Press "Enter" to skip to content

Returning from the dark side of music | Katrina McFerran | TEDxStKilda


picture this

picture this it’s 6:40 4:00 a.m. and you’re just

it’s 6:40 4:00 a.m. and you’re just

it’s 6:40 4:00 a.m. and you’re just starting to rouse and then as the clock

starting to rouse and then as the clock

starting to rouse and then as the clock ticks over to the designated hour the

ticks over to the designated hour the

ticks over to the designated hour the music playing on the radio is you’re in

music playing on the radio is you’re in

music playing on the radio is you’re in this chair like you’re washing your hair

this chair like you’re washing your hair

this chair like you’re washing your hair and you’re singing along and you’re

and you’re singing along and you’re

and you’re singing along and you’re thinking to yourself oh my goodness

thinking to yourself oh my goodness

thinking to yourself oh my goodness music is magic I’m gonna set my alarm

music is magic I’m gonna set my alarm

music is magic I’m gonna set my alarm clock to that song every single day but

clock to that song every single day but

clock to that song every single day but let’s just run that fan again and this

let’s just run that fan again and this

let’s just run that fan again and this time with a couple of small changes it’s

time with a couple of small changes it’s

time with a couple of small changes it’s still 6:44 a.m. joy you’re starting to

still 6:44 a.m. joy you’re starting to

still 6:44 a.m. joy you’re starting to rouse but as the clock ticks over this

rouse but as the clock ticks over this

rouse but as the clock ticks over this time the music playing on the radio is

in our sunshine when he’s coming and

in our sunshine when he’s coming and he’s always but anytime you know all of

he’s always but anytime you know all of

he’s always but anytime you know all of a sudden you remember the relationship

a sudden you remember the relationship

a sudden you remember the relationship breakup that just happened and you

breakup that just happened and you

breakup that just happened and you become plagued with questions like will

become plagued with questions like will

become plagued with questions like will I ever find love again will anybody ever

I ever find love again will anybody ever

I ever find love again will anybody ever love me again am i destined to be alone

love me again am i destined to be alone

love me again am i destined to be alone and instead of being out and in the

and instead of being out and in the

and instead of being out and in the shower you reach over and you turn off

shower you reach over and you turn off

shower you reach over and you turn off the alarm clock and you send a quick

the alarm clock and you send a quick

the alarm clock and you send a quick text to work saying that you’re feeling

text to work saying that you’re feeling

text to work saying that you’re feeling very sick and you pull the cover back

very sick and you pull the cover back

very sick and you pull the cover back over your head as the song goes around

over your head as the song goes around

over your head as the song goes around and around Wow that’s two very different

and around Wow that’s two very different

and around Wow that’s two very different morning experiences isn’t it from two

morning experiences isn’t it from two

morning experiences isn’t it from two classic sunshine hits what does that

classic sunshine hits what does that

classic sunshine hits what does that tell us about the power of music and how

tell us about the power of music and how

tell us about the power of music and how it works while most people assume it

it works while most people assume it

it works while most people assume it explains how music has an effect on us

explains how music has an effect on us

explains how music has an effect on us and makes us feel and do certain things

and makes us feel and do certain things

and makes us feel and do certain things but actually in my work as a music

but actually in my work as a music

but actually in my work as a music therapist and a researcher I have seen

therapist and a researcher I have seen

therapist and a researcher I have seen the same music have very different

the same music have very different

the same music have very different effects on people so if you’re not going

effects on people so if you’re not going

effects on people so if you’re not going through a relationship break up and in

through a relationship break up and in

through a relationship break up and in our Sun shower where he is gone comes on

our Sun shower where he is gone comes on

our Sun shower where he is gone comes on you might just go oh I remember that guy

you might just go oh I remember that guy

you might just go oh I remember that guy that was beautiful or you might get

that was beautiful or you might get

that was beautiful or you might get caught up in the poignant melody and how

caught up in the poignant melody and how

caught up in the poignant melody and how stunning it is and no matter how good

stunning it is and no matter how good

stunning it is and no matter how good that drum beat from Katrina and the

that drum beat from Katrina and the

that drum beat from Katrina and the waves is it’s not going to get you out

waves is it’s not going to get you out

waves is it’s not going to get you out of bed if you’ve just had like a major

of bed if you’ve just had like a major

of bed if you’ve just had like a major car accident or something like that

car accident or something like that

car accident or something like that music is definitely not magic so what is

music is definitely not magic so what is

music is definitely not magic so what is it that’s counterintuitive to our

it that’s counterintuitive to our

it that’s counterintuitive to our assumptions about how music works it’s

assumptions about how music works it’s

assumptions about how music works it’s not that music has the power to do

not that music has the power to do

not that music has the power to do something to you it’s you who has the

something to you it’s you who has the

something to you it’s you who has the power to use the almighty affordances of

power to use the almighty affordances of

power to use the almighty affordances of music

music

music any way that you choose and because you

any way that you choose and because you

any way that you choose and because you have the power and responsibility you

have the power and responsibility you

have the power and responsibility you can do that to make yourself feel

can do that to make yourself feel

can do that to make yourself feel fabulous you can use it to relax you can

fabulous you can use it to relax you can

fabulous you can use it to relax you can use it to pump yourself up you can use

use it to pump yourself up you can use

use it to pump yourself up you can use it to connect with people but you can

it to connect with people but you can

it to connect with people but you can also use it to make yourself feel worse

also use it to make yourself feel worse

also use it to make yourself feel worse and music has been used for some pretty

and music has been used for some pretty

and music has been used for some pretty dark purposes over time like isolation

dark purposes over time like isolation

dark purposes over time like isolation an exclusion Hitler is an excellent

an exclusion Hitler is an excellent

an exclusion Hitler is an excellent example of somebody who clearly

example of somebody who clearly

example of somebody who clearly understood how to use the power of music

understood how to use the power of music

understood how to use the power of music he combined pomp and ceremony and

he combined pomp and ceremony and

he combined pomp and ceremony and marching together in time to promote

marching together in time to promote

marching together in time to promote group bonding which is very effective

group bonding which is very effective

group bonding which is very effective for both between him and his troops and

for both between him and his troops and

for both between him and his troops and he paired that with widespread community

he paired that with widespread community

he paired that with widespread community group singing of Nazi propaganda songs

group singing of Nazi propaganda songs

group singing of Nazi propaganda songs putting this enormous sense of community

putting this enormous sense of community

putting this enormous sense of community and of people who were in the in-group

and of people who were in the in-group

and of people who were in the in-group which as we know he then manipulated and

which as we know he then manipulated and

which as we know he then manipulated and turned against those outside of the

turned against those outside of the

turned against those outside of the group and those in the group were able

group and those in the group were able

group and those in the group were able to tolerate unthinkable cruelty and

to tolerate unthinkable cruelty and

to tolerate unthinkable cruelty and violence it happens all the time today

violence it happens all the time today

violence it happens all the time today online in schools if you think about

online in schools if you think about

online in schools if you think about what it feels like when you go to a

what it feels like when you go to a

what it feels like when you go to a concept and that invincible feeling like

concept and that invincible feeling like

concept and that invincible feeling like everybody is just bopping along to the

everybody is just bopping along to the

everybody is just bopping along to the music and singing and you feel connected

music and singing and you feel connected

music and singing and you feel connected and you transcend the moment and you’re

and you transcend the moment and you’re

and you transcend the moment and you’re so combined with everybody around you

so combined with everybody around you

so combined with everybody around you and how that actually could be turned

and how that actually could be turned

and how that actually could be turned and manipulated in any moment so that

and manipulated in any moment so that

and manipulated in any moment so that those outside the group are excluded the

those outside the group are excluded the

those outside the group are excluded the power of music can be used in any

power of music can be used in any

power of music can be used in any direction so exclusion is one and

direction so exclusion is one and

direction so exclusion is one and intensifying emotions is another if we

intensifying emotions is another if we

intensifying emotions is another if we go back to that scene from the beginning

go back to that scene from the beginning

go back to that scene from the beginning the relationship breakup scene and fast

the relationship breakup scene and fast

the relationship breakup scene and fast forward a couple of days you make it to

forward a couple of days you make it to

forward a couple of days you make it to work you tolerate the day and you’re

work you tolerate the day and you’re

work you tolerate the day and you’re driving home glad to have made it

driving home glad to have made it

driving home glad to have made it through and then all of a sudden

through and then all of a sudden

through and then all of a sudden somebody breaks suddenly in front of you

somebody breaks suddenly in front of you

somebody breaks suddenly in front of you and somebody else cuts across in front

and somebody else cuts across in front

and somebody else cuts across in front of you and you start to get frustrated

of you and you start to get frustrated

of you and you start to get frustrated so you go into the supermarket

so you go into the supermarket

so you go into the supermarket and the person at the checkout counter

and the person at the checkout counter

and the person at the checkout counter is unbelievably rude to you for no

is unbelievably rude to you for no

is unbelievably rude to you for no reason at all so that by the time you

reason at all so that by the time you

reason at all so that by the time you get home you’re feeling extremely

get home you’re feeling extremely

get home you’re feeling extremely intense and you choose not to put on air

intense and you choose not to put on air

intense and you choose not to put on air no such because you’re not feeling sad

no such because you’re not feeling sad

no such because you’re not feeling sad you’re feeling mad so the question is

you’re feeling mad so the question is

you’re feeling mad so the question is what rage anthem will you go for

what rage anthem will you go for

what rage anthem will you go for Tchaikovsky very good Lincoln Park could

Tchaikovsky very good Lincoln Park could

Tchaikovsky very good Lincoln Park could work

work

work how about Nirvana Morissette

how about Nirvana Morissette

how about Nirvana Morissette [Music]

every spring is trying to sublimate your

every spring is trying to sublimate your rage through the music and out the other

rage through the music and out the other

rage through the music and out the other side so that you feel better

side so that you feel better

side so that you feel better but unfortunately you don’t feel better

but unfortunately you don’t feel better

but unfortunately you don’t feel better you just feel more rage and even more

you just feel more rage and even more

you just feel more rage and even more unfortunately so do the neighbors who

unfortunately so do the neighbors who

unfortunately so do the neighbors who have heard it all before and who raced

have heard it all before and who raced

have heard it all before and who raced down to your door the minute the volume

down to your door the minute the volume

down to your door the minute the volume goes throw the rope and start knocking

goes throw the rope and start knocking

goes throw the rope and start knocking but you don’t need them because you

but you don’t need them because you

but you don’t need them because you scream

fun fact the police received more calls

fun fact the police received more calls to intervene in violent situations

to intervene in violent situations

to intervene in violent situations between neighbors when music has been

between neighbors when music has been

between neighbors when music has been the trigger then you would expect so the

the trigger then you would expect so the

the trigger then you would expect so the most common use I’ve seen of using music

most common use I’ve seen of using music

most common use I’ve seen of using music is for rumination we all do it it’s very

is for rumination we all do it it’s very

is for rumination we all do it it’s very normal to use music to match our moods

normal to use music to match our moods

normal to use music to match our moods and music has this incredible power to

and music has this incredible power to

and music has this incredible power to bear witness to the intensity of our

bear witness to the intensity of our

bear witness to the intensity of our darkest feelings and we can listen to it

darkest feelings and we can listen to it

darkest feelings and we can listen to it over and over and we can listen to it

over and over and we can listen to it

over and over and we can listen to it over

over

over [Music]

[Music]

[Music] and

you know it can be the classic breakup

you know it can be the classic breakup song or it could be your nobody

song or it could be your nobody

song or it could be your nobody understands me song or your rage song

understands me song or your rage song

understands me song or your rage song it’s perfectly normal to use music in

it’s perfectly normal to use music in

it’s perfectly normal to use music in that way as the Sun Goes Down and the

that way as the Sun Goes Down and the

that way as the Sun Goes Down and the hours go by and we truly believe in hope

hours go by and we truly believe in hope

hours go by and we truly believe in hope and often it occurs that we get some

and often it occurs that we get some

and often it occurs that we get some sense of release through that

sense of release through that

sense of release through that opportunity to stay with our feelings in

opportunity to stay with our feelings in

opportunity to stay with our feelings in the moment but because we’re the ones

the moment but because we’re the ones

the moment but because we’re the ones who choose how to use music it

who choose how to use music it

who choose how to use music it definitely does not always work that way

definitely does not always work that way

definitely does not always work that way you can use music to make yourself feel

you can use music to make yourself feel

you can use music to make yourself feel better but you can use music to stay

better but you can use music to stay

better but you can use music to stay intensely connected to dark feelings so

intensely connected to dark feelings so

intensely connected to dark feelings so when I say that I’m a music therapist

when I say that I’m a music therapist

when I say that I’m a music therapist what that means is that I use active

what that means is that I use active

what that means is that I use active music making and music listening with

music making and music listening with

music making and music listening with people who are currently living with the

people who are currently living with the

people who are currently living with the dark side perhaps it’s due to illness or

dark side perhaps it’s due to illness or

dark side perhaps it’s due to illness or injury or a range of life circumstances

injury or a range of life circumstances

injury or a range of life circumstances and my particular work the people I like

and my particular work the people I like

and my particular work the people I like most to work with their young and

most to work with their young and

most to work with their young and lessons and they often are struggling

lessons and they often are struggling

lessons and they often are struggling with depression and other issues and

with depression and other issues and

with depression and other issues and they really don’t need any help

they really don’t need any help

they really don’t need any help connecting to their darkest feelings

connecting to their darkest feelings

connecting to their darkest feelings they feel them inside they feel them

they feel them inside they feel them

they feel them inside they feel them above them they’re surrounded by their

above them they’re surrounded by their

above them they’re surrounded by their darkest feelings it’s tough but they do

darkest feelings it’s tough but they do

darkest feelings it’s tough but they do believe in the power of music and they

believe in the power of music and they

believe in the power of music and they often rely on music to help them to feel

often rely on music to help them to feel

often rely on music to help them to feel better they’re some of the greatest

better they’re some of the greatest

better they’re some of the greatest users but because they misunderstand the

users but because they misunderstand the

users but because they misunderstand the mechanism of how music works and that it

mechanism of how music works and that it

mechanism of how music works and that it relies on their own agency to use it in

relies on their own agency to use it in

relies on their own agency to use it in particular ways the results of their

particular ways the results of their

particular ways the results of their music listening can sometimes be

music listening can sometimes be

music listening can sometimes be extremely bewildering to them and as I

extremely bewildering to them and as I

extremely bewildering to them and as I often hear from people to the caring

often hear from people to the caring

often hear from people to the caring adults who are watching over them so I

adults who are watching over them so I

adults who are watching over them so I once worked with a young man who had

once worked with a young man who had

once worked with a young man who had been using drumming very successfully

been using drumming very successfully

been using drumming very successfully for a number of years to ventilate his

for a number of years to ventilate his

for a number of years to ventilate his feelings his rage and he was doing it in

feelings his rage and he was doing it in

feelings his rage and he was doing it in a way it doesn’t hurt anybody when you

a way it doesn’t hurt anybody when you

a way it doesn’t hurt anybody when you play the drums you have to be pretty bit

play the drums you have to be pretty bit

play the drums you have to be pretty bit but it doesn’t hurt anybody it was very

but it doesn’t hurt anybody it was very

but it doesn’t hurt anybody it was very successful strategy him for him but as

successful strategy him for him but as

successful strategy him for him but as the years went by and as his psychosis

the years went by and as his psychosis

the years went by and as his psychosis worsened he began to associate practice

worsened he began to associate practice

worsened he began to associate practice we’re building up towards cutting in

we’re building up towards cutting in

we’re building up towards cutting in self-harm and so something which had

self-harm and so something which had

self-harm and so something which had been really helpful for him changed and

been really helpful for him changed and

been really helpful for him changed and became extremely unhelpful same action

became extremely unhelpful same action

became extremely unhelpful same action same intention he really just wanted to

same intention he really just wanted to

same intention he really just wanted to feel better but a very different outcome

feel better but a very different outcome

feel better but a very different outcome so we worked together in music therapy

so we worked together in music therapy

so we worked together in music therapy to establish a connection with a

to establish a connection with a

to establish a connection with a healthier musical identity looking at

healthier musical identity looking at

healthier musical identity looking at different ways of using music in his

different ways of using music in his

different ways of using music in his life and establishing a sense of agency

life and establishing a sense of agency

life and establishing a sense of agency about doing that and we gradually

about doing that and we gradually

about doing that and we gradually reintroduce strumming and over time he

reintroduce strumming and over time he

reintroduce strumming and over time he was able to keep drumming again without

was able to keep drumming again without

was able to keep drumming again without triggering the desire to self-harm but

triggering the desire to self-harm but

triggering the desire to self-harm but it took time and it took commitment this

it took time and it took commitment this

it took time and it took commitment this therapy usually does there was another

therapy usually does there was another

therapy usually does there was another young woman that I worked with and she

young woman that I worked with and she

young woman that I worked with and she classically liked to listen to music as

classically liked to listen to music as

classically liked to listen to music as a way of escaping from the very

a way of escaping from the very

a way of escaping from the very dysfunctional life circumstances that

dysfunctional life circumstances that

dysfunctional life circumstances that she found herself in and so instead she

she found herself in and so instead she

she found herself in and so instead she would focus on lyrics about love and

would focus on lyrics about love and

would focus on lyrics about love and hope and other things that we all like

hope and other things that we all like

hope and other things that we all like to think about but as she escaped she

to think about but as she escaped she

to think about but as she escaped she also disconnected from some pretty

also disconnected from some pretty

also disconnected from some pretty important life functions like eating and

important life functions like eating and

important life functions like eating and then she began to compare her own body

then she began to compare her own body

then she began to compare her own body unfavorably to the pop idols who she

unfavorably to the pop idols who she

unfavorably to the pop idols who she worships even though she’d managed an

worships even though she’d managed an

worships even though she’d managed an astonishing and very unhealthy loss of

astonishing and very unhealthy loss of

astonishing and very unhealthy loss of weight during that period of time so

weight during that period of time so

weight during that period of time so then we worked together using song

then we worked together using song

then we worked together using song writing in that case to write a new

writing in that case to write a new

writing in that case to write a new narrative for her life that began by

narrative for her life that began by

narrative for her life that began by acknowledging the complexity and the

acknowledging the complexity and the

acknowledging the complexity and the darkness that she was living with at

darkness that she was living with at

darkness that she was living with at that time but stepped gradually towards

that time but stepped gradually towards

that time but stepped gradually towards something more hopeful again as a part

something more hopeful again as a part

something more hopeful again as a part of long-term treatment so neither of

of long-term treatment so neither of

of long-term treatment so neither of these two young people were at the

these two young people were at the

these two young people were at the effect of music making them feel worse

effect of music making them feel worse

effect of music making them feel worse but both of them used music as a way of

but both of them used music as a way of

but both of them used music as a way of supporting their journey into the

supporting their journey into the

supporting their journey into the darkness

darkness

darkness and in both cases they used it very

and in both cases they used it very

and in both cases they used it very successfully despite not intentionally

successfully despite not intentionally

successfully despite not intentionally meaning to do it that way so the next

meaning to do it that way so the next

meaning to do it that way so the next time you’re listening to music it’s

time you’re listening to music it’s

time you’re listening to music it’s still a great thing to do it’s a wonder

still a great thing to do it’s a wonder

still a great thing to do it’s a wonder way to match the mood for all I ask is

way to match the mood for all I ask is

way to match the mood for all I ask is that you notice whether or not your

that you notice whether or not your

that you notice whether or not your intentions are being actualized through

intentions are being actualized through

intentions are being actualized through your music use because it doesn’t happen

your music use because it doesn’t happen

your music use because it doesn’t happen by magic so if you want to use music to

by magic so if you want to use music to

by magic so if you want to use music to feel better

feel better

feel better great did it work if it didn’t work

great did it work if it didn’t work

great did it work if it didn’t work straight away and you’re happy to wait a

straight away and you’re happy to wait a

straight away and you’re happy to wait a little bit and spend more time there did

little bit and spend more time there did

little bit and spend more time there did it work eventually and if you want to

it work eventually and if you want to

it work eventually and if you want to use music to make you feel worse which

use music to make you feel worse which

use music to make you feel worse which we often do then notice when you’ve had

we often do then notice when you’ve had

we often do then notice when you’ve had enough time there how you might use

enough time there how you might use

enough time there how you might use music to step away again when I’m

music to step away again when I’m

music to step away again when I’m working with young people we often kind

working with young people we often kind

working with young people we often kind of actualize that process by creating

of actualize that process by creating

of actualize that process by creating playlists together so we start with

playlists together so we start with

playlists together so we start with songs that mirror and validate the

songs that mirror and validate the

songs that mirror and validate the intensity of the darkest feelings and

intensity of the darkest feelings and

intensity of the darkest feelings and then we choose more songs from their

then we choose more songs from their

then we choose more songs from their favorite preferred repertoire and we

favorite preferred repertoire and we

favorite preferred repertoire and we step them gradually away towards

step them gradually away towards

step them gradually away towards something that’s more hopeful so that

something that’s more hopeful so that

something that’s more hopeful so that they have a pathway out of their dark

they have a pathway out of their dark

they have a pathway out of their dark feelings in case they get stuck there I

feelings in case they get stuck there I

feelings in case they get stuck there I remember overly worked with one young

remember overly worked with one young

remember overly worked with one young man who decided he would reprogram his

man who decided he would reprogram his

man who decided he would reprogram his favorite music use once he realized that

favorite music use once he realized that

favorite music use once he realized that he was using it in an unhealthy way and

he was using it in an unhealthy way and

he was using it in an unhealthy way and then actually his favorite songs had

then actually his favorite songs had

then actually his favorite songs had become associated with trauma in his

become associated with trauma in his

become associated with trauma in his life and when he listened to the songs

life and when he listened to the songs

life and when he listened to the songs he felt retraumatization is expand have

he felt retraumatization is expand have

he felt retraumatization is expand have positive thoughts and then if he had a

positive thoughts and then if he had a

positive thoughts and then if he had a good time if it all worked out well and

good time if it all worked out well and

good time if it all worked out well and he had a good time when he drive home

he had a good time when he drive home

he had a good time when he drive home again he would play those songs again

again he would play those songs again

again he would play those songs again and he effectively reprogrammed his own

and he effectively reprogrammed his own

and he effectively reprogrammed his own music use because he really wanted to

music use because he really wanted to

music use because he really wanted to keep listening to those songs so I

keep listening to those songs so I

keep listening to those songs so I encourage you when you’re using music to

encourage you when you’re using music to

encourage you when you’re using music to keep it up

keep it up

keep it up it’s a great access accessible resource

it’s a great access accessible resource

it’s a great access accessible resource in our world more freely available to us

in our world more freely available to us

in our world more freely available to us now than it has ever been so it’s a

now than it has ever been so it’s a

now than it has ever been so it’s a wonderful opportunity in a great time

wonderful opportunity in a great time

wonderful opportunity in a great time but just to be conscious of the fact

but just to be conscious of the fact

but just to be conscious of the fact that you were the one who is responsible

that you were the one who is responsible

that you were the one who is responsible for how you use music and that if you

for how you use music and that if you

for how you use music and that if you choose to use music to take yourself

choose to use music to take yourself

choose to use music to take yourself into the dark side just remember to use

into the dark side just remember to use

into the dark side just remember to use it

it

it bring you back again hmm thank you

bring you back again hmm thank you

bring you back again hmm thank you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *