Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rules, Games and Corruption | Dominic Spengler | TEDxUniversityofYork


now I’ve seen many tech talks like many

now I’ve seen many tech talks like many of you have and it struck me that very

of you have and it struck me that very

of you have and it struck me that very few of them talk about this sort of

few of them talk about this sort of

few of them talk about this sort of interdisciplinary topics that we discuss

interdisciplinary topics that we discuss

interdisciplinary topics that we discuss like corruption so I want to talk today

like corruption so I want to talk today

like corruption so I want to talk today about rules games and and corruption and

about rules games and and corruption and

about rules games and and corruption and part of that will be the use of game

part of that will be the use of game

part of that will be the use of game theory to analyze corruption as well as

theory to analyze corruption as well as

theory to analyze corruption as well as ethics and perhaps the object of that

ethics and perhaps the object of that

ethics and perhaps the object of that law so let me start by talking about

law so let me start by talking about

law so let me start by talking about rules rules for cooperation there’s much

rules rules for cooperation there’s much

rules rules for cooperation there’s much talk about zero-sum games and non zero

talk about zero-sum games and non zero

talk about zero-sum games and non zero sum games and win-win situations all

sum games and win-win situations all

sum games and win-win situations all that sort of thing so what are these non

that sort of thing so what are these non

that sort of thing so what are these non zero sum or zero-sum game is a thing

zero sum or zero-sum game is a thing

zero sum or zero-sum game is a thing like for example tennis if I score it’s

like for example tennis if I score it’s

like for example tennis if I score it’s good for me and it’s bad for you and if

good for me and it’s bad for you and if

good for me and it’s bad for you and if you score is bad for me and it’s good

you score is bad for me and it’s good

you score is bad for me and it’s good for you and then there are win-win

for you and then there are win-win

for you and then there are win-win situations which you might also call

situations which you might also call

situations which you might also call positive some games which are situations

positive some games which are situations

positive some games which are situations that are good for both of us and people

that are good for both of us and people

that are good for both of us and people kind of relish in in pointing out those

kind of relish in in pointing out those

kind of relish in in pointing out those win-win situations is sort of a thing at

win-win situations is sort of a thing at

win-win situations is sort of a thing at the moment usually followed with some

the moment usually followed with some

the moment usually followed with some kind of triumphant smirk and then we

kind of triumphant smirk and then we

kind of triumphant smirk and then we must also maybe not forget that less

must also maybe not forget that less

must also maybe not forget that less fashionable lose-lose situations which

fashionable lose-lose situations which

fashionable lose-lose situations which are the ones where the outcome is bad

are the ones where the outcome is bad

are the ones where the outcome is bad for both you and me so I want to propose

for both you and me so I want to propose

for both you and me so I want to propose to you that win-win situations are

to you that win-win situations are

to you that win-win situations are actually everywhere abundant when you

actually everywhere abundant when you

actually everywhere abundant when you engage in a trade on eBay for example

engage in a trade on eBay for example

engage in a trade on eBay for example then as a buyer of a good you’ve done

then as a buyer of a good you’ve done

then as a buyer of a good you’ve done that probably of your own volition and

that probably of your own volition and

that probably of your own volition and what you’re buying is a good so it’s

what you’re buying is a good so it’s

what you’re buying is a good so it’s good for you so it’s better for you than

good for you so it’s better for you than

good for you so it’s better for you than the money that you would get in return

the money that you would get in return

the money that you would get in return on the other hand there is a seller and

on the other hand there is a seller and

on the other hand there is a seller and the seller is also better of having

the seller is also better of having

the seller is also better of having engaged in the trade of course because

engaged in the trade of course because

engaged in the trade of course because for him there’s a healthy profit profit

for him there’s a healthy profit profit

for him there’s a healthy profit profit coming from it in otherwise he wouldn’t

coming from it in otherwise he wouldn’t

coming from it in otherwise he wouldn’t have done it

have done it

have done it win-win situations like that actually

win-win situations like that actually

win-win situations like that actually abundant we can find them anywhere

abundant we can find them anywhere

abundant we can find them anywhere so whether you go to the pub for a pint

so whether you go to the pub for a pint

so whether you go to the pub for a pint or you go to the supermarket to buy some

or you go to the supermarket to buy some

or you go to the supermarket to buy some toilet paper

toilet paper

toilet paper all of those are win-win situations I

all of those are win-win situations I

all of those are win-win situations I want to propose to you I want to go a

want to propose to you I want to go a

want to propose to you I want to go a little bit deeper I want to show to you

little bit deeper I want to show to you

little bit deeper I want to show to you why rules are actually important to us

why rules are actually important to us

why rules are actually important to us and why it’s not just about win-win

and why it’s not just about win-win

and why it’s not just about win-win situations now that is the proposal that

situations now that is the proposal that

situations now that is the proposal that rules are in essence what makes us

rules are in essence what makes us

rules are in essence what makes us overcome

overcome

overcome uncertainty and makes transactions

uncertainty and makes transactions

uncertainty and makes transactions between each other cheaper so needless

between each other cheaper so needless

between each other cheaper so needless to say when we think about the

to say when we think about the

to say when we think about the transactions on on ebay for example then

transactions on on ebay for example then

transactions on on ebay for example then the question is why is it possible that

the question is why is it possible that

the question is why is it possible that both of us can trust each other so that

both of us can trust each other so that

both of us can trust each other so that you can why over some money to China and

you can why over some money to China and

you can why over some money to China and at the same time trust that the good

at the same time trust that the good

at the same time trust that the good will be sent across to you how can we

will be sent across to you how can we

will be sent across to you how can we trust in this situation the answer for

trust in this situation the answer for

trust in this situation the answer for this are rules so let’s start like an

this are rules so let’s start like an

this are rules so let’s start like an economists will talk about this in that

economists will talk about this in that

economists will talk about this in that sort of slightly crude fashion imagine a

sort of slightly crude fashion imagine a

sort of slightly crude fashion imagine a world where we don’t have any rules

world where we don’t have any rules

world where we don’t have any rules something like Anarchy for example if

something like Anarchy for example if

something like Anarchy for example if you imagine you are a farmer for example

you imagine you are a farmer for example

you imagine you are a farmer for example in this world and you set about I don’t

in this world and you set about I don’t

in this world and you set about I don’t know growing some crops and storing some

know growing some crops and storing some

know growing some crops and storing some grain then countering is a great deal of

grain then countering is a great deal of

grain then countering is a great deal of uncertainty it’s not so easy to just

uncertainty it’s not so easy to just

uncertainty it’s not so easy to just sell the stuff it’s very expensive

sell the stuff it’s very expensive

sell the stuff it’s very expensive because you have to make sure not just

because you have to make sure not just

because you have to make sure not just to be protected against droughts and

to be protected against droughts and

to be protected against droughts and storms but also against loot and pillage

storms but also against loot and pillage

storms but also against loot and pillage so you can’t trust your neighbour that

so you can’t trust your neighbour that

so you can’t trust your neighbour that you just won’t use violence to take the

you just won’t use violence to take the

you just won’t use violence to take the stuff off of you so it’s best to be

stuff off of you so it’s best to be

stuff off of you so it’s best to be shorter mist and selfish in that

shorter mist and selfish in that

shorter mist and selfish in that situation why is it that we can in fact

situation why is it that we can in fact

situation why is it that we can in fact trust as a farmer to grow our crops or

trust as a farmer to grow our crops or

trust as a farmer to grow our crops or to send the money across the China and

to send the money across the China and

to send the money across the China and so on and so forth it’s because we have

so on and so forth it’s because we have

so on and so forth it’s because we have rules good rules in this case

rules good rules in this case

rules good rules in this case institutions like in this case eBay and

institutions like in this case eBay and

institutions like in this case eBay and PayPal that make it possible for us to

PayPal that make it possible for us to

PayPal that make it possible for us to have these transactions with one another

have these transactions with one another

have these transactions with one another you know as a trader on eBay if you’re a

you know as a trader on eBay if you’re a

you know as a trader on eBay if you’re a seller that if you send the good across

seller that if you send the good across

seller that if you send the good across if you don’t send it

if you don’t send it

if you don’t send it across if you don’t play by the rules

across if you don’t play by the rules

across if you don’t play by the rules that you will lose out you will be

that you will lose out you will be

that you will lose out you will be barred from participation this one means

barred from participation this one means

barred from participation this one means a loss of trade and a loss of income so

a loss of trade and a loss of income so

a loss of trade and a loss of income so in other words people will keep to these

in other words people will keep to these

in other words people will keep to these rules and what we get to is a sort of

rules and what we get to is a sort of

rules and what we get to is a sort of flourishing Society this is what we see

flourishing Society this is what we see

flourishing Society this is what we see all around us institutions good

all around us institutions good

all around us institutions good institutions work for us and make it

institutions work for us and make it

institutions work for us and make it possible that society prospers as we

possible that society prospers as we

possible that society prospers as we look through the centuries until where

look through the centuries until where

look through the centuries until where we are today

we are today

we are today now I mentioned at the beginning

now I mentioned at the beginning

now I mentioned at the beginning corruption so I want to definitely get

corruption so I want to definitely get

corruption so I want to definitely get back to that how do they get to this

back to that how do they get to this

back to that how do they get to this when I was a master student I had just

when I was a master student I had just

when I was a master student I had just quit my job I was working in the IT

quit my job I was working in the IT

quit my job I was working in the IT industry for one of the large

industry for one of the large

industry for one of the large multinational corporations and I found

multinational corporations and I found

multinational corporations and I found myself in a tricky situation where on

myself in a tricky situation where on

myself in a tricky situation where on the one hand I was paid double as much

the one hand I was paid double as much

the one hand I was paid double as much as I’m being paid now which is 10 years

as I’m being paid now which is 10 years

as I’m being paid now which is 10 years down the line on the other hand I was

down the line on the other hand I was

down the line on the other hand I was grappling with the issue of the doctrine

grappling with the issue of the doctrine

grappling with the issue of the doctrine of profit maximization and so on at the

of profit maximization and so on at the

of profit maximization and so on at the time it was the financial crisis this

time it was the financial crisis this

time it was the financial crisis this big company one of the biggest companies

big company one of the biggest companies

big company one of the biggest companies in the world had just laid off twenty

in the world had just laid off twenty

in the world had just laid off twenty five thousand people at the same time

five thousand people at the same time

five thousand people at the same time they paid three and a million dollars to

they paid three and a million dollars to

they paid three and a million dollars to the top five individuals of the company

the top five individuals of the company

the top five individuals of the company I thought I need to study this this is a

I thought I need to study this this is a

I thought I need to study this this is a big conundrum I realized this was hard

big conundrum I realized this was hard

big conundrum I realized this was hard to digest truth that actually it’s very

to digest truth that actually it’s very

to digest truth that actually it’s very hard to find a corporation that makes a

hard to find a corporation that makes a

hard to find a corporation that makes a negative net contribution to society

negative net contribution to society

negative net contribution to society in fact certainly my employer wasn’t one

in fact certainly my employer wasn’t one

in fact certainly my employer wasn’t one of them

of them

of them the numbers I told you are true but at

the numbers I told you are true but at

the numbers I told you are true but at the same time they are spending they are

the same time they are spending they are

the same time they are spending they are paying in tax money vast amounts much in

paying in tax money vast amounts much in

paying in tax money vast amounts much in excess of the three and a million and

excess of the three and a million and

excess of the three and a million and they were employing several hundred

they were employing several hundred

they were employing several hundred thousand employees across the globe’s

thousand employees across the globe’s

thousand employees across the globe’s globe so I realized a real issue is not

globe so I realized a real issue is not

globe so I realized a real issue is not what corporations do when they’re when

what corporations do when they’re when

what corporations do when they’re when when they’re not doing the right thing

when they’re not doing the right thing

when they’re not doing the right thing perhaps I was wondering what was wrong

perhaps I was wondering what was wrong

perhaps I was wondering what was wrong there it was possibly the rules that

there it was possibly the rules that

there it was possibly the rules that were bad but I realized one much more

were bad but I realized one much more

were bad but I realized one much more big problem much bigger problem is

big problem much bigger problem is

big problem much bigger problem is corruption corruption in fact is the

corruption corruption in fact is the

corruption corruption in fact is the biggest obstacle to one of the biggest

biggest obstacle to one of the biggest

biggest obstacle to one of the biggest obstacles of the

obstacles of the

obstacles of the to human development and here just some

to human development and here just some

to human development and here just some numbers so I’m not gonna read them out

numbers so I’m not gonna read them out

numbers so I’m not gonna read them out to you but I thought striking is for

to you but I thought striking is for

to you but I thought striking is for example of the World Bank reckons that

example of the World Bank reckons that

example of the World Bank reckons that 50% of its donations across history have

50% of its donations across history have

50% of its donations across history have not gone into healthcare where they

not gone into healthcare where they

not gone into healthcare where they should should have gone for example but

should should have gone for example but

should should have gone for example but in to corrupt hands and there are

in to corrupt hands and there are

in to corrupt hands and there are millions of facts out there these are

millions of facts out there these are

millions of facts out there these are just some up like from the internet a

just some up like from the internet a

just some up like from the internet a day ago so we want to think about what

day ago so we want to think about what

day ago so we want to think about what we could do about this so let me go back

we could do about this so let me go back

we could do about this so let me go back to rules and corruption I wanted to

to rules and corruption I wanted to

to rules and corruption I wanted to think about how I could study this

think about how I could study this

think about how I could study this problem and initially I was thinking I

problem and initially I was thinking I

problem and initially I was thinking I was reading different articles in

was reading different articles in

was reading different articles in political science and political economy

political science and political economy

political science and political economy and it’s struck me there were lots of

and it’s struck me there were lots of

and it’s struck me there were lots of different proposals some countries are

different proposals some countries are

different proposals some countries are rich in resources others have scarce of

rich in resources others have scarce of

rich in resources others have scarce of resources some have hot climates or more

resources some have hot climates or more

resources some have hot climates or more moderate climates all of these were

moderate climates all of these were

moderate climates all of these were explanations people in the northern

explanations people in the northern

explanations people in the northern hemisphere in the southern hemisphere

hemisphere in the southern hemisphere

hemisphere in the southern hemisphere and cultural things in the end I realize

and cultural things in the end I realize

and cultural things in the end I realize there’s only one thing that really

there’s only one thing that really

there’s only one thing that really matters and that was the rules that

matters and that was the rules that

matters and that was the rules that govern people’s behavior rules actors

govern people’s behavior rules actors

govern people’s behavior rules actors incentives for how we act in the world

incentives for how we act in the world

incentives for how we act in the world and the perfect place to start with this

and the perfect place to start with this

and the perfect place to start with this and the answer really to it was game

and the answer really to it was game

and the answer really to it was game theory for me because rules is about

theory for me because rules is about

theory for me because rules is about strategic interactions between ourselves

strategic interactions between ourselves

strategic interactions between ourselves and the question of how the rules lead

and the question of how the rules lead

and the question of how the rules lead us to behave in the way we do behave so

us to behave in the way we do behave so

us to behave in the way we do behave so how do we start I started by thinking

how do we start I started by thinking

how do we start I started by thinking about corruption as a transaction you

about corruption as a transaction you

about corruption as a transaction you have a briber who pays a bribe to an

have a briber who pays a bribe to an

have a briber who pays a bribe to an official and these guys are engaging in

official and these guys are engaging in

official and these guys are engaging in this little transaction with each other

this little transaction with each other

this little transaction with each other which might be a win-win situation for

which might be a win-win situation for

which might be a win-win situation for them but you also have a loser Society

them but you also have a loser Society

them but you also have a loser Society so if you look at it at a bigger scheme

so if you look at it at a bigger scheme

so if you look at it at a bigger scheme not in that narrow sense and actually

not in that narrow sense and actually

not in that narrow sense and actually it’s a lose-lose situation because

it’s a lose-lose situation because

it’s a lose-lose situation because society certainly is losing out because

society certainly is losing out because

society certainly is losing out because whatever there being corrupt about it’s

whatever there being corrupt about it’s

whatever there being corrupt about it’s not going to be good to a society by

not going to be good to a society by

not going to be good to a society by definition and at the same time it is

definition and at the same time it is

definition and at the same time it is probably in the long run also bad for

probably in the long run also bad for

probably in the long run also bad for the initial perpetrators because if you

the initial perpetrators because if you

the initial perpetrators because if you just imagine an example like Brazil

just imagine an example like Brazil

just imagine an example like Brazil you’ll have on the one hand millions of

you’ll have on the one hand millions of

you’ll have on the one hand millions of people that live in favelas on the other

people that live in favelas on the other

people that live in favelas on the other hand you’ve got an a small rich elite

hand you’ve got an a small rich elite

hand you’ve got an a small rich elite that live in

that live in

that live in self-built golden prisons high security

self-built golden prisons high security

self-built golden prisons high security which they can only leave in armored

which they can only leave in armored

which they can only leave in armored vehicles just because they have to fear

vehicles just because they have to fear

vehicles just because they have to fear that the money that they’ve made is

that the money that they’ve made is

that the money that they’ve made is going to be taking off of them by the

going to be taking off of them by the

going to be taking off of them by the people they’re not as well-off you get

people they’re not as well-off you get

people they’re not as well-off you get where I’m going with that story so let’s

where I’m going with that story so let’s

where I’m going with that story so let’s think about how to think of corruption

think about how to think of corruption

think about how to think of corruption as a game here are sort of three people

as a game here are sort of three people

as a game here are sort of three people if you like you’ve got a briber and a

if you like you’ve got a briber and a

if you like you’ve got a briber and a public official and you’ve got an

public official and you’ve got an

public official and you’ve got an inspector and we can sort of take them

inspector and we can sort of take them

inspector and we can sort of take them as metaphors for groups of people in the

as metaphors for groups of people in the

as metaphors for groups of people in the Society of you like the briber hands a

Society of you like the briber hands a

Society of you like the briber hands a bribe gets some kind of permit that he

bribe gets some kind of permit that he

bribe gets some kind of permit that he likes it’s good for him but it’s bad for

likes it’s good for him but it’s bad for

likes it’s good for him but it’s bad for us because we don’t want that guy to go

us because we don’t want that guy to go

us because we don’t want that guy to go about the business that he’s doing any

about the business that he’s doing any

about the business that he’s doing any plot a couple of legal fishing you’ve

plot a couple of legal fishing you’ve

plot a couple of legal fishing you’ve got the inspector is watching these guys

got the inspector is watching these guys

got the inspector is watching these guys going through piles of permits to see

going through piles of permits to see

going through piles of permits to see whether there’s corruption in there or

whether there’s corruption in there or

whether there’s corruption in there or not now what is the condition under

not now what is the condition under

not now what is the condition under which the briber pays the bribe crudely

which the briber pays the bribe crudely

which the briber pays the bribe crudely speaking it depends on two things on the

speaking it depends on two things on the

speaking it depends on two things on the one hand he only pays it if the official

one hand he only pays it if the official

one hand he only pays it if the official is going to reciprocate pays back the

is going to reciprocate pays back the

is going to reciprocate pays back the bribe pays pays that gives him back the

bribe pays pays that gives him back the

bribe pays pays that gives him back the permit on the other hand we need the

permit on the other hand we need the

permit on the other hand we need the briber to not fear that he’s going to

briber to not fear that he’s going to

briber to not fear that he’s going to get incarcerated so the balance has to

get incarcerated so the balance has to

get incarcerated so the balance has to be just right an expectation he meets he

be just right an expectation he meets he

be just right an expectation he meets he needs to be better off by paying the

needs to be better off by paying the

needs to be better off by paying the bribe same goes for the public official

bribe same goes for the public official

bribe same goes for the public official if he thinks he’s going to go to prison

if he thinks he’s going to go to prison

if he thinks he’s going to go to prison with a to higher likelihood then he’s

with a to higher likelihood then he’s

with a to higher likelihood then he’s not going to accept the bribe and

not going to accept the bribe and

not going to accept the bribe and reciprocate but instead decline it now

reciprocate but instead decline it now

reciprocate but instead decline it now what about the inspector we could think

what about the inspector we could think

what about the inspector we could think about his incentives too so this

about his incentives too so this

about his incentives too so this inspector has a world in which he knows

inspector has a world in which he knows

inspector has a world in which he knows there is a certain relatively high

there is a certain relatively high

there is a certain relatively high punishment for both of the parties and

punishment for both of the parties and

punishment for both of the parties and he’s got a pile of permits if he does

he’s got a pile of permits if he does

he’s got a pile of permits if he does his work in a diligent fashion he’s

his work in a diligent fashion he’s

his work in a diligent fashion he’s going to look through all of the permits

going to look through all of the permits

going to look through all of the permits and you realize there’s no corruption in

and you realize there’s no corruption in

and you realize there’s no corruption in there because the other guys can

there because the other guys can

there because the other guys can anticipate that they can know that if

anticipate that they can know that if

anticipate that they can know that if punishment is high in every permit is

punishment is high in every permit is

punishment is high in every permit is checked

checked

checked they wouldn’t engage in the crime

they wouldn’t engage in the crime

they wouldn’t engage in the crime because they’ll find out so that is when

because they’ll find out so that is when

because they’ll find out so that is when the inspector things well maybe I

the inspector things well maybe I

the inspector things well maybe I shouldn’t check all of them just check

shouldn’t check all of them just check

shouldn’t check all of them just check the sporadically and this is where the

the sporadically and this is where the

the sporadically and this is where the chance creeps in that it might just

chance creeps in that it might just

chance creeps in that it might just make sense to pay a bribe or reciprocate

make sense to pay a bribe or reciprocate

make sense to pay a bribe or reciprocate so what ensues is a complicated analysis

so what ensues is a complicated analysis

so what ensues is a complicated analysis which I’m not going to bore you with but

which I’m not going to bore you with but

which I’m not going to bore you with but what we can do instead is look at the

what we can do instead is look at the

what we can do instead is look at the results so I want to think about rules

results so I want to think about rules

results so I want to think about rules as incentives again how we can make sure

as incentives again how we can make sure

as incentives again how we can make sure that we undermine the corrupt behavior

that we undermine the corrupt behavior

that we undermine the corrupt behavior that we see there here are two ways of

that we see there here are two ways of

that we see there here are two ways of how we could do that I propose to you

how we could do that I propose to you

how we could do that I propose to you two different punishment regimes one

two different punishment regimes one

two different punishment regimes one regime would be what moral philosophers

regime would be what moral philosophers

regime would be what moral philosophers might call a deontological approach as a

might call a deontological approach as a

might call a deontological approach as a rights-based approach where we say we

rights-based approach where we say we

rights-based approach where we say we want just punishment so if we want just

want just punishment so if we want just

want just punishment so if we want just just punishment we’re looking at these

just punishment we’re looking at these

just punishment we’re looking at these two perpetrators we’re thinking both of

two perpetrators we’re thinking both of

two perpetrators we’re thinking both of them are guilty as each other because

them are guilty as each other because

them are guilty as each other because they’re both in it together then we

they’re both in it together then we

they’re both in it together then we should also punish them equally that

should also punish them equally that

should also punish them equally that would be one proposal and this is in

would be one proposal and this is in

would be one proposal and this is in fact what many countries do instead we

fact what many countries do instead we

fact what many countries do instead we tried something else and we said what

tried something else and we said what

tried something else and we said what happens if we punish them differently if

happens if we punish them differently if

happens if we punish them differently if we have an asymmetric punishment regime

we have an asymmetric punishment regime

we have an asymmetric punishment regime regime and the results were surprising

regime and the results were surprising

regime and the results were surprising we found that if you punish bribes very

we found that if you punish bribes very

we found that if you punish bribes very little and you punish officials a lot

little and you punish officials a lot

little and you punish officials a lot then what you do is you undermine the

then what you do is you undermine the

then what you do is you undermine the reciprocal relationship between the two

reciprocal relationship between the two

reciprocal relationship between the two the probability of reciprocation goes

the probability of reciprocation goes

the probability of reciprocation goes right down because it never pays off if

right down because it never pays off if

right down because it never pays off if you have such a high penalty as an

you have such a high penalty as an

you have such a high penalty as an official and then as a bribe as you know

official and then as a bribe as you know

official and then as a bribe as you know your bribe will barely ever be

your bribe will barely ever be

your bribe will barely ever be reciprocated you don’t see it much point

reciprocated you don’t see it much point

reciprocated you don’t see it much point in bribing either so with the asymmetric

in bribing either so with the asymmetric

in bribing either so with the asymmetric regime you end up with corruption being

regime you end up with corruption being

regime you end up with corruption being very low with corruption very low very

very low with corruption very low very

very low with corruption very low very few people will go to prison if they

few people will go to prison if they

few people will go to prison if they ever get caught now if you compare the

ever get caught now if you compare the

ever get caught now if you compare the two regimes in the first case what

two regimes in the first case what

two regimes in the first case what you’ll find is yeah you’ve got a lot of

you’ll find is yeah you’ve got a lot of

you’ll find is yeah you’ve got a lot of people that are corrupt and you punish

people that are corrupt and you punish

people that are corrupt and you punish them justly you’ve got lots of people

them justly you’ve got lots of people

them justly you’ve got lots of people that justly punished are in prison with

that justly punished are in prison with

that justly punished are in prison with the second regime

the second regime

the second regime you’ve got very few people little to no

you’ve got very few people little to no

you’ve got very few people little to no corruption and very few people that end

corruption and very few people that end

corruption and very few people that end up in prison albeit punished unjustly

up in prison albeit punished unjustly

up in prison albeit punished unjustly now we could decide for the latter

now we could decide for the latter

now we could decide for the latter because that seems relatively intuitive

because that seems relatively intuitive

because that seems relatively intuitive intuitive to be the better answer to the

intuitive to be the better answer to the

intuitive to be the better answer to the problem but the point is

problem but the point is

problem but the point is bigger than that what I want to say is

bigger than that what I want to say is

bigger than that what I want to say is that we can use the tools that were

that we can use the tools that were

that we can use the tools that were giving given in philosophy and economics

giving given in philosophy and economics

giving given in philosophy and economics in this case and game theory to you to

in this case and game theory to you to

in this case and game theory to you to understand problems like corruption and

understand problems like corruption and

understand problems like corruption and to analyze the law that we have in this

to analyze the law that we have in this

to analyze the law that we have in this and in many other cases to decide

and in many other cases to decide

and in many other cases to decide whether it’s efficient in trying and

whether it’s efficient in trying and

whether it’s efficient in trying and achieving the things that we wanted to

achieving the things that we wanted to

achieving the things that we wanted to achieve in society and with that I want

achieve in society and with that I want

achieve in society and with that I want to end by just saying what the nature of

to end by just saying what the nature of

to end by just saying what the nature of good rules is so the final proposal is

good rules is so the final proposal is

good rules is so the final proposal is that I think the best thing that the

that I think the best thing that the

that I think the best thing that the good rules that we have the institutions

good rules that we have the institutions

good rules that we have the institutions that govern our society when they are

that govern our society when they are

that govern our society when they are good are the best accomplishment of any

good are the best accomplishment of any

good are the best accomplishment of any society now whether it is above the

society now whether it is above the

society now whether it is above the totalitarian governments that we

totalitarian governments that we

totalitarian governments that we becoming increasingly so when we’re

becoming increasingly so when we’re

becoming increasingly so when we’re surrendering our rights and are being

surrendering our rights and are being

surrendering our rights and are being surveilled with every step that we do

surveilled with every step that we do

surveilled with every step that we do all in the name of the fight against

all in the name of the fight against

all in the name of the fight against terror or whether it’s about corrupt

terror or whether it’s about corrupt

terror or whether it’s about corrupt regimes that dominate the population and

regimes that dominate the population and

regimes that dominate the population and take from it whatever they can what I

take from it whatever they can what I

take from it whatever they can what I would like you to realize is that good

would like you to realize is that good

would like you to realize is that good rules good institutions are the things

rules good institutions are the things

rules good institutions are the things that make us maximize our potential for

that make us maximize our potential for

that make us maximize our potential for win-win situations they maximize the

win-win situations they maximize the

win-win situations they maximize the potential there minimize the potential

potential there minimize the potential

potential there minimize the potential for lose-lose situation of which we are

for lose-lose situation of which we are

for lose-lose situation of which we are equally capable and it’s these good

equally capable and it’s these good

equally capable and it’s these good rules that prevent the types of

rules that prevent the types of

rules that prevent the types of situations that start so harmlessly with

situations that start so harmlessly with

situations that start so harmlessly with charismatic leadership and and so

charismatic leadership and and so

charismatic leadership and and so hopefully in war or tyranny thank you

hopefully in war or tyranny thank you

hopefully in war or tyranny thank you very much

very much

very much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *