Press "Enter" to skip to content

Race and the Leave Campaign | Rachel Epstein | TEDxDenisonU


in 1969 after a tumultuous application

in 1969 after a tumultuous application process involving two vetoed

process involving two vetoed

process involving two vetoed applications by France the United

applications by France the United

applications by France the United Kingdom became an accepted member of the

Kingdom became an accepted member of the

Kingdom became an accepted member of the European Union this decision was upheld

European Union this decision was upheld

European Union this decision was upheld in 1975 when the British public voted

in 1975 when the British public voted

in 1975 when the British public voted 67% in favor of a unified European

67% in favor of a unified European

67% in favor of a unified European community in the wake of World War two

community in the wake of World War two

community in the wake of World War two unification therefore became a strategy

unification therefore became a strategy

unification therefore became a strategy for political power and more importantly

for political power and more importantly

for political power and more importantly British survival in a tense and changing

British survival in a tense and changing

British survival in a tense and changing global climate fast forward now to June

global climate fast forward now to June

global climate fast forward now to June 23rd 2016 when the UK voted to reverse

23rd 2016 when the UK voted to reverse

23rd 2016 when the UK voted to reverse 41 years of membership in the European

41 years of membership in the European

41 years of membership in the European Union with a leave vote of 51.9%

Union with a leave vote of 51.9%

Union with a leave vote of 51.9% to 48.1% essentially after the 2008

to 48.1% essentially after the 2008

to 48.1% essentially after the 2008 financial crash pared itself with

financial crash pared itself with

financial crash pared itself with skepticism over power transfers from

skepticism over power transfers from

skepticism over power transfers from Parliament to Brussels the public’s

Parliament to Brussels the public’s

Parliament to Brussels the public’s concerned over bureaucratic meltdown and

concerned over bureaucratic meltdown and

concerned over bureaucratic meltdown and border control pushed then Prime

border control pushed then Prime

border control pushed then Prime Minister David Cameron to promise a

Minister David Cameron to promise a

Minister David Cameron to promise a referendum although some argue that the

referendum although some argue that the

referendum although some argue that the referendum was purely a way to appease

referendum was purely a way to appease

referendum was purely a way to appease other political parties on the right

other political parties on the right

other political parties on the right this monumental decision will likely

this monumental decision will likely

this monumental decision will likely stay in Britain’s future with an intense

stay in Britain’s future with an intense

stay in Britain’s future with an intense mark of disagreement over how the

mark of disagreement over how the

mark of disagreement over how the country both functions and supports all

country both functions and supports all

country both functions and supports all citizens residing in the UK and in the

citizens residing in the UK and in the

citizens residing in the UK and in the broader EU as a British citizen myself

broader EU as a British citizen myself

broader EU as a British citizen myself who voted to remain in the EU this past

who voted to remain in the EU this past

who voted to remain in the EU this past June

June

June I found myself drawn to the other side’s

I found myself drawn to the other side’s

I found myself drawn to the other side’s campaign’s racial use of language

campaign’s racial use of language

campaign’s racial use of language now I’m when it boils down to it I’m not

now I’m when it boils down to it I’m not

now I’m when it boils down to it I’m not just upset that Britain chose to leave

just upset that Britain chose to leave

just upset that Britain chose to leave the EU I’m angry about the tactics they

the EU I’m angry about the tactics they

the EU I’m angry about the tactics they used to get there using the ideology

used to get there using the ideology

used to get there using the ideology that immigrants were sucking resources

that immigrants were sucking resources

that immigrants were sucking resources from the National Health Service as a

from the National Health Service as a

from the National Health Service as a way to promote white society the leave

way to promote white society the leave

way to promote white society the leave campaign showed one group as more

campaign showed one group as more

campaign showed one group as more deserving because they were in some way

deserving because they were in some way

deserving because they were in some way more British than their non-immigrant

more British than their non-immigrant

more British than their non-immigrant peers now pairing this idea with a

peers now pairing this idea with a

peers now pairing this idea with a strong sense of national identity this

strong sense of national identity this

strong sense of national identity this ideology played on fears that the fruits

ideology played on fears that the fruits

ideology played on fears that the fruits of one groups hard work would be taken

of one groups hard work would be taken

of one groups hard work would be taken from them by people they had willingly

from them by people they had willingly

from them by people they had willingly accepted into the country but were for

accepted into the country but were for

accepted into the country but were for whatever reason seen as less British due

whatever reason seen as less British due

whatever reason seen as less British due to their origin this sentiment could not

to their origin this sentiment could not

to their origin this sentiment could not be seen more clearly than from Michael

be seen more clearly than from Michael

be seen more clearly than from Michael Gove statement in The Times because we

Gove statement in The Times because we

Gove statement in The Times because we cannot protect our borders public

cannot protect our borders public

cannot protect our borders public services such as the NHS will face an

services such as the NHS will face an

services such as the NHS will face an unquantifiable strength further in a

unquantifiable strength further in a

unquantifiable strength further in a study conducted by the independent

study conducted by the independent

study conducted by the independent research organization if sis Maureen

research organization if sis Maureen

research organization if sis Maureen where 1000 British citizens were asked

where 1000 British citizens were asked

where 1000 British citizens were asked the question out of every 100 residents

the question out of every 100 residents

the question out of every 100 residents in the UK how many do you think were

in the UK how many do you think were

in the UK how many do you think were born in EU member states other than the

born in EU member states other than the

born in EU member states other than the UK regs Eaters responded that they

UK regs Eaters responded that they

UK regs Eaters responded that they believe 20% of UK residents to be EU

believe 20% of UK residents to be EU

believe 20% of UK residents to be EU immigrants now the actual figure is just

immigrants now the actual figure is just

immigrants now the actual figure is just slightly less than 5% so in my opinion

slightly less than 5% so in my opinion

slightly less than 5% so in my opinion this narratives can best be explained

this narratives can best be explained

this narratives can best be explained through the idea of identity stories so

through the idea of identity stories so

through the idea of identity stories so what is an identity story basically when

what is an identity story basically when

what is an identity story basically when good and bad narratives become

good and bad narratives become

good and bad narratives become objectified in material form people buy

objectified in material form people buy

objectified in material form people buy into and then create societally

into and then create societally

into and then create societally acceptable identities take for instance

acceptable identities take for instance

acceptable identities take for instance the identity story of being a good

the identity story of being a good

the identity story of being a good neighbor this allegory goes as far back

neighbor this allegory goes as far back

neighbor this allegory goes as far back as the Bible and it exists as a stable

as the Bible and it exists as a stable

as the Bible and it exists as a stable narrative for ideas like kindness

narrative for ideas like kindness

narrative for ideas like kindness morality and positivity we even

morality and positivity we even

morality and positivity we even construct images of being a good

construct images of being a good

construct images of being a good neighbor like taking a pie to a

neighbor like taking a pie to a

neighbor like taking a pie to a neighbor’s home and they’ve just moved

neighbor’s home and they’ve just moved

neighbor’s home and they’ve just moved in or watering a neighbor’s plants when

in or watering a neighbor’s plants when

in or watering a neighbor’s plants when they leave for vacation in fact this

they leave for vacation in fact this

they leave for vacation in fact this common identity story is global the

common identity story is global the

common identity story is global the Italians call it Bravo gender thanks to

Italians call it Bravo gender thanks to

Italians call it Bravo gender thanks to the leave campaign immigrants were

the leave campaign immigrants were

the leave campaign immigrants were suddenly being viewed as bad neighbors

suddenly being viewed as bad neighbors

suddenly being viewed as bad neighbors so what does this mean basically the

so what does this mean basically the

so what does this mean basically the former London Mayor Boris Johnson was

former London Mayor Boris Johnson was

former London Mayor Boris Johnson was one of the key proponents for furthering

one of the key proponents for furthering

one of the key proponents for furthering the leave campaigns narrative on

the leave campaigns narrative on

the leave campaigns narrative on immigration while the campaign itself

immigration while the campaign itself

immigration while the campaign itself touted misinformation and false

touted misinformation and false

touted misinformation and false prediction for immigration statistics if

prediction for immigration statistics if

prediction for immigration statistics if Britain were to remain a member state

Britain were to remain a member state

Britain were to remain a member state Johnson supported the campaign’s claims

Johnson supported the campaign’s claims

Johnson supported the campaign’s claims that Turkey was close to joining the EU

that Turkey was close to joining the EU

that Turkey was close to joining the EU citing the country itself as a direct

citing the country itself as a direct

citing the country itself as a direct risk to national security with this

risk to national security with this

risk to national security with this false assertion the leave campaign

false assertion the leave campaign

false assertion the leave campaign furthered the narrative publishing

furthered the narrative publishing

furthered the narrative publishing posters citing Turkey’s location on a

posters citing Turkey’s location on a

posters citing Turkey’s location on a map and questioning the risk to national

map and questioning the risk to national

map and questioning the risk to national security Turkey might possess given its

security Turkey might possess given its

security Turkey might possess given its proximity to unstable hotspots like Iraq

proximity to unstable hotspots like Iraq

proximity to unstable hotspots like Iraq and Syria perhaps even more distressing

and Syria perhaps even more distressing

and Syria perhaps even more distressing a figure was Nigel Faraj another key

a figure was Nigel Faraj another key

a figure was Nigel Faraj another key leave leader who supported publication

leave leader who supported publication

leave leader who supported publication of a poster entitled breaking point

of a poster entitled breaking point

of a poster entitled breaking point featuring hundreds of Arab people

featuring hundreds of Arab people

featuring hundreds of Arab people swarming in a large crowd with the

swarming in a large crowd with the

swarming in a large crowd with the caption take back control in an

caption take back control in an

caption take back control in an interview with the BBC former Minister

interview with the BBC former Minister

interview with the BBC former Minister of State for faith and communities

of State for faith and communities

of State for faith and communities fairness Aida warsi was quoted saying

fairness Aida warsi was quoted saying

fairness Aida warsi was quoted saying this kind of nudge-nudge wink-wink

this kind of nudge-nudge wink-wink

this kind of nudge-nudge wink-wink xenophobic racist campaign may be

xenophobic racist campaign may be

xenophobic racist campaign may be politically savvy or useful in the short

politically savvy or useful in the short

politically savvy or useful in the short term but it causes long-term damage to

term but it causes long-term damage to

term but it causes long-term damage to communities but is this kind of public

communities but is this kind of public

communities but is this kind of public racism new

racism new

racism new the simple answer is no the narrative

the simple answer is no the narrative

the simple answer is no the narrative used by the leave campaign is not a

used by the leave campaign is not a

used by the leave campaign is not a foreign concept to the British public

foreign concept to the British public

foreign concept to the British public the media have been cultivating and

the media have been cultivating and

the media have been cultivating and perpetuating the same story in a public

perpetuating the same story in a public

perpetuating the same story in a public space for years and years fine-tuning

space for years and years fine-tuning

space for years and years fine-tuning language – perfectly encompass that kind

language – perfectly encompass that kind

language – perfectly encompass that kind of wink wink racist rhetoric however

of wink wink racist rhetoric however

of wink wink racist rhetoric however this message is far more deeply rooted

this message is far more deeply rooted

this message is far more deeply rooted implicit and settled in the leave

implicit and settled in the leave

implicit and settled in the leave campaign strategies in one 2008 study

campaign strategies in one 2008 study

campaign strategies in one 2008 study researchers analyzed over 140 million

researchers analyzed over 140 million

researchers analyzed over 140 million words of British media text on refugees

words of British media text on refugees

words of British media text on refugees asylum seekers immigrants and migrants

asylum seekers immigrants and migrants

asylum seekers immigrants and migrants collectively referred to as race in to

collectively referred to as race in to

collectively referred to as race in to reveal that racial eccentricities were

reveal that racial eccentricities were

reveal that racial eccentricities were ever-present in British journalistic

ever-present in British journalistic

ever-present in British journalistic language a language that is ultimately

language a language that is ultimately

language a language that is ultimately meant to be objective specifically the

meant to be objective specifically the

meant to be objective specifically the researchers wanted to know if racism

researchers wanted to know if racism

researchers wanted to know if racism really was linguistically defined and

really was linguistically defined and

really was linguistically defined and constructed by the press as well as if

constructed by the press as well as if

constructed by the press as well as if attitudes towards racism emerged from UK

attitudes towards racism emerged from UK

attitudes towards racism emerged from UK newspapers through these various

newspapers through these various

newspapers through these various linguistic objectives the study indeed

linguistic objectives the study indeed

linguistic objectives the study indeed found that the press had defined the

found that the press had defined the

found that the press had defined the story of racism through the pollution of

story of racism through the pollution of

story of racism through the pollution of language words like aloud as in allowed

language words like aloud as in allowed

language words like aloud as in allowed into Britain or references to a convoy

into Britain or references to a convoy

into Britain or references to a convoy or an army of immigrants clearly define

or an army of immigrants clearly define

or an army of immigrants clearly define an expected epistemic norm of how these

an expected epistemic norm of how these

an expected epistemic norm of how these groups were to be considered now

groups were to be considered now

groups were to be considered now interestingly the narrative appeared

interestingly the narrative appeared

interestingly the narrative appeared across broadsheet published press and

across broadsheet published press and

across broadsheet published press and tabloids so we know that the story is

tabloids so we know that the story is

tabloids so we know that the story is everywhere it transcends demographics

everywhere it transcends demographics

everywhere it transcends demographics and audiences and it’s communal effect

and audiences and it’s communal effect

and audiences and it’s communal effect on the perception of immigrants is

on the perception of immigrants is

on the perception of immigrants is obvious so what happens is when you take

obvious so what happens is when you take

obvious so what happens is when you take this racist narrative and you pair it

this racist narrative and you pair it

this racist narrative and you pair it with the most nationalist and socialist

with the most nationalist and socialist

with the most nationalist and socialist institution of Britain the National

institution of Britain the National

institution of Britain the National Health Service it seems that there’s a

Health Service it seems that there’s a

Health Service it seems that there’s a strong correlation between concerns over

strong correlation between concerns over

strong correlation between concerns over immigration policy in England and

immigration policy in England and

immigration policy in England and concerns over the success of the NHS in

concerns over the success of the NHS in

concerns over the success of the NHS in 2015 the University of Oxford’s

2015 the University of Oxford’s

2015 the University of Oxford’s migration Observatory on UK public

migration Observatory on UK public

migration Observatory on UK public opinion towards immigration held a

opinion towards immigration held a

opinion towards immigration held a survey focused on these overall

survey focused on these overall

survey focused on these overall attitudes and level of concern when the

attitudes and level of concern when the

attitudes and level of concern when the public were asked what they thought the

public were asked what they thought the

public were asked what they thought the greatest threat to British success were

greatest threat to British success were

greatest threat to British success were most of them said and there was a steady

most of them said and there was a steady

most of them said and there was a steady trend pattern that followed that

trend pattern that followed that

trend pattern that followed that immigration policy was at the top

immigration policy was at the top

immigration policy was at the top concern along with success for the NHS

concern along with success for the NHS

concern along with success for the NHS in fact concerns over immigration policy

in fact concerns over immigration policy

in fact concerns over immigration policy ranks slightly higher than concerns for

ranks slightly higher than concerns for

ranks slightly higher than concerns for the NHS by just 5% now at first the

the NHS by just 5% now at first the

the NHS by just 5% now at first the leave campaign intertwine these top two

leave campaign intertwine these top two

leave campaign intertwine these top two concerns with an air

concerns with an air

concerns with an air of subtlety about a month before the

of subtlety about a month before the

of subtlety about a month before the boat Boris Johnson released a statement

boat Boris Johnson released a statement

boat Boris Johnson released a statement including only one line on immigration

including only one line on immigration

including only one line on immigration in the NHS quote it is intolerable to

in the NHS quote it is intolerable to

in the NHS quote it is intolerable to continue without Democratic consent for

continue without Democratic consent for

continue without Democratic consent for Britain’s immigration policy that is

Britain’s immigration policy that is

Britain’s immigration policy that is what will be best for our public

what will be best for our public

what will be best for our public services particularly the NHS Johnson

services particularly the NHS Johnson

services particularly the NHS Johnson was likely referring to a quote that

was likely referring to a quote that

was likely referring to a quote that took the front page on the vote leave

took the front page on the vote leave

took the front page on the vote leave take calm take control Tom’s website

take calm take control Tom’s website

take calm take control Tom’s website that pointed out that 2 billion pounds a

that pointed out that 2 billion pounds a

that pointed out that 2 billion pounds a year was being spent from the NHS on

year was being spent from the NHS on

year was being spent from the NHS on immigrant and immigrant families however

immigrant and immigrant families however

immigrant and immigrant families however following the campaign’s trend of

following the campaign’s trend of

following the campaign’s trend of misinformation this statement neglects

misinformation this statement neglects

misinformation this statement neglects to mention that the overall budget for

to mention that the overall budget for

to mention that the overall budget for the NHS is 113 billion pounds a year

the NHS is 113 billion pounds a year

the NHS is 113 billion pounds a year which means that support for immigrants

which means that support for immigrants

which means that support for immigrants and their families clocks in at just 2%

and their families clocks in at just 2%

and their families clocks in at just 2% of the entire budget now it seems that

of the entire budget now it seems that

of the entire budget now it seems that the leave campaign successfully told a

the leave campaign successfully told a

the leave campaign successfully told a story that led to a rise in ethnic

story that led to a rise in ethnic

story that led to a rise in ethnic nationalism and as a result dissolved UK

nationalism and as a result dissolved UK

nationalism and as a result dissolved UK membership in the European Union as a

membership in the European Union as a

membership in the European Union as a reporter for the International Business

reporter for the International Business

reporter for the International Business Times James Bloodworth points out in an

Times James Bloodworth points out in an

Times James Bloodworth points out in an interview with NPR hostility towards

interview with NPR hostility towards

interview with NPR hostility towards immigration and by extension hostility

immigration and by extension hostility

immigration and by extension hostility to Europe is driven by cultural concerns

to Europe is driven by cultural concerns

to Europe is driven by cultural concerns as much as by economic worries that is

as much as by economic worries that is

as much as by economic worries that is certainly what we see here and in

certainly what we see here and in

certainly what we see here and in essence it is whether or not England

essence it is whether or not England

essence it is whether or not England feels like England the rhetoric used to

feels like England the rhetoric used to

feels like England the rhetoric used to illustrate these economic and cultural

illustrate these economic and cultural

illustrate these economic and cultural concerns was no doubt as clever as it

concerns was no doubt as clever as it

concerns was no doubt as clever as it was xenophobic multiracial nationalism

was xenophobic multiracial nationalism

was xenophobic multiracial nationalism continues to overpower multiracial

continues to overpower multiracial

continues to overpower multiracial success in the UK and the EU referendum

success in the UK and the EU referendum

success in the UK and the EU referendum is yet another example of brutal anti

is yet another example of brutal anti

is yet another example of brutal anti immigration policy overlaid with a

immigration policy overlaid with a

immigration policy overlaid with a racist mentality and it just goes to

racist mentality and it just goes to

racist mentality and it just goes to show that race is indeed a direct

show that race is indeed a direct

show that race is indeed a direct proponent of class hierarchy and social

proponent of class hierarchy and social

proponent of class hierarchy and social structure while an unfortunate part of

structure while an unfortunate part of

structure while an unfortunate part of human behavior in the political system

human behavior in the political system

human behavior in the political system racial biases are used globally to

racial biases are used globally to

racial biases are used globally to divide and rank society and while the UK

divide and rank society and while the UK

divide and rank society and while the UK is a first-world developed country much

is a first-world developed country much

is a first-world developed country much like the u.s. it is not immune to the

like the u.s. it is not immune to the

like the u.s. it is not immune to the kind of racial rhetoric used to pick

kind of racial rhetoric used to pick

kind of racial rhetoric used to pick groups against each other for political

groups against each other for political

groups against each other for political motivations in the case of the EU

motivations in the case of the EU

motivations in the case of the EU referendum race was the catalyst that

referendum race was the catalyst that

referendum race was the catalyst that spurred voters are already fearful of

spurred voters are already fearful of

spurred voters are already fearful of losing their rights to truly believe

losing their rights to truly believe

losing their rights to truly believe that the campaign would be overrun by

that the campaign would be overrun by

that the campaign would be overrun by immigrants amidst

immigrants amidst

immigrants amidst facts and figures lay fierce threatening

facts and figures lay fierce threatening

facts and figures lay fierce threatening propaganda for a campaign against

propaganda for a campaign against

propaganda for a campaign against immigrants often those with different

immigrants often those with different

immigrants often those with different social customs religious backgrounds and

social customs religious backgrounds and

social customs religious backgrounds and darker skin my goal is to show how

darker skin my goal is to show how

darker skin my goal is to show how political campaigns use race to make a

political campaigns use race to make a

political campaigns use race to make a point whether or not that point is true

point whether or not that point is true

point whether or not that point is true or honorable still the most important

or honorable still the most important

or honorable still the most important point I hope to make is that with

point I hope to make is that with

point I hope to make is that with growing awareness to these ploys we as a

growing awareness to these ploys we as a

growing awareness to these ploys we as a global community can begin to change the

global community can begin to change the

global community can begin to change the face of this kind of propaganda so that

face of this kind of propaganda so that

face of this kind of propaganda so that it is based on policy and not the

it is based on policy and not the

it is based on policy and not the perpetuation of racist values thank you

perpetuation of racist values thank you

perpetuation of racist values thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *