Press "Enter" to skip to content

The People vs The Trolls: cyberbullying and the law | David Harvey | TEDxAuckland


we’ve heard a bit about cyberbullying

we’ve heard a bit about cyberbullying and what this session is about is what

and what this session is about is what

and what this session is about is what the law can do because there is help at

the law can do because there is help at

the law can do because there is help at hand

hand

hand recently in England The Guardian

recently in England The Guardian

recently in England The Guardian newspaper has been running a series of

newspaper has been running a series of

newspaper has been running a series of articles about misbehavior on the

articles about misbehavior on the

articles about misbehavior on the Internet what they’re after is the web

Internet what they’re after is the web

Internet what they’re after is the web that we want a sort of safe environment

that we want a sort of safe environment

that we want a sort of safe environment where everybody can get along together

where everybody can get along together

where everybody can get along together and can interact in a civilized way the

and can interact in a civilized way the

and can interact in a civilized way the only trouble is that the stories that

only trouble is that the stories that

only trouble is that the stories that those articles tell anything but the web

those articles tell anything but the web

those articles tell anything but the web we want they tell stories of annoyance

we want they tell stories of annoyance

we want they tell stories of annoyance threats harassment misconduct of a most

threats harassment misconduct of a most

threats harassment misconduct of a most terrible nature and it all falls within

terrible nature and it all falls within

terrible nature and it all falls within the definition of cyberbullying a kind

the definition of cyberbullying a kind

the definition of cyberbullying a kind of umbrella term that we might use for

of umbrella term that we might use for

of umbrella term that we might use for these sort of behaviors so what are they

these sort of behaviors so what are they

these sort of behaviors so what are they include they can include harassment

include they can include harassment

include they can include harassment those continual unpleasant messages that

those continual unpleasant messages that

those continual unpleasant messages that are posted on your Facebook page or that

are posted on your Facebook page or that

are posted on your Facebook page or that are sent to you at your Twitter address

are sent to you at your Twitter address

are sent to you at your Twitter address stalking where you know the person is

stalking where you know the person is

stalking where you know the person is present sitting there in the online

present sitting there in the online

present sitting there in the online environment watching you do what you do

environment watching you do what you do

environment watching you do what you do the spreading of rumors which can

the spreading of rumors which can

the spreading of rumors which can destroy your digital shadow or your

destroy your digital shadow or your

destroy your digital shadow or your online reputation the disclosure of

online reputation the disclosure of

online reputation the disclosure of those facts that it may be okay for your

those facts that it may be okay for your

those facts that it may be okay for your family to know about but really do you

family to know about but really do you

family to know about but really do you want them broadcast to the world

want them broadcast to the world

want them broadcast to the world exclusion I saw your photograph on your

exclusion I saw your photograph on your

exclusion I saw your photograph on your Facebook page at such-and-such a

Facebook page at such-and-such a

Facebook page at such-and-such a restaurant why didn’t you invite me I’m

restaurant why didn’t you invite me I’m

restaurant why didn’t you invite me I’m not going to have anything to do with

not going to have anything to do with

not going to have anything to do with you anymore

you anymore

you anymore and that message gets around or the same

and that message gets around or the same

and that message gets around or the same with the text messages that go around

with the text messages that go around

with the text messages that go around the school playground

the school playground

the school playground except for one person who sees another

except for one person who sees another

except for one person who sees another group sniggering and laughing and

group sniggering and laughing and

group sniggering and laughing and they’re laughing of him or her excluding

they’re laughing of him or her excluding

they’re laughing of him or her excluding we all know about flame wars on the

we all know about flame wars on the

we all know about flame wars on the internet heated exchanges that go

internet heated exchanges that go

internet heated exchanges that go completely out of control and end up in

completely out of control and end up in

completely out of control and end up in abuse and defaming and belittling and

abuse and defaming and belittling and

abuse and defaming and belittling and mocking and then there are the incidents

mocking and then there are the incidents

mocking and then there are the incidents of impersonation taking somebody’s

of impersonation taking somebody’s

of impersonation taking somebody’s identity identity theft and creating an

identity identity theft and creating an

identity identity theft and creating an entirely different persona for a digital

entirely different persona for a digital

entirely different persona for a digital person and this is really worse than

person and this is really worse than

person and this is really worse than real-world bullying which is bad enough

real-world bullying which is bad enough

real-world bullying which is bad enough because real-world bullying you can walk

because real-world bullying you can walk

because real-world bullying you can walk away from if you’ve got the courage or

away from if you’ve got the courage or

away from if you’ve got the courage or it does stop when you leave work or you

it does stop when you leave work or you

it does stop when you leave work or you leave the school playground but cyber

leave the school playground but cyber

leave the school playground but cyber bullying is very very insidious indeed

bullying is very very insidious indeed

bullying is very very insidious indeed and the reason for that lies within the

and the reason for that lies within the

and the reason for that lies within the very properties of digital technologies

very properties of digital technologies

very properties of digital technologies that we are using exponential

that we are using exponential

that we are using exponential dissemination is a term that I use I’m a

dissemination is a term that I use I’m a

dissemination is a term that I use I’m a lawyer so I try to make it as

lawyer so I try to make it as

lawyer so I try to make it as complicated as possible

complicated as possible

complicated as possible for going viral persistence of

for going viral persistence of

for going viral persistence of information or the document that doesn’t

information or the document that doesn’t

information or the document that doesn’t die once the information is out there on

die once the information is out there on

die once the information is out there on the Internet you lose control of it and

the Internet you lose control of it and

the Internet you lose control of it and of course with your devices your iPad’s

of course with your devices your iPad’s

of course with your devices your iPad’s your smartphones and so on and so forth

your smartphones and so on and so forth

your smartphones and so on and so forth an extension of your arm it’s always on

an extension of your arm it’s always on

an extension of your arm it’s always on 24/7 and those particular qualities or

24/7 and those particular qualities or

24/7 and those particular qualities or why cyberbullying can be so much more

why cyberbullying can be so much more

why cyberbullying can be so much more serious than the real world thing so a

serious than the real world thing so a

serious than the real world thing so a little bit of background history in 2011

little bit of background history in 2011

little bit of background history in 2011 New Zealand had a conversation about

New Zealand had a conversation about

New Zealand had a conversation about cyberbullying there were to be

cyberbullying there were to be

cyberbullying there were to be discussions about this prompted by the

discussions about this prompted by the

discussions about this prompted by the coroner who was concerned about

coroner who was concerned about

coroner who was concerned about incidents of suicide and mental health

incidents of suicide and mental health

incidents of suicide and mental health issues which was seen to be linked to

issues which was seen to be linked to

issues which was seen to be linked to the cyberbullying problem because they

the cyberbullying problem because they

the cyberbullying problem because they were being suffered by young people

were being suffered by young people

were being suffered by young people digital natives Millennials for

digital natives Millennials for

digital natives Millennials for a smartphone or a digital device was an

a smartphone or a digital device was an

a smartphone or a digital device was an extension of the arm then in 2012 the

extension of the arm then in 2012 the

extension of the arm then in 2012 the New Zealand Herald ran a series of

New Zealand Herald ran a series of

New Zealand Herald ran a series of articles on cyberbullying some of you

articles on cyberbullying some of you

articles on cyberbullying some of you may remember them and this led to

may remember them and this led to

may remember them and this led to investigations and discussions within

investigations and discussions within

investigations and discussions within government and an investigation by the

government and an investigation by the

government and an investigation by the law commission and I was involved in a

law commission and I was involved in a

law commission and I was involved in a consultative capacity in that regard

consultative capacity in that regard

consultative capacity in that regard and that all led to the enactment last

and that all led to the enactment last

and that all led to the enactment last year 2015 of the harmful digital

year 2015 of the harmful digital

year 2015 of the harmful digital communications Act this Act has very

communications Act this Act has very

communications Act this Act has very wide application indeed because it goes

wide application indeed because it goes

wide application indeed because it goes beyond mere social media

beyond mere social media

beyond mere social media it covers all forms of electronic

it covers all forms of electronic

it covers all forms of electronic communication regardless of platform so

communication regardless of platform so

communication regardless of platform so it covers every form of communication as

it covers every form of communication as

it covers every form of communication as long as it’s electronic and the Act

long as it’s electronic and the Act

long as it’s electronic and the Act provides two possible remedies one is a

provides two possible remedies one is a

provides two possible remedies one is a criminal prosecution and the other is a

criminal prosecution and the other is a

criminal prosecution and the other is a civil enforcement order the criminal

civil enforcement order the criminal

civil enforcement order the criminal prosecution is alive it’s living it’s

prosecution is alive it’s living it’s

prosecution is alive it’s living it’s now the civil enforcement order which

now the civil enforcement order which

now the civil enforcement order which will enable you to remove content

will enable you to remove content

will enable you to remove content harmful content is not yet enforce we

harmful content is not yet enforce we

harmful content is not yet enforce we hope it’ll be along by the end of the

hope it’ll be along by the end of the

hope it’ll be along by the end of the year and in some respects these two

year and in some respects these two

year and in some respects these two remedies overlap so let’s talk for a

remedies overlap so let’s talk for a

remedies overlap so let’s talk for a moment about the criminal prosecution

moment about the criminal prosecution

moment about the criminal prosecution first thing that’s got to happen of

first thing that’s got to happen of

first thing that’s got to happen of course is that there’s got to be the

course is that there’s got to be the

course is that there’s got to be the posting that is the placing on online of

posting that is the placing on online of

posting that is the placing on online of a digital communication the perpetrator

a digital communication the perpetrator

a digital communication the perpetrator has got to do that with the intention of

has got to do that with the intention of

has got to do that with the intention of causing harm and when you look at the

causing harm and when you look at the

causing harm and when you look at the particular post you ask yourself well

particular post you ask yourself well

particular post you ask yourself well would that cause harm to an ordinary

would that cause harm to an ordinary

would that cause harm to an ordinary person taking into account the position

person taking into account the position

person taking into account the position of the victim so there’s a mixed sort of

of the victim so there’s a mixed sort of

of the victim so there’s a mixed sort of test about it and then finally there

test about it and then finally there

test about it and then finally there must be actual harm caused by the

must be actual harm caused by the

must be actual harm caused by the electronic communication so what is harm

electronic communication so what is harm

electronic communication so what is harm it’s a word that we use and how I have

it’s a word that we use and how I have

it’s a word that we use and how I have used quite a bit so far well serious

used quite a bit so far well serious

used quite a bit so far well serious emotional distress this is

emotional distress this is

emotional distress this is online communication bullying so there

online communication bullying so there

online communication bullying so there isn’t going to be a blood nose or back

isn’t going to be a blood nose or back

isn’t going to be a blood nose or back knuckles or a punch in the arm or

knuckles or a punch in the arm or

knuckles or a punch in the arm or anything like that it’s serious

anything like that it’s serious

anything like that it’s serious emotional distress and for lawyers when

emotional distress and for lawyers when

emotional distress and for lawyers when you have the word serious that really

you have the word serious that really

you have the word serious that really means something so what’s been happening

means something so what’s been happening

means something so what’s been happening so far there have been 12 prosecutions

so far there have been 12 prosecutions

so far there have been 12 prosecutions under the harmful digital Communications

under the harmful digital Communications

under the harmful digital Communications Act and the sentences that have been

Act and the sentences that have been

Act and the sentences that have been imposed have ranged between supervision

imposed have ranged between supervision

imposed have ranged between supervision and community work all the way to a

and community work all the way to a

and community work all the way to a sentence of 11 months imprisonment for a

sentence of 11 months imprisonment for a

sentence of 11 months imprisonment for a very serious incident of posting a

very serious incident of posting a

very serious incident of posting a harmful digital communication so that’s

harmful digital communication so that’s

harmful digital communication so that’s the criminal side what about the civil

the criminal side what about the civil

the criminal side what about the civil enforcement order not enforce yet but it

enforcement order not enforce yet but it

enforcement order not enforce yet but it will be and this remedy is as I’ve said

will be and this remedy is as I’ve said

will be and this remedy is as I’ve said a remedial one it involves the removal

a remedial one it involves the removal

a remedial one it involves the removal of content no claims for damages no

of content no claims for damages no

of content no claims for damages no claims for reparation or anything like

claims for reparation or anything like

claims for reparation or anything like that this deals with the content itself

that this deals with the content itself

that this deals with the content itself and how to remove it

and how to remove it

and how to remove it and it’s by way of what we call a civil

and it’s by way of what we call a civil

and it’s by way of what we call a civil enforcement order and this involves an

enforcement order and this involves an

enforcement order and this involves an organization called an approved agency

organization called an approved agency

organization called an approved agency and the first port of call if there is a

and the first port of call if there is a

and the first port of call if there is a desire to remove content on the part of

desire to remove content on the part of

desire to remove content on the part of an affected individual is to go to the

an affected individual is to go to the

an affected individual is to go to the approved agency and that agency has yet

approved agency and that agency has yet

approved agency and that agency has yet to be appointed and the agency will try

to be appointed and the agency will try

to be appointed and the agency will try and resolve the matter by way of

and resolve the matter by way of

and resolve the matter by way of negotiation or mediation or discussion

negotiation or mediation or discussion

negotiation or mediation or discussion between the affected individual and the

between the affected individual and the

between the affected individual and the person who’s posted the content the

person who’s posted the content the

person who’s posted the content the author in its dealings the approved

author in its dealings the approved

author in its dealings the approved agency has to be sure that there has in

agency has to be sure that there has in

agency has to be sure that there has in fact been harm

fact been harm

fact been harm remember serious emotional distress plus

remember serious emotional distress plus

remember serious emotional distress plus a breach of one of 10 communications

a breach of one of 10 communications

a breach of one of 10 communications principles and the Act sets out 10

principles and the Act sets out 10

principles and the Act sets out 10 communications principles which are no

communications principles which are no

communications principles which are no more and no less than rules for polite

more and no less than rules for polite

more and no less than rules for polite conversation the type of rules that you

conversation the type of rules that you

conversation the type of rules that you would normally associate with a polite

would normally associate with a polite

would normally associate with a polite dialogue

dialogue

dialogue now if the approved agency can’t resolve

now if the approved agency can’t resolve

now if the approved agency can’t resolve the matter

the matter

the matter then it will proceed through to the

then it will proceed through to the

then it will proceed through to the district court and the court may order

district court and the court may order

district court and the court may order that the material be removed or it may

that the material be removed or it may

that the material be removed or it may go to the author and say we’re going to

go to the author and say we’re going to

go to the author and say we’re going to make a restraining order

make a restraining order

make a restraining order don’t you post anything more like this

don’t you post anything more like this

don’t you post anything more like this because if you do you will have

because if you do you will have

because if you do you will have committed an offense and furthermore

committed an offense and furthermore

committed an offense and furthermore don’t get all of your mates to post the

don’t get all of your mates to post the

don’t get all of your mates to post the similar sort of content either so the

similar sort of content either so the

similar sort of content either so the court will have that power the court may

court will have that power the court may

court will have that power the court may require an apology or it may give to the

require an apology or it may give to the

require an apology or it may give to the affected individual a right of

affected individual a right of

affected individual a right of correction or a right of reply and in

correction or a right of reply and in

correction or a right of reply and in addition the court will have powers to

addition the court will have powers to

addition the court will have powers to make orders against online content hosts

make orders against online content hosts

make orders against online content hosts suppose for example we have an anonymous

suppose for example we have an anonymous

suppose for example we have an anonymous author the online content host may be

author the online content host may be

author the online content host may be the port of call for having the content

the port of call for having the content

the port of call for having the content removed it may well be that the

removed it may well be that the

removed it may well be that the anonymous poster can be identified by

anonymous poster can be identified by

anonymous poster can be identified by asking the internet service provider for

asking the internet service provider for

asking the internet service provider for the name of the particular person who is

the name of the particular person who is

the name of the particular person who is associated with the IP address at the

associated with the IP address at the

associated with the IP address at the time that the content was posted this

time that the content was posted this

time that the content was posted this piece of legislation was designed to

piece of legislation was designed to

piece of legislation was designed to address cyber bullying but it goes a lot

address cyber bullying but it goes a lot

address cyber bullying but it goes a lot further than that because serious

further than that because serious

further than that because serious emotional harm serious emotional

emotional harm serious emotional

emotional harm serious emotional distress gives the act a very wide scope

distress gives the act a very wide scope

distress gives the act a very wide scope indeed so it could be used for court by

indeed so it could be used for court by

indeed so it could be used for court by corporate entities or it could be used

corporate entities or it could be used

corporate entities or it could be used by individuals for reputational harms

by individuals for reputational harms

by individuals for reputational harms that they may have suffered that are

that they may have suffered that are

that they may have suffered that are causing them damage which results in

causing them damage which results in

causing them damage which results in serious emotional distress serious

serious emotional distress serious

serious emotional distress serious emotional distress is the threshold as

emotional distress is the threshold as

emotional distress is the threshold as things stand at the moment for the civil

things stand at the moment for the civil

things stand at the moment for the civil side of things help is at hand knit safe

side of things help is at hand knit safe

side of things help is at hand knit safe is one organisation in New Zealand that

is one organisation in New Zealand that

is one organisation in New Zealand that is very experienced with dealing with

is very experienced with dealing with

is very experienced with dealing with complaints with cyberbullying and they

complaints with cyberbullying and they

complaints with cyberbullying and they have a lot of skills in that area and

have a lot of skills in that area and

have a lot of skills in that area and most other countries around the world

most other countries around the world

most other countries around the world that

that

that don’t have legislation like the harmful

don’t have legislation like the harmful

don’t have legislation like the harmful digital Communications Act have

digital Communications Act have

digital Communications Act have organizations similar to net safe that

organizations similar to net safe that

organizations similar to net safe that will be able to deal with incidents of

will be able to deal with incidents of

will be able to deal with incidents of cyberbullying now we’ve got to be

cyberbullying now we’ve got to be

cyberbullying now we’ve got to be reasonable about this

reasonable about this

reasonable about this in the same way that the crime of theft

in the same way that the crime of theft

in the same way that the crime of theft is not going to stop people stealing

is not going to stop people stealing

is not going to stop people stealing stuff a law against cyberbullying isn’t

stuff a law against cyberbullying isn’t

stuff a law against cyberbullying isn’t going to stop cyberbullying or digital

going to stop cyberbullying or digital

going to stop cyberbullying or digital communications that cause harm but what

communications that cause harm but what

communications that cause harm but what is important is that there is a remedy

is important is that there is a remedy

is important is that there is a remedy the law will provide a remedy for those

the law will provide a remedy for those

the law will provide a remedy for those who suffer from cyberbullying the good

who suffer from cyberbullying the good

who suffer from cyberbullying the good thing about it is that victims no longer

thing about it is that victims no longer

thing about it is that victims no longer have to take it they no longer have to

have to take it they no longer have to

have to take it they no longer have to curl up into a little ball mentally or

curl up into a little ball mentally or

curl up into a little ball mentally or physically and hope that it all goes

physically and hope that it all goes

physically and hope that it all goes away they can do something about it they

away they can do something about it they

away they can do something about it they can bring the perpetrator to account

can bring the perpetrator to account

can bring the perpetrator to account thanks for listening

thanks for listening

thanks for listening [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *