Press "Enter" to skip to content

How to create a masterpiece | Gil Shohat | TEDxTelAviv


good evening my friends this creation of

good evening my friends this creation of absolute beauty by volved Anka Modell’s

absolute beauty by volved Anka Modell’s

absolute beauty by volved Anka Modell’s Mozart needs no explanation it’s a

Mozart needs no explanation it’s a

Mozart needs no explanation it’s a masterpiece

masterpiece

masterpiece now you’re trying to create something

now you’re trying to create something

now you’re trying to create something each one of you in your own fields it

each one of you in your own fields it

each one of you in your own fields it could be music arts literature

could be music arts literature

could be music arts literature it could be science or technology and

it could be science or technology and

it could be science or technology and when you create you don’t necessarily

when you create you don’t necessarily

when you create you don’t necessarily think about a masterpiece you are just

think about a masterpiece you are just

think about a masterpiece you are just trying to create but only a masterpiece

trying to create but only a masterpiece

trying to create but only a masterpiece is a piece that touches eternity it’s a

is a piece that touches eternity it’s a

is a piece that touches eternity it’s a piece that lasts so how do you create a

piece that lasts so how do you create a

piece that lasts so how do you create a masterpiece and what do we know about

masterpiece and what do we know about

masterpiece and what do we know about masterpieces my friends Leonard Cohen

masterpieces my friends Leonard Cohen

masterpieces my friends Leonard Cohen wrote this beautiful song called

wrote this beautiful song called

wrote this beautiful song called hallelujah

hallelujah

hallelujah in 1984 if you know the tune please

in 1984 if you know the tune please

in 1984 if you know the tune please don’t be shy and join me

don’t be shy and join me

don’t be shy and join me [Music]

[Music]

[Music] yeah

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] now since we sang it so well let’s go to

now since we sang it so well let’s go to

now since we sang it so well let’s go to another example a great is a true

another example a great is a true

another example a great is a true masterpiece for piano solo from the 20th

masterpiece for piano solo from the 20th

masterpiece for piano solo from the 20th century it goes like this if you know

century it goes like this if you know

century it goes like this if you know that you enjoy me

what you did in the same well some

what you did in the same well some people believe that this is the greatest

people believe that this is the greatest

people believe that this is the greatest journal piece written in the 20th

journal piece written in the 20th

journal piece written in the 20th century

century

century it’s called gas pedal and we by French

it’s called gas pedal and we by French

it’s called gas pedal and we by French composer Melissa ville and it was

composer Melissa ville and it was

composer Melissa ville and it was written in 1908 so how is it possible

written in 1908 so how is it possible

written in 1908 so how is it possible that you didn’t recognize it well some

that you didn’t recognize it well some

that you didn’t recognize it well some of you will say you know this is

of you will say you know this is

of you will say you know this is classical music it’s a style that is

classical music it’s a style that is

classical music it’s a style that is practically gone and classical music is

practically gone and classical music is

practically gone and classical music is not popular so let’s talk about style

not popular so let’s talk about style

not popular so let’s talk about style and popularity two terms are they really

and popularity two terms are they really

and popularity two terms are they really relevant to how to create a masterpiece

relevant to how to create a masterpiece

relevant to how to create a masterpiece I think that they are overrated and let

I think that they are overrated and let

I think that they are overrated and let me prove it to you let’s start with

me prove it to you let’s start with

me prove it to you let’s start with musical style here is a tune not written

musical style here is a tune not written

musical style here is a tune not written by Mozart it’s going like this this is

by Mozart it’s going like this this is

by Mozart it’s going like this this is the Nokia tune but let me play it for

the Nokia tune but let me play it for

the Nokia tune but let me play it for you in the style of Mozart

you in the style of Mozart

you in the style of Mozart [Music]

you know let me play it for you in

you know let me play it for you in impressionistic style by Chloe BC

impressionistic style by Chloe BC

impressionistic style by Chloe BC [Music]

[Music]

[Music] and here it is in the romantic style of

and here it is in the romantic style of

and here it is in the romantic style of Wagner

and wait here is the same tune in the

and wait here is the same tune in the toccata style of Russian composer Sergei

toccata style of Russian composer Sergei

toccata style of Russian composer Sergei Prokofiev

Prokofiev

Prokofiev [Music]

[Music]

[Music] you know my friend it doesn’t really

you know my friend it doesn’t really

you know my friend it doesn’t really matter in which style and playing this

matter in which style and playing this

matter in which style and playing this tune once you recognize it you once you

tune once you recognize it you once you

tune once you recognize it you once you know it once you like it you will indeed

know it once you like it you will indeed

know it once you like it you will indeed identified with any musical style so

identified with any musical style so

identified with any musical style so maybe it’s not about musical style now

maybe it’s not about musical style now

maybe it’s not about musical style now let’s think about popularity the other

let’s think about popularity the other

let’s think about popularity the other term that I think that is overrated be

term that I think that is overrated be

term that I think that is overrated be honest the music that you listen in your

honest the music that you listen in your

honest the music that you listen in your car at home the music that you like that

car at home the music that you like that

car at home the music that you like that you really loves not what your

you really loves not what your

you really loves not what your professors told you to say was written

professors told you to say was written

professors told you to say was written when 10 years ago 20 years ago 30 years

when 10 years ago 20 years ago 30 years

when 10 years ago 20 years ago 30 years ago

ago

ago now this is a timeline assuming that men

now this is a timeline assuming that men

now this is a timeline assuming that men started to write music put it in notes

started to write music put it in notes

started to write music put it in notes actually in the 5th century during the

actually in the 5th century during the

actually in the 5th century during the time more or less of the Gregorian

time more or less of the Gregorian

time more or less of the Gregorian chants and today we are in the year of

chants and today we are in the year of

chants and today we are in the year of 2017 look what a small fraction of the

2017 look what a small fraction of the

2017 look what a small fraction of the timeline we’re actually listening to

timeline we’re actually listening to

timeline we’re actually listening to think of 1500 years of creativity that

think of 1500 years of creativity that

think of 1500 years of creativity that we just ignore think of thousands of

we just ignore think of thousands of

we just ignore think of thousands of masterpieces that have been written

masterpieces that have been written

masterpieces that have been written during this time that we don’t know we

during this time that we don’t know we

during this time that we don’t know we never heard them well some culture

never heard them well some culture

never heard them well some culture vultures and severe educators they found

vultures and severe educators they found

vultures and severe educators they found who to blame they blame us they blame

who to blame they blame us they blame

who to blame they blame us they blame the public and they say that the public

the public and they say that the public

the public and they say that the public is shallow that public is narrow-minded

is shallow that public is narrow-minded

is shallow that public is narrow-minded the public is not educated and they they

the public is not educated and they they

the public is not educated and they they blame an educational system the Internet

blame an educational system the Internet

blame an educational system the Internet the government’s I don’t believe in this

the government’s I don’t believe in this

the government’s I don’t believe in this first of all I never blame the public

first of all I never blame the public

first of all I never blame the public second of all men always like to listen

second of all men always like to listen

second of all men always like to listen to music and enjoy pieces in general

to music and enjoy pieces in general

to music and enjoy pieces in general that are closer to him chronologically

that are closer to him chronologically

that are closer to him chronologically so instead of talking about style and

so instead of talking about style and

so instead of talking about style and instead of talking about popularity that

instead of talking about popularity that

instead of talking about popularity that as I said I think they overrated I would

as I said I think they overrated I would

as I said I think they overrated I would like to talk about three C’s three times

like to talk about three C’s three times

like to talk about three C’s three times letter C and we start with communication

letter C and we start with communication

letter C and we start with communication when Mozart writes this piece that I

when Mozart writes this piece that I

when Mozart writes this piece that I started my lecture

he composes it he encodes it it puts it

he composes it he encodes it it puts it in there in notes he transmits it to you

in there in notes he transmits it to you

in there in notes he transmits it to you through playing it on the piano

through playing it on the piano

through playing it on the piano through conducted it on the with the

through conducted it on the with the

through conducted it on the with the orchestra my question is do you receive

orchestra my question is do you receive

orchestra my question is do you receive it yes

it yes

it yes the melody is simple the Harmony is

the melody is simple the Harmony is

the melody is simple the Harmony is simple do you make sense out of it

simple do you make sense out of it

simple do you make sense out of it absolutely the flow between a and B is

absolutely the flow between a and B is

absolutely the flow between a and B is perfect and like that we have

perfect and like that we have

perfect and like that we have communication now if I play a piece that

communication now if I play a piece that

communication now if I play a piece that is avant-garde piece like that let’s say

is avant-garde piece like that let’s say

is avant-garde piece like that let’s say that I wrote it and I wrote it sincerely

that I wrote it and I wrote it sincerely

that I wrote it and I wrote it sincerely and I wrote it from the blood of my

and I wrote it from the blood of my

and I wrote it from the blood of my heart I really meant it I have a message

heart I really meant it I have a message

heart I really meant it I have a message to convey to you and let’s say that I’m

to convey to you and let’s say that I’m

to convey to you and let’s say that I’m you know educated enough to encode it to

you know educated enough to encode it to

you know educated enough to encode it to put it in music in a musical score and i

put it in music in a musical score and i

put it in music in a musical score and i transmitted i played on the piano i

transmitted i played on the piano i

transmitted i played on the piano i conduct it with my orchestra did you

conduct it with my orchestra did you

conduct it with my orchestra did you receive it did you make sense out of it

receive it did you make sense out of it

receive it did you make sense out of it my guess is not so the flow stops

beyonce she has a message around the

beyonce she has a message around the world my friend’s girl

world my friend’s girl

world my friend’s girl and babies and cheer up bitches

[Music]

[Music] go around the world girls who run the

go around the world girls who run the

go around the world girls who run the world girls that’s a message she simple

world girls that’s a message she simple

world girls that’s a message she simple you know she encode it and transmit it

you know she encode it and transmit it

you know she encode it and transmit it like no one else in the world she’s

like no one else in the world she’s

like no one else in the world she’s queen bee she’s the best did you receive

queen bee she’s the best did you receive

queen bee she’s the best did you receive it yes did you make sense out of it yes

it yes did you make sense out of it yes

it yes did you make sense out of it yes now some of you may think that who run

now some of you may think that who run

now some of you may think that who run the world

the world

the world boys even if you think like that

boys even if you think like that

boys even if you think like that it doesn’t matter because the flow

it doesn’t matter because the flow

it doesn’t matter because the flow between a and B is perfect is 100% and

between a and B is perfect is 100% and

between a and B is perfect is 100% and that’s why I think and I may say unlike

that’s why I think and I may say unlike

that’s why I think and I may say unlike my colleagues many of my colleagues that

my colleagues many of my colleagues that

my colleagues many of my colleagues that pop music and pop art do create

pop music and pop art do create

pop music and pop art do create masterpieces in our time

masterpieces in our time

masterpieces in our time so this is about communication my first

so this is about communication my first

so this is about communication my first C let’s go to the second C complexity

C let’s go to the second C complexity

C let’s go to the second C complexity consists of come together and Plex woven

consists of come together and Plex woven

consists of come together and Plex woven think of a big city you know with its

think of a big city you know with its

think of a big city you know with its woven streets now when you look at the

woven streets now when you look at the

woven streets now when you look at the picture you see all the details in the

picture you see all the details in the

picture you see all the details in the picture even though it’s complex I’m not

picture even though it’s complex I’m not

picture even though it’s complex I’m not afraid of this complex I’m taking a step

afraid of this complex I’m taking a step

afraid of this complex I’m taking a step back and I’m looking at the picture it’s

back and I’m looking at the picture it’s

back and I’m looking at the picture it’s magnificent it’s beautiful and why is it

magnificent it’s beautiful and why is it

magnificent it’s beautiful and why is it beautiful because it’s bigger than the

beautiful because it’s bigger than the

beautiful because it’s bigger than the sum of its parts the third C is

sum of its parts the third C is

sum of its parts the third C is complication consists of come together

complication consists of come together

complication consists of come together and click folded here some layers hide

and click folded here some layers hide

and click folded here some layers hide each other then we don’t really see the

each other then we don’t really see the

each other then we don’t really see the whole picture when I play a piece like

whole picture when I play a piece like

whole picture when I play a piece like that

that

that [Music]

[Music]

[Music] this is not complex this is complicated

this is not complex this is complicated

this is not complex this is complicated and the difference between the two so

and the difference between the two so

and the difference between the two so here is our model of the three C’s

here is our model of the three C’s

here is our model of the three C’s communication complexity and

communication complexity and

communication complexity and complication can we live with that

complication can we live with that

complication can we live with that no why because communication and

no why because communication and

no why because communication and complexity they have relations between

complexity they have relations between

complexity they have relations between them and complexity and complication

them and complexity and complication

them and complexity and complication they have thin border between themselves

they have thin border between themselves

they have thin border between themselves but my friends communication and

but my friends communication and

but my friends communication and complication will never get along and it

complication will never get along and it

complication will never get along and it doesn’t matter what you create in your

doesn’t matter what you create in your

doesn’t matter what you create in your life these two do not get along and in

life these two do not get along and in

life these two do not get along and in fact there are some dangers in this

fact there are some dangers in this

fact there are some dangers in this model because if I focus is a creator

model because if I focus is a creator

model because if I focus is a creator only on communication then I have the

only on communication then I have the

only on communication then I have the danger of adding the false see which is

danger of adding the false see which is

danger of adding the false see which is cheap and if I focus only on

cheap and if I focus only on

cheap and if I focus only on complication and I say communication is

complication and I say communication is

complication and I say communication is not important many people do that

not important many people do that

not important many people do that unfortunately then we have the risk of

unfortunately then we have the risk of

unfortunately then we have the risk of making something confusing now pieces

making something confusing now pieces

making something confusing now pieces can be confused people can be confused

can be confused people can be confused

can be confused people can be confused allow me to tell you a personal story

allow me to tell you a personal story

allow me to tell you a personal story but a tall one 20 years ago I was

but a tall one 20 years ago I was

but a tall one 20 years ago I was sitting in a beautiful day blue sky on

sitting in a beautiful day blue sky on

sitting in a beautiful day blue sky on the Spanish Steps in Rome Italy and I

the Spanish Steps in Rome Italy and I

the Spanish Steps in Rome Italy and I was very sad and I was very confused in

was very sad and I was very confused in

was very sad and I was very confused in that period of my life I did my PhD in

that period of my life I did my PhD in

that period of my life I did my PhD in musical composition in Europe and my

musical composition in Europe and my

musical composition in Europe and my teachers they forced me to believe in

teachers they forced me to believe in

teachers they forced me to believe in music that was complicated and that

music that was complicated and that

music that was complicated and that wasn’t me and that on that particular

wasn’t me and that on that particular

wasn’t me and that on that particular day my mentor the teacher that I fully

day my mentor the teacher that I fully

day my mentor the teacher that I fully adored told me Gil stopped writing for

adored told me Gil stopped writing for

adored told me Gil stopped writing for few years and I felt devastated I felt

few years and I felt devastated I felt

few years and I felt devastated I felt it’s the end of my way I felt it’s a

it’s the end of my way I felt it’s a

it’s the end of my way I felt it’s a t-junction it’s either right or left

t-junction it’s either right or left

t-junction it’s either right or left it’s either life or death so you know

it’s either life or death so you know

it’s either life or death so you know what I did right there on the Spanish

what I did right there on the Spanish

what I did right there on the Spanish Steps I invented miss H in my mind do

Steps I invented miss H in my mind do

Steps I invented miss H in my mind do you remember the film the wall by Pink

you remember the film the wall by Pink

you remember the film the wall by Pink Floyd 1982

Floyd 1982

Floyd 1982 this woman is Pink’s mom I chose her

this woman is Pink’s mom I chose her

this woman is Pink’s mom I chose her because she’s a very opinionated lady

because she’s a very opinionated lady

because she’s a very opinionated lady and she has no mercy nor compassion and

and she has no mercy nor compassion and

and she has no mercy nor compassion and she sometimes is wrong also in the short

she sometimes is wrong also in the short

she sometimes is wrong also in the short term but she’s always right

term but she’s always right

term but she’s always right in the long term and this lady holds the

in the long term and this lady holds the

in the long term and this lady holds the key of how to create a masterpiece in

key of how to create a masterpiece in

key of how to create a masterpiece in fact let’s think about this lady and her

fact let’s think about this lady and her

fact let’s think about this lady and her feelings regarding our model and I used

feelings regarding our model and I used

feelings regarding our model and I used that it will be understood for everybody

that it will be understood for everybody

that it will be understood for everybody the feelings that we use on Facebook she

the feelings that we use on Facebook she

the feelings that we use on Facebook she likes communication she’s wowed by

likes communication she’s wowed by

likes communication she’s wowed by complexity she doesn’t take seriously

complexity she doesn’t take seriously

complexity she doesn’t take seriously anything that is cheap and she said

anything that is cheap and she said

anything that is cheap and she said about complication and the reason she

about complication and the reason she

about complication and the reason she said about complication because she

said about complication because she

said about complication because she thinks all this work invested in vain

thinks all this work invested in vain

thinks all this work invested in vain she’s really angry at confusion so what

she’s really angry at confusion so what

she’s really angry at confusion so what she does she takes a big pair of

she does she takes a big pair of

she does she takes a big pair of scissors and my friends this is the

scissors and my friends this is the

scissors and my friends this is the point of my whole lecture miss H starts

point of my whole lecture miss H starts

point of my whole lecture miss H starts to cut who is Miss H who is Miss age

to cut who is Miss H who is Miss age

to cut who is Miss H who is Miss age miss H is history history will never

miss H is history history will never

miss H is history history will never tolerate anything that is complicated

tolerate anything that is complicated

tolerate anything that is complicated anything that is confusing or anything

anything that is confusing or anything

anything that is confusing or anything that is cheap she will cut without mercy

that is cheap she will cut without mercy

that is cheap she will cut without mercy and we are left with only to cease

and we are left with only to cease

and we are left with only to cease communication and complexity this is how

communication and complexity this is how

communication and complexity this is how you create a masterpiece communication

you create a masterpiece communication

you create a masterpiece communication and complexity and the interaction

and complexity and the interaction

and complexity and the interaction between the two that’s the most

between the two that’s the most

between the two that’s the most important thing Steve Jobs with H loves

important thing Steve Jobs with H loves

important thing Steve Jobs with H loves him you know why he thought that pieces

him you know why he thought that pieces

him you know why he thought that pieces are ugly and complicated so he invented

are ugly and complicated so he invented

are ugly and complicated so he invented this you know this is come this is we’re

this you know this is come this is we’re

this you know this is come this is we’re all communicating with this with this

all communicating with this with this

all communicating with this with this instrument but it’s cutting edge

instrument but it’s cutting edge

instrument but it’s cutting edge technology it’s very complex at the same

technology it’s very complex at the same

technology it’s very complex at the same time Shakespeare we think of Romeo and

time Shakespeare we think of Romeo and

time Shakespeare we think of Romeo and Juliet and we think of great love but

Juliet and we think of great love but

Juliet and we think of great love but did you really read woman Juliet

did you really read woman Juliet

did you really read woman Juliet oh man Juliet is one of the most complex

oh man Juliet is one of the most complex

oh man Juliet is one of the most complex plays ever written like she actually

plays ever written like she actually

plays ever written like she actually plays you know the relationships between

plays you know the relationships between

plays you know the relationships between the characters it’s just crazy

the characters it’s just crazy

the characters it’s just crazy Athens Parthenon stands for thousands of

Athens Parthenon stands for thousands of

Athens Parthenon stands for thousands of years it’s a true masterpiece when when

years it’s a true masterpiece when when

years it’s a true masterpiece when when we look at it it seems simple but the

we look at it it seems simple but the

we look at it it seems simple but the mathematical relationships between its

mathematical relationships between its

mathematical relationships between its proportions are infinite Ludwig van

proportions are infinite Ludwig van

proportions are infinite Ludwig van battery he took four simple notes sounds

battery he took four simple notes sounds

battery he took four simple notes sounds like this you know it’s so simple so

like this you know it’s so simple so

like this you know it’s so simple so communicative and he created one of the

communicative and he created one of the

communicative and he created one of the greatest symphonies ever written

greatest symphonies ever written

greatest symphonies ever written Beethoven’s fifth and extremely complex

Beethoven’s fifth and extremely complex

Beethoven’s fifth and extremely complex one Big Mac McDonald’s makes me hungry

one Big Mac McDonald’s makes me hungry

one Big Mac McDonald’s makes me hungry what could be more simple than

what could be more simple than

what could be more simple than McDonald’s my friends if you only knew

McDonald’s my friends if you only knew

McDonald’s my friends if you only knew how many months and what a complex

how many months and what a complex

how many months and what a complex process the McDonald brothers had to go

process the McDonald brothers had to go

process the McDonald brothers had to go through in order to place the workers in

through in order to place the workers in

through in order to place the workers in the kitchen in terms of centimeters to

the kitchen in terms of centimeters to

the kitchen in terms of centimeters to create a hamburger in 30 seconds so how

create a hamburger in 30 seconds so how

create a hamburger in 30 seconds so how do we create a masterpiece first of all

do we create a masterpiece first of all

do we create a masterpiece first of all we don’t listen to our teachers

we don’t listen to our teachers

we don’t listen to our teachers second of all we take big pair of

second of all we take big pair of

second of all we take big pair of scissors and we cut everything that is

scissors and we cut everything that is

scissors and we cut everything that is complicated confusing cheap from what we

complicated confusing cheap from what we

complicated confusing cheap from what we created we stay communicative and we are

created we stay communicative and we are

created we stay communicative and we are not afraid of complexity and we let miss

not afraid of complexity and we let miss

not afraid of complexity and we let miss H do the rest

H do the rest

H do the rest [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *