Press "Enter" to skip to content

Intellectual property kills creativity | Joost Smiers | TEDxEindhoven


I like to speak about issue about doubt

I like to speak about issue about doubt and Bay maybe a little bit in the line

and Bay maybe a little bit in the line

and Bay maybe a little bit in the line of the first talk of this morning but it

of the first talk of this morning but it

of the first talk of this morning but it will get a more political turn I will

will get a more political turn I will

will get a more political turn I will speak about fundamental doubt the short

speak about fundamental doubt the short

speak about fundamental doubt the short moment the split moment if you think

moment the split moment if you think

moment the split moment if you think something what was important

something what was important

something what was important self-evident for me and it is not

self-evident for me and it is not

self-evident for me and it is not anymore and I ask you to come with me

anymore and I ask you to come with me

anymore and I ask you to come with me back in time April 1993 to the city of

back in time April 1993 to the city of

back in time April 1993 to the city of Geneva I was there for research and I

Geneva I was there for research and I

Geneva I was there for research and I went to the what would be the WTO the

went to the what would be the WTO the

went to the what would be the WTO the World Trade Organization you know the

World Trade Organization you know the

World Trade Organization you know the name but a bus must specifically more

name but a bus must specifically more

name but a bus must specifically more organized him what would come in this

organized him what would come in this

organized him what would come in this organization a treaty called trips trade

organization a treaty called trips trade

organization a treaty called trips trade related intellectual properties

related intellectual properties

related intellectual properties intellectual properties are copyrights

intellectual properties are copyrights

intellectual properties are copyrights patents breeders rights etc and would

patents breeders rights etc and would

patents breeders rights etc and would come a treaty about this so had several

come a treaty about this so had several

come a treaty about this so had several interviews with surface servants at that

interviews with surface servants at that

interviews with surface servants at that organization and in one of the

organization and in one of the

organization and in one of the interviews I mentioned that in the

interviews I mentioned that in the

interviews I mentioned that in the months before in India they have big

months before in India they have big

months before in India they have big uprisings from farmers against stiff

uprisings from farmers against stiff

uprisings from farmers against stiff strips because says that this treaty

strips because says that this treaty

strips because says that this treaty intellectual properties rights the

intellectual properties rights the

intellectual properties rights the privatize our seats we handed our seats

privatize our seats we handed our seats

privatize our seats we handed our seats from generation to generation and now it

from generation to generation and now it

from generation to generation and now it might be possible that a company comes

might be possible that a company comes

might be possible that a company comes along

along

along for instance Monsanto who says now

for instance Monsanto who says now

for instance Monsanto who says now belongs to me and you know this company

belongs to me and you know this company

belongs to me and you know this company controls also the distribution of seats

controls also the distribution of seats

controls also the distribution of seats and then I still remember the answer of

and then I still remember the answer of

and then I still remember the answer of this surfer servant he said this is a

this surfer servant he said this is a

this surfer servant he said this is a misunderstanding of those farmers of

misunderstanding of those farmers of

misunderstanding of those farmers of course to make it deceits but I’m not

course to make it deceits but I’m not

course to make it deceits but I’m not song to improves it of course it belongs

song to improves it of course it belongs

song to improves it of course it belongs to Monsanto and then they came that

to Monsanto and then they came that

to Monsanto and then they came that split moment of awareness after the

split moment of awareness after the

split moment of awareness after the interviewer looked over loch lomond lake

interviewer looked over loch lomond lake

interviewer looked over loch lomond lake near geneva looking to the mountains and

near geneva looking to the mountains and

near geneva looking to the mountains and I thought how cynical that what we built

I thought how cynical that what we built

I thought how cynical that what we built up for generation after generation that

up for generation after generation that

up for generation after generation that at one moment it can be multiple iced

at one moment it can be multiple iced

at one moment it can be multiple iced and privatized third it’s the start of a

and privatized third it’s the start of a

and privatized third it’s the start of a doubt about intellectual property rights

doubt about intellectual property rights

doubt about intellectual property rights because what is happening visit it is a

because what is happening visit it is a

because what is happening visit it is a privatization of a knowledge and of

privatization of a knowledge and of

privatization of a knowledge and of course many times the argument will be

course many times the argument will be

course many times the argument will be used we knew it the minute is not

used we knew it the minute is not

used we knew it the minute is not intellectual property rights otherwise

intellectual property rights otherwise

intellectual property rights otherwise we don’t get innovations did you real

we don’t get innovations did you real

we don’t get innovations did you real the site if you cover monopoly light for

the site if you cover monopoly light for

the site if you cover monopoly light for the supposed market failure at the other

the supposed market failure at the other

the supposed market failure at the other site you will get another market failure

site you will get another market failure

site you will get another market failure that at the same mind moment you give in

that at the same mind moment you give in

that at the same mind moment you give in monopoly property right nobody else may

monopoly property right nobody else may

monopoly property right nobody else may use this knowledge anymore to continue

use this knowledge anymore to continue

use this knowledge anymore to continue to fail abet cetera and that’s quite

to fail abet cetera and that’s quite

to fail abet cetera and that’s quite stupid for our societies at the meantime

stupid for our societies at the meantime

stupid for our societies at the meantime the system of intellectual property

the system of intellectual property

the system of intellectual property rights exist for longer the last 30

rights exist for longer the last 30

rights exist for longer the last 30 years have become broader extensive etc

years have become broader extensive etc

years have become broader extensive etc but understand all your arguments and

but understand all your arguments and

but understand all your arguments and that is for every product we buy we have

that is for every product we buy we have

that is for every product we buy we have to pay for mentorship property rights an

to pay for mentorship property rights an

to pay for mentorship property rights an American scholar the American economist

American scholar the American economist

American scholar the American economist Joseph Stiglitz said you may compare it

Joseph Stiglitz said you may compare it

Joseph Stiglitz said you may compare it to text

to text

to text you have to pay it and the saying is no

you have to pay it and the saying is no

you have to pay it and the saying is no taxation without representation but the

taxation without representation but the

taxation without representation but the consequence of this if we have to pay

consequence of this if we have to pay

consequence of this if we have to pay for it

for it

for it why we don’t have a saying what kind of

why we don’t have a saying what kind of

why we don’t have a saying what kind of things will developed what kind of

things will developed what kind of

things will developed what kind of results will be done

results will be done

results will be done why suitably the companies will decide

why suitably the companies will decide

why suitably the companies will decide for us what is good for us and I don’t

for us what is good for us and I don’t

for us what is good for us and I don’t like to say that everybody companies are

like to say that everybody companies are

like to say that everybody companies are developing is not good but there’s no

developing is not good but there’s no

developing is not good but there’s no say of us we don’t have any say about it

say of us we don’t have any say about it

say of us we don’t have any say about it and that’s no democratic so I started to

and that’s no democratic so I started to

and that’s no democratic so I started to change my doubt in the idea we should

change my doubt in the idea we should

change my doubt in the idea we should abolish a system of copyright and at the

abolish a system of copyright and at the

abolish a system of copyright and at the same time my responsibility was to think

same time my responsibility was to think

same time my responsibility was to think how can we finance new inventions at the

how can we finance new inventions at the

how can we finance new inventions at the same time your bilasa save some of

same time your bilasa save some of

same time your bilasa save some of copyrights products will become cheaper

copyrights products will become cheaper

copyrights products will become cheaper certainly in pharmaceuticals

certainly in pharmaceuticals

certainly in pharmaceuticals substantially cheaper if you take away

substantially cheaper if you take away

substantially cheaper if you take away this price this enormous price on the

this price this enormous price on the

this price this enormous price on the product the products will become cheaper

product the products will become cheaper

product the products will become cheaper and a part of that King can be put in

and a part of that King can be put in

and a part of that King can be put in public funds and this public funds can

public funds and this public funds can

public funds and this public funds can make tenders for research for university

make tenders for research for university

make tenders for research for university departments other institutes and the

departments other institutes and the

departments other institutes and the result of this will be free available

result of this will be free available

result of this will be free available for all us the means that via society

for all us the means that via society

for all us the means that via society enterprises citizens and TOC et cetera

enterprises citizens and TOC et cetera

enterprises citizens and TOC et cetera have to say about what kind of things we

have to say about what kind of things we

have to say about what kind of things we like to have developed I don’t have the

like to have developed I don’t have the

like to have developed I don’t have the time to give contradictions in this

obviously I’m not naive what I propose

obviously I’m not naive what I propose is an enormous change an enormous change

is an enormous change an enormous change

is an enormous change an enormous change an enormous transition

an enormous transition

an enormous transition and many of us will be here afraid for

and many of us will be here afraid for

and many of us will be here afraid for it yeah afraid what will happen what

it yeah afraid what will happen what

it yeah afraid what will happen what will happen but then I’d say it should

will happen but then I’d say it should

will happen but then I’d say it should become we made a lot of research about

become we made a lot of research about

become we made a lot of research about my proposal to abolish copyright and

my proposal to abolish copyright and

my proposal to abolish copyright and this in year that is a shame and our

this in year that is a shame and our

this in year that is a shame and our Peter DISA shame that our university

Peter DISA shame that our university

Peter DISA shame that our university departments and law economics here in

departments and law economics here in

departments and law economics here in the technical universities are cultural

the technical universities are cultural

the technical universities are cultural universities don’t do research about

universities don’t do research about

universities don’t do research about this paradigm shift the paradigm shift

this paradigm shift the paradigm shift

this paradigm shift the paradigm shift is in the air but they don’t do anything

is in the air but they don’t do anything

is in the air but they don’t do anything that is a shame but I propose to you is

that is a shame but I propose to you is

that is a shame but I propose to you is don’t be afraid for your doubts thank

don’t be afraid for your doubts thank

don’t be afraid for your doubts thank you very much

you very much

you very much [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *