Press "Enter" to skip to content

Technology… Tool or Toy? Exploring play in the classroom | Chris Meylan | TEDxSHMS


so an iPad does it really bring value to

so an iPad does it really bring value to a classroom or is it just a toy this is

a classroom or is it just a toy this is

a classroom or is it just a toy this is the big question we had amongst all

the big question we had amongst all

the big question we had amongst all teachers as the iPad was a really big

teachers as the iPad was a really big

teachers as the iPad was a really big disrupter in the way we teach to explain

disrupter in the way we teach to explain

disrupter in the way we teach to explain that please let me give you an example

that please let me give you an example

that please let me give you an example one day I was in my class about to teach

one day I was in my class about to teach

one day I was in my class about to teach research it’s quite a tedious topic

research it’s quite a tedious topic

research it’s quite a tedious topic students don’t enjoy it that much so I

students don’t enjoy it that much so I

students don’t enjoy it that much so I really had to give him my best shot my

really had to give him my best shot my

really had to give him my best shot my best delivery to get students engaging

best delivery to get students engaging

best delivery to get students engaging was I was about to tell them so I

was I was about to tell them so I

was I was about to tell them so I started my class started teaching and

started my class started teaching and

started my class started teaching and then suddenly in the back of the room I

then suddenly in the back of the room I

then suddenly in the back of the room I see this one of the students holding his

see this one of the students holding his

see this one of the students holding his iPad on the air moving around like that

iPad on the air moving around like that

iPad on the air moving around like that and I was thinking what are you doing so

and I was thinking what are you doing so

and I was thinking what are you doing so stopped teaching he realized that I saw

stopped teaching he realized that I saw

stopped teaching he realized that I saw him so he put his iPad down I didn’t see

him so he put his iPad down I didn’t see

him so he put his iPad down I didn’t see anything but I was a bit put out I was

anything but I was a bit put out I was

anything but I was a bit put out I was wondering shouldn’t be listening to what

wondering shouldn’t be listening to what

wondering shouldn’t be listening to what I’m saying rather than playing a game

I’m saying rather than playing a game

I’m saying rather than playing a game but I went on anyway I looked at him he

but I went on anyway I looked at him he

but I went on anyway I looked at him he didn’t pay attention to anything I had

didn’t pay attention to anything I had

didn’t pay attention to anything I had to say but he was not only because of

to say but he was not only because of

to say but he was not only because of him only I realized that many students

him only I realized that many students

him only I realized that many students were disengaged especially the longer I

were disengaged especially the longer I

were disengaged especially the longer I talked the easier for them was it to

talked the easier for them was it to

talked the easier for them was it to completely lose focus and interest so as

completely lose focus and interest so as

completely lose focus and interest so as a teacher you’re not happy you you want

a teacher you’re not happy you you want

a teacher you’re not happy you you want everybody to be engaged in what you say

everybody to be engaged in what you say

everybody to be engaged in what you say so I started to do some reading and I

so I started to do some reading and I

so I started to do some reading and I found a very interesting piece of

found a very interesting piece of

found a very interesting piece of research from Eric Mazur from Harvard

research from Eric Mazur from Harvard

research from Eric Mazur from Harvard University and if epi’ speaks about one

University and if epi’ speaks about one

University and if epi’ speaks about one specific piece of research where looks

specific piece of research where looks

specific piece of research where looks at students brain activity during a day

at students brain activity during a day

at students brain activity during a day and it’s how it looks like so you see

and it’s how it looks like so you see

and it’s how it looks like so you see the brain activity going through the day

the brain activity going through the day

the brain activity going through the day and the student in the classroom

and the student in the classroom

and the student in the classroom actually the brain is dead less active

actually the brain is dead less active

actually the brain is dead less active than in sleep so can you imagine for

than in sleep so can you imagine for

than in sleep so can you imagine for teachers like us how that is not very

teachers like us how that is not very

teachers like us how that is not very encouraging

encouraging

encouraging another interesting research that I

another interesting research that I

another interesting research that I found was from dr. John Medina he’s

found was from dr. John Medina he’s

found was from dr. John Medina he’s written a great book called brain rules

written a great book called brain rules

written a great book called brain rules and one of these rule is called the ten

and one of these rule is called the ten

and one of these rule is called the ten rule it’s the amount of time that you

rule it’s the amount of time that you

rule it’s the amount of time that you have to catch your audience’s attention

have to catch your audience’s attention

have to catch your audience’s attention after that the brain just goes away it’s

after that the brain just goes away it’s

after that the brain just goes away it’s much more difficult for us to focus so

much more difficult for us to focus so

much more difficult for us to focus so we learned that students get easily

we learned that students get easily

we learned that students get easily bored in the classroom we learn that if

bored in the classroom we learn that if

bored in the classroom we learn that if you’re lucky you maybe get 10 minutes

you’re lucky you maybe get 10 minutes

you’re lucky you maybe get 10 minutes attention but when my student was

attention but when my student was

attention but when my student was playing with his iPad

playing with his iPad

playing with his iPad he was very engaged in that and very

he was very engaged in that and very

he was very engaged in that and very attentive so why can’t we use play in

attentive so why can’t we use play in

attentive so why can’t we use play in the class so but if you look at the

the class so but if you look at the

the class so but if you look at the Oxford English Dictionary it’s

Oxford English Dictionary it’s

Oxford English Dictionary it’s apparently not appropriate because play

apparently not appropriate because play

apparently not appropriate because play and work are two different things and

and work are two different things and

and work are two different things and it’s quite common perception today that

it’s quite common perception today that

it’s quite common perception today that when you work you don’t play so when you

when you work you don’t play so when you

when you work you don’t play so when you study you work hard hence you don’t play

study you work hard hence you don’t play

study you work hard hence you don’t play but is it really true do you love

but is it really true do you love

but is it really true do you love playing games I do and I realize that I

playing games I do and I realize that I

playing games I do and I realize that I learn a lot when I play games but I also

learn a lot when I play games but I also

learn a lot when I play games but I also see that when we play together with my

see that when we play together with my

see that when we play together with my daughters they also enjoy playing games

daughters they also enjoy playing games

daughters they also enjoy playing games but they learn a lot here we play a Star

but they learn a lot here we play a Star

but they learn a lot here we play a Star Wars game together we play a cation game

Wars game together we play a cation game

Wars game together we play a cation game together with a strategy game and not

together with a strategy game and not

together with a strategy game and not only do they enjoy playing hard games

only do they enjoy playing hard games

only do they enjoy playing hard games because there’s a lot of rules in these

because there’s a lot of rules in these

because there’s a lot of rules in these games but I see that they develop great

games but I see that they develop great

games but I see that they develop great skills in reading mathematic negotiating

skills in reading mathematic negotiating

skills in reading mathematic negotiating I would even argue that they start

I would even argue that they start

I would even argue that they start thinking strategically even if they are

thinking strategically even if they are

thinking strategically even if they are quite young sometimes even more

quite young sometimes even more

quite young sometimes even more strategic than me

strategic than me

strategic than me Angie from Arizona State University

Angie from Arizona State University

Angie from Arizona State University actually explains that when we are

actually explains that when we are

actually explains that when we are playing the brain works in very similar

playing the brain works in very similar

playing the brain works in very similar ways that when we are studying and

ways that when we are studying and

ways that when we are studying and companies have been using play recently

companies have been using play recently

companies have been using play recently and we can put play in three different

and we can put play in three different

and we can put play in three different categories which are simulation

categories which are simulation

categories which are simulation gamification and Gav game based learning

gamification and Gav game based learning

gamification and Gav game based learning I’m going to explain how we use those

I’m going to explain how we use those

I’m going to explain how we use those three different types of play in the

three different types of play in the

three different types of play in the classroom at the Swiss Hotel Management

classroom at the Swiss Hotel Management

classroom at the Swiss Hotel Management school with quite some success so the

school with quite some success so the

school with quite some success so the first one is simulation you all know

first one is simulation you all know

first one is simulation you all know simulation it’s been here for like quite

simulation it’s been here for like quite

simulation it’s been here for like quite a while companies use it to train their

a while companies use it to train their

a while companies use it to train their employees like airlines use simulation

employees like airlines use simulation

employees like airlines use simulation to train their pilots the US army use

to train their pilots the US army use

to train their pilots the US army use simulation to train their military but

simulation to train their military but

simulation to train their military but we use simulation for a topic students

we use simulation for a topic students

we use simulation for a topic students don’t enjoy that much as well called

don’t enjoy that much as well called

don’t enjoy that much as well called accounting and we use simulation as

accounting and we use simulation as

accounting and we use simulation as students are actually running a hotel a

students are actually running a hotel a

students are actually running a hotel a simulated hotel through the iPads they

simulated hotel through the iPads they

simulated hotel through the iPads they make decisions on how much they want to

make decisions on how much they want to

make decisions on how much they want to invest how much they want to spend what

invest how much they want to spend what

invest how much they want to spend what rates they want to set and they see the

rates they want to set and they see the

rates they want to set and they see the results of those decisions it’s not

results of those decisions it’s not

results of those decisions it’s not anymore about teaching them to do a P&L

anymore about teaching them to do a P&L

anymore about teaching them to do a P&L calculate ratios but it’s about giving

calculate ratios but it’s about giving

calculate ratios but it’s about giving them the opportunity to think and

them the opportunity to think and

them the opportunity to think and reflect on the decisions they’ve made

reflect on the decisions they’ve made

reflect on the decisions they’ve made for example a student might decide to

for example a student might decide to

for example a student might decide to win the game and by doing that she’s not

win the game and by doing that she’s not

win the game and by doing that she’s not gonna renovate her rooms but what might

gonna renovate her rooms but what might

gonna renovate her rooms but what might happen is our customers might go to

happen is our customers might go to

happen is our customers might go to someone else’s hotel because the rooms

someone else’s hotel because the rooms

someone else’s hotel because the rooms are not good enough and by playing that

are not good enough and by playing that

are not good enough and by playing that she learns that which normally is always

she learns that which normally is always

she learns that which normally is always taught by teachers so and what is also

taught by teachers so and what is also

taught by teachers so and what is also very interesting with this is that we

very interesting with this is that we

very interesting with this is that we can see that students are actually very

can see that students are actually very

can see that students are actually very motivated to read financial statements

motivated to read financial statements

motivated to read financial statements that doesn’t sound right students

that doesn’t sound right students

that doesn’t sound right students motivated to read financial statements

motivated to read financial statements

motivated to read financial statements but they really are because it helps

but they really are because it helps

but they really are because it helps them win the game the second use of play

them win the game the second use of play

them win the game the second use of play is called gamification you might have

is called gamification you might have

is called gamification you might have heard about it or you might use it every

heard about it or you might use it every

heard about it or you might use it every day because it’s really everywhere its

day because it’s really everywhere its

day because it’s really everywhere its use of point badges leaderboards that

use of point badges leaderboards that

use of point badges leaderboards that get us motivated to achieve a certain

get us motivated to achieve a certain

get us motivated to achieve a certain goal it’s in our loyalty programs

goal it’s in our loyalty programs

goal it’s in our loyalty programs Starbucks uses it and gives you little

Starbucks uses it and gives you little

Starbucks uses it and gives you little points and badges depending on how much

points and badges depending on how much

points and badges depending on how much you spend it’s in our fitness trackers

you spend it’s in our fitness trackers

you spend it’s in our fitness trackers it tells us how much we walk and

it tells us how much we walk and

it tells us how much we walk and exercise and if you walk enough it gives

exercise and if you walk enough it gives

exercise and if you walk enough it gives you a little badge and sometimes you’re

you a little badge and sometimes you’re

you a little badge and sometimes you’re almost there so you’re gonna walk out

almost there so you’re gonna walk out

almost there so you’re gonna walk out you’re going to go out and walk and

you’re going to go out and walk and

you’re going to go out and walk and exercise

exercise

exercise to get that badge right so that’s

to get that badge right so that’s

to get that badge right so that’s gamification what is gamification is all

gamification what is gamification is all

gamification what is gamification is all about and we are using an app called

about and we are using an app called

about and we are using an app called Kahoot kuru is a simple quiz app but it

Kahoot kuru is a simple quiz app but it

Kahoot kuru is a simple quiz app but it uses some play element to get student

uses some play element to get student

uses some play element to get student motivated questions are shown on the

motivated questions are shown on the

motivated questions are shown on the board there’s a little fun music in the

board there’s a little fun music in the

board there’s a little fun music in the background

background

background question are limited in time students

question are limited in time students

question are limited in time students input the answers on their iPad and they

input the answers on their iPad and they

input the answers on their iPad and they get scores depending on how quickly

get scores depending on how quickly

get scores depending on how quickly they’re correct the answer and how

they’re correct the answer and how

they’re correct the answer and how quickly and or correctly they answer as

quickly and or correctly they answer as

quickly and or correctly they answer as well at the end there’s a podium with

well at the end there’s a podium with

well at the end there’s a podium with the winner and it really motivates

the winner and it really motivates

the winner and it really motivates students that’s just one of the class

students that’s just one of the class

students that’s just one of the class playing the game got the right answer

playing the game got the right answer

playing the game got the right answer and everybody is motivated and see and

and everybody is motivated and see and

and everybody is motivated and see and happy that they got the right answer

happy that they got the right answer

happy that they got the right answer traditionally if I ask a question to my

traditionally if I ask a question to my

traditionally if I ask a question to my students only the good ones would answer

students only the good ones would answer

students only the good ones would answer everybody else wants to leave as quickly

everybody else wants to leave as quickly

everybody else wants to leave as quickly as possible because they want to go for

as possible because they want to go for

as possible because they want to go for lunch but with this we can see that

lunch but with this we can see that

lunch but with this we can see that students are motivated they even want to

students are motivated they even want to

students are motivated they even want to play the second time and everybody is

play the second time and everybody is

play the second time and everybody is motivated to play the game because they

motivated to play the game because they

motivated to play the game because they want to try to win it so they give their

want to try to win it so they give their

want to try to win it so they give their best shot so that’s good another app

best shot so that’s good another app

best shot so that’s good another app that we use alchol Quizlet out who’s

that we use alchol Quizlet out who’s

that we use alchol Quizlet out who’s that live it’s an app that allows us to

that live it’s an app that allows us to

that live it’s an app that allows us to link definition with terms very simple

link definition with terms very simple

link definition with terms very simple you have a definition on top and you

you have a definition on top and you

you have a definition on top and you have the matching term below but the

have the matching term below but the

have the matching term below but the right term might not be on your screen

right term might not be on your screen

right term might not be on your screen because the app puts you together in a

because the app puts you together in a

because the app puts you together in a team and as a team you need to match

team and as a team you need to match

team and as a team you need to match those two together so you sit down with

those two together so you sit down with

those two together so you sit down with your team you look at the terms you look

your team you look at the terms you look

your team you look at the terms you look right term try to find it and oops this

right term try to find it and oops this

right term try to find it and oops this team didn’t get it right so what is

team didn’t get it right so what is

team didn’t get it right so what is gamification about gamification because

gamification about gamification because

gamification about gamification because the team that reaches 12 points first

the team that reaches 12 points first

the team that reaches 12 points first wins the game and stopped for everybody

wins the game and stopped for everybody

wins the game and stopped for everybody else so you can say okay they’re just

else so you can say okay they’re just

else so you can say okay they’re just gonna quit and so as quickly as possible

gonna quit and so as quickly as possible

gonna quit and so as quickly as possible then but that’s not possible because if

then but that’s not possible because if

then but that’s not possible because if you reach 10 points and you get it wrong

you reach 10 points and you get it wrong

you reach 10 points and you get it wrong it puts you down to zero so a game can

it puts you down to zero so a game can

it puts you down to zero so a game can easily last half an hour 45 minutes and

easily last half an hour 45 minutes and

easily last half an hour 45 minutes and this is an example of students after

this is an example of students after

this is an example of students after thirty minutes of play happy and

thirty minutes of play happy and

thirty minutes of play happy and motivated they wear for one one more

motivated they wear for one one more

motivated they wear for one one more time she says she wanted to play again

time she says she wanted to play again

time she says she wanted to play again and I’m going to show you one more

and I’m going to show you one more

and I’m going to show you one more example because I’d like you to think

example because I’d like you to think

example because I’d like you to think back to your school when a teacher asked

back to your school when a teacher asked

back to your school when a teacher asked you to read definitions did you like

you to read definitions did you like

you to read definitions did you like that students don’t in general but look

that students don’t in general but look

that students don’t in general but look how motivated they are at looking at

how motivated they are at looking at

how motivated they are at looking at definitions looking at specific turns

definitions looking at specific turns

definitions looking at specific turns trying to match them together they

trying to match them together they

trying to match them together they really really passionate because again

really really passionate because again

really really passionate because again they want to win the game Aleksandra

they want to win the game Aleksandra

they want to win the game Aleksandra talked about dopamine and it’s all about

talked about dopamine and it’s all about

talked about dopamine and it’s all about that as well and finally last example of

that as well and finally last example of

that as well and finally last example of play is game based learning game based

play is game based learning game based

play is game based learning game based learning is what you ask students to

learning is what you ask students to

learning is what you ask students to play a game and they learn from playing

play a game and they learn from playing

play a game and they learn from playing that game

that game

that game one of our teachers Ivy Villa teaches

one of our teachers Ivy Villa teaches

one of our teachers Ivy Villa teaches revenue management when he asked

revenue management when he asked

revenue management when he asked students to play farmville and from

students to play farmville and from

students to play farmville and from playing farmville to see what students

playing farmville to see what students

playing farmville to see what students are learning because the concept

are learning because the concept

are learning because the concept actually very similar and what is

actually very similar and what is

actually very similar and what is interesting is that they when they give

interesting is that they when they give

interesting is that they when they give answers they actually understand the

answers they actually understand the

answers they actually understand the topic without having learned the

topic without having learned the

topic without having learned the theories first and that’s the idea of

theories first and that’s the idea of

theories first and that’s the idea of game based learning is that students

game based learning is that students

game based learning is that students practice and through the practice they

practice and through the practice they

practice and through the practice they learn and with games it games them also

learn and with games it games them also

learn and with games it games them also a fun environment in which to play so

a fun environment in which to play so

a fun environment in which to play so technology eventually was great because

technology eventually was great because

technology eventually was great because without technology we would not have

without technology we would not have

without technology we would not have been able to do simulations gamification

been able to do simulations gamification

been able to do simulations gamification game based learning but you don’t always

game based learning but you don’t always

game based learning but you don’t always need technology to play a game for

need technology to play a game for

need technology to play a game for example there’s a great game that I love

example there’s a great game that I love

example there’s a great game that I love to play which is called antique you run

to play which is called antique you run

to play which is called antique you run a civilization like the Romans or the

a civilization like the Romans or the

a civilization like the Romans or the Egyptians you construct your

Egyptians you construct your

Egyptians you construct your civilization you attack your enemies you

civilization you attack your enemies you

civilization you attack your enemies you build temples fantastic game but what is

build temples fantastic game but what is

build temples fantastic game but what is great about the game is there is no luck

great about the game is there is no luck

great about the game is there is no luck involved

involved

involved it’s all about your choices it’s all

it’s all about your choices it’s all

it’s all about your choices it’s all about your strategy and whenever I

about your strategy and whenever I

about your strategy and whenever I played this game

played this game

played this game I’m always to animals told myself I want

I’m always to animals told myself I want

I’m always to animals told myself I want to use it to teach strategy and then I

to use it to teach strategy and then I

to use it to teach strategy and then I talked to my colleague Patrick toughen

talked to my colleague Patrick toughen

talked to my colleague Patrick toughen and I said and he said why don’t we do

and I said and he said why don’t we do

and I said and he said why don’t we do it let’s go ahead let’s create the game

it let’s go ahead let’s create the game

it let’s go ahead let’s create the game so we took the exact same rules but we

so we took the exact same rules but we

so we took the exact same rules but we changed it so the students are running a

changed it so the students are running a

changed it so the students are running a hospital

hospital

hospital company rather than a civilization we

company rather than a civilization we

company rather than a civilization we use class time where we put students

use class time where we put students

use class time where we put students together in groups and they play the

together in groups and they play the

together in groups and they play the game for more than two hours and there’s

game for more than two hours and there’s

game for more than two hours and there’s many different ways to win the game you

many different ways to win the game you

many different ways to win the game you can expand your brand you can build

can expand your brand you can build

can expand your brand you can build palaces you can buy over the competition

palaces you can buy over the competition

palaces you can buy over the competition you can acquire capabilities but what

you can acquire capabilities but what

you can acquire capabilities but what we’ve seen is that the students who have

we’ve seen is that the students who have

we’ve seen is that the students who have one had the one who set a very specific

one had the one who set a very specific

one had the one who set a very specific strategy and set to that strategy but

strategy and set to that strategy but

strategy and set to that strategy but that’s see like in real life we have

that’s see like in real life we have

that’s see like in real life we have some strategies in the class in the

some strategies in the class in the

some strategies in the class in the class in the audience so it’s real life

class in the audience so it’s real life

class in the audience so it’s real life you need to set your strategy and stick

you need to set your strategy and stick

you need to set your strategy and stick to it so what does they’ve learned by

to it so what does they’ve learned by

to it so what does they’ve learned by playing the game and that’s what we also

playing the game and that’s what we also

playing the game and that’s what we also tell them in the in the theory as well

tell them in the in the theory as well

tell them in the in the theory as well so they’ve been able to put it into

so they’ve been able to put it into

so they’ve been able to put it into practice after two hours of play I

practice after two hours of play I

practice after two hours of play I didn’t see anybody check their Facebook

didn’t see anybody check their Facebook

didn’t see anybody check their Facebook or check the Instagram they really

or check the Instagram they really

or check the Instagram they really really were engrossed in the play and

really were engrossed in the play and

really were engrossed in the play and after two hours one team was a little

after two hours one team was a little

after two hours one team was a little bit behind so all the rest of the class

bit behind so all the rest of the class

bit behind so all the rest of the class came looking around and tried to comment

came looking around and tried to comment

came looking around and tried to comment and give recommendations and at the end

and give recommendations and at the end

and give recommendations and at the end of the session we ran a debriefing and

of the session we ran a debriefing and

of the session we ran a debriefing and asked them what did you learn and

asked them what did you learn and

asked them what did you learn and students were able to really relate all

students were able to really relate all

students were able to really relate all the strategic theoretical terms to the

the strategic theoretical terms to the

the strategic theoretical terms to the way they played how we were stuck in the

way they played how we were stuck in the

way they played how we were stuck in the middle

middle

middle we were differentiators we try to lower

we were differentiators we try to lower

we were differentiators we try to lower our costs was really really interesting

our costs was really really interesting

our costs was really really interesting so play is great do you need game to

so play is great do you need game to

so play is great do you need game to play not all the time you can actually

play not all the time you can actually

play not all the time you can actually play by having a brainstorming session

play by having a brainstorming session

play by having a brainstorming session in the classroom you can play by role

in the classroom you can play by role

in the classroom you can play by role playing a business situation you can

playing a business situation you can

playing a business situation you can play by having a debate in the classroom

play by having a debate in the classroom

play by having a debate in the classroom now with the technology you can play and

now with the technology you can play and

now with the technology you can play and asking students to create a video

asking students to create a video

asking students to create a video and then share it on social media and

and then share it on social media and

and then share it on social media and see them amount of likes that they have

see them amount of likes that they have

see them amount of likes that they have so what what makes play so engaging its

so what what makes play so engaging its

so what what makes play so engaging its engaging because it makes the student

engaging because it makes the student

engaging because it makes the student active they are active participants in

active they are active participants in

active they are active participants in their own learning they’re just not

their own learning they’re just not

their own learning they’re just not sitting there passively listening to an

sitting there passively listening to an

sitting there passively listening to an expert and on top of that they have fun

expert and on top of that they have fun

expert and on top of that they have fun so while they have fun they are

so while they have fun they are

so while they have fun they are interested and they’ve interested they

interested and they’ve interested they

interested and they’ve interested they pay attention and it’s not anymore just

pay attention and it’s not anymore just

pay attention and it’s not anymore just about memorization it’s about deeper

about memorization it’s about deeper

about memorization it’s about deeper learning in the introduction I said that

learning in the introduction I said that

learning in the introduction I said that the iPad disrupted the way we teach but

the iPad disrupted the way we teach but

the iPad disrupted the way we teach but I wasn’t completely correct it didn’t

I wasn’t completely correct it didn’t

I wasn’t completely correct it didn’t disrupt the way we teach it forced us

disrupt the way we teach it forced us

disrupt the way we teach it forced us and give us the apology to reflect on

and give us the apology to reflect on

and give us the apology to reflect on our teaching methods and rather than

our teaching methods and rather than

our teaching methods and rather than focus on us teaching we decided to focus

focus on us teaching we decided to focus

focus on us teaching we decided to focus on the students learning thank you very

on the students learning thank you very

on the students learning thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *