Press "Enter" to skip to content

Some Students Left Behind | Eli Wachs | TEDxLynbrookHighSchool


Nelson Mandela once said the education

Nelson Mandela once said the education is the most powerful weapon with which

is the most powerful weapon with which

is the most powerful weapon with which you can use to change the world but I

you can use to change the world but I

you can use to change the world but I probably don’t have to quote a famous

probably don’t have to quote a famous

probably don’t have to quote a famous figure for you to know the importance of

figure for you to know the importance of

figure for you to know the importance of Education our most formative years the

Education our most formative years the

Education our most formative years the years in which our brains developed the

years in which our brains developed the

years in which our brains developed the most are spent in schools should come as

most are spent in schools should come as

most are spent in schools should come as no surprise that education is the most

no surprise that education is the most

no surprise that education is the most impactful body on one’s life and if one

impactful body on one’s life and if one

impactful body on one’s life and if one were to look up how America is doing at

were to look up how America is doing at

were to look up how America is doing at education today they would likely see

education today they would likely see

education today they would likely see that where around the middle of the pack

that where around the middle of the pack

that where around the middle of the pack of the world

of the world

of the world placing around 30th on the Pisa test

placing around 30th on the Pisa test

placing around 30th on the Pisa test which is generally considered to be the

which is generally considered to be the

which is generally considered to be the most holistic measure on worldwide

most holistic measure on worldwide

most holistic measure on worldwide education standards however this

education standards however this

education standards however this statistic is deeply misleading a deeper

statistic is deeply misleading a deeper

statistic is deeply misleading a deeper dive reveals that American schools and

dive reveals that American schools and

dive reveals that American schools and areas in which poverty is less than 10%

areas in which poverty is less than 10%

areas in which poverty is less than 10% have scores which ranked first in the

have scores which ranked first in the

have scores which ranked first in the world in that test meanwhile schools in

world in that test meanwhile schools in

world in that test meanwhile schools in which poverty is greater than 75% or our

which poverty is greater than 75% or our

which poverty is greater than 75% or our bottom fifth of schools have scores on

bottom fifth of schools have scores on

bottom fifth of schools have scores on par with those developing countries do

par with those developing countries do

par with those developing countries do the centuries of systemic racism which

the centuries of systemic racism which

the centuries of systemic racism which closely linked housing segregation and a

closely linked housing segregation and a

closely linked housing segregation and a biased criminal justice system to

biased criminal justice system to

biased criminal justice system to education students in those schools with

education students in those schools with

education students in those schools with less than 10% poverty are almost fully

less than 10% poverty are almost fully

less than 10% poverty are almost fully white while school students in those

white while school students in those

white while school students in those bottom fifth of schools are almost fully

bottom fifth of schools are almost fully

bottom fifth of schools are almost fully black or students of color startlingly

black or students of color startlingly

black or students of color startlingly our schools today are more segregated

our schools today are more segregated

our schools today are more segregated than they were when Martin Luther King

than they were when Martin Luther King

than they were when Martin Luther King jr. died some four decades ago the

jr. died some four decades ago the

jr. died some four decades ago the courses talk I’ll explain how this

courses talk I’ll explain how this

courses talk I’ll explain how this resegregate schools has occurred the

resegregate schools has occurred the

resegregate schools has occurred the immensely beneficial impact integrated

immensely beneficial impact integrated

immensely beneficial impact integrated schooling can have on students and ways

schooling can have on students and ways

schooling can have on students and ways in which we can reintegrate our schools

in which we can reintegrate our schools

in which we can reintegrate our schools the landmark 1954 Brown versus Board of

the landmark 1954 Brown versus Board of

the landmark 1954 Brown versus Board of Education Supreme Court decision took

Education Supreme Court decision took

Education Supreme Court decision took nearly two decades to change schooling

nearly two decades to change schooling

nearly two decades to change schooling in the south and a little to change

in the south and a little to change

in the south and a little to change schooling in the north in a decade

schooling in the north in a decade

schooling in the north in a decade following the decision only one percent

following the decision only one percent

following the decision only one percent of black students in the South attended

of black students in the South attended

of black students in the South attended an integrated school meanwhile because

an integrated school meanwhile because

an integrated school meanwhile because laws after the decision solely sought to

laws after the decision solely sought to

laws after the decision solely sought to break up laws which specifically

break up laws which specifically

break up laws which specifically segregated schools they did a little to

segregated schools they did a little to

segregated schools they did a little to address the more there’s your type of

address the more there’s your type of

address the more there’s your type of school segregation the north which was

school segregation the north which was

school segregation the north which was more so rooted in red line housing

more so rooted in red line housing

more so rooted in red line housing segregation therefore little efforts to

segregation therefore little efforts to

segregation therefore little efforts to integrate

integrate

integrate were taken in the north which remains

were taken in the north which remains

were taken in the north which remains most integrated area of schooling in the

most integrated area of schooling in the

most integrated area of schooling in the country to this day nonetheless more

country to this day nonetheless more

country to this day nonetheless more supreme and Circuit Court decisions in

supreme and Circuit Court decisions in

supreme and Circuit Court decisions in the 70s mandated busing in the south

the 70s mandated busing in the south

the 70s mandated busing in the south that integrated schools and so dramatic

that integrated schools and so dramatic

that integrated schools and so dramatic strides were made so let’s look at the

strides were made so let’s look at the

strides were made so let’s look at the impact of some of these dramatic strides

impact of some of these dramatic strides

impact of some of these dramatic strides do the mandated busing to integrate

do the mandated busing to integrate

do the mandated busing to integrate schools there’s a growing body of

schools there’s a growing body of

schools there’s a growing body of research in this field with perhaps the

research in this field with perhaps the

research in this field with perhaps the most comprehensive study being out of

most comprehensive study being out of

most comprehensive study being out of Berkeley professor Rucker Johnson in

Berkeley professor Rucker Johnson in

Berkeley professor Rucker Johnson in 2015 the study found the average per

2015 the study found the average per

2015 the study found the average per pupil spending on black students who

pupil spending on black students who

pupil spending on black students who went to an integrated school went up

went to an integrated school went up

went to an integrated school went up 22.5% that each year of black students

22.5% that each year of black students

22.5% that each year of black students spent in an integrated school the

spent in an integrated school the

spent in an integrated school the likelihood that they would graduate went

likelihood that they would graduate went

likelihood that they would graduate went up 1.8% and that black students who went

up 1.8% and that black students who went

up 1.8% and that black students who went to integrated schools were 22 percent

to integrated schools were 22 percent

to integrated schools were 22 percent less likely to be incarcerated in life

less likely to be incarcerated in life

less likely to be incarcerated in life further the education gap in his country

further the education gap in his country

further the education gap in his country between blacks and whites is roughly

between blacks and whites is roughly

between blacks and whites is roughly equivalent to a year the study found

equivalent to a year the study found

equivalent to a year the study found that for each year of black students

that for each year of black students

that for each year of black students spent in an integrated school they

spent in an integrated school they

spent in an integrated school they gained an additional 0.1 years of

gained an additional 0.1 years of

gained an additional 0.1 years of schooling meaning that if a black

schooling meaning that if a black

schooling meaning that if a black student spent say 12 years in an

student spent say 12 years in an

student spent say 12 years in an integrated school they would more than

integrated school they would more than

integrated school they would more than make up the education gap on a whole the

make up the education gap on a whole the

make up the education gap on a whole the study found the quote the average

study found the quote the average

study found the quote the average effects of a five year exposure to

effects of a five year exposure to

effects of a five year exposure to court-ordered school desegregation led

court-ordered school desegregation led

court-ordered school desegregation led to an 11 percentage point decline in the

to an 11 percentage point decline in the

to an 11 percentage point decline in the average annual instance of poverty in

average annual instance of poverty in

average annual instance of poverty in adulthood and a 25 percent increase in

adulthood and a 25 percent increase in

adulthood and a 25 percent increase in annual family income and this study as

annual family income and this study as

annual family income and this study as well as others found integrated

well as others found integrated

well as others found integrated schooling had no negative impact on

schooling had no negative impact on

schooling had no negative impact on white students yet rather a neutral a

white students yet rather a neutral a

white students yet rather a neutral a positive one to better understand how

positive one to better understand how

positive one to better understand how integration occurs and the ways in which

integration occurs and the ways in which

integration occurs and the ways in which it has been gutted in the past 20 years

it has been gutted in the past 20 years

it has been gutted in the past 20 years it’s worth looking at a few examples

it’s worth looking at a few examples

it’s worth looking at a few examples Charlotte specifically West Charlotte

Charlotte specifically West Charlotte

Charlotte specifically West Charlotte high school was once seen as a model

high school was once seen as a model

high school was once seen as a model example for integration in the country

example for integration in the country

example for integration in the country this was due to a 1971 Court decision

this was due to a 1971 Court decision

this was due to a 1971 Court decision Swann verse charlotte-mecklenburg Board

Swann verse charlotte-mecklenburg Board

Swann verse charlotte-mecklenburg Board of Education which mandated busing to

of Education which mandated busing to

of Education which mandated busing to use race-based busing to integrate

use race-based busing to integrate

use race-based busing to integrate students across district lines soon West

students across district lines soon West

students across district lines soon West Charlotte high school was 40% black and

Charlotte high school was 40% black and

Charlotte high school was 40% black and 60% white

60% white

60% white meanwhile in the 1988 through 89 school

meanwhile in the 1988 through 89 school

meanwhile in the 1988 through 89 school year just one and three percent of

year just one and three percent of

year just one and three percent of Latino and black students respectively

Latino and black students respectively

Latino and black students respectively in Charlotte attended 90 plus percent

in Charlotte attended 90 plus percent

in Charlotte attended 90 plus percent minority schools flash forward to the

minority schools flash forward to the

minority schools flash forward to the day however due to a 1997 lawsuit which

day however due to a 1997 lawsuit which

day however due to a 1997 lawsuit which overturned that 71 ruling and white

overturned that 71 ruling and white

overturned that 71 ruling and white flight those numbers look quite

flight those numbers look quite

flight those numbers look quite different in fact today West Charlotte

different in fact today West Charlotte

different in fact today West Charlotte High School is 88% black and just 1%

High School is 88% black and just 1%

High School is 88% black and just 1% white meanwhile 44 and 47 percent of

white meanwhile 44 and 47 percent of

white meanwhile 44 and 47 percent of Latino and black students respectively

Latino and black students respectively

Latino and black students respectively attend those 90 plus percent minority

attend those 90 plus percent minority

attend those 90 plus percent minority schools in 2013 the New York Times

schools in 2013 the New York Times

schools in 2013 the New York Times reported that two-thirds of school

reported that two-thirds of school

reported that two-thirds of school districts originally under court order

districts originally under court order

districts originally under court order the inter eighth were no longer required

the inter eighth were no longer required

the inter eighth were no longer required to do so and are no longer doing so the

to do so and are no longer doing so the

to do so and are no longer doing so the number of apartheid schools schools in

number of apartheid schools schools in

number of apartheid schools schools in which the white student population is

which the white student population is

which the white student population is less than one percent verse from 2762

less than one percent verse from 2762

less than one percent verse from 2762 1988 to six thousand seven hundred and

1988 to six thousand seven hundred and

1988 to six thousand seven hundred and twenty seven and twenty eleven a

twenty seven and twenty eleven a

twenty seven and twenty eleven a startling number Baton Rouge like

startling number Baton Rouge like

startling number Baton Rouge like Charlotte had a similarly successful

Charlotte had a similarly successful

Charlotte had a similarly successful integration program based in busing

integration program based in busing

integration program based in busing before it was ended by 1991 court

before it was ended by 1991 court

before it was ended by 1991 court decision this was further compounded by

decision this was further compounded by

decision this was further compounded by white middle class movement which sought

white middle class movement which sought

white middle class movement which sought to create a new district of the city

to create a new district of the city

to create a new district of the city which would just so happened to be 70%

which would just so happened to be 70%

which would just so happened to be 70% white according to a PBS Frontline

white according to a PBS Frontline

white according to a PBS Frontline documentary further this new district

documentary further this new district

documentary further this new district would just so happen to have most of the

would just so happen to have most of the

would just so happen to have most of the AP and honor schools from the original

AP and honor schools from the original

AP and honor schools from the original district and efforts like these that

district and efforts like these that

district and efforts like these that have greatly dismantled the very nice

have greatly dismantled the very nice

have greatly dismantled the very nice strides the country made in school

strides the country made in school

strides the country made in school integration the 70s 80s and early 90s

integration the 70s 80s and early 90s

integration the 70s 80s and early 90s so with courts making it quite onerous

so with courts making it quite onerous

so with courts making it quite onerous or even impossible for school districts

or even impossible for school districts

or even impossible for school districts to use race as a basis for busing to

to use race as a basis for busing to

to use race as a basis for busing to integrate districts which risk to remain

integrate districts which risk to remain

integrate districts which risk to remain integrated had to get creative the most

integrated had to get creative the most

integrated had to get creative the most popular choice has been voluntary

popular choice has been voluntary

popular choice has been voluntary programs in which minority students can

programs in which minority students can

programs in which minority students can enroll to be bused to more white better

enroll to be bused to more white better

enroll to be bused to more white better resourced areas this program is perhaps

resourced areas this program is perhaps

resourced areas this program is perhaps most well known in Boston the NPR

most well known in Boston the NPR

most well known in Boston the NPR reports that only 33 hundred students

reports that only 33 hundred students

reports that only 33 hundred students enroll in it each year perhaps

enroll in it each year perhaps

enroll in it each year perhaps unsurprisingly though given what we have

unsurprisingly though given what we have

unsurprisingly though given what we have discussed 90 percent of the students in

discussed 90 percent of the students in

discussed 90 percent of the students in that fervor

that fervor

that fervor go on to graduate high school on time

go on to graduate high school on time

go on to graduate high school on time with higher state achievement test

with higher state achievement test

with higher state achievement test scores than their peers at other Boston

scores than their peers at other Boston

scores than their peers at other Boston area public high schools nearby this

area public high schools nearby this

area public high schools nearby this talk in San Jose the tinsley transfer

talk in San Jose the tinsley transfer

talk in San Jose the tinsley transfer program allows for students from

program allows for students from

program allows for students from Ravenswood City School District to

Ravenswood City School District to

Ravenswood City School District to transfer to the nearby better resource

transfer to the nearby better resource

transfer to the nearby better resource Redwood City or Palo Alto districts

Redwood City or Palo Alto districts

Redwood City or Palo Alto districts however the program only accepts 166

however the program only accepts 166

however the program only accepts 166 students each year the problem with

students each year the problem with

students each year the problem with these voluntary transfer programs aside

these voluntary transfer programs aside

these voluntary transfer programs aside from the main one that most school

from the main one that most school

from the main one that most school districts originally under court order

districts originally under court order

districts originally under court order to integrate don’t even offer them is

to integrate don’t even offer them is

to integrate don’t even offer them is that they put the onus on minority

that they put the onus on minority

that they put the onus on minority students to travel the extra distance in

students to travel the extra distance in

students to travel the extra distance in order to integrate so we know that

order to integrate so we know that

order to integrate so we know that integrating schools can dramatically

integrating schools can dramatically

integrating schools can dramatically change the lives for minority students

change the lives for minority students

change the lives for minority students we also need it through court decisions

we also need it through court decisions

we also need it through court decisions in the 90s and early 2000s many

in the 90s and early 2000s many

in the 90s and early 2000s many districts are unable to do those pro to

districts are unable to do those pro to

districts are unable to do those pro to do those programs to integrate so what

do those programs to integrate so what

do those programs to integrate so what can we do one proposals put well

can we do one proposals put well

can we do one proposals put well resourced magnet schools in minority

resourced magnet schools in minority

resourced magnet schools in minority areas as a drawl for a diverse set of

areas as a drawl for a diverse set of

areas as a drawl for a diverse set of applicants another is to put affordable

applicants another is to put affordable

applicants another is to put affordable housing in high-income areas yet while

housing in high-income areas yet while

housing in high-income areas yet while both of these proposals are nice and may

both of these proposals are nice and may

both of these proposals are nice and may work in a sample they don’t address the

work in a sample they don’t address the

work in a sample they don’t address the real root of the problem districting as

real root of the problem districting as

real root of the problem districting as a Century Foundation discovered between

a Century Foundation discovered between

a Century Foundation discovered between 60 and 70% of school segregation can be

60 and 70% of school segregation can be

60 and 70% of school segregation can be attributed to how students are sorted

attributed to how students are sorted

attributed to how students are sorted across district boundary lines therefore

across district boundary lines therefore

across district boundary lines therefore the foundation reposes that in order for

the foundation reposes that in order for

the foundation reposes that in order for us to undo centuries of systemic racism

us to undo centuries of systemic racism

us to undo centuries of systemic racism decades of schooling and housing

decades of schooling and housing

decades of schooling and housing segregation we must redistricting

segregation we must redistricting

segregation we must redistricting inter-district our cities an example of

inter-district our cities an example of

inter-district our cities an example of this can be found in Louisville a final

this can be found in Louisville a final

this can be found in Louisville a final City worth examining in this talk in

City worth examining in this talk in

City worth examining in this talk in 1975 on the precipice of busing to

1975 on the precipice of busing to

1975 on the precipice of busing to integrate schools in Louisville

integrate schools in Louisville

integrate schools in Louisville ninety-eight percent of white parents

ninety-eight percent of white parents

ninety-eight percent of white parents opposed such a program flash-forward and

opposed such a program flash-forward and

opposed such a program flash-forward and today Louisville’s one of the most

today Louisville’s one of the most

today Louisville’s one of the most integrated school districts in the

integrated school districts in the

integrated school districts in the country in which 89 percent of parents

country in which 89 percent of parents

country in which 89 percent of parents see diversity as desirable compare that

see diversity as desirable compare that

see diversity as desirable compare that to Detroit a district with a very

to Detroit a district with a very

to Detroit a district with a very similar racial makeup and school

similar racial makeup and school

similar racial makeup and school segregation numbers into 60s and 70s the

segregation numbers into 60s and 70s the

segregation numbers into 60s and 70s the difference the 1974 court case Milliken

difference the 1974 court case Milliken

difference the 1974 court case Milliken vers Bradley which halted busing to

vers Bradley which halted busing to

vers Bradley which halted busing to enter

enter

enter great students by race in Detroit the

great students by race in Detroit the

great students by race in Detroit the Atlantic reports that Gary Orfield

Atlantic reports that Gary Orfield

Atlantic reports that Gary Orfield co-founder the Civil Rights Project

co-founder the Civil Rights Project

co-founder the Civil Rights Project found that by 2000 the average black

found that by 2000 the average black

found that by 2000 the average black student in Detroit went to schools less

student in Detroit went to schools less

student in Detroit went to schools less than two percent of white students while

than two percent of white students while

than two percent of white students while the average black student in Louisville

the average black student in Louisville

the average black student in Louisville went to school that was half white

went to school that was half white

went to school that was half white furthermore in 2011 62 percent of

furthermore in 2011 62 percent of

furthermore in 2011 62 percent of Louisville fourth graders could do math

Louisville fourth graders could do math

Louisville fourth graders could do math at or above a fourth-grade level that

at or above a fourth-grade level that

at or above a fourth-grade level that percentage was just half that in Detroit

percentage was just half that in Detroit

percentage was just half that in Detroit is it too much to extrapolate the

is it too much to extrapolate the

is it too much to extrapolate the current financial situation of each city

current financial situation of each city

current financial situation of each city from this Detroit’s coming out of

from this Detroit’s coming out of

from this Detroit’s coming out of bankruptcy while Louisville remains from

bankruptcy while Louisville remains from

bankruptcy while Louisville remains from the lone economic bright spots on the

the lone economic bright spots on the

the lone economic bright spots on the Rust Belt and even in 2007 when the

Rust Belt and even in 2007 when the

Rust Belt and even in 2007 when the supreme court deemed Louisville’s Reid

supreme court deemed Louisville’s Reid

supreme court deemed Louisville’s Reid deem Louisville’s busing by race to

deem Louisville’s busing by race to

deem Louisville’s busing by race to integrate to be unconstitutional the

integrate to be unconstitutional the

integrate to be unconstitutional the city wish to remain integrated so they

city wish to remain integrated so they

city wish to remain integrated so they turned to Orfield designed a complex

turned to Orfield designed a complex

turned to Orfield designed a complex system of city clusters which

system of city clusters which

system of city clusters which essentially inner district of the city

essentially inner district of the city

essentially inner district of the city was essentially voluntary redistricting

was essentially voluntary redistricting

was essentially voluntary redistricting which schools were then composed of a

which schools were then composed of a

which schools were then composed of a mix of minority students students with

mix of minority students students with

mix of minority students students with parents of different educational

parents of different educational

parents of different educational attainments and students who came from

attainments and students who came from

attainments and students who came from homes of different annual income to

homes of different annual income to

homes of different annual income to recap by some metrics our schools are

recap by some metrics our schools are

recap by some metrics our schools are more segregated than they were 40 years

more segregated than they were 40 years

more segregated than they were 40 years ago that’s what the Civil Rights Project

ago that’s what the Civil Rights Project

ago that’s what the Civil Rights Project declared at January 2009 report we also

declared at January 2009 report we also

declared at January 2009 report we also know as rocker Johnson showed the

know as rocker Johnson showed the

know as rocker Johnson showed the integration can the impact of

integration can the impact of

integration can the impact of integration cannot be understated black

integration cannot be understated black

integration cannot be understated black students are more likely to graduate on

students are more likely to graduate on

students are more likely to graduate on time and go on to live healthier more

time and go on to live healthier more

time and go on to live healthier more prosperous lives what students either no

prosperous lives what students either no

prosperous lives what students either no effect or a slight positive one due to

effect or a slight positive one due to

effect or a slight positive one due to court decisions were mostly unable to

court decisions were mostly unable to

court decisions were mostly unable to use race as a basis to bus to integrate

use race as a basis to bus to integrate

use race as a basis to bus to integrate students across districts so we must

students across districts so we must

students across districts so we must look for other ways to get those answers

look for other ways to get those answers

look for other ways to get those answers we know work though not always

we know work though not always

we know work though not always politically expedient Louisville shows

politically expedient Louisville shows

politically expedient Louisville shows that redistricting or inter districting

that redistricting or inter districting

that redistricting or inter districting a city can make integration more

a city can make integration more

a city can make integration more logistical feasible further mandating

logistical feasible further mandating

logistical feasible further mandating busing to integrate districts based on

busing to integrate districts based on

busing to integrate districts based on socioeconomic class as opposed to race

socioeconomic class as opposed to race

socioeconomic class as opposed to race may assist in answering the

may assist in answering the

may assist in answering the same problem without troubling the court

same problem without troubling the court

same problem without troubling the court decisions we just had a black president

decisions we just had a black president

decisions we just had a black president it doesn’t mean it’s time to stop some

it doesn’t mean it’s time to stop some

it doesn’t mean it’s time to stop some very successful programs at mending the

very successful programs at mending the

very successful programs at mending the scars of centuries of poor race

scars of centuries of poor race

scars of centuries of poor race relations in this country rather we must

relations in this country rather we must

relations in this country rather we must continue to strive to make America an

continue to strive to make America an

continue to strive to make America an even more perfect society and in order

even more perfect society and in order

even more perfect society and in order to do so we need all of our students to

to do so we need all of our students to

to do so we need all of our students to be well educated thank you

be well educated thank you

be well educated thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *