Press "Enter" to skip to content

Strengthening Debates by Strengthening your Opponent | Elisabeth Gniosdorsch | TEDxFrankfurt


[Applause]

[Applause] after high school I was like so many

after high school I was like so many

after high school I was like so many others convinced that I could change the

others convinced that I could change the

others convinced that I could change the world so I thought I would be the one to

world so I thought I would be the one to

world so I thought I would be the one to stop bad people doing bad things and to

stop bad people doing bad things and to

stop bad people doing bad things and to help good people doing good things and

help good people doing good things and

help good people doing good things and so I went to law school in Berlin and in

so I went to law school in Berlin and in

so I went to law school in Berlin and in my first week I discovered something

my first week I discovered something

my first week I discovered something that’s called a debating society and I

that’s called a debating society and I

that’s called a debating society and I thought well for my work of saving the

thought well for my work of saving the

thought well for my work of saving the world obviously learning how to speak in

world obviously learning how to speak in

world obviously learning how to speak in front of people and arguing a case is a

front of people and arguing a case is a

front of people and arguing a case is a good skill so I went there and they had

good skill so I went there and they had

good skill so I went there and they had a beginner’s program they organized all

a beginner’s program they organized all

a beginner’s program they organized all of us in groups and they gave us mentors

of us in groups and they gave us mentors

of us in groups and they gave us mentors and they taught us the principle of

and they taught us the principle of

and they taught us the principle of debate so a debate is different from a

debate so a debate is different from a

debate so a debate is different from a discussion because it follows clear

discussion because it follows clear

discussion because it follows clear rules in a debate usually you have eight

rules in a debate usually you have eight

rules in a debate usually you have eight people four on each side and you don’t

people four on each side and you don’t

people four on each side and you don’t know what you’re talking about what the

know what you’re talking about what the

know what you’re talking about what the debate is going to be about until

debate is going to be about until

debate is going to be about until shortly beforehand also you will be

shortly beforehand also you will be

shortly beforehand also you will be allocated aside so you cannot choose

allocated aside so you cannot choose

allocated aside so you cannot choose whether you want to argue for or against

whether you want to argue for or against

whether you want to argue for or against the topic another principle of debating

the topic another principle of debating

the topic another principle of debating is called rebuttal rebuttal means that

is called rebuttal rebuttal means that

is called rebuttal rebuttal means that you have to answer to your opponent’s

you have to answer to your opponent’s

you have to answer to your opponent’s arguments and explain what your

arguments and explain what your

arguments and explain what your arguments are actually better so one of

arguments are actually better so one of

arguments are actually better so one of my mentors johannes he used to call it

my mentors johannes he used to call it

my mentors johannes he used to call it repelling like fighting back the whole

repelling like fighting back the whole

repelling like fighting back the whole concept of rebuttal and to be honest

concept of rebuttal and to be honest

concept of rebuttal and to be honest this is what I did in the beginning I

this is what I did in the beginning I

this is what I did in the beginning I felt good I felt witty I felt funny and

felt good I felt witty I felt funny and

felt good I felt witty I felt funny and I used to look for the mistakes my

I used to look for the mistakes my

I used to look for the mistakes my opponents made and used that for my

opponents made and used that for my

opponents made and used that for my advantage and I worked out quite well in

advantage and I worked out quite well in

advantage and I worked out quite well in the beginning but then the beginner’s

the beginning but then the beginner’s

the beginning but then the beginner’s phrase ended we were mixed with the more

phrase ended we were mixed with the more

phrase ended we were mixed with the more experienced debaters and they all were

experienced debaters and they all were

experienced debaters and they all were better speakers than I was they were

better speakers than I was they were

better speakers than I was they were funnier than I was they had better

funnier than I was they had better

funnier than I was they had better arguments that I had so it was really

arguments that I had so it was really

arguments that I had so it was really frustrating because

frustrating because

frustrating because apparently looking for your opponent’s

apparently looking for your opponent’s

apparently looking for your opponent’s weakest spots only works until you meet

weakest spots only works until you meet

weakest spots only works until you meet someone who is stronger than you are

someone who is stronger than you are

someone who is stronger than you are who is whittier than you are who’s

who is whittier than you are who’s

who is whittier than you are who’s funnier than you are or who’s just

funnier than you are or who’s just

funnier than you are or who’s just louder than you are and if you meet that

louder than you are and if you meet that

louder than you are and if you meet that person then you need a new strategy so

person then you need a new strategy so

person then you need a new strategy so obviously I needed a new strategy too so

obviously I needed a new strategy too so

obviously I needed a new strategy too so again I went to my mentors and ask them

again I went to my mentors and ask them

again I went to my mentors and ask them so what do I need to do to win a debate

so what do I need to do to win a debate

so what do I need to do to win a debate and they told me you know you always

and they told me you know you always

and they told me you know you always focus on your opponent’s weakest points

focus on your opponent’s weakest points

focus on your opponent’s weakest points but what actually makes you win a debate

but what actually makes you win a debate

but what actually makes you win a debate and what also makes a debate good is if

and what also makes a debate good is if

and what also makes a debate good is if you look for your opponent’s strongest

you look for your opponent’s strongest

you look for your opponent’s strongest points so that’s why I understand that

points so that’s why I understand that

points so that’s why I understand that actually strengthening your opponent

actually strengthening your opponent

actually strengthening your opponent strengthening your opponent’s arguments

strengthening your opponent’s arguments

strengthening your opponent’s arguments it’s also strengthening the debate as a

it’s also strengthening the debate as a

it’s also strengthening the debate as a whole and this is also why I understood

whole and this is also why I understood

whole and this is also why I understood why my other mentor Jude’s

why my other mentor Jude’s

why my other mentor Jude’s she would always insist that it’s called

she would always insist that it’s called

she would always insist that it’s called rebuttal it’s about answering it’s about

rebuttal it’s about answering it’s about

rebuttal it’s about answering it’s about engaging it’s not about fighting back so

engaging it’s not about fighting back so

engaging it’s not about fighting back so I felt I needed to practice that and I

I felt I needed to practice that and I

I felt I needed to practice that and I went on my first few tournaments one of

went on my first few tournaments one of

went on my first few tournaments one of my first tournaments was in Cambridge I

my first tournaments was in Cambridge I

my first tournaments was in Cambridge I was in my first year my debating partner

was in my first year my debating partner

was in my first year my debating partner was also the beginner and we were in a

was also the beginner and we were in a

was also the beginner and we were in a debate with a team from Oxford a team

debate with a team from Oxford a team

debate with a team from Oxford a team from Cambridge and the team from

from Cambridge and the team from

from Cambridge and the team from Princeton I was really intimidated

Princeton I was really intimidated

Princeton I was really intimidated I felt that I hardly understood half of

I felt that I hardly understood half of

I felt that I hardly understood half of what they were saying they were speaking

what they were saying they were speaking

what they were saying they were speaking really fast and I thought they had each

really fast and I thought they had each

really fast and I thought they had each about 1000 arguments and I had maybe

about 1000 arguments and I had maybe

about 1000 arguments and I had maybe half an argument but what they actually

half an argument but what they actually

half an argument but what they actually did was listen and all they cared about

did was listen and all they cared about

did was listen and all they cared about was my argument they didn’t care that I

was my argument they didn’t care that I

was my argument they didn’t care that I was a beginner

was a beginner

was a beginner they wouldn’t have cared if I was the

they wouldn’t have cared if I was the

they wouldn’t have cared if I was the President of the United States they only

President of the United States they only

President of the United States they only cared about my argument so this actually

cared about my argument so this actually

cared about my argument so this actually encouraged me because I felt respected

encouraged me because I felt respected

encouraged me because I felt respected and I felt included and I felt like I

and I felt included and I felt like I

and I felt included and I felt like I could continue

could continue

could continue working on myself and it also showed me

working on myself and it also showed me

working on myself and it also showed me that strengthening your opponent’s

that strengthening your opponent’s

that strengthening your opponent’s arguments strengthens a debate on a

arguments strengthens a debate on a

arguments strengthens a debate on a personal and on an argumentative level

personal and on an argumentative level

personal and on an argumentative level on a personal level I think we all know

on a personal level I think we all know

on a personal level I think we all know this feeling we all know this we have

this feeling we all know this we have

this feeling we all know this we have this experience if I make you feel bad

this experience if I make you feel bad

this experience if I make you feel bad or if I make you feel stupid then you

or if I make you feel stupid then you

or if I make you feel stupid then you will probably not want to talk to me

will probably not want to talk to me

will probably not want to talk to me again or if you do talk to me again

again or if you do talk to me again

again or if you do talk to me again maybe you want to make me feel stupid or

maybe you want to make me feel stupid or

maybe you want to make me feel stupid or bad in return or maybe you get angry or

bad in return or maybe you get angry or

bad in return or maybe you get angry or you get aggressive or maybe you take

you get aggressive or maybe you take

you get aggressive or maybe you take your frustration and want to focus it on

your frustration and want to focus it on

your frustration and want to focus it on someone else all I do is create a cycle

someone else all I do is create a cycle

someone else all I do is create a cycle of frustration but if I do take you

of frustration but if I do take you

of frustration but if I do take you seriously even if I disagree with

seriously even if I disagree with

seriously even if I disagree with everything you’re saying then we can

everything you’re saying then we can

everything you’re saying then we can keep talking I mean and we can keep

keep talking I mean and we can keep

keep talking I mean and we can keep talking about arguments strengthening

talking about arguments strengthening

talking about arguments strengthening your opponent’s points and taking them

your opponent’s points and taking them

your opponent’s points and taking them seriously is also important on an

seriously is also important on an

seriously is also important on an argumentative level because if you match

argumentative level because if you match

argumentative level because if you match your own arguments your own opinions

your own arguments your own opinions

your own arguments your own opinions against the strongest points of your

against the strongest points of your

against the strongest points of your opponent this means that your points

opponent this means that your points

opponent this means that your points need to be really strong too if you

need to be really strong too if you

need to be really strong too if you don’t do that if you’re just looking for

don’t do that if you’re just looking for

don’t do that if you’re just looking for weaknesses then it’s easy to just come

weaknesses then it’s easy to just come

weaknesses then it’s easy to just come up with some nice words something that

up with some nice words something that

up with some nice words something that people are agree on but if you have to

people are agree on but if you have to

people are agree on but if you have to test it from all angles because you want

test it from all angles because you want

test it from all angles because you want it to be really strong against your

it to be really strong against your

it to be really strong against your opponent’s arguments and it has to be a

opponent’s arguments and it has to be a

opponent’s arguments and it has to be a really good argument and you have to

really good argument and you have to

really good argument and you have to reflect upon your own argument and think

reflect upon your own argument and think

reflect upon your own argument and think about what the other person is going to

about what the other person is going to

about what the other person is going to do and going to say in return so

do and going to say in return so

do and going to say in return so strengthening the Bates rebuttal in and

strengthening the Bates rebuttal in and

strengthening the Bates rebuttal in and not be battling this is something that’s

not be battling this is something that’s

not be battling this is something that’s important also outside of debate land I

important also outside of debate land I

important also outside of debate land I think right now we are seeing that there

think right now we are seeing that there

think right now we are seeing that there is a lot of frustration out there in the

is a lot of frustration out there in the

is a lot of frustration out there in the world this is changing the political

world this is changing the political

world this is changing the political discourse we have presidents who are

discourse we have presidents who are

discourse we have presidents who are calling each other fads or olds we have

calling each other fads or olds we have

calling each other fads or olds we have people who are marching this

people who are marching this

people who are marching this deeds of capitals with torches we have

deeds of capitals with torches we have

deeds of capitals with torches we have campaigns for more walls more borders

campaigns for more walls more borders

campaigns for more walls more borders less communication and I don’t agree

less communication and I don’t agree

less communication and I don’t agree with any of that and I don’t support it

with any of that and I don’t support it

with any of that and I don’t support it and I totally understand if you’re too

and I totally understand if you’re too

and I totally understand if you’re too exhausted to answer if you’re too if

exhausted to answer if you’re too if

exhausted to answer if you’re too if it’s too hurtful for you but ignoring

it’s too hurtful for you but ignoring

it’s too hurtful for you but ignoring these people ignoring these trends it’s

these people ignoring these trends it’s

these people ignoring these trends it’s not gonna make them go away ignoring

not gonna make them go away ignoring

not gonna make them go away ignoring them is only going to create a breeding

them is only going to create a breeding

them is only going to create a breeding ground for extremism for fundamentalism

ground for extremism for fundamentalism

ground for extremism for fundamentalism for radicalization on every level not

for radicalization on every level not

for radicalization on every level not communicating is going to widen the gap

communicating is going to widen the gap

communicating is going to widen the gap within a society and it’s closing doors

within a society and it’s closing doors

within a society and it’s closing doors because the wider the gap the less

because the wider the gap the less

because the wider the gap the less communication there is the less likely

communication there is the less likely

communication there is the less likely it is that we can start engaging with

it is that we can start engaging with

it is that we can start engaging with each other again that we can close the

each other again that we can close the

each other again that we can close the gaps that we can move on we progressive

gaps that we can move on we progressive

gaps that we can move on we progressive so I would say that we should indeed

so I would say that we should indeed

so I would say that we should indeed keep talking that we should keep on the

keep talking that we should keep on the

keep talking that we should keep on the communication even if it’s exhausting

communication even if it’s exhausting

communication even if it’s exhausting even if it’s frustrating even if it’s

even if it’s frustrating even if it’s

even if it’s frustrating even if it’s sometimes hurtful but we should not make

sometimes hurtful but we should not make

sometimes hurtful but we should not make the same mistake that I made at the

the same mistake that I made at the

the same mistake that I made at the beginning of my debating career we

beginning of my debating career we

beginning of my debating career we should not call them names we should not

should not call them names we should not

should not call them names we should not look for their weakest spot we should

look for their weakest spot we should

look for their weakest spot we should not try to find the meanest tweet that

not try to find the meanest tweet that

not try to find the meanest tweet that we can send out and feel Whitney and

we can send out and feel Whitney and

we can send out and feel Whitney and feel funny about ourselves because

feel funny about ourselves because

feel funny about ourselves because that’s not gonna make them change maybe

that’s not gonna make them change maybe

that’s not gonna make them change maybe if we are looking for the core of their

if we are looking for the core of their

if we are looking for the core of their argument if we test it from all angles

argument if we test it from all angles

argument if we test it from all angles if we engage with that maybe that’s not

if we engage with that maybe that’s not

if we engage with that maybe that’s not going to change them either but if we do

going to change them either but if we do

going to change them either but if we do that it’s going to do some things for

that it’s going to do some things for

that it’s going to do some things for sure it’s going to keep up the

sure it’s going to keep up the

sure it’s going to keep up the communication it is going to create an

communication it is going to create an

communication it is going to create an alternative to an aggressive environment

alternative to an aggressive environment

alternative to an aggressive environment and it is going to strengthen your own

and it is going to strengthen your own

and it is going to strengthen your own arguments your own criticism and it’s

arguments your own criticism and it’s

arguments your own criticism and it’s going to make it more reflective so

going to make it more reflective so

going to make it more reflective so I went to law school because I thought I

I went to law school because I thought I

I went to law school because I thought I could change the world well now I study

could change the world well now I study

could change the world well now I study politics no but I think that respectful

politics no but I think that respectful

politics no but I think that respectful communication that leaves doors open

communication that leaves doors open

communication that leaves doors open that is on an argumentative level this

that is on an argumentative level this

that is on an argumentative level this is something that could truly change the

is something that could truly change the

is something that could truly change the world and make the world a better place

world and make the world a better place

world and make the world a better place thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *