Press "Enter" to skip to content

How refugees can teach us cultural competency | Daniel Socha | TEDxKentState


so often when we think about culture we

so often when we think about culture we look outwardly we try to understand and

look outwardly we try to understand and

look outwardly we try to understand and figure out others cultural practices and

figure out others cultural practices and

figure out others cultural practices and beliefs and although this can be

beliefs and although this can be

beliefs and although this can be important another crucial part of

important another crucial part of

important another crucial part of intercultural communication is to look

intercultural communication is to look

intercultural communication is to look introspectively at our own assumptions

introspectively at our own assumptions

introspectively at our own assumptions values and norms and as global

values and norms and as global

values and norms and as global integration and emigration continue at

integration and emigration continue at

integration and emigration continue at it to increase at an exponential rate

it to increase at an exponential rate

it to increase at an exponential rate never has there been a more important

never has there been a more important

never has there been a more important time to focus on our relationships and

time to focus on our relationships and

time to focus on our relationships and our communication in intercultural

our communication in intercultural

our communication in intercultural spaces over the next few minutes I will

spaces over the next few minutes I will

spaces over the next few minutes I will describe some techniques for enacting an

describe some techniques for enacting an

describe some techniques for enacting an introspective approach to culture this

introspective approach to culture this

introspective approach to culture this is an approach in which we continually

is an approach in which we continually

is an approach in which we continually and critically question our assumptions

and critically question our assumptions

and critically question our assumptions and work to deconstruct the stereotypes

and work to deconstruct the stereotypes

and work to deconstruct the stereotypes which we might have so over the past 40

which we might have so over the past 40

which we might have so over the past 40 years or so there’s been this large

years or so there’s been this large

years or so there’s been this large large number of industries that have

large number of industries that have

large number of industries that have come up with these cultural competency

come up with these cultural competency

come up with these cultural competency programs in response to rapid

programs in response to rapid

programs in response to rapid globalization many of these programs are

globalization many of these programs are

globalization many of these programs are designed to make practitioners more

designed to make practitioners more

designed to make practitioners more competent in their knowledge of others

competent in their knowledge of others

competent in their knowledge of others cultural practices and beliefs such as

cultural practices and beliefs such as

cultural practices and beliefs such as appropriate hand gestures and personal

appropriate hand gestures and personal

appropriate hand gestures and personal space boundaries however in recent years

space boundaries however in recent years

space boundaries however in recent years scholars and practitioners have begun to

scholars and practitioners have begun to

scholars and practitioners have begun to notice the shortcomings of such

notice the shortcomings of such

notice the shortcomings of such approaches for instance in one training

approaches for instance in one training

approaches for instance in one training that tried to train medical

that tried to train medical

that tried to train medical practitioners about Latino culture it

practitioners about Latino culture it

practitioners about Latino culture it was found that latina patients on Latino

was found that latina patients on Latino

was found that latina patients on Latino patients received less pain medication

patients received less pain medication

patients received less pain medication than other patients with similar

than other patients with similar

than other patients with similar ailments based on the assumption that

ailments based on the assumption that

ailments based on the assumption that their pain was over exaggerated and so

their pain was over exaggerated and so

their pain was over exaggerated and so in response to these cultural competency

in response to these cultural competency

in response to these cultural competency trainings authors and researchers

trainings authors and researchers

trainings authors and researchers Melanie toulebonne and John Marie Garcia

Melanie toulebonne and John Marie Garcia

Melanie toulebonne and John Marie Garcia contend that instead of learning some

contend that instead of learning some

contend that instead of learning some fixed body of cultural know-how we need

fixed body of cultural know-how we need

fixed body of cultural know-how we need to enact cultural humility these

to enact cultural humility these

to enact cultural humility these processes of ongoing self-reflection and

processes of ongoing self-reflection and

processes of ongoing self-reflection and so building on the notion of cultural

so building on the notion of cultural

so building on the notion of cultural humility the first strategy for working

humility the first strategy for working

humility the first strategy for working introspectively involves

introspectively involves

introspectively involves working with others and coming over our

working with others and coming over our

working with others and coming over our cultural know-how going beyond our

cultural know-how going beyond our

cultural know-how going beyond our cultural know-how and so in order to do

cultural know-how and so in order to do

cultural know-how and so in order to do that first we must resist the urge to

that first we must resist the urge to

that first we must resist the urge to essentialize and generalize culture

essentialize and generalize culture

essentialize and generalize culture post-colonial writer Gary at Steve axe

post-colonial writer Gary at Steve axe

post-colonial writer Gary at Steve axe turns terms essential izing as the

turns terms essential izing as the

turns terms essential izing as the process through which we reduce a

process through which we reduce a

process through which we reduce a culture down to a select number of

culture down to a select number of

culture down to a select number of traits we’ve all done that right I mean

traits we’ve all done that right I mean

traits we’ve all done that right I mean at some point in time so for instance

at some point in time so for instance

at some point in time so for instance you might think about French culture and

you might think about French culture and

you might think about French culture and you might think about sitting in a cafe

you might think about sitting in a cafe

you might think about sitting in a cafe in the middle of the day and drinking a

in the middle of the day and drinking a

in the middle of the day and drinking a glass of wine and smoking a cigarette

glass of wine and smoking a cigarette

glass of wine and smoking a cigarette but is that all there is to French

but is that all there is to French

but is that all there is to French culture and if the culture is not our

culture and if the culture is not our

culture and if the culture is not our own we’re predisposed to use stereotypes

own we’re predisposed to use stereotypes

own we’re predisposed to use stereotypes about those cultures to inform ourselves

about those cultures to inform ourselves

about those cultures to inform ourselves about it and sometimes that can lead us

about it and sometimes that can lead us

about it and sometimes that can lead us into making some crazy assumptions the

into making some crazy assumptions the

into making some crazy assumptions the other thing is with essentializing so

other thing is with essentializing so

other thing is with essentializing so reducing down we also generalize we lump

reducing down we also generalize we lump

reducing down we also generalize we lump people together from particular places

people together from particular places

people together from particular places and we expect them to conform to our

and we expect them to conform to our

and we expect them to conform to our stereotypes and so ponder for a minute

stereotypes and so ponder for a minute

stereotypes and so ponder for a minute we’re all we’re all here in the United

we’re all we’re all here in the United

we’re all we’re all here in the United States of America if someone were to ask

States of America if someone were to ask

States of America if someone were to ask us what is American culture can you

us what is American culture can you

us what is American culture can you define that for me we would likely

define that for me we would likely

define that for me we would likely provide a variety of responses based on

provide a variety of responses based on

provide a variety of responses based on our own personal experiences here in the

our own personal experiences here in the

our own personal experiences here in the United States stereotypes would also

United States stereotypes would also

United States stereotypes would also likely inform our different orientations

likely inform our different orientations

likely inform our different orientations and ideas about cultural practices in

and ideas about cultural practices in

and ideas about cultural practices in the United States so an example that

the United States so an example that

the United States so an example that highlights this is one time I was

highlights this is one time I was

highlights this is one time I was teaching a English culture class English

teaching a English culture class English

teaching a English culture class English ESL and culture class to a group of

ESL and culture class to a group of

ESL and culture class to a group of refugees and we came on the topic of

refugees and we came on the topic of

refugees and we came on the topic of sports and at that time the Cape

sports and at that time the Cape

sports and at that time the Cape Cleveland Cavaliers were in the National

Cleveland Cavaliers were in the National

Cleveland Cavaliers were in the National Basketball Association finals and some

Basketball Association finals and some

Basketball Association finals and some of the members of the class were really

of the members of the class were really

of the members of the class were really curious about this they started hearing

curious about this they started hearing

curious about this they started hearing there was big hype around the Cleveland

there was big hype around the Cleveland

there was big hype around the Cleveland Cavs and they said you know hey how’s

Cavs and they said you know hey how’s

Cavs and they said you know hey how’s this game work I can only name LeBron

this game work I can only name LeBron

this game work I can only name LeBron James you know and I know absolutely

James you know and I know absolutely

James you know and I know absolutely nothing about basketball I’m like can

nothing about basketball I’m like can

nothing about basketball I’m like can you pick it up and like throw it in the

you pick it up and like throw it in the

you pick it up and like throw it in the air I have no idea so so to their dismay

air I have no idea so so to their dismay

air I have no idea so so to their dismay I had no idea about these things and and

I had no idea about these things and and

I had no idea about these things and and something that really stuck

something that really stuck

something that really stuck me is when one of my students said to me

me is when one of my students said to me

me is when one of my students said to me he said but Daniel aren’t you American

he said but Daniel aren’t you American

he said but Daniel aren’t you American and from there the class began to

and from there the class began to

and from there the class began to question whether or not I was Swedish so

question whether or not I was Swedish so

question whether or not I was Swedish so they thought that and it wasn’t quite

they thought that and it wasn’t quite

they thought that and it wasn’t quite true and so although this instance is

true and so although this instance is

true and so although this instance is humorous and light-hearted the problem

humorous and light-hearted the problem

humorous and light-hearted the problem is that sometimes these assumptions can

is that sometimes these assumptions can

is that sometimes these assumptions can be very presumptuous and fraught with

be very presumptuous and fraught with

be very presumptuous and fraught with racist you know racist notions and we

racist you know racist notions and we

racist you know racist notions and we don’t know that we’re doing it and so we

don’t know that we’re doing it and so we

don’t know that we’re doing it and so we need to think about that and so surely

need to think about that and so surely

need to think about that and so surely we’re all going to generalize and

we’re all going to generalize and

we’re all going to generalize and essentialize this is inevitable and so

essentialize this is inevitable and so

essentialize this is inevitable and so this inter called introspective approach

this inter called introspective approach

this inter called introspective approach to culture that I’m talking about tells

to culture that I’m talking about tells

to culture that I’m talking about tells us that we don’t need to adhere to some

us that we don’t need to adhere to some

us that we don’t need to adhere to some pristine cultural morality in which we

pristine cultural morality in which we

pristine cultural morality in which we no longer generalize that’s not going to

no longer generalize that’s not going to

no longer generalize that’s not going to happen but rather such an approach asks

happen but rather such an approach asks

happen but rather such an approach asks us to continuously question our

us to continuously question our

us to continuously question our assumptions and look introspectively

assumptions and look introspectively

assumptions and look introspectively at the ways in which our personal

at the ways in which our personal

at the ways in which our personal experiences and our personal knowledge

experiences and our personal knowledge

experiences and our personal knowledge can create and perpetuate stereotypes

can create and perpetuate stereotypes

can create and perpetuate stereotypes and so this leads into the second

and so this leads into the second

and so this leads into the second fundamental strategy to this

fundamental strategy to this

fundamental strategy to this introspective approach and it’s called

introspective approach and it’s called

introspective approach and it’s called reflexivity

reflexivity

reflexivity and reflexivity goes beyond evading

and reflexivity goes beyond evading

and reflexivity goes beyond evading stereotypes and prompts us to reflect

stereotypes and prompts us to reflect

stereotypes and prompts us to reflect and think during our cultural

and think during our cultural

and think during our cultural interactions and after and so on one

interactions and after and so on one

interactions and after and so on one level reflexivity is enacted in fleeting

level reflexivity is enacted in fleeting

level reflexivity is enacted in fleeting moments where we just take a moment to

moments where we just take a moment to

moments where we just take a moment to stop and pause and we don’t do that

stop and pause and we don’t do that

stop and pause and we don’t do that often enough and but then on another

often enough and but then on another

often enough and but then on another level we can practice reflexivity before

level we can practice reflexivity before

level we can practice reflexivity before and after interactions in intercultural

and after interactions in intercultural

and after interactions in intercultural spaces and we can do this through

spaces and we can do this through

spaces and we can do this through jotting down notes you know just musing

jotting down notes you know just musing

jotting down notes you know just musing for a while journaling talking with a

for a while journaling talking with a

for a while journaling talking with a friend about our experiences um and so

friend about our experiences um and so

friend about our experiences um and so we need when we’re doing this we need to

we need when we’re doing this we need to

we need when we’re doing this we need to silence the assumption making demons our

silence the assumption making demons our

silence the assumption making demons our head the other important part is we need

head the other important part is we need

head the other important part is we need to ask our questions more humbly and

to ask our questions more humbly and

to ask our questions more humbly and whoever said there are no bad questions

whoever said there are no bad questions

whoever said there are no bad questions they were very very wrong I’m under the

they were very very wrong I’m under the

they were very very wrong I’m under the belief that they were and so for

belief that they were and so for

belief that they were and so for instance a professor of history and

instance a professor of history and

instance a professor of history and political science

political science

political science Curtis kiemce he notes that when

Curtis kiemce he notes that when

Curtis kiemce he notes that when Americans meet people from Africa

Americans meet people from Africa

Americans meet people from Africa oftentimes the very first question they

oftentimes the very first question they

oftentimes the very first question they ask is what tribe are you from and so

ask is what tribe are you from and so

ask is what tribe are you from and so Curtis Keene goes on to point out the

Curtis Keene goes on to point out the

Curtis Keene goes on to point out the ways in which this can be really

ways in which this can be really

ways in which this can be really offensive and loaded with assumptions

offensive and loaded with assumptions

offensive and loaded with assumptions first Africa is an incredibly diverse

first Africa is an incredibly diverse

first Africa is an incredibly diverse continent it’s huge and to describe the

continent it’s huge and to describe the

continent it’s huge and to describe the social and political structures in that

social and political structures in that

social and political structures in that continent and reduce it down to just

continent and reduce it down to just

continent and reduce it down to just tribe is completely incorrect and then

tribe is completely incorrect and then

tribe is completely incorrect and then the other part is sometimes we think

the other part is sometimes we think

the other part is sometimes we think about tribe and its associated with

about tribe and its associated with

about tribe and its associated with primitiveness and it perpetuates

primitiveness and it perpetuates

primitiveness and it perpetuates falesha stereotypes of Africa is savage

falesha stereotypes of Africa is savage

falesha stereotypes of Africa is savage or backwards and this is not true and so

or backwards and this is not true and so

or backwards and this is not true and so although these kind of questions are

although these kind of questions are

although these kind of questions are formed with curious intentions it’s very

formed with curious intentions it’s very

formed with curious intentions it’s very fun to learn about where other people

fun to learn about where other people

fun to learn about where other people are from we all want to do that right

are from we all want to do that right

are from we all want to do that right like that’s that’s what’s fun about

like that’s that’s what’s fun about

like that’s that’s what’s fun about living in an intercultural world but

living in an intercultural world but

living in an intercultural world but what we need to do is we need to look

what we need to do is we need to look

what we need to do is we need to look more introspectively

more introspectively

more introspectively at how our assumptions can hinder us in

at how our assumptions can hinder us in

at how our assumptions can hinder us in the way that we can add those

the way that we can add those

the way that we can add those assumptions into our intercultural

assumptions into our intercultural

assumptions into our intercultural communication and so the next thing is

communication and so the next thing is

communication and so the next thing is we need to get rid of this learned

we need to get rid of this learned

we need to get rid of this learned cultural expertise in this day and age

cultural expertise in this day and age

cultural expertise in this day and age we like to learn about culture and I do

we like to learn about culture and I do

we like to learn about culture and I do it all the time I’m so guilty of it all

it all the time I’m so guilty of it all

it all the time I’m so guilty of it all the time and I noticed myself thinking

the time and I noticed myself thinking

the time and I noticed myself thinking like I’m the expert and people will ask

like I’m the expert and people will ask

like I’m the expert and people will ask me they’ll say oh you’ve been Africa

me they’ll say oh you’ve been Africa

me they’ll say oh you’ve been Africa tell me about what they do in Africa and

tell me about what they do in Africa and

tell me about what they do in Africa and I’m like well I don’t really know

I’m like well I don’t really know

I’m like well I don’t really know because I’ve been to like five cities

because I’ve been to like five cities

because I’ve been to like five cities you know and so when we’re thinking

you know and so when we’re thinking

you know and so when we’re thinking about this when we relinquish our selves

about this when we relinquish our selves

about this when we relinquish our selves of expertise we need to go beyond what

of expertise we need to go beyond what

of expertise we need to go beyond what we read on the internet so I have this

we read on the internet so I have this

we read on the internet so I have this story is when I went to Morocco I went

story is when I went to Morocco I went

story is when I went to Morocco I went to Morocco and before I went I went on

to Morocco and before I went I went on

to Morocco and before I went I went on the internet to learn about the taboos

the internet to learn about the taboos

the internet to learn about the taboos and culturally appropriate customs of

and culturally appropriate customs of

and culturally appropriate customs of Morocco and in many ways this served me

Morocco and in many ways this served me

Morocco and in many ways this served me well I learned that you eat with your

well I learned that you eat with your

well I learned that you eat with your right hand and you put your hand on your

right hand and you put your hand on your

right hand and you put your hand on your heart to say nice to meet you and these

heart to say nice to meet you and these

heart to say nice to meet you and these things were really helpful because

things were really helpful because

things were really helpful because people were very happy that I took the

people were very happy that I took the

people were very happy that I took the time to learn

time to learn

time to learn but sometimes it sent me astray and so

but sometimes it sent me astray and so

but sometimes it sent me astray and so an instance of this is in Morocco dogs I

an instance of this is in Morocco dogs I

an instance of this is in Morocco dogs I read on the internet on this website

read on the internet on this website

read on the internet on this website should never be in the house they’re

should never be in the house they’re

should never be in the house they’re considered dirty they are considered

considered dirty they are considered

considered dirty they are considered dangerous

dangerous

dangerous you shouldn’t go and touch a dog on the

you shouldn’t go and touch a dog on the

you shouldn’t go and touch a dog on the street this is just a bad bad thing to

street this is just a bad bad thing to

street this is just a bad bad thing to do

do

do so I was like alright I’ll see a dog I’m

so I was like alright I’ll see a dog I’m

so I was like alright I’ll see a dog I’m not touching it like get out of there

not touching it like get out of there

not touching it like get out of there and there’s a lot of stray dogs and so

and there’s a lot of stray dogs and so

and there’s a lot of stray dogs and so one day my friend invited me to his home

one day my friend invited me to his home

one day my friend invited me to his home for dinner and he’s like alright come

for dinner and he’s like alright come

for dinner and he’s like alright come over to my house Daniel we’d love to

over to my house Daniel we’d love to

over to my house Daniel we’d love to have you I want to introduce you to my

have you I want to introduce you to my

have you I want to introduce you to my father and I walk into the house and the

father and I walk into the house and the

father and I walk into the house and the first thing I see is my friend’s father

first thing I see is my friend’s father

first thing I see is my friend’s father sitting on the couch with this tiny

sitting on the couch with this tiny

sitting on the couch with this tiny little dog on his lap and he’s petting

little dog on his lap and he’s petting

little dog on his lap and he’s petting it and I think the thought I forget what

it and I think the thought I forget what

it and I think the thought I forget what the dog’s name was but so like I go up

the dog’s name was but so like I go up

the dog’s name was but so like I go up to him and with curious tension in

to him and with curious tension in

to him and with curious tension in tension I go up and I say hello and I

tension I go up and I say hello and I

tension I go up and I say hello and I say why do you have a dog in your house

say why do you have a dog in your house

say why do you have a dog in your house isn’t that taboo in Morocco to which he

isn’t that taboo in Morocco to which he

isn’t that taboo in Morocco to which he responded for some people yes but for me

responded for some people yes but for me

responded for some people yes but for me I really like my dog so I go to my

I really like my dog so I go to my

I really like my dog so I go to my friend’s house for dinner and the first

friend’s house for dinner and the first

friend’s house for dinner and the first question I even say like how are you I

question I even say like how are you I

question I even say like how are you I just say to him isn’t that taboo and

just say to him isn’t that taboo and

just say to him isn’t that taboo and Morocco based on something that I had

Morocco based on something that I had

Morocco based on something that I had read on the Internet and so although

read on the Internet and so although

read on the Internet and so although like this wasn’t super detrimental to

like this wasn’t super detrimental to

like this wasn’t super detrimental to the relationship sometimes when we

the relationship sometimes when we

the relationship sometimes when we impose our assumptions and put them into

impose our assumptions and put them into

impose our assumptions and put them into our questions they can and so through

our questions they can and so through

our questions they can and so through practicing reflexivity this really

practicing reflexivity this really

practicing reflexivity this really crucial part of an introspective

crucial part of an introspective

crucial part of an introspective approach we can take the time to make

approach we can take the time to make

approach we can take the time to make pauses in our communication and think

pauses in our communication and think

pauses in our communication and think you know just thing is that is there an

you know just thing is that is there an

you know just thing is that is there an assumption in there and then so an

assumption in there and then so an

assumption in there and then so an introspective approach can be

introspective approach can be

introspective approach can be drastically helpful in improving our

drastically helpful in improving our

drastically helpful in improving our relationships in intercultural spaces

relationships in intercultural spaces

relationships in intercultural spaces and now more than ever in a social and

and now more than ever in a social and

and now more than ever in a social and political climate that demonizes

political climate that demonizes

political climate that demonizes refugees and immigrants we need to look

refugees and immigrants we need to look

refugees and immigrants we need to look inside of ourselves for ways to support

inside of ourselves for ways to support

inside of ourselves for ways to support and welcome people from diverse cultural

and welcome people from diverse cultural

and welcome people from diverse cultural backgrounds and ultimately an

backgrounds and ultimately an

backgrounds and ultimately an introspective approach looking inside of

introspective approach looking inside of

introspective approach looking inside of ourselves lacks us to focus less on

ourselves lacks us to focus less on

ourselves lacks us to focus less on culture and more on individuals as you

culture and more on individuals as you

culture and more on individuals as you and beings thank you so much

and beings thank you so much

and beings thank you so much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *