Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rolling with the punches: Why do we fight? | Manuela Dal Borgo | TEDxChathamKent


why do we fight well we’ve read about

why do we fight well we’ve read about conflict in general in the favelas in

conflict in general in the favelas in

conflict in general in the favelas in Brazil the gang fighting the American

Brazil the gang fighting the American

Brazil the gang fighting the American grand militarism in the world or the

grand militarism in the world or the

grand militarism in the world or the total warfare of the ancient Greeks but

total warfare of the ancient Greeks but

total warfare of the ancient Greeks but also in very mundane things of everyday

also in very mundane things of everyday

also in very mundane things of everyday life for example splitting up with your

life for example splitting up with your

life for example splitting up with your partner or divorce but the ancient

partner or divorce but the ancient

partner or divorce but the ancient Greeks have something or two to teach us

Greeks have something or two to teach us

Greeks have something or two to teach us and I think through cities in particular

and I think through cities in particular

and I think through cities in particular is going to be the man to do it he is an

is going to be the man to do it he is an

is going to be the man to do it he is an expert on conflict having written the

expert on conflict having written the

expert on conflict having written the history of the Peloponnesian War which

history of the Peloponnesian War which

history of the Peloponnesian War which is the history between the war of

is the history between the war of

is the history between the war of between Athens and Sparta which was a 24

between Athens and Sparta which was a 24

between Athens and Sparta which was a 24 year war and he believes that the war

year war and he believes that the war

year war and he believes that the war began because of fear okay let’s just

began because of fear okay let’s just

began because of fear okay let’s just start like that the Athenians

start like that the Athenians

start like that the Athenians the Athenians becoming great and

the Athenians becoming great and

the Athenians becoming great and arousing fear in the Spartans compelled

arousing fear in the Spartans compelled

arousing fear in the Spartans compelled them to war okay now the fact is is that

them to war okay now the fact is is that

them to war okay now the fact is is that Thucydides looks at any interaction in a

Thucydides looks at any interaction in a

Thucydides looks at any interaction in a game theoretic way and what is game

game theoretic way and what is game

game theoretic way and what is game theory game theory is a mathematical

theory game theory is a mathematical

theory game theory is a mathematical theory of interaction and of course

theory of interaction and of course

theory of interaction and of course lucidity didn’t use calculus or algebra

lucidity didn’t use calculus or algebra

lucidity didn’t use calculus or algebra but he had a proto game theoretic

but he had a proto game theoretic

but he had a proto game theoretic perspective on the world where he saw

perspective on the world where he saw

perspective on the world where he saw people’s behavior intertwined and I’ll

people’s behavior intertwined and I’ll

people’s behavior intertwined and I’ll show you how so let’s first look at the

show you how so let’s first look at the

show you how so let’s first look at the first battle and how King OTT kadam owes

first battle and how King OTT kadam owes

first battle and how King OTT kadam owes the king of the Spartans he invaded

the king of the Spartans he invaded

the king of the Spartans he invaded Attica and this is modern Europe of

Attica and this is modern Europe of

Attica and this is modern Europe of course transport yourself 2,500 years

course transport yourself 2,500 years

course transport yourself 2,500 years ago imagine you know eliminate these

ago imagine you know eliminate these

ago imagine you know eliminate these highways pretend it’s ancient Greece

highways pretend it’s ancient Greece

highways pretend it’s ancient Greece there we go so we have Athens on the

there we go so we have Athens on the

there we go so we have Athens on the right and we have Sparta in the south of

right and we have Sparta in the south of

right and we have Sparta in the south of the Peloponnesus and we have the route

the Peloponnesus and we have the route

the Peloponnesus and we have the route which kid almost took to invade Attica

which kid almost took to invade Attica

which kid almost took to invade Attica or the region of Athens of the city of

or the region of Athens of the city of

or the region of Athens of the city of Athens now what we first would imagine

Athens now what we first would imagine

Athens now what we first would imagine is that he went as quickly as possible

is that he went as quickly as possible

is that he went as quickly as possible to make it a surprise attack

to make it a surprise attack

to make it a surprise attack but in fact no he was very slowly he

but in fact no he was very slowly he

but in fact no he was very slowly he lethargically marched his troops up

lethargically marched his troops up

lethargically marched his troops up through the Peloponnesus through the

through the Peloponnesus through the

through the Peloponnesus through the corinthian isthmus around the garrison

corinthian isthmus around the garrison

corinthian isthmus around the garrison of annoy and then finally settled in one

of annoy and then finally settled in one

of annoy and then finally settled in one of the largest districts around the city

of the largest districts around the city

of the largest districts around the city the garrison wall or the the wall of

the garrison wall or the the wall of

the garrison wall or the the wall of Athens in the district of a cotton I

Athens in the district of a cotton I

Athens in the district of a cotton I okay and which you see with the red dot

okay and which you see with the red dot

okay and which you see with the red dot and the blue dot is Athens the walled

and the blue dot is Athens the walled

and the blue dot is Athens the walled city of Athens now this is apparently

city of Athens now this is apparently

city of Athens now this is apparently from what Thucydides tells us was not a

from what Thucydides tells us was not a

from what Thucydides tells us was not a typical Spartans were in fact very

typical Spartans were in fact very

typical Spartans were in fact very cautious people and the Corinthians who

cautious people and the Corinthians who

cautious people and the Corinthians who were part of the Spartan League before

were part of the Spartan League before

were part of the Spartan League before the war actually went to Sparta and told

the war actually went to Sparta and told

the war actually went to Sparta and told the Spartans Spartans you alone of the

the Spartans Spartans you alone of the

the Spartans Spartans you alone of the Greeks pursue a passive policy and this

Greeks pursue a passive policy and this

Greeks pursue a passive policy and this was a reproach now in this first

was a reproach now in this first

was a reproach now in this first invasion is a Adamo’s actually being

invasion is a Adamo’s actually being

invasion is a Adamo’s actually being lazy or is it a clever tactic let’s try

lazy or is it a clever tactic let’s try

lazy or is it a clever tactic let’s try and analyze this so in fact I could

and analyze this so in fact I could

and analyze this so in fact I could almost did this on purpose I hadn’t I

almost did this on purpose I hadn’t I

almost did this on purpose I hadn’t I the district in which he encounters

the district in which he encounters

the district in which he encounters troops is in a high position so it’s on

troops is in a high position so it’s on

troops is in a high position so it’s on the hilltops near the the valley of

the hilltops near the the valley of

the hilltops near the the valley of where the walled city is and he knew

where the walled city is and he knew

where the walled city is and he knew that the entire city or all the citizens

that the entire city or all the citizens

that the entire city or all the citizens in the city would be able to see him and

in the city would be able to see him and

in the city would be able to see him and he was visible his entire encampment is

he was visible his entire encampment is

he was visible his entire encampment is visible to all the people in the urban

visible to all the people in the urban

visible to all the people in the urban center of course all the people who were

center of course all the people who were

center of course all the people who were in the urban center were not only the

in the urban center were not only the

in the urban center were not only the urban citizens but also the rural

urban citizens but also the rural

urban citizens but also the rural citizens who had evacuated the the rural

citizens who had evacuated the the rural

citizens who had evacuated the the rural areas including a car light to take

areas including a car light to take

areas including a car light to take refuge inside of the city walls so now

refuge inside of the city walls so now

refuge inside of the city walls so now you have all of the Athenians staring

you have all of the Athenians staring

you have all of the Athenians staring back at each other and this is turns

back at each other and this is turns

back at each other and this is turns into a staring match because Akkad

into a staring match because Akkad

into a staring match because Akkad almost seems not to be doing anything so

almost seems not to be doing anything so

almost seems not to be doing anything so what our kid almost preferences whether

what our kid almost preferences whether

what our kid almost preferences whether his options are to damos can either stay

his options are to damos can either stay

his options are to damos can either stay where he is

where he is

where he is and do nothing and simply ravage the

and do nothing and simply ravage the

and do nothing and simply ravage the local land burn a bit of crops here

local land burn a bit of crops here

local land burn a bit of crops here destroy some property there but nothing

destroy some property there but nothing

destroy some property there but nothing that will exhaust his troops at all or

that will exhaust his troops at all or

that will exhaust his troops at all or he can go on a full-on ravaging campaign

he can go on a full-on ravaging campaign

he can go on a full-on ravaging campaign invade the plains of Attica near the

invade the plains of Attica near the

invade the plains of Attica near the city walls and tried to take the city

city walls and tried to take the city

city walls and tried to take the city and bash his head against those huge

and bash his head against those huge

and bash his head against those huge walls and actually exhaust all of his

walls and actually exhaust all of his

walls and actually exhaust all of his resources and waste his time and exhaust

resources and waste his time and exhaust

resources and waste his time and exhaust his army so our cadavers prefers to be

his army so our cadavers prefers to be

his army so our cadavers prefers to be passive than to be aggressive no matter

passive than to be aggressive no matter

passive than to be aggressive no matter what the Athenians choose to do because

what the Athenians choose to do because

what the Athenians choose to do because if the Athenians choose to come out even

if the Athenians choose to come out even

if the Athenians choose to come out even when he’s passive his Spartans have the

when he’s passive his Spartans have the

when he’s passive his Spartans have the lead on the battlefield they are the

lead on the battlefield they are the

lead on the battlefield they are the most formidable infantry in Greece no

most formidable infantry in Greece no

most formidable infantry in Greece no one beats them on land so we call

one beats them on land so we call

one beats them on land so we call passive behavior D and aggressive

passive behavior D and aggressive

passive behavior D and aggressive behavior E and D is preferred to e and

behavior E and D is preferred to e and

behavior E and D is preferred to e and of course when I mean pasture that’s

of course when I mean pasture that’s

of course when I mean pasture that’s more of a passive aggressive okay it’s

more of a passive aggressive okay it’s

more of a passive aggressive okay it’s like you know don’t make me hurt you

like you know don’t make me hurt you

like you know don’t make me hurt you so I’m gonna show you mmm how the

so I’m gonna show you mmm how the

so I’m gonna show you mmm how the Athenians felt watching our ki damos

Athenians felt watching our ki damos

Athenians felt watching our ki damos sitting there at a Karan I so what I

sitting there at a Karan I so what I

sitting there at a Karan I so what I needed to do is not to tell your

needed to do is not to tell your

needed to do is not to tell your neighbor and simply look at this image

neighbor and simply look at this image

neighbor and simply look at this image and it says in X it’s an experiment okay

and it says in X it’s an experiment okay

and it says in X it’s an experiment okay and here we go what do you see who sees

and here we go what do you see who sees

and here we go what do you see who sees a young lady lift up your hand great

a young lady lift up your hand great

a young lady lift up your hand great look around

look around

look around lift up your hand up and look around a

lift up your hand up and look around a

lift up your hand up and look around a lot of people who can’t see the young

lot of people who can’t see the young

lot of people who can’t see the young lady you you probably see an old lady

lady you you probably see an old lady

lady you you probably see an old lady right so this is exactly how the

right so this is exactly how the

right so this is exactly how the Athenians felt they were collectively

Athenians felt they were collectively

Athenians felt they were collectively indifferent about what perspective to

indifferent about what perspective to

indifferent about what perspective to take half of the population wanted to

take half of the population wanted to

take half of the population wanted to vote to go out and charge against the

vote to go out and charge against the

vote to go out and charge against the Spartans especially the accordions who

Spartans especially the accordions who

Spartans especially the accordions who were the largest district and the most

were the largest district and the most

were the largest district and the most the greater number of the people inside

the greater number of the people inside

the greater number of the people inside of the the city and the rest of the

of the the city and the rest of the

of the the city and the rest of the Athenians wanted to stay inside the

Athenians wanted to stay inside the

Athenians wanted to stay inside the walls and this collective indifference

walls and this collective indifference

walls and this collective indifference we call

we call

we call therefore be so the opinion preferences

therefore be so the opinion preferences

therefore be so the opinion preferences we have no matter what the Spartans do

we have no matter what the Spartans do

we have no matter what the Spartans do be is indifference however if the

be is indifference however if the

be is indifference however if the Spartans are aggressive the best

Spartans are aggressive the best

Spartans are aggressive the best possible choice for the Athenians to

possible choice for the Athenians to

possible choice for the Athenians to make is to stay behind the walls and let

make is to stay behind the walls and let

make is to stay behind the walls and let the Spartans use their resources waste

the Spartans use their resources waste

the Spartans use their resources waste their resources and exhaust their

their resources and exhaust their

their resources and exhaust their infantry and the worst possible decision

infantry and the worst possible decision

infantry and the worst possible decision is to actually go out and fight against

is to actually go out and fight against

is to actually go out and fight against them because they were most likely lose

them because they were most likely lose

them because they were most likely lose given the formidable Ness of their army

given the formidable Ness of their army

given the formidable Ness of their army so if we put these two preferences

so if we put these two preferences

so if we put these two preferences together both of the Athenians and of

together both of the Athenians and of

together both of the Athenians and of vodka da Mo’s we see that we have our

vodka da Mo’s we see that we have our

vodka da Mo’s we see that we have our key Damas if he is passive the Athenians

key Damas if he is passive the Athenians

key Damas if he is passive the Athenians are indifferent so BB and if a Adamas is

are indifferent so BB and if a Adamas is

are indifferent so BB and if a Adamas is aggressive the opinions always prefer to

aggressive the opinions always prefer to

aggressive the opinions always prefer to be passive a / c got that in the case of

be passive a / c got that in the case of

be passive a / c got that in the case of the athenians if the Athenians are

the athenians if the Athenians are

the athenians if the Athenians are passive arcade ahmo’s prefers to be

passive arcade ahmo’s prefers to be

passive arcade ahmo’s prefers to be passive to aggressive and if they are

passive to aggressive and if they are

passive to aggressive and if they are aggressive they are kadam’s prefers to

aggressive they are kadam’s prefers to

aggressive they are kadam’s prefers to be passive to aggressive so no matter

be passive to aggressive so no matter

be passive to aggressive so no matter what the Athenians do he always prefers

what the Athenians do he always prefers

what the Athenians do he always prefers to be passive he doesn’t want to exhaust

to be passive he doesn’t want to exhaust

to be passive he doesn’t want to exhaust his troops or waste resources okay so

his troops or waste resources okay so

his troops or waste resources okay so this is the matrix formulation and these

this is the matrix formulation and these

this is the matrix formulation and these are the four possible outcomes that are

are the four possible outcomes that are

are the four possible outcomes that are key damos this is all in the plans of

key damos this is all in the plans of

key damos this is all in the plans of arc Adamo’s that arc Adamas envisions

arc Adamo’s that arc Adamas envisions

arc Adamo’s that arc Adamas envisions and envisions is going to happen so what

and envisions is going to happen so what

and envisions is going to happen so what is he gonna do about this he says well

is he gonna do about this he says well

is he gonna do about this he says well everybody is going to act in their own

everybody is going to act in their own

everybody is going to act in their own self-interest and so what he thinks to

self-interest and so what he thinks to

self-interest and so what he thinks to himself is one I prefer to be passive if

himself is one I prefer to be passive if

himself is one I prefer to be passive if they’re passive I prefer to be passive

they’re passive I prefer to be passive

they’re passive I prefer to be passive if they’re aggressive therefore I’m

if they’re aggressive therefore I’m

if they’re aggressive therefore I’m going to be passive no matter what

going to be passive no matter what

going to be passive no matter what that’s my dominant strategy those are my

that’s my dominant strategy those are my

that’s my dominant strategy those are my best choices I put a star next to it now

best choices I put a star next to it now

best choices I put a star next to it now the Athenians he says to himself are

the Athenians he says to himself are

the Athenians he says to himself are going to think in the following way if

going to think in the following way if

going to think in the following way if I’m passive they’re going to be confused

I’m passive they’re going to be confused

I’m passive they’re going to be confused and they are going to be split in their

and they are going to be split in their

and they are going to be split in their vote because they have their democracy

vote because they have their democracy

vote because they have their democracy they’re a collective decision maker

they’re a collective decision maker

they’re a collective decision maker they’re not one king there is a

they’re not one king there is a

they’re not one king there is a collective number of people taking a

collective number of people taking a

collective number of people taking a decision and therefore

decision and therefore

decision and therefore of an aggressive very indifferent

of an aggressive very indifferent

of an aggressive very indifferent between that however if he’s aggressive

between that however if he’s aggressive

between that however if he’s aggressive and comes against the city walls more

and comes against the city walls more

and comes against the city walls more certainly they will take up the passive

certainly they will take up the passive

certainly they will take up the passive position and barricade themselves behind

position and barricade themselves behind

position and barricade themselves behind the walls and then we can star those

the walls and then we can star those

the walls and then we can star those best choices as well and in that case

best choices as well and in that case

best choices as well and in that case the Athenians let’s just go back to that

the Athenians let’s just go back to that

the Athenians let’s just go back to that in that case the Athenians have a weakly

in that case the Athenians have a weakly

in that case the Athenians have a weakly dominant strategy so they prefer most of

dominant strategy so they prefer most of

dominant strategy so they prefer most of the time to be passive but there is a

the time to be passive but there is a

the time to be passive but there is a potential for error

potential for error

potential for error right so what did we do this information

right so what did we do this information

right so what did we do this information of these best choices where these best

of these best choices where these best

of these best choices where these best choices intersect we say that these are

choices intersect we say that these are

choices intersect we say that these are the most likely outcomes okay and this

the most likely outcomes okay and this

the most likely outcomes okay and this is what our key damos did he was trying

is what our key damos did he was trying

is what our key damos did he was trying to force the hand of the Athenians by

to force the hand of the Athenians by

to force the hand of the Athenians by being passive to make a mistake to

being passive to make a mistake to

being passive to make a mistake to actually charge them in a battlefield

actually charge them in a battlefield

actually charge them in a battlefield that they would be more likely to lose

that they would be more likely to lose

that they would be more likely to lose and so when I asked you where they

and so when I asked you where they

and so when I asked you where they raised your clever

raised your clever

raised your clever you should think to yourself obviously

you should think to yourself obviously

you should think to yourself obviously clever very clever tactic on the part of

clever very clever tactic on the part of

clever very clever tactic on the part of arcade ammos now this type of civil

arcade ammos now this type of civil

arcade ammos now this type of civil strife okay that arcade ahmo’s had

strife okay that arcade ahmo’s had

strife okay that arcade ahmo’s had created within athens is something that

created within athens is something that

created within athens is something that is not only typical within States but

is not only typical within States but

is not only typical within States but also happens within unions

also happens within unions

also happens within unions confederacies and leagues and sorts and

confederacies and leagues and sorts and

confederacies and leagues and sorts and anything that requires membership okay

anything that requires membership okay

anything that requires membership okay and this was the case of new laws the

and this was the case of new laws the

and this was the case of new laws the Athenian League okay wanted new laws to

Athenian League okay wanted new laws to

Athenian League okay wanted new laws to stay within the Athenian Empire they

stay within the Athenian Empire they

stay within the Athenian Empire they wanted them to be part of the Athenian

wanted them to be part of the Athenian

wanted them to be part of the Athenian League and the median said we don’t want

League and the median said we don’t want

League and the median said we don’t want to be part of your league okay so they

to be part of your league okay so they

to be part of your league okay so they had a very Exeter attitude they wanted

had a very Exeter attitude they wanted

had a very Exeter attitude they wanted to exit the league now the Athenians

to exit the league now the Athenians

to exit the league now the Athenians they were afraid that if the millions

they were afraid that if the millions

they were afraid that if the millions didn’t stay within the league that it

didn’t stay within the league that it

didn’t stay within the league that it would create a contagion effect where

would create a contagion effect where

would create a contagion effect where all the other members would say to

all the other members would say to

all the other members would say to themselves well if they’re not joining

themselves well if they’re not joining

themselves well if they’re not joining why should we

why should we

why should we maybe we should Lee and so they said to

maybe we should Lee and so they said to

maybe we should Lee and so they said to the millions you have the choice we need

the millions you have the choice we need

the millions you have the choice we need you to be in the league and we need you

you to be in the league and we need you

you to be in the league and we need you to accept our offer and our offer is the

to accept our offer and our offer is the

to accept our offer and our offer is the following you will have to pay as

following you will have to pay as

following you will have to pay as tribute and submit to our regulatory

tribute and submit to our regulatory

tribute and submit to our regulatory control our jurisdiction okay which

control our jurisdiction okay which

control our jurisdiction okay which usually meant the Athenian courts and of

usually meant the Athenian courts and of

usually meant the Athenian courts and of course the median said this is unfair we

course the median said this is unfair we

course the median said this is unfair we don’t think this very this is a very

don’t think this very this is a very

don’t think this very this is a very similar situation to what is going on in

similar situation to what is going on in

similar situation to what is going on in the UK today the analogy is not perfect

the UK today the analogy is not perfect

the UK today the analogy is not perfect but it still is very well mimicked in

but it still is very well mimicked in

but it still is very well mimicked in the sense that the UK has been offered

the sense that the UK has been offered

the sense that the UK has been offered by the EU to stay within the membership

by the EU to stay within the membership

by the EU to stay within the membership and simply pay a 8 to 9 million pounds

and simply pay a 8 to 9 million pounds

and simply pay a 8 to 9 million pounds as part of their membership and to also

as part of their membership and to also

as part of their membership and to also submit the regulatory control of the ECJ

submit the regulatory control of the ECJ

submit the regulatory control of the ECJ to which the UK said that’s unfair and

to which the UK said that’s unfair and

to which the UK said that’s unfair and what happens then the thing is it’s not

what happens then the thing is it’s not

what happens then the thing is it’s not the bit the offer is unfair it’s that

the bit the offer is unfair it’s that

the bit the offer is unfair it’s that the consequences of rejecting that offer

the consequences of rejecting that offer

the consequences of rejecting that offer are going to be far worse and this is

are going to be far worse and this is

are going to be far worse and this is what the other members of the league are

what the other members of the league are

what the other members of the league are trying to argue so in the case of the

trying to argue so in the case of the

trying to argue so in the case of the Athenians the Athenians say to the

Athenians the Athenians say to the

Athenians the Athenians say to the millions look if you reject our offer

millions look if you reject our offer

millions look if you reject our offer we’re going to destroy your city enslave

we’re going to destroy your city enslave

we’re going to destroy your city enslave and your women and children kill all the

and your women and children kill all the

and your women and children kill all the men in the city and recolonize your

men in the city and recolonize your

men in the city and recolonize your entire territory not a very good outcome

entire territory not a very good outcome

entire territory not a very good outcome so you know some tribute let them rule

so you know some tribute let them rule

so you know some tribute let them rule is instead of everybody getting killed

is instead of everybody getting killed

is instead of everybody getting killed in the case of the UK the Europeans have

in the case of the UK the Europeans have

in the case of the UK the Europeans have said that they will deny a single market

said that they will deny a single market

said that they will deny a single market access to Britain which will severely

access to Britain which will severely

access to Britain which will severely and seriously damage the financial

and seriously damage the financial

and seriously damage the financial sector in the City of London especially

sector in the City of London especially

sector in the City of London especially given that the UK is a service run

given that the UK is a service run

given that the UK is a service run economy the tax national tax

economy the tax national tax

economy the tax national tax contributions of those immigrants in

contributions of those immigrants in

contributions of those immigrants in those European immigrants is a

those European immigrants is a

those European immigrants is a big chunk and they would be losing out

big chunk and they would be losing out

big chunk and they would be losing out on that and the added bonus that there

on that and the added bonus that there

on that and the added bonus that there would be military alienation given that

would be military alienation given that

would be military alienation given that they would be separate from the Block in

they would be separate from the Block in

they would be separate from the Block in that’s in from the military block of the

that’s in from the military block of the

that’s in from the military block of the EU and so very negative outcomes now so

EU and so very negative outcomes now so

EU and so very negative outcomes now so what is the negotiation what’s going on

what is the negotiation what’s going on

what is the negotiation what’s going on so although these are the offers and

so although these are the offers and

so although these are the offers and this is the offer and we can either

this is the offer and we can either

this is the offer and we can either accept or reject what’s going on behind

accept or reject what’s going on behind

accept or reject what’s going on behind the scenes what is the rhetoric so

the scenes what is the rhetoric so

the scenes what is the rhetoric so what’s really going on is that there is

what’s really going on is that there is

what’s really going on is that there is a realist rhetoric okay on the side of

a realist rhetoric okay on the side of

a realist rhetoric okay on the side of the Athenians as well as the EU which is

the Athenians as well as the EU which is

the Athenians as well as the EU which is simply possible actions are defined by

simply possible actions are defined by

simply possible actions are defined by what the strong do and the weak accept

what the strong do and the weak accept

what the strong do and the weak accept so if you’re little get with the program

so if you’re little get with the program

so if you’re little get with the program okay and on the side of the millions

okay and on the side of the millions

okay and on the side of the millions just as the UK there is a extreme

just as the UK there is a extreme

just as the UK there is a extreme rhetoric of fairness and justice and

rhetoric of fairness and justice and

rhetoric of fairness and justice and this is this is something that we should

this is this is something that we should

this is this is something that we should do that requires that we think ethically

do that requires that we think ethically

do that requires that we think ethically and morally these are the idealists and

and morally these are the idealists and

and morally these are the idealists and in this case this is why we hear Teresa

in this case this is why we hear Teresa

in this case this is why we hear Teresa may talk about her slogan and she’s been

may talk about her slogan and she’s been

may talk about her slogan and she’s been vilified time and time again for saying

vilified time and time again for saying

vilified time and time again for saying no deal is better than a bad deal but

no deal is better than a bad deal but

no deal is better than a bad deal but this is very much in line okay this this

this is very much in line okay this this

this is very much in line okay this this attitude towards breakfast brexit is

attitude towards breakfast brexit is

attitude towards breakfast brexit is very much in line with the attitude that

very much in line with the attitude that

very much in line with the attitude that Yanis varoufakis head with the grexit

Yanis varoufakis head with the grexit

Yanis varoufakis head with the grexit crisis in fact Yanni’s varoufakis wrote

crisis in fact Yanni’s varoufakis wrote

crisis in fact Yanni’s varoufakis wrote an entire monograph a book about the

an entire monograph a book about the

an entire monograph a book about the situation that they had with the troika

situation that they had with the troika

situation that they had with the troika and he entitled it the very same quote

and he entitled it the very same quote

and he entitled it the very same quote of the millions as a reproach to this

of the millions as a reproach to this

of the millions as a reproach to this realist perspective he called it and the

realist perspective he called it and the

realist perspective he called it and the weak suffer what they must and in fact

weak suffer what they must and in fact

weak suffer what they must and in fact it says and the weak suffer what they

it says and the weak suffer what they

it says and the weak suffer what they must should they

so so this is the situation we’ve seen

so so this is the situation we’ve seen that fear begins competition and

that fear begins competition and

that fear begins competition and conflict we see that honor is a desire

conflict we see that honor is a desire

conflict we see that honor is a desire for fairness and that selfish

for fairness and that selfish

for fairness and that selfish self-interest is and it is a desire to

self-interest is and it is a desire to

self-interest is and it is a desire to acquire things and Thucydides kind of

acquire things and Thucydides kind of

acquire things and Thucydides kind of summarizes this strategy of coalition or

summarizes this strategy of coalition or

summarizes this strategy of coalition or this strategy of empire in one sentence

this strategy of empire in one sentence

this strategy of empire in one sentence the opinion ambassadors come to Sparta

the opinion ambassadors come to Sparta

the opinion ambassadors come to Sparta before the war long before the world and

before the war long before the world and

before the war long before the world and they come and they say well and I’m

they come and they say well and I’m

they come and they say well and I’m going to read it off here there is

going to read it off here there is

going to read it off here there is nothing remarkable or contrary to human

nothing remarkable or contrary to human

nothing remarkable or contrary to human behavior and what we have done just

behavior and what we have done just

behavior and what we have done just because we accepted an empire when one

because we accepted an empire when one

because we accepted an empire when one was offered and then declined to let it

was offered and then declined to let it

was offered and then declined to let it go overcome by the strongest of all

go overcome by the strongest of all

go overcome by the strongest of all motives honor fear and self-interest

motives honor fear and self-interest

motives honor fear and self-interest so honor is the need for fairness fear

so honor is the need for fairness fear

so honor is the need for fairness fear compels us us to fight and self-interest

compels us us to fight and self-interest

compels us us to fight and self-interest is the desire to acquire I have designed

is the desire to acquire I have designed

is the desire to acquire I have designed a game theoretic model that tries to

a game theoretic model that tries to

a game theoretic model that tries to incorporate these three ideas in a

incorporate these three ideas in a

incorporate these three ideas in a networked annales analysis and then i

networked annales analysis and then i

networked annales analysis and then i computer-simulated it and i’m going to

computer-simulated it and i’m going to

computer-simulated it and i’m going to show you this computer simulation today

show you this computer simulation today

show you this computer simulation today so here i’ve only included one of the

so here i’ve only included one of the

so here i’ve only included one of the elements in the simulation so we have

elements in the simulation so we have

elements in the simulation so we have fear so compelled to fight and the

fear so compelled to fight and the

fear so compelled to fight and the number of resources of each node okay

number of resources of each node okay

number of resources of each node okay and each of these nodes are the major

and each of these nodes are the major

and each of these nodes are the major states in the 5th century BC ok at the

states in the 5th century BC ok at the

states in the 5th century BC ok at the time of the Peloponnesian War and how

time of the Peloponnesian War and how

time of the Peloponnesian War and how they interacted and hegemony was reached

they interacted and hegemony was reached

they interacted and hegemony was reached so Spartan hegemony was reached very

so Spartan hegemony was reached very

so Spartan hegemony was reached very quickly and here you see Sparta in

quickly and here you see Sparta in

quickly and here you see Sparta in Laconia which is the lower node called

Laconia which is the lower node called

Laconia which is the lower node called Laconia that’s just a region where

Laconia that’s just a region where

Laconia that’s just a region where Sparta is this is very unrealistic

Sparta is this is very unrealistic

Sparta is this is very unrealistic because hegemonies are not acquired so

because hegemonies are not acquired so

because hegemonies are not acquired so quickly in this case I’ve added the

quickly in this case I’ve added the

quickly in this case I’ve added the costs of war because two cities

costs of war because two cities

costs of war because two cities explicitly tells us that war is more

explicitly tells us that war is more

explicitly tells us that war is more about is less about weapons and arms

about is less about weapons and arms

about is less about weapons and arms it is about money and the work and the

it is about money and the work and the

it is about money and the work and the word he uses for money is da pani and da

word he uses for money is da pani and da

word he uses for money is da pani and da da Pinay just means cost and expenditure

da Pinay just means cost and expenditure

da Pinay just means cost and expenditure so what we have to do is that we have to

so what we have to do is that we have to

so what we have to do is that we have to add the costs of war so every time I go

add the costs of war so every time I go

add the costs of war so every time I go to war with somebody it costs me

to war with somebody it costs me

to war with somebody it costs me something and if we include this we find

something and if we include this we find

something and if we include this we find in fact that given the the parameters of

in fact that given the the parameters of

in fact that given the the parameters of the time we we create the two leaks we

the time we we create the two leaks we

the time we we create the two leaks we find that the brown stabilizes in the

find that the brown stabilizes in the

find that the brown stabilizes in the Peloponnesian League and the blue which

Peloponnesian League and the blue which

Peloponnesian League and the blue which is on the left hand side and the blue

is on the left hand side and the blue

is on the left hand side and the blue stabilizes on the league Athenian League

stabilizes on the league Athenian League

stabilizes on the league Athenian League on the right what I do next is that I

on the right what I do next is that I

on the right what I do next is that I include the idea of fairness to make it

include the idea of fairness to make it

include the idea of fairness to make it even more realistic so now each state

even more realistic so now each state

even more realistic so now each state has the opportunity to decide if it

has the opportunity to decide if it

has the opportunity to decide if it wants to exit the union or not if we do

wants to exit the union or not if we do

wants to exit the union or not if we do this by having the initial state to be

this by having the initial state to be

this by having the initial state to be the two leagues the Peloponnesian League

the two leagues the Peloponnesian League

the two leagues the Peloponnesian League Spartan League and the Delian League the

Spartan League and the Delian League the

Spartan League and the Delian League the Athenian League that Sparta actually

Athenian League that Sparta actually

Athenian League that Sparta actually takes over and creates a hegemony even

takes over and creates a hegemony even

takes over and creates a hegemony even though there are defections throughout

though there are defections throughout

though there are defections throughout and exits of course if I let this

and exits of course if I let this

and exits of course if I let this simulation keep on going the defections

simulation keep on going the defections

simulation keep on going the defections would continue but the idea that

would continue but the idea that

would continue but the idea that hegemony is still we can still arrive I

hegemony is still we can still arrive I

hegemony is still we can still arrive I arrived at hegemonic States or or

arrived at hegemonic States or or

arrived at hegemonic States or or coalitional States even though there are

coalitional States even though there are

coalitional States even though there are exits is very heartening and so and this

exits is very heartening and so and this

exits is very heartening and so and this is what was what actually did happen in

is what was what actually did happen in

is what was what actually did happen in 404 BC when Athens Falls and spot that

404 BC when Athens Falls and spot that

404 BC when Athens Falls and spot that takes over most of ancient Greece so

takes over most of ancient Greece so

takes over most of ancient Greece so it’s all conflict destructive well I

it’s all conflict destructive well I

it’s all conflict destructive well I contend that it’s not there’s a lot of

contend that it’s not there’s a lot of

contend that it’s not there’s a lot of friendly conflict for example that you

friendly conflict for example that you

friendly conflict for example that you can you know use your fake Jedi sabers

can you know use your fake Jedi sabers

can you know use your fake Jedi sabers when you’re playing tennis in London or

when you’re playing tennis in London or

when you’re playing tennis in London or you can have two guys actually wrestling

you can have two guys actually wrestling

you can have two guys actually wrestling on a vaaz and athletic competition is

on a vaaz and athletic competition is

on a vaaz and athletic competition is simply a friendly version of the more

simply a friendly version of the more

simply a friendly version of the more serious version of war and what we can

serious version of war and what we can

serious version of war and what we can do is simply just keep rolling with the

do is simply just keep rolling with the

do is simply just keep rolling with the punches thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *