Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Earth Has Been Trying to Tell Us; How Are We Listening? | Peter Fox | TEDxSchenectady


I’m going to start off by acknowledging

I’m going to start off by acknowledging my colleagues Karen Rogers and Bruce

my colleagues Karen Rogers and Bruce

my colleagues Karen Rogers and Bruce Watson in particular Karen and I gave a

Watson in particular Karen and I gave a

Watson in particular Karen and I gave a red talk which is a Rensselaer version

red talk which is a Rensselaer version

red talk which is a Rensselaer version of a TED talk last Friday at our capital

of a TED talk last Friday at our capital

of a TED talk last Friday at our capital campaign kickoff and Homecoming weekend

campaign kickoff and Homecoming weekend

campaign kickoff and Homecoming weekend and I decided to present a variant on

and I decided to present a variant on

and I decided to present a variant on that talk so that you get an idea of

that talk so that you get an idea of

that talk so that you get an idea of what we’re doing at Rensselaer and

what we’re doing at Rensselaer and

what we’re doing at Rensselaer and before we do that I’m gonna keep you in

before we do that I’m gonna keep you in

before we do that I’m gonna keep you in your seat by asking you to buckle your

your seat by asking you to buckle your

your seat by asking you to buckle your seatbelt so now you don’t have any real

seatbelt so now you don’t have any real

seatbelt so now you don’t have any real seatbelts but the reason I’m asking you

seatbelts but the reason I’m asking you

seatbelts but the reason I’m asking you to do this is I’m going to take you

to do this is I’m going to take you

to do this is I’m going to take you through 27 orders of magnitude in scale

through 27 orders of magnitude in scale

through 27 orders of magnitude in scale and 4.5 billion years in 18 minutes

and 4.5 billion years in 18 minutes

and 4.5 billion years in 18 minutes so just so get ready so here’s the Milky

so just so get ready so here’s the Milky

so just so get ready so here’s the Milky Way it’s a spiral galaxy our earth or at

Way it’s a spiral galaxy our earth or at

Way it’s a spiral galaxy our earth or at least may be an early version of our

least may be an early version of our

least may be an early version of our earth is is located in in the corner of

earth is is located in in the corner of

earth is is located in in the corner of one of those spiral arms this image

one of those spiral arms this image

one of those spiral arms this image we’re going to come back to in a minute

we’re going to come back to in a minute

we’re going to come back to in a minute it’s very very early Earth so it’s not a

it’s very very early Earth so it’s not a

it’s very very early Earth so it’s not a real picture it’s an artist’s rendition

real picture it’s an artist’s rendition

real picture it’s an artist’s rendition in those early systems especially in the

in those early systems especially in the

in those early systems especially in the oceans on early Earth

oceans on early Earth

oceans on early Earth there were hydrothermal systems which

there were hydrothermal systems which

there were hydrothermal systems which had abundance we discovered had

had abundance we discovered had

had abundance we discovered had abundance of life but when did that life

abundance of life but when did that life

abundance of life but when did that life actually really begin begin to occur and

actually really begin begin to occur and

actually really begin begin to occur and what happened to it afterwards and then

what happened to it afterwards and then

what happened to it afterwards and then down at the very microscopic scale this

down at the very microscopic scale this

down at the very microscopic scale this is a community of microorganisms

is a community of microorganisms

is a community of microorganisms coexisting together and this is at the

coexisting together and this is at the

coexisting together and this is at the scale of 10 to the minus 6 so in here we

scale of 10 to the minus 6 so in here we

scale of 10 to the minus 6 so in here we have 27 orders of magnitude and the way

have 27 orders of magnitude and the way

have 27 orders of magnitude and the way in which we listen to the earth and the

in which we listen to the earth and the

in which we listen to the earth and the way in which we understand what it’s

way in which we understand what it’s

way in which we understand what it’s trying to tell us is to move across each

trying to tell us is to move across each

trying to tell us is to move across each of these scales and we do that in

of these scales and we do that in

of these scales and we do that in laboratory settings experimental

laboratory settings experimental

laboratory settings experimental settings as well as computational

settings as well as computational

settings as well as computational settings as a result of looking across

settings as a result of looking across

settings as a result of looking across the entire age of the planet 4.5 5

the entire age of the planet 4.5 5

the entire age of the planet 4.5 5 billion years from the very early Earth

billion years from the very early Earth

billion years from the very early Earth to the current day where we can go and

to the current day where we can go and

to the current day where we can go and study microbial systems using gene

study microbial systems using gene

study microbial systems using gene sequencing and

sequencing and

sequencing and and all of the omics techniques that are

and all of the omics techniques that are

and all of the omics techniques that are available to us the volume of data is

available to us the volume of data is

available to us the volume of data is substantially increased but our

substantially increased but our

substantially increased but our challenge is to not just work with

challenge is to not just work with

challenge is to not just work with today’s data today’s earth but to find

today’s data today’s earth but to find

today’s data today’s earth but to find out things about the planet that have

out things about the planet that have

out things about the planet that have could long long ago so here’s the early

could long long ago so here’s the early

could long long ago so here’s the early Earth artist’s rendition what did it

Earth artist’s rendition what did it

Earth artist’s rendition what did it really look like well you know if you

really look like well you know if you

really look like well you know if you don’t you can’t go back and visit it you

don’t you can’t go back and visit it you

don’t you can’t go back and visit it you have to resort to other means and one of

have to resort to other means and one of

have to resort to other means and one of the very earliest means of asking the

the very earliest means of asking the

the very earliest means of asking the planet what was doing was go into a

planet what was doing was go into a

planet what was doing was go into a laboratory and sort of guess at what the

laboratory and sort of guess at what the

laboratory and sort of guess at what the composition of the early Earth say exact

composition of the early Earth say exact

composition of the early Earth say exact at Mysterio marine systems was composed

at Mysterio marine systems was composed

at Mysterio marine systems was composed of this is a very famous picture it’s

of this is a very famous picture it’s

of this is a very famous picture it’s probably in your biology textbook still

probably in your biology textbook still

probably in your biology textbook still and secure experiment conducted by

and secure experiment conducted by

and secure experiment conducted by Miller and Urey at the Scripps

Miller and Urey at the Scripps

Miller and Urey at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and what

Institution of Oceanography and what

Institution of Oceanography and what they did if you’ve never heard of this

they did if you’ve never heard of this

they did if you’ve never heard of this is they put ammonia and methane in in

is they put ammonia and methane in in

is they put ammonia and methane in in this particular receptacle and zapped it

this particular receptacle and zapped it

this particular receptacle and zapped it with static discharge so anyone know

with static discharge so anyone know

with static discharge so anyone know what they produced they produced amino

what they produced they produced amino

what they produced they produced amino acids amino acids are the fundamental

acids amino acids are the fundamental

acids amino acids are the fundamental building blocks of proteins proteins

building blocks of proteins proteins

building blocks of proteins proteins fundamentally related to the to the

fundamentally related to the to the

fundamentally related to the to the formation of life and so for 60 years

formation of life and so for 60 years

formation of life and so for 60 years almost

almost

almost after that experiment which was in the

after that experiment which was in the

after that experiment which was in the 50s we thought that the early earth

50s we thought that the early earth

50s we thought that the early earth atmosphere was about the same pressure

atmosphere was about the same pressure

atmosphere was about the same pressure as it is today about the same density

as it is today about the same density

as it is today about the same density but was composed comprised of primarily

but was composed comprised of primarily

but was composed comprised of primarily methane and ammonia well that’s wrong

methane and ammonia well that’s wrong

methane and ammonia well that’s wrong that’s completely wrong so far wrong and

that’s completely wrong so far wrong and

that’s completely wrong so far wrong and it’s partly wrong because we went in and

it’s partly wrong because we went in and

it’s partly wrong because we went in and we guessed and what we’ve been doing in

we guessed and what we’ve been doing in

we guessed and what we’ve been doing in the last 15 20 years we’ve stopped

the last 15 20 years we’ve stopped

the last 15 20 years we’ve stopped guessing and we started going out back

guessing and we started going out back

guessing and we started going out back to other parts of the earth and asked

to other parts of the earth and asked

to other parts of the earth and asked the earth by different means minerals

the earth by different means minerals

the earth by different means minerals fossils and proteins what were you doing

fossils and proteins what were you doing

fossils and proteins what were you doing at that time

at that time

at that time now 4.5 billion years ago what was

now 4.5 billion years ago what was

now 4.5 billion years ago what was happening well it turns out that there’s

happening well it turns out that there’s

happening well it turns out that there’s in in Australia at the jack at Jack

in in Australia at the jack at Jack

in in Australia at the jack at Jack River there are rocks that are three to

River there are rocks that are three to

River there are rocks that are three to three-and-a-half

three-and-a-half

three-and-a-half years old and we go and collect them and

years old and we go and collect them and

years old and we go and collect them and in those three and a half billion year

in those three and a half billion year

in those three and a half billion year old rocks there are these minerals you

old rocks there are these minerals you

old rocks there are these minerals you if you polish them you call them

if you polish them you call them

if you polish them you call them gemstones scientists call them minerals

gemstones scientists call them minerals

gemstones scientists call them minerals those are 4.4 billion years old and they

those are 4.4 billion years old and they

those are 4.4 billion years old and they still exist and we’ve had to find them

still exist and we’ve had to find them

still exist and we’ve had to find them and my colleague Bruce Watson here has

and my colleague Bruce Watson here has

and my colleague Bruce Watson here has been painstakingly examining these

been painstakingly examining these

been painstakingly examining these zircons using relationships known

zircons using relationships known

zircons using relationships known relationships between the element

relationships between the element

relationships between the element titanium which is part of the zircon and

titanium which is part of the zircon and

titanium which is part of the zircon and the temperature at the time and through

the temperature at the time and through

the temperature at the time and through various analytic techniques we found out

various analytic techniques we found out

various analytic techniques we found out that there was water on the earth from

that there was water on the earth from

that there was water on the earth from the very earliest days back 4.4 billion

the very earliest days back 4.4 billion

the very earliest days back 4.4 billion years ago the oceans are about 70

years ago the oceans are about 70

years ago the oceans are about 70 degrees C and the atmosphere was

degrees C and the atmosphere was

degrees C and the atmosphere was actually comprised of carbon dioxide and

actually comprised of carbon dioxide and

actually comprised of carbon dioxide and molecular nitrogen not methane not

molecular nitrogen not methane not

molecular nitrogen not methane not ammonia and we even think there was

ammonia and we even think there was

ammonia and we even think there was probably some reasonable amount of water

probably some reasonable amount of water

probably some reasonable amount of water there so we just have fundamentally

there so we just have fundamentally

there so we just have fundamentally changed by going and picking up these

changed by going and picking up these

changed by going and picking up these rocks and bringing them back to the

rocks and bringing them back to the

rocks and bringing them back to the laboratory and using very sophisticated

laboratory and using very sophisticated

laboratory and using very sophisticated techniques to analyze them so that’s

techniques to analyze them so that’s

techniques to analyze them so that’s good that’s early Earth we have the

good that’s early Earth we have the

good that’s early Earth we have the zircons but the earth does evolve

zircons but the earth does evolve

zircons but the earth does evolve through time and the earth has gone

through time and the earth has gone

through time and the earth has gone through a series of movements in the

through a series of movements in the

through a series of movements in the thinness at the system level the

thinness at the system level the

thinness at the system level the continents have moved oceans have opened

continents have moved oceans have opened

continents have moved oceans have opened and closed and as a result of that

and closed and as a result of that

and closed and as a result of that things that we go and pick up today in

things that we go and pick up today in

things that we go and pick up today in current earth environments are not where

current earth environments are not where

current earth environments are not where they were billions of years ago millions

they were billions of years ago millions

they were billions of years ago millions of years ago so we have to use even more

of years ago so we have to use even more

of years ago so we have to use even more sophisticated techniques so here’s this

sophisticated techniques so here’s this

sophisticated techniques so here’s this is so there’s the so-called

is so there’s the so-called

is so there’s the so-called supercontinent cycle some of you may

supercontinent cycle some of you may

supercontinent cycle some of you may have heard of God one a land and rodinia

have heard of God one a land and rodinia

have heard of God one a land and rodinia and those things so we go we’re now

and those things so we go we’re now

and those things so we go we’re now going back across each of those

going back across each of those

going back across each of those supercontinent cycles and and looking at

supercontinent cycles and and looking at

supercontinent cycles and and looking at things like when did the oxygen really

things like when did the oxygen really

things like when did the oxygen really come into the atmosphere at the levels

come into the atmosphere at the levels

come into the atmosphere at the levels it is today and it turns out there’s

it is today and it turns out there’s

it is today and it turns out there’s been two oxidation events we think the

been two oxidation events we think the

been two oxidation events we think the first one is called the great oxidation

first one is called the great oxidation

first one is called the great oxidation event

event

event because it was the first but there’s

because it was the first but there’s

because it was the first but there’s been another one but the gray here

been another one but the gray here

been another one but the gray here represents the tremenda and this is an

represents the tremenda and this is an

represents the tremenda and this is an exponential log scale over here

exponential log scale over here

exponential log scale over here tremendous amount of uncertainty and so

tremendous amount of uncertainty and so

tremendous amount of uncertainty and so our job in listening to the planet is to

our job in listening to the planet is to

our job in listening to the planet is to start to use our knowledge of evidence

start to use our knowledge of evidence

start to use our knowledge of evidence of where the continents were and

of where the continents were and

of where the continents were and composition of the atmosphere changes

composition of the atmosphere changes

composition of the atmosphere changes over time and those those Clues lie in

over time and those those Clues lie in

over time and those those Clues lie in minerals fossils and proteins so one

minerals fossils and proteins so one

minerals fossils and proteins so one thing that we’ve done is we have an

thing that we’ve done is we have an

thing that we’ve done is we have an extensive mineral record thanks to the

extensive mineral record thanks to the

extensive mineral record thanks to the to the fascination that humans have with

to the fascination that humans have with

to the fascination that humans have with collecting minerals have tremendous

collecting minerals have tremendous

collecting minerals have tremendous crowd source databases MnDOT and

crowd source databases MnDOT and

crowd source databases MnDOT and scientific databases and what’s been

scientific databases and what’s been

scientific databases and what’s been very typical is that an individual

very typical is that an individual

very typical is that an individual scientist will go and study a particular

scientist will go and study a particular

scientist will go and study a particular mineral at a particular time in a

mineral at a particular time in a

mineral at a particular time in a particular place the thing that’s

particular place the thing that’s

particular place the thing that’s different now is Big Data

different now is Big Data

different now is Big Data because we can now look at all of the

because we can now look at all of the

because we can now look at all of the data and one thing we found out one of

data and one thing we found out one of

data and one thing we found out one of the advanced and all that that xtext is

the advanced and all that that xtext is

the advanced and all that that xtext is that minerals have a social life and a

that minerals have a social life and a

that minerals have a social life and a social life many of you involved in

social life many of you involved in

social life many of you involved in social networks is best explored through

social networks is best explored through

social networks is best explored through network analyses so there this series of

network analyses so there this series of

network analyses so there this series of images at the top without going into a

images at the top without going into a

images at the top without going into a great deal of detail here at the ages 4

great deal of detail here at the ages 4

great deal of detail here at the ages 4 min 4 billion years 2 billion years 3/4

min 4 billion years 2 billion years 3/4

min 4 billion years 2 billion years 3/4 of billion years up to the current age

of billion years up to the current age

of billion years up to the current age this is the the network of associations

this is the the network of associations

this is the the network of associations of chromium minerals and it evolves over

of chromium minerals and it evolves over

of chromium minerals and it evolves over time and it evolves in very interesting

time and it evolves in very interesting

time and it evolves in very interesting ways in the way in which these networks

ways in the way in which these networks

ways in the way in which these networks are laid out tell us a lot about the

are laid out tell us a lot about the

are laid out tell us a lot about the evolution of those minerals the the

evolution of those minerals the the

evolution of those minerals the the temperature and pressure conditions

temperature and pressure conditions

temperature and pressure conditions under which they were formed as well as

under which they were formed as well as

under which they were formed as well as trace traces of the composition of the

trace traces of the composition of the

trace traces of the composition of the atmosphere another tool that we’re using

atmosphere another tool that we’re using

atmosphere another tool that we’re using is looking at where minerals occur

is looking at where minerals occur

is looking at where minerals occur together that should be

pretty boring right now you don’t see

pretty boring right now you don’t see that

there we go so this is the evolution of

there we go so this is the evolution of minerals occurring together over time

minerals occurring together over time

minerals occurring together over time this is a chord diagram and so I’m gonna

this is a chord diagram and so I’m gonna

this is a chord diagram and so I’m gonna left here the silica silica based

left here the silica silica based

left here the silica silica based minerals your guide and you’ll see the

minerals your guide and you’ll see the

minerals your guide and you’ll see the complexity of the occurrence of minerals

complexity of the occurrence of minerals

complexity of the occurrence of minerals occur where they occur together also

occur where they occur together also

occur where they occur together also gives us clues as to the so the in a

gives us clues as to the so the in a

gives us clues as to the so the in a comparison between the minerals because

comparison between the minerals because

comparison between the minerals because minerals have different chemical

minerals have different chemical

minerals have different chemical compositions as well as being fairly

compositions as well as being fairly

compositions as well as being fairly cool to to look out we’re in addition

alright in addition we are able to now

alright in addition we are able to now look using visual analytics techniques

look using visual analytics techniques

look using visual analytics techniques at all of the data that we have on

at all of the data that we have on

at all of the data that we have on minerals and I’m not gonna show you all

minerals and I’m not gonna show you all

minerals and I’m not gonna show you all of them but this is for four billion

of them but this is for four billion

of them but this is for four billion years of history here’s the little

years of history here’s the little

years of history here’s the little supercontinent cycle as you can see

supercontinent cycle as you can see

supercontinent cycle as you can see across here and what you’re seeing are

across here and what you’re seeing are

across here and what you’re seeing are the relative occurrences of minerals in

the relative occurrences of minerals in

the relative occurrences of minerals in certain locations for each of the the

certain locations for each of the the

certain locations for each of the the metal elements in the first row of the

metal elements in the first row of the

metal elements in the first row of the periodic table so it’s called the first

periodic table so it’s called the first

periodic table so it’s called the first row transition element so it’s cobalt

row transition element so it’s cobalt

row transition element so it’s cobalt nickel chromium titanium zinc vanadium

nickel chromium titanium zinc vanadium

nickel chromium titanium zinc vanadium manganese copper and iron and and it’s

manganese copper and iron and and it’s

manganese copper and iron and and it’s animated because it’s a little bit hard

animated because it’s a little bit hard

animated because it’s a little bit hard so it’s called a skyline plot and for

so it’s called a skyline plot and for

so it’s called a skyline plot and for the first time mineralogists have been

the first time mineralogists have been

the first time mineralogists have been able to look at all of this data at the

able to look at all of this data at the

able to look at all of this data at the same time and draw correspondences

same time and draw correspondences

same time and draw correspondences between where the supercontinent cycles

between where the supercontinent cycles

between where the supercontinent cycles and the occurrence of minerals coincides

and the occurrence of minerals coincides

and the occurrence of minerals coincides and doesn’t come inside and which

and doesn’t come inside and which

and doesn’t come inside and which minerals show up in certainly

minerals show up in certainly

minerals show up in certainly intercontinental cycles and don’t show

intercontinental cycles and don’t show

intercontinental cycles and don’t show up in others but there’s one really

up in others but there’s one really

up in others but there’s one really important thing that you should know

important thing that you should know

important thing that you should know about this and that is minerals go

about this and that is minerals go

about this and that is minerals go extinct we tend to think of living

extinct we tend to think of living

extinct we tend to think of living things going extinct but minerals go

things going extinct but minerals go

things going extinct but minerals go extinct and that extinction is another

extinct and that extinction is another

extinct and that extinction is another really important thing that tells us

really important thing that tells us

really important thing that tells us what the composition of the earth

what the composition of the earth

what the composition of the earth because they go extinct under certain

because they go extinct under certain

because they go extinct under certain chemical reaction conditions above

chemical reaction conditions above

chemical reaction conditions above certain temperatures and pressures and

certain temperatures and pressures and

certain temperatures and pressures and other environmental conditions

other environmental conditions

other environmental conditions so the next thing that we we started to

so the next thing that we we started to

so the next thing that we we started to do was take our for each of the

do was take our for each of the

do was take our for each of the individual elemental elemental base

individual elemental elemental base

individual elemental elemental base minerals so all minerals are basically

minerals so all minerals are basically

minerals so all minerals are basically categorized by the primary element that

categorized by the primary element that

categorized by the primary element that they are composed of this is the

they are composed of this is the

they are composed of this is the manganese Network of all known minerals

manganese Network of all known minerals

manganese Network of all known minerals and it has an extra set of data in there

and it has an extra set of data in there

and it has an extra set of data in there whether actually has a lot of extra sets

whether actually has a lot of extra sets

whether actually has a lot of extra sets of data and the colors represent

of data and the colors represent

of data and the colors represent particular formation conditions for

particular formation conditions for

particular formation conditions for those minerals and in a minute you will

those minerals and in a minute you will

those minerals and in a minute you will go into it this is called a bipartite

go into it this is called a bipartite

go into it this is called a bipartite Network bipartite network has two types

Network bipartite network has two types

Network bipartite network has two types of nodes one is the mineral and the

of nodes one is the mineral and the

of nodes one is the mineral and the other is its location and so very hard

other is its location and so very hard

other is its location and so very hard to sort of tell what’s going on here but

to sort of tell what’s going on here but

to sort of tell what’s going on here but you’ll see a basic structure you’ll see

you’ll see a basic structure you’ll see

you’ll see a basic structure you’ll see a very condensed area at the lower part

a very condensed area at the lower part

a very condensed area at the lower part of the network and you’ll see this more

of the network and you’ll see this more

of the network and you’ll see this more isolated mostly red cluster up top and

isolated mostly red cluster up top and

isolated mostly red cluster up top and this leads us by looking at all this is

this leads us by looking at all this is

this leads us by looking at all this is all of the data on manganese it’s never

all of the data on manganese it’s never

all of the data on manganese it’s never been looked at before we can now go and

been looked at before we can now go and

been looked at before we can now go and say well what’s that cluster up there

say well what’s that cluster up there

say well what’s that cluster up there and we can go in and explore it when and

and we can go in and explore it when and

and we can go in and explore it when and we can go and do clustering tech

we can go and do clustering tech

we can go and do clustering tech techniques and classification to find

techniques and classification to find

techniques and classification to find other commonalities between the

other commonalities between the

other commonalities between the manganese based crystals the other thing

manganese based crystals the other thing

manganese based crystals the other thing is without going into too much detail

is without going into too much detail

is without going into too much detail the separation between that upper part

the separation between that upper part

the separation between that upper part of the network and the lower part of the

of the network and the lower part of the

of the network and the lower part of the network actually gives us evidence on

network actually gives us evidence on

network actually gives us evidence on extinction the fact that there is such a

extinction the fact that there is such a

extinction the fact that there is such a large distance between those two

large distance between those two

large distance between those two groupings tells us tremendous amount of

groupings tells us tremendous amount of

groupings tells us tremendous amount of information about earth

these were set to autoplay so these are

these were set to autoplay so these are these are some of the tools and

these are some of the tools and

these are some of the tools and techniques that were able to sit

techniques that were able to sit

techniques that were able to sit alongside mineralogists paleo biologists

alongside mineralogists paleo biologists

alongside mineralogists paleo biologists and and biochemists and start to ask

and and biochemists and start to ask

and and biochemists and start to ask questions about these networks and

questions about these networks and

questions about these networks and you’ll see it’s very interactive you can

you’ll see it’s very interactive you can

you’ll see it’s very interactive you can pick out particular minerals and the

pick out particular minerals and the

pick out particular minerals and the gray nodes which here are a little bit

gray nodes which here are a little bit

gray nodes which here are a little bit hard to see our mineral localities

and as soon as you let your mineralogist

and as soon as you let your mineralogist friends take control of the mouse

friends take control of the mouse

friends take control of the mouse there’s suing around zooming in zooming

there’s suing around zooming in zooming

there’s suing around zooming in zooming out it’s very disorienting now because

out it’s very disorienting now because

out it’s very disorienting now because we don’t have a virtual reality

we don’t have a virtual reality

we don’t have a virtual reality projector here this is also available in

projector here this is also available in

projector here this is also available in virtual reality form so you can actually

virtual reality form so you can actually

virtual reality form so you can actually look at it on your VR enabled phone and

look at it on your VR enabled phone and

look at it on your VR enabled phone and that is ridiculously cool here isn’t

that is ridiculously cool here isn’t

that is ridiculously cool here isn’t here’s an example one of my favorite

here’s an example one of my favorite

here’s an example one of my favorite elements I’m studying right now is

elements I’m studying right now is

elements I’m studying right now is carbon this is the carbon bipartite

carbon this is the carbon bipartite

carbon this is the carbon bipartite Network so the black dots are locations

Network so the black dots are locations

Network so the black dots are locations the other colored dots are carbon

the other colored dots are carbon

the other colored dots are carbon minerals the size of the dot is the

minerals the size of the dot is the

minerals the size of the dot is the relative occurrence but there’s things

relative occurrence but there’s things

relative occurrence but there’s things that we can extract out of this

that we can extract out of this

that we can extract out of this particular diagram such as there’s a

particular diagram such as there’s a

particular diagram such as there’s a time axis we think in this network

time axis we think in this network

time axis we think in this network diagram that’s actually showing us the

diagram that’s actually showing us the

diagram that’s actually showing us the fact that there are more of the red

fact that there are more of the red

fact that there are more of the red co-occurring minerals of a very similar

co-occurring minerals of a very similar

co-occurring minerals of a very similar type that have existed for a very long

type that have existed for a very long

type that have existed for a very long time and all the blue new ones around

time and all the blue new ones around

time and all the blue new ones around the end are very very recently formed so

the end are very very recently formed so

the end are very very recently formed so here’s here’s the the VR rendering of

here’s here’s the the VR rendering of

here’s here’s the the VR rendering of the of the carbon network again the gray

the of the carbon network again the gray

the of the carbon network again the gray is the of the localities and we’re just

is the of the localities and we’re just

is the of the localities and we’re just going to go in and take a look at this

don’t have any control here so close

don’t have any control here so close your eyes and imagine the same thing is

your eyes and imagine the same thing is

your eyes and imagine the same thing is that you saw before we go in and we

that you saw before we go in and we

that you saw before we go in and we examine clustering of locations and

examine clustering of locations and

examine clustering of locations and you’ll notice that the larger

you’ll notice that the larger

you’ll notice that the larger significantly a large larger number of

significantly a large larger number of

significantly a large larger number of colors it’s because the the nodes are

colors it’s because the the nodes are

colors it’s because the the nodes are colored using a different a different

colored using a different a different

colored using a different a different piece of data it’s the actual oxidation

piece of data it’s the actual oxidation

piece of data it’s the actual oxidation state the plus one plus plus two so this

state the plus one plus plus two so this

state the plus one plus plus two so this is minerals so we’ve gone in and we’ve

is minerals so we’ve gone in and we’ve

is minerals so we’ve gone in and we’ve started up to all known minerals we’ve

started up to all known minerals we’ve

started up to all known minerals we’ve we’ve found out that as we construct

we’ve found out that as we construct

we’ve found out that as we construct models of what these minerals have been

models of what these minerals have been

models of what these minerals have been doing we’ve predicted that we haven’t

doing we’ve predicted that we haven’t

doing we’ve predicted that we haven’t found around fifteen hundred minerals

found around fifteen hundred minerals

found around fifteen hundred minerals there’s still 1,500 minerals that should

there’s still 1,500 minerals that should

there’s still 1,500 minerals that should exist that haven’t been found and that’s

exist that haven’t been found and that’s

exist that haven’t been found and that’s sort of interesting to ponder so because

sort of interesting to ponder so because

sort of interesting to ponder so because people like minerals they’re off out

people like minerals they’re off out

people like minerals they’re off out searching for them now I’m not going to

searching for them now I’m not going to

searching for them now I’m not going to cover fossils fossils are really cool

cover fossils fossils are really cool

cover fossils fossils are really cool but just to say colleagues that we’re

but just to say colleagues that we’re

but just to say colleagues that we’re working with at Rutgers Jana Bromberg

working with at Rutgers Jana Bromberg

working with at Rutgers Jana Bromberg has been doing the same thing for

has been doing the same thing for

has been doing the same thing for proteins constructing network analysis

proteins constructing network analysis

proteins constructing network analysis diagrams so this is a network of protein

diagrams so this is a network of protein

diagrams so this is a network of protein evolution and the red is the is the iron

evolution and the red is the is the iron

evolution and the red is the is the iron based proteins which we know is one of

based proteins which we know is one of

based proteins which we know is one of the very earliest forming minerals for

the very earliest forming minerals for

the very earliest forming minerals for proteins and them and the much later

proteins and them and the much later

proteins and them and the much later ones a copper so there’s a time axis

ones a copper so there’s a time axis

ones a copper so there’s a time axis going through this particular this

going through this particular this

going through this particular this particular network as well so what do we

particular network as well so what do we

particular network as well so what do we got as we go back in time our coverage

got as we go back in time our coverage

got as we go back in time our coverage on earth is of course limited because

on earth is of course limited because

on earth is of course limited because things have moved so we can only collect

things have moved so we can only collect

things have moved so we can only collect things from where they were today we can

things from where they were today we can

things from where they were today we can trace them in some cases back we can do

trace them in some cases back we can do

trace them in some cases back we can do network analysis over time but let’s

network analysis over time but let’s

network analysis over time but let’s come back a little bit to the

come back a little bit to the

come back a little bit to the microorganisms the the settings that

microorganisms the the settings that

microorganisms the the settings that that we started off with we’re

that we started off with we’re

that we started off with we’re coexisting communities because there are

coexisting communities because there are

coexisting communities because there are opportunities for substantial amounts of

opportunities for substantial amounts of

opportunities for substantial amounts of data analysis in these environments

data analysis in these environments

data analysis in these environments today so let’s take a look at the

today so let’s take a look at the

today so let’s take a look at the microbiome so one of the challenges with

microbiome so one of the challenges with

microbiome so one of the challenges with the with the microbiome and microbiome

the with the microbiome and microbiome

the with the microbiome and microbiome is

is

is Assembly of us of community of

Assembly of us of community of

Assembly of us of community of microorganisms is that the conditions

microorganisms is that the conditions

microorganisms is that the conditions that are representative earlier times on

that are representative earlier times on

that are representative earlier times on earth higher pressures higher

earth higher pressures higher

earth higher pressures higher temperatures different compositions

temperatures different compositions

temperatures different compositions actually those environmental samples do

actually those environmental samples do

actually those environmental samples do exist on the planet

exist on the planet

exist on the planet there’s sites in volcano the sites in

there’s sites in volcano the sites in

there’s sites in volcano the sites in Yellowstone National Park that actually

Yellowstone National Park that actually

Yellowstone National Park that actually have compositional conditions and so

have compositional conditions and so

have compositional conditions and so we’re about to undertake a project with

we’re about to undertake a project with

we’re about to undertake a project with colleagues at RPI that’s going to go out

colleagues at RPI that’s going to go out

colleagues at RPI that’s going to go out and sample all of these and you have

and sample all of these and you have

and sample all of these and you have heads are cut off here but Karen Rogers

heads are cut off here but Karen Rogers

heads are cut off here but Karen Rogers AG and Julius and Cynthia Collins and

AG and Julius and Cynthia Collins and

AG and Julius and Cynthia Collins and what you’re seeing here is an

what you’re seeing here is an

what you’re seeing here is an engineering approach to to examining the

engineering approach to to examining the

engineering approach to to examining the environment and the reason why we need

environment and the reason why we need

environment and the reason why we need to do this is in environmental science

to do this is in environmental science

to do this is in environmental science in Earth history we have a sampling bias

in Earth history we have a sampling bias

in Earth history we have a sampling bias because we can’t go back to all those

because we can’t go back to all those

because we can’t go back to all those places we cannot create all the

places we cannot create all the

places we cannot create all the temperature and pressure and salinity

temperature and pressure and salinity

temperature and pressure and salinity and and and so on conditions but we can

and and and so on conditions but we can

and and and so on conditions but we can do it in the lab but we have to be able

do it in the lab but we have to be able

do it in the lab but we have to be able to transport the samples the actual real

to transport the samples the actual real

to transport the samples the actual real physical samples so at the beginning I

physical samples so at the beginning I

physical samples so at the beginning I showed you Miller you’re a we don’t want

showed you Miller you’re a we don’t want

showed you Miller you’re a we don’t want to guess at what those microorganisms

to guess at what those microorganisms

to guess at what those microorganisms are we don’t want to fake it we’re not

are we don’t want to fake it we’re not

are we don’t want to fake it we’re not trying to build a medicine or something

trying to build a medicine or something

trying to build a medicine or something like that we’re actually looking at

like that we’re actually looking at

like that we’re actually looking at Earth so we go out we collect them and

Earth so we go out we collect them and

Earth so we go out we collect them and we bring them back to the lab and then

we bring them back to the lab and then

we bring them back to the lab and then in in at scale we analyze their

in in at scale we analyze their

in in at scale we analyze their geochemistry the chemistry we do gene

geochemistry the chemistry we do gene

geochemistry the chemistry we do gene sequencing and we expect to find out a

sequencing and we expect to find out a

sequencing and we expect to find out a tremendous amount about what our planet

tremendous amount about what our planet

tremendous amount about what our planet has been telling us so we started with

has been telling us so we started with

has been telling us so we started with this very very sort of coarse view the

this very very sort of coarse view the

this very very sort of coarse view the one where we don’t really know what the

one where we don’t really know what the

one where we don’t really know what the planet looks like over time our

planet looks like over time our

planet looks like over time our knowledge of what the planet has been

knowledge of what the planet has been

knowledge of what the planet has been doing has has become clearer we’ve gone

doing has has become clearer we’ve gone

doing has has become clearer we’ve gone down to smaller scales we’ve gone into

down to smaller scales we’ve gone into

down to smaller scales we’ve gone into into conditions that are of order of the

into conditions that are of order of the

into conditions that are of order of the original conditions on earth and now

original conditions on earth and now

original conditions on earth and now we’re going down to the microbial level

we’re going down to the microbial level

we’re going down to the microbial level and so we have fundamentally changed

and so we have fundamentally changed

and so we have fundamentally changed just in the last 10 years the ways in

just in the last 10 years the ways in

just in the last 10 years the ways in which we’re listening to the planet but

which we’re listening to the planet but

which we’re listening to the planet but yet we still have me

yet we still have me

yet we still have me more questions thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *