Press "Enter" to skip to content

Waiting for Superman: Coastal Erosion and Environmental Accountability | Alex Liebeskind | TEDxCSUSM


so when I was growing up I was always

so when I was growing up I was always waiting for the grunion runs and on

waiting for the grunion runs and on

waiting for the grunion runs and on these nights I’d always go to bed and I

these nights I’d always go to bed and I

these nights I’d always go to bed and I wouldn’t know anything was happening

wouldn’t know anything was happening

wouldn’t know anything was happening until I’d wake up at midnight and a

until I’d wake up at midnight and a

until I’d wake up at midnight and a minivan crammed with my entire family

minivan crammed with my entire family

minivan crammed with my entire family were all packed in there was our family

were all packed in there was our family

were all packed in there was our family tradition and my mom would have been

tradition and my mom would have been

tradition and my mom would have been doing it when she was a child is

doing it when she was a child is

doing it when she was a child is something that we were always talking

something that we were always talking

something that we were always talking about and so we’d all pour out onto the

about and so we’d all pour out onto the

about and so we’d all pour out onto the beach and we just stand there and wait

beach and we just stand there and wait

beach and we just stand there and wait for the magic to happen and then out of

for the magic to happen and then out of

for the magic to happen and then out of nowhere you’d see this one silvery

nowhere you’d see this one silvery

nowhere you’d see this one silvery grunion this little silver fish they’re

grunion this little silver fish they’re

grunion this little silver fish they’re kind of like sardines and then the next

kind of like sardines and then the next

kind of like sardines and then the next few moments you cheat hundreds of them

few moments you cheat hundreds of them

few moments you cheat hundreds of them it’s something that’s really amazing and

it’s something that’s really amazing and

it’s something that’s really amazing and something that really inspired on me

something that really inspired on me

something that really inspired on me from young age there’s the sand is just

from young age there’s the sand is just

from young age there’s the sand is just made of scales deriving all around your

made of scales deriving all around your

made of scales deriving all around your feet and something that was really cool

feet and something that was really cool

feet and something that was really cool to experience at 1:00 a.m. and so I

to experience at 1:00 a.m. and so I

to experience at 1:00 a.m. and so I always want with my family it was my

always want with my family it was my

always want with my family it was my brother my grandpa and we were always

brother my grandpa and we were always

brother my grandpa and we were always there and so over time we kept going on

there and so over time we kept going on

there and so over time we kept going on these grunion runs but we saw the

these grunion runs but we saw the

these grunion runs but we saw the numbers start to dwindle one year we

numbers start to dwindle one year we

numbers start to dwindle one year we went and we stood there and there were

went and we stood there and there were

went and we stood there and there were fifty grunion and next year we went in

fifty grunion and next year we went in

fifty grunion and next year we went in there were a dozen and so we kept going

there were a dozen and so we kept going

there were a dozen and so we kept going in year after year it was kind of

in year after year it was kind of

in year after year it was kind of declining and I started to worry that

declining and I started to worry that

declining and I started to worry that there was some fundamental thing wrong

there was some fundamental thing wrong

there was some fundamental thing wrong there was some pattern and so I got

there was some pattern and so I got

there was some pattern and so I got involved to heal the bay and beach

involved to heal the bay and beach

involved to heal the bay and beach cleanups and picking up trash and stuff

cleanups and picking up trash and stuff

cleanups and picking up trash and stuff like that but I started to learn that

like that but I started to learn that

like that but I started to learn that the grunion were harmed by coastal

the grunion were harmed by coastal

the grunion were harmed by coastal erosion and by climate change and that

erosion and by climate change and that

erosion and by climate change and that was harming their habitats there was

was harming their habitats there was

was harming their habitats there was something more fundamentally wrong and

something more fundamentally wrong and

something more fundamentally wrong and so at the time I was working at UCLA in

so at the time I was working at UCLA in

so at the time I was working at UCLA in a computer science lab on image

a computer science lab on image

a computer science lab on image recognition techniques and image

recognition techniques and image

recognition techniques and image analysis and so the question became how

analysis and so the question became how

analysis and so the question became how do I apply my skill set into the issues

do I apply my skill set into the issues

do I apply my skill set into the issues that really matter to me and so I

that really matter to me and so I

that really matter to me and so I started working at the Linette wave

started working at the Linette wave

started working at the Linette wave research group and I know what you guys

research group and I know what you guys

research group and I know what you guys are probably thinking is you’re just

are probably thinking is you’re just

are probably thinking is you’re just working at a computer I thought

working at a computer I thought

working at a computer I thought environmental engineering lab there’d be

environmental engineering lab there’d be

environmental engineering lab there’d be some wave tanks and test vials something

some wave tanks and test vials something

some wave tanks and test vials something like that and to me what’s really

like that and to me what’s really

like that and to me what’s really amazing is that you go in there and you

amazing is that you go in there and you

amazing is that you go in there and you see some cubicles you see people working

see some cubicles you see people working

see some cubicles you see people working at desks but on these computers there’s

at desks but on these computers there’s

at desks but on these computers there’s groundbreaking research that is changing

groundbreaking research that is changing

groundbreaking research that is changing society and so these are the

society and so these are the

society and so these are the the people I was working with the guy on

the people I was working with the guy on

the people I was working with the guy on my left worked at Google for a while

my left worked at Google for a while

my left worked at Google for a while before he came to the lab the guy on my

before he came to the lab the guy on my

before he came to the lab the guy on my right was working in Greece so this is

right was working in Greece so this is

right was working in Greece so this is really a global issue and there’s a wide

really a global issue and there’s a wide

really a global issue and there’s a wide array of people who were working on it

array of people who were working on it

array of people who were working on it and so I was looking at it in Pacifica

and so I was looking at it in Pacifica

and so I was looking at it in Pacifica in Northern California and how it’s

in Northern California and how it’s

in Northern California and how it’s affecting the houses on the coastline

affecting the houses on the coastline

affecting the houses on the coastline and then from a broader perspective and

and then from a broader perspective and

and then from a broader perspective and Connecticut and how it’s affecting Cape

Connecticut and how it’s affecting Cape

Connecticut and how it’s affecting Cape Cod and Savin Iraq and eating away at

Cod and Savin Iraq and eating away at

Cod and Savin Iraq and eating away at the roads and then going even wider than

the roads and then going even wider than

the roads and then going even wider than that in New Zealand where I’m still a

that in New Zealand where I’m still a

that in New Zealand where I’m still a really big issue so we see this is

really big issue so we see this is

really big issue so we see this is something that’s really global and just

something that’s really global and just

something that’s really global and just by the amount of people who are caring

by the amount of people who are caring

by the amount of people who are caring about it it’s it’s something that really

about it it’s it’s something that really

about it it’s it’s something that really affects all of us but I’m really lucky

affects all of us but I’m really lucky

affects all of us but I’m really lucky to be giving this speech at San Marcos

to be giving this speech at San Marcos

to be giving this speech at San Marcos because you guys are all pretty close to

because you guys are all pretty close to

because you guys are all pretty close to a coastline and it’s a very tangible

a coastline and it’s a very tangible

a coastline and it’s a very tangible thing but if I was giving this speech in

thing but if I was giving this speech in

thing but if I was giving this speech in Nebraska or in Oklahoma and some

Nebraska or in Oklahoma and some

Nebraska or in Oklahoma and some landlocked place I might not have the

landlocked place I might not have the

landlocked place I might not have the same audience and so I mean I’m sure

same audience and so I mean I’m sure

same audience and so I mean I’m sure someone would be saying great coastal

someone would be saying great coastal

someone would be saying great coastal erosion I’m getting a beachfront

erosion I’m getting a beachfront

erosion I’m getting a beachfront property but I think the big problem

property but I think the big problem

property but I think the big problem with coastal erosion is that it affects

with coastal erosion is that it affects

with coastal erosion is that it affects all of us 29% of the United States

all of us 29% of the United States

all of us 29% of the United States popular population lives in coastal

popular population lives in coastal

popular population lives in coastal counties five of the ten greatest cities

counties five of the ten greatest cities

counties five of the ten greatest cities in the United States are on the

in the United States are on the

in the United States are on the coastline so we start to think about

coastline so we start to think about

coastline so we start to think about places like Miami like Los Angeles like

places like Miami like Los Angeles like

places like Miami like Los Angeles like New York and these are really social

New York and these are really social

New York and these are really social hubs cultural hubs and economic hubs in

hubs cultural hubs and economic hubs in

hubs cultural hubs and economic hubs in terms of focusing on the economics ocean

terms of focusing on the economics ocean

terms of focusing on the economics ocean industries I’m talking about tourism and

industries I’m talking about tourism and

industries I’m talking about tourism and shipping and fishing contribute to 4.4

shipping and fishing contribute to 4.4

shipping and fishing contribute to 4.4 percent of United States GDP and that’s

percent of United States GDP and that’s

percent of United States GDP and that’s 258 billion dollars of direct GDP and

258 billion dollars of direct GDP and

258 billion dollars of direct GDP and 375 indirectly as well as 2.8 million

375 indirectly as well as 2.8 million

375 indirectly as well as 2.8 million jobs and 2.6 million jobs indirectly so

jobs and 2.6 million jobs indirectly so

jobs and 2.6 million jobs indirectly so I knew it I know I just threw a lot of

I knew it I know I just threw a lot of

I knew it I know I just threw a lot of numbers at you but to put that into some

numbers at you but to put that into some

numbers at you but to put that into some perspective all of United States

perspective all of United States

perspective all of United States agriculture it was less than that so if

agriculture it was less than that so if

agriculture it was less than that so if we start to think about losing every

we start to think about losing every

we start to think about losing every farm in the United States while watching

farm in the United States while watching

farm in the United States while watching the implications of cities like New York

the implications of cities like New York

the implications of cities like New York and Los Angeles and Miami decay into the

and Los Angeles and Miami decay into the

and Los Angeles and Miami decay into the ocean

ocean

ocean that’s something that really puts it

that’s something that really puts it

that’s something that really puts it into perspective the scope of the

into perspective the scope of the

into perspective the scope of the problem we’re dealing with and so the

problem we’re dealing with and so the

problem we’re dealing with and so the other thing that’s really scary about

other thing that’s really scary about

other thing that’s really scary about this is that it’s actually accelerating

this is that it’s actually accelerating

this is that it’s actually accelerating and in its confounded by factors like

and in its confounded by factors like

and in its confounded by factors like sea level rise and storms reaction at El

sea level rise and storms reaction at El

sea level rise and storms reaction at El Nino and

Nino and

Nino and our own man-made features so in terms of

our own man-made features so in terms of

our own man-made features so in terms of sea level rise for every inch of sea

sea level rise for every inch of sea

sea level rise for every inch of sea level rise we expect 150 times that in

level rise we expect 150 times that in

level rise we expect 150 times that in shore

shore

shore retreat and so it’s highly

retreat and so it’s highly

retreat and so it’s highly multiplicative and it’s feeding into it

multiplicative and it’s feeding into it

multiplicative and it’s feeding into it in addition we start to think about like

in addition we start to think about like

in addition we start to think about like El Nino and hurricane Harvey we just had

El Nino and hurricane Harvey we just had

El Nino and hurricane Harvey we just had and we see the implications of that and

and we see the implications of that and

and we see the implications of that and so a huge swath of land that was never

so a huge swath of land that was never

so a huge swath of land that was never exposed to the coastline that we where

exposed to the coastline that we where

exposed to the coastline that we where we never had to worry about crystal

we never had to worry about crystal

we never had to worry about crystal erosion or about sediment loss this

erosion or about sediment loss this

erosion or about sediment loss this becomes an issue and that’s in addition

becomes an issue and that’s in addition

becomes an issue and that’s in addition to the increased wave action and things

to the increased wave action and things

to the increased wave action and things like that on the coastline immediately

like that on the coastline immediately

like that on the coastline immediately during the storm and then with man-made

during the storm and then with man-made

during the storm and then with man-made features like dams were hindering the

features like dams were hindering the

features like dams were hindering the natural processes that when coastal

natural processes that when coastal

natural processes that when coastal erosion does occur there’s no way for it

erosion does occur there’s no way for it

erosion does occur there’s no way for it to recuperate because we’re harming the

to recuperate because we’re harming the

to recuperate because we’re harming the way where it’s naturally recovering and

way where it’s naturally recovering and

way where it’s naturally recovering and so it’s really an issue that we’re

so it’s really an issue that we’re

so it’s really an issue that we’re feeding into and so there’s three main

feeding into and so there’s three main

feeding into and so there’s three main solutions to coastal erosion three main

solutions to coastal erosion three main

solutions to coastal erosion three main ways that we’re dealing with it right

ways that we’re dealing with it right

ways that we’re dealing with it right now the first is sea walls where in

now the first is sea walls where in

now the first is sea walls where in short you build a physical barrier and

short you build a physical barrier and

short you build a physical barrier and I’m sure you guys have seen it it’s

I’m sure you guys have seen it it’s

I’m sure you guys have seen it it’s either on the coast or just off the

either on the coast or just off the

either on the coast or just off the coast and you hope that this will

coast and you hope that this will

coast and you hope that this will prevent the wave action from affecting

prevent the wave action from affecting

prevent the wave action from affecting the coast and it’ll prevent the sediment

the coast and it’ll prevent the sediment

the coast and it’ll prevent the sediment loss but the thing about sea walls is

loss but the thing about sea walls is

loss but the thing about sea walls is that they actually make coastal erosion

that they actually make coastal erosion

that they actually make coastal erosion worse in the surrounding area so in the

worse in the surrounding area so in the

worse in the surrounding area so in the coast of the north south east or west

coast of the north south east or west

coast of the north south east or west there’s actually intensified coastal

there’s actually intensified coastal

there’s actually intensified coastal erosion there and so the cost on society

erosion there and so the cost on society

erosion there and so the cost on society is actually greater than the benefit

is actually greater than the benefit

is actually greater than the benefit when you employ a seawall the second

when you employ a seawall the second

when you employ a seawall the second solution that I was looking at is sand

solution that I was looking at is sand

solution that I was looking at is sand dredging and so when we see a similar

dredging and so when we see a similar

dredging and so when we see a similar problem a lot of the same themes and

problem a lot of the same themes and

problem a lot of the same themes and that’s it doesn’t actually solve the

that’s it doesn’t actually solve the

that’s it doesn’t actually solve the problem it’s more of a band-aid solution

problem it’s more of a band-aid solution

problem it’s more of a band-aid solution we’re dealing with the damage and not

we’re dealing with the damage and not

we’re dealing with the damage and not with the actual problem so you basically

with the actual problem so you basically

with the actual problem so you basically take a bunch of sand and replace the

take a bunch of sand and replace the

take a bunch of sand and replace the sediment but over time this is

sediment but over time this is

sediment but over time this is consistently eroded by more coastal

consistently eroded by more coastal

consistently eroded by more coastal erosion and again you have to keep

erosion and again you have to keep

erosion and again you have to keep repeating this so it’s highly expensive

repeating this so it’s highly expensive

repeating this so it’s highly expensive and extremely temporary and the third

and extremely temporary and the third

and extremely temporary and the third which I’m hesitant to even call a

which I’m hesitant to even call a

which I’m hesitant to even call a solution is managed retreat where you

solution is managed retreat where you

solution is managed retreat where you basically just pick up your stuff and

basically just pick up your stuff and

basically just pick up your stuff and move away from the coastline and I think

move away from the coastline and I think

move away from the coastline and I think I think that really speaks to how dire

I think that really speaks to how dire

I think that really speaks to how dire the circumstances are that one of our

the circumstances are that one of our

the circumstances are that one of our primary solutions is just get out of

primary solutions is just get out of

primary solutions is just get out of there and so since we don’t really have

there and so since we don’t really have

there and so since we don’t really have a great solution this was something that

a great solution this was something that

a great solution this was something that really into

really into

really into to me I was really affected by the

to me I was really affected by the

to me I was really affected by the grunion and so I wanted to know how can

grunion and so I wanted to know how can

grunion and so I wanted to know how can we deal with us and so this is where

we deal with us and so this is where

we deal with us and so this is where culeros came in for me and the way

culeros came in for me and the way

culeros came in for me and the way klaris works is you start with a just

klaris works is you start with a just

klaris works is you start with a just the pure background there’s no land

the pure background there’s no land

the pure background there’s no land features you just start off with the

features you just start off with the

features you just start off with the waves and seeing how the water is

waves and seeing how the water is

waves and seeing how the water is interacting with itself you can start to

interacting with itself you can start to

interacting with itself you can start to toggle the frequency and amplitude and

toggle the frequency and amplitude and

toggle the frequency and amplitude and the wavelengths of these waves and so

the wavelengths of these waves and so

the wavelengths of these waves and so there Marlow just based on the equations

there Marlow just based on the equations

there Marlow just based on the equations and you see how they’re working and then

and you see how they’re working and then

and you see how they’re working and then that complex flies and you start to add

that complex flies and you start to add

that complex flies and you start to add in some land features and see how it’s

in some land features and see how it’s

in some land features and see how it’s interacting with a circular island at

interacting with a circular island at

interacting with a circular island at first and so you can see instead of just

first and so you can see instead of just

first and so you can see instead of just water water interactions interactions

water water interactions interactions

water water interactions interactions between the water and the land and

between the water and the land and

between the water and the land and eventually you can start to input your

eventually you can start to input your

eventually you can start to input your own features or your own input into the

own features or your own input into the

own features or your own input into the situation when it’s already progressing

situation when it’s already progressing

situation when it’s already progressing and so you can start to play with it and

and so you can start to play with it and

and so you can start to play with it and see how the environments going to react

see how the environments going to react

see how the environments going to react when you change different things and

when you change different things and

when you change different things and eventually you end up with this full

eventually you end up with this full

eventually you end up with this full model that has a 3d visual of what the

model that has a 3d visual of what the

model that has a 3d visual of what the coastlines actually going to be like and

coastlines actually going to be like and

coastlines actually going to be like and it’s really amazing because you can

it’s really amazing because you can

it’s really amazing because you can build this for any coastline without

build this for any coastline without

build this for any coastline without actually going there or seeing it you

actually going there or seeing it you

actually going there or seeing it you just need to know what the geographic

just need to know what the geographic

just need to know what the geographic features and the bathymetry the

features and the bathymetry the

features and the bathymetry the underwater geography is like and so this

underwater geography is like and so this

underwater geography is like and so this also gives you a depth model where you

also gives you a depth model where you

also gives you a depth model where you can work with more numerical data and

can work with more numerical data and

can work with more numerical data and kind of visualize it in terms of how

kind of visualize it in terms of how

kind of visualize it in terms of how deep is the water and how high are the

deep is the water and how high are the

deep is the water and how high are the waves and things like that and so

waves and things like that and so

waves and things like that and so eventually when you start to combine

eventually when you start to combine

eventually when you start to combine these things you get a real simulation

these things you get a real simulation

these things you get a real simulation of what a real coastline is actually

of what a real coastline is actually

of what a real coastline is actually like and so you can start to see how

like and so you can start to see how

like and so you can start to see how it’s going to react to things like sea

it’s going to react to things like sea

it’s going to react to things like sea level rise which I was talking about for

level rise which I was talking about for

level rise which I was talking about for it you start to see how it’s gonna react

it you start to see how it’s gonna react

it you start to see how it’s gonna react to changing geographic features and how

to changing geographic features and how

to changing geographic features and how these different waves are gonna interact

these different waves are gonna interact

these different waves are gonna interact with the coastline and I think it’s

with the coastline and I think it’s

with the coastline and I think it’s really amazing because it’s this

really amazing because it’s this

really amazing because it’s this immersive 3d model but you don’t

immersive 3d model but you don’t

immersive 3d model but you don’t actually have the coastline so this

actually have the coastline so this

actually have the coastline so this could be built for any situation this

could be built for any situation this

could be built for any situation this this is built for a wide variety of

this is built for a wide variety of

this is built for a wide variety of different coastlines and you can see how

different coastlines and you can see how

different coastlines and you can see how each environment is going to react as

each environment is going to react as

each environment is going to react as you start to change your inputs and so

you start to change your inputs and so

you start to change your inputs and so this gives us insight into the future

this gives us insight into the future

this gives us insight into the future and so I think what’s really amazing

and so I think what’s really amazing

and so I think what’s really amazing about culeros and about predictive

about culeros and about predictive

about culeros and about predictive modeling is that it gives us a way to

modeling is that it gives us a way to

modeling is that it gives us a way to improve our current solutions but it

improve our current solutions but it

improve our current solutions but it also

also

also is billed into the future so if we start

is billed into the future so if we start

is billed into the future so if we start looking at sea walls we can start to say

looking at sea walls we can start to say

looking at sea walls we can start to say when is the cost/benefit actually worth

when is the cost/benefit actually worth

when is the cost/benefit actually worth it if building a sea wall here versus

it if building a sea wall here versus

it if building a sea wall here versus the societal damage it’s actually going

the societal damage it’s actually going

the societal damage it’s actually going to cause or when is it worth the sand

to cause or when is it worth the sand

to cause or when is it worth the sand dredging to replace the sediment versus

dredging to replace the sediment versus

dredging to replace the sediment versus when it’s going to be lost in a year or

when it’s going to be lost in a year or

when it’s going to be lost in a year or two and then my favorite in terms of

two and then my favorite in terms of

two and then my favorite in terms of manager treat when do we actually have

manager treat when do we actually have

manager treat when do we actually have to go and when can we just sit there and

to go and when can we just sit there and

to go and when can we just sit there and hope for the best

hope for the best

hope for the best and so I think that it’s really amazing

and so I think that it’s really amazing

and so I think that it’s really amazing in that it employs the solutions that we

in that it employs the solutions that we

in that it employs the solutions that we already have so right now it’s already

already have so right now it’s already

already have so right now it’s already effective but on the other hand there’s

effective but on the other hand there’s

effective but on the other hand there’s a lot of ways this can improve future

a lot of ways this can improve future

a lot of ways this can improve future solution solutions and the Netherlands

solution solutions and the Netherlands

solution solutions and the Netherlands they’ve been using predictive modeling

they’ve been using predictive modeling

they’ve been using predictive modeling and they’ve they’ve made predictive and

and they’ve they’ve made predictive and

and they’ve they’ve made predictive and pre-emptive action a huge part of their

pre-emptive action a huge part of their

pre-emptive action a huge part of their culture they actually have swim tests

culture they actually have swim tests

culture they actually have swim tests where you have to swim with all your

where you have to swim with all your

where you have to swim with all your clothes on by the age of five because

clothes on by the age of five because

clothes on by the age of five because they’re so sure that there’s going to be

they’re so sure that there’s going to be

they’re so sure that there’s going to be these problems with the water and so

these problems with the water and so

these problems with the water and so it’s really about not trying to defeat

it’s really about not trying to defeat

it’s really about not trying to defeat nature or defeat coastal erosion or

nature or defeat coastal erosion or

nature or defeat coastal erosion or these issues but learning to live with

these issues but learning to live with

these issues but learning to live with them and so they have something called

them and so they have something called

them and so they have something called the I know ox folder excuse my

the I know ox folder excuse my

the I know ox folder excuse my pronunciation on that if any of you or a

pronunciation on that if any of you or a

pronunciation on that if any of you or a Dutch but it’s basically a 22-acre

Dutch but it’s basically a 22-acre

Dutch but it’s basically a 22-acre plot of reclaimed land and it’s really

plot of reclaimed land and it’s really

plot of reclaimed land and it’s really amazing because on one hand it’s

amazing because on one hand it’s

amazing because on one hand it’s contributing society they held the World

contributing society they held the World

contributing society they held the World Rowing Championships there one year but

Rowing Championships there one year but

Rowing Championships there one year but on the other hand it also places a

on the other hand it also places a

on the other hand it also places a crucial buffer between the Chi

crucial buffer between the Chi

crucial buffer between the Chi structures of society and the coastal

structures of society and the coastal

structures of society and the coastal erosions that when coastal erosion does

erosions that when coastal erosion does

erosions that when coastal erosion does occur it’s not immediately harming

occur it’s not immediately harming

occur it’s not immediately harming houses or the main city or metropolitan

houses or the main city or metropolitan

houses or the main city or metropolitan areas and so if there’s one takeaway I

areas and so if there’s one takeaway I

areas and so if there’s one takeaway I want you guys to have from all this it’s

want you guys to have from all this it’s

want you guys to have from all this it’s not directly related to coastal erosion

not directly related to coastal erosion

not directly related to coastal erosion it’s I think it’s bigger theme and so

it’s I think it’s bigger theme and so

it’s I think it’s bigger theme and so we’re in the 21st century we have this

we’re in the 21st century we have this

we’re in the 21st century we have this insight into the future that we’ve never

insight into the future that we’ve never

insight into the future that we’ve never had before and there’s a way to predict

had before and there’s a way to predict

had before and there’s a way to predict what’s gonna happen but this makes our

what’s gonna happen but this makes our

what’s gonna happen but this makes our old solutions outdated we used to be

old solutions outdated we used to be

old solutions outdated we used to be reactionary and dealing with problems

reactionary and dealing with problems

reactionary and dealing with problems when they came to affect us in dealing

when they came to affect us in dealing

when they came to affect us in dealing with the symptoms of the of coastal

with the symptoms of the of coastal

with the symptoms of the of coastal erosion but not necessarily with coastal

erosion but not necessarily with coastal

erosion but not necessarily with coastal erosion itself I think we need to be

erosion itself I think we need to be

erosion itself I think we need to be more proactive and worried about

more proactive and worried about

more proactive and worried about our future and taking accountability so

our future and taking accountability so

our future and taking accountability so that way we’re not standing there in the

that way we’re not standing there in the

that way we’re not standing there in the middle of the night on an empty beach

middle of the night on an empty beach

middle of the night on an empty beach waiting for the grunion when it’s

waiting for the grunion when it’s

waiting for the grunion when it’s already too late thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *