Press "Enter" to skip to content

Refugee Resettlement: Burden or Bargain? | Ghulam Kehar | TEDxUniversityofHouston


the US refugee resettlement system has

the US refugee resettlement system has been operational and active since 1948

been operational and active since 1948

been operational and active since 1948 men women and children from all parts of

men women and children from all parts of

men women and children from all parts of the globe had been resettled to this

the globe had been resettled to this

the globe had been resettled to this great land of opportunity through this

great land of opportunity through this

great land of opportunity through this program according to the refugee

program according to the refugee

program according to the refugee processing center which is the State

processing center which is the State

processing center which is the State Department agency that monitors

Department agency that monitors

Department agency that monitors resettlement since 1975 more than 3.3

resettlement since 1975 more than 3.3

resettlement since 1975 more than 3.3 million new Americans have been added to

million new Americans have been added to

million new Americans have been added to our population through this program

our population through this program

our population through this program prior to the Syrian refugee crisis this

prior to the Syrian refugee crisis this

prior to the Syrian refugee crisis this program was unknown in the public sphere

program was unknown in the public sphere

program was unknown in the public sphere it started to get attention when the

it started to get attention when the

it started to get attention when the image of Alan Cody took the world by

image of Alan Cody took the world by

image of Alan Cody took the world by storm the image of a lifeless boy

storm the image of a lifeless boy

storm the image of a lifeless boy facedown dead on a beach in Turkey he

facedown dead on a beach in Turkey he

facedown dead on a beach in Turkey he drowned

drowned

drowned seeking refuge this prompted a global

seeking refuge this prompted a global

seeking refuge this prompted a global call to action and people looked to the

call to action and people looked to the

call to action and people looked to the US to take in more refugees through

US to take in more refugees through

US to take in more refugees through their resettlement program but many

their resettlement program but many

their resettlement program but many Americans led by our current president

Americans led by our current president

Americans led by our current president started to criticize the system for

started to criticize the system for

started to criticize the system for being a security threat and a financial

being a security threat and a financial

being a security threat and a financial burden let’s put aside the fact that we

burden let’s put aside the fact that we

burden let’s put aside the fact that we are talking about human beings here

are talking about human beings here

are talking about human beings here let’s put aside the moral justification

let’s put aside the moral justification

let’s put aside the moral justification let’s put aside the fact that these are

let’s put aside the fact that these are

let’s put aside the fact that these are vulnerable desperate stateless people

vulnerable desperate stateless people

vulnerable desperate stateless people let’s ignore that for a moment

let’s ignore that for a moment

let’s ignore that for a moment and let’s do the numbers because that’s

and let’s do the numbers because that’s

and let’s do the numbers because that’s what people seem to understand as of yet

what people seem to understand as of yet

what people seem to understand as of yet there is no comprehensive clear and

there is no comprehensive clear and

there is no comprehensive clear and precise way to measure the exact cost

precise way to measure the exact cost

precise way to measure the exact cost and the exact value of the refugee

and the exact value of the refugee

and the exact value of the refugee resettlement system on the national

resettlement system on the national

resettlement system on the national level however there is enough data and

level however there is enough data and

level however there is enough data and research to conduct a basic analysis

research to conduct a basic analysis

research to conduct a basic analysis let’s take two

let’s take two

let’s take two thousand 14 as an example in 2014 The

thousand 14 as an example in 2014 The

thousand 14 as an example in 2014 The Washington Post reported that the Office

Washington Post reported that the Office

Washington Post reported that the Office of refugee resettlement the agency that

of refugee resettlement the agency that

of refugee resettlement the agency that provides resettlement in this country

provides resettlement in this country

provides resettlement in this country spent about five hundred and eighty two

spent about five hundred and eighty two

spent about five hundred and eighty two million dollars to resettle 70,000

million dollars to resettle 70,000

million dollars to resettle 70,000 refugees let’s tag on another seventy

refugees let’s tag on another seventy

refugees let’s tag on another seventy million dollars and make it six hundred

million dollars and make it six hundred

million dollars and make it six hundred and fifty four cost that may not be

and fifty four cost that may not be

and fifty four cost that may not be included such as travel the it cost the

included such as travel the it cost the

included such as travel the it cost the US government six hundred and fifty

US government six hundred and fifty

US government six hundred and fifty million dollars to increase our

million dollars to increase our

million dollars to increase our population by seven thousand in 2014

population by seven thousand in 2014

population by seven thousand in 2014 federal expenditure was three point two

federal expenditure was three point two

federal expenditure was three point two three trillion dollars refugee

three trillion dollars refugee

three trillion dollars refugee resettlement as a percentage zero point

resettlement as a percentage zero point

resettlement as a percentage zero point zero zero zero two percent if every

zero zero zero two percent if every

zero zero zero two percent if every American citizen or every American in

American citizen or every American in

American citizen or every American in this country at the time which was three

this country at the time which was three

this country at the time which was three hundred and eighteen million dollars

hundred and eighteen million dollars

hundred and eighteen million dollars contributed to this program it would

contributed to this program it would

contributed to this program it would cost each American two dollars and five

cost each American two dollars and five

cost each American two dollars and five cents but every American is not a

cents but every American is not a

cents but every American is not a taxpaying citizen in 2014 there were

taxpaying citizen in 2014 there were

taxpaying citizen in 2014 there were approximately 139 taxpaying citizens the

approximately 139 taxpaying citizens the

approximately 139 taxpaying citizens the average tax bill was nine thousand eight

average tax bill was nine thousand eight

average tax bill was nine thousand eight hundred and fifty six dollars of that

hundred and fifty six dollars of that

hundred and fifty six dollars of that four dollars and sixty seven cents went

four dollars and sixty seven cents went

four dollars and sixty seven cents went to the u.s. refugee resettlement program

to the u.s. refugee resettlement program

to the u.s. refugee resettlement program so for four dollars and sixty seven

so for four dollars and sixty seven

so for four dollars and sixty seven cents per taxpaying citizen we increased

cents per taxpaying citizen we increased

cents per taxpaying citizen we increased our population by seventy thousand

our population by seventy thousand

our population by seventy thousand roughly half of the 70,000 were children

roughly half of the 70,000 were children

roughly half of the 70,000 were children the other half were men and women

the other half were men and women

the other half were men and women skilled and unskilled that at some point

skilled and unskilled that at some point

skilled and unskilled that at some point were joined joined the labor force we

were joined joined the labor force we

were joined joined the labor force we looked at the cost which is great what

looked at the cost which is great what

looked at the cost which is great what about the value let’s look at a real

about the value let’s look at a real

about the value let’s look at a real exam

exam

exam Erie Pennsylvania a small town of a

Erie Pennsylvania a small town of a

Erie Pennsylvania a small town of a hundred thousand a manufacturing company

hundred thousand a manufacturing company

hundred thousand a manufacturing company called sterling technologies has many

called sterling technologies has many

called sterling technologies has many well-paying jobs available but they’re

well-paying jobs available but they’re

well-paying jobs available but they’re struggling to fill them why the

struggling to fill them why the

struggling to fill them why the applicants don’t seem to can’t seem to

applicants don’t seem to can’t seem to

applicants don’t seem to can’t seem to pass a drug test there’s a drug epidemic

pass a drug test there’s a drug epidemic

pass a drug test there’s a drug epidemic in that city so they have all these jobs

in that city so they have all these jobs

in that city so they have all these jobs and no one to fill them so they reached

and no one to fill them so they reached

and no one to fill them so they reached out to the refugee resettlement

out to the refugee resettlement

out to the refugee resettlement organizations in the area and started

organizations in the area and started

organizations in the area and started hiring some of them quickly resettled

hiring some of them quickly resettled

hiring some of them quickly resettled refugees became a majority of their

refugees became a majority of their

refugees became a majority of their workforce Erie Pennsylvania and the

workforce Erie Pennsylvania and the

workforce Erie Pennsylvania and the senior management of this company all

senior management of this company all

senior management of this company all voted for the current administration but

voted for the current administration but

voted for the current administration but they oppose any ban or reduction in

they oppose any ban or reduction in

they oppose any ban or reduction in refugee resettlement they because they

refugee resettlement they because they

refugee resettlement they because they have seen the financial benefit of it

have seen the financial benefit of it

have seen the financial benefit of it firsthand this is taking place across

firsthand this is taking place across

firsthand this is taking place across the country from Utica New York to

the country from Utica New York to

the country from Utica New York to Louisville Kentucky employers are seeing

Louisville Kentucky employers are seeing

Louisville Kentucky employers are seeing and realizing that we have an entire

and realizing that we have an entire

and realizing that we have an entire population entering the workforce that

population entering the workforce that

population entering the workforce that has a strong work ethic which makes them

has a strong work ethic which makes them

has a strong work ethic which makes them a valuable part of the workforce a

little known fact about the u.s. refugee

little known fact about the u.s. refugee resettlement system every resembled

resettlement system every resembled

resettlement system every resembled refugee has to pay back the US

refugee has to pay back the US

refugee has to pay back the US government the cost of the airfare to

government the cost of the airfare to

government the cost of the airfare to get here every single one of them and

get here every single one of them and

get here every single one of them and the State Department reports that since

the State Department reports that since

the State Department reports that since nineteen eighty eight hundred and

nineteen eighty eight hundred and

nineteen eighty eight hundred and seventy-six million dollars has been

seventy-six million dollars has been

seventy-six million dollars has been paid back to this day every single month

paid back to this day every single month

paid back to this day every single month resettled refugees are paying the

resettled refugees are paying the

resettled refugees are paying the government back a Department of Health

government back a Department of Health

government back a Department of Health and Human Services report estimated that

and Human Services report estimated that

and Human Services report estimated that between 2005 and 2014 the fiscal benefit

between 2005 and 2014 the fiscal benefit

between 2005 and 2014 the fiscal benefit of the US refugee resettlement program

of the US refugee resettlement program

of the US refugee resettlement program was a net sixty three billion dollars on

was a net sixty three billion dollars on

was a net sixty three billion dollars on this economy

this economy

this economy the current administration as expected

the current administration as expected

the current administration as expected quickly dismissed that report to be

quickly dismissed that report to be

quickly dismissed that report to be illegitimate and politically motivated

illegitimate and politically motivated

illegitimate and politically motivated but I want us to pause for a moment and

but I want us to pause for a moment and

but I want us to pause for a moment and see the situation we find ourselves in

see the situation we find ourselves in

see the situation we find ourselves in today we the United States of America

today we the United States of America

today we the United States of America the most prosperous and powerful nation

the most prosperous and powerful nation

the most prosperous and powerful nation on earth are looking at the most

on earth are looking at the most

on earth are looking at the most helpless people on earth and telling

helpless people on earth and telling

helpless people on earth and telling them what’s in it for me

them what’s in it for me

them what’s in it for me how do I benefit from giving you

how do I benefit from giving you

how do I benefit from giving you security a basic human right this cannot

security a basic human right this cannot

security a basic human right this cannot be our moral standard this is

be our moral standard this is

be our moral standard this is contradictory to the values that we’ve

contradictory to the values that we’ve

contradictory to the values that we’ve clearly stated give me your tired your

clearly stated give me your tired your

clearly stated give me your tired your poor the huddled masses yearning to

poor the huddled masses yearning to

poor the huddled masses yearning to breathe free the refugee resettlement

breathe free the refugee resettlement

breathe free the refugee resettlement program by no means is perfect it needs

program by no means is perfect it needs

program by no means is perfect it needs a lot of improvement and it is vastly

a lot of improvement and it is vastly

a lot of improvement and it is vastly more complicated than simple math but

more complicated than simple math but

more complicated than simple math but the u.s. refugee resettlement program is

the u.s. refugee resettlement program is

the u.s. refugee resettlement program is enriching our country it is not a burden

enriching our country it is not a burden

enriching our country it is not a burden it is one heck of a bargain it is a

it is one heck of a bargain it is a

it is one heck of a bargain it is a bargain which is adding to the diversity

bargain which is adding to the diversity

bargain which is adding to the diversity of our population contributing to our

of our population contributing to our

of our population contributing to our economic future and helping us fulfill

economic future and helping us fulfill

economic future and helping us fulfill our moral responsibility as a people we

our moral responsibility as a people we

our moral responsibility as a people we must support the program we must work to

must support the program we must work to

must support the program we must work to improve it and we must do everything in

improve it and we must do everything in

improve it and we must do everything in our power to expand it thank you

our power to expand it thank you

our power to expand it thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *