Press "Enter" to skip to content

Walls, and where to put them. | Jennah Kriebel | TEDxAgroParisTech


we have a number of challenges you and I

we have a number of challenges you and I I speak American we’re doing this in

I speak American we’re doing this in

I speak American we’re doing this in English and my topic over the past week

English and my topic over the past week

English and my topic over the past week has gone from being relatively

has gone from being relatively

has gone from being relatively disturbing to a complete political

disturbing to a complete political

disturbing to a complete political disaster so what I want to do first of

disaster so what I want to do first of

disaster so what I want to do first of all just to ensure that you’re generally

all just to ensure that you’re generally

all just to ensure that you’re generally on the same page is introduce a meme

on the same page is introduce a meme

on the same page is introduce a meme that has been popular at least in my

that has been popular at least in my

that has been popular at least in my Facebook feeds and across the American

Facebook feeds and across the American

Facebook feeds and across the American landscape which is no band no wall yeah

landscape which is no band no wall yeah

landscape which is no band no wall yeah and I want to actually have you know

and I want to actually have you know

and I want to actually have you know you’ve got some energy after eating a

you’ve got some energy after eating a

you’ve got some energy after eating a little too say it with me so I’m going

little too say it with me so I’m going

little too say it with me so I’m going to insist so that at least we have this

to insist so that at least we have this

to insist so that at least we have this basis of understanding that we’re all

basis of understanding that we’re all

basis of understanding that we’re all generally on the same page otherwise I’m

generally on the same page otherwise I’m

generally on the same page otherwise I’m going to have a heart attack talking

going to have a heart attack talking

going to have a heart attack talking about walls this week at this moment

about walls this week at this moment

about walls this week at this moment being an American

in this way we start off with an

in this way we start off with an understanding that we are all generally

understanding that we are all generally

understanding that we are all generally on the same side this discussion which

on the same side this discussion which

on the same side this discussion which allows us the space maybe to talk about

allows us the space maybe to talk about

allows us the space maybe to talk about the original premise of my talk which

the original premise of my talk which

the original premise of my talk which predates the politics of this week which

predates the politics of this week which

predates the politics of this week which is to look at walls effective on the

is to look at walls effective on the

is to look at walls effective on the first slide the nineteen before we were

first slide the nineteen before we were

first slide the nineteen before we were all talking about this but my my

all talking about this but my my

all talking about this but my my comments are the reason for this talk is

comments are the reason for this talk is

comments are the reason for this talk is to look at walls or systems to

to look at walls or systems to

to look at walls or systems to understand that if we look at the

understand that if we look at the

understand that if we look at the boundary between things the inside and

boundary between things the inside and

boundary between things the inside and outside and we understand the interfaces

outside and we understand the interfaces

outside and we understand the interfaces that’s often where the action is and in

that’s often where the action is and in

that’s often where the action is and in setting up your systems in setting up

setting up your systems in setting up

setting up your systems in setting up their businesses or optimizing your

their businesses or optimizing your

their businesses or optimizing your strategies if you’re looking at where

strategies if you’re looking at where

strategies if you’re looking at where the system boundaries are you can often

the system boundaries are you can often

the system boundaries are you can often gain a lot of understanding if I start

gain a lot of understanding if I start

gain a lot of understanding if I start going too fast

going too fast

going too fast which I do also for english-speakers

which I do also for english-speakers

which I do also for english-speakers just yell out no ma’am no everybody from

just yell out no ma’am no everybody from

just yell out no ma’am no everybody from the back do it because I will start

the back do it because I will start

the back do it because I will start talking too fast I get excited and I

talking too fast I get excited and I

talking too fast I get excited and I talk too fast I’m sorry

talk too fast I’m sorry

talk too fast I’m sorry I knew Tony is as few words as possible

I knew Tony is as few words as possible

I knew Tony is as few words as possible so we have this topic we’re looking at

so we have this topic we’re looking at

so we have this topic we’re looking at solid physical walls to start with this

solid physical walls to start with this

solid physical walls to start with this is an example of the kind of walls that

is an example of the kind of walls that

is an example of the kind of walls that we’ll get to yeah

we’ll get to yeah

we’ll get to yeah everything has walls we were going to

everything has walls we were going to

everything has walls we were going to talk about these physical stone walls

talk about these physical stone walls

talk about these physical stone walls but here even in our premise of thinking

but here even in our premise of thinking

but here even in our premise of thinking outside the box there’s walls there yeah

outside the box there’s walls there yeah

outside the box there’s walls there yeah there’s the inside there’s the outside

there’s the inside there’s the outside

there’s the inside there’s the outside the wall is what defines that your

the wall is what defines that your

the wall is what defines that your thinking is actually outside of the box

thinking is actually outside of the box

thinking is actually outside of the box if you move the walls all of a sudden

if you move the walls all of a sudden

if you move the walls all of a sudden here you can use inside the box

here you can use inside the box

here you can use inside the box yeah so this this wall becomes this very

yeah so this this wall becomes this very

yeah so this this wall becomes this very important part of the system it’s often

important part of the system it’s often

important part of the system it’s often where the action is this is the physical

where the action is this is the physical

where the action is this is the physical wall of Geneva Geneva is a city of peace

wall of Geneva Geneva is a city of peace

wall of Geneva Geneva is a city of peace but they had for a long time

but they had for a long time

but they had for a long time neighbors who were attacking them it was

neighbors who were attacking them it was

neighbors who were attacking them it was the French

of all physical Stonewall the reason I

of all physical Stonewall the reason I mentioned this particular city role is

mentioned this particular city role is

mentioned this particular city role is because of an interesting thing that

because of an interesting thing that

because of an interesting thing that they did when they built the wall when

they did when they built the wall when

they did when they built the wall when they built the wall this giant stone

they built the wall this giant stone

they built the wall this giant stone thing physical wall they destroyed

thing physical wall they destroyed

thing physical wall they destroyed everything outside of the wall they got

everything outside of the wall they got

everything outside of the wall they got rid of there was architecture there was

rid of there was architecture there was

rid of there was architecture there was culture they destroyed it so that there

culture they destroyed it so that there

culture they destroyed it so that there was complete clarity inside we’re safe

was complete clarity inside we’re safe

was complete clarity inside we’re safe outside you’re on your own this is

outside you’re on your own this is

outside you’re on your own this is important to me because it gives this

important to me because it gives this

important to me because it gives this physical picture of the wall as a

physical picture of the wall as a

physical picture of the wall as a boundary between safe and unsafe there’s

boundary between safe and unsafe there’s

boundary between safe and unsafe there’s a lot of discussion this week in our

a lot of discussion this week in our

a lot of discussion this week in our political discussion around this concept

political discussion around this concept

political discussion around this concept of safety and here and also in the

of safety and here and also in the

of safety and here and also in the premise of smart walls versus stupid

premise of smart walls versus stupid

premise of smart walls versus stupid walls the Pope has talked extensively

walls the Pope has talked extensively

walls the Pope has talked extensively about the fear that comes from wolves

about the fear that comes from wolves

about the fear that comes from wolves howl wolves divide us it was a bit more

howl wolves divide us it was a bit more

howl wolves divide us it was a bit more and who is my center and also my hero

and who is my center and also my hero

and who is my center and also my hero has just declared that there are simply

has just declared that there are simply

has just declared that there are simply stupid walls yeah these two concepts

stupid walls yeah these two concepts

stupid walls yeah these two concepts that fear is at the boundary of these

that fear is at the boundary of these

that fear is at the boundary of these walls where that fear and wolves are

walls where that fear and wolves are

walls where that fear and wolves are very linked to each other and also that

very linked to each other and also that

very linked to each other and also that there are such thing as stupid walls for

there are such thing as stupid walls for

there are such thing as stupid walls for example our no band or wall wall yeah

example our no band or wall wall yeah

example our no band or wall wall yeah here is a wall where at least it’s not

here is a wall where at least it’s not

here is a wall where at least it’s not quite stupid it’s got the intention of

quite stupid it’s got the intention of

quite stupid it’s got the intention of being safe in fact you see in a corner

being safe in fact you see in a corner

being safe in fact you see in a corner there’s angels people feel good they

there’s angels people feel good they

there’s angels people feel good they feel safe when they’re there they’ve

feel safe when they’re there they’ve

feel safe when they’re there they’ve made this wall that they’re inside this

made this wall that they’re inside this

made this wall that they’re inside this wall they they know that they’re safe

wall they they know that they’re safe

wall they they know that they’re safe they can keep their valuables in there

they can keep their valuables in there

they can keep their valuables in there one state and it’s not stupid because

one state and it’s not stupid because

one state and it’s not stupid because you can see exactly where the boundary

you can see exactly where the boundary

you can see exactly where the boundary is

is

is and you know whether you’re inside the

and you know whether you’re inside the

and you know whether you’re inside the wall or outside the law you know where

wall or outside the law you know where

wall or outside the law you know where you’re safe that’s important for our

you’re safe that’s important for our

you’re safe that’s important for our next example which gets a little bit

next example which gets a little bit

next example which gets a little bit into the theoretical now it happens that

into the theoretical now it happens that

into the theoretical now it happens that this example happens within the physical

this example happens within the physical

this example happens within the physical walls of Geneva but the physical walls

walls of Geneva but the physical walls

walls of Geneva but the physical walls don’t matter in inside of this circle

don’t matter in inside of this circle

don’t matter in inside of this circle there’s a bank the bank had a firewall

there’s a bank the bank had a firewall

there’s a bank the bank had a firewall is a firewall the phrase that that

is a firewall the phrase that that

is a firewall the phrase that that translates of the digital wall that

translates of the digital wall that

translates of the digital wall that keeps your data safe maybe it’s the same

keeps your data safe maybe it’s the same

keeps your data safe maybe it’s the same word for wall but it’s a firewall inside

word for wall but it’s a firewall inside

word for wall but it’s a firewall inside anyway they got hacked in the particular

anyway they got hacked in the particular

anyway they got hacked in the particular type of hack which was the that’s called

type of hack which was the that’s called

type of hack which was the that’s called ransomware it’s essentially a kidnapping

ransomware it’s essentially a kidnapping

ransomware it’s essentially a kidnapping of data so somebody gets your data and

of data so somebody gets your data and

of data so somebody gets your data and they say I’ll give you your David back

they say I’ll give you your David back

they say I’ll give you your David back when you pay the ransom

when you pay the ransom

when you pay the ransom yeah and then you get your data back

yeah and then you get your data back

yeah and then you get your data back this Bank was ransomed for less than the

this Bank was ransomed for less than the

this Bank was ransomed for less than the cost over there any one of the bankers

cost over there any one of the bankers

cost over there any one of the bankers watches yeah very small amount

watches yeah very small amount

watches yeah very small amount relatively but they said no and they

relatively but they said no and they

relatively but they said no and they said no for an interesting reason

said no for an interesting reason

said no for an interesting reason because they said all of the data that

because they said all of the data that

because they said all of the data that was kidnapped with outside of our

was kidnapped with outside of our

was kidnapped with outside of our firewall therefore we’re not protecting

firewall therefore we’re not protecting

firewall therefore we’re not protecting that data the problem was that lots of

that data the problem was that lots of

that data the problem was that lots of their customers and the hackers proved

their customers and the hackers proved

their customers and the hackers proved this lots of their customers didn’t

this lots of their customers didn’t

this lots of their customers didn’t understand that they were outside of the

understand that they were outside of the

understand that they were outside of the firewall they had provided private

firewall they had provided private

firewall they had provided private information to their bank thinking they

information to their bank thinking they

information to their bank thinking they were safe and then it turns out they

were safe and then it turns out they

were safe and then it turns out they were outside they’re just so great about

were outside they’re just so great about

were outside they’re just so great about a wall they were outside the fire they

a wall they were outside the fire they

a wall they were outside the fire they didn’t know yeah this is interesting

didn’t know yeah this is interesting

didn’t know yeah this is interesting that if you think back to the Geneva

that if you think back to the Geneva

that if you think back to the Geneva wall the original physical solid wall

wall the original physical solid wall

wall the original physical solid wall and how there is this clear boundary

and how there is this clear boundary

and how there is this clear boundary everything outside is destroyed

everything outside is destroyed

everything outside is destroyed I would guess I know myself and I would

I would guess I know myself and I would

I would guess I know myself and I would guess that a lot of people don’t

guess that a lot of people don’t

guess that a lot of people don’t necessarily know when they’re outside of

necessarily know when they’re outside of

necessarily know when they’re outside of all of the digital firewalls that

all of the digital firewalls that

all of the digital firewalls that surround us when are you safe

surround us when are you safe

surround us when are you safe we don’t really know this is extremely

we don’t really know this is extremely

we don’t really know this is extremely important as we become more and more

important as we become more and more

important as we become more and more entangled in this digital world because

entangled in this digital world because

entangled in this digital world because if we don’t know we’re safe how can we

if we don’t know we’re safe how can we

if we don’t know we’re safe how can we how can we ever feel safe anywhere

how can we ever feel safe anywhere

how can we ever feel safe anywhere you just don’t know our next example is

you just don’t know our next example is

you just don’t know our next example is even further from the physical wall

even further from the physical wall

even further from the physical wall again this is the physical wall again

again this is the physical wall again

again this is the physical wall again it’s not relevant this is actually the

it’s not relevant this is actually the

it’s not relevant this is actually the wall of Harvard Yard and it doesn’t

wall of Harvard Yard and it doesn’t

wall of Harvard Yard and it doesn’t matter at all simply because what I’m

matter at all simply because what I’m

matter at all simply because what I’m describing here is not even a digital

describing here is not even a digital

describing here is not even a digital wall it’s a social wall or systemic wall

wall it’s a social wall or systemic wall

wall it’s a social wall or systemic wall around academic institutions hold on no

around academic institutions hold on no

around academic institutions hold on no bad no wall the wall and no this becomes

bad no wall the wall and no this becomes

bad no wall the wall and no this becomes less like a wall right but there’s

less like a wall right but there’s

less like a wall right but there’s really a wall around academic

really a wall around academic

really a wall around academic institutions inside the academic

institutions inside the academic

institutions inside the academic institution you can think you’re free to

institution you can think you’re free to

institution you can think you’re free to explore you’re free to play to try to

explore you’re free to play to try to

explore you’re free to play to try to break things yeah outside of the wall

break things yeah outside of the wall

break things yeah outside of the wall maybe not so much but here you’re safe

maybe not so much but here you’re safe

maybe not so much but here you’re safe and that has nothing to do with the

and that has nothing to do with the

and that has nothing to do with the physical wall the case that I wanted to

physical wall the case that I wanted to

physical wall the case that I wanted to describe here happened in Texas there

describe here happened in Texas there

describe here happened in Texas there was a boy young 14 who did an

was a boy young 14 who did an

was a boy young 14 who did an extra-credit project for his electronics

extra-credit project for his electronics

extra-credit project for his electronics class brought it into his school wearing

class brought it into his school wearing

class brought it into his school wearing of all things and all American NASA

of all things and all American NASA

of all things and all American NASA t-shirts and that arrested handcuffed

t-shirts and that arrested handcuffed

t-shirts and that arrested handcuffed and taken to jail in the school know

and taken to jail in the school know

and taken to jail in the school know what what and I haven’t claimed that

what what and I haven’t claimed that

what what and I haven’t claimed that what happened here was because the wall

what happened here was because the wall

what happened here was because the wall was not clear or was not shored up

was not clear or was not shored up

was not clear or was not shored up enough he was allowed to the fear that

enough he was allowed to the fear that

enough he was allowed to the fear that in with him in who he was he was a

in with him in who he was he was a

in with him in who he was he was a non-white Muslim foreign boy with the

non-white Muslim foreign boy with the

non-white Muslim foreign boy with the name Ahmed Mohammed he built an

name Ahmed Mohammed he built an

name Ahmed Mohammed he built an electronic alarm clock now his alarm

electronic alarm clock now his alarm

electronic alarm clock now his alarm clock was the kind that set besides

clock was the kind that set besides

clock was the kind that set besides everybody’s bedside table until our

everybody’s bedside table until our

everybody’s bedside table until our iPhones replaced them but this boy

iPhones replaced them but this boy

iPhones replaced them but this boy because of who he was because he was not

because of who he was because he was not

because of who he was because he was not a white Texan named Andy Smith was

a white Texan named Andy Smith was

a white Texan named Andy Smith was arrested in handcuffs and taken away how

arrested in handcuffs and taken away how

arrested in handcuffs and taken away how can that happen within the safe space

can that happen within the safe space

can that happen within the safe space how can you experiment inside of the

how can you experiment inside of the

how can you experiment inside of the beautiful academic space if you can’t

beautiful academic space if you can’t

beautiful academic space if you can’t even trust that this sort of thing isn’t

even trust that this sort of thing isn’t

even trust that this sort of thing isn’t going to happen this is a wall that is

going to happen this is a wall that is

going to happen this is a wall that is not a stupid wall this is an important

not a stupid wall this is an important

not a stupid wall this is an important role and it’s fear that broke down this

role and it’s fear that broke down this

role and it’s fear that broke down this wall so another example of a wall now

wall so another example of a wall now

wall so another example of a wall now maybe a different one in an interesting

maybe a different one in an interesting

maybe a different one in an interesting one not digital this last example is

one not digital this last example is

one not digital this last example is that it gives a little bit of pepper

that it gives a little bit of pepper

that it gives a little bit of pepper well which doesn’t look at all like a

well which doesn’t look at all like a

well which doesn’t look at all like a wall in fact it’s the most beautiful

wall in fact it’s the most beautiful

wall in fact it’s the most beautiful wall that kind of all that you want to

wall that kind of all that you want to

wall that kind of all that you want to see happen I am NOT apologist for walls

see happen I am NOT apologist for walls

see happen I am NOT apologist for walls no bad no wall but this wall in this

no bad no wall but this wall in this

no bad no wall but this wall in this case was a really interesting situation

case was a really interesting situation

case was a really interesting situation a CEO of a technology company

a CEO of a technology company

a CEO of a technology company the famous one was interested in

the famous one was interested in

the famous one was interested in building an economy industry around

building an economy industry around

building an economy industry around green commerce of electric cars watts

so what he realized is these are part of

so what he realized is these are part of this that’s very important we’re all

this that’s very important we’re all

this that’s very important we’re all technology companies all energy

technology companies all energy

technology companies all energy companies basically everybody that deals

companies basically everybody that deals

companies basically everybody that deals in technology has a huge wall of

in technology has a huge wall of

in technology has a huge wall of intellectual property all healthcare

intellectual property all healthcare

intellectual property all healthcare companies all and just everybody has

companies all and just everybody has

companies all and just everybody has this wall of patents and then behind the

this wall of patents and then behind the

this wall of patents and then behind the patents you have your lawyers and

patents you have your lawyers and

patents you have your lawyers and they’re armed to the teeth with

they’re armed to the teeth with

they’re armed to the teeth with everything that you can find everything

everything that you can find everything

everything that you can find everything battle each other like armies this is a

battle each other like armies this is a

battle each other like armies this is a constant thing that’s going on in

constant thing that’s going on in

constant thing that’s going on in Silicon Valley this is a constant thing

Silicon Valley this is a constant thing

Silicon Valley this is a constant thing that’s going across technology this CEO

that’s going across technology this CEO

that’s going across technology this CEO did an absolutely fascinating thing even

did an absolutely fascinating thing even

did an absolutely fascinating thing even in the midst of this situation where

in the midst of this situation where

in the midst of this situation where there’s so much fear there’s armies in

there’s so much fear there’s armies in

there’s so much fear there’s armies in trench two battles going on you’ve got

trench two battles going on you’ve got

trench two battles going on you’ve got this was specially called a landscape

this was specially called a landscape

this was specially called a landscape and you’ve got your boundaries and it’s

and you’ve got your boundaries and it’s

and you’ve got your boundaries and it’s a war around intellectual property he

a war around intellectual property he

a war around intellectual property he took the whole thing and he turned it on

took the whole thing and he turned it on

took the whole thing and he turned it on its head in a very sweet post involving

its head in a very sweet post involving

its head in a very sweet post involving cats and video games he released all of

cats and video games he released all of

cats and video games he released all of his patents into the internet and said

his patents into the internet and said

his patents into the internet and said everybody use these take my condoms

everybody use these take my condoms

everybody use these take my condoms they’re free for you which is crazy

they’re free for you which is crazy

they’re free for you which is crazy everybody else in the industry is doing

everybody else in the industry is doing

everybody else in the industry is doing the opposite they’re fighting tooth and

the opposite they’re fighting tooth and

the opposite they’re fighting tooth and nail and battling for the value of these

nail and battling for the value of these

nail and battling for the value of these things and he says it’s free please use

things and he says it’s free please use

things and he says it’s free please use the genius of this move for him was that

the genius of this move for him was that

the genius of this move for him was that he realized he needed to build an

he realized he needed to build an

he realized he needed to build an ecosystem he needed the diversity of

ecosystem he needed the diversity of

ecosystem he needed the diversity of ideas of everybody coming and building

ideas of everybody coming and building

ideas of everybody coming and building on his stuff he couldn’t do it alone he

on his stuff he couldn’t do it alone he

on his stuff he couldn’t do it alone he couldn’t build an entire industry and so

couldn’t build an entire industry and so

couldn’t build an entire industry and so he invited everyone in to use his

he invited everyone in to use his

he invited everyone in to use his patents and then in that way there was a

patents and then in that way there was a

patents and then in that way there was a community so the reason that I have this

community so the reason that I have this

community so the reason that I have this picture is because this is a community

picture is because this is a community

picture is because this is a community garden in New York everybody is throwing

garden in New York everybody is throwing

garden in New York everybody is throwing their plants in

their plants in

their plants in you can see it’s an absolute raging mesh

you can see it’s an absolute raging mesh

you can see it’s an absolute raging mesh but it’s lush it’s green it’s growing

but it’s lush it’s green it’s growing

but it’s lush it’s green it’s growing it’s actually growing across the walls

it’s actually growing across the walls

it’s actually growing across the walls you end up with this this lovely

you end up with this this lovely

you end up with this this lovely ecosystem and possibility because of the

ecosystem and possibility because of the

ecosystem and possibility because of the power of all of these people and all of

power of all of these people and all of

power of all of these people and all of this interaction in all of this fertile

this interaction in all of this fertile

this interaction in all of this fertile space so here’s somebody who in the

space so here’s somebody who in the

space so here’s somebody who in the midst of maximum fear in the middle of a

midst of maximum fear in the middle of a

midst of maximum fear in the middle of a war

war

war around intellectual property was able to

around intellectual property was able to

around intellectual property was able to take the thing look at it think

take the thing look at it think

take the thing look at it think innovatively about it and say no we can

innovatively about it and say no we can

innovatively about it and say no we can do this completely differently pretty

do this completely differently pretty

do this completely differently pretty cool this this is actually visitor an

cool this this is actually visitor an

cool this this is actually visitor an aside now back to our Nevada wall where

aside now back to our Nevada wall where

aside now back to our Nevada wall where the fellow this particular CEO is

the fellow this particular CEO is

the fellow this particular CEO is actually one of the advisors to the

actually one of the advisors to the

actually one of the advisors to the government so maybe he can apply some of

government so maybe he can apply some of

government so maybe he can apply some of the same thinking to to the current

the same thinking to to the current

the same thinking to to the current situation we can only hope so look even

situation we can only hope so look even

situation we can only hope so look even before the events of this week it was a

before the events of this week it was a

before the events of this week it was a strange and distressing and tumultuous

strange and distressing and tumultuous

strange and distressing and tumultuous violent for the topic to come here and

violent for the topic to come here and

violent for the topic to come here and talk about walls in a session that’s all

talk about walls in a session that’s all

talk about walls in a session that’s all about thinking outside of the box

about thinking outside of the box

about thinking outside of the box preservation but being the scientist say

preservation but being the scientist say

preservation but being the scientist say I’m looking at the strategies I do I

I’m looking at the strategies I do I

I’m looking at the strategies I do I would claim that there’s an awful lot of

would claim that there’s an awful lot of

would claim that there’s an awful lot of action at these boundaries at these

action at these boundaries at these

action at these boundaries at these walls and if we take a moment or you

walls and if we take a moment or you

walls and if we take a moment or you know while you’re thinking about

know while you’re thinking about

know while you’re thinking about everything else you think about in your

everything else you think about in your

everything else you think about in your systems think about the boundaries and

systems think about the boundaries and

systems think about the boundaries and think about the way the interactions

think about the way the interactions

think about the way the interactions between insides and outsides work

between insides and outsides work

between insides and outsides work because there’s a lot of action there

because there’s a lot of action there

because there’s a lot of action there thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *