Press "Enter" to skip to content

Tomemos juntos las grandes decisiones de la humanidad | Mariano Sigman | TEDxValladolid


[Music]

José Saramago said we did not take

decisions but decisions are not

take us and these fifteen minutes

that we are going to spend here together

is going to be a mere of or a kind of

revolve around this idea that is a

idea that I took this case of joseph

Saramago and instead I work in

make decisions or scientific but not

I want to tell you the things that we have

discovered but I want that together

doing experiments that are our

eyes in science we discover things thing

let’s go through this idea trying to

make decisions that are not enough for

time let’s do three experiments

the dogs are are prelude are

food products and we have finished a

true experiment but it works like this

so they are parents here they know that

when one especially parents more

recent happened when I do not know

Who is going to be a father and a

bunch of things at the time in the

which the bus on the wall a lot of

ideas of one’s own history of

projection towards the future things

that we believe we want

our children are and what appears

summed up in that narrow idea so much

in time it is the very simple name

name something with the name something but

when a man is making a

huge statement about whether you have a

original name weird different name that

it reminds us what excites us so much

a man who links us to at least

with a grandfather a return for a father

with an uncle when choosing a name one

choose how to relate that future to the

history what we are going to do is a

difficult decision that parents take

in principle it is a decision

agreed and let’s start by naming

here are two objects

let’s call them back one is

just give the names and they go to

choose who is who

one is Cuba and the other is Kiki

a Cuba other kiki if I can have light

on stage in the audience would be

much easier for people to put on a

little light in room

would be ideal some kiki players have

to decide which is which one has told them

nothing

raise your hand those who think that

is on your left in Cuba where the

hand there are 123 456 of how can it be that

do not think go hand in hand they think

that the kiki talles

and now look, look a little for good

as my friend says a friend of mine that

those beginnings of are human beings their

residents the test is weird truth be it

will explain why this is weird

that even after the decisions the

they take

it is rare for two reasons the first

because it’s obvious that the designated

here as I do not go out for the six that

we will be there for that was always there

let’s just ask those who did

the other way around that comes later because

we look for those people with all the fervor

of the world but what is weird because

because it’s obvious for a while because

it would be obvious that once some

day you have to be Jorge or have

that being Carlos does not have the face of Pedro

people do not have a name face without

But these people and we know the

reason

The reason is that when we

we produce sounds the mouth makes shapes

side the u

the are round sounds and the

consonants attack the appellative of the

cross where one attacks the sound closes it

acute angles correspond

nobody ever explained that to us but we are

as idiosyncratic as human beings

that we not only walk a way

more note

we choose names according to certain

Orphism between the shape of the mouth that

choose to pronounce this is an example

it gives me of course it is a

much more relevant example more in a

game so imagine you have a

things in that suitcase are things

most important of his life

In fact, what I want to know is that

in that suitcase people I’m going to

ask each one to reflect is a good

Introspective exercise and photos there

money there are letters there are things that do not

they want other people things that they want

you what you want

that goal is the most important thing

of your life as you know us to

we are animals and we have a

lots of we have needs of everything

type and included so much does not have to the

bathroom imperatively says it is

mundane this to not seem the most

glamorous the world but when one

have to reign in going to the bathroom

complete the rest disappears that

meeting matters universe with you

They have the biggest suitcase in the world

but they have to go to the bathroom at all costs

and there’s a damn for more than that suitcase

does not enter the bathroom door

I tell you I do not go no today there is no for the

moment that is everyone knows what

is speaking the drive is so strong

that takes us for evil not only that

one has to leave the way that

is involved and there are these three types

from here

what you have to choose who

It is left and you will see that this is not like

here that there was pool cayumba have going

to have a pattern but it’s not going to be all

the world except six barker a little

more difference but they will see that all

we are thinking more or less the same

then the question is who would leave

the suitcase with the most important things

from his life to the one that is there they go from the

hand

he calculated 15% the room more or less

what is happening in all the

corners of the world who would leave the

which is next door there are few and not what

seem they are big and strong men to

the discussion deep debate or women

big and strong for people who have

a lot of confidence that is left in the middle

and we will see where it touches us and also

here are all human beings not

only beat Argentina could not help it

there is dispersion that we are all from

agreement on the same and that establishes the 2

and 3 in Argentina we have a boludo

so that he understands and without so much precision

semantics we can call an idiot

adjective that also fits those who

they not only left as

notice I do not know anything else that I am a

magician also thinking always

we are human beings who left us

to efe

it’s not that they did not trust him they trust

in him but he is so poor idiot that

someone is going to steal or go and if

one does not like is how to leave oneself in a

bank that has no obstacles that opens its

doors for me understand me

like the other then just in case

persist or not but consider this you

he does not know anything these people can be that

that guy from there be the Samaritan who

embrace your children with all the warmth of

universe and that is hitler

however one from the curvature

from the mouth of the curvature of the eyebrows

not only like this the moral beliefs

very strong in another person about what

I would do about what I would not do about what

decide we are so unfair

we have sejos that take us so

strongly unless we know that

we assign beliefs in people not

so they do that this must be but

for the face that they had to contribute that

we all understand that it is unfair but

It’s all very difficult to drive

human avoid this vice and we will do

the rest were like how soon

experiment we are an experiment of

true or the simple one comes off we go

to discover some knowledge is a

experiment are we doing with

different colleagues in different places

of the world we do it like that in theaters and

places where we already do it with pencil and

paper because I like to think that the

science does not have to look can have with

technology there are many ways to

do science but sometimes they are

just ask the questions like

want to be done is the foundation that

be done but with a certain method that

allow these answers to be

build on science and that we are going to

do now at this time and for that

let’s ask ourselves about what I think

that are the most difficult things are

those decisions that we things

they seem to be well radically

well the things that we think that

they are really bad

all of us at this time and in

particular in Spain this moment

we live in a current situation there are people

that sees one side the others and one thinks about

One thing is perfect and another thinks

which is abominable and which is absolutely

the other way around and how could it be that we have

opinions so different people maybe

let’s be reasonable and that however

we have so much conviction of where it comes from

the one that to each one of us something

It looks good or something seems wrong to us

reasoning process we do that

process of reduction that principles

we use to believe with so much

conviction that something is fine or is

wrong

as well as it is going to reflect on

how do we put names on how

we can learn is the other and we will think

that way and that we do it doing a

experiment and for that they’re going to use this

high technology tool that

it is called paper that is what

we distribute here and they will see that

beginning to the page of questions that

are your name your age no name has not

made his name we are just interested

but their age gender and they have children or not

these things interest us for us

we really do science with this no longer

it’s a demonstration but after

the results of what is done here

in a lot of other situations

similar to this we turn them into

then it will be that then

turn to the first page where it says

page 2 it says Part 1

I do not feel it like that or page 12

where part 1 goes here to part 1

and there they will respond there are usually three

questions each question is part of a

Moral dilemma

are things in which they will see that the

kind of early clash there

reasons to be a side reasons for

be on the other side and you were asked to

each ponder if he will give you actions

of things that people do only

he asked in no time very

important your grief and in that we do not

confused is that you would do what

I used to tell you I’m counting them

it seems fine I think it’s right that

someone do it to many things too

they seem to make personaría never

then you did not ask him what do they do

if it does not seem good to you if someone

would do and they answer you between 0 and 10 where

means it seems perfect to me that the

society to the right to whom sings

to do that and if it does not mean doing that

is abominable is very wrong and you can

answer in a continuous you

understand that for example 3 means

is bad but not the worst thing the

world and nine means that it seems very

ok but there is something that bothers a little and

so they are responding in a continuum and

then answer this I’m interested

especially for you they exercise certain

introspection of this about how

sure are that many of us are very

sure things but I think not

we reflect too much is respond

honestly what are they sure of the

opinion that they just gave and only

do it for question 1 234 not what

let’s do

the sadness do not go to the first

the second and third we will do

then we’ll see what we do then

these are the dilemmas you have to

listen to them with attention slow loneliness

and then they have ten seconds one

quick decision to answer from 0 to

10

John, well, what do you think of the action?

is doing

10 means to be perfect center

it means it’s very bad the first one is a

little looking to the future a company

offers the following service take a

fertilized egg are embryo and what

they dictate genetically

genetically what allows the

parents have a baby that shares their

combined genome but at the same time

be able to select your height or that of

son

the color of the eyes the intelligence the

social competence and others

characteristics unrelated

health is a company that can manipulate

genes so that the son does not believe he has

virtues that you want them to have not in

the field of health

the moral question for you that home

this company is 10 means is

perfect it seems perfect to be done

that 0 means it’s very bad just

I ask you to respond with your pencil and

answer

now let’s chat about these products

they will put and also answer below with

insurance are back 10 means

I’m very sure and one means no

he answered that but but the truth is that

live a sea of doubts this Sunday in

argentina nobody answers one is a

problem why we left Argentina

good sex between siblings is the title

of the second which explains are not you

gave the title the following dilemma is

well says two brothers feel

attracted this has nothing to do with game

of thrones two brothers feel

attracted and decide in full consensus

the parameters are important ok two

brothers are attracted and decide

complete consensus have relationships

sexual cared for and protected the week

both enjoy and decide not to return

do what

what these two brothers did is

good or bad of turns seems perfect

to put a 10 if it seems lousy

they put one and then put the trust

that they were going to the third wife

answer fast let’s go do the

established from question is the

present a country

this is not good in the end you do not have to

the argentina nor with spain

the sun is worse part the president a

country is an excellent leader a great

manager and has brought a level of

unprecedented prosperity and wellbeing

to your nation is the president is a great

gesture however the attention is

discover reliably that they are

requirements has been enriched by a

huge corruption act large sector

president but it is corrupt proceeds to

prosecute what it means to separate it from

his charge the president type steals

then send prisoner but it was a

excellent president have put it

prisoner is 10 it seems perfect but I

it seems lousy anywhere the middle

and your trust and now comes the

fun

good as you have seen these things

these things are good they are very things

first you’re here you will know the

ejido and hopefully chose these questions

so that that various points to some

it seems to me the corrupt cis

has a price says good does not matter if

they are each will have different

beginning

and surely you around people

who shares a lot of things with

you have the same city that you are going to

same events that have disappeared

may have different opinions

the exercise we want is that o

is that he can not talk about

these things that seem so difficult

to talk and about we are a

experiment then they will do what

next each person has a piece of paper

in that paper they look for the number that

there were going to be two people who

they are around you that have the same

number and the fast buzkantza is

they meet with their friends

do not do anything yet it ‘s now

Find yourself and introduce yourself more

fast now now I heard you listen to me

I need there to be a bit of order in what

next let’s do the first two

questions nothing more the first two

I’m going to say when they start

talk listening is important that

understand that they understand what they have

what to do

they will join in groups of three and the

question is if it falls listens better shape

It has been a bit of excellence then

we are going to make noise and then needed

make noise but now silence

each group has to at this minute is

just enough time for the

segment has to try if they can

find a number that brings your

opinions

a and with a unique number with which

this is very important

all three agree osaka 123

he says I’m ok with my group

respond to a 51 8 10 11 10

if there is only one that says to me this

number is not worth me in a minute

they put we do not reach any consensus

It is possible that a group does not have

agreement has to try to do it but

it is not no there is no obligation for

supposedly and if they fail to do so

they will simply leave that then only

it’s bad weather they have a minute to

talk and when usually 10 seconds

in those seconds he fell on one side or the

another one number that resulted in your

consensus or says we did not get on

agreement

they start debating the case of the

company that publishes genes a minute

ahead

and

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

10 98

you have to finish 76 54 have to

finish sa finish time time put

a number put a number or if not

they put in if there was no agreement without any

problem put we see ourselves in a consensus

and we have to make it look like it ‘s

one time now the second question

have a minute to discuss the

question of sex between siblings

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

good time back time have

ten seconds already have to put on

agreement if we do not have to go from here

now yes people people please answer

Wide answer and we need the skirt

term has to end because if not

We will not leave

well let’s go from here in 30 seconds

the conversations between both areas

we actually do programs

of science but later when kaka has

reappeared in reality only

by listening to the sound of

conversations that is very beautiful is very

nice to listen to debates that

they seem impossible debates at the same

time the noise of the debates

I find it moving because

shows that the dialogue even when

it seems impossible many times it is possible

we gave science for forgiveness

from the bunch of things I want to tell

in 15 seconds nothing more what for me

is the most moving perhaps the most

interesting more touching

we asked people before

this for example a tip 10 is put together

and does not think 0 in very different positions

what is the probability that it

agree people think the

present as 65 percent

It is very rare that they agree

two people who have positions

antagonistic

our results in thousands of groups

50% show the groups that start

with two people with a zero in ten one

of each two is according to what

made me understand that I think it ‘s

important in this context more than

It’s never that many times we do not discuss

for fear of arguing

we do not argue because we are skeptical and

we assume that the conversation does not have

or will not have the power that we are

discovering that it actually has

thank you very much

[Applause]

me

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *