create a space for positive and healthy

create a space for positive and healthy

create a space for positive and healthy discourse depending on what our

discourse depending on what our

discourse depending on what our intentions are and so I think for

intentions are and so I think for

intentions are and so I think for citizen journalists out there that

citizen journalists out there that

citizen journalists out there that really want to do this and that really

really want to do this and that really

really want to do this and that really want to have an impact I have three

want to have an impact I have three

want to have an impact I have three points that I want you to consider the

points that I want you to consider the

points that I want you to consider the first is to have good intentions so what

first is to have good intentions so what

first is to have good intentions so what is your purpose behind posting behind

is your purpose behind posting behind

is your purpose behind posting behind engaging on social media to begin with

engaging on social media to begin with

engaging on social media to begin with is it to be controversial and if so do

is it to be controversial and if so do

is it to be controversial and if so do your controversial actions have an

your controversial actions have an

your controversial actions have an intended outcome that’s going to impact

intended outcome that’s going to impact

intended outcome that’s going to impact the greater good in a positive way is

the greater good in a positive way is

the greater good in a positive way is your goal to become the next social

your goal to become the next social

your goal to become the next social media star I would have a problem with

media star I would have a problem with

media star I would have a problem with that if I could be a million-dollar

that if I could be a million-dollar

that if I could be a million-dollar social media star right now my TED talk

social media star right now my TED talk

social media star right now my TED talk would be teaching you all how to do it

would be teaching you all how to do it

would be teaching you all how to do it too but when you take to social media

too but when you take to social media

too but when you take to social media and you’re using words that are so

and you’re using words that are so

and you’re using words that are so powerful what impact does that have on

powerful what impact does that have on

powerful what impact does that have on the traditional field of journalism it

the traditional field of journalism it

the traditional field of journalism it has a significant impact so again what

has a significant impact so again what

has a significant impact so again what are your intentions so one of the

are your intentions so one of the

are your intentions so one of the movements that I think was directly

movements that I think was directly

movements that I think was directly connected to social activism and citizen

connected to social activism and citizen

connected to social activism and citizen journalism was that of the black lives

journalism was that of the black lives

journalism was that of the black lives matter movement and I think that it

matter movement and I think that it

matter movement and I think that it started with good intentions and it

started with good intentions and it

started with good intentions and it still does have good intentions although

still does have good intentions although

still does have good intentions although was impacted by outliers such as hatred

was impacted by outliers such as hatred

was impacted by outliers such as hatred misunderstanding and a loss of momentum

misunderstanding and a loss of momentum

misunderstanding and a loss of momentum at one point what’s what this is done

at one point what’s what this is done

at one point what’s what this is done it’s moved from being a hashtag to being

it’s moved from being a hashtag to being

it’s moved from being a hashtag to being a space in which citizen journalists are

a space in which citizen journalists are

a space in which citizen journalists are now sharing the stories in which law

now sharing the stories in which law

now sharing the stories in which law enforcement are coming together with

enforcement are coming together with

enforcement are coming together with communities across the country to fix

communities across the country to fix

communities across the country to fix what has been a long-standing fractured

what has been a long-standing fractured

what has been a long-standing fractured relationship and I don’t think that we

relationship and I don’t think that we

relationship and I don’t think that we would have as much attention on the

would have as much attention on the

would have as much attention on the positives

positives

positives if it weren’t for citizen journalists

if it weren’t for citizen journalists

if it weren’t for citizen journalists everyday people like you and I who are

everyday people like you and I who are

everyday people like you and I who are recounting these stories who are sharing

recounting these stories who are sharing

recounting these stories who are sharing these stories their personal stories so

these stories their personal stories so

these stories their personal stories so again what are your intentions the

again what are your intentions the

again what are your intentions the second one is to be responsible for your

second one is to be responsible for your

second one is to be responsible for your content how many of you went on social

content how many of you went on social

content how many of you went on social media this morning and posted something

media this morning and posted something

media this morning and posted something raise your hands I really can’t because

raise your hands I really can’t because

raise your hands I really can’t because a lot of us so and sometimes you just

a lot of us so and sometimes you just

a lot of us so and sometimes you just it’s based on how you feel you just type

it’s based on how you feel you just type

it’s based on how you feel you just type and you know you hit Send or whatever

and you know you hit Send or whatever

and you know you hit Send or whatever the button you sent you had you hit the

the button you sent you had you hit the

the button you sent you had you hit the button and boom it’s gone and then if

button and boom it’s gone and then if

button and boom it’s gone and then if you’re like me you go back and check

you’re like me you go back and check

you’re like me you go back and check like every few minutes to see how many

like every few minutes to see how many

like every few minutes to see how many likes you got if you got any shares but

likes you got if you got any shares but

likes you got if you got any shares but you’re really not doing anything to harm

you’re really not doing anything to harm

you’re really not doing anything to harm anyone because your content is not

anyone because your content is not

anyone because your content is not designed that way it’s not designed to

designed that way it’s not designed to

designed that way it’s not designed to do harm it’s designed just to share to

do harm it’s designed just to share to

do harm it’s designed just to share to be your self expression but because

be your self expression but because

be your self expression but because there’s so much fake news and because of

there’s so much fake news and because of

there’s so much fake news and because of the rising fake news as people view it

the rising fake news as people view it

the rising fake news as people view it through the lens of social media

through the lens of social media

through the lens of social media practitioners some folks believe that

practitioners some folks believe that

practitioners some folks believe that that social media needs to have a legal

that social media needs to have a legal

that social media needs to have a legal context to it so that we can help to

context to it so that we can help to

context to it so that we can help to flush out the fake news now fake news

flush out the fake news now fake news

flush out the fake news now fake news didn’t just happen as a result of the

didn’t just happen as a result of the

didn’t just happen as a result of the social media wave it’s been around for a

social media wave it’s been around for a

social media wave it’s been around for a long time but I think when you have

long time but I think when you have

long time but I think when you have something like a social media tool where

something like a social media tool where

something like a social media tool where news can travel fast or seemingly than

news can travel fast or seemingly than

news can travel fast or seemingly than the speed of light you have to be

the speed of light you have to be

the speed of light you have to be concerned about the power of those words

concerned about the power of those words

concerned about the power of those words that are being shared and so you have to

that are being shared and so you have to

that are being shared and so you have to ask yourself am I putting out junk or

ask yourself am I putting out junk or

ask yourself am I putting out junk or chatter or am I putting out real news

chatter or am I putting out real news

chatter or am I putting out real news and how does what I create as a citizen

and how does what I create as a citizen

and how does what I create as a citizen journalists impacts the field which

journalists impacts the field which

journalists impacts the field which leads me to my last point value the

leads me to my last point value the

leads me to my last point value the profession at heart I’m a journalist and

profession at heart I’m a journalist and

profession at heart I’m a journalist and it’s really important for me to engage

it’s really important for me to engage

it’s really important for me to engage in storytelling and one of the things

in storytelling and one of the things

in storytelling and one of the things that I think about social media and

that I think about social media and

that I think about social media and citizen journalism is it allows the real

citizen journalism is it allows the real

citizen journalism is it allows the real story to be told everyday people who are

story to be told everyday people who are

story to be told everyday people who are living and breathing in a situation are

living and breathing in a situation are

living and breathing in a situation are telling their story they’re telling

telling their story they’re telling

telling their story they’re telling their story unedited they don’t have to

their story unedited they don’t have to

their story unedited they don’t have to worry about a word count for a print

worry about a word count for a print

worry about a word count for a print medium they don’t have to worry about a

medium they don’t have to worry about a

medium they don’t have to worry about a timeframe for a new story and here’s the

timeframe for a new story and here’s the

timeframe for a new story and here’s the best part they’re doing it in an

best part they’re doing it in an

best part they’re doing it in an environment that is not profit driven or

environment that is not profit driven or

environment that is not profit driven or at least not yet so let’s hope we can

at least not yet so let’s hope we can

at least not yet so let’s hope we can keep it that way

keep it that way

keep it that way so it’s really important to have this

so it’s really important to have this

so it’s really important to have this intersection of understanding between

intersection of understanding between

intersection of understanding between traditional paid journalists and amateur

traditional paid journalists and amateur

traditional paid journalists and amateur journalists who are passionate about

journalists who are passionate about

journalists who are passionate about some things that they talk about on a

some things that they talk about on a

some things that they talk about on a regular basis and who have developed a

regular basis and who have developed a

regular basis and who have developed a really strong following of people who

really strong following of people who

really strong following of people who share similar concerns and so I love

share similar concerns and so I love

share similar concerns and so I love social media I am one of those 40 some

social media I am one of those 40 some

social media I am one of those 40 some people who took over facebook from all

people who took over facebook from all

people who took over facebook from all the young kids out there and i’m proud

the young kids out there and i’m proud

the young kids out there and i’m proud to say thank you Mark Zuckerberg for

to say thank you Mark Zuckerberg for

to say thank you Mark Zuckerberg for making it the mom and dad platform but

making it the mom and dad platform but

making it the mom and dad platform but you will rarely see my journalistic

you will rarely see my journalistic

you will rarely see my journalistic acumen come to life on social media

acumen come to life on social media

acumen come to life on social media because there’s something that I value

because there’s something that I value

because there’s something that I value about traditional news delivery and I’m

about traditional news delivery and I’m

about traditional news delivery and I’m always amazed at my students who will at

always amazed at my students who will at

always amazed at my students who will at the beginning of class because you can

the beginning of class because you can

the beginning of class because you can never get away from a cell phone in a

never get away from a cell phone in a

never get away from a cell phone in a class so if you can incorporate it in

class so if you can incorporate it in

class so if you can incorporate it in your class you know the 90 minutes go by

your class you know the 90 minutes go by

your class you know the 90 minutes go by a lot quicker so I always you know ask

a lot quicker so I always you know ask

a lot quicker so I always you know ask kids what’s happening in the world tell

kids what’s happening in the world tell

kids what’s happening in the world tell me what’s going on and the first thing

me what’s going on and the first thing

me what’s going on and the first thing they do is go to social media they won’t

they do is go to social media they won’t

they do is go to social media they won’t go to a c-span com or a CNN com or they

go to a c-span com or a CNN com or they

go to a c-span com or a CNN com or they won’t pull up a you know New York Times

won’t pull up a you know New York Times

won’t pull up a you know New York Times paper they’ll go to social media and

paper they’ll go to social media and

paper they’ll go to social media and then they’ll go to another social media

then they’ll go to another social media

then they’ll go to another social media platform to do their fact-checking so

platform to do their fact-checking so

platform to do their fact-checking so the reality is we’re all looking for

the reality is we’re all looking for

the reality is we’re all looking for shortcuts in terms of consuming news and

shortcuts in terms of consuming news and

shortcuts in terms of consuming news and information it’s important we live in a

information it’s important we live in a

information it’s important we live in a fast-paced world we’re always moving we

fast-paced world we’re always moving we

fast-paced world we’re always moving we really don’t have time to do the hard

really don’t have time to do the hard

really don’t have time to do the hard core research that we need to do that

core research that we need to do that

core research that we need to do that being said all the more reason for an

being said all the more reason for an

being said all the more reason for an ethical thread to be woven through this

ethical thread to be woven through this

ethical thread to be woven through this process now the society of professional

process now the society of professional

process now the society of professional journalism does have a series of points

journalism does have a series of points

journalism does have a series of points in terms of their ethical code of

in terms of their ethical code of

in terms of their ethical code of conduct and there may include but

conduct and there may include but

conduct and there may include but they’re not limited to things like being

they’re not limited to things like being

they’re not limited to things like being responsible for the accuracy of your

responsible for the accuracy of your

responsible for the accuracy of your work making sure that you don’t take

work making sure that you don’t take

work making sure that you don’t take shortcuts or oversimplify what you’re

shortcuts or oversimplify what you’re

shortcuts or oversimplify what you’re putting out there staying away from

putting out there staying away from

putting out there staying away from stereotypes and making sure that you

stereotypes and making sure that you

stereotypes and making sure that you stick to the facts and in creating a

stick to the facts and in creating a

stick to the facts and in creating a space in which we can engage in

space in which we can engage in

space in which we can engage in discourse and accept an eval you dear

discourse and accept an eval you dear

discourse and accept an eval you dear pinions of others even if we don’t like

pinions of others even if we don’t like

pinions of others even if we don’t like the things that other people have to say

the things that other people have to say

the things that other people have to say and so I think

and so I think

and so I think ethical journalism matters it matters at

ethical journalism matters it matters at

ethical journalism matters it matters at all levels whether you are a paid

all levels whether you are a paid

all levels whether you are a paid trained professional whether you’re an

trained professional whether you’re an

trained professional whether you’re an unpaid amateur journalists and so if

unpaid amateur journalists and so if

unpaid amateur journalists and so if you’re a citizen journalists out there

you’re a citizen journalists out there

you’re a citizen journalists out there continue the work if you’re a budding

continue the work if you’re a budding

continue the work if you’re a budding citizen journalists start your career

citizen journalists start your career

citizen journalists start your career with the foundation in ethics I think

with the foundation in ethics I think

with the foundation in ethics I think the revolution will continue to be

the revolution will continue to be

the revolution will continue to be televised maybe not in the same way but

televised maybe not in the same way but

televised maybe not in the same way but we know that for the next four years

we know that for the next four years

we know that for the next four years it’s going to be tweeted about you’re

it’s going to be tweeted about you’re

it’s going to be tweeted about you’re going to see it on snapchat you’re going

going to see it on snapchat you’re going

going to see it on snapchat you’re going to see it on Instagram thanks to my

to see it on Instagram thanks to my

to see it on Instagram thanks to my students you’ll see it on Facebook live

students you’ll see it on Facebook live

students you’ll see it on Facebook live but how will you be impacted the next

but how will you be impacted the next

but how will you be impacted the next time you snap a picture record a video

time you snap a picture record a video

time you snap a picture record a video read write or post thank

read write or post thank

read write or post thank [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *