
some people would push you off a cliff just to touch you and say they saved
just to touch you and say they saved
just to touch you and say they saved your life what’s worse than that is that
your life what’s worse than that is that
your life what’s worse than that is that some would actually believe them and
some would actually believe them and
some would actually believe them and depending on the person most of us here
depending on the person most of us here
depending on the person most of us here probably would so what would you call
probably would so what would you call
probably would so what would you call this manipulation I think we can broadly
this manipulation I think we can broadly
this manipulation I think we can broadly agree on that what we would probably
agree on that what we would probably
agree on that what we would probably struggle to reach a consensus on though
struggle to reach a consensus on though
struggle to reach a consensus on though is the nature of that manipulation is it
is the nature of that manipulation is it
is the nature of that manipulation is it deceitful is it rude or just plain
deceitful is it rude or just plain
deceitful is it rude or just plain admirable whatever adjective we choose
admirable whatever adjective we choose
admirable whatever adjective we choose to agree with the simple truth is this
to agree with the simple truth is this
to agree with the simple truth is this the chief purpose of manipulation is to
the chief purpose of manipulation is to
the chief purpose of manipulation is to bypass rationality so let’s mean to be
bypass rationality so let’s mean to be
bypass rationality so let’s mean to be rational when you are being rational
rational when you are being rational
rational when you are being rational your decisions are motivated by logic
your decisions are motivated by logic
your decisions are motivated by logic rather than impulse and emotion and
rather than impulse and emotion and
rather than impulse and emotion and these are exactly the kind of choices
these are exactly the kind of choices
these are exactly the kind of choices economics expects humans to make but we
economics expects humans to make but we
economics expects humans to make but we are constantly being pressed to make
are constantly being pressed to make
are constantly being pressed to make choices that defy our intrinsic sense of
choices that defy our intrinsic sense of
choices that defy our intrinsic sense of rationality making us the plaything of
rationality making us the plaything of
rationality making us the plaything of easy manipulation to understand this
easy manipulation to understand this
easy manipulation to understand this better let’s go back in time
better let’s go back in time
better let’s go back in time what’s history’s favorite example of
what’s history’s favorite example of
what’s history’s favorite example of manipulation propaganda let’s add a
manipulation propaganda let’s add a
manipulation propaganda let’s add a pinch of truth to it sprinkle it with
pinch of truth to it sprinkle it with
pinch of truth to it sprinkle it with commercialism and fire it up with a
commercialism and fire it up with a
commercialism and fire it up with a brand name what do we have now
brand name what do we have now
brand name what do we have now advertising an industry based around
advertising an industry based around
advertising an industry based around shaping how people think about their
shaping how people think about their
shaping how people think about their choices now this can be approached from
choices now this can be approached from
choices now this can be approached from two different angles you can use
two different angles you can use
two different angles you can use advertising to inform or you can use it
advertising to inform or you can use it
advertising to inform or you can use it to persuade and while providing
to persuade and while providing
to persuade and while providing information can often by itself be
information can often by itself be
information can often by itself be persuasive most of the times it’s not
persuasive most of the times it’s not
persuasive most of the times it’s not enough and that’s where the emotional
enough and that’s where the emotional
enough and that’s where the emotional appeal comes in and forces us to pick
appeal comes in and forces us to pick
appeal comes in and forces us to pick heart over mind now this behind me shows
heart over mind now this behind me shows
heart over mind now this behind me shows us a straightforward relationship
us a straightforward relationship
us a straightforward relationship in other words how it’s meant to be done
in other words how it’s meant to be done
in other words how it’s meant to be done buyers are provided with information
buyers are provided with information
buyers are provided with information which in turn drives their rational
which in turn drives their rational
which in turn drives their rational choice but now we know that it’s not
choice but now we know that it’s not
choice but now we know that it’s not that easy hence the second visual our
that easy hence the second visual our
that easy hence the second visual our choice is framed by this glittering
choice is framed by this glittering
choice is framed by this glittering gilded idea that appeals more to our gut
gilded idea that appeals more to our gut
gilded idea that appeals more to our gut or instinct rather than our rationality
or instinct rather than our rationality
or instinct rather than our rationality what’s significant here is that the
what’s significant here is that the
what’s significant here is that the actual product information is outside of
actual product information is outside of
actual product information is outside of this frame and thus far less important
this frame and thus far less important
this frame and thus far less important to our decision-making here comes the
to our decision-making here comes the
to our decision-making here comes the problem in economic jargon consumers are
problem in economic jargon consumers are
problem in economic jargon consumers are expected to have access to true and
expected to have access to true and
expected to have access to true and perfect information but how many of us
perfect information but how many of us
perfect information but how many of us here are willing to look outside the
here are willing to look outside the
here are willing to look outside the frame for this information truth is not
frame for this information truth is not
frame for this information truth is not a lot of us
a lot of us
a lot of us now last week I bought a hand sanitizer
now last week I bought a hand sanitizer
now last week I bought a hand sanitizer and just said every time any of us go
and just said every time any of us go
and just said every time any of us go out to buy something I had to make a
out to buy something I had to make a
out to buy something I had to make a choice a choice between two different
choice a choice between two different
choice a choice between two different brands of sanitizers one of them looked
brands of sanitizers one of them looked
brands of sanitizers one of them looked like this and the other looked a bit
like this and the other looked a bit
like this and the other looked a bit like this so I went out there and I made
like this so I went out there and I made
like this so I went out there and I made the seemingly rational choice I bet the
the seemingly rational choice I bet the
the seemingly rational choice I bet the one that told me it kills 99.99% of the
one that told me it kills 99.99% of the
one that told me it kills 99.99% of the germs on my hands but was this really
germs on my hands but was this really
germs on my hands but was this really rational I had no way of knowing if this
rational I had no way of knowing if this
rational I had no way of knowing if this was an accurate figure in fact it would
was an accurate figure in fact it would
was an accurate figure in fact it would have been easier for me to test the
have been easier for me to test the
have been easier for me to test the lavender scent rather than test of the
lavender scent rather than test of the
lavender scent rather than test of the sanitizer actually killed 99.99% of
sanitizer actually killed 99.99% of
sanitizer actually killed 99.99% of germs but there’s a certain
germs but there’s a certain
germs but there’s a certain believability about numbers
believability about numbers
believability about numbers well someone tells you for example that
well someone tells you for example that
well someone tells you for example that 45% of our closet consists of clothes
45% of our closet consists of clothes
45% of our closet consists of clothes you will never wear we are likely to
you will never wear we are likely to
you will never wear we are likely to believe them simply because numbers are
believe them simply because numbers are
believe them simply because numbers are concrete and so we take them to be
concrete and so we take them to be
concrete and so we take them to be now that was not a fact and
now that was not a fact and
now that was not a fact and believe it or not there is an actual
believe it or not there is an actual
believe it or not there is an actual figure for the percentage of our clothes
figure for the percentage of our clothes
figure for the percentage of our clothes we actually wear but the point is we are
we actually wear but the point is we are
we actually wear but the point is we are easily manipulated by numbers and
easily manipulated by numbers and
easily manipulated by numbers and advertisers they capitalize on that they
advertisers they capitalize on that they
advertisers they capitalize on that they assume that we don’t require the facts
assume that we don’t require the facts
assume that we don’t require the facts backing up the 99.99% to make our choice
backing up the 99.99% to make our choice
backing up the 99.99% to make our choice while that would be the real basis for a
while that would be the real basis for a
while that would be the real basis for a rational consumer to decide to buy the
rational consumer to decide to buy the
rational consumer to decide to buy the product so where is all of this leading
product so where is all of this leading
product so where is all of this leading to the thing is we need adverts to help
to the thing is we need adverts to help
to the thing is we need adverts to help us make our choices in market selling
us make our choices in market selling
us make our choices in market selling similar products we need a sense of
similar products we need a sense of
similar products we need a sense of direction when deciding to buy something
direction when deciding to buy something
direction when deciding to buy something and that’s precisely what adverse
and that’s precisely what adverse
and that’s precisely what adverse provide us with and why we do possess
provide us with and why we do possess
provide us with and why we do possess rationality it is bounded rationality
rationality it is bounded rationality
rationality it is bounded rationality this means that we do not have infinite
this means that we do not have infinite
this means that we do not have infinite decision-making abilities and at some
decision-making abilities and at some
decision-making abilities and at some point we need something more than just
point we need something more than just
point we need something more than just objective information to help us make
objective information to help us make
objective information to help us make our choices so there you have it we are
our choices so there you have it we are
our choices so there you have it we are being manipulated by adverts but without
being manipulated by adverts but without
being manipulated by adverts but without that manipulation we would never be able
that manipulation we would never be able
that manipulation we would never be able to make a choice Cerreta we go from here
to make a choice Cerreta we go from here
to make a choice Cerreta we go from here the truth is know where we can stay
the truth is know where we can stay
the truth is know where we can stay exactly where we are doing exactly what
exactly where we are doing exactly what
exactly where we are doing exactly what we do every day but now just a bit
we do every day but now just a bit
we do every day but now just a bit differently the problem isn’t getting
differently the problem isn’t getting
differently the problem isn’t getting pushed off the cliff the problem is
pushed off the cliff the problem is
pushed off the cliff the problem is believing the person who said they saved
believing the person who said they saved
believing the person who said they saved your life when they were the ones to
your life when they were the ones to
your life when they were the ones to push you off we should focus not on
push you off we should focus not on
push you off we should focus not on resisting the manipulation of
resisting the manipulation of
resisting the manipulation of advertising but first on knowing that
advertising but first on knowing that
advertising but first on knowing that manipulation awareness is the key unless
manipulation awareness is the key unless
manipulation awareness is the key unless we become aware of emotional advertising
we become aware of emotional advertising
we become aware of emotional advertising we can stop reflect and make better
we can stop reflect and make better
we can stop reflect and make better choices and we can start taking our
choices and we can start taking our
choices and we can start taking our first steps to practicing full
first steps to practicing full
first steps to practicing full rationality in all our choices every day
rationality in all our choices every day
rationality in all our choices every day thank you
thank you
thank you [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment