Press "Enter" to skip to content

Living together: Mind and machine intelligence | Neil Lawrence | TEDxExeterSalon


[Applause]

[Applause] the diving bell and the butterfly is the

the diving bell and the butterfly is the

the diving bell and the butterfly is the autobiography of Jean Dominique Bobby in

autobiography of Jean Dominique Bobby in

autobiography of Jean Dominique Bobby in 1995 Jean Dominique was the

1995 Jean Dominique was the

1995 Jean Dominique was the editor-in-chief of the French fashion

editor-in-chief of the French fashion

editor-in-chief of the French fashion magazine Elle he suffered a stroke that

magazine Elle he suffered a stroke that

magazine Elle he suffered a stroke that destroyed his brain stem he lost almost

destroyed his brain stem he lost almost

destroyed his brain stem he lost almost all his physical capability but remained

all his physical capability but remained

all his physical capability but remained mentally active he had acquired what we

mentally active he had acquired what we

mentally active he had acquired what we know of as locked-in syndrome incredibly

know of as locked-in syndrome incredibly

know of as locked-in syndrome incredibly Bobby wrote his book after he had become

Bobby wrote his book after he had become

Bobby wrote his book after he had become locked in the only muscle he could move

locked in the only muscle he could move

locked in the only muscle he could move was his left eye so he wrote the entire

was his left eye so he wrote the entire

was his left eye so he wrote the entire book by winking the way they did it is

book by winking the way they did it is

book by winking the way they did it is they set up the letters of the French

they set up the letters of the French

they set up the letters of the French alphabet in frequency order pointed to

alphabet in frequency order pointed to

alphabet in frequency order pointed to each one and when they came across the

each one and when they came across the

each one and when they came across the letter that he wanted he would wink it

letter that he wanted he would wink it

letter that he wanted he would wink it took ten months four hours a day to

took ten months four hours a day to

took ten months four hours a day to complete the book each word took two

complete the book each word took two

complete the book each word took two minutes to write that is the nature of

minutes to write that is the nature of

minutes to write that is the nature of being locked in your intelligence my

being locked in your intelligence my

being locked in your intelligence my intelligence is also locked in Claude

intelligence is also locked in Claude

intelligence is also locked in Claude Shannon is the father of information

Shannon is the father of information

Shannon is the father of information theory he defined the fundamental unit

theory he defined the fundamental unit

theory he defined the fundamental unit of information as to be the amount of

of information as to be the amount of

of information as to be the amount of information that transfers between us if

information that transfers between us if

information that transfers between us if I were to toss a coin look at the result

I were to toss a coin look at the result

I were to toss a coin look at the result and say heads that’s one bit of

and say heads that’s one bit of

and say heads that’s one bit of information he suggested that

information he suggested that

information he suggested that information should be additive so if I

information should be additive so if I

information should be additive so if I toss the coin twice heads and in the

toss the coin twice heads and in the

toss the coin twice heads and in the second time tails you get two bits of

second time tails you get two bits of

second time tails you get two bits of information he was also interested in

information he was also interested in

information he was also interested in the amount of information in the English

the amount of information in the English

the amount of information in the English language and he determined on average

language and he determined on average

language and he determined on average each word in the English language has 12

each word in the English language has 12

each word in the English language has 12 bits of information equivalent

bits of information equivalent

bits of information equivalent well of coin tosses now if we think

well of coin tosses now if we think

well of coin tosses now if we think about Bobby he was communicating at a

about Bobby he was communicating at a

about Bobby he was communicating at a rate of one word every two minutes now

rate of one word every two minutes now

rate of one word every two minutes now if we assume the amount of information

if we assume the amount of information

if we assume the amount of information in the French language is the same as

in the French language is the same as

in the French language is the same as the English which it certainly isn’t to

the English which it certainly isn’t to

the English which it certainly isn’t to me but to a French speaker it would be

me but to a French speaker it would be

me but to a French speaker it would be then we can see that he was

then we can see that he was

then we can see that he was communicating at a rate of twelve bits

communicating at a rate of twelve bits

communicating at a rate of twelve bits every two minutes so six bits per minute

every two minutes so six bits per minute

every two minutes so six bits per minute that’s his communication rate so how

that’s his communication rate so how

that’s his communication rate so how does that compare to us well the average

does that compare to us well the average

does that compare to us well the average TEDx speaker talks at about 160 words

TEDx speaker talks at about 160 words

TEDx speaker talks at about 160 words per minute 320 times faster than Bobi so

per minute 320 times faster than Bobi so

per minute 320 times faster than Bobi so that’s about 2,000 bits per minute 2000

that’s about 2,000 bits per minute 2000

that’s about 2,000 bits per minute 2000 coin tosses that’s a lot I don’t think I

coin tosses that’s a lot I don’t think I

coin tosses that’s a lot I don’t think I could say that just straight out like

could say that just straight out like

could say that just straight out like that so there’s a lot of information my

that so there’s a lot of information my

that so there’s a lot of information my words we’re doing quite well but imagine

words we’re doing quite well but imagine

words we’re doing quite well but imagine how much more thought that Bobby was

how much more thought that Bobby was

how much more thought that Bobby was putting in to each of his words that’s

putting in to each of his words that’s

putting in to each of his words that’s what it means to be locked in now we

what it means to be locked in now we

what it means to be locked in now we have other intelligences around us it’s

have other intelligences around us it’s

have other intelligences around us it’s not just us there are computers and

not just us there are computers and

not just us there are computers and those computers also communicate with

those computers also communicate with

those computers also communicate with one another now when a computer is

one another now when a computer is

one another now when a computer is communicating with another computer it

communicating with another computer it

communicating with another computer it does so at the rate of billions of bits

does so at the rate of billions of bits

does so at the rate of billions of bits per minute orders of magnitude faster

per minute orders of magnitude faster

per minute orders of magnitude faster than us it’s in a totally different

than us it’s in a totally different

than us it’s in a totally different regime now communication isn’t the only

regime now communication isn’t the only

regime now communication isn’t the only aspect of being locked in you have to

aspect of being locked in you have to

aspect of being locked in you have to have a number of thoughts so it’s not

have a number of thoughts so it’s not

have a number of thoughts so it’s not just how fast you’re communicating it’s

just how fast you’re communicating it’s

just how fast you’re communicating it’s how fast you can think so Bobby and I we

how fast you can think so Bobby and I we

how fast you can think so Bobby and I we can assume we probably roughly think at

can assume we probably roughly think at

can assume we probably roughly think at the same rate but where our computers on

the same rate but where our computers on

the same rate but where our computers on that scale well you might be surprised

that scale well you might be surprised

that scale well you might be surprised to know that actually computers think

to know that actually computers think

to know that actually computers think slower than Mouse what am I saying that

slower than Mouse what am I saying that

slower than Mouse what am I saying that doesn’t seem to make sense because we

doesn’t seem to make sense because we

doesn’t seem to make sense because we know that a computer can calculate

know that a computer can calculate

know that a computer can calculate faster than us and ensure it can if

faster than us and ensure it can if

faster than us and ensure it can if we’re calculating consciously but

we’re calculating consciously but

we’re calculating consciously but underlying our thoughts

underlying our thoughts

underlying our thoughts there’s millions hundreds billions of

there’s millions hundreds billions of

there’s millions hundreds billions of calculations going on in our neurons

calculations going on in our neurons

calculations going on in our neurons which generate our higher thoughts how

which generate our higher thoughts how

which generate our higher thoughts how many we don’t know because we don’t know

many we don’t know because we don’t know

many we don’t know because we don’t know the mapping of those calculations to our

the mapping of those calculations to our

the mapping of those calculations to our thoughts but what we can estimate is how

thoughts but what we can estimate is how

thoughts but what we can estimate is how large

large

large machine it would require for us to

machine it would require for us to

machine it would require for us to emulate a human mind the machine we

emulate a human mind the machine we

emulate a human mind the machine we would need is actually here in Exeter

would need is actually here in Exeter

would need is actually here in Exeter it’s the fastest computer in the UK it’s

it’s the fastest computer in the UK it’s

it’s the fastest computer in the UK it’s the eleventh fastest in the world we

the eleventh fastest in the world we

the eleventh fastest in the world we just missed the top ten it computes that

just missed the top ten it computes that

just missed the top ten it computes that 16 billion billion calculations per

16 billion billion calculations per

16 billion billion calculations per second and it’s used to simulate the

second and it’s used to simulate the

second and it’s used to simulate the weather across the world every day so in

weather across the world every day so in

weather across the world every day so in order to compute as as fast as a human

order to compute as as fast as a human

order to compute as as fast as a human being we need that 11th fastest computer

being we need that 11th fastest computer

being we need that 11th fastest computer but in contrast our ability to

but in contrast our ability to

but in contrast our ability to communicate is slower this is what leads

communicate is slower this is what leads

communicate is slower this is what leads to our locked-in intelligence the ratio

to our locked-in intelligence the ratio

to our locked-in intelligence the ratio our ability to communicate versus our

our ability to communicate versus our

our ability to communicate versus our ability to compute I call this the

ability to compute I call this the

ability to compute I call this the embodiment factor and one way of

embodiment factor and one way of

embodiment factor and one way of thinking about it is to think of how

thinking about it is to think of how

thinking about it is to think of how long it would take to tell you what is

long it would take to tell you what is

long it would take to tell you what is in one second of computation so if we

in one second of computation so if we

in one second of computation so if we were to take a computer and take what it

were to take a computer and take what it

were to take a computer and take what it does in one second of computation and

does in one second of computation and

does in one second of computation and allow it to try and communicate all that

allow it to try and communicate all that

allow it to try and communicate all that information it turns out it would take

information it turns out it would take

information it turns out it would take for a typical computer not the Met

for a typical computer not the Met

for a typical computer not the Met Office wanna sort of slow one that we

Office wanna sort of slow one that we

Office wanna sort of slow one that we might own around 20 minutes so a little

might own around 20 minutes so a little

might own around 20 minutes so a little bit longer than a TEDTalk should be

bit longer than a TEDTalk should be

bit longer than a TEDTalk should be however if I were to stop and think for

however if I were to stop and think for

however if I were to stop and think for a second and if I now was capable of

a second and if I now was capable of

a second and if I now was capable of accessing all my neurons and all the

accessing all my neurons and all the

accessing all my neurons and all the calculations they were doing and capable

calculations they were doing and capable

calculations they were doing and capable of starting to speak and tell you those

of starting to speak and tell you those

of starting to speak and tell you those it would take us 15 billion years to get

it would take us 15 billion years to get

it would take us 15 billion years to get through them that’s longer than the age

through them that’s longer than the age

through them that’s longer than the age of the universe I think most of you

of the universe I think most of you

of the universe I think most of you would have left

Bobi on the other hand is five trillion

Bobi on the other hand is five trillion years longer sure 320 times longer but

years longer sure 320 times longer but

years longer sure 320 times longer but when you compare the computer with its

when you compare the computer with its

when you compare the computer with its twenty minutes and asked with our 15

twenty minutes and asked with our 15

twenty minutes and asked with our 15 billion years we’re right there with

billion years we’re right there with

billion years we’re right there with Bobby we’re in the same place that’s

Bobby we’re in the same place that’s

Bobby we’re in the same place that’s what I mean when I say that you’re

what I mean when I say that you’re

what I mean when I say that you’re locked in one analogy I use to think

locked in one analogy I use to think

locked in one analogy I use to think about this is is cars I was a mechanical

about this is is cars I was a mechanical

about this is is cars I was a mechanical engineer as an undergraduate I love cars

engineer as an undergraduate I love cars

engineer as an undergraduate I love cars so I like to think of Formula one engine

so I like to think of Formula one engine

so I like to think of Formula one engine is very powerful engines that’s our

is very powerful engines that’s our

is very powerful engines that’s our intellect that’s the quality of what’s

intellect that’s the quality of what’s

intellect that’s the quality of what’s going on in our head that’s the power

going on in our head that’s the power

going on in our head that’s the power that we have but unfortunately when we

that we have but unfortunately when we

that we have but unfortunately when we try and drive those cars think not of

try and drive those cars think not of

try and drive those cars think not of the regular Formula One car think of a

the regular Formula One car think of a

the regular Formula One car think of a car with that engine but when you look

car with that engine but when you look

car with that engine but when you look at the wheels in your mind think of

at the wheels in your mind think of

at the wheels in your mind think of bicycle wheels

bicycle wheels

bicycle wheels that’s your ability to deploy that

that’s your ability to deploy that

that’s your ability to deploy that intellectual power onto the track in

intellectual power onto the track in

intellectual power onto the track in contrast our computers are less well

contrast our computers are less well

contrast our computers are less well powered they have less power in their

powered they have less power in their

powered they have less power in their engines but they have well matched tires

engines but they have well matched tires

engines but they have well matched tires they’re more like a go-cart they can use

they’re more like a go-cart they can use

they’re more like a go-cart they can use all their power to deploy so they’re

all their power to deploy so they’re

all their power to deploy so they’re more efficient than us but they’re

more efficient than us but they’re

more efficient than us but they’re somehow less beautiful less

somehow less beautiful less

somehow less beautiful less extraordinary who wouldn’t want to watch

extraordinary who wouldn’t want to watch

extraordinary who wouldn’t want to watch people driving those extraordinary

people driving those extraordinary

people driving those extraordinary vehicles or attempting to so where do we

vehicles or attempting to so where do we

vehicles or attempting to so where do we use that excess power if we can’t deploy

use that excess power if we can’t deploy

use that excess power if we can’t deploy it on the track well I’m trying to

it on the track well I’m trying to

it on the track well I’m trying to communicate with you now whether I’m

communicate with you now whether I’m

communicate with you now whether I’m doing so well or not is dependent on my

doing so well or not is dependent on my

doing so well or not is dependent on my choice of what words I use the analogies

choice of what words I use the analogies

choice of what words I use the analogies I choose the things I say to try and

I choose the things I say to try and

I choose the things I say to try and understand my audience and say if I say

understand my audience and say if I say

understand my audience and say if I say this thing it will move their mind

this thing it will move their mind

this thing it will move their mind towards where my mind is I can

towards where my mind is I can

towards where my mind is I can communicate state in that way if I have

communicate state in that way if I have

communicate state in that way if I have a conversation with an individual when

a conversation with an individual when

a conversation with an individual when I’m speaking to that individual I have a

I’m speaking to that individual I have a

I’m speaking to that individual I have a mental model in my mind of what that

mental model in my mind of what that

mental model in my mind of what that individual thinks and I choose my words

individual thinks and I choose my words

individual thinks and I choose my words that I send to that individual in order

that I send to that individual in order

that I send to that individual in order to try and take my thoughts and put it

to try and take my thoughts and put it

to try and take my thoughts and put it in their minds they of course have the

in their minds they of course have the

in their minds they of course have the same image in their heads of who I am

same image in their heads of who I am

same image in their heads of who I am and what I think about them so they then

and what I think about them so they then

and what I think about them so they then make a choice of what to say back

make a choice of what to say back

make a choice of what to say back because they don’t understand or they

because they don’t understand or they

because they don’t understand or they look quizzically at me they make some

look quizzically at me they make some

look quizzically at me they make some kind of response

kind of response

kind of response when it works this this dance is

when it works this this dance is

when it works this this dance is beautiful our ability to communicate

beautiful our ability to communicate

beautiful our ability to communicate ideas but if we misdirect our words or

ideas but if we misdirect our words or

ideas but if we misdirect our words or we don’t understand each other what we

we don’t understand each other what we

we don’t understand each other what we get is a horrible crash an argument

get is a horrible crash an argument

get is a horrible crash an argument follows computers are very different

follows computers are very different

follows computers are very different their intelligence is based on large

their intelligence is based on large

their intelligence is based on large amounts of data they are not using all

amounts of data they are not using all

amounts of data they are not using all that compute to model us they use more

that compute to model us they use more

that compute to model us they use more data than we can possibly imagine and

data than we can possibly imagine and

data than we can possibly imagine and that’s not a problem

that’s not a problem

that’s not a problem that’s fine because that’s complementary

that’s fine because that’s complementary

that’s fine because that’s complementary to what we do we can’t deal with the

to what we do we can’t deal with the

to what we do we can’t deal with the large data but we work well with other

large data but we work well with other

large data but we work well with other humans they deal with large data but

humans they deal with large data but

humans they deal with large data but don’t work so well with other humans

don’t work so well with other humans

don’t work so well with other humans however when you interact with the

however when you interact with the

however when you interact with the computer it’s important to bear this in

computer it’s important to bear this in

computer it’s important to bear this in mind it’s important to remember that you

mind it’s important to remember that you

mind it’s important to remember that you are not interacting with another human

are not interacting with another human

are not interacting with another human our tendency to model what we

our tendency to model what we

our tendency to model what we communicate means that we tend to

communicate means that we tend to

communicate means that we tend to anthropomorphize everything embodiment

anthropomorphize everything embodiment

anthropomorphize everything embodiment in fact is explain why at one level we

in fact is explain why at one level we

in fact is explain why at one level we are capable of simulating our weather

are capable of simulating our weather

are capable of simulating our weather across the planet but not capable of

across the planet but not capable of

across the planet but not capable of designing things that understand our

designing things that understand our

designing things that understand our moods as humans we empathize a cat’s

moods as humans we empathize a cat’s

moods as humans we empathize a cat’s dogs a cars we give them all human

dogs a cars we give them all human

dogs a cars we give them all human characteristics in an effort to

characteristics in an effort to

characteristics in an effort to communicate with them our computers are

communicate with them our computers are

communicate with them our computers are very different their computation is

very different their computation is

very different their computation is being based on very large amounts of

being based on very large amounts of

being based on very large amounts of data the challenge is that our fears

data the challenge is that our fears

data the challenge is that our fears around AI are based on this

around AI are based on this

around AI are based on this anthropomorphize ation we fear we are

anthropomorphize ation we fear we are

anthropomorphize ation we fear we are creating a better version of us

creating a better version of us

creating a better version of us something with the same motivations as

something with the same motivations as

something with the same motivations as ourselves but more powerful because it

ourselves but more powerful because it

ourselves but more powerful because it has these additional abilities we are

has these additional abilities we are

has these additional abilities we are not the real danger is a very different

not the real danger is a very different

not the real danger is a very different one the real danger is that those

one the real danger is that those

one the real danger is that those computers do not anthropomorphize us

computers do not anthropomorphize us

computers do not anthropomorphize us they work below our cognitive radar they

they work below our cognitive radar they

they work below our cognitive radar they make decisions about us without

make decisions about us without

make decisions about us without understanding the human condition that

understanding the human condition that

understanding the human condition that is the challenge

is the challenge

is the challenge some researchers advocate transhumanism

some researchers advocate transhumanism

some researchers advocate transhumanism who wouldn’t want the ability to

who wouldn’t want the ability to

who wouldn’t want the ability to assimilate this communication power of

assimilate this communication power of

assimilate this communication power of the computer that multi-billionaire

the computer that multi-billionaire

the computer that multi-billionaire power that is within the machine what if

power that is within the machine what if

power that is within the machine what if it is our limitations that define us

it is our limitations that define us

it is our limitations that define us what if the thing that we value the most

what if the thing that we value the most

what if the thing that we value the most our consciousness is a side effect of

our consciousness is a side effect of

our consciousness is a side effect of our need to understand and be understood

our need to understand and be understood

our need to understand and be understood artificial intelligence is not the same

artificial intelligence is not the same

artificial intelligence is not the same as humans the a in AI does not stand for

as humans the a in AI does not stand for

as humans the a in AI does not stand for anthropomorphic it stands for artificial

anthropomorphic it stands for artificial

anthropomorphic it stands for artificial artificial in the way that a plastic

artificial in the way that a plastic

artificial in the way that a plastic plant is artificial there are real

plant is artificial there are real

plant is artificial there are real dangers with AI as there are with any

dangers with AI as there are with any

dangers with AI as there are with any new technology but if we are to face

new technology but if we are to face

new technology but if we are to face those dangers head-on as a society we

those dangers head-on as a society we

those dangers head-on as a society we need to understand what we are dealing

need to understand what we are dealing

need to understand what we are dealing with we are defined by a need to

with we are defined by a need to

with we are defined by a need to communicate our lives are defined by the

communicate our lives are defined by the

communicate our lives are defined by the things we create whether it’s music

things we create whether it’s music

things we create whether it’s music dance art literature poetry even sport

dance art literature poetry even sport

dance art literature poetry even sport the computer has no need of these your

the computer has no need of these your

the computer has no need of these your cat understands you better than your

cat understands you better than your

cat understands you better than your computer understands you your cat

computer understands you your cat

computer understands you your cat understands me better than your computer

understands me better than your computer

understands me better than your computer understands me and it hasn’t even met me

when you think of AI think of the

when you think of AI think of the plastic plant a plastic plant does some

plastic plant a plastic plant does some

plastic plant a plastic plant does some of the things a real plant does it’s

of the things a real plant does it’s

of the things a real plant does it’s also very convenient it doesn’t need

also very convenient it doesn’t need

also very convenient it doesn’t need watering it doesn’t need light it won’t

watering it doesn’t need light it won’t

watering it doesn’t need light it won’t outgrow the place you put it it fulfills

outgrow the place you put it it fulfills

outgrow the place you put it it fulfills some of the characteristics of a real

some of the characteristics of a real

some of the characteristics of a real plant but it is not a real plant our

plant but it is not a real plant our

plant but it is not a real plant our fears around AI are based around a

fears around AI are based around a

fears around AI are based around a conflation of who we are

conflation of who we are

conflation of who we are and what we create we are defined by our

and what we create we are defined by our

and what we create we are defined by our limitations just as Bobby was defined by

limitations just as Bobby was defined by

limitations just as Bobby was defined by his or maybe limitations is the wrong

his or maybe limitations is the wrong

his or maybe limitations is the wrong word because as Bobby says we can always

word because as Bobby says we can always

word because as Bobby says we can always escape within ourselves and these are

escape within ourselves and these are

escape within ourselves and these are his words my cocoon becomes less

his words my cocoon becomes less

his words my cocoon becomes less oppressive and my mind takes flight like

oppressive and my mind takes flight like

oppressive and my mind takes flight like a butterfly

a butterfly

a butterfly there is so much to do you can wander

there is so much to do you can wander

there is so much to do you can wander off in space or in time set out for

off in space or in time set out for

off in space or in time set out for Tierra del Fuego or for King Midas’s

Tierra del Fuego or for King Midas’s

Tierra del Fuego or for King Midas’s Court you can visit the woman you love

Court you can visit the woman you love

Court you can visit the woman you love slide down beside her and Stroke her

slide down beside her and Stroke her

slide down beside her and Stroke her still sleeping face you can build

still sleeping face you can build

still sleeping face you can build castles in Spain steal the Golden Fleece

castles in Spain steal the Golden Fleece

castles in Spain steal the Golden Fleece discover Atlantis realize your childhood

discover Atlantis realize your childhood

discover Atlantis realize your childhood dreams and adult ambitions enough

dreams and adult ambitions enough

dreams and adult ambitions enough rambling my main task now is to compose

rambling my main task now is to compose

rambling my main task now is to compose the first of these bedridden travel

the first of these bedridden travel

the first of these bedridden travel notes so that I shall be ready when my

notes so that I shall be ready when my

notes so that I shall be ready when my publisher is a missionary emissary Rhys

publisher is a missionary emissary Rhys

publisher is a missionary emissary Rhys arrives to take my dictation letter by

arrives to take my dictation letter by

arrives to take my dictation letter by letter in my head I turn over every

letter in my head I turn over every

letter in my head I turn over every sentence 10 times delete a word add an

sentence 10 times delete a word add an

sentence 10 times delete a word add an adjective and learn my text by heart

adjective and learn my text by heart

adjective and learn my text by heart paragraph by paragraph this book this

paragraph by paragraph this book this

paragraph by paragraph this book this fight can never bud from an artificial

fight can never bud from an artificial

fight can never bud from an artificial plant

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *