Press "Enter" to skip to content

Neuroethics and the Study of You | Fahad Paryani | TEDxYouth@LakesideHS


in 1992 a 65 year old man by the name of

in 1992 a 65 year old man by the name of Herbert Weinstein strangled and threw

Herbert Weinstein strangled and threw

Herbert Weinstein strangled and threw his wife out of his 12 story apartment

his wife out of his 12 story apartment

his wife out of his 12 story apartment in New York City now mr. Weinstein was

in New York City now mr. Weinstein was

in New York City now mr. Weinstein was often described as a loving and outgoing

often described as a loving and outgoing

often described as a loving and outgoing person by his family members in fear but

person by his family members in fear but

person by his family members in fear but during his actual testimony in court he

during his actual testimony in court he

during his actual testimony in court he quickly admitted to his guilt and even

quickly admitted to his guilt and even

quickly admitted to his guilt and even attempt to cover up the murders so that

attempt to cover up the murders so that

attempt to cover up the murders so that it would look like a suicide but here’s

it would look like a suicide but here’s

it would look like a suicide but here’s the thing mr. Weinstein has no criminal

the thing mr. Weinstein has no criminal

the thing mr. Weinstein has no criminal history whatsoever and so this raised

history whatsoever and so this raised

history whatsoever and so this raised serious questions about the mental

serious questions about the mental

serious questions about the mental health of mr. Weinstein and even to the

health of mr. Weinstein and even to the

health of mr. Weinstein and even to the point where his lawyers that were

point where his lawyers that were

point where his lawyers that were defending him decided to get an MRI to

defending him decided to get an MRI to

defending him decided to get an MRI to see what was truly going on inside the

see what was truly going on inside the

see what was truly going on inside the mind of mr. Weinstein or the mind of a

mind of mr. Weinstein or the mind of a

mind of mr. Weinstein or the mind of a killer and so these images appear or

killer and so these images appear or

killer and so these images appear or asked for MRI scan of mr. Weinstein and

asked for MRI scan of mr. Weinstein and

asked for MRI scan of mr. Weinstein and what they found is that it seems to be

what they found is that it seems to be

what they found is that it seems to be some sort of object that seems to be

some sort of object that seems to be

some sort of object that seems to be growing deep within his brain near the

growing deep within his brain near the

growing deep within his brain near the frontal lobe and what this thing that’s

frontal lobe and what this thing that’s

frontal lobe and what this thing that’s growing is actually a cyst and inside

growing is actually a cyst and inside

growing is actually a cyst and inside the cyst it’s filled with cerebral

the cyst it’s filled with cerebral

the cyst it’s filled with cerebral spinal fluid and over time this Siskin

spinal fluid and over time this Siskin

spinal fluid and over time this Siskin begin to swell inside the brain and

begin to swell inside the brain and

begin to swell inside the brain and cause serious neurological damage to the

cause serious neurological damage to the

cause serious neurological damage to the brain and even shut down large parts of

brain and even shut down large parts of

brain and even shut down large parts of the brain and in order to confirm this

the brain and in order to confirm this

the brain and in order to confirm this finding the team then ran a PET scan and

finding the team then ran a PET scan and

finding the team then ran a PET scan and what a PET scan does measures how well

what a PET scan does measures how well

what a PET scan does measures how well the brain is functioning in different

the brain is functioning in different

the brain is functioning in different areas and indeed what they found was

areas and indeed what they found was

areas and indeed what they found was that the areas in which the cysts were

that the areas in which the cysts were

that the areas in which the cysts were growing were also the areas in which

growing were also the areas in which

growing were also the areas in which there was low to no brain activity so

there was low to no brain activity so

there was low to no brain activity so now the question in court becomes

now the question in court becomes

now the question in court becomes whether this low activity and mr.

whether this low activity and mr.

whether this low activity and mr. Weinstein friend truly coincide with the

Weinstein friend truly coincide with the

Weinstein friend truly coincide with the violence behavior we were seeing in him

violence behavior we were seeing in him

violence behavior we were seeing in him I mean unfold I mean what was happening

I mean unfold I mean what was happening

I mean unfold I mean what was happening is they didn’t know how to address this

is they didn’t know how to address this

is they didn’t know how to address this issue and unfortunately due to a lack of

issue and unfortunately due to a lack of

issue and unfortunately due to a lack of understanding of the brain during this

understanding of the brain during this

understanding of the brain during this time period and the fact that PET scan

time period and the fact that PET scan

time period and the fact that PET scan technologies were relatively new caused

technologies were relatively new caused

technologies were relatively new caused the court and

the court and

the court and to believe that there wasn’t enough

to believe that there wasn’t enough

to believe that there wasn’t enough evidence to justify what mr. Weinstein

evidence to justify what mr. Weinstein

evidence to justify what mr. Weinstein had done so as a result mr. Weinstein

had done so as a result mr. Weinstein

had done so as a result mr. Weinstein ended up serving years in prison but

ended up serving years in prison but

ended up serving years in prison but let’s take a step back let’s take a

let’s take a step back let’s take a

let’s take a step back let’s take a hypothetical situation let’s imagine if

hypothetical situation let’s imagine if

hypothetical situation let’s imagine if the surgical cyst in mr. Weinstein brain

the surgical cyst in mr. Weinstein brain

the surgical cyst in mr. Weinstein brain was to be removed surgically and I mean

was to be removed surgically and I mean

was to be removed surgically and I mean in theory mr. Weinstein would go back to

in theory mr. Weinstein would go back to

in theory mr. Weinstein would go back to being himself right and if that was the

being himself right and if that was the

being himself right and if that was the case who exactly would we be punishing

case who exactly would we be punishing

case who exactly would we be punishing in court I mean a crime has been

in court I mean a crime has been

in court I mean a crime has been committed but who’s the real criminal

committed but who’s the real criminal

committed but who’s the real criminal and if he was to be excused of this

and if he was to be excused of this

and if he was to be excused of this crime any criminal would any sort of

crime any criminal would any sort of

crime any criminal would any sort of problems in the brain can be excused of

problems in the brain can be excused of

problems in the brain can be excused of their crime and to further that

their crime and to further that

their crime and to further that statement any person with any sort of

statement any person with any sort of

statement any person with any sort of problems in their brain can be excused

problems in their brain can be excused

problems in their brain can be excused of their responsibility and that’s

of their responsibility and that’s

of their responsibility and that’s absolutely nonsense and that’s

absolutely nonsense and that’s

absolutely nonsense and that’s ridiculous

ridiculous

ridiculous so the question becomes where is the

so the question becomes where is the

so the question becomes where is the line of self control in the human mind

line of self control in the human mind

line of self control in the human mind and these were all questions that were

and these were all questions that were

and these were all questions that were being asked during this case but were

being asked during this case but were

being asked during this case but were also the very question that were setting

also the very question that were setting

also the very question that were setting up the foundation for the field of neuro

up the foundation for the field of neuro

up the foundation for the field of neuro epochs and today we know that the

epochs and today we know that the

epochs and today we know that the frontal lobe is indeed in fact

frontal lobe is indeed in fact

frontal lobe is indeed in fact responsible for many of the cognitive

responsible for many of the cognitive

responsible for many of the cognitive skills that mr. Weinstein was missing

skills that mr. Weinstein was missing

skills that mr. Weinstein was missing like emotional expressions

like emotional expressions

like emotional expressions problem-solving and even critical

problem-solving and even critical

problem-solving and even critical thinking and this makes sense because we

thinking and this makes sense because we

thinking and this makes sense because we know that the brain develops from the

know that the brain develops from the

know that the brain develops from the back to the front and what also helps to

back to the front and what also helps to

back to the front and what also helps to explain why teenagers don’t always make

explain why teenagers don’t always make

explain why teenagers don’t always make the best decision but on a serious note

the best decision but on a serious note

the best decision but on a serious note I’m by no means trying to justify the

I’m by no means trying to justify the

I’m by no means trying to justify the murder of mrs. Weinstein but rather

murder of mrs. Weinstein but rather

murder of mrs. Weinstein but rather raise discussion on what’s best to be

raise discussion on what’s best to be

raise discussion on what’s best to be done if this was to occur in another

done if this was to occur in another

done if this was to occur in another case and I mean imagine if one of your

case and I mean imagine if one of your

case and I mean imagine if one of your loved one or family members were all the

loved one or family members were all the

loved one or family members were all the sudden to become a different person due

sudden to become a different person due

sudden to become a different person due to some sort of cyst or tumor that was

to some sort of cyst or tumor that was

to some sort of cyst or tumor that was going in the brain I mean what would you

going in the brain I mean what would you

going in the brain I mean what would you do and I feel by raising under public

do and I feel by raising under public

do and I feel by raising under public understanding of the brain and neurotic

understanding of the brain and neurotic

understanding of the brain and neurotic will be better able to treat these I

will be better able to treat these I

will be better able to treat these I mean will better be able to make more

mean will better be able to make more

mean will better be able to make more informed decision and even treat

informed decision and even treat

informed decision and even treat psychological issues that we once

psychological issues that we once

psychological issues that we once thought were incurable and we’re in such

thought were incurable and we’re in such

thought were incurable and we’re in such an age where the amount of information

an age where the amount of information

an age where the amount of information we’re learning at the

we’re learning at the

we’re learning at the learning about the brain its exponential

learning about the brain its exponential

learning about the brain its exponential and so much that we don’t even

and so much that we don’t even

and so much that we don’t even understand that the fact that it can

understand that the fact that it can

understand that the fact that it can even change the norms of our society

even change the norms of our society

even change the norms of our society questions that are being asked and

questions that are being asked and

questions that are being asked and neuroethics are like what are the two

neuroethics are like what are the two

neuroethics are like what are the two limits of stress and how will that

limits of stress and how will that

limits of stress and how will that change the way business owners treat

change the way business owners treat

change the way business owners treat their employees or how does an

their employees or how does an

their employees or how does an individual truly learn will

individual truly learn will

individual truly learn will revolutionize the field of teaching or

revolutionize the field of teaching or

revolutionize the field of teaching or what is the role of artificial

what is the role of artificial

what is the role of artificial intelligence in our society and how a

intelligence in our society and how a

intelligence in our society and how a bat shape our future and these questions

bat shape our future and these questions

bat shape our future and these questions are all deep and at the center of

are all deep and at the center of

are all deep and at the center of discussion and neurotic but are only a

discussion and neurotic but are only a

discussion and neurotic but are only a fraction of the hundreds of thousands of

fraction of the hundreds of thousands of

fraction of the hundreds of thousands of questions that are being asked in this

questions that are being asked in this

questions that are being asked in this field and in order to tackle these

field and in order to tackle these

field and in order to tackle these questions we have to still learn a

questions we have to still learn a

questions we have to still learn a little bit more about the brain and one

little bit more about the brain and one

little bit more about the brain and one of the ways in which we’re doing this is

of the ways in which we’re doing this is

of the ways in which we’re doing this is through the human connectome project and

through the human connectome project and

through the human connectome project and the human connectome project is an

the human connectome project is an

the human connectome project is an effort to map every single neuron and

effort to map every single neuron and

effort to map every single neuron and the brain of 1500 patients from all

the brain of 1500 patients from all

the brain of 1500 patients from all across the United States and from all

across the United States and from all

across the United States and from all different backgrounds

different backgrounds

different backgrounds this picture that you see up here is a

this picture that you see up here is a

this picture that you see up here is a picture of someone’s brain or more

picture of someone’s brain or more

picture of someone’s brain or more specifically the neural network and it’s

specifically the neural network and it’s

specifically the neural network and it’s often referred to at the connectome now

often referred to at the connectome now

often referred to at the connectome now what scientists are learning about this

what scientists are learning about this

what scientists are learning about this connectome is that they are unique to an

connectome is that they are unique to an

connectome is that they are unique to an individual even in twin so my brain your

individual even in twin so my brain your

individual even in twin so my brain your brains or your family members brain or

brains or your family members brain or

brains or your family members brain or your friends brain they’re all

your friends brain they’re all

your friends brain they’re all completely different because of

completely different because of

completely different because of different neural network that’s

different neural network that’s

different neural network that’s happening I mean after all we’re all

happening I mean after all we’re all

happening I mean after all we’re all different in our own way and so is the

different in our own way and so is the

different in our own way and so is the beauty of diversity in the human race

beauty of diversity in the human race

beauty of diversity in the human race but there’s some serious problem with

but there’s some serious problem with

but there’s some serious problem with this project and some very scary

this project and some very scary

this project and some very scary elements that are also coming out of it

elements that are also coming out of it

elements that are also coming out of it another thing that we learned about

another thing that we learned about

another thing that we learned about these connectome is that a simple

these connectome is that a simple

these connectome is that a simple analysis of this connectome can actually

analysis of this connectome can actually

analysis of this connectome can actually lead them to understand what field one

lead them to understand what field one

lead them to understand what field one would be best at or not and I mean who

would be best at or not and I mean who

would be best at or not and I mean who has access to this kind of information

has access to this kind of information

has access to this kind of information and the way I see it there’s only two

and the way I see it there’s only two

and the way I see it there’s only two outcomes that can occur one we could

outcomes that can occur one we could

outcomes that can occur one we could easily begin to discriminate each other

easily begin to discriminate each other

easily begin to discriminate each other and only allow the people who are the

and only allow the people who are the

and only allow the people who are the best or naturally gifted to succeed in

best or naturally gifted to succeed in

best or naturally gifted to succeed in the workforce or we can use it as a way

the workforce or we can use it as a way

the workforce or we can use it as a way to help each other learn to learn more

to help each other learn to learn more

to help each other learn to learn more about itself and improve it and the

about itself and improve it and the

about itself and improve it and the other element is the idea that the brain

other element is the idea that the brain

other element is the idea that the brain is merely just a series of complex

is merely just a series of complex

is merely just a series of complex no pattern and these complex neural

no pattern and these complex neural

no pattern and these complex neural patterns is what makes our personality

patterns is what makes our personality

patterns is what makes our personality and makes us who we are who we are and

and makes us who we are who we are and

and makes us who we are who we are and if we can understand how these neural

if we can understand how these neural

if we can understand how these neural networks are interacting in the brain

networks are interacting in the brain

networks are interacting in the brain through this project we can in theory

through this project we can in theory

through this project we can in theory simulate this into a computer and then

simulate this into a computer and then

simulate this into a computer and then in theory would also be able to create a

in theory would also be able to create a

in theory would also be able to create a simulation of you and maybe even learn

simulation of you and maybe even learn

simulation of you and maybe even learn more about you in the future and that

more about you in the future and that

more about you in the future and that seems really exciting but there also

seems really exciting but there also

seems really exciting but there also comes some serious controversy about

comes some serious controversy about

comes some serious controversy about this project but the other idea is that

this project but the other idea is that

this project but the other idea is that we can use it as a way as artificial

we can use it as a way as artificial

we can use it as a way as artificial intelligence you know imagine you being

intelligence you know imagine you being

intelligence you know imagine you being your own artificial intelligence that is

your own artificial intelligence that is

your own artificial intelligence that is pretty cool right and whenever I use the

pretty cool right and whenever I use the

pretty cool right and whenever I use the word artificial intelligence what’s the

word artificial intelligence what’s the

word artificial intelligence what’s the things that happen that comes up to in

things that happen that comes up to in

things that happen that comes up to in most people’s mind is our robots they’re

most people’s mind is our robots they’re

most people’s mind is our robots they’re gonna take over our world and take our

gonna take over our world and take our

gonna take over our world and take our job and kill us and these ideas are

job and kill us and these ideas are

job and kill us and these ideas are often exaggerated in movies like The

often exaggerated in movies like The

often exaggerated in movies like The Terminator Matrix and even iRobot and

Terminator Matrix and even iRobot and

Terminator Matrix and even iRobot and although these ideas are exaggerated

although these ideas are exaggerated

although these ideas are exaggerated they aren’t completely false either but

they aren’t completely false either but

they aren’t completely false either but one thing we often fail to recognize is

one thing we often fail to recognize is

one thing we often fail to recognize is that artificial intelligence has

that artificial intelligence has

that artificial intelligence has actually been around for decades now and

actually been around for decades now and

actually been around for decades now and it’s not a brand new thing at all

it’s not a brand new thing at all

it’s not a brand new thing at all in fact in 1967 this computer was about

in fact in 1967 this computer was about

in fact in 1967 this computer was about the size of a classroom and was designed

the size of a classroom and was designed

the size of a classroom and was designed to play tic-tac-toe and this is one of

to play tic-tac-toe and this is one of

to play tic-tac-toe and this is one of the first artificial intelligence we

the first artificial intelligence we

the first artificial intelligence we were beginning to see fast-forward 40

were beginning to see fast-forward 40

were beginning to see fast-forward 40 years later deep blue defeated Kasparov

years later deep blue defeated Kasparov

years later deep blue defeated Kasparov one of the world’s best chess player

one of the world’s best chess player

one of the world’s best chess player during this time 2011 IBM Watson

during this time 2011 IBM Watson

during this time 2011 IBM Watson defeated these two gentlemen who were

defeated these two gentlemen who were

defeated these two gentlemen who were considered the world best jeopardy

considered the world best jeopardy

considered the world best jeopardy players and jeopardy is a game that

players and jeopardy is a game that

players and jeopardy is a game that requires more than just logical

requires more than just logical

requires more than just logical reasoning and pattern recognition but

reasoning and pattern recognition but

reasoning and pattern recognition but one that requires memory retention and

one that requires memory retention and

one that requires memory retention and applicability and was generally the

applicability and was generally the

applicability and was generally the first sign of general intelligence and

first sign of general intelligence and

first sign of general intelligence and just last year google’s deepmind alphago

just last year google’s deepmind alphago

just last year google’s deepmind alphago defeated the world best player in the

defeated the world best player in the

defeated the world best player in the game go and the game go has more

game go and the game go has more

game go and the game go has more possible moves than there are atoms in

possible moves than there are atoms in

possible moves than there are atoms in this universe and you can see easily

this universe and you can see easily

this universe and you can see easily that the power of artificial

that the power of artificial

that the power of artificial intelligence is progressing

intelligence is progressing

intelligence is progressing very very fast but it’s also progressing

very very fast but it’s also progressing

very very fast but it’s also progressing to keep up with the amount of

to keep up with the amount of

to keep up with the amount of information that we’re also learning in

information that we’re also learning in

information that we’re also learning in fact every eighteen month the amount of

fact every eighteen month the amount of

fact every eighteen month the amount of information that we’ve learned

information that we’ve learned

information that we’ve learned discovered or research is doubling so

discovered or research is doubling so

discovered or research is doubling so next year and next year in August the

next year and next year in August the

next year and next year in August the amount of information that we’ve learned

amount of information that we’ve learned

amount of information that we’ve learned discovered of research in that one

discovered of research in that one

discovered of research in that one 18-month period is more than the amount

18-month period is more than the amount

18-month period is more than the amount of information than the entire history

of information than the entire history

of information than the entire history of the human race that is a lot of

of the human race that is a lot of

of the human race that is a lot of information that’s medical cases doctors

information that’s medical cases doctors

information that’s medical cases doctors have to keep up with theories that

have to keep up with theories that

have to keep up with theories that mathematicians and physicists have to

mathematicians and physicists have to

mathematicians and physicists have to learn and technique that surgeons have

learn and technique that surgeons have

learn and technique that surgeons have to master and there’s mainly just way

to master and there’s mainly just way

to master and there’s mainly just way too much information for want to be

too much information for want to be

too much information for want to be doing everything and the idea is that we

doing everything and the idea is that we

doing everything and the idea is that we can use artificial intelligence to aid

can use artificial intelligence to aid

can use artificial intelligence to aid us in this process and even increase our

us in this process and even increase our

us in this process and even increase our knowledge about everything but will it I

knowledge about everything but will it I

knowledge about everything but will it I mean if such information is available in

mean if such information is available in

mean if such information is available in our reach what is the entire purpose of

our reach what is the entire purpose of

our reach what is the entire purpose of learning anymore if any of mean any

learning anymore if any of mean any

learning anymore if any of mean any questions that we have now can be showed

questions that we have now can be showed

questions that we have now can be showed up in a device that’s the size of our

up in a device that’s the size of our

up in a device that’s the size of our hand I mean will we as a society began

hand I mean will we as a society began

hand I mean will we as a society began to value knowledge less and less and if

to value knowledge less and less and if

to value knowledge less and less and if I was to ask any of you this questions

I was to ask any of you this questions

I was to ask any of you this questions now I believe most of you would say

now I believe most of you would say

now I believe most of you would say absolutely not I mean humans are always

absolutely not I mean humans are always

absolutely not I mean humans are always curious endeavors and seek to learn more

curious endeavors and seek to learn more

curious endeavors and seek to learn more about the world around us but what if I

about the world around us but what if I

about the world around us but what if I was to tell you that you’re already a

was to tell you that you’re already a

was to tell you that you’re already a victim of this how many of you have used

victim of this how many of you have used

victim of this how many of you have used the GPS or have used one before okay you

the GPS or have used one before okay you

the GPS or have used one before okay you guys are all victims a study just

guys are all victims a study just

guys are all victims a study just recently came out and has shown that

recently came out and has shown that

recently came out and has shown that people who use GPS s their hippocampus

people who use GPS s their hippocampus

people who use GPS s their hippocampus is shrinking and the hippocampus is the

is shrinking and the hippocampus is the

is shrinking and the hippocampus is the region of the brain that’s responsible

region of the brain that’s responsible

region of the brain that’s responsible for a sense of direction and long-term

for a sense of direction and long-term

for a sense of direction and long-term memory and when we’re using our GPS s to

memory and when we’re using our GPS s to

memory and when we’re using our GPS s to listen to Siri or some Google Maps app

listen to Siri or some Google Maps app

listen to Siri or some Google Maps app to tell us turned left we are not

to tell us turned left we are not

to tell us turned left we are not practicing our sense of direction

practicing our sense of direction

practicing our sense of direction anymore

anymore

anymore and indeed that part of the brain begins

and indeed that part of the brain begins

and indeed that part of the brain begins to shrink and in a way we’re actually

to shrink and in a way we’re actually

to shrink and in a way we’re actually getting Dumber but the whole point of

getting Dumber but the whole point of

getting Dumber but the whole point of technology and artificial intelligence

technology and artificial intelligence

technology and artificial intelligence was to aid us and

was to aid us and

was to aid us and smarter and there seems to completely

smarter and there seems to completely

smarter and there seems to completely counteract what we what I just said but

counteract what we what I just said but

counteract what we what I just said but I believe that artificial intelligence

I believe that artificial intelligence

I believe that artificial intelligence has one of the greatest potentials put

has one of the greatest potentials put

has one of the greatest potentials put aside all this I think that it will

aside all this I think that it will

aside all this I think that it will allow us to learn more about ourselves

allow us to learn more about ourselves

allow us to learn more about ourselves than ever before this picture that you

than ever before this picture that you

than ever before this picture that you see on the left as a picture of the

see on the left as a picture of the

see on the left as a picture of the neocortical column it’s a region of the

neocortical column it’s a region of the

neocortical column it’s a region of the brain that’s responsible for thinking

brain that’s responsible for thinking

brain that’s responsible for thinking learning and even dreaming and the

learning and even dreaming and the

learning and even dreaming and the picture that you see on the right is the

picture that you see on the right is the

picture that you see on the right is the picture of a neural network that was

picture of a neural network that was

picture of a neural network that was created by an artificial intelligence

created by an artificial intelligence

created by an artificial intelligence after learning a series of tasks and as

after learning a series of tasks and as

after learning a series of tasks and as you can see these two mirrored these two

you can see these two mirrored these two

you can see these two mirrored these two images almost mirror each other and this

images almost mirror each other and this

images almost mirror each other and this revolutionary the artificial

revolutionary the artificial

revolutionary the artificial intelligence will allow us to understand

intelligence will allow us to understand

intelligence will allow us to understand how learning occurs at the neural level

how learning occurs at the neural level

how learning occurs at the neural level and that will change the way we teach

and that will change the way we teach

and that will change the way we teach and learn and improve our mind and this

and learn and improve our mind and this

and learn and improve our mind and this is only one of many potential

is only one of many potential

is only one of many potential applications of artificial intelligence

applications of artificial intelligence

applications of artificial intelligence but it’s the way we decide as a society

but it’s the way we decide as a society

but it’s the way we decide as a society how we want to go about this and never

how we want to go about this and never

how we want to go about this and never ethics can see be seen as a very scary

ethics can see be seen as a very scary

ethics can see be seen as a very scary field questions that are very difficult

field questions that are very difficult

field questions that are very difficult to answer and face but I feel like we

to answer and face but I feel like we

to answer and face but I feel like we should be looking at it with excitement

should be looking at it with excitement

should be looking at it with excitement and passion because it’s a glimpse into

and passion because it’s a glimpse into

and passion because it’s a glimpse into a future that I’m looking forward to are

a future that I’m looking forward to are

a future that I’m looking forward to are you thank you

you thank you

you thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *