Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Fire of Free Speech | Shreya Singhal | TEDxAIIMS


so what is vital so medical students

so what is vital so medical students like yourselves it might be a heartbeat

like yourselves it might be a heartbeat

like yourselves it might be a heartbeat it might be you know a pulse a heartbeat

it might be you know a pulse a heartbeat

it might be you know a pulse a heartbeat a brain wave something like that but

a brain wave something like that but

a brain wave something like that but what if you go one step back what if you

what if you go one step back what if you

what if you go one step back what if you look at society what do you think is

look at society what do you think is

look at society what do you think is vital to society I feel that that’s

vital to society I feel that that’s

vital to society I feel that that’s freedom of speech and expression in

freedom of speech and expression in

freedom of speech and expression in today’s day and age where you have

today’s day and age where you have

today’s day and age where you have higher connectivity where the Internet

higher connectivity where the Internet

higher connectivity where the Internet of Things is bringing us closer and less

of Things is bringing us closer and less

of Things is bringing us closer and less and more connected it’s vital that we

and more connected it’s vital that we

and more connected it’s vital that we are allowed to speak what we want and

are allowed to speak what we want and

are allowed to speak what we want and behave and be given and be given the

behave and be given and be given the

behave and be given and be given the protection to do it freely and without

protection to do it freely and without

protection to do it freely and without fear the right to free speech and

fear the right to free speech and

fear the right to free speech and expression in India is guaranteed under

expression in India is guaranteed under

expression in India is guaranteed under the Constitution it’s a fundamental

the Constitution it’s a fundamental

the Constitution it’s a fundamental right which affords every citizen the

right which affords every citizen the

right which affords every citizen the most important thing that can be there

most important thing that can be there

most important thing that can be there upon infringement you can seek a remedy

upon infringement you can seek a remedy

upon infringement you can seek a remedy and not just go to the police or go to a

and not just go to the police or go to a

and not just go to the police or go to a you know a district court you can go all

you know a district court you can go all

you know a district court you can go all the way right up to the Supreme Court at

the way right up to the Supreme Court at

the way right up to the Supreme Court at the first instance and seek a remedy for

the first instance and seek a remedy for

the first instance and seek a remedy for the violation section article 19 1a of

the violation section article 19 1a of

the violation section article 19 1a of the Constitution says that there shall

the Constitution says that there shall

the Constitution says that there shall be the right every citizen shall have

be the right every citizen shall have

be the right every citizen shall have the right to the freedom of speech and

the right to the freedom of speech and

the right to the freedom of speech and expression it is subjects not an

expression it is subjects not an

expression it is subjects not an absolute right it’s subject to eight

absolute right it’s subject to eight

absolute right it’s subject to eight very specific very narrowly construed by

very specific very narrowly construed by

very specific very narrowly construed by the courts restrictions which are which

the courts restrictions which are which

the courts restrictions which are which have been termed as reasonable

have been termed as reasonable

have been termed as reasonable restrictions this includes the

restrictions this includes the

restrictions this includes the sovereignty and integrity of India

sovereignty and integrity of India

sovereignty and integrity of India defamation incitement to violence

defamation incitement to violence

defamation incitement to violence friendly relations with foreign States

friendly relations with foreign States

friendly relations with foreign States and other things amongst the eight only

and other things amongst the eight only

and other things amongst the eight only eight which the courts have also

eight which the courts have also

eight which the courts have also construed to be very specific all the

construed to be very specific all the

construed to be very specific all the way from 1951 when the Constitution was

way from 1951 when the Constitution was

way from 1951 when the Constitution was brought in till now we have had various

brought in till now we have had various

brought in till now we have had various landmark cases on which have dealt

landmark cases on which have dealt

landmark cases on which have dealt specifically with the right to free

specifically with the right to free

specifically with the right to free speech

speech

speech this includes the right to press the of

this includes the right to press the of

this includes the right to press the of the press to have free speech because

the press to have free speech because

the press to have free speech because that is how traditionally that’s how

that is how traditionally that’s how

that is how traditionally that’s how information got out if it was on the TV

information got out if it was on the TV

information got out if it was on the TV or the newspaper before that or the

or the newspaper before that or the

or the newspaper before that or the radio that’s how you learned something

radio that’s how you learned something

radio that’s how you learned something happened if you didn’t hear it on the

happened if you didn’t hear it on the

happened if you didn’t hear it on the radio I mean our grandparents it

radio I mean our grandparents it

radio I mean our grandparents it probably didn’t happen it was all

probably didn’t happen it was all

probably didn’t happen it was all hearsay it was all gossip by the way so

hearsay it was all gossip by the way so

hearsay it was all gossip by the way so the radio the newspapers the TV the news

the radio the newspapers the TV the news

the radio the newspapers the TV the news these are the sources of information

these are the sources of information

these are the sources of information that we have in our lives today and

that we have in our lives today and

that we have in our lives today and which are evolved and now with the

which are evolved and now with the

which are evolved and now with the evolution of Technology it’s become the

evolution of Technology it’s become the

evolution of Technology it’s become the Internet you don’t even need a laptop

Internet you don’t even need a laptop

Internet you don’t even need a laptop you don’t even need a computer to access

you don’t even need a computer to access

you don’t even need a computer to access the Internet all you need is a

the Internet all you need is a

the Internet all you need is a smartphone so with that kind of

smartphone so with that kind of

smartphone so with that kind of connectivity you know you can everyone

connectivity you know you can everyone

connectivity you know you can everyone has access to it and everyone has then

has access to it and everyone has then

has access to it and everyone has then the ability to just say something and

the ability to just say something and

the ability to just say something and have that make a difference you have

have that make a difference you have

have that make a difference you have change.org which is come about which is

change.org which is come about which is

change.org which is come about which is so vital I mean the traditional forms of

so vital I mean the traditional forms of

so vital I mean the traditional forms of protest have have been you know go to a

protest have have been you know go to a

protest have have been you know go to a congregate at a spot and say we are with

congregate at a spot and say we are with

congregate at a spot and say we are with you we support you now you don’t even

you we support you now you don’t even

you we support you now you don’t even have to do that it’s so much easier for

have to do that it’s so much easier for

have to do that it’s so much easier for people so much more convenient for

people so much more convenient for

people so much more convenient for people to say yes I support you by

people to say yes I support you by

people to say yes I support you by signing up to the table to for

signing up to the table to for

signing up to the table to for repetition online or starting a campaign

repetition online or starting a campaign

repetition online or starting a campaign online where you know you can do it from

online where you know you can do it from

online where you know you can do it from the comes the comfort of your own rooms

the comes the comfort of your own rooms

the comes the comfort of your own rooms or your office or wherever so that’s

or your office or wherever so that’s

or your office or wherever so that’s basically what free speech is to us I

basically what free speech is to us I

basically what free speech is to us I think that you know it’s the right it’s

think that you know it’s the right it’s

think that you know it’s the right it’s it’s not just a right it’s integral it’s

it’s not just a right it’s integral it’s

it’s not just a right it’s integral it’s our thought our opinions that we that we

our thought our opinions that we that we

our thought our opinions that we that we form and it’s our way of expressing it

form and it’s our way of expressing it

form and it’s our way of expressing it and that includes the right to not speak

and that includes the right to not speak

and that includes the right to not speak if you don’t want to speak about

if you don’t want to speak about

if you don’t want to speak about something there’s no compulsion that yes

something there’s no compulsion that yes

something there’s no compulsion that yes you have to have an opinion on something

you have to have an opinion on something

you have to have an opinion on something you don’t and that is where your freedom

you don’t and that is where your freedom

you don’t and that is where your freedom comes into play section 66 a was

comes into play section 66 a was

comes into play section 66 a was introduced in 2008 into the information

introduced in 2008 into the information

introduced in 2008 into the information and Technology Act can you guess how

and Technology Act can you guess how

and Technology Act can you guess how long Parliament spent debating it

long Parliament spent debating it

long Parliament spent debating it six minutes that’s it six minutes and it

six minutes that’s it six minutes and it

six minutes that’s it six minutes and it was law do you know why it came

was law do you know why it came

was law do you know why it came the idea the general idea and this is

the idea the general idea and this is

the idea the general idea and this is way back in say 2007 when they were

way back in say 2007 when they were

way back in say 2007 when they were trying to figure out oh my god what what

trying to figure out oh my god what what

trying to figure out oh my god what what do we do to curb this evil of spamming

do we do to curb this evil of spamming

do we do to curb this evil of spamming spamming that’s the reason why 66a was

spamming that’s the reason why 66a was

spamming that’s the reason why 66a was there was included so it came about

there was included so it came about

there was included so it came about because of spamming I don’t think it’s

because of spamming I don’t think it’s

because of spamming I don’t think it’s ever I don’t think there was a single

ever I don’t think there was a single

ever I don’t think there was a single instance where it was used because oh we

instance where it was used because oh we

instance where it was used because oh we got too many you know emails for wrong

got too many you know emails for wrong

got too many you know emails for wrong viagra so you know um it would all if it

viagra so you know um it would all if it

viagra so you know um it would all if it always been misused and it kind of went

always been misused and it kind of went

always been misused and it kind of went you know disappeared into obscurity in

you know disappeared into obscurity in

you know disappeared into obscurity in 2008 then come in comes 2012 where you

2008 then come in comes 2012 where you

2008 then come in comes 2012 where you know there were a slew of arrests and

know there were a slew of arrests and

know there were a slew of arrests and these are this the ones that the media

these are this the ones that the media

these are this the ones that the media picked up mind you there was the two

picked up mind you there was the two

picked up mind you there was the two girls in Maharashtra in Thani one of

girls in Maharashtra in Thani one of

girls in Maharashtra in Thani one of whom was arrested for liking just liking

whom was arrested for liking just liking

whom was arrested for liking just liking a post that the other one put up another

a post that the other one put up another

a post that the other one put up another was a professor in West Bengal who had

was a professor in West Bengal who had

was a professor in West Bengal who had made a satirical cartoon on month on the

made a satirical cartoon on month on the

made a satirical cartoon on month on the Chief Minister another was a businessman

Chief Minister another was a businessman

Chief Minister another was a businessman in Pondicherry who had said something

in Pondicherry who had said something

in Pondicherry who had said something against a politician’s son

against a politician’s son

against a politician’s son those were the him you know the popular

those were the him you know the popular

those were the him you know the popular ones I’ll say that the media picked up

ones I’ll say that the media picked up

ones I’ll say that the media picked up and that basically filtered their way

and that basically filtered their way

and that basically filtered their way down to me and when I found out when you

down to me and when I found out when you

down to me and when I found out when you know when I I was like why are they

know when I I was like why are they

know when I I was like why are they getting arrested you know someone is

getting arrested you know someone is

getting arrested you know someone is questioning why Bombay’s shut down after

questioning why Bombay’s shut down after

questioning why Bombay’s shut down after a lead a political leaders death and

a lead a political leaders death and

a lead a political leaders death and being arrested for that I think that’s

being arrested for that I think that’s

being arrested for that I think that’s ridiculous because if not then then much

ridiculous because if not then then much

ridiculous because if not then then much before people have been debating this on

before people have been debating this on

before people have been debating this on the news on TV in newspapers in articles

the news on TV in newspapers in articles

the news on TV in newspapers in articles in you know in forum in fault fora like

in you know in forum in fault fora like

in you know in forum in fault fora like this so it’s not that it was something

this so it’s not that it was something

this so it’s not that it was something that was vastly different to what has

that was vastly different to what has

that was vastly different to what has been said in traditional forms of media

been said in traditional forms of media

been said in traditional forms of media the only difference here was that it was

the only difference here was that it was

the only difference here was that it was over the Internet

over the Internet

over the Internet now I come back to 66 866 a basically it

now I come back to 66 866 a basically it

now I come back to 66 866 a basically it deals with the content put up on the

deals with the content put up on the

deals with the content put up on the Internet oh sorry dealt with the content

Internet oh sorry dealt with the content

Internet oh sorry dealt with the content put up on the Internet anything that was

put up on the Internet anything that was

put up on the Internet anything that was put up on the Internet any communication

put up on the Internet any communication

put up on the Internet any communication put up on the Internet via private so

put up on the Internet via private so

put up on the Internet via private so that’s a whatsapp message a private

that’s a whatsapp message a private

that’s a whatsapp message a private email you know a prior Facebook message

email you know a prior Facebook message

email you know a prior Facebook message anything like that all public so that’s

anything like that all public so that’s

anything like that all public so that’s anything you post on the internet so a

anything you post on the internet so a

anything you post on the internet so a blog posts a restaurant review anything

blog posts a restaurant review anything

blog posts a restaurant review anything was subject to this it came under the

was subject to this it came under the

was subject to this it came under the purview of section 66 a the second

purview of section 66 a the second

purview of section 66 a the second ingredient was that if any person so any

ingredient was that if any person so any

ingredient was that if any person so any person apart from the uploader who found

person apart from the uploader who found

person apart from the uploader who found that either annoying of menacing

that either annoying of menacing

that either annoying of menacing character or grossly offensive these are

character or grossly offensive these are

character or grossly offensive these are the three words used to describe the

the three words used to describe the

the three words used to describe the crime annoying grossly offensive and of

crime annoying grossly offensive and of

crime annoying grossly offensive and of menacing character was liable to be

menacing character was liable to be

menacing character was liable to be arrested for up to three years and have

arrested for up to three years and have

arrested for up to three years and have a fine now if you go to a police station

a fine now if you go to a police station

a fine now if you go to a police station and say oh this X Y Zed has posted

and say oh this X Y Zed has posted

and say oh this X Y Zed has posted something on the Internet

something on the Internet

something on the Internet I find it annoying can you define that

I find it annoying can you define that

I find it annoying can you define that can you define what Annoying is or what

can you define what Annoying is or what

can you define what Annoying is or what grossly offensive is all of all what of

grossly offensive is all of all what of

grossly offensive is all of all what of menacing character can be will if I

menacing character can be will if I

menacing character can be will if I define it in a certain way will that

define it in a certain way will that

define it in a certain way will that definition be the same for say you know

definition be the same for say you know

definition be the same for say you know it won’t it’s never going to be the same

it won’t it’s never going to be the same

it won’t it’s never going to be the same it’s so subjective that they can never

it’s so subjective that they can never

it’s so subjective that they can never be a yardstick of concrete yardstick

be a yardstick of concrete yardstick

be a yardstick of concrete yardstick where you say yes this is like you know

where you say yes this is like you know

where you say yes this is like you know like you have first degree murder second

like you have first degree murder second

like you have first degree murder second degree mother murder manslaughter in the

degree mother murder manslaughter in the

degree mother murder manslaughter in the American criminal system there’s got

American criminal system there’s got

American criminal system there’s got very specific definitions for things

very specific definitions for things

very specific definitions for things that carry pinna therefore things that

that carry pinna therefore things that

that carry pinna therefore things that carry penal implications or have a and a

carry penal implications or have a and a

carry penal implications or have a and a prison sentence associated with it you

prison sentence associated with it you

prison sentence associated with it you can’t have ambiguity you

can’t have ambiguity you

can’t have ambiguity you it can’t be vague so all of this

it can’t be vague so all of this

it can’t be vague so all of this combined really got me thinking as the

combined really got me thinking as the

combined really got me thinking as the why and how can this section section 66

why and how can this section section 66

why and how can this section section 66 a how can it survive how can it how can

a how can it survive how can it how can

a how can it survive how can it how can it be there in a democracy like India

it be there in a democracy like India

it be there in a democracy like India where we have so many different kinds of

where we have so many different kinds of

where we have so many different kinds of people so it’s we’re multifaceted multi

people so it’s we’re multifaceted multi

people so it’s we’re multifaceted multi religious multi

religious multi

religious multi act assets of in the Indian society are

act assets of in the Indian society are

act assets of in the Indian society are cherished they are encouraged they are

cherished they are encouraged they are

cherished they are encouraged they are developed so by that entire logic of 66

developed so by that entire logic of 66

developed so by that entire logic of 66 1/2 of you could go and say go to a

1/2 of you could go and say go to a

1/2 of you could go and say go to a police station and say I don’t like what

police station and say I don’t like what

police station and say I don’t like what this half is saying

this half is saying

this half is saying so please arrest them and they would

so please arrest them and they would

so please arrest them and they would have no choice but to by procedure they

have no choice but to by procedure they

have no choice but to by procedure they would have no choice if they would if

would have no choice if they would if

would have no choice if they would if any pressure was applied they would have

any pressure was applied they would have

any pressure was applied they would have no choice but to arrest you and that’s

no choice but to arrest you and that’s

no choice but to arrest you and that’s what was happening and later on I

what was happening and later on I

what was happening and later on I recently only learned that there were

recently only learned that there were

recently only learned that there were over 4000 arrests that happened up until

over 4000 arrests that happened up until

over 4000 arrests that happened up until it was scrapped under Section 66 a so

it was scrapped under Section 66 a so

it was scrapped under Section 66 a so you can imagine it was being put on on

you can imagine it was being put on on

you can imagine it was being put on on any on any put on as an offence on

any on any put on as an offence on

any on any put on as an offence on anything that dealt with the internet so

anything that dealt with the internet so

anything that dealt with the internet so you know that was a one short way of

you know that was a one short way of

you know that was a one short way of being sent to prison so it was all of

being sent to prison so it was all of

being sent to prison so it was all of this that really inspired me to file the

this that really inspired me to file the

this that really inspired me to file the petition I filed a public interest

petition I filed a public interest

petition I filed a public interest litigation in the Supreme Court in 2012

litigation in the Supreme Court in 2012

litigation in the Supreme Court in 2012 and and my basic contention my most

and and my basic contention my most

and and my basic contention my most basic contention there was that section

basic contention there was that section

basic contention there was that section 66 a is a gross violation of our right

66 a is a gross violation of our right

66 a is a gross violation of our right to free speech by preaching it by

to free speech by preaching it by

to free speech by preaching it by pitting the Internet at a different

pitting the Internet at a different

pitting the Internet at a different level to the media for referral forms of

level to the media for referral forms of

level to the media for referral forms of media so things that were said on both

media so things that were said on both

media so things that were said on both platforms mind you and then only

platforms mind you and then only

platforms mind you and then only arresting them on because they said it

arresting them on because they said it

arresting them on because they said it on the Internet that was not okay so and

on the Internet that was not okay so and

on the Internet that was not okay so and what the Supreme Court also held was

what the Supreme Court also held was

what the Supreme Court also held was that section 66 E and this is a British

that section 66 E and this is a British

that section 66 E and this is a British doctrine that they brought in had a

doctrine that they brought in had a

doctrine that they brought in had a chilling effect a chilling effect this

chilling effect a chilling effect this

chilling effect a chilling effect this is the Supreme Court who said that there

is the Supreme Court who said that there

is the Supreme Court who said that there is a chilling effect that section 66 a

is a chilling effect that section 66 a

is a chilling effect that section 66 a has on the freedom of speech and

has on the freedom of speech and

has on the freedom of speech and expression and this they struck it down

expression and this they struck it down

expression and this they struck it down last year in March they struck it down

last year in March they struck it down

last year in March they struck it down they held that it was a violation of

they held that it was a violation of

they held that it was a violation of free speech and expression so all of

free speech and expression so all of

free speech and expression so all of this combined we’ve come to the fact

this combined we’ve come to the fact

this combined we’ve come to the fact that the most important thing in our

that the most important thing in our

that the most important thing in our society well you know we have different

society well you know we have different

society well you know we have different political parties different religions as

political parties different religions as

political parties different religions as I said earlier different thoughts

I said earlier different thoughts

I said earlier different thoughts different associations all of that in a

different associations all of that in a

different associations all of that in a society like ours we can

society like ours we can

society like ours we can if you have something to say if you have

if you have something to say if you have

if you have something to say if you have a different view that is something that

a different view that is something that

a different view that is something that has to be cherished the right to free

has to be cherished the right to free

has to be cherished the right to free speech includes the right to dissent to

speech includes the right to dissent to

speech includes the right to dissent to be different to say something that is in

be different to say something that is in

be different to say something that is in a minority your thought might be in a

a minority your thought might be in a

a minority your thought might be in a minority but if you feel you’re right

minority but if you feel you’re right

minority but if you feel you’re right and if you feel that that this scent is

and if you feel that that this scent is

and if you feel that that this scent is right then you have to do something

right then you have to do something

right then you have to do something about it you can’t keep quiet and that

about it you can’t keep quiet and that

about it you can’t keep quiet and that needs to be protected when the status

needs to be protected when the status

needs to be protected when the status quo is maintained there’s never going to

quo is maintained there’s never going to

quo is maintained there’s never going to be a problem it’s when the minority says

be a problem it’s when the minority says

be a problem it’s when the minority says there’s something wrong happening and I

there’s something wrong happening and I

there’s something wrong happening and I think you should do something about it

think you should do something about it

think you should do something about it and there is something wrong happening

and there is something wrong happening

and there is something wrong happening that you need to protect you can’t just

that you need to protect you can’t just

that you need to protect you can’t just go with the flow on the with the biggest

go with the flow on the with the biggest

go with the flow on the with the biggest you must the biggest image things you

you must the biggest image things you

you must the biggest image things you need to you know as a society we need to

need to you know as a society we need to

need to you know as a society we need to evolve in a way where we don’t need a

evolve in a way where we don’t need a

evolve in a way where we don’t need a all pervasive police system which is

all pervasive police system which is

all pervasive police system which is which one’s spy or invade our privacy

which one’s spy or invade our privacy

which one’s spy or invade our privacy this is the way well if you if the

this is the way well if you if the

this is the way well if you if the dissent if the critique if that

dissent if the critique if that

dissent if the critique if that criticism is something that you feel is

criticism is something that you feel is

criticism is something that you feel is is you know it going giving you going in

is you know it going giving you going in

is you know it going giving you going in the right direction you’re going against

the right direction you’re going against

the right direction you’re going against yeah you may be going against the flow

yeah you may be going against the flow

yeah you may be going against the flow you may be going against the majority

you may be going against the majority

you may be going against the majority but it’s for the greater good

but it’s for the greater good

but it’s for the greater good then say it express it and it’s it you

then say it express it and it’s it you

then say it express it and it’s it you shouldn’t keep quiet because out of fear

shouldn’t keep quiet because out of fear

shouldn’t keep quiet because out of fear of punishment or you know oh my god how

of punishment or you know oh my god how

of punishment or you know oh my god how can you say something like that that’s

can you say something like that that’s

can you say something like that that’s how everything starts that’s how you

how everything starts that’s how you

how everything starts that’s how you start a movement a movement it’s a

start a movement a movement it’s a

start a movement a movement it’s a thought that thought you have to you

thought that thought you have to you

thought that thought you have to you need to express it and with that

need to express it and with that

need to express it and with that expression you will be able to achieve

expression you will be able to achieve

expression you will be able to achieve so much more and it’s and it’s you just

so much more and it’s and it’s you just

so much more and it’s and it’s you just have to be different be different think

have to be different be different think

have to be different be different think differently and act on it

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *