
so in 2015 I started the young American journalist grant I remember my plane
journalist grant I remember my plane
journalist grant I remember my plane landing in life sees an East German city
landing in life sees an East German city
landing in life sees an East German city not far from Berlin and I was ecstatic I
not far from Berlin and I was ecstatic I
not far from Berlin and I was ecstatic I was fresh out of grad school and I was
was fresh out of grad school and I was
was fresh out of grad school and I was here to talk with farmers about how they
here to talk with farmers about how they
here to talk with farmers about how they use antibiotics or how they feel about
use antibiotics or how they feel about
use antibiotics or how they feel about regulations regarding antibiotic I know
regulations regarding antibiotic I know
regulations regarding antibiotic I know antibiotics in agriculture and I was
antibiotics in agriculture and I was
antibiotics in agriculture and I was especially curious whether US farmers
especially curious whether US farmers
especially curious whether US farmers would face similar challenges when a
would face similar challenges when a
would face similar challenges when a similar policy went into effect and I
similar policy went into effect and I
similar policy went into effect and I won’t bore you with all the details or
won’t bore you with all the details or
won’t bore you with all the details or why you’ve done with it but more or less
why you’ve done with it but more or less
why you’ve done with it but more or less it would require veterinary oversight so
it would require veterinary oversight so
it would require veterinary oversight so you couldn’t just give it to your
you couldn’t just give it to your
you couldn’t just give it to your animals when you want it to it was also
animals when you want it to it was also
animals when you want it to it was also around this time that big newsrooms like
around this time that big newsrooms like
around this time that big newsrooms like the New York Times in The Guardian they
the New York Times in The Guardian they
the New York Times in The Guardian they were publishing their own texts about an
were publishing their own texts about an
were publishing their own texts about an apocalyptic post-antibiotic era a time
apocalyptic post-antibiotic era a time
apocalyptic post-antibiotic era a time when superbugs would run rampant and
when superbugs would run rampant and
when superbugs would run rampant and common infections would no longer be
common infections would no longer be
common infections would no longer be curable due to antibiotic resistance and
curable due to antibiotic resistance and
curable due to antibiotic resistance and you can think of antibiotic resistance
you can think of antibiotic resistance
you can think of antibiotic resistance as a type of natural stalemate that
as a type of natural stalemate that
as a type of natural stalemate that occurs as an as pathogens are exposed to
occurs as an as pathogens are exposed to
occurs as an as pathogens are exposed to antibiotics over time but for me it was
antibiotics over time but for me it was
antibiotics over time but for me it was always a little bit too abstract too
always a little bit too abstract too
always a little bit too abstract too distant we had germs these microscopic
distant we had germs these microscopic
distant we had germs these microscopic cellular organisms things you can’t see
cellular organisms things you can’t see
cellular organisms things you can’t see with the human eye affecting thousands
with the human eye affecting thousands
with the human eye affecting thousands of people and costing hundreds of
of people and costing hundreds of
of people and costing hundreds of thousands of dollars headlines were
thousands of dollars headlines were
thousands of dollars headlines were sensationalistic if not dramatic
sensationalistic if not dramatic
sensationalistic if not dramatic antibiotic freeze nightmare bacteria
antibiotic freeze nightmare bacteria
antibiotic freeze nightmare bacteria superbugs every now and then I’d find a
superbugs every now and then I’d find a
superbugs every now and then I’d find a paragraph about a pharmaceutical
paragraph about a pharmaceutical
paragraph about a pharmaceutical companies reluctance to pour millions of
companies reluctance to pour millions of
companies reluctance to pour millions of dollars into antibiotic research simply
dollars into antibiotic research simply
dollars into antibiotic research simply because the drugs are you so sparingly
because the drugs are you so sparingly
because the drugs are you so sparingly they don’t turn a profit so zero return
they don’t turn a profit so zero return
they don’t turn a profit so zero return means zero incentive or I’d hear a
means zero incentive or I’d hear a
means zero incentive or I’d hear a little bit about the importance of
little bit about the importance of
little bit about the importance of making sure physicians prescribed
making sure physicians prescribed
making sure physicians prescribed antibiotics in a proper fashion to make
antibiotics in a proper fashion to make
antibiotics in a proper fashion to make sure to make sure they retain their
sure to make sure they retain their
sure to make sure they retain their efficacy
but what was missing were pieces of the
but what was missing were pieces of the puzzle explaining what was happening on
puzzle explaining what was happening on
puzzle explaining what was happening on the ground how were these policies being
the ground how were these policies being
the ground how were these policies being implemented and how were the individuals
implemented and how were the individuals
implemented and how were the individuals implementing them being affected this is
implementing them being affected this is
implementing them being affected this is what drew me to Germany they had
what drew me to Germany they had
what drew me to Germany they had recently made such policy changes and
recently made such policy changes and
recently made such policy changes and the EU has a very impressive huge
the EU has a very impressive huge
the EU has a very impressive huge database with impressive data sets
database with impressive data sets
database with impressive data sets looking at not only antibiotic
looking at not only antibiotic
looking at not only antibiotic resistance trends but antibiotic usage
resistance trends but antibiotic usage
resistance trends but antibiotic usage and I found myself looking for sources
and I found myself looking for sources
and I found myself looking for sources as I went about my reporting process who
as I went about my reporting process who
as I went about my reporting process who was I going to talk to and I started
was I going to talk to and I started
was I going to talk to and I started with the pig and dairy farmers I started
with the pig and dairy farmers I started
with the pig and dairy farmers I started with farming associations the head of
with farming associations the head of
with farming associations the head of the FDA in Brussels the head the
the FDA in Brussels the head the
the FDA in Brussels the head the president of the FAO
president of the FAO
president of the FAO retired employees of the FDA university
retired employees of the FDA university
retired employees of the FDA university researchers and experts who presented at
researchers and experts who presented at
researchers and experts who presented at conferences like the World Health Summit
conferences like the World Health Summit
conferences like the World Health Summit or the joint programming initiative on
or the joint programming initiative on
or the joint programming initiative on antimicrobial resistance in Stockholm
antimicrobial resistance in Stockholm
antimicrobial resistance in Stockholm and I’d like to say that access was easy
and I’d like to say that access was easy
and I’d like to say that access was easy but it wasn’t sometimes a source would
but it wasn’t sometimes a source would
but it wasn’t sometimes a source would take a month and my farmers took five
take a month and my farmers took five
take a month and my farmers took five before they were even willing to talk
before they were even willing to talk
before they were even willing to talk with me and I think this is due in part
with me and I think this is due in part
with me and I think this is due in part to a broad definition of media which
to a broad definition of media which
to a broad definition of media which makes it very difficult for news
makes it very difficult for news
makes it very difficult for news consumers to distinguish between
consumers to distinguish between
consumers to distinguish between journalism and entertainment fact and
journalism and entertainment fact and
journalism and entertainment fact and fiction credible and non credible the
fiction credible and non credible the
fiction credible and non credible the intersections are many they’re complex
intersections are many they’re complex
intersections are many they’re complex and they’re increasingly blurred this
and they’re increasingly blurred this
and they’re increasingly blurred this fuels have persistent hesitancy people
fuels have persistent hesitancy people
fuels have persistent hesitancy people have when engaging with the media will
have when engaging with the media will
have when engaging with the media will we be fair will we use misuse your trust
we be fair will we use misuse your trust
we be fair will we use misuse your trust are we going to be honest about our
are we going to be honest about our
are we going to be honest about our intentions and I think this stems from a
intentions and I think this stems from a
intentions and I think this stems from a misunderstanding of how to engage with
misunderstanding of how to engage with
misunderstanding of how to engage with one another fundamentally science and
one another fundamentally science and
one another fundamentally science and journalism actually have quite a lot in
journalism actually have quite a lot in
journalism actually have quite a lot in common
common
common it starts with a question I hypothesis
it starts with a question I hypothesis
it starts with a question I hypothesis that evolves as more information comes
that evolves as more information comes
that evolves as more information comes to light and if you think about the
to light and if you think about the
to light and if you think about the similarities you also want to make sure
similarities you also want to make sure
similarities you also want to make sure that you can interact with one another
that you can interact with one another
that you can interact with one another that you feel confident in that
that you feel confident in that
that you feel confident in that situation in the process of reporting my
situation in the process of reporting my
situation in the process of reporting my stories
stories
stories I had to rely on what I learned from my
I had to rely on what I learned from my
I had to rely on what I learned from my sources and each story was different but
sources and each story was different but
sources and each story was different but what I learned fundamentally was that
what I learned fundamentally was that
what I learned fundamentally was that people were very surprised to learn that
people were very surprised to learn that
people were very surprised to learn that journalism is not simply the
journalism is not simply the
journalism is not simply the presentation or regurgitation of facts
presentation or regurgitation of facts
presentation or regurgitation of facts but is instead a process that requires
but is instead a process that requires
but is instead a process that requires looking at information skeptically and
looking at information skeptically and
looking at information skeptically and critically with the help of experts
critically with the help of experts
critically with the help of experts which also includes acknowledging your
which also includes acknowledging your
which also includes acknowledging your own biases great journalism occurs when
own biases great journalism occurs when
own biases great journalism occurs when it informs and contextualizes while
it informs and contextualizes while
it informs and contextualizes while emotionally engaging your audience it’s
emotionally engaging your audience it’s
emotionally engaging your audience it’s not as easy as it sounds if it were
not as easy as it sounds if it were
not as easy as it sounds if it were researchers would be making their
researchers would be making their
researchers would be making their journal articles a lot more fun to read
journal articles a lot more fun to read
journal articles a lot more fun to read most journalists strive for this ideal
most journalists strive for this ideal
most journalists strive for this ideal so contextually and emotionally engage
so contextually and emotionally engage
so contextually and emotionally engage but there are some that report for their
but there are some that report for their
but there are some that report for their byline for that ego but this is the
byline for that ego but this is the
byline for that ego but this is the exception not the rule most journalists
exception not the rule most journalists
exception not the rule most journalists do this work because they care you don’t
do this work because they care you don’t
do this work because they care you don’t have to look far for great journalism
have to look far for great journalism
have to look far for great journalism there’s Carl Zimmer of stat Marin
there’s Carl Zimmer of stat Marin
there’s Carl Zimmer of stat Marin McKenna of National Geographic and coral
McKenna of National Geographic and coral
McKenna of National Geographic and coral Davenport of the New York Times and
Davenport of the New York Times and
Davenport of the New York Times and their work if anything has proven that
their work if anything has proven that
their work if anything has proven that there’s an appetite for science
there’s an appetite for science
there’s an appetite for science journalism journalists need individuals
journalism journalists need individuals
journalism journalists need individuals willing to share their observations
willing to share their observations
willing to share their observations professionals who have spent their
professionals who have spent their
professionals who have spent their careers studying and focusing on
careers studying and focusing on
careers studying and focusing on important issues like artificial
important issues like artificial
important issues like artificial intelligence antimicrobial resistance or
intelligence antimicrobial resistance or
intelligence antimicrobial resistance or mRNA vaccines and this is true not just
mRNA vaccines and this is true not just
mRNA vaccines and this is true not just across Sciences but across all fields my
across Sciences but across all fields my
across Sciences but across all fields my father always said to me people have
father always said to me people have
father always said to me people have stories to tell you just have to listen
stories to tell you just have to listen
stories to tell you just have to listen and it was exactly these stories that I
and it was exactly these stories that I
and it was exactly these stories that I heard from my sources and through my own
heard from my sources and through my own
heard from my sources and through my own experiences that helped me note a big
experiences that helped me note a big
experiences that helped me note a big difference in the way that the u.s.
difference in the way that the u.s.
difference in the way that the u.s. presents antibiotic use data and the way
presents antibiotic use data and the way
presents antibiotic use data and the way that the European Union and Germany does
that the European Union and Germany does
that the European Union and Germany does the European Union already provides a
the European Union already provides a
the European Union already provides a country-by-country breakdown that is
country-by-country breakdown that is
country-by-country breakdown that is further broken down across region and
further broken down across region and
further broken down across region and state in Germany the you
state in Germany the you
state in Germany the you has yet to break it down across
has yet to break it down across
has yet to break it down across state-by-state it’s roughly a ten-year
state-by-state it’s roughly a ten-year
state-by-state it’s roughly a ten-year difference if you look at when the
difference if you look at when the
difference if you look at when the program started and without this data no
program started and without this data no
program started and without this data no meaningful trends can be found you can’t
meaningful trends can be found you can’t
meaningful trends can be found you can’t make a generalization there’s just not
make a generalization there’s just not
make a generalization there’s just not enough information and I found myself
enough information and I found myself
enough information and I found myself wondering why this was the case and I
wondering why this was the case and I
wondering why this was the case and I was a little bit disheartened to find
was a little bit disheartened to find
was a little bit disheartened to find that there wasn’t enough data to make an
that there wasn’t enough data to make an
that there wasn’t enough data to make an assumption or an assessment to me this
assumption or an assessment to me this
assumption or an assessment to me this is fascinating stuff this is the
is fascinating stuff this is the
is fascinating stuff this is the intersection of Health and Environment
intersection of Health and Environment
intersection of Health and Environment and animals and who else but a
and animals and who else but a
and animals and who else but a journalist has the resources and the
journalist has the resources and the
journalist has the resources and the time to look at these issues in closer
time to look at these issues in closer
time to look at these issues in closer detail journalists believe it or not are
detail journalists believe it or not are
detail journalists believe it or not are necessary we serve as an outset set of
necessary we serve as an outset set of
necessary we serve as an outset set of eyes to look at these issues and it’s
eyes to look at these issues and it’s
eyes to look at these issues and it’s our job to be transparent and I don’t
our job to be transparent and I don’t
our job to be transparent and I don’t mean to say that journalists don’t bring
mean to say that journalists don’t bring
mean to say that journalists don’t bring their own opinions or object our
their own opinions or object our
their own opinions or object our assumptions to the table but through our
assumptions to the table but through our
assumptions to the table but through our evidence through our sourcing and
evidence through our sourcing and
evidence through our sourcing and through the production process there’s
through the production process there’s
through the production process there’s an element of transparency I myself grew
an element of transparency I myself grew
an element of transparency I myself grew enthusiastic about the way Germany
enthusiastic about the way Germany
enthusiastic about the way Germany managed antibiotic use but I was also
managed antibiotic use but I was also
managed antibiotic use but I was also disheartened because the researchers on
disheartened because the researchers on
disheartened because the researchers on the ground who were working so hard to
the ground who were working so hard to
the ground who were working so hard to make this data available for us very
make this data available for us very
make this data available for us very rarely had recognition or knew what or
rarely had recognition or knew what or
rarely had recognition or knew what or really did it come to light what they
really did it come to light what they
really did it come to light what they were actually doing and this is a piece
were actually doing and this is a piece
were actually doing and this is a piece that’s very important and missing in the
that’s very important and missing in the
that’s very important and missing in the focus of making their own advancements
focus of making their own advancements
focus of making their own advancements researchers forget to tell their own
researchers forget to tell their own
researchers forget to tell their own stories stories it’s very much need to
stories stories it’s very much need to
stories stories it’s very much need to be told especially outside of their own
be told especially outside of their own
be told especially outside of their own research or research communities and the
research or research communities and the
research or research communities and the scientific field so how can I as a
scientific field so how can I as a
scientific field so how can I as a journalist help researchers share their
journalist help researchers share their
journalist help researchers share their stories and how can researchers help us
stories and how can researchers help us
stories and how can researchers help us maybe you’re a farmer a researcher or a
maybe you’re a farmer a researcher or a
maybe you’re a farmer a researcher or a politician and one day you might find
politician and one day you might find
politician and one day you might find yourself face to face with a journalist
yourself face to face with a journalist
yourself face to face with a journalist and instead of feeling hesitate
and instead of feeling hesitate
and instead of feeling hesitate or disinterested I’d hope you’d feel
or disinterested I’d hope you’d feel
or disinterested I’d hope you’d feel eager willing to engage with them and
eager willing to engage with them and
eager willing to engage with them and tell them a little bit about what you
tell them a little bit about what you
tell them a little bit about what you know remembering that your experiences
know remembering that your experiences
know remembering that your experiences are part of a large complex puzzle
are part of a large complex puzzle
are part of a large complex puzzle that’s why I have a couple of tips for
that’s why I have a couple of tips for
that’s why I have a couple of tips for interacting with journalists that I’d
interacting with journalists that I’d
interacting with journalists that I’d like to give you today the first is to
like to give you today the first is to
like to give you today the first is to use analogies and metaphors finding a
use analogies and metaphors finding a
use analogies and metaphors finding a way to explain complex topics in a
way to explain complex topics in a
way to explain complex topics in a simple way is very effective yes you
simple way is very effective yes you
simple way is very effective yes you have a professional role but you might
have a professional role but you might
have a professional role but you might also be a nice or an uncle how would you
also be a nice or an uncle how would you
also be a nice or an uncle how would you explain a topic to your cousin or your
explain a topic to your cousin or your
explain a topic to your cousin or your your daughter you wouldn’t just say DNA
your daughter you wouldn’t just say DNA
your daughter you wouldn’t just say DNA is deoxyribonucleic acid
is deoxyribonucleic acid
is deoxyribonucleic acid you’d say DNA is a blueprint for
you’d say DNA is a blueprint for
you’d say DNA is a blueprint for creating cells or an instruction manual
creating cells or an instruction manual
creating cells or an instruction manual and be careful with the analogies and
and be careful with the analogies and
and be careful with the analogies and metaphors you use because sometimes they
metaphors you use because sometimes they
metaphors you use because sometimes they can distort you need to really see what
can distort you need to really see what
can distort you need to really see what the professional level of the journalist
the professional level of the journalist
the professional level of the journalist is when you interact the next is to kill
is when you interact the next is to kill
is when you interact the next is to kill jargon not everyone knows what you know
jargon not everyone knows what you know
jargon not everyone knows what you know you’ve studied so instead of saying
you’ve studied so instead of saying
you’ve studied so instead of saying something like this is incredibly so
something like this is incredibly so
something like this is incredibly so linic just say it’s salty or high in
linic just say it’s salty or high in
linic just say it’s salty or high in salt this is so much more effective the
salt this is so much more effective the
salt this is so much more effective the next thing is to keep an open mind yes
next thing is to keep an open mind yes
next thing is to keep an open mind yes you want things presented in a
you want things presented in a
you want things presented in a particular way but we’re trying to make
particular way but we’re trying to make
particular way but we’re trying to make it accessible for as many people as
it accessible for as many people as
it accessible for as many people as possible some of whom don’t have
possible some of whom don’t have
possible some of whom don’t have scientific literacy work with the
scientific literacy work with the
scientific literacy work with the journalists to find a middle ground next
journalists to find a middle ground next
journalists to find a middle ground next is to provide access whether that’s
is to provide access whether that’s
is to provide access whether that’s access to you as a professional or
access to you as a professional or
access to you as a professional or access to a study it does wonders I
access to a study it does wonders I
access to a study it does wonders I would often draft 10 to 15 questions
would often draft 10 to 15 questions
would often draft 10 to 15 questions went before I reached out to a primary
went before I reached out to a primary
went before I reached out to a primary investigator and only having looked at
investigator and only having looked at
investigator and only having looked at the abstract of their study but once I
the abstract of their study but once I
the abstract of their study but once I had the study I could look at the
had the study I could look at the
had the study I could look at the methods I could look at who funded it I
methods I could look at who funded it I
methods I could look at who funded it I could look at a number of different
could look at a number of different
could look at a number of different things that dropped the number of
things that dropped the number of
things that dropped the number of questions I had down to five or six
questions I had down to five or six
questions I had down to five or six essentially saving then
essentially saving then
essentially saving then time and me time as well the next is to
time and me time as well the next is to
time and me time as well the next is to say feel free to say off the record if
say feel free to say off the record if
say feel free to say off the record if you don’t want information attributed to
you don’t want information attributed to
you don’t want information attributed to you maybe it’s important contextually
you maybe it’s important contextually
you maybe it’s important contextually but you don’t really want it mentioned
but you don’t really want it mentioned
but you don’t really want it mentioned in the story every one of my farmers
in the story every one of my farmers
in the story every one of my farmers wanted to be anonymous they did not want
wanted to be anonymous they did not want
wanted to be anonymous they did not want to say what they really felt about the
to say what they really felt about the
to say what they really felt about the policies but these on background
policies but these on background
policies but these on background conversations were very helpful for me
conversations were very helpful for me
conversations were very helpful for me as I move through it in my reporting you
as I move through it in my reporting you
as I move through it in my reporting you should absolutely feel comfortable to do
should absolutely feel comfortable to do
should absolutely feel comfortable to do that remember that a journalist is not
that remember that a journalist is not
that remember that a journalist is not here for PR it is not our job to make
here for PR it is not our job to make
here for PR it is not our job to make you look good or your institution we’re
you look good or your institution we’re
you look good or your institution we’re going to talk with your colleagues and
going to talk with your colleagues and
going to talk with your colleagues and talk with your critics and try to figure
talk with your critics and try to figure
talk with your critics and try to figure out whether what you said can be
out whether what you said can be
out whether what you said can be verified just like in an experiment is
verified just like in an experiment is
verified just like in an experiment is it replicable is it verifiable
it replicable is it verifiable
it replicable is it verifiable titrations are really boring but it’s an
titrations are really boring but it’s an
titrations are really boring but it’s an idea and lastly keep an open mind
idea and lastly keep an open mind
idea and lastly keep an open mind oh let go yeah sorry you won’t be able
oh let go yeah sorry you won’t be able
oh let go yeah sorry you won’t be able to control everything that happens in
to control everything that happens in
to control everything that happens in the text and I never send a full copy to
the text and I never send a full copy to
the text and I never send a full copy to my sources before it’s done I don’t know
my sources before it’s done I don’t know
my sources before it’s done I don’t know any journalist who does but you should
any journalist who does but you should
any journalist who does but you should go back if a journalist does not reach
go back if a journalist does not reach
go back if a journalist does not reach out to you and asks to see your quotes
out to you and asks to see your quotes
out to you and asks to see your quotes have them read back to you and make sure
have them read back to you and make sure
have them read back to you and make sure that the dates and numbers and all of
that the dates and numbers and all of
that the dates and numbers and all of that has been accuracy checked this is
that has been accuracy checked this is
that has been accuracy checked this is beneficial to you and also to the
beneficial to you and also to the
beneficial to you and also to the journalists in my experience when
journalists in my experience when
journalists in my experience when science and journalism come together
science and journalism come together
science and journalism come together it’s a magical relationship they
it’s a magical relationship they
it’s a magical relationship they mutually benefit one another and it’s a
mutually benefit one another and it’s a
mutually benefit one another and it’s a great way to facilitate between
great way to facilitate between
great way to facilitate between researchers and the general public I
researchers and the general public I
researchers and the general public I think that there are so many topics like
think that there are so many topics like
think that there are so many topics like genetically modified organisms or cancer
genetically modified organisms or cancer
genetically modified organisms or cancer therapies or antidepressants these are
therapies or antidepressants these are
therapies or antidepressants these are topics which make headlines and they’re
topics which make headlines and they’re
topics which make headlines and they’re no longer limited to science sections
no longer limited to science sections
no longer limited to science sections but find themselves on as the centerfold
but find themselves on as the centerfold
but find themselves on as the centerfold of Business and Economics papers this is
of Business and Economics papers this is
of Business and Economics papers this is true today and will be true in the
true today and will be true in the
true today and will be true in the future and it’s my job as a journalist
future and it’s my job as a journalist
future and it’s my job as a journalist to to facilitate but also garner
to to facilitate but also garner
to to facilitate but also garner curiosity for the
curiosity for the
curiosity for the work that’s being done I want to make
work that’s being done I want to make
work that’s being done I want to make the science and technology accessible
the science and technology accessible
the science and technology accessible for anyone who finds themself interested
for anyone who finds themself interested
for anyone who finds themself interested in it and it’s my hope that by providing
in it and it’s my hope that by providing
in it and it’s my hope that by providing a small little glimpse into the world of
a small little glimpse into the world of
a small little glimpse into the world of journalism maybe if you do find a
journalism maybe if you do find a
journalism maybe if you do find a journalist at your door you will feel
journalist at your door you will feel
journalist at your door you will feel empowered and capable of taking on the
empowered and capable of taking on the
empowered and capable of taking on the challenge of communicating with them
challenge of communicating with them
challenge of communicating with them rather than keeping your own story
rather than keeping your own story
rather than keeping your own story behind closed doors thank you
”
Be First to Comment