Press "Enter" to skip to content

Is it better to be a generalist or a specialist? | Zach Jones | TEDxYouth@BrayfordPool


you should specialize focus on one thing

you should specialize focus on one thing and become an expert in your field and

and become an expert in your field and

and become an expert in your field and you you should keep your options open

you you should keep your options open

you you should keep your options open by being learning lots of things –

by being learning lots of things –

by being learning lots of things – either of those phrases sound familiar

either of those phrases sound familiar

either of those phrases sound familiar which one should you believe in the 15th

which one should you believe in the 15th

which one should you believe in the 15th century Renaissance man Leon Battista

century Renaissance man Leon Battista

century Renaissance man Leon Battista Alberti said and man can do all things

Alberti said and man can do all things

Alberti said and man can do all things if he Bob Wilson and I believe that’s

if he Bob Wilson and I believe that’s

if he Bob Wilson and I believe that’s still true for both men and women alike

still true for both men and women alike

still true for both men and women alike they might recognize the term

they might recognize the term

they might recognize the term Renaissance man or it’s more Mollison in

Renaissance man or it’s more Mollison in

Renaissance man or it’s more Mollison in polymath it was most famously used to

polymath it was most famously used to

polymath it was most famously used to describe Leonardo da Vinci a person

describe Leonardo da Vinci a person

describe Leonardo da Vinci a person whose areas of interest included anatomy

whose areas of interest included anatomy

whose areas of interest included anatomy painting architecture science music

painting architecture science music

painting architecture science music mathematics engineering literature and

mathematics engineering literature and

mathematics engineering literature and invention and there’s many many more so

invention and there’s many many more so

invention and there’s many many more so it’s certainly safe to say that he was

it’s certainly safe to say that he was

it’s certainly safe to say that he was not the specialist he was held in high

not the specialist he was held in high

not the specialist he was held in high regard by all of his peers and is still

regard by all of his peers and is still

regard by all of his peers and is still regarded as a universal genius by

regarded as a universal genius by

regarded as a universal genius by remaining open to all forms of knowledge

remaining open to all forms of knowledge

remaining open to all forms of knowledge da Vinci if you give the world the Mona

da Vinci if you give the world the Mona

da Vinci if you give the world the Mona Lisa as well as designs for inventions

Lisa as well as designs for inventions

Lisa as well as designs for inventions that were only conceived to be possible

that were only conceived to be possible

that were only conceived to be possible for centuries after his death more

for centuries after his death more

for centuries after his death more recently there was Thomas young

recently there was Thomas young

recently there was Thomas young described as the last man who knew

described as the last man who knew

described as the last man who knew everything which is a pretty killer

everything which is a pretty killer

everything which is a pretty killer title he worked in the fields of physics

title he worked in the fields of physics

title he worked in the fields of physics physiology music and Egyptology to

physiology music and Egyptology to

physiology music and Egyptology to mention a few

mention a few

mention a few his self-described most important

his self-described most important

his self-described most important discovery was the wave theory of life a

discovery was the wave theory of life a

discovery was the wave theory of life a scientific breakthrough so significant

scientific breakthrough so significant

scientific breakthrough so significant it’s still being taught in science

it’s still being taught in science

it’s still being taught in science lessons today

lessons today

lessons today unless many people might have seen this

unless many people might have seen this

unless many people might have seen this as their life’s work it was merely

as their life’s work it was merely

as their life’s work it was merely another bullet points on young’s long

another bullet points on young’s long

another bullet points on young’s long list of achievements if not fares

list of achievements if not fares

list of achievements if not fares Polymathic traits he would not have been

Polymathic traits he would not have been

Polymathic traits he would not have been one of the key contributors to the

one of the key contributors to the

one of the key contributors to the deciphering of the rosetta stone which

deciphering of the rosetta stone which

deciphering of the rosetta stone which subsequently led to the translation of

subsequently led to the translation of

subsequently led to the translation of ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics today

ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics today

ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics today polymaths and their collective hunger

polymaths and their collective hunger

polymaths and their collective hunger for knowledge has seen more as a novelty

for knowledge has seen more as a novelty

for knowledge has seen more as a novelty someone you would put on a quiz show or

someone you would put on a quiz show or

someone you would put on a quiz show or call on to settle a debate rather than

call on to settle a debate rather than

call on to settle a debate rather than being one of the leading minds in their

being one of the leading minds in their

being one of the leading minds in their field throughout their young lives we’re

field throughout their young lives we’re

field throughout their young lives we’re told to focus on those areas in which we

told to focus on those areas in which we

told to focus on those areas in which we excel becoming naturally specialized so

excel becoming naturally specialized so

excel becoming naturally specialized so this could potentially mean that were in

this could potentially mean that were in

this could potentially mean that were in a special society of specialization an

a special society of specialization an

a special society of specialization an example of this being Barry C bearish

example of this being Barry C bearish

example of this being Barry C bearish one of the three physicists who was

one of the three physicists who was

one of the three physicists who was recently awarded the Nobel Prize for his

recently awarded the Nobel Prize for his

recently awarded the Nobel Prize for his control contributions to the discovery

control contributions to the discovery

control contributions to the discovery of gravitational waves he has spent his

of gravitational waves he has spent his

of gravitational waves he has spent his entire life working in the field of

entire life working in the field of

entire life working in the field of physics so yes it’s partly true that we

physics so yes it’s partly true that we

physics so yes it’s partly true that we do live in a society of specialization

do live in a society of specialization

do live in a society of specialization throughout our young lives we are start

throughout our young lives we are start

throughout our young lives we are start off with a breadth of knowledge our

off with a breadth of knowledge our

off with a breadth of knowledge our eager young minds are gassed at what the

eager young minds are gassed at what the

eager young minds are gassed at what the world has to offer however soon we’re

world has to offer however soon we’re

world has to offer however soon we’re told that we must pick some subjects

told that we must pick some subjects

told that we must pick some subjects that we are good at or ones that we

that we are good at or ones that we

that we are good at or ones that we remember favourably finally we become

remember favourably finally we become

remember favourably finally we become specialized focusing our focusing our

specialized focusing our focusing our

specialized focusing our focusing our minds on one specific field with

minds on one specific field with

minds on one specific field with everything else being labeled as a hobby

everything else being labeled as a hobby

everything else being labeled as a hobby so is it still possible to be a polymath

so is it still possible to be a polymath

so is it still possible to be a polymath in that instance I believe so but not in

in that instance I believe so but not in

in that instance I believe so but not in the same way as Leonardo da Vinci Thomas

the same way as Leonardo da Vinci Thomas

the same way as Leonardo da Vinci Thomas Young are those many other generalists

Young are those many other generalists

Young are those many other generalists at the past we need a modern framework a

at the past we need a modern framework a

at the past we need a modern framework a modern definition a modern renaissance

modern definition a modern renaissance

modern definition a modern renaissance in our current society structured

in our current society structured

in our current society structured education is defined by the needs

education is defined by the needs

education is defined by the needs the companies the students will ascend

the companies the students will ascend

the companies the students will ascend to you learned direction to be a

to you learned direction to be a

to you learned direction to be a director or programming to be a

director or programming to be a

director or programming to be a programmer and so on rather than picking

programmer and so on rather than picking

programmer and so on rather than picking up as many different subjects as you

up as many different subjects as you

up as many different subjects as you would like this has changed over time

would like this has changed over time

would like this has changed over time primarily due to the fact that we’ve

primarily due to the fact that we’ve

primarily due to the fact that we’ve become a lot more smart smart as a

become a lot more smart smart as a

become a lot more smart smart as a society we have it we’ve intellectually

society we have it we’ve intellectually

society we have it we’ve intellectually advanced to the point where the simpler

advanced to the point where the simpler

advanced to the point where the simpler problems of the past have become much

problems of the past have become much

problems of the past have become much more complex which can be seen for the

more complex which can be seen for the

more complex which can be seen for the more streamlined discoveries of Thomas

more streamlined discoveries of Thomas

more streamlined discoveries of Thomas young compared to Leonardo da Vinci with

young compared to Leonardo da Vinci with

young compared to Leonardo da Vinci with the former being able to truly focus on

the former being able to truly focus on

the former being able to truly focus on fewer subjects than the latter

so today specialization seems to be the

so today specialization seems to be the most important way and the most

most important way and the most

most important way and the most pertinent way that we can unlock the

pertinent way that we can unlock the

pertinent way that we can unlock the complex mysteries of each subject

complex mysteries of each subject

complex mysteries of each subject however whilst generalization cannot be

however whilst generalization cannot be

however whilst generalization cannot be cannot lead to the most in the most

cannot lead to the most in the most

cannot lead to the most in the most innovative discoveries neither can

innovative discoveries neither can

innovative discoveries neither can complete specialization the most

complete specialization the most

complete specialization the most pressing issues are interdisciplinary

pressing issues are interdisciplinary

pressing issues are interdisciplinary and whilst a specialist can can be can

and whilst a specialist can can be can

and whilst a specialist can can be can benefit immensely from their their

benefit immensely from their their

benefit immensely from their their knowledge of their field they can be

knowledge of their field they can be

knowledge of their field they can be held back by this when working with

held back by this when working with

held back by this when working with those outside with specialization as the

those outside with specialization as the

those outside with specialization as the key pathway for learning was founded at

key pathway for learning was founded at

key pathway for learning was founded at a time when we were more single-minded

a time when we were more single-minded

a time when we were more single-minded and our problems were narrower in scope

and our problems were narrower in scope

and our problems were narrower in scope however the constantly evolving

however the constantly evolving

however the constantly evolving technological landscape of the past 60

technological landscape of the past 60

technological landscape of the past 60 years has caused much to change in that

years has caused much to change in that

years has caused much to change in that regard using the Internet as a tool for

regard using the Internet as a tool for

regard using the Internet as a tool for learning has changed the way in which we

learning has changed the way in which we

learning has changed the way in which we communicate and receive information we

communicate and receive information we

communicate and receive information we are no longer solitary neurological

are no longer solitary neurological

are no longer solitary neurological beings but a hive mind of infinitely

beings but a hive mind of infinitely

beings but a hive mind of infinitely expanding knowledge if we are truly to

expanding knowledge if we are truly to

expanding knowledge if we are truly to unlock the innovative

unlock the innovative

unlock the innovative potential of our species then

potential of our species then

potential of our species then collaboration is the key

collaboration is the key

collaboration is the key the modern polymath is not like Leonardo

the modern polymath is not like Leonardo

the modern polymath is not like Leonardo da Vinci or Thomas Young the modern

da Vinci or Thomas Young the modern

da Vinci or Thomas Young the modern polymath is a leader so take the head of

polymath is a leader so take the head of

polymath is a leader so take the head of a small online magazine company they

a small online magazine company they

a small online magazine company they would need to communicate creatively

would need to communicate creatively

would need to communicate creatively with the designers technically with the

with the designers technically with the

with the designers technically with the web developers linguistically with the

web developers linguistically with the

web developers linguistically with the writers all the while using business

writers all the while using business

writers all the while using business prowess to determine the financial needs

prowess to determine the financial needs

prowess to determine the financial needs of the company and steer the magazine’s

of the company and steer the magazine’s

of the company and steer the magazine’s content to the wants of its readers to

content to the wants of its readers to

content to the wants of its readers to be able to express themselves adequately

be able to express themselves adequately

be able to express themselves adequately in all of those fields is no small feat

in all of those fields is no small feat

in all of those fields is no small feat and whilst the head of this company must

and whilst the head of this company must

and whilst the head of this company must have a breadth of knowledge in order to

have a breadth of knowledge in order to

have a breadth of knowledge in order to be able to discuss thoroughly with each

be able to discuss thoroughly with each

be able to discuss thoroughly with each of these areas being a world leading

of these areas being a world leading

of these areas being a world leading expert in every single one of them would

expert in every single one of them would

expert in every single one of them would be an even greater and perhaps

be an even greater and perhaps

be an even greater and perhaps impossible task the specialist needs the

impossible task the specialist needs the

impossible task the specialist needs the generalist just as much as the

generalist just as much as the

generalist just as much as the generalists need the specialists the

generalists need the specialists the

generalists need the specialists the place for the generalists of today is to

place for the generalists of today is to

place for the generalists of today is to bridge the gap between those that

bridge the gap between those that

bridge the gap between those that specialize so this can be seen from

specialize so this can be seen from

specialize so this can be seen from Stephen Fry now he himself shares many

Stephen Fry now he himself shares many

Stephen Fry now he himself shares many Polymathic traits and as he once said

Polymathic traits and as he once said

Polymathic traits and as he once said regarding the polymaths natural

regarding the polymaths natural

regarding the polymaths natural inquisitiveness you have this impulse to

inquisitiveness you have this impulse to

inquisitiveness you have this impulse to know and therefore things stick to you

know and therefore things stick to you

know and therefore things stick to you you put on as it were epistemological

you put on as it were epistemological

you put on as it were epistemological wait

wait

wait I’ve always been fantastically greedy to

I’ve always been fantastically greedy to

I’ve always been fantastically greedy to know things now I like this quote

know things now I like this quote

know things now I like this quote because it gives us an insight into the

because it gives us an insight into the

because it gives us an insight into the thought processes of a generalist they

thought processes of a generalist they

thought processes of a generalist they it is no

it is no

it is no a lack of commitments that stares them

a lack of commitments that stares them

a lack of commitments that stares them away from single-subject learning but

away from single-subject learning but

away from single-subject learning but rather the soft satisfaction they gain

rather the soft satisfaction they gain

rather the soft satisfaction they gain from expanding their knowledge banks

from expanding their knowledge banks

from expanding their knowledge banks they don’t learn for any specific reason

they don’t learn for any specific reason

they don’t learn for any specific reason they simply enjoy it now Stephen Fry

they simply enjoy it now Stephen Fry

they simply enjoy it now Stephen Fry isn’t the only isn’t the only example

isn’t the only isn’t the only example

isn’t the only isn’t the only example surely but I picked I picked him because

surely but I picked I picked him because

surely but I picked I picked him because he’s both well-known and also as I said

he’s both well-known and also as I said

he’s both well-known and also as I said this quote is perfect for the insight

this quote is perfect for the insight

this quote is perfect for the insight you see the poem F is like a hungry

you see the poem F is like a hungry

you see the poem F is like a hungry child and the specialists of today are

child and the specialists of today are

child and the specialists of today are their parents slaving away in the

their parents slaving away in the

their parents slaving away in the kitchen to provide a meal that will

kitchen to provide a meal that will

kitchen to provide a meal that will excite their senses so in his research

excite their senses so in his research

excite their senses so in his research paper being interdisciplinary trading

paper being interdisciplinary trading

paper being interdisciplinary trading zones in cognitive science researcher

zones in cognitive science researcher

zones in cognitive science researcher Paul Fogg art discusses the way in which

Paul Fogg art discusses the way in which

Paul Fogg art discusses the way in which the boundaries of study can limit the

the boundaries of study can limit the

the boundaries of study can limit the scope of people’s cognition given the

scope of people’s cognition given the

scope of people’s cognition given the breadth of many of today’s problems

breadth of many of today’s problems

breadth of many of today’s problems phago concludes that by facilitating

phago concludes that by facilitating

phago concludes that by facilitating interdisciplinary teaching is this cause

interdisciplinary teaching is this cause

interdisciplinary teaching is this cause the field of cognitive science to

the field of cognitive science to

the field of cognitive science to flourish and this has been made possible

flourish and this has been made possible

flourish and this has been made possible by focusing on five key areas people

by focusing on five key areas people

by focusing on five key areas people those are our polymaths

those are our polymaths

those are our polymaths eager to cross disciplinary boundaries

eager to cross disciplinary boundaries

eager to cross disciplinary boundaries places where interdisciplinary

places where interdisciplinary

places where interdisciplinary collaboration is encouraged

collaboration is encouraged

collaboration is encouraged organizations they foster the

organizations they foster the

organizations they foster the collaboration between disciplines ideas

collaboration between disciplines ideas

collaboration between disciplines ideas these are the problems that combine

these are the problems that combine

these are the problems that combine areas of work and methods these are the

areas of work and methods these are the

areas of work and methods these are the solutions that require the input of

solutions that require the input of

solutions that require the input of polymaths now whilst this structure was

polymaths now whilst this structure was

polymaths now whilst this structure was originally defined for education it is

originally defined for education it is

originally defined for education it is just as person for the working world as

just as person for the working world as

just as person for the working world as well the key points that can be

well the key points that can be

well the key points that can be extrapolated from Paul research

extrapolated from Paul research

extrapolated from Paul research is that places places of work and

is that places places of work and

is that places places of work and educate

educate

educate along with the organizations that own

along with the organizations that own

along with the organizations that own them need to facilitate the polymath by

them need to facilitate the polymath by

them need to facilitate the polymath by creating a platform on which the the

creating a platform on which the the

creating a platform on which the the generalists can do what they do best it

generalists can do what they do best it

generalists can do what they do best it is possible that they will naturally

is possible that they will naturally

is possible that they will naturally place themselves to formulate a solution

place themselves to formulate a solution

place themselves to formulate a solution this can be done by focusing on what

this can be done by focusing on what

this can be done by focusing on what Fagor defines as the ideas if we make

Fagor defines as the ideas if we make

Fagor defines as the ideas if we make them the basis of everything we do then

them the basis of everything we do then

them the basis of everything we do then it’s possible that the polymaths will

it’s possible that the polymaths will

it’s possible that the polymaths will find this position and naturally solve

find this position and naturally solve

find this position and naturally solve the world’s problems and innovate an

the world’s problems and innovate an

the world’s problems and innovate an example Steven Spielberg for the filming

example Steven Spielberg for the filming

example Steven Spielberg for the filming of Schindler’s List there were at least

of Schindler’s List there were at least

of Schindler’s List there were at least 20 different departments ranging from

20 different departments ranging from

20 different departments ranging from sound production to set design Spielberg

sound production to set design Spielberg

sound production to set design Spielberg would have had to communicate with all

would have had to communicate with all

would have had to communicate with all of these incredibly differing with

of these incredibly differing with

of these incredibly differing with fields in order to keep everyone in line

fields in order to keep everyone in line

fields in order to keep everyone in line with the creative vision of the projects

with the creative vision of the projects

with the creative vision of the projects at ASCII certainly succeeded in with the

at ASCII certainly succeeded in with the

at ASCII certainly succeeded in with the film winning seven Oscars including one

film winning seven Oscars including one

film winning seven Oscars including one for Best Director going beyond just one

for Best Director going beyond just one

for Best Director going beyond just one film Steven Spielberg epitomizes the way

film Steven Spielberg epitomizes the way

film Steven Spielberg epitomizes the way in which the collaborative efforts of

in which the collaborative efforts of

in which the collaborative efforts of today’s polymaths

today’s polymaths

today’s polymaths can bring about change with his work

can bring about change with his work

can bring about change with his work contributing to the founding of the new

contributing to the founding of the new

contributing to the founding of the new Hollywood era another example of a

Hollywood era another example of a

Hollywood era another example of a modern polymath would be Oprah Winfrey

modern polymath would be Oprah Winfrey

modern polymath would be Oprah Winfrey thought by many to be the most

thought by many to be the most

thought by many to be the most influential woman in the world as the

influential woman in the world as the

influential woman in the world as the CEO of both Harpo Productions and the

CEO of both Harpo Productions and the

CEO of both Harpo Productions and the Oprah Winfrey Network chic encompasses

Oprah Winfrey Network chic encompasses

Oprah Winfrey Network chic encompasses the same Polymathic collaboration a

the same Polymathic collaboration a

the same Polymathic collaboration a Spielberg

Spielberg

Spielberg however it’s not purely as the head of

however it’s not purely as the head of

however it’s not purely as the head of two companies that she truly shows the

two companies that she truly shows the

two companies that she truly shows the importance of working with others this

importance of working with others this

importance of working with others this can be seen from her work as a public

can be seen from her work as a public

can be seen from her work as a public figure

figure

figure she is hailed as bringing change to the

she is hailed as bringing change to the

she is hailed as bringing change to the talk-show industry and this has been

talk-show industry and this has been

talk-show industry and this has been attributed to a natural empathy of

attributed to a natural empathy of

attributed to a natural empathy of people’s lives she’s a woman who has

people’s lives she’s a woman who has

people’s lives she’s a woman who has spent her entire life working towards

spent her entire life working towards

spent her entire life working towards and public expansion she is a modern

and public expansion she is a modern

and public expansion she is a modern polymath now you may all be sitting

polymath now you may all be sitting

polymath now you may all be sitting there thinking Steven Spielberg Oprah

there thinking Steven Spielberg Oprah

there thinking Steven Spielberg Oprah Winfrey there at the top of their

Winfrey there at the top of their

Winfrey there at the top of their industries the only way I can be a

industries the only way I can be a

industries the only way I can be a generalist is to pay my dues as a

generalist is to pay my dues as a

generalist is to pay my dues as a specialist however all it takes is that

specialist however all it takes is that

specialist however all it takes is that thirst for more knowledge the desire to

thirst for more knowledge the desire to

thirst for more knowledge the desire to do anything and everything I myself

do anything and everything I myself

do anything and everything I myself would not be here today standing in

would not be here today standing in

would not be here today standing in front of all of you if not for

front of all of you if not for

front of all of you if not for collaboration and a constant desire to

collaboration and a constant desire to

collaboration and a constant desire to learn I originally was specialized in

learn I originally was specialized in

learn I originally was specialized in computing yet after having the

computing yet after having the

computing yet after having the opportunity to work with media and

opportunity to work with media and

opportunity to work with media and design students I became much more

design students I became much more

design students I became much more involved in the arts long story short

involved in the arts long story short

involved in the arts long story short after working on multiple art projects

after working on multiple art projects

after working on multiple art projects one of which was with her team I was

one of which was with her team I was

one of which was with her team I was given the opportunity to speak with all

given the opportunity to speak with all

given the opportunity to speak with all of you about generalization and

of you about generalization and

of you about generalization and specialization so after all of this

specialization so after all of this

specialization so after all of this you’re probably wondering which one is

you’re probably wondering which one is

you’re probably wondering which one is better the truth is we need both

better the truth is we need both

better the truth is we need both specialists and generalists to solve the

specialists and generalists to solve the

specialists and generalists to solve the complex issues of the future in the past

complex issues of the future in the past

complex issues of the future in the past the Renaissance man held a monopoly over

the Renaissance man held a monopoly over

the Renaissance man held a monopoly over the over the knowledge and discoveries

the over the knowledge and discoveries

the over the knowledge and discoveries of the world there it collects all the

of the world there it collects all the

of the world there it collects all the research and lead the charge in as many

research and lead the charge in as many

research and lead the charge in as many different areas as possible and today

different areas as possible and today

different areas as possible and today we’re forced on a path of specialization

we’re forced on a path of specialization

we’re forced on a path of specialization even if we wish to discover as much as

even if we wish to discover as much as

even if we wish to discover as much as we can with those that truly dedicate

we can with those that truly dedicate

we can with those that truly dedicate themselves to a singular field being

themselves to a singular field being

themselves to a singular field being able to solve many of the world’s most

able to solve many of the world’s most

able to solve many of the world’s most pressing issues in the very near future

pressing issues in the very near future

pressing issues in the very near future however we will face into disciplinary

however we will face into disciplinary

however we will face into disciplinary minefields where the boundaries between

minefields where the boundaries between

minefields where the boundaries between lines of study are blurred and it

lines of study are blurred and it

lines of study are blurred and it requires more than just specialists in a

requires more than just specialists in a

requires more than just specialists in a singular field we need to collaborate in

singular field we need to collaborate in

singular field we need to collaborate in order to find these solutions and push

order to find these solutions and push

order to find these solutions and push humanity to its intellectual limits

humanity to its intellectual limits

humanity to its intellectual limits the future will not be centered around

the future will not be centered around

the future will not be centered around the question of specialists versus

the question of specialists versus

the question of specialists versus generalists it will instead be centered

generalists it will instead be centered

generalists it will instead be centered around specialists and generalists thank

around specialists and generalists thank

around specialists and generalists thank you

[Music]

[Music] you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *