Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Hidden Power Within – Bee-ing Healthy | Vienna Kowallik | TEDxOIST


[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

it is not that long that we realized

it is not that long that we realized that we are surrounded by a world

that we are surrounded by a world

that we are surrounded by a world invisible to our eyes consisting of very

invisible to our eyes consisting of very

invisible to our eyes consisting of very tiny organisms which yet have a

tiny organisms which yet have a

tiny organisms which yet have a tremendous influence on animal health

tremendous influence on animal health

tremendous influence on animal health ecology and evolution on earth we are

ecology and evolution on earth we are

ecology and evolution on earth we are surrounded by a fascinating biodiversity

surrounded by a fascinating biodiversity

surrounded by a fascinating biodiversity and this biodiversity clearly must have

and this biodiversity clearly must have

and this biodiversity clearly must have been evolved at some point and taking a

been evolved at some point and taking a

been evolved at some point and taking a look onto this and putting the earth

look onto this and putting the earth

look onto this and putting the earth life history onto a simplified time

life history onto a simplified time

life history onto a simplified time scale like over a calendar year we will

scale like over a calendar year we will

scale like over a calendar year we will realize that early my life just appeared

realize that early my life just appeared

realize that early my life just appeared around March on earth and was consisted

around March on earth and was consisted

around March on earth and was consisted of single-celled organisms until

of single-celled organisms until

of single-celled organisms until September the first multicellular

September the first multicellular

September the first multicellular organisms just appeared in October lands

organisms just appeared in October lands

organisms just appeared in October lands like land plants and insects evolved in

like land plants and insects evolved in

like land plants and insects evolved in November and higher animals in December

November and higher animals in December

November and higher animals in December and when we put the evolution of the

and when we put the evolution of the

and when we put the evolution of the humans onto the scale will realize that

humans onto the scale will realize that

humans onto the scale will realize that we just appeared very very recently in

we just appeared very very recently in

we just appeared very very recently in earth life history like basically in the

earth life history like basically in the

earth life history like basically in the end of December so life on Earth was

end of December so life on Earth was

end of December so life on Earth was dominated by and consisted of simple

dominated by and consisted of simple

dominated by and consisted of simple single-celled organisms for most of the

single-celled organisms for most of the

single-celled organisms for most of the time we all evolved in a microbial world

time we all evolved in a microbial world

time we all evolved in a microbial world and the word microorganism already

and the word microorganism already

and the word microorganism already implies that these organisms are too

implies that these organisms are too

implies that these organisms are too tiny to be seen by naked eye and

tiny to be seen by naked eye and

tiny to be seen by naked eye and therefore humans had no idea about the

therefore humans had no idea about the

therefore humans had no idea about the existence for a very long time even

existence for a very long time even

existence for a very long time even fatal disease hunger crisis and

fatal disease hunger crisis and

fatal disease hunger crisis and epidemics which are actually caused by

epidemics which are actually caused by

epidemics which are actually caused by microbial pathogens could never be

microbial pathogens could never be

microbial pathogens could never be brought into context and there was no

brought into context and there was no

brought into context and there was no explanation for that and so the first

explanation for that and so the first

explanation for that and so the first insights into microbiology

insights into microbiology

insights into microbiology was achieved in 1675 by antonie van

was achieved in 1675 by antonie van

was achieved in 1675 by antonie van Leeuwenhoek so Anthony wasn’t the

Leeuwenhoek so Anthony wasn’t the

Leeuwenhoek so Anthony wasn’t the scientist he was a lens grinder but his

scientist he was a lens grinder but his

scientist he was a lens grinder but his abilities were very great that he could

abilities were very great that he could

abilities were very great that he could grind a lens of the size of a rice grain

grind a lens of the size of a rice grain

grind a lens of the size of a rice grain which was extremely effective and he

which was extremely effective and he

which was extremely effective and he built these first small microscopes and

built these first small microscopes and

built these first small microscopes and he decided to take a look into a droplet

he decided to take a look into a droplet

he decided to take a look into a droplet of pond water and what he saw was

of pond water and what he saw was

of pond water and what he saw was basically mind-blowing for him he got

basically mind-blowing for him he got

basically mind-blowing for him he got inside

inside

inside into a new hidden world full of

into a new hidden world full of

into a new hidden world full of mysterious creatures that no human being

mysterious creatures that no human being

mysterious creatures that no human being has ever seen before and he called them

has ever seen before and he called them

has ever seen before and he called them very little and immaculate and he drew

very little and immaculate and he drew

very little and immaculate and he drew them but actually his work wasn’t fully

them but actually his work wasn’t fully

them but actually his work wasn’t fully acknowledged for almost 200 years

acknowledged for almost 200 years

acknowledged for almost 200 years and most work about pulling the

and most work about pulling the

and most work about pulling the microbial world into light was achieved

microbial world into light was achieved

microbial world into light was achieved between the 1860 s and 70s and two of

between the 1860 s and 70s and two of

between the 1860 s and 70s and two of the most important works were done by

the most important works were done by

the most important works were done by Louis Pasteur who could show that wine

Louis Pasteur who could show that wine

Louis Pasteur who could show that wine fermentation is actually not caused by a

fermentation is actually not caused by a

fermentation is actually not caused by a chemical process which was believed to

chemical process which was believed to

chemical process which was believed to that time point but rather by metabolic

that time point but rather by metabolic

that time point but rather by metabolic processes of living microorganisms

processes of living microorganisms

processes of living microorganisms because if you boil everything you kill

because if you boil everything you kill

because if you boil everything you kill the life and there’s no activity anymore

the life and there’s no activity anymore

the life and there’s no activity anymore and this is a sterilization method which

and this is a sterilization method which

and this is a sterilization method which is still used in food industries and

is still used in food industries and

is still used in food industries and which is called pasteurization and

which is called pasteurization and

which is called pasteurization and Hobart caja was the first person who

Hobart caja was the first person who

Hobart caja was the first person who could show that a bacterium was the

could show that a bacterium was the

could show that a bacterium was the cause of a disease of anthrax and

cause of a disease of anthrax and

cause of a disease of anthrax and afterwards the germ theory of disease

afterwards the germ theory of disease

afterwards the germ theory of disease was generally acknowledged which was

was generally acknowledged which was

was generally acknowledged which was followed by a boom and microbiological

followed by a boom and microbiological

followed by a boom and microbiological research and discovering several

research and discovering several

research and discovering several pathogens being the cause of many

pathogens being the cause of many

pathogens being the cause of many horrible disease but there were also

horrible disease but there were also

horrible disease but there were also findings about making beneficial use of

findings about making beneficial use of

findings about making beneficial use of some microbes in terms of fighting such

some microbes in terms of fighting such

some microbes in terms of fighting such pathogens in 1929 Alexander Fleming

pathogens in 1929 Alexander Fleming

pathogens in 1929 Alexander Fleming discovered that there was a mold

discovered that there was a mold

discovered that there was a mold contamination on one of his agar plates

contamination on one of his agar plates

contamination on one of his agar plates he actually studied pathogenic bacteria

he actually studied pathogenic bacteria

he actually studied pathogenic bacteria and normally that’s not a big problem

and normally that’s not a big problem

and normally that’s not a big problem you which is discs are displayed but he

you which is discs are displayed but he

you which is discs are displayed but he realized that around this mold colony

realized that around this mold colony

realized that around this mold colony the bacterial growth was inhibited so

the bacterial growth was inhibited so

the bacterial growth was inhibited so the mold was secreting something that

the mold was secreting something that

the mold was secreting something that killed the bacterium and this is the

killed the bacterium and this is the

killed the bacterium and this is the very first antibiotic penicillin which

very first antibiotic penicillin which

very first antibiotic penicillin which saved thousands and thousands of lives

saved thousands and thousands of lives

saved thousands and thousands of lives and clearly the mold is not producing

and clearly the mold is not producing

and clearly the mold is not producing this for human sake it is doing this

this for human sake it is doing this

this for human sake it is doing this because in a natural microbial community

because in a natural microbial community

because in a natural microbial community it will be surrounded by divers other

it will be surrounded by divers other

it will be surrounded by divers other microbial species and they are all fired

microbial species and they are all fired

microbial species and they are all fired they fight for resources for space and

they fight for resources for space and

they fight for resources for space and food and indeed there are several

food and indeed there are several

food and indeed there are several microbes that are able to produce a

microbes that are able to produce a

microbes that are able to produce a bunch of nasty compounds like

bunch of nasty compounds like

bunch of nasty compounds like antibiotics toxins or ethanol to kill

antibiotics toxins or ethanol to kill

antibiotics toxins or ethanol to kill competing microbial species

competing microbial species

competing microbial species so people started to realize the

so people started to realize the

so people started to realize the importance but also the potential to

importance but also the potential to

importance but also the potential to stop to study microorganisms and indeed

stop to study microorganisms and indeed

stop to study microorganisms and indeed we can’t culture several of them and we

we can’t culture several of them and we

we can’t culture several of them and we can make them visible and accessible for

can make them visible and accessible for

can make them visible and accessible for us but indeed only the minority of

us but indeed only the minority of

us but indeed only the minority of microorganisms on earth is really

microorganisms on earth is really

microorganisms on earth is really cultivable and it’s a bit hard to talk

cultivable and it’s a bit hard to talk

cultivable and it’s a bit hard to talk about numbers because researchers are

about numbers because researchers are

about numbers because researchers are still arguing how many microbial species

still arguing how many microbial species

still arguing how many microbial species really we really have on earth but

really we really have on earth but

really we really have on earth but potentially it’s about one percent that

potentially it’s about one percent that

potentially it’s about one percent that we know so if you want to study

we know so if you want to study

we know so if you want to study microorganisms from an natural

microorganisms from an natural

microorganisms from an natural environment you culture them and then

environment you culture them and then

environment you culture them and then you can classify them you can run

you can classify them you can run

you can classify them you can run experiments and you can sequence them to

experiments and you can sequence them to

experiments and you can sequence them to get their genomic information but this

get their genomic information but this

get their genomic information but this information is just the tip of the

information is just the tip of the

information is just the tip of the iceberg and we have no idea what is

iceberg and we have no idea what is

iceberg and we have no idea what is below and which diversity we are missing

below and which diversity we are missing

below and which diversity we are missing just because we cannot culture this

just because we cannot culture this

just because we cannot culture this stuff and luckily science is progressing

stuff and luckily science is progressing

stuff and luckily science is progressing and nowadays we have different methods

and nowadays we have different methods

and nowadays we have different methods which will not rely on the scattering

which will not rely on the scattering

which will not rely on the scattering step anymore and depending on what

step anymore and depending on what

step anymore and depending on what you’re interested in you can extract

you’re interested in you can extract

you’re interested in you can extract total DNA RNA or proteins you can

total DNA RNA or proteins you can

total DNA RNA or proteins you can analyze the data and you can check the

analyze the data and you can check the

analyze the data and you can check the diversity the relative abundance or you

diversity the relative abundance or you

diversity the relative abundance or you do functional profiling of the whole

do functional profiling of the whole

do functional profiling of the whole microbial community and this is when

microbial community and this is when

microbial community and this is when researchers started to basically

researchers started to basically

researchers started to basically sequence everything around them and also

sequence everything around them and also

sequence everything around them and also when we realized how huge the

when we realized how huge the

when we realized how huge the biodiversity in the microbial world

biodiversity in the microbial world

biodiversity in the microbial world really is and look outside of the window

really is and look outside of the window

really is and look outside of the window go into a forest or dive deep dive

go into a forest or dive deep dive

go into a forest or dive deep dive deeply down to an awesome coral reef it

deeply down to an awesome coral reef it

deeply down to an awesome coral reef it is very likely that he will never face

is very likely that he will never face

is very likely that he will never face such biodiversity that you can find in

such biodiversity that you can find in

such biodiversity that you can find in microbial communities and it was also

microbial communities and it was also

microbial communities and it was also the time point when we realized microbes

the time point when we realized microbes

the time point when we realized microbes are not only everywhere around us they

are not only everywhere around us they

are not only everywhere around us they also colonize us inside and outside so

also colonize us inside and outside so

also colonize us inside and outside so we have at least as many bacterial cells

we have at least as many bacterial cells

we have at least as many bacterial cells colonizing us as we have actual human

colonizing us as we have actual human

colonizing us as we have actual human body cells there are 30 to 40 trillion

body cells there are 30 to 40 trillion

body cells there are 30 to 40 trillion there are 12 zeroes so this is a really

there are 12 zeroes so this is a really

there are 12 zeroes so this is a really huge number and it somehow must affect

huge number and it somehow must affect

huge number and it somehow must affect us somehow that

us somehow that

us somehow that and nowadays we agree that all higher

and nowadays we agree that all higher

and nowadays we agree that all higher organisms are closely associated with a

organisms are closely associated with a

organisms are closely associated with a diverse microbial community and this

diverse microbial community and this

diverse microbial community and this gave rise to the term hula beyond

gave rise to the term hula beyond

gave rise to the term hula beyond defining the host organism together with

defining the host organism together with

defining the host organism together with these associated microbes the microbiota

these associated microbes the microbiota

these associated microbes the microbiota as the unit natural selection acts on in

as the unit natural selection acts on in

as the unit natural selection acts on in the beginning of hosts microbiota

the beginning of hosts microbiota

the beginning of hosts microbiota research again many peoples focused on

research again many peoples focused on

research again many peoples focused on studying the bad guys and clearly there

studying the bad guys and clearly there

studying the bad guys and clearly there are some pathogenic microbes that can

are some pathogenic microbes that can

are some pathogenic microbes that can make us sick but that’s not everything

make us sick but that’s not everything

make us sick but that’s not everything and it more and more turned out that

and it more and more turned out that

and it more and more turned out that there are diverse microorganisms having

there are diverse microorganisms having

there are diverse microorganisms having different beneficial functions for the

different beneficial functions for the

different beneficial functions for the host and so your microbiota will act as

host and so your microbiota will act as

host and so your microbiota will act as a first barrier protecting your body

a first barrier protecting your body

a first barrier protecting your body from getting colonized by pathogens they

from getting colonized by pathogens they

from getting colonized by pathogens they can actively fight pathogens by for

can actively fight pathogens by for

can actively fight pathogens by for example producing antimicrobial

example producing antimicrobial

example producing antimicrobial compounds they can improve host

compounds they can improve host

compounds they can improve host nutrition by helping the host to digest

nutrition by helping the host to digest

nutrition by helping the host to digest food or by supplying beneficial

food or by supplying beneficial

food or by supplying beneficial substances they can detoxify harmful

substances they can detoxify harmful

substances they can detoxify harmful substances in the diet and they are also

substances in the diet and they are also

substances in the diet and they are also known to be involved in modulating host

known to be involved in modulating host

known to be involved in modulating host development immune system and even

development immune system and even

development immune system and even behavior so microorganisms are taking

behavior so microorganisms are taking

behavior so microorganisms are taking huge tasks and so it’s not that

huge tasks and so it’s not that

huge tasks and so it’s not that surprising that they can actually act as

surprising that they can actually act as

surprising that they can actually act as drivers of animal evolution and to give

drivers of animal evolution and to give

drivers of animal evolution and to give some examples the microorganisms in the

some examples the microorganisms in the

some examples the microorganisms in the intestines of herbivores are responsible

intestines of herbivores are responsible

intestines of herbivores are responsible that the host can get enough nutrients

that the host can get enough nutrients

that the host can get enough nutrients from the cellulose rich plant diet like

from the cellulose rich plant diet like

from the cellulose rich plant diet like the Koala has a 2 meter long cecum which

the Koala has a 2 meter long cecum which

the Koala has a 2 meter long cecum which is densely colonized by microbes which

is densely colonized by microbes which

is densely colonized by microbes which help to digest the eucalyptus leaves

help to digest the eucalyptus leaves

help to digest the eucalyptus leaves bioluminescent bacteria are helping to

bioluminescent bacteria are helping to

bioluminescent bacteria are helping to modulate the light organs of some squids

modulate the light organs of some squids

modulate the light organs of some squids they will also colonize this emitting a

they will also colonize this emitting a

they will also colonize this emitting a constant light and the squid will

constant light and the squid will

constant light and the squid will provide nutrients to these bacteria and

provide nutrients to these bacteria and

provide nutrients to these bacteria and is also able to manipulate the light

is also able to manipulate the light

is also able to manipulate the light intensity based on the actual moon and

intensity based on the actual moon and

intensity based on the actual moon and star light which will erase its shadow

star light which will erase its shadow

star light which will erase its shadow in the water making it invisible for

in the water making it invisible for

in the water making it invisible for bottom-dwelling predators and I think

bottom-dwelling predators and I think

bottom-dwelling predators and I think many of us like coffee

so the plant is not producing caffeine

so the plant is not producing caffeine to give us a better starter to the

to give us a better starter to the

to give us a better starter to the morning it’s doing that to protect

morning it’s doing that to protect

morning it’s doing that to protect itself from getting eaten

itself from getting eaten

itself from getting eaten and indeed high doses of caffeine is

and indeed high doses of caffeine is

and indeed high doses of caffeine is deadly for most insects like they just

deadly for most insects like they just

deadly for most insects like they just get immediately paralyzed and die and

get immediately paralyzed and die and

get immediately paralyzed and die and really almost all of them one exceptions

really almost all of them one exceptions

really almost all of them one exceptions this is a little beetle this is the

this is a little beetle this is the

this is a little beetle this is the coffee borer and it will develop in the

coffee borer and it will develop in the

coffee borer and it will develop in the coffee berry it’s basically based in

coffee berry it’s basically based in

coffee berry it’s basically based in caffeine but it’s not the beetle itself

caffeine but it’s not the beetle itself

caffeine but it’s not the beetle itself that evolved resistance against the

that evolved resistance against the

that evolved resistance against the substance when you remove the internal

substance when you remove the internal

substance when you remove the internal bacteria then the beetle will react like

bacteria then the beetle will react like

bacteria then the beetle will react like all the other insects it will die when

all the other insects it will die when

all the other insects it will die when it consumes caffeine so the internal

it consumes caffeine so the internal

it consumes caffeine so the internal bacteria are responsible for detoxifying

bacteria are responsible for detoxifying

bacteria are responsible for detoxifying the caffeine for the beetle opening a

the caffeine for the beetle opening a

the caffeine for the beetle opening a new niche and environment for it so

new niche and environment for it so

new niche and environment for it so there are many more awesome examples

there are many more awesome examples

there are many more awesome examples around but we might see that microbes

around but we might see that microbes

around but we might see that microbes actually have a huge influence on animal

actually have a huge influence on animal

actually have a huge influence on animal ecology and evolution so might be

ecology and evolution so might be

ecology and evolution so might be surprising that host microbiota research

surprising that host microbiota research

surprising that host microbiota research is still hampered and one simple reason

is still hampered and one simple reason

is still hampered and one simple reason is the number of species involved in

is the number of species involved in

is the number of species involved in most systems like in the human gut we

most systems like in the human gut we

most systems like in the human gut we have at least 160 main bacterial species

have at least 160 main bacterial species

have at least 160 main bacterial species and we are talking about a microbial

and we are talking about a microbial

and we are talking about a microbial community all of these species can have

community all of these species can have

community all of these species can have an effect on the host but they will also

an effect on the host but they will also

an effect on the host but they will also interact with each other and the outcome

interact with each other and the outcome

interact with each other and the outcome of these interactions again can have a

of these interactions again can have a

of these interactions again can have a complete different effect to make the

complete different effect to make the

complete different effect to make the whole system more complicated we know

whole system more complicated we know

whole system more complicated we know that hosts that the host genotype can

that hosts that the host genotype can

that hosts that the host genotype can influence the microbial community

influence the microbial community

influence the microbial community composition and on top of that we have

composition and on top of that we have

composition and on top of that we have environmental factors like for example

environmental factors like for example

environmental factors like for example coming from the host diet to put it in

coming from the host diet to put it in

coming from the host diet to put it in simple words most host microbiota

simple words most host microbiota

simple words most host microbiota systems are simply too complex and not

systems are simply too complex and not

systems are simply too complex and not experimental attractable and this is

experimental attractable and this is

experimental attractable and this is what we need to understand the phenomena

what we need to understand the phenomena

what we need to understand the phenomena it is basically like studying a tornado

it is basically like studying a tornado

it is basically like studying a tornado while you are standing in the middle of

while you are standing in the middle of

while you are standing in the middle of it so this is the reason why we are why

it so this is the reason why we are why

it so this is the reason why we are why we really need simple systems that we

we really need simple systems that we

we really need simple systems that we can fully understand to be able to apply

can fully understand to be able to apply

can fully understand to be able to apply this knowledge to the more complex

this knowledge to the more complex

this knowledge to the more complex systems this is the time point where I

systems this is the time point where I

systems this is the time point where I would like to introduce the honeybee

would like to introduce the honeybee

would like to introduce the honeybee being a really good model

being a really good model

being a really good model for host microbiota questions honeybees

for host microbiota questions honeybees

for host microbiota questions honeybees are naturally associated with a small

are naturally associated with a small

are naturally associated with a small stable and long wave of microbiota

stable and long wave of microbiota

stable and long wave of microbiota consisting of about nine core bacterial

consisting of about nine core bacterial

consisting of about nine core bacterial species which are all accountable the

species which are all accountable the

species which are all accountable the microbiota gets horizontally transmitted

microbiota gets horizontally transmitted

microbiota gets horizontally transmitted from older to younger bees which is

from older to younger bees which is

from older to younger bees which is actually similar compared to how the

actually similar compared to how the

actually similar compared to how the human microbiota gets transmitted and

human microbiota gets transmitted and

human microbiota gets transmitted and the whole system is experimentally

the whole system is experimentally

the whole system is experimentally tractable but there’s also another

tractable but there’s also another

tractable but there’s also another reason why it’s really important to

reason why it’s really important to

reason why it’s really important to better understand the system and that

better understand the system and that

better understand the system and that bees are having a very important job on

bees are having a very important job on

bees are having a very important job on earth they are all main pollinating

earth they are all main pollinating

earth they are all main pollinating species and at least one-third of our

species and at least one-third of our

species and at least one-third of our daily diet depends on pollination so

daily diet depends on pollination so

daily diet depends on pollination so without natural pollinators we get

without natural pollinators we get

without natural pollinators we get significantly restricted and these

significantly restricted and these

significantly restricted and these people are not having fun climbing

people are not having fun climbing

people are not having fun climbing around in the trees they are doing the

around in the trees they are doing the

around in the trees they are doing the job of bees they actually pollinate

job of bees they actually pollinate

job of bees they actually pollinate flowers by hand because it is already

flowers by hand because it is already

flowers by hand because it is already reality in the world that we have areas

reality in the world that we have areas

reality in the world that we have areas without natural pollinators around the

without natural pollinators around the

without natural pollinators around the reason for this worldwide decline is a

reason for this worldwide decline is a

reason for this worldwide decline is a combination of different stress factors

combination of different stress factors

combination of different stress factors like poor nutrition due to agricultural

like poor nutrition due to agricultural

like poor nutrition due to agricultural monocultures or the toxins that we apply

monocultures or the toxins that we apply

monocultures or the toxins that we apply to our natural environment but honey

to our natural environment but honey

to our natural environment but honey bees are also naturally challenged with

bees are also naturally challenged with

bees are also naturally challenged with the diversity of pathogenic bacteria

the diversity of pathogenic bacteria

the diversity of pathogenic bacteria fungi viruses and parasites making their

fungi viruses and parasites making their

fungi viruses and parasites making their lives pretty miserable and all of these

lives pretty miserable and all of these

lives pretty miserable and all of these stress factors could be already shown to

stress factors could be already shown to

stress factors could be already shown to negatively influence honeybee health a

negatively influence honeybee health a

negatively influence honeybee health a healthy intake microbiota on the other

healthy intake microbiota on the other

healthy intake microbiota on the other hand is positive for the be potentially

hand is positive for the be potentially

hand is positive for the be potentially being able to buffer some of the

being able to buffer some of the

being able to buffer some of the negative effects coming from the stress

negative effects coming from the stress

negative effects coming from the stress factors but interestingly it just turned

factors but interestingly it just turned

factors but interestingly it just turned out recently that these stress vectors

out recently that these stress vectors

out recently that these stress vectors will also negatively influence the

will also negatively influence the

will also negatively influence the microbiota leading to for example

microbiota leading to for example

microbiota leading to for example dysbiosis and this can be the beginning

dysbiosis and this can be the beginning

dysbiosis and this can be the beginning of a vicious cycle for the be leading to

of a vicious cycle for the be leading to

of a vicious cycle for the be leading to sick and dying populations so an insect

sick and dying populations so an insect

sick and dying populations so an insect microbiota is crucial for honeybee

microbiota is crucial for honeybee

microbiota is crucial for honeybee health and we need to better understand

health and we need to better understand

health and we need to better understand all factors and the interconnections one

all factors and the interconnections one

all factors and the interconnections one smart thing to do is in general to take

smart thing to do is in general to take

smart thing to do is in general to take a look at her nature

a look at her nature

a look at her nature and when we do that we will realize that

and when we do that we will realize that

and when we do that we will realize that not all honeybees species or subspecies

not all honeybees species or subspecies

not all honeybees species or subspecies are suffering equally from the same

are suffering equally from the same

are suffering equally from the same stresses the African Bee has been

stresses the African Bee has been

stresses the African Bee has been introduced to Brazil in 1956 and has

introduced to Brazil in 1956 and has

introduced to Brazil in 1956 and has colonized almost all of the Western

colonized almost all of the Western

colonized almost all of the Western Hemisphere which is one of the most

Hemisphere which is one of the most

Hemisphere which is one of the most rapid biological invasions known it has

rapid biological invasions known it has

rapid biological invasions known it has met the white European bees and they

met the white European bees and they

met the white European bees and they made it and they formed hybrids the

made it and they formed hybrids the

made it and they formed hybrids the Africanized bees there we go and these

Africanized bees there we go and these

Africanized bees there we go and these hybrids are actually the ones that

hybrids are actually the ones that

hybrids are actually the ones that spread so rapidly

spread so rapidly

spread so rapidly so indicating that they have a higher

so indicating that they have a higher

so indicating that they have a higher fitness under the same natural

fitness under the same natural

fitness under the same natural circumstances we know that the genotype

circumstances we know that the genotype

circumstances we know that the genotype can influence the microbiota composition

can influence the microbiota composition

can influence the microbiota composition if we now consider that the microbiota

if we now consider that the microbiota

if we now consider that the microbiota has an impact on hosts fitness this can

has an impact on hosts fitness this can

has an impact on hosts fitness this can lead to a difference in fitness and

lead to a difference in fitness and

lead to a difference in fitness and different changing challenging or new

different changing challenging or new

different changing challenging or new environments we have three factors here

environments we have three factors here

environments we have three factors here we have host genotype we have microbiota

we have host genotype we have microbiota

we have host genotype we have microbiota we have environment and we can sequence

we have environment and we can sequence

we have environment and we can sequence that we can check for microbiota

that we can check for microbiota

that we can check for microbiota differences between the genotypes but

differences between the genotypes but

differences between the genotypes but this will not give us any answer about

this will not give us any answer about

this will not give us any answer about functional relationships so what we need

functional relationships so what we need

functional relationships so what we need are controlled experiments first thing

are controlled experiments first thing

are controlled experiments first thing we need to get rid of the environmental

we need to get rid of the environmental

we need to get rid of the environmental factors because this is far too much to

factors because this is far too much to

factors because this is far too much to control for so we can do something like

control for so we can do something like

control for so we can do something like Richelieu proko microbiota transfer

Richelieu proko microbiota transfer

Richelieu proko microbiota transfer experiments in the lab we can challenge

experiments in the lab we can challenge

experiments in the lab we can challenge the bees against stress factors and now

the bees against stress factors and now

the bees against stress factors and now we can disentangle if host genotype or

we can disentangle if host genotype or

we can disentangle if host genotype or the microbiota is more important in

the microbiota is more important in

the microbiota is more important in terms of stress resistance we can break

terms of stress resistance we can break

terms of stress resistance we can break the system down we can feed single

the system down we can feed single

the system down we can feed single bacterial cells to test the effect we

bacterial cells to test the effect we

bacterial cells to test the effect we can feed two bacteria or we go step by

can feed two bacteria or we go step by

can feed two bacteria or we go step by step more complex 3 4 5 to test which

step more complex 3 4 5 to test which

step more complex 3 4 5 to test which affects the interactions between the

affects the interactions between the

affects the interactions between the bacteria will have from the host and to

bacteria will have from the host and to

bacteria will have from the host and to put everything together honeybee

put everything together honeybee

put everything together honeybee colonies are worldwide in danger and the

colonies are worldwide in danger and the

colonies are worldwide in danger and the reason are different stress factors like

reason are different stress factors like

reason are different stress factors like poor nutrition and toxins and this can

poor nutrition and toxins and this can

poor nutrition and toxins and this can negatively influence the microbiota

negatively influence the microbiota

negatively influence the microbiota leading to example for low to a lowering

leading to example for low to a lowering

leading to example for low to a lowering of the diversity but that’s not

of the diversity but that’s not

of the diversity but that’s not everything there’s more stress around so

everything there’s more stress around so

everything there’s more stress around so we have pathogens we have parasites it

we have pathogens we have parasites it

we have pathogens we have parasites it with a negative influence on the bee and

with a negative influence on the bee and

with a negative influence on the bee and what a beekeeper will do now to save the

what a beekeeper will do now to save the

what a beekeeper will do now to save the colony he will he or she will provide

colony he will he or she will provide

colony he will he or she will provide antibiotics or apply toxins to the –

antibiotics or apply toxins to the –

antibiotics or apply toxins to the – vironment and but again this could be

vironment and but again this could be

vironment and but again this could be shown to negatively influence the

shown to negatively influence the

shown to negatively influence the microbiota and of course the whole

microbiota and of course the whole

microbiota and of course the whole system so there’s there are many more

system so there’s there are many more

system so there’s there are many more factors involved than just genotype and

factors involved than just genotype and

factors involved than just genotype and microbiota and stress and it also

microbiota and stress and it also

microbiota and stress and it also doesn’t matter which stress factors

doesn’t matter which stress factors

doesn’t matter which stress factors comes first and in which combination but

comes first and in which combination but

comes first and in which combination but at some point it might be too much

at some point it might be too much

at some point it might be too much stress and so one solution could be

stress and so one solution could be

stress and so one solution could be instead of going for this short-term

instead of going for this short-term

instead of going for this short-term solution by providing antibiotics and

solution by providing antibiotics and

solution by providing antibiotics and toxins will be to maintain a healthy and

toxins will be to maintain a healthy and

toxins will be to maintain a healthy and diverse microbiota which is co-evolved

diverse microbiota which is co-evolved

diverse microbiota which is co-evolved with the host and to allow it to fight

with the host and to allow it to fight

with the host and to allow it to fight for its host and we can do something

for its host and we can do something

for its host and we can do something like this by providing beneficial

like this by providing beneficial

like this by providing beneficial microorganisms for example but before we

microorganisms for example but before we

microorganisms for example but before we can do something like this in an

can do something like this in an

can do something like this in an efficient way we must understand

efficient way we must understand

efficient way we must understand everything and so we still need to do

everything and so we still need to do

everything and so we still need to do some more research thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *