Press "Enter" to skip to content

Teams of robots with a real world impact | Nora Ayanian | TEDxCibeles


[Applause]

[Applause] according to the World Bank nearly

according to the World Bank nearly

according to the World Bank nearly 60,000 people die each year in natural

60,000 people die each year in natural

60,000 people die each year in natural disasters mostly in developing countries

disasters mostly in developing countries

disasters mostly in developing countries most of these deaths are due to building

most of these deaths are due to building

most of these deaths are due to building collapses in earthquakes after an

collapses in earthquakes after an

collapses in earthquakes after an earthquake areas can be inaccessible

earthquake areas can be inaccessible

earthquake areas can be inaccessible making it difficult to search for

making it difficult to search for

making it difficult to search for survivors and for survivors to find

survivors and for survivors to find

survivors and for survivors to find potable water this makes robots and

potable water this makes robots and

potable water this makes robots and drones the perfect tool to search for

drones the perfect tool to search for

drones the perfect tool to search for survivors after an earthquake in fact

survivors after an earthquake in fact

survivors after an earthquake in fact one of the largest drone manufacturers

one of the largest drone manufacturers

one of the largest drone manufacturers in the world recently said that one

in the world recently said that one

in the world recently said that one properly equipped drone can find a

properly equipped drone can find a

properly equipped drone can find a missing person up to five times faster

missing person up to five times faster

missing person up to five times faster than traditional search methods that’s

than traditional search methods that’s

than traditional search methods that’s just one drone imagine what 210 or even

just one drone imagine what 210 or even

just one drone imagine what 210 or even a swarm of 100 drones could do right now

a swarm of 100 drones could do right now

a swarm of 100 drones could do right now each drone is operated by a single

each drone is operated by a single

each drone is operated by a single trained pilot which tell the drone

trained pilot which tell the drone

trained pilot which tell the drone exactly what to do imagine if instead

exactly what to do imagine if instead

exactly what to do imagine if instead that pilot could control that entire

that pilot could control that entire

that pilot could control that entire swarm of drones or even better if that

swarm of drones or even better if that

swarm of drones or even better if that entire swarm of drones could work

entire swarm of drones could work

entire swarm of drones could work autonomously on their own without a

autonomously on their own without a

autonomously on their own without a trained pilot in developing countries

trained pilot in developing countries

trained pilot in developing countries where a trained drone pilot might be

where a trained drone pilot might be

where a trained drone pilot might be hours away local first response teams

hours away local first response teams

hours away local first response teams can deploy an autonomous team of aerial

can deploy an autonomous team of aerial

can deploy an autonomous team of aerial robots to search for survivors and tell

robots to search for survivors and tell

robots to search for survivors and tell them where to go immediately after a

them where to go immediately after a

them where to go immediately after a natural disaster saving many more lives

natural disaster saving many more lives

natural disaster saving many more lives I’ve been working on these kinds of

I’ve been working on these kinds of

I’ve been working on these kinds of complex problems of how to get teams of

complex problems of how to get teams of

complex problems of how to get teams of robots to work together for more than a

robots to work together for more than a

robots to work together for more than a decade and it’s deceptively difficult to

decade and it’s deceptively difficult to

decade and it’s deceptively difficult to get robots to work together but we have

get robots to work together but we have

get robots to work together but we have big dreams we want robots to search for

big dreams we want robots to search for

big dreams we want robots to search for survivors after earthquakes we want

survivors after earthquakes we want

survivors after earthquakes we want robots to contain forest fires we want

robots to contain forest fires we want

robots to contain forest fires we want them to deliver medicine to area

them to deliver medicine to area

them to deliver medicine to area in need but these environments are very

in need but these environments are very

in need but these environments are very different than the environment that that

different than the environment that that

different than the environment that that we’ve trained the robots in so we’ve

we’ve trained the robots in so we’ve

we’ve trained the robots in so we’ve solved very similar problems to these so

solved very similar problems to these so

solved very similar problems to these so in this example this is a video from my

in this example this is a video from my

in this example this is a video from my lab where we’re doing a demonstration of

lab where we’re doing a demonstration of

lab where we’re doing a demonstration of drones flying through windows so we’ve

drones flying through windows so we’ve

drones flying through windows so we’ve been successful in labs in manufacturing

been successful in labs in manufacturing

been successful in labs in manufacturing and warehousing facilities and even in

and warehousing facilities and even in

and warehousing facilities and even in entertainment but these environments

entertainment but these environments

entertainment but these environments like I said are very different and so

like I said are very different and so

like I said are very different and so we’re dreaming big but something is

we’re dreaming big but something is

we’re dreaming big but something is holding us back and I believe it’s how

holding us back and I believe it’s how

holding us back and I believe it’s how we solve the problem it’s a really big

we solve the problem it’s a really big

we solve the problem it’s a really big challenge to get a team of robots to

challenge to get a team of robots to

challenge to get a team of robots to work together on search and rescue in

work together on search and rescue in

work together on search and rescue in fact it’s the biggest challenge I faced

fact it’s the biggest challenge I faced

fact it’s the biggest challenge I faced in my career I want you to think back to

in my career I want you to think back to

in my career I want you to think back to the biggest challenge you’ve ever faced

the biggest challenge you’ve ever faced

the biggest challenge you’ve ever faced did you solve it entirely on your own or

did you solve it entirely on your own or

did you solve it entirely on your own or did you work in a group or ask other

did you work in a group or ask other

did you work in a group or ask other people for advice I know that when I

people for advice I know that when I

people for advice I know that when I work on a big challenge I ask as many

work on a big challenge I ask as many

work on a big challenge I ask as many people as I can I try to get as many

people as I can I try to get as many

people as I can I try to get as many opinions from people who’ve been through

opinions from people who’ve been through

opinions from people who’ve been through it and people who have it people who are

it and people who have it people who are

it and people who have it people who are my senior and people who are my junior

my senior and people who are my junior

my senior and people who are my junior people in my field people outside my

people in my field people outside my

people in my field people outside my field I collect as many ideas as I can

field I collect as many ideas as I can

field I collect as many ideas as I can and then I take the best of those ideas

and then I take the best of those ideas

and then I take the best of those ideas that work for me and so we work in

that work for me and so we work in

that work for me and so we work in groups so that we can take advantage of

groups so that we can take advantage of

groups so that we can take advantage of the diversity in our experiences and in

the diversity in our experiences and in

the diversity in our experiences and in our knowledge so that we can come up

our knowledge so that we can come up

our knowledge so that we can come up with better solutions but when I think

with better solutions but when I think

with better solutions but when I think about how we actually try to get robots

about how we actually try to get robots

about how we actually try to get robots to work together we’re not applying this

to work together we’re not applying this

to work together we’re not applying this right now what we do is we have our

right now what we do is we have our

right now what we do is we have our problem like search and rescue it’s very

problem like search and rescue it’s very

problem like search and rescue it’s very complicated so we try to make it simpler

complicated so we try to make it simpler

complicated so we try to make it simpler by making assumptions like the building

by making assumptions like the building

by making assumptions like the building is made of a certain kind of material or

is made of a certain kind of material or

is made of a certain kind of material or the earthquake is going to be of a

the earthquake is going to be of a

the earthquake is going to be of a certain type or a certain size and then

certain type or a certain size and then

certain type or a certain size and then we optimize the solution based on those

we optimize the solution based on those

we optimize the solution based on those assumptions and we deploy it on all of

assumptions and we deploy it on all of

assumptions and we deploy it on all of the robots the trouble is that the world

the robots the trouble is that the world

the robots the trouble is that the world rarely meets our expectations

rarely meets our expectations

rarely meets our expectations and so when one of those robots fails

and so when one of those robots fails

and so when one of those robots fails all of them are gonna fail so we’re not

all of them are gonna fail so we’re not

all of them are gonna fail so we’re not applying what comes a second nature to

applying what comes a second nature to

applying what comes a second nature to ourselves trying to come up with diverse

ourselves trying to come up with diverse

ourselves trying to come up with diverse solutions so that they work better and

solutions so that they work better and

solutions so that they work better and so if humans are so good at this then

so if humans are so good at this then

so if humans are so good at this then why can’t we learn from humans robot

why can’t we learn from humans robot

why can’t we learn from humans robot assist hub is studying animals like

assist hub is studying animals like

assist hub is studying animals like birds fish and sand lions to try to

birds fish and sand lions to try to

birds fish and sand lions to try to figure out how they collaborate on tasks

figure out how they collaborate on tasks

figure out how they collaborate on tasks so that we can observe them and actually

so that we can observe them and actually

so that we can observe them and actually apply those learnings to robots but we

apply those learnings to robots but we

apply those learnings to robots but we can actually communicate with humans but

can actually communicate with humans but

can actually communicate with humans but unfortunately it’s not that simple as

unfortunately it’s not that simple as

unfortunately it’s not that simple as you may already know robots are nothing

you may already know robots are nothing

you may already know robots are nothing like humans humans have very different

like humans humans have very different

like humans humans have very different ways of communicating just a facial

ways of communicating just a facial

ways of communicating just a facial expression or a hand gesture can

expression or a hand gesture can

expression or a hand gesture can communicate something to you robots

communicate something to you robots

communicate something to you robots can’t do that their communication is

can’t do that their communication is

can’t do that their communication is much less expressive and much more

much less expressive and much more

much less expressive and much more intentional robots can communicate by

intentional robots can communicate by

intentional robots can communicate by broadcast so for example if you heard

broadcast so for example if you heard

broadcast so for example if you heard over the speaker’s right now somebody

over the speaker’s right now somebody

over the speaker’s right now somebody saying follow me if you don’t know where

saying follow me if you don’t know where

saying follow me if you don’t know where that’s coming from how would you know

that’s coming from how would you know

that’s coming from how would you know what to do robots can also communicate

what to do robots can also communicate

what to do robots can also communicate by address that’s like maybe one of your

by address that’s like maybe one of your

by address that’s like maybe one of your friends in the audience sending you a

friends in the audience sending you a

friends in the audience sending you a text message saying come over here now

text message saying come over here now

text message saying come over here now as a human you might be able to figure

as a human you might be able to figure

as a human you might be able to figure out where your friend is by using

out where your friend is by using

out where your friend is by using context but robots don’t have that

context but robots don’t have that

context but robots don’t have that capability and so communicating within a

capability and so communicating within a

capability and so communicating within a large team of robots becomes really

large team of robots becomes really

large team of robots becomes really difficult because they need to share a

difficult because they need to share a

difficult because they need to share a lot more information than we’re used to

lot more information than we’re used to

lot more information than we’re used to that uses up all of our bandwidth so

that uses up all of our bandwidth so

that uses up all of our bandwidth so that we can’t use it for more important

that we can’t use it for more important

that we can’t use it for more important things beyond communication

things beyond communication

things beyond communication we’re must also see the world in an

we’re must also see the world in an

we’re must also see the world in an entirely different way in this video you

entirely different way in this video you

entirely different way in this video you can see the world from a robots

can see the world from a robots

can see the world from a robots perspective it’s really hard for us as

perspective it’s really hard for us as

perspective it’s really hard for us as humans to understand what’s going on in

humans to understand what’s going on in

humans to understand what’s going on in this video but the robot is actually

this video but the robot is actually

this video but the robot is actually using this information to complete its

using this information to complete its

using this information to complete its task and so if we expect robots to be

task and so if we expect robots to be

task and so if we expect robots to be able to use this small amount of

able to use this small amount of

able to use this small amount of information to do complex things it’s

information to do complex things it’s

information to do complex things it’s no wonder that we haven’t been able to

no wonder that we haven’t been able to

no wonder that we haven’t been able to do things like use teams of robots for

do things like use teams of robots for

do things like use teams of robots for search and rescue so I thought about

search and rescue so I thought about

search and rescue so I thought about this for a very long time how can we

this for a very long time how can we

this for a very long time how can we actually get humans how could he get

actually get humans how could he get

actually get humans how could he get robots to act more like humans but we

robots to act more like humans but we

robots to act more like humans but we can’t really do that because they’re so

can’t really do that because they’re so

can’t really do that because they’re so different so instead what we decided to

different so instead what we decided to

different so instead what we decided to do is to actually use interfaces to

do is to actually use interfaces to

do is to actually use interfaces to change how humans act so humans can act

change how humans act so humans can act

change how humans act so humans can act more like robots and so we develop a

more like robots and so we develop a

more like robots and so we develop a multiplayer game in order to learn how

multiplayer game in order to learn how

multiplayer game in order to learn how humans coordinate on complex tasks and

humans coordinate on complex tasks and

humans coordinate on complex tasks and we gave them very robot light

we gave them very robot light

we gave them very robot light capabilities so in this game each player

capabilities so in this game each player

capabilities so in this game each player they’re all human players is represented

they’re all human players is represented

they’re all human players is represented by a single dot on the screen there are

by a single dot on the screen there are

by a single dot on the screen there are many other people playing at the same

many other people playing at the same

many other people playing at the same time but much like you could only see a

time but much like you could only see a

time but much like you could only see a limited field of view of people seated

limited field of view of people seated

limited field of view of people seated around you we only allow them to see a

around you we only allow them to see a

around you we only allow them to see a limited field of view and much like the

limited field of view and much like the

limited field of view and much like the person next to you blocks what you see

person next to you blocks what you see

person next to you blocks what you see beyond them we also include this kind of

beyond them we also include this kind of

beyond them we also include this kind of occlusion we allow the people to move up

occlusion we allow the people to move up

occlusion we allow the people to move up down left and right and then we ask them

down left and right and then we ask them

down left and right and then we ask them to do tasks like form rectangles and

to do tasks like form rectangles and

to do tasks like form rectangles and circles together note that I didn’t

circles together note that I didn’t

circles together note that I didn’t mention that we give people any kind of

mention that we give people any kind of

mention that we give people any kind of communication so we already talked about

communication so we already talked about

communication so we already talked about why communication is difficult so we

why communication is difficult so we

why communication is difficult so we don’t include any communication in this

don’t include any communication in this

don’t include any communication in this game so to give you an idea of what it’s

game so to give you an idea of what it’s

game so to give you an idea of what it’s like to play the game if you’re playing

like to play the game if you’re playing

like to play the game if you’re playing the game you’re the red dot in the

the game you’re the red dot in the

the game you’re the red dot in the center here and all the other black

center here and all the other black

center here and all the other black parts are controlled by other people so

parts are controlled by other people so

parts are controlled by other people so this is not a computer game this is

this is not a computer game this is

this is not a computer game this is people actually playing the game and so

people actually playing the game and so

people actually playing the game and so you can see in this small example that

you can see in this small example that

you can see in this small example that it’s kind of you can kind of understand

it’s kind of you can kind of understand

it’s kind of you can kind of understand what’s going on and so in a small group

what’s going on and so in a small group

what’s going on and so in a small group with this little amount of information

with this little amount of information

with this little amount of information it’s actually easy to form a rectangle

it’s actually easy to form a rectangle

it’s actually easy to form a rectangle but now I’m going to show you what it

but now I’m going to show you what it

but now I’m going to show you what it looks like in a larger group but to give

looks like in a larger group but to give

looks like in a larger group but to give you a better understanding of what that

you a better understanding of what that

you a better understanding of what that looks like I’m gonna show it to you from

looks like I’m gonna show it to you from

looks like I’m gonna show it to you from it

it

it overhead view so you can see all the

overhead view so you can see all the

overhead view so you can see all the players know that the players here only

players know that the players here only

players know that the players here only see that small circle around them as

see that small circle around them as

see that small circle around them as well so we ask these players to also

well so we ask these players to also

well so we ask these players to also form a rectangle and so in the beginning

form a rectangle and so in the beginning

form a rectangle and so in the beginning what happens is because people can’t see

what happens is because people can’t see

what happens is because people can’t see each other they start forming rectangles

each other they start forming rectangles

each other they start forming rectangles in different locations and eventually

in different locations and eventually

in different locations and eventually one guy in the large group in the center

one guy in the large group in the center

one guy in the large group in the center figures out there aren’t enough people

figures out there aren’t enough people

figures out there aren’t enough people there will try to go out and find two

there will try to go out and find two

there will try to go out and find two other people but doesn’t go far enough

other people but doesn’t go far enough

other people but doesn’t go far enough someone from the other group does the

someone from the other group does the

someone from the other group does the same thing goes far enough I’m not as

same thing goes far enough I’m not as

same thing goes far enough I’m not as able to actually go back and recruit the

able to actually go back and recruit the

able to actually go back and recruit the other players using motion alone no

other players using motion alone no

other players using motion alone no communication just motion and so people

communication just motion and so people

communication just motion and so people played a game very differently so some

played a game very differently so some

played a game very differently so some of them form groups some of them are

of them form groups some of them are

of them form groups some of them are passive some of them are active some of

passive some of them are active some of

passive some of them are active some of them are explorers and all these

them are explorers and all these

them are explorers and all these different personalities combined to make

different personalities combined to make

different personalities combined to make the game actually work and so from this

the game actually work and so from this

the game actually work and so from this game we’re learning how humans

game we’re learning how humans

game we’re learning how humans coordinate on these kinds of tasks so

coordinate on these kinds of tasks so

coordinate on these kinds of tasks so that we can better apply this to robots

that we can better apply this to robots

that we can better apply this to robots you might be asking me couldn’t I just

you might be asking me couldn’t I just

you might be asking me couldn’t I just come up with a controller that would get

come up with a controller that would get

come up with a controller that would get the robots to form a perfect rectangle

the robots to form a perfect rectangle

the robots to form a perfect rectangle every time the answer is yes just like

every time the answer is yes just like

every time the answer is yes just like if I could train a team of aerial robots

if I could train a team of aerial robots

if I could train a team of aerial robots to search the same exact building that’s

to search the same exact building that’s

to search the same exact building that’s collapsed after an earthquake and they’d

collapsed after an earthquake and they’d

collapsed after an earthquake and they’d be perfect at it every time but change

be perfect at it every time but change

be perfect at it every time but change that building change the location change

that building change the location change

that building change the location change the materials it’s not gonna work

the materials it’s not gonna work

the materials it’s not gonna work and this is why diversity is necessary

and this is why diversity is necessary

and this is why diversity is necessary we need to take different solutions and

we need to take different solutions and

we need to take different solutions and combine them so if we have robots that

combine them so if we have robots that

combine them so if we have robots that are trained on different kinds of

are trained on different kinds of

are trained on different kinds of buildings then one of them is bound to

buildings then one of them is bound to

buildings then one of them is bound to work and the others can learn from that

work and the others can learn from that

work and the others can learn from that one so instead of taking our problem and

one so instead of taking our problem and

one so instead of taking our problem and making a set of assumptions and applying

making a set of assumptions and applying

making a set of assumptions and applying it to all of our robots instead we

it to all of our robots instead we

it to all of our robots instead we should come up with different solutions

should come up with different solutions

should come up with different solutions that have different strengths combined

that have different strengths combined

that have different strengths combined the best ones and use those on the team

the best ones and use those on the team

the best ones and use those on the team of robots this way if one of them fails

of robots this way if one of them fails

of robots this way if one of them fails they can actually learn from the others

they can actually learn from the others

they can actually learn from the others and

this actually goes well beyond just

this actually goes well beyond just having robots form circles and

having robots form circles and

having robots form circles and rectangles diversity is extremely

rectangles diversity is extremely

rectangles diversity is extremely important and what we’re learning

important and what we’re learning

important and what we’re learning through this game is how diversity works

through this game is how diversity works

through this game is how diversity works by studying how humans use it and so

by studying how humans use it and so

by studying how humans use it and so with this information we can actually

with this information we can actually

with this information we can actually learn how much diversity is necessary

learn how much diversity is necessary

learn how much diversity is necessary and whether it’s different for different

and whether it’s different for different

and whether it’s different for different tasks so that we can take robots out of

tasks so that we can take robots out of

tasks so that we can take robots out of our labs and warehouses and

our labs and warehouses and

our labs and warehouses and manufacturing facilities and put them in

manufacturing facilities and put them in

manufacturing facilities and put them in these complex environments like search

these complex environments like search

these complex environments like search and rescue or any kind of outdoor

and rescue or any kind of outdoor

and rescue or any kind of outdoor example so imagine in a developing

example so imagine in a developing

example so imagine in a developing country after a natural disaster that a

country after a natural disaster that a

country after a natural disaster that a local first response team can deploy a

local first response team can deploy a

local first response team can deploy a team of aerial drones to search for

team of aerial drones to search for

team of aerial drones to search for survivors and tell them where to go

survivors and tell them where to go

survivors and tell them where to go those hours or minutes

those hours or minutes

those hours or minutes even than it saves can help us change

even than it saves can help us change

even than it saves can help us change this to statistics dramatically but this

this to statistics dramatically but this

this to statistics dramatically but this goes well beyond search and rescue

goes well beyond search and rescue

goes well beyond search and rescue having teams of robots that can take

having teams of robots that can take

having teams of robots that can take advantage of diversity will allow us to

advantage of diversity will allow us to

advantage of diversity will allow us to do deep-sea exploration they’ll allow us

do deep-sea exploration they’ll allow us

do deep-sea exploration they’ll allow us to monitor our aging infrastructure and

to monitor our aging infrastructure and

to monitor our aging infrastructure and even take teams of robots to space the

even take teams of robots to space the

even take teams of robots to space the sky is the limit as the late Maya

sky is the limit as the late Maya

sky is the limit as the late Maya Angelou said in diversity there’s beauty

Angelou said in diversity there’s beauty

Angelou said in diversity there’s beauty and their strength our differences or

and their strength our differences or

and their strength our differences or make us unique and will make us valuable

make us unique and will make us valuable

make us unique and will make us valuable and we need to embrace that let’s teach

and we need to embrace that let’s teach

and we need to embrace that let’s teach our robots to do the same thing so that

our robots to do the same thing so that

our robots to do the same thing so that together we can change the statistics

together we can change the statistics

together we can change the statistics thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *