Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Case for Cosmic Modesty | Abraham (Avi) Loeb | TEDxHarvardCollege


as students many of you are occupied

as students many of you are occupied with life in the university in this talk

with life in the university in this talk

with life in the university in this talk I would like to venture into life in the

I would like to venture into life in the

I would like to venture into life in the universe we all aspire to make Harvard

universe we all aspire to make Harvard

universe we all aspire to make Harvard the best University on earth

the best University on earth

the best University on earth but is it could it be the best

but is it could it be the best

but is it could it be the best university in the universe this boils

university in the universe this boils

university in the universe this boils down to the fundamental question are we

down to the fundamental question are we

down to the fundamental question are we alone what you see on the screen behind

alone what you see on the screen behind

alone what you see on the screen behind me is not the motto of a dating site it

me is not the motto of a dating site it

me is not the motto of a dating site it is the most fundamental question in

is the most fundamental question in

is the most fundamental question in science are we alone there are many

science are we alone there are many

science are we alone there are many reasons to be modest my mother used to

reasons to be modest my mother used to

reasons to be modest my mother used to tell me when I was a kid but after three

tell me when I was a kid but after three

tell me when I was a kid but after three decades of being a professional

decades of being a professional

decades of being a professional astronomer I can add one additional

astronomer I can add one additional

astronomer I can add one additional reason the richness of the universe

reason the richness of the universe

reason the richness of the universe around us let me explain prior to the

around us let me explain prior to the

around us let me explain prior to the development of modern astronomy we

development of modern astronomy we

development of modern astronomy we tended to think that we are the center

tended to think that we are the center

tended to think that we are the center of the physical universe and that it’s

of the physical universe and that it’s

of the physical universe and that it’s centered on us the Sun and the stars

centered on us the Sun and the stars

centered on us the Sun and the stars were thought to revolve around the earth

were thought to revolve around the earth

were thought to revolve around the earth although naive in retrospect this is a

although naive in retrospect this is a

although naive in retrospect this is a natural starting point when my

natural starting point when my

natural starting point when my daughter’s were infants they tended to

daughter’s were infants they tended to

daughter’s were infants they tended to think that the world centers on them

think that the world centers on them

think that the world centers on them their development portrayed an

their development portrayed an

their development portrayed an accelerated miniature of human history

accelerated miniature of human history

accelerated miniature of human history as they grew up they matured and

as they grew up they matured and

as they grew up they matured and acquired a more balanced perspective

similarly observing the sky makes us

similarly observing the sky makes us aware of the big picture and it teaches

aware of the big picture and it teaches

aware of the big picture and it teaches us modesty we now know that we

us modesty we now know that we

us modesty we now know that we not at the center of the physical

not at the center of the physical

not at the center of the physical universe since the Earth orbits the Sun

universe since the Earth orbits the Sun

universe since the Earth orbits the Sun which itself moves around the center of

which itself moves around the center of

which itself moves around the center of the Milky Way galaxy which drifts in

the Milky Way galaxy which drifts in

the Milky Way galaxy which drifts in some random direction throughout the

some random direction throughout the

some random direction throughout the universe so there is not really a center

universe so there is not really a center

universe so there is not really a center to the universe however many people

to the universe however many people

to the universe however many people still believe that we are at the center

still believe that we are at the center

still believe that we are at the center of the biological universe namely that

of the biological universe namely that

of the biological universe namely that life is rare or unique to earth

life is rare or unique to earth

life is rare or unique to earth in contrast my working hypothesis is

in contrast my working hypothesis is

in contrast my working hypothesis is that we are not special based on the

that we are not special based on the

that we are not special based on the analogy with the physical universe we

analogy with the physical universe we

analogy with the physical universe we are not special in general in terms of

are not special in general in terms of

are not special in general in terms of our physical coordinates and also net

our physical coordinates and also net

our physical coordinates and also net not specialist forms of life and

not specialist forms of life and

not specialist forms of life and adopting this perspective implies that

adopting this perspective implies that

adopting this perspective implies that we are not alone this principle of

we are not alone this principle of

we are not alone this principle of cosmic net modesty implies that there

cosmic net modesty implies that there

cosmic net modesty implies that there should be life out there both primitive

should be life out there both primitive

should be life out there both primitive and intelligent and it has practical

and intelligent and it has practical

and intelligent and it has practical implications if life is out there we

implications if life is out there we

implications if life is out there we should search for it in all of its

should search for it in all of its

should search for it in all of its possible forms we now know thanks to the

possible forms we now know thanks to the

possible forms we now know thanks to the Kepler satellite that about a quarter of

Kepler satellite that about a quarter of

Kepler satellite that about a quarter of all the stars in the Milky Way galaxy

all the stars in the Milky Way galaxy

all the stars in the Milky Way galaxy have planets like the earth at the right

have planets like the earth at the right

have planets like the earth at the right distance from their star to have liquid

distance from their star to have liquid

distance from their star to have liquid water on their surface and there are 300

water on their surface and there are 300

water on their surface and there are 300 billion stars in the Milky Way galaxy

billion stars in the Milky Way galaxy

billion stars in the Milky Way galaxy and three billion similar galaxies in

and three billion similar galaxies in

and three billion similar galaxies in the observable volume of the universe

the observable volume of the universe

the observable volume of the universe so altogether there are 10 to the power

so altogether there are 10 to the power

so altogether there are 10 to the power 20 habitable planets roughly the size of

20 habitable planets roughly the size of

20 habitable planets roughly the size of the earth that could potentially have

the earth that could potentially have

the earth that could potentially have life

life

life is it reasonable to assume that life is

is it reasonable to assume that life is

is it reasonable to assume that life is only realized on our planet our

only realized on our planet our

only realized on our planet our civilization reached the milestone we

civilization reached the milestone we

civilization reached the milestone we now have access to unprecedented

now have access to unprecedented

now have access to unprecedented technologies that allow us to search for

technologies that allow us to search for

technologies that allow us to search for both primitive and intelligent forms of

both primitive and intelligent forms of

both primitive and intelligent forms of life and both of them exist in the one

life and both of them exist in the one

life and both of them exist in the one example where we find it here on earth

example where we find it here on earth

example where we find it here on earth the search for primitive life is

the search for primitive life is

the search for primitive life is underway and well-funded but the search

underway and well-funded but the search

underway and well-funded but the search for intelligent life is out of the

for intelligent life is out of the

for intelligent life is out of the mainstream of federal funding agencies

mainstream of federal funding agencies

mainstream of federal funding agencies this should not be the case given that

this should not be the case given that

this should not be the case given that the only planet where life is found to

the only planet where life is found to

the only planet where life is found to exist has both primitive and intelligent

exist has both primitive and intelligent

exist has both primitive and intelligent forms on it there is no doubt that

forms on it there is no doubt that

forms on it there is no doubt that noticing the big picture taught my young

noticing the big picture taught my young

noticing the big picture taught my young daughters modesty and similarly the

daughters modesty and similarly the

daughters modesty and similarly the Kepler satellite provides astronomers

Kepler satellite provides astronomers

Kepler satellite provides astronomers with a perspective that there are many

with a perspective that there are many

with a perspective that there are many habitable earth mass planets out there

habitable earth mass planets out there

habitable earth mass planets out there there are more such planets in the

there are more such planets in the

there are more such planets in the observable volume of the universe then

observable volume of the universe then

observable volume of the universe then there are grains of sand on all the

there are grains of sand on all the

there are grains of sand on all the beaches on earth and if you think about

beaches on earth and if you think about

beaches on earth and if you think about an emperor or a king in the history of

an emperor or a king in the history of

an emperor or a king in the history of humankind that used to boast about

humankind that used to boast about

humankind that used to boast about conquering a piece of land here on earth

conquering a piece of land here on earth

conquering a piece of land here on earth that person resembles an ant that hugs a

that person resembles an ant that hugs a

that person resembles an ant that hugs a single grain of sand on the landscape of

single grain of sand on the landscape of

single grain of sand on the landscape of a huge beach the chemistry of life as we

a huge beach the chemistry of life as we

a huge beach the chemistry of life as we know it requires liquid water but being

know it requires liquid water but being

know it requires liquid water but being at the right distance from the star is

at the right distance from the star is

at the right distance from the star is not sufficient to maintain life one

not sufficient to maintain life one

not sufficient to maintain life one needs to have an atmosphere because

needs to have an atmosphere because

needs to have an atmosphere because without an atmosphere if you warm up

without an atmosphere if you warm up

without an atmosphere if you warm up water ice it will go directly into a gas

water ice it will go directly into a gas

water ice it will go directly into a gas phase not into a liquid so to have

phase not into a liquid so to have

phase not into a liquid so to have liquid water you

liquid water you

liquid water you really need an external pressure of an

really need an external pressure of an

really need an external pressure of an atmosphere and the warning sign for that

atmosphere and the warning sign for that

atmosphere and the warning sign for that can be found next door Mars it has a

can be found next door Mars it has a

can be found next door Mars it has a tenth of the mass of the earth and has

tenth of the mass of the earth and has

tenth of the mass of the earth and has no atmosphere right now and we don’t see

no atmosphere right now and we don’t see

no atmosphere right now and we don’t see life crawling on its surface but rather

life crawling on its surface but rather

life crawling on its surface but rather than being guided by Fermi’s paradox

than being guided by Fermi’s paradox

than being guided by Fermi’s paradox where is everybody

where is everybody

where is everybody or by philosophical arguments about the

or by philosophical arguments about the

or by philosophical arguments about the rarity of intelligence we should invest

rarity of intelligence we should invest

rarity of intelligence we should invest funds in building better observatories

funds in building better observatories

funds in building better observatories and searching for a wide variety of

and searching for a wide variety of

and searching for a wide variety of artificial signals and these signals

artificial signals and these signals

artificial signals and these signals need not be just communication radio

need not be just communication radio

need not be just communication radio signals they could be artefacts on the

signals they could be artefacts on the

signals they could be artefacts on the surface of a planet our civilization

surface of a planet our civilization

surface of a planet our civilization could produce mostly weak signals for

could produce mostly weak signals for

could produce mostly weak signals for example a nuclear war would not be

example a nuclear war would not be

example a nuclear war would not be visible on the nearest planet to us even

visible on the nearest planet to us even

visible on the nearest planet to us even if we were to use our best telescopes

if we were to use our best telescopes

if we were to use our best telescopes but very advanced civilizations could

but very advanced civilizations could

but very advanced civilizations could potentially be detectable out to the

potentially be detectable out to the

potentially be detectable out to the edge of the observable universe through

edge of the observable universe through

edge of the observable universe through their most powerful beacons the evidence

their most powerful beacons the evidence

their most powerful beacons the evidence for intelligent civilization could be in

for intelligent civilization could be in

for intelligent civilization could be in the form of pollution of the atmosphere

the form of pollution of the atmosphere

the form of pollution of the atmosphere if they are not very intelligent could

if they are not very intelligent could

if they are not very intelligent could be in terms of artifacts on the surface

be in terms of artifacts on the surface

be in terms of artifacts on the surface of the planet and beams sweeping across

of the planet and beams sweeping across

of the planet and beams sweeping across the sky that are used for a variety of

the sky that are used for a variety of

the sky that are used for a variety of purposes such as propulsion of

purposes such as propulsion of

purposes such as propulsion of spacecrafts once formed extreme forms of

spacecrafts once formed extreme forms of

spacecrafts once formed extreme forms of life like tardigrades would survive

life like tardigrades would survive

life like tardigrades would survive Astrophysical catastrophes like

Astrophysical catastrophes like

Astrophysical catastrophes like exploding stars nearby and so forth

exploding stars nearby and so forth

exploding stars nearby and so forth tardigrades these tiny water bears are

tardigrades these tiny water bears are

tardigrades these tiny water bears are known to survive extreme condition the

known to survive extreme condition the

known to survive extreme condition the some of them were put in space and

some of them were put in space and

some of them were put in space and survive the journey for over a week

survive the journey for over a week

survive the journey for over a week under extreme dehydration cosmic rays

under extreme dehydration cosmic rays

under extreme dehydration cosmic rays and so forth so they could in principle

and so forth so they could in principle

and so forth so they could in principle serve as tiny astronauts if they

serve as tiny astronauts if they

serve as tiny astronauts if they happened to lie on the surface of a rock

happened to lie on the surface of a rock

happened to lie on the surface of a rock or deep in the interior of the rock that

or deep in the interior of the rock that

or deep in the interior of the rock that was thrown out of a planet so they can

was thrown out of a planet so they can

was thrown out of a planet so they can transfer life from one planet to another

just over the past year astronomers

just over the past year astronomers discovered a habitable planet around the

discovered a habitable planet around the

discovered a habitable planet around the nearest star Proxima Centauri and also a

nearest star Proxima Centauri and also a

nearest star Proxima Centauri and also a system of seven planets around another

system of seven planets around another

system of seven planets around another star that is 40 light-years away called

star that is 40 light-years away called

star that is 40 light-years away called Trappist one you can see it’s planets

Trappist one you can see it’s planets

Trappist one you can see it’s planets above me three of these planets are just

above me three of these planets are just

above me three of these planets are just in the habitable zone the rocky planets

in the habitable zone the rocky planets

in the habitable zone the rocky planets that could have liquid water on their

that could have liquid water on their

that could have liquid water on their surface we don’t know if they have life

surface we don’t know if they have life

surface we don’t know if they have life on their surface this star is 8% of the

on their surface this star is 8% of the

on their surface this star is 8% of the mass of the Sun and so it’s much fainter

mass of the Sun and so it’s much fainter

mass of the Sun and so it’s much fainter and the habitable zone is 20 times

and the habitable zone is 20 times

and the habitable zone is 20 times closer to the star then the Earth is

closer to the star then the Earth is

closer to the star then the Earth is from the Sun and you can see here the

from the Sun and you can see here the

from the Sun and you can see here the earth and the three habitable planets

earth and the three habitable planets

earth and the three habitable planets around Trappist one now Trappist one is

around Trappist one now Trappist one is

around Trappist one now Trappist one is an example for a dwarf star about a

an example for a dwarf star about a

an example for a dwarf star about a tenth of the mass of the Sun and such

tenth of the mass of the Sun and such

tenth of the mass of the Sun and such stars are the most common in our galaxy

stars are the most common in our galaxy

stars are the most common in our galaxy and they live for a thousand times

and they live for a thousand times

and they live for a thousand times longer than the Sun the Sun is roughly

longer than the Sun the Sun is roughly

longer than the Sun the Sun is roughly at the middle of its life right now and

at the middle of its life right now and

at the middle of its life right now and such stars will live for trillions of

such stars will live for trillions of

such stars will live for trillions of years the first stars formed when the

years the first stars formed when the

years the first stars formed when the universe was much younger than the

universe was much younger than the

universe was much younger than the current age about a hundred million

current age about a hundred million

current age about a hundred million years after the Big Bang so we might ask

years after the Big Bang so we might ask

years after the Big Bang so we might ask ourselves why is it that we find

ourselves why is it that we find

ourselves why is it that we find ourselves today next to a star like the

ourselves today next to a star like the

ourselves today next to a star like the Sun and not in in the distant future

Sun and not in in the distant future

Sun and not in in the distant future next to the much common population of

next to the much common population of

next to the much common population of powers that are much smaller than the

powers that are much smaller than the

powers that are much smaller than the Sun where does the likelihood of life

Sun where does the likelihood of life

Sun where does the likelihood of life peak in the history of the universe so

peak in the history of the universe so

peak in the history of the universe so if one allows for life to exist around

if one allows for life to exist around

if one allows for life to exist around dwarf stars they provide excellent

dwarf stars they provide excellent

dwarf stars they provide excellent prospects for life in the distant future

prospects for life in the distant future

prospects for life in the distant future and when you plot the likelihood of life

and when you plot the likelihood of life

and when you plot the likelihood of life as a function of cosmic history it

as a function of cosmic history it

as a function of cosmic history it actually Peaks trillions of years from

actually Peaks trillions of years from

actually Peaks trillions of years from now and you can see it in the rightmost

now and you can see it in the rightmost

now and you can see it in the rightmost curve above me on the other hand such

curve above me on the other hand such

curve above me on the other hand such stars may pose risks for life and it’s

stars may pose risks for life and it’s

stars may pose risks for life and it’s quite possible that only stars like the

quite possible that only stars like the

quite possible that only stars like the Sun allow life as we know it to exist in

Sun allow life as we know it to exist in

Sun allow life as we know it to exist in that case we are just at the right time

that case we are just at the right time

that case we are just at the right time where the likelihood for life Peaks when

where the likelihood for life Peaks when

where the likelihood for life Peaks when the age of the universe is comparable to

the age of the universe is comparable to

the age of the universe is comparable to the lifetime of the Sun and the good

the lifetime of the Sun and the good

the lifetime of the Sun and the good news is that the possible existence of

news is that the possible existence of

news is that the possible existence of life around long lived low mass stars

life around long lived low mass stars

life around long lived low mass stars can be tested observational e we can

can be tested observational e we can

can be tested observational e we can just look around us and search for life

just look around us and search for life

just look around us and search for life around those stars and then figure out

around those stars and then figure out

around those stars and then figure out if indeed stars like the Sun are much

if indeed stars like the Sun are much

if indeed stars like the Sun are much more hospitable for life so the closest

more hospitable for life so the closest

more hospitable for life so the closest star to the earth Proxima Centauri is

star to the earth Proxima Centauri is

star to the earth Proxima Centauri is only 4 light years away it takes light

only 4 light years away it takes light

only 4 light years away it takes light for years to get to us from the nearest

for years to get to us from the nearest

for years to get to us from the nearest star and it’s a member of a triple

star and it’s a member of a triple

star and it’s a member of a triple system there are two other stars in that

system there are two other stars in that

system there are two other stars in that system it’s called Alpha Centauri and

system it’s called Alpha Centauri and

system it’s called Alpha Centauri and two other stars are just like the Sun

two other stars are just like the Sun

two other stars are just like the Sun Proxima Centauri is 12 percent of the

Proxima Centauri is 12 percent of the

Proxima Centauri is 12 percent of the mass of the Sun and amazingly a

mass of the Sun and amazingly a

mass of the Sun and amazingly a habitable earth mass planet was found

habitable earth mass planet was found

habitable earth mass planet was found around the nearest star Proxima Centauri

around the nearest star Proxima Centauri

around the nearest star Proxima Centauri it because the star is so light relative

it because the star is so light relative

it because the star is so light relative to the Sun the habitable zone is much

to the Sun the habitable zone is much

to the Sun the habitable zone is much closer in 20 times

closer in 20 times

closer in 20 times closer in and this planet orbits around

closer in and this planet orbits around

closer in and this planet orbits around Proxima Centauri every 11.2 days so if

Proxima Centauri every 11.2 days so if

Proxima Centauri every 11.2 days so if you were to live on that planet you

you were to live on that planet you

you were to live on that planet you would celebrate a birthday every week

would celebrate a birthday every week

would celebrate a birthday every week and a half you would also need infrared

and a half you would also need infrared

and a half you would also need infrared eyes because this star is bright mostly

eyes because this star is bright mostly

eyes because this star is bright mostly in the infrared but to have life as we

in the infrared but to have life as we

in the infrared but to have life as we know it

know it

know it one needs liquid water on the surface of

one needs liquid water on the surface of

one needs liquid water on the surface of this planet and to have liquid water one

this planet and to have liquid water one

this planet and to have liquid water one needs an atmosphere so does Proxima be

needs an atmosphere so does Proxima be

needs an atmosphere so does Proxima be this planet near us outside the solar

this planet near us outside the solar

this planet near us outside the solar system does it have an atmosphere we

system does it have an atmosphere we

system does it have an atmosphere we don’t know it was just discovered a year

don’t know it was just discovered a year

don’t know it was just discovered a year ago how can we find out one way to do so

ago how can we find out one way to do so

ago how can we find out one way to do so is to look at the temperature contrast

is to look at the temperature contrast

is to look at the temperature contrast between the side facing the star and the

between the side facing the star and the

between the side facing the star and the other side as it turns out this planet

other side as it turns out this planet

other side as it turns out this planet is so close to the star that it always

is so close to the star that it always

is so close to the star that it always faces it with the same side so there is

faces it with the same side so there is

faces it with the same side so there is a permanent day side

a permanent day side

a permanent day side and a permanent night side the permanent

and a permanent night side the permanent

and a permanent night side the permanent day side is hot the Nightside is called

day side is hot the Nightside is called

day side is hot the Nightside is called the temperature contrast between the two

the temperature contrast between the two

the temperature contrast between the two depends on whether there is an

depends on whether there is an

depends on whether there is an atmosphere or an ocean because these

atmosphere or an ocean because these

atmosphere or an ocean because these components medium moderate the

components medium moderate the

components medium moderate the temperature contrast if you have just

temperature contrast if you have just

temperature contrast if you have just bare rock the temperature difference

bare rock the temperature difference

bare rock the temperature difference could be quite large so how can you tell

could be quite large so how can you tell

could be quite large so how can you tell well as the planet moves around the star

well as the planet moves around the star

well as the planet moves around the star you see different phases of it and so

you see different phases of it and so

you see different phases of it and so you can monitor the temperature that you

you can monitor the temperature that you

you can monitor the temperature that you see as a function of time and over an

see as a function of time and over an

see as a function of time and over an eleven point two days period you can

eleven point two days period you can

eleven point two days period you can figure out what the temperature contrast

figure out what the temperature contrast

figure out what the temperature contrast is between the two sides of the planet

is between the two sides of the planet

is between the two sides of the planet and that will tell us whether it has an

and that will tell us whether it has an

and that will tell us whether it has an atmosphere or not because we can

atmosphere or not because we can

atmosphere or not because we can calculate the temperature contrast for

calculate the temperature contrast for

calculate the temperature contrast for bare rock at that distance from that

bare rock at that distance from that

bare rock at that distance from that star and as it turns out the James Webb

star and as it turns out the James Webb

star and as it turns out the James Webb Space Telescope to be launched in 2019

Space Telescope to be launched in 2019

Space Telescope to be launched in 2019 will be able to tell tell us whether the

will be able to tell tell us whether the

will be able to tell tell us whether the temperature contrast excluded an

temperature contrast excluded an

temperature contrast excluded an atmosphere around this planet a cosmic

atmosphere around this planet a cosmic

atmosphere around this planet a cosmic perspective about our origins

perspective about our origins

perspective about our origins would contribute to a balanced worldview

would contribute to a balanced worldview

would contribute to a balanced worldview the heavy elements that assembled to

the heavy elements that assembled to

the heavy elements that assembled to make our body were produced at the heart

make our body were produced at the heart

make our body were produced at the heart of a massive star that was nearby and

of a massive star that was nearby and

of a massive star that was nearby and exploded a speck of this material took

exploded a speck of this material took

exploded a speck of this material took the form of our body during our takes

the form of our body during our takes

the form of our body during our takes the form of our body during our life and

the form of our body during our life and

the form of our body during our life and then goes back to earth with one

then goes back to earth with one

then goes back to earth with one exception namely the ashes of Clyde

exception namely the ashes of Clyde

exception namely the ashes of Clyde Tombaugh that discovered Pluto were put

Tombaugh that discovered Pluto were put

Tombaugh that discovered Pluto were put on the New Horizons spacecraft and are

on the New Horizons spacecraft and are

on the New Horizons spacecraft and are making their way back to space the rest

making their way back to space the rest

making their way back to space the rest of us return to Earth what are we then

of us return to Earth what are we then

of us return to Earth what are we then if not just a transient shape that the

if not just a transient shape that the

if not just a transient shape that the speck of material takes for a brief

speck of material takes for a brief

speck of material takes for a brief moment in time over cosmic history on

moment in time over cosmic history on

moment in time over cosmic history on the surface of one planet out of so many

the surface of one planet out of so many

the surface of one planet out of so many out there despite all of this life is

out there despite all of this life is

out there despite all of this life is still the most precious phenomenon that

still the most precious phenomenon that

still the most precious phenomenon that we cherish and treasure here on earth it

we cherish and treasure here on earth it

we cherish and treasure here on earth it would be amazing if we find evidence for

would be amazing if we find evidence for

would be amazing if we find evidence for life as we know it on the surface of

life as we know it on the surface of

life as we know it on the surface of another planet and even more remarkable

another planet and even more remarkable

another planet and even more remarkable if our telescopes will trace evidence

if our telescopes will trace evidence

if our telescopes will trace evidence for an advanced technology on an alien

for an advanced technology on an alien

for an advanced technology on an alien spacecraft roaming through interstellar

spacecraft roaming through interstellar

spacecraft roaming through interstellar space thank

space thank

space thank [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *