Press "Enter" to skip to content

THE HIDDEN WAR OF WOMEN SOLDIERS | HELEN BENEDICT | TEDxISM


I first saw Michaela standing upright

I first saw Michaela standing upright and silent in the back of a classroom

and silent in the back of a classroom

and silent in the back of a classroom while a group of male soldiers told

while a group of male soldiers told

while a group of male soldiers told stories about fighting in the Iraq war

stories about fighting in the Iraq war

stories about fighting in the Iraq war struck by her youth and posture I asked

struck by her youth and posture I asked

struck by her youth and posture I asked if she had been a soldier – oh yes she

if she had been a soldier – oh yes she

if she had been a soldier – oh yes she said I was a gunner every night I was

said I was a gunner every night I was

said I was a gunner every night I was shot at but when I say I was in a war

shot at but when I say I was in a war

shot at but when I say I was in a war nobody believes me and you know why

nobody believes me and you know why

nobody believes me and you know why because I’m a female but what was it

because I’m a female but what was it

because I’m a female but what was it like being a woman in combat I asked she

like being a woman in combat I asked she

like being a woman in combat I asked she looked at me

looked at me

looked at me well she said the first thing you’ve got

well she said the first thing you’ve got

well she said the first thing you’ve got to understand is that if you’re a girl

to understand is that if you’re a girl

to understand is that if you’re a girl in the military the guys only let you be

in the military the guys only let you be

in the military the guys only let you be one of three things a bitch a poor or a

one of three things a bitch a poor or a

one of three things a bitch a poor or a dyke you’re a bitch if you won’t sleep

dyke you’re a bitch if you won’t sleep

dyke you’re a bitch if you won’t sleep with them you’re a whore if you’ve got

with them you’re a whore if you’ve got

with them you’re a whore if you’ve got even one boyfriend and you’re a dyke if

even one boyfriend and you’re a dyke if

even one boyfriend and you’re a dyke if they don’t like you so you can’t win yes

they don’t like you so you can’t win yes

they don’t like you so you can’t win yes sir the young woman who was standing

sir the young woman who was standing

sir the young woman who was standing beside her that’s how it was for me I

beside her that’s how it was for me I

beside her that’s how it was for me I was shocked at the time I knew nothing

was shocked at the time I knew nothing

was shocked at the time I knew nothing about soldiers but I did know that more

about soldiers but I did know that more

about soldiers but I did know that more American women had served in Iraq than

American women had served in Iraq than

American women had served in Iraq than in any war since World War two and that

in any war since World War two and that

in any war since World War two and that many had been wounded had lost limbs and

many had been wounded had lost limbs and

many had been wounded had lost limbs and some had even been killed could what

some had even been killed could what

some had even been killed could what these young women were telling me be

these young women were telling me be

these young women were telling me be true and if so what did that say about

true and if so what did that say about

true and if so what did that say about the progress of women in my country in

the progress of women in my country in

the progress of women in my country in general I decided to find out so I spent

general I decided to find out so I spent

general I decided to find out so I spent the next three years traveling the u.s.

the next three years traveling the u.s.

the next three years traveling the u.s. listening to some 40 women who had

listening to some 40 women who had

listening to some 40 women who had served in Iraq or Afghanistan I learned

served in Iraq or Afghanistan I learned

served in Iraq or Afghanistan I learned a lot from them

a lot from them

a lot from them I learned about endurance and resilience

I learned about endurance and resilience

I learned about endurance and resilience and terrible suffering but I also

and terrible suffering but I also

and terrible suffering but I also learned about courage some of the women

learned about courage some of the women

learned about courage some of the women I met told me they were proud of their

I met told me they were proud of their

I met told me they were proud of their service others were not but almost all

service others were not but almost all

service others were not but almost all Michaela’s words and told me they had

Michaela’s words and told me they had

Michaela’s words and told me they had felt painfully alone in Iraq because

felt painfully alone in Iraq because

felt painfully alone in Iraq because they were so outnumbered by men my

they were so outnumbered by men my

they were so outnumbered by men my company consisted of 1,500 men and only

company consisted of 1,500 men and only

company consisted of 1,500 men and only 18 women one told me I was fresh meat to

18 women one told me I was fresh meat to

18 women one told me I was fresh meat to the hungry men there the mortar rounds

the hungry men there the mortar rounds

the hungry men there the mortar rounds that came in daily did less damage to me

that came in daily did less damage to me

that came in daily did less damage to me than the men who shared my food sadly

than the men who shared my food sadly

than the men who shared my food sadly her experience was not unusual at the

her experience was not unusual at the

her experience was not unusual at the time some 90% of women in the US

time some 90% of women in the US

time some 90% of women in the US military were reporting being sexually

military were reporting being sexually

military were reporting being sexually harassed while serving and between a

harassed while serving and between a

harassed while serving and between a quarter and a third said they were raped

quarter and a third said they were raped

quarter and a third said they were raped not by the enemy but by the men on their

not by the enemy but by the men on their

not by the enemy but by the men on their own side was sexual persecution

own side was sexual persecution

own side was sexual persecution considered a disease these rates would

considered a disease these rates would

considered a disease these rates would be an epidemic and even though the

be an epidemic and even though the

be an epidemic and even though the military has been instigating reformists

military has been instigating reformists

military has been instigating reformists lately these these numbers have not

lately these these numbers have not

lately these these numbers have not decreased this isn’t only an American

decreased this isn’t only an American

decreased this isn’t only an American problem

problem

problem Canada Britain France Italy South Korea

Canada Britain France Italy South Korea

Canada Britain France Italy South Korea Israel have all reported sexual assault

Israel have all reported sexual assault

Israel have all reported sexual assault of women in their militaries and women

of women in their militaries and women

of women in their militaries and women are not the only targets in the u.s.

are not the only targets in the u.s.

are not the only targets in the u.s. some 2 percent of men in the military

some 2 percent of men in the military

some 2 percent of men in the military are also sexually assaulted usually by

are also sexually assaulted usually by

are also sexually assaulted usually by groups of other men or of someone of a

groups of other men or of someone of a

groups of other men or of someone of a higher rank the reason men rape men is

higher rank the reason men rape men is

higher rank the reason men rape men is the same reason men rape women not out

the same reason men rape women not out

the same reason men rape women not out of out of control lust as is commonly

of out of control lust as is commonly

of out of control lust as is commonly assumed but as a way to degrade

assumed but as a way to degrade

assumed but as a way to degrade humiliate and terrorize yes there are

humiliate and terrorize yes there are

humiliate and terrorize yes there are rapists who are sexual sadists but by

rapists who are sexual sadists but by

rapists who are sexual sadists but by far the most are venting rage and

far the most are venting rage and

far the most are venting rage and resentment or trying to punish people

resentment or trying to punish people

resentment or trying to punish people they see as threats or Outsiders the

they see as threats or Outsiders the

they see as threats or Outsiders the same is true of sexual harassment and

same is true of sexual harassment and

same is true of sexual harassment and bullying in the military which is why

bullying in the military which is why

bullying in the military which is why military assailants tend to target those

military assailants tend to target those

military assailants tend to target those who have traditionally been

who have traditionally been

who have traditionally been considered outliers women anyone who’s

considered outliers women anyone who’s

considered outliers women anyone who’s not white men they see as weak or gay

not white men they see as weak or gay

not white men they see as weak or gay and lately Muslims let me talk a minute

and lately Muslims let me talk a minute

and lately Muslims let me talk a minute about military culture there is probably

about military culture there is probably

about military culture there is probably no institution that gives ordinary

no institution that gives ordinary

no institution that gives ordinary people so much power over others as the

people so much power over others as the

people so much power over others as the military with its chain of command

military with its chain of command

military with its chain of command structure and insistence on

structure and insistence on

structure and insistence on unquestioning obedience unfortunately

unquestioning obedience unfortunately

unquestioning obedience unfortunately this leads easily to abuse last July

this leads easily to abuse last July

this leads easily to abuse last July the New York Times revealed that certain

the New York Times revealed that certain

the New York Times revealed that certain drill sergeants in the US Marine Corps

drill sergeants in the US Marine Corps

drill sergeants in the US Marine Corps were treating their recruits so badly so

were treating their recruits so badly so

were treating their recruits so badly so cruelly tormenting them torturing and

cruelly tormenting them torturing and

cruelly tormenting them torturing and beating them that several died and some

beating them that several died and some

beating them that several died and some committed suicide yet had those recruits

committed suicide yet had those recruits

committed suicide yet had those recruits tried to fight back or report the

tried to fight back or report the

tried to fight back or report the attacks they probably would have been

attacks they probably would have been

attacks they probably would have been made to suffer even more

made to suffer even more

made to suffer even more this tradition of blind obedience and

this tradition of blind obedience and

this tradition of blind obedience and extreme punishment exists to some extent

extreme punishment exists to some extent

extreme punishment exists to some extent in all the military branches officer

in all the military branches officer

in all the military branches officer academies included because it’s seen as

academies included because it’s seen as

academies included because it’s seen as a way to build a disciplined fighting

a way to build a disciplined fighting

a way to build a disciplined fighting force but when it’s combined with the

force but when it’s combined with the

force but when it’s combined with the misogyny so deeply embedded in military

misogyny so deeply embedded in military

misogyny so deeply embedded in military culture it creates an atmosphere ripe

culture it creates an atmosphere ripe

culture it creates an atmosphere ripe for sexual persecution and rape of

for sexual persecution and rape of

for sexual persecution and rape of course sexual predation exists in

course sexual predation exists in

course sexual predation exists in civilian life too but there are

civilian life too but there are

civilian life too but there are differences in the military that in many

differences in the military that in many

differences in the military that in many ways make it worse your comrades could

ways make it worse your comrades could

ways make it worse your comrades could your or your your superiors could be

your or your your superiors could be

your or your your superiors could be insulting you all day long mocking you

insulting you all day long mocking you

insulting you all day long mocking you threatening you grabbing you but you can

threatening you grabbing you but you can

threatening you grabbing you but you can never escape them to go home to the

never escape them to go home to the

never escape them to go home to the comfort of friends and family you have

comfort of friends and family you have

comfort of friends and family you have to live with these people 24 hours a day

to live with these people 24 hours a day

to live with these people 24 hours a day for months sometimes even four years the

for months sometimes even four years the

for months sometimes even four years the same is true even if you’ve been

same is true even if you’ve been

same is true even if you’ve been sexually assaulted a sexual assault can

sexually assaulted a sexual assault can

sexually assaulted a sexual assault can feel like an attempt

feel like an attempt

feel like an attempt murder and indeed assailants do often

murder and indeed assailants do often

murder and indeed assailants do often threaten to kill or maim their victims

threaten to kill or maim their victims

threaten to kill or maim their victims but in the military you might have to

but in the military you might have to

but in the military you might have to live with that assailant day and night

live with that assailant day and night

live with that assailant day and night and even obey his every order of he’s

and even obey his every order of he’s

and even obey his every order of he’s your superior and rank all the while

your superior and rank all the while

your superior and rank all the while afraid that he might attack you again

afraid that he might attack you again

afraid that he might attack you again and then because a soldier is supposed

and then because a soldier is supposed

and then because a soldier is supposed to be able to defend herself and never

to be able to defend herself and never

to be able to defend herself and never complain even if you do report the abuse

complain even if you do report the abuse

complain even if you do report the abuse you are likely to be treated as weak a

you are likely to be treated as weak a

you are likely to be treated as weak a failure and liar and a snitch to be

failure and liar and a snitch to be

failure and liar and a snitch to be bitch to be blamed and ostracized and

bitch to be blamed and ostracized and

bitch to be blamed and ostracized and maybe even punished victim blaming and

maybe even punished victim blaming and

maybe even punished victim blaming and retaliation are so rife in the US

retaliation are so rife in the US

retaliation are so rife in the US military that an average of 80 percent

military that an average of 80 percent

military that an average of 80 percent of victims never report the assaults at

of victims never report the assaults at

of victims never report the assaults at all moreover because you’ve been trained

all moreover because you’ve been trained

all moreover because you’ve been trained to see your comrades as family the

to see your comrades as family the

to see your comrades as family the trauma of an assault is exacerbated by a

trauma of an assault is exacerbated by a

trauma of an assault is exacerbated by a devastating sense of betrayal and the

devastating sense of betrayal and the

devastating sense of betrayal and the knowledge that the very people who are

knowledge that the very people who are

knowledge that the very people who are supposed to watch your back in battle

supposed to watch your back in battle

supposed to watch your back in battle are threatening you instead this might

are threatening you instead this might

are threatening you instead this might be why a woman who’s been sexually

be why a woman who’s been sexually

be why a woman who’s been sexually assaulted in the US military is six

assaulted in the US military is six

assaulted in the US military is six times more likely to kill herself than

times more likely to kill herself than

times more likely to kill herself than any other veterans it is not only

any other veterans it is not only

any other veterans it is not only military women who suffer this sort of

military women who suffer this sort of

military women who suffer this sort of retribution for trying to be equal to

retribution for trying to be equal to

retribution for trying to be equal to men women have almost always been

men women have almost always been

men women have almost always been punished when they first enter all-male

punished when they first enter all-male

punished when they first enter all-male domains you might know women

domains you might know women

domains you might know women firefighters or women police officers or

firefighters or women police officers or

firefighters or women police officers or others who were facing this now and look

others who were facing this now and look

others who were facing this now and look at the scandals to have come out of the

at the scandals to have come out of the

at the scandals to have come out of the Silicon Valley recently about the way

Silicon Valley recently about the way

Silicon Valley recently about the way women are being treated in the tech

women are being treated in the tech

women are being treated in the tech industry back when women first sought

industry back when women first sought

industry back when women first sought the vote it was not unusual for them to

the vote it was not unusual for them to

the vote it was not unusual for them to be imprisoned beaten fired from jobs

be imprisoned beaten fired from jobs

be imprisoned beaten fired from jobs sometimes even forced to be to give up

sometimes even forced to be to give up

sometimes even forced to be to give up their children the story of women’s

their children the story of women’s

their children the story of women’s fight for equality is the story of the

fight for equality is the story of the

fight for equality is the story of the fight for civil rights against resistant

fight for civil rights against resistant

fight for civil rights against resistant all over the world that is why I see

all over the world that is why I see

all over the world that is why I see military women today as fighting for

military women today as fighting for

military women today as fighting for sexual equality for us all they have

sexual equality for us all they have

sexual equality for us all they have gone to the most extreme citadel of

gone to the most extreme citadel of

gone to the most extreme citadel of maleness the military with its age-old

maleness the military with its age-old

maleness the military with its age-old macho traditions and said I am taking my

macho traditions and said I am taking my

macho traditions and said I am taking my place not behind you not beneath you but

place not behind you not beneath you but

place not behind you not beneath you but beside you and more and more women are

beside you and more and more women are

beside you and more and more women are succeeding men are accepting this and

succeeding men are accepting this and

succeeding men are accepting this and things are evening out but resistance

things are evening out but resistance

things are evening out but resistance from some in the Citadel remains strong

from some in the Citadel remains strong

from some in the Citadel remains strong only two years ago Human Rights Watch

only two years ago Human Rights Watch

only two years ago Human Rights Watch released statistics showing that a woman

released statistics showing that a woman

released statistics showing that a woman who reports a sexual assault in the US

who reports a sexual assault in the US

who reports a sexual assault in the US military is 12 times more likely to be

military is 12 times more likely to be

military is 12 times more likely to be punished than a man who commits 1 6 out

punished than a man who commits 1 6 out

punished than a man who commits 1 6 out of 10 women who reported assaults were

of 10 women who reported assaults were

of 10 women who reported assaults were retaliated against and one out of 3 was

retaliated against and one out of 3 was

retaliated against and one out of 3 was pushed out of the military altogether

pushed out of the military altogether

pushed out of the military altogether meanwhile not one of those retaliate

meanwhile not one of those retaliate

meanwhile not one of those retaliate errs or even face charges and the

errs or even face charges and the

errs or even face charges and the conviction rates for rape in the US

conviction rates for rape in the US

conviction rates for rape in the US military has been actually declining at

military has been actually declining at

military has been actually declining at this point you might well wonder why a

this point you might well wonder why a

this point you might well wonder why a woman would want to join the military at

woman would want to join the military at

woman would want to join the military at all if women are treated this badly you

all if women are treated this badly you

all if women are treated this badly you may well be thinking maybe they should

may well be thinking maybe they should

may well be thinking maybe they should just stay out but women are treated

just stay out but women are treated

just stay out but women are treated badly in civilian life 2 in the u.s.

badly in civilian life 2 in the u.s.

badly in civilian life 2 in the u.s. domestic violence is the leading cause

domestic violence is the leading cause

domestic violence is the leading cause of injury to women but we can’t expect

of injury to women but we can’t expect

of injury to women but we can’t expect half the world’s population to hide

half the world’s population to hide

half the world’s population to hide itself away no misogyny is not the fault

itself away no misogyny is not the fault

itself away no misogyny is not the fault of a woman and she should not be

of a woman and she should not be

of a woman and she should not be punished for it it is the fault of men

punished for it it is the fault of men

punished for it it is the fault of men who have yet to face up to reality

speaking of reality over the years I’ve

speaking of reality over the years I’ve heard a lot of objections to women

heard a lot of objections to women

heard a lot of objections to women joining the military

joining the military

joining the military look I confess I’ve made some myself

look I confess I’ve made some myself

look I confess I’ve made some myself but they all depend on

but they all depend on

but they all depend on types stuck in the past some of those

types stuck in the past some of those

types stuck in the past some of those stereotypes are sentimental a woman is

stereotypes are sentimental a woman is

stereotypes are sentimental a woman is built to nurture not fight and is better

built to nurture not fight and is better

built to nurture not fight and is better suited to promoting peace than war

suited to promoting peace than war

suited to promoting peace than war this is appealing but it’s not true of

this is appealing but it’s not true of

this is appealing but it’s not true of all women some of the stereotypes are

all women some of the stereotypes are

all women some of the stereotypes are insulting women are too physically weak

insulting women are too physically weak

insulting women are too physically weak and emotionally volatile to depend upon

and emotionally volatile to depend upon

and emotionally volatile to depend upon in a crisis

in a crisis

in a crisis well military women and world leaders

well military women and world leaders

well military women and world leaders have long proven that one false some of

have long proven that one false some of

have long proven that one false some of the stereotypes are absurd women will

the stereotypes are absurd women will

the stereotypes are absurd women will ruin the camaraderie of all-male units

ruin the camaraderie of all-male units

ruin the camaraderie of all-male units and chivalry will make men more inclined

and chivalry will make men more inclined

and chivalry will make men more inclined to protect women in a battle than to

to protect women in a battle than to

to protect women in a battle than to fight I find this last one particularly

fight I find this last one particularly

fight I find this last one particularly laughable in the light of the most under

laughable in the light of the most under

laughable in the light of the most under chivalrous rates of sexual assault in

chivalrous rates of sexual assault in

chivalrous rates of sexual assault in the military these were the same sorts

the military these were the same sorts

the military these were the same sorts of arguments that were used to prevent

of arguments that were used to prevent

of arguments that were used to prevent women from voting from inheriting

women from voting from inheriting

women from voting from inheriting property from choosing their own

property from choosing their own

property from choosing their own destinies from going to university from

destinies from going to university from

destinies from going to university from becoming doctors or scientists

becoming doctors or scientists

becoming doctors or scientists politicians or presidents and every one

politicians or presidents and every one

politicians or presidents and every one of these arguments has been proven

of these arguments has been proven

of these arguments has been proven specious now a woman should be able to

specious now a woman should be able to

specious now a woman should be able to choose for herself who and what to be

choose for herself who and what to be

choose for herself who and what to be certainly not all women are suited to

certainly not all women are suited to

certainly not all women are suited to the military but then nor are all men

the military but then nor are all men

the military but then nor are all men that is a decision that should be up to

that is a decision that should be up to

that is a decision that should be up to the individual not you or me or a bunch

the individual not you or me or a bunch

the individual not you or me or a bunch of all boys in the government with this

of all boys in the government with this

of all boys in the government with this in mind I have a suggestion to measure

in mind I have a suggestion to measure

in mind I have a suggestion to measure how women are doing in your country take

how women are doing in your country take

how women are doing in your country take a look at how your military is treating

a look at how your military is treating

a look at how your military is treating them do they have the same job

them do they have the same job

them do they have the same job opportunities as men how many women

opportunities as men how many women

opportunities as men how many women holds the highest ranks what are the

holds the highest ranks what are the

holds the highest ranks what are the rates of sexual assault and harassment

rates of sexual assault and harassment

rates of sexual assault and harassment in your military and what is your

in your military and what is your

in your military and what is your military doing about it are women even

military doing about it are women even

military doing about it are women even allowed in your military at all and if

allowed in your military at all and if

allowed in your military at all and if not why not now take a look at the women

not why not now take a look at the women

not why not now take a look at the women you know

you know

you know at school at work at home among your

at school at work at home among your

at school at work at home among your friends are they being held back from

friends are they being held back from

friends are they being held back from opportunities can they speak up about

opportunities can they speak up about

opportunities can they speak up about their rights are they listened to with

their rights are they listened to with

their rights are they listened to with the same respect as men are they paid

the same respect as men are they paid

the same respect as men are they paid and promoted at the same rapes as men

and promoted at the same rapes as men

and promoted at the same rapes as men and if you’re a woman are you and if not

and if you’re a woman are you and if not

and if you’re a woman are you and if not what are you gonna do about it you don’t

what are you gonna do about it you don’t

what are you gonna do about it you don’t have to be in the military to fight for

have to be in the military to fight for

have to be in the military to fight for what’s right

what’s right

what’s right remember Michaela standing so silently

remember Michaela standing so silently

remember Michaela standing so silently in the back of that classroom she didn’t

in the back of that classroom she didn’t

in the back of that classroom she didn’t stay silent for long she spoke out on

stay silent for long she spoke out on

stay silent for long she spoke out on behalf of military women not only to me

behalf of military women not only to me

behalf of military women not only to me for my book but on television and now

for my book but on television and now

for my book but on television and now she holds an important job in government

she holds an important job in government

she holds an important job in government helping veterans and this brings me to

helping veterans and this brings me to

helping veterans and this brings me to my earlier point about courage a lot of

my earlier point about courage a lot of

my earlier point about courage a lot of the women I met are fighting back now

the women I met are fighting back now

the women I met are fighting back now they’ve overcome the self blame and

they’ve overcome the self blame and

they’ve overcome the self blame and shame they learned in the military and

shame they learned in the military and

shame they learned in the military and are speaking out about sexual assault

are speaking out about sexual assault

are speaking out about sexual assault and discrimination to help others and

and discrimination to help others and

and discrimination to help others and demand reform but this entails taking

demand reform but this entails taking

demand reform but this entails taking risks because military whistleblowers

risks because military whistleblowers

risks because military whistleblowers are seen by many as disloyal or even

are seen by many as disloyal or even

are seen by many as disloyal or even treacherous these women know better

treacherous these women know better

treacherous these women know better some have joined lawsuits some have

some have joined lawsuits some have

some have joined lawsuits some have testified to Congress some have appeared

testified to Congress some have appeared

testified to Congress some have appeared in documentaries and some have written

in documentaries and some have written

in documentaries and some have written books after all a soldier’s courage

books after all a soldier’s courage

books after all a soldier’s courage doesn’t have to be defined by saving or

doesn’t have to be defined by saving or

doesn’t have to be defined by saving or killing people on a battlefield it can

killing people on a battlefield it can

killing people on a battlefield it can be the kind of courage it takes to speak

be the kind of courage it takes to speak

be the kind of courage it takes to speak out against injustice even in the face

out against injustice even in the face

out against injustice even in the face of threats and that is the kind of

of threats and that is the kind of

of threats and that is the kind of courage we can all use military and

courage we can all use military and

courage we can all use military and civilian alike that’s the kind of

civilian alike that’s the kind of

civilian alike that’s the kind of courage that gives us hope thank you

courage that gives us hope thank you

courage that gives us hope thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *