Press "Enter" to skip to content

Les toilettes : constructions spatiales et sociales | Lucile Biarrotte | TEDxChampsElyseesWomen


[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

I’m sure some of you

and especially some have already

asked why there was more

often queue in front of the toilet

women than men

good it is explained by lots of

factors

the fact that we have 52% of the population

but also for reasons

physiological

they have their rules they have

smaller bladders and then she

also accompanies still predominantly

people who need both

children and the elderly

older people who are themselves

mostly women

but there is also a spatial factor to

this phenomenon

in truth the toilets are like a

incarnation of gender inequalities

parties space the way we do them

designs and builds them that

reflects gender values ​​when we

look in public spaces

today there is still a lot more

black rice for example that toilet

at 6

sasa presupposes in quotation marks that

women will rather spend in the

public spaces rather than getting them

appropriating in a real way I know

not if you heard about it there is a

months ago there was a controversy at

amsterdam because there is a judge who has

fined a woman who

had urinated in the street he had him

explained that even though it was not

super convenient

she could still have used the

urinals blow of the coup feminists

Irish boy was not great

happy and she counted the number

of public toilets amsterdam 35

urinals for three public toilets

to this problem we can also

to cross with other discriminations

like age disability or origin

maybe you saw the film

shadow figures that came out this

year that tells the story of

catherine johnson a woman

african american who worked nasa

in the 60s there is a scene

recurrent in this film we see it

run from one end of the base to the other

from NASA to find toilets

because in his building

there are no black women’s toilets

and that really embodies the system

inegalitarian of that time in this

professional environment there that is at the

times extremely white is extremely

masculine yet in spaces

urbanized and very densely

urbanized

the toilets are one of

most indispensable infrastructures

to satisfy our basic needs

obviously if we restrict access to

toilets to a part of the

population that means that we block

its displacement capacity

work-related leisure compared to

part of the population that she has

access to toilets

yet in my research when

I’m asking professionals from

architects of urban planners

a sentence that I hear extremely

often it is but we discriminate

no one is planning for everyone

it’s as if these gender inequalities

was totally invisible to their

eyes because actually they have them and

they are not used to

take into account the inequalities of

kind in account in their work

daily

because as soon as the training is done

do not talk about these questions at all

we are used to speaking by

example of class inequalities

social

by reading very classical books

like that of henri lefebvre the right to

the city is also criticizing urbanism

safe against people who

live on the street and then we do a

little hint of questions

accessibility for people to

reduced mobility by studying the laws

who are meant to make them

accessible all public space

we also learn one of the definitions

one of the definitions of urbanism that

is the spatial organization of cities

which presupposes that an authority

make choices based on certain values

yet according to who make up this

authority in fact especially when the 13

homogeneous from a social point of view we

realizes that there are certain parts

of the population that are going to be

advantaged and others who are going to be

rather discriminated and up

recently we’ve seen this medium of

the architect of urbanism was

extremely masculine

there is also extremely little when we

look in the urbanism theory

extremely few women who are

studied and when they are both

they are extremely contemporary

can think of françoise choay or

jane jacobs and here I speak to you

no culture and knowledge

feminists or gender studies

because that’s not at all

generally integrated in fact

in these formations there myself I

had to actually make the connection between the two

and it’s a bit of a coincidence

it was in 2011 that one year

after I start my studies

of town planning and I was in the process of

search a research topic

but it was not really passionate

by classical subjects like the

social housing infrastructure

transport or developments in the

land ownership

at the same time I discovered the

feminist circles and literature

feminist and this is the year that

I have read for the first time

simone de beauvoir and her second sex

and his awake been published 60 years

before my reading over 60 years to a

calf before reading but yet

it really echoed my

daily experience as a

person socialize as a woman

this reading there she has me as much

revolted that liberated somehow

and suddenly I had a species

of idea like that to tell me ah but in

I would have to do

urbanism and feminism in the same

time and I started doing a

little search is right now I

came across montréal and his

program fans’ city of the coup I

decided to go do my first

field of research there during

some months

did I find out there it’s

really hyper interesting the program

women and cities it was developed

in the early 90s in the goal

to integrate women at all ages

all scales of decision as much

citizen that administrative and political

in planning decisions and the

blow there have been all the years

following for a decade

about fifteen years ago

a lot of work that has been done

starting from the base and has in all

Montreal neighborhoods women have

makes exploratory

groups of women day and night

and the information they have

harvested were allowed to produce

documents towards the services

of town planning and suddenly there are plenty of

spaces that have been redeveloped

like park parking

underground metro stations

at the same time there is a feminization

also from the administrative and

technical of the body and then also

a takeover of more women

in places of decision in 1996 he

was there that system that was put in

place that is called between two stops

and it’s a system that allows people

women who travel alone in the evening in

the bus of requests is to ask this

we stop between two stops

story to be dropped closer

from her home that system they

still work today more than

twenty years later he is extremely

popular and it’s not just

used by women from all over

this work that has been done since

decades in montreal and in

other canadian cities like toronto

and in other cities of the united states

from australia also cities

European countries to which we have already

hint as come but also

berlin barcelona london and also

developing countries as

India or Mexico

urban planning professionals

France does not take into account these issues

the

compared to decades of work in

other countries than for some

years and that’s my subject of

current research of a thesis topic

I’m trying to understand why this

taking into account gender is also

late at the professionals of

urban planning in France

I’m trying to understand what are the

factors that encourage this

account or who discourages him or who

brake then I have several tracks to

to share with you

the first is the lack of

legitimacy of knowledge of the

feminist knowledge of the studies of

kind in this area yet there is

a lot of literature that exists but

it is very unknown there are

hundreds of references in English

but also in French that exists is

besides, I created a tool

online bibliography line that all the

world

we can consult or there are hundreds of

references available

the second hypothesis where tracks of

search this is the posture of

neutrality that the only

professionals to adopt in general

it’s a bit like they’re considering

they and they considered that they

were neutral people

totally rational and that their

personal experience not influenced him

at all their decisions

professional

it is the knowledge actually located

and the third point is more of a

hanging from the demographics of the middle

professional

the hypothesis is that the more there is more

are women in this environment but also

of people lgbt iq ie

lesbian gay bisexual transgender

queer intersex but also people

feminist plus the interests of all

these groups can be integrated

in daily work and better better

taken into account

so once we know how to ask all

his questions and that we integrate more

diversity in thinking what

solutions we can find for example

for the toilets

if I take the example of departure

today when we are designing

toilets men and women have made the

50 50 in terms of surface gold we saw that

women have more often than not

toilet that is larger and

and that there are systems

also more space compared to the eyes

blacks for example so necessarily that

largely explains the question of

there only because there are fewer stations

available for the same surface so

maybe we could think

simply to make a breakdown a

little more fair of the surface 60 40

70 30

for example we could also say

that it’s important to avoid this kind

of problem it was done at

the airport of orly in 2013 then

maybe we could avoid in

as a professional to reproduce

gender stereotypes and encourage

better division of labor

reproduction is important enough

we could even go further when

even compared to lass is question

of binary men women

we can go further than that

proposing for example systematically

neutral toilets that people

who do not consider themselves doing

part of neither category

category men or women that’s at

to say the intersex people the

people non- binary people

trans who are undergoing a lot of violence

in these spaces she could

use neutral toilets in all

peace of mind in all

security

maybe in the future we’ll go

even up to genres is

completely toilet spaces

for example launched by year only

only according to the functionality

that is, sitting or standing

knowing that there are also designers

currently looking for ways

to make totally alternative

good toilet to go back to a

point of view a little more general in

as professionals in urban planning

and the architectured

for sure we can not force

people to use the spaces of such or

such way

but that does not prevent us from

still wondering what

societal changes we want

to accompany that it goes into a

reflective approach

that means we will try to

understand what are our beers in

as an individual and as a

collective of professionals to find

better solutions really

inclusive

so that means we’re going to ask ourselves

questions like this are what are my

tickets as a person of such or

such origin this or that class

social of this or that genre is what

I tend to forget some

categories of the population

can i what can i

do in this case for

rebalance this oversight is mostly bac

societal evolution I want to

accompany it in time once

that we asked ourselves these questions

can start doing things a

other way in a new way

and more inclusive and I am

persuaded that those questions that you

be architects urbanists or whatever

be your job you can also

you

You the

[Applause]

[Music]

[Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *