Press "Enter" to skip to content

Tooth + Sex = Identity | Mandan Kazzazi | TEDxUniversityofEdinburgh


[Applause]

[Applause] from 1975 to 1990 thousands of people

from 1975 to 1990 thousands of people

from 1975 to 1990 thousands of people died during the Lebanese civil war 50

died during the Lebanese civil war 50

died during the Lebanese civil war 50 thousands of those were killed in towns

thousands of those were killed in towns

thousands of those were killed in towns cities and villages then we have 17

cities and villages then we have 17

cities and villages then we have 17 thousands others the missing those who

thousands others the missing those who

thousands others the missing those who are still being looked for today their

are still being looked for today their

are still being looked for today their families wants the remains of their

families wants the remains of their

families wants the remains of their loved ones returned to them those they

loved ones returned to them those they

loved ones returned to them those they shared good and bad moments with but is

shared good and bad moments with but is

shared good and bad moments with but is it really possible to identify the

it really possible to identify the

it really possible to identify the remains of their loved ones among 17

remains of their loved ones among 17

remains of their loved ones among 17 thousands of skeletons this is where

thousands of skeletons this is where

thousands of skeletons this is where forensic anthropology comes into play

forensic anthropology comes into play

forensic anthropology comes into play and can attempt to put forward a

and can attempt to put forward a

and can attempt to put forward a comforts inside to a tragic story the

comforts inside to a tragic story the

comforts inside to a tragic story the key aspect of forensic anthropology is

key aspect of forensic anthropology is

key aspect of forensic anthropology is the identification of unknown

the identification of unknown

the identification of unknown individuals and of course the very first

individuals and of course the very first

individuals and of course the very first step in doing so is to estimate their

step in doing so is to estimate their

step in doing so is to estimate their sex I want you now think about the key

sex I want you now think about the key

sex I want you now think about the key physical differences between men and

physical differences between men and

physical differences between men and women I know what you’re thinking now

women I know what you’re thinking now

women I know what you’re thinking now and that is correct but just imagine if

and that is correct but just imagine if

and that is correct but just imagine if there was no skin or soft tissue

there was no skin or soft tissue

there was no skin or soft tissue presence what could we do there are

presence what could we do there are

presence what could we do there are still some methods that can be used for

still some methods that can be used for

still some methods that can be used for sex estimation of the skeletons based on

sex estimation of the skeletons based on

sex estimation of the skeletons based on the morphological features of the skull

the morphological features of the skull

the morphological features of the skull and pelvis but the only problem here is

and pelvis but the only problem here is

and pelvis but the only problem here is that as the organic matter bones do not

that as the organic matter bones do not

that as the organic matter bones do not survive in poor conditions so we need to

survive in poor conditions so we need to

survive in poor conditions so we need to look for a harder element in human body

look for a harder element in human body

look for a harder element in human body but what is harder than bone

but what is harder than bone

but what is harder than bone the enamel that covers our teeth is the

the enamel that covers our teeth is the

the enamel that covers our teeth is the hardest and most highly mineralized

hardest and most highly mineralized

hardest and most highly mineralized elements in human body and teeth are

elements in human body and teeth are

elements in human body and teeth are often preserved even when the bones are

often preserved even when the bones are

often preserved even when the bones are not you brush your teeth every day you

not you brush your teeth every day you

not you brush your teeth every day you look at your teeth in the mirror but

look at your teeth in the mirror but

look at your teeth in the mirror but have you ever thought that these tiny

have you ever thought that these tiny

have you ever thought that these tiny white elements in your mouth can provide

white elements in your mouth can provide

white elements in your mouth can provide us with valuable information about your

us with valuable information about your

us with valuable information about your age of death your health and diets your

age of death your health and diets your

age of death your health and diets your identity your ethnicity your biological

identity your ethnicity your biological

identity your ethnicity your biological relationships your ancestry and they can

relationships your ancestry and they can

relationships your ancestry and they can also provide an estimation of your sex

also provide an estimation of your sex

also provide an estimation of your sex in general males have larger teeth than

in general males have larger teeth than

in general males have larger teeth than females and it could be because of the

females and it could be because of the

females and it could be because of the longer period of tooth formation in

longer period of tooth formation in

longer period of tooth formation in males the other possibility could be the

males the other possibility could be the

males the other possibility could be the sex chromosomes as you know women have

sex chromosomes as you know women have

sex chromosomes as you know women have two X chromosomes and men have one X

two X chromosomes and men have one X

two X chromosomes and men have one X chromosome and one Y chromosome it has

chromosome and one Y chromosome it has

chromosome and one Y chromosome it has shown that the effects of the Y

shown that the effects of the Y

shown that the effects of the Y chromosome in two throws is greater than

chromosome in two throws is greater than

chromosome in two throws is greater than that of the X chromosome and this may

that of the X chromosome and this may

that of the X chromosome and this may cause larger – signs in males we can get

cause larger – signs in males we can get

cause larger – signs in males we can get a pretty good idea about the differences

a pretty good idea about the differences

a pretty good idea about the differences between men and women teeth by comparing

between men and women teeth by comparing

between men and women teeth by comparing their cervical measurements that is the

their cervical measurements that is the

their cervical measurements that is the diameter of the tooth where the crown

diameter of the tooth where the crown

diameter of the tooth where the crown which is actually the white part of your

which is actually the white part of your

which is actually the white part of your tooth joins the roots that is the part

tooth joins the roots that is the part

tooth joins the roots that is the part inside your gums this difference could

inside your gums this difference could

inside your gums this difference could be less than one millimeter and can vary

be less than one millimeter and can vary

be less than one millimeter and can vary from between 10 to 100 micrometers now

from between 10 to 100 micrometers now

from between 10 to 100 micrometers now the question is can we really use such a

the question is can we really use such a

the question is can we really use such a tiny difference for

tiny difference for

tiny difference for estimation in human populations in my

estimation in human populations in my

estimation in human populations in my research I’ve investigated this question

research I’ve investigated this question

research I’ve investigated this question while developing a brand new and highly

while developing a brand new and highly

while developing a brand new and highly accurate technique that allows me to

accurate technique that allows me to

accurate technique that allows me to combine 2d 3d and volumetric

combine 2d 3d and volumetric

combine 2d 3d and volumetric measurements of the tooth for sex

measurements of the tooth for sex

measurements of the tooth for sex estimation in my research I used CT

estimation in my research I used CT

estimation in my research I used CT scans of more than 2,000 teeth from

scans of more than 2,000 teeth from

scans of more than 2,000 teeth from around 117 male and female individuals

around 117 male and female individuals

around 117 male and female individuals to create a separate 3d model of every

to create a separate 3d model of every

to create a separate 3d model of every single tooth these models allow me to

single tooth these models allow me to

single tooth these models allow me to take both 2d and 3d measurements of the

take both 2d and 3d measurements of the

take both 2d and 3d measurements of the crown itself and they also allow me to

crown itself and they also allow me to

crown itself and they also allow me to take the measurements of those parts of

take the measurements of those parts of

take the measurements of those parts of the teeth which are hidden in the job

the teeth which are hidden in the job

the teeth which are hidden in the job such as the volume of the tooths root in

such as the volume of the tooths root in

such as the volume of the tooths root in total I recorded more than ten thousands

total I recorded more than ten thousands

total I recorded more than ten thousands measurements and by using the

measurements and by using the

measurements and by using the statistical analysis of this data I came

statistical analysis of this data I came

statistical analysis of this data I came up with a set of equations that

up with a set of equations that

up with a set of equations that distinguish between males and females my

distinguish between males and females my

distinguish between males and females my research showed that male teeth are an

research showed that male teeth are an

research showed that male teeth are an average 0.15 millimeters larger than

average 0.15 millimeters larger than

average 0.15 millimeters larger than female teens and this tiny difference

female teens and this tiny difference

female teens and this tiny difference helped me to sex more than 90% of

helped me to sex more than 90% of

helped me to sex more than 90% of individuals correctly this new technique

individuals correctly this new technique

individuals correctly this new technique is faster more accurate and quite

is faster more accurate and quite

is faster more accurate and quite non-invasive in comparison with

non-invasive in comparison with

non-invasive in comparison with traditional techniques such as dental

traditional techniques such as dental

traditional techniques such as dental caliper and it can also be very helpful

caliper and it can also be very helpful

caliper and it can also be very helpful for the identification of debod badly

for the identification of debod badly

for the identification of debod badly decomposed bodies and disaster victims

decomposed bodies and disaster victims

decomposed bodies and disaster victims because just by having the tooth root we

because just by having the tooth root we

because just by having the tooth root we can still estimate the sex of the

can still estimate the sex of the

can still estimate the sex of the individuals and therefore helping

individuals and therefore helping

individuals and therefore helping identify them and maybe giving some

identify them and maybe giving some

identify them and maybe giving some comforts to their families

comforts to their families

comforts to their families this is also important considering that

this is also important considering that

this is also important considering that a large number of forensic cases remain

a large number of forensic cases remain

a large number of forensic cases remain unsolved simply because we cannot

unsolved simply because we cannot

unsolved simply because we cannot estimate the sex of the individuals this

estimate the sex of the individuals this

estimate the sex of the individuals this is always the first step in developing

is always the first step in developing

is always the first step in developing the biological profile of an identified

the biological profile of an identified

the biological profile of an identified bodies and so we doubt it we cannot

bodies and so we doubt it we cannot

bodies and so we doubt it we cannot proceed further in identifications these

proceed further in identifications these

proceed further in identifications these methods also of course have many

methods also of course have many

methods also of course have many applications in the field of archaeology

forensic studies of sex estimation using

forensic studies of sex estimation using novel and alternative methods like tooth

novel and alternative methods like tooth

novel and alternative methods like tooth measurements make a vital contribution

measurements make a vital contribution

measurements make a vital contribution to a field that will always be necessary

to a field that will always be necessary

to a field that will always be necessary and provide crucial help in the

and provide crucial help in the

and provide crucial help in the aftermath of mass disasters homos or

aftermath of mass disasters homos or

aftermath of mass disasters homos or homicides and accidents what we all as

homicides and accidents what we all as

homicides and accidents what we all as the researchers in the field are trying

the researchers in the field are trying

the researchers in the field are trying to do is to bring just a little bit of

to do is to bring just a little bit of

to do is to bring just a little bit of comfort to the victim’s family so that

comfort to the victim’s family so that

comfort to the victim’s family so that they might be able to cope with such

they might be able to cope with such

they might be able to cope with such disasters a little bit more easily at

disasters a little bit more easily at

disasters a little bit more easily at the ends as barone georges cuvier the

the ends as barone georges cuvier the

the ends as barone georges cuvier the famous french naturalist said show me

famous french naturalist said show me

famous french naturalist said show me your teeth and I will tell you who you

your teeth and I will tell you who you

your teeth and I will tell you who you are thank you

you

you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *