Press "Enter" to skip to content

HIV: the virus that made me a better doctor | Mary Horgan | TEDxUCD


[Music]

[Music] I’m going to take you back to the

I’m going to take you back to the

I’m going to take you back to the beginning the summer of 1981 the world

beginning the summer of 1981 the world

beginning the summer of 1981 the world was absolutely unprepared for what was

was absolutely unprepared for what was

was absolutely unprepared for what was about to happen

about to happen

about to happen five young gay men in the West Coast of

five young gay men in the West Coast of

five young gay men in the West Coast of America were noted to have a very

America were noted to have a very

America were noted to have a very unusual infection by the time the report

unusual infection by the time the report

unusual infection by the time the report was published on the 5th of June 1981

was published on the 5th of June 1981

was published on the 5th of June 1981 two of those young men died over the

two of those young men died over the

two of those young men died over the next several months and up to the end of

next several months and up to the end of

next several months and up to the end of the year there are 270 more reported

the year there are 270 more reported

the year there are 270 more reported cases of very unusual infections and

cases of very unusual infections and

cases of very unusual infections and tumors predominantly in young gay men

tumors predominantly in young gay men

tumors predominantly in young gay men this termed the phrase of gay plague was

this termed the phrase of gay plague was

this termed the phrase of gay plague was coined in response to what appear to be

coined in response to what appear to be

coined in response to what appear to be a new outbreak of an infection but with

a new outbreak of an infection but with

a new outbreak of an infection but with that fear ensued these young men were

that fear ensued these young men were

that fear ensued these young men were dying and wasting of brain what looked

dying and wasting of brain what looked

dying and wasting of brain what looked like brain tumors they got strokes they

like brain tumors they got strokes they

like brain tumors they got strokes they went blind the fear was because we

went blind the fear was because we

went blind the fear was because we didn’t know how it was transmitted we

didn’t know how it was transmitted we

didn’t know how it was transmitted we didn’t know who was going to get it next

didn’t know who was going to get it next

didn’t know who was going to get it next and as such there was a lot of I suppose

and as such there was a lot of I suppose

and as such there was a lot of I suppose a discrimination that would eventually

a discrimination that would eventually

a discrimination that would eventually unfold in 1980 I started in the School

unfold in 1980 I started in the School

unfold in 1980 I started in the School of Medicine in UCD so by the end of that

of Medicine in UCD so by the end of that

of Medicine in UCD so by the end of that year all of this was unfolding and all

year all of this was unfolding and all

year all of this was unfolding and all of a sudden I was in the start of what

of a sudden I was in the start of what

of a sudden I was in the start of what was to be the HIV epidemic that unfolded

was to be the HIV epidemic that unfolded

was to be the HIV epidemic that unfolded over the next few decades and is still

over the next few decades and is still

over the next few decades and is still ongoing

ongoing

ongoing I also came from a sheltered

I also came from a sheltered

I also came from a sheltered middle-class background which is typical

middle-class background which is typical

middle-class background which is typical for those of us who went to UCD at the

for those of us who went to UCD at the

for those of us who went to UCD at the time I was from Carey thought I was

time I was from Carey thought I was

time I was from Carey thought I was sophisticated until I came to Dublin

sophisticated until I came to Dublin

sophisticated until I came to Dublin past Newlands cross and I was ecology so

past Newlands cross and I was ecology so

past Newlands cross and I was ecology so two years later in 1983 the cause of

two years later in 1983 the cause of

two years later in 1983 the cause of this new infection was found and it was

this new infection was found and it was

this new infection was found and it was a human immunodeficiency virus

a human immunodeficiency virus

a human immunodeficiency virus so essentially what HIV is it’s a

so essentially what HIV is it’s a

so essentially what HIV is it’s a chronic viral infection that attacks

chronic viral infection that attacks

chronic viral infection that attacks certain parts of the immune system

certain parts of the immune system

certain parts of the immune system and wot ensues is AIDS which is acquired

and wot ensues is AIDS which is acquired

and wot ensues is AIDS which is acquired immunodeficiency syndrome which is a

immunodeficiency syndrome which is a

immunodeficiency syndrome which is a long list of infections and tumors that

long list of infections and tumors that

long list of infections and tumors that are caused by the weakened immune system

are caused by the weakened immune system

are caused by the weakened immune system and this is exactly what was happening I

and this is exactly what was happening I

and this is exactly what was happening I still remember the lecture I got got

still remember the lecture I got got

still remember the lecture I got got from Professor Hillary who was our

from Professor Hillary who was our

from Professor Hillary who was our professor of medical microbiology here

professor of medical microbiology here

professor of medical microbiology here it covered an a4 sheet of paper in 1983

it covered an a4 sheet of paper in 1983

it covered an a4 sheet of paper in 1983 and all I can still remember is the four

and all I can still remember is the four

and all I can still remember is the four H’s what are the four H’s they were the

H’s what are the four H’s they were the

H’s what are the four H’s they were the groups who were prone to getting the

groups who were prone to getting the

groups who were prone to getting the infection there were hemophiliacs

infection there were hemophiliacs

infection there were hemophiliacs homosexuals Haitians and heroin users

homosexuals Haitians and heroin users

homosexuals Haitians and heroin users now this was a time in Ireland where

now this was a time in Ireland where

now this was a time in Ireland where homosexuality was illegal contraception

homosexuality was illegal contraception

homosexuality was illegal contraception was not widely available or barely

was not widely available or barely

was not widely available or barely available at all and sex certainly

available at all and sex certainly

available at all and sex certainly wasn’t spoken about so society not only

wasn’t spoken about so society not only

wasn’t spoken about so society not only in Ireland but worldwide took the higher

in Ireland but worldwide took the higher

in Ireland but worldwide took the higher mara ground and felt that well because

mara ground and felt that well because

mara ground and felt that well because of lifestyle choices these people got

of lifestyle choices these people got

of lifestyle choices these people got the infection and that’s exactly what

the infection and that’s exactly what

the infection and that’s exactly what they deserved so what what ensued was

they deserved so what what ensued was

they deserved so what what ensued was the Society pointed fingers and it

the Society pointed fingers and it

the Society pointed fingers and it showned people to the point that people

showned people to the point that people

showned people to the point that people were if who were infected were afraid to

were if who were infected were afraid to

were if who were infected were afraid to tell anybody else that they were

tell anybody else that they were

tell anybody else that they were infected because not only would they be

infected because not only would they be

infected because not only would they be targeted but their friends and families

targeted but their friends and families

targeted but their friends and families may also have been had recriminations

may also have been had recriminations

may also have been had recriminations from this infection at that point what

from this infection at that point what

from this infection at that point what happened was probably good in that

happened was probably good in that

happened was probably good in that celebrity started succumbing to the

celebrity started succumbing to the

celebrity started succumbing to the infection some of you are old enough in

infection some of you are old enough in

infection some of you are old enough in the audience to know some of them Rock

the audience to know some of them Rock

the audience to know some of them Rock Hudson Liberace

Hudson Liberace

Hudson Liberace Arthur Ashe who was a famous tennis

Arthur Ashe who was a famous tennis

Arthur Ashe who was a famous tennis player Rudolf Nureyev a ballerina and

player Rudolf Nureyev a ballerina and

player Rudolf Nureyev a ballerina and our own Vincent Hanley now Vincent for

our own Vincent Hanley now Vincent for

our own Vincent Hanley now Vincent for those of you who are young enough not to

those of you who are young enough not to

those of you who are young enough not to remember had it all he was a Carmel boy

remember had it all he was a Carmel boy

remember had it all he was a Carmel boy who was big and gosh bigger in the Big

who was big and gosh bigger in the Big

who was big and gosh bigger in the Big Apple where he was a presenter on MTV

Apple where he was a presenter on MTV

Apple where he was a presenter on MTV for those of us who remember every

for those of us who remember every

for those of us who remember every Sunday afternoon we would watch the

Sunday afternoon we would watch the

Sunday afternoon we would watch the video series on

video series on

video series on or T 1 or 2 and before our eyes

or T 1 or 2 and before our eyes

or T 1 or 2 and before our eyes Vincent wasted away and it ended up that

Vincent wasted away and it ended up that

Vincent wasted away and it ended up that he had AIDS and died at the age of 33

he had AIDS and died at the age of 33

he had AIDS and died at the age of 33 plus what celebrity starters brought the

plus what celebrity starters brought the

plus what celebrity starters brought the infection is our ability to speak about

infection is our ability to speak about

infection is our ability to speak about us and the ability of celebrities to

us and the ability of celebrities to

us and the ability of celebrities to actually fundraise for what was a

actually fundraise for what was a

actually fundraise for what was a disease that people didn’t want to talk

disease that people didn’t want to talk

disease that people didn’t want to talk about and that has been very successful

about and that has been very successful

about and that has been very successful and it was probably the example of the

and it was probably the example of the

and it was probably the example of the disease that celebrity status made Hugh

disease that celebrity status made Hugh

disease that celebrity status made Hugh a huge difference in Princess Diana went

a huge difference in Princess Diana went

a huge difference in Princess Diana went and shook hands and abrade embraced AIDS

and shook hands and abrade embraced AIDS

and shook hands and abrade embraced AIDS patients in the mid-1980s this hugely

patients in the mid-1980s this hugely

patients in the mid-1980s this hugely helped in not only the public’s ability

helped in not only the public’s ability

helped in not only the public’s ability to contact or touch people with HIV and

to contact or touch people with HIV and

to contact or touch people with HIV and AIDS but also for fellow health care

AIDS but also for fellow health care

AIDS but also for fellow health care professionals to do the same but also

professionals to do the same but also

professionals to do the same but also what happened was activism which really

what happened was activism which really

what happened was activism which really spawned from anger the gay community

spawned from anger the gay community

spawned from anger the gay community were particularly angry at how they and

were particularly angry at how they and

were particularly angry at how they and those amongst them who suffered from

those amongst them who suffered from

those amongst them who suffered from AIDS were treated so with activism and

AIDS were treated so with activism and

AIDS were treated so with activism and advocacy they were hugely instrumental

advocacy they were hugely instrumental

advocacy they were hugely instrumental instrumental in driving policy at

instrumental in driving policy at

instrumental in driving policy at government level to ensure that there

government level to ensure that there

government level to ensure that there was research funders for this new

was research funders for this new

was research funders for this new infection but also that there was

infection but also that there was

infection but also that there was treatment providers in as much as it was

treatment providers in as much as it was

treatment providers in as much as it was available in nineteen in the 1980s and

available in nineteen in the 1980s and

available in nineteen in the 1980s and that care was given for the patients it

that care was given for the patients it

that care was given for the patients it wasn’t until 1985 that a test was

wasn’t until 1985 that a test was

wasn’t until 1985 that a test was available but you’d wonder with all that

available but you’d wonder with all that

available but you’d wonder with all that happened why in the head why would you

happened why in the head why would you

happened why in the head why would you bother getting tested there was no

bother getting tested there was no

bother getting tested there was no treatment and if you were known to have

treatment and if you were known to have

treatment and if you were known to have it you’re absolutely shunned so in 1986

it you’re absolutely shunned so in 1986

it you’re absolutely shunned so in 1986 I graduated from UCD started my intern

I graduated from UCD started my intern

I graduated from UCD started my intern year and that was the first time I had

year and that was the first time I had

year and that was the first time I had real contact with HIV patients what

real contact with HIV patients what

real contact with HIV patients what happened at the time is that they were

happened at the time is that they were

happened at the time is that they were put in isolation their trays of food

put in isolation their trays of food

put in isolation their trays of food were slid under the door

were slid under the door

were slid under the door health care professionals doctors and

health care professionals doctors and

health care professionals doctors and nurses gound up in spacesuits

nurses gound up in spacesuits

nurses gound up in spacesuits – can’t go in to interact with the

– can’t go in to interact with the

– can’t go in to interact with the patient so imagine if you were a patient

patient so imagine if you were a patient

patient so imagine if you were a patient in that room

in that room

in that room no human touch from a healthcare

no human touch from a healthcare

no human touch from a healthcare professional

professional

professional no human touch from anybody because you

no human touch from anybody because you

no human touch from anybody because you were in isolation and everyone afraid to

were in isolation and everyone afraid to

were in isolation and everyone afraid to talk to you about it because in effect

talk to you about it because in effect

talk to you about it because in effect there was nothing we could do for you so

there was nothing we could do for you so

there was nothing we could do for you so I suppose that inspired me to leave my

I suppose that inspired me to leave my

I suppose that inspired me to leave my comfort zone and decide to pursue a

comfort zone and decide to pursue a

comfort zone and decide to pursue a career in effective diseases it didn’t

career in effective diseases it didn’t

career in effective diseases it didn’t exist in Ireland at the time of course

exist in Ireland at the time of course

exist in Ireland at the time of course there were infectious diseases but the

there were infectious diseases but the

there were infectious diseases but the specialty didn’t exist and I said look

specialty didn’t exist and I said look

specialty didn’t exist and I said look if I do what I want to do I leave my

if I do what I want to do I leave my

if I do what I want to do I leave my comfort zone I’ll go abroad and do what

comfort zone I’ll go abroad and do what

comfort zone I’ll go abroad and do what I want so that if when I wake up every

I want so that if when I wake up every

I want so that if when I wake up every morning I’ll do the specialty that I

morning I’ll do the specialty that I

morning I’ll do the specialty that I want and that’s exactly what I did left

want and that’s exactly what I did left

want and that’s exactly what I did left like many others in 1990 landed in st.

like many others in 1990 landed in st.

like many others in 1990 landed in st. Louis to the new world and to a new

Louis to the new world and to a new

Louis to the new world and to a new world of HIV and AIDS because the wards

world of HIV and AIDS because the wards

world of HIV and AIDS because the wards were full the clinics were full of HIV

were full the clinics were full of HIV

were full the clinics were full of HIV and AIDS patients it was still a dire

and AIDS patients it was still a dire

and AIDS patients it was still a dire infection by 1994 the commonest cause of

infection by 1994 the commonest cause of

infection by 1994 the commonest cause of death in the u.s. of people aged between

death in the u.s. of people aged between

death in the u.s. of people aged between 25 and 44 was hiv/aids so that’s saying

25 and 44 was hiv/aids so that’s saying

25 and 44 was hiv/aids so that’s saying something so I ran the clinic there

something so I ran the clinic there

something so I ran the clinic there after I did my training and unlike

after I did my training and unlike

after I did my training and unlike society that discriminated against those

society that discriminated against those

society that discriminated against those who were HIV infected AIDS the HIV

who were HIV infected AIDS the HIV

who were HIV infected AIDS the HIV didn’t it infected anybody so I was

didn’t it infected anybody so I was

didn’t it infected anybody so I was treating the 17 year old inner-city poor

treating the 17 year old inner-city poor

treating the 17 year old inner-city poor pregnant girl and her mother who was 34

pregnant girl and her mother who was 34

pregnant girl and her mother who was 34 who was also infected I was treating the

who was also infected I was treating the

who was also infected I was treating the affluent accountant I was treating the

affluent accountant I was treating the

affluent accountant I was treating the transgender beauty queen they’re all in

transgender beauty queen they’re all in

transgender beauty queen they’re all in the same clinic all united by one

the same clinic all united by one

the same clinic all united by one infection HIV why so there was very

infection HIV why so there was very

infection HIV why so there was very little hope at the time and then in 1994

little hope at the time and then in 1994

little hope at the time and then in 1994 I was pregnant with my daughter Aisling

I was pregnant with my daughter Aisling

I was pregnant with my daughter Aisling and I still remembered them Wednesday

and I still remembered them Wednesday

and I still remembered them Wednesday morning when the first glimmer of hope

morning when the first glimmer of hope

morning when the first glimmer of hope was presented and that was a trial

was presented and that was a trial

was presented and that was a trial Nicoll trial called ACTG zero 76 and

Nicoll trial called ACTG zero 76 and

Nicoll trial called ACTG zero 76 and this was when antiviral tablets were

this was when antiviral tablets were

this was when antiviral tablets were given to pregnant women in it in an

given to pregnant women in it in an

given to pregnant women in it in an attempt to prevent the infection going

attempt to prevent the infection going

attempt to prevent the infection going from the mother to the child and they

from the mother to the child and they

from the mother to the child and they had to try to stop the child the trial

had to try to stop the child the trial

had to try to stop the child the trial prematurely because there was a

prematurely because there was a

prematurely because there was a significant drop in the rates of

significant drop in the rates of

significant drop in the rates of infection to the newborn babies from 25%

infection to the newborn babies from 25%

infection to the newborn babies from 25% to 8% and it’s much much less at the

to 8% and it’s much much less at the

to 8% and it’s much much less at the time and that rolled out into antenatal

time and that rolled out into antenatal

time and that rolled out into antenatal testing which is now standard of care in

testing which is now standard of care in

testing which is now standard of care in HIV pregnant women and after that it

HIV pregnant women and after that it

HIV pregnant women and after that it became a standard of care to use

became a standard of care to use

became a standard of care to use multiple antiviral treatments to you to

multiple antiviral treatments to you to

multiple antiviral treatments to you to treat HIV patients because was found

treat HIV patients because was found

treat HIV patients because was found that if you tack the virus in different

that if you tack the virus in different

that if you tack the virus in different steps of its life cycle it was much more

steps of its life cycle it was much more

steps of its life cycle it was much more effective than just using one drug alone

effective than just using one drug alone

effective than just using one drug alone and so in about 1997 it became standard

and so in about 1997 it became standard

and so in about 1997 it became standard of care to use combination of what we

of care to use combination of what we

of care to use combination of what we call highly active antiretroviral

call highly active antiretroviral

call highly active antiretroviral therapy thankfully I got my job in

therapy thankfully I got my job in

therapy thankfully I got my job in Ireland at the same time because it was

Ireland at the same time because it was

Ireland at the same time because it was looked as if I had the cure and it

looked as if I had the cure and it

looked as if I had the cure and it brought it back in my suitcase from the

brought it back in my suitcase from the

brought it back in my suitcase from the states that wasn’t the case it was just

states that wasn’t the case it was just

states that wasn’t the case it was just serendipity

serendipity

serendipity so I started back in core I won’t say

so I started back in core I won’t say

so I started back in core I won’t say back in Cork it started in Cork walked

back in Cork it started in Cork walked

back in Cork it started in Cork walked in the door had not nothing not even an

in the door had not nothing not even an

in the door had not nothing not even an office but I did have 19 HIV patients

office but I did have 19 HIV patients

office but I did have 19 HIV patients awaiting me they were delighted I was

awaiting me they were delighted I was

awaiting me they were delighted I was delighted and I had the Friday afternoon

delighted and I had the Friday afternoon

delighted and I had the Friday afternoon clinic but brought in all my infectious

clinic but brought in all my infectious

clinic but brought in all my infectious diseases didn’t matter if your HIV or

diseases didn’t matter if your HIV or

diseases didn’t matter if your HIV or hepatitis or recovering from meningitis

hepatitis or recovering from meningitis

hepatitis or recovering from meningitis everyone got brought into the same

everyone got brought into the same

everyone got brought into the same clinic because to me it was just another

clinic because to me it was just another

clinic because to me it was just another infection but what I did have two other

infection but what I did have two other

infection but what I did have two other people didn’t see it the same way there

people didn’t see it the same way there

people didn’t see it the same way there was a yellow biohazard sticker stuck in

was a yellow biohazard sticker stuck in

was a yellow biohazard sticker stuck in the front of those with HIV it took me

the front of those with HIV it took me

the front of those with HIV it took me two years to get rid of that but I am

two years to get rid of that but I am

two years to get rid of that but I am extremely persistent person and it’s

extremely persistent person and it’s

extremely persistent person and it’s gone so several years later we have now

gone so several years later we have now

gone so several years later we have now about 600 HIV infected people we see

about 600 HIV infected people we see

about 600 HIV infected people we see them usually every six months because

them usually every six months because

them usually every six months because the treatments are so good

the treatments are so good

the treatments are so good they lifespan with people who are lucky

they lifespan with people who are lucky

they lifespan with people who are lucky enough as we are in Ireland to have

enough as we are in Ireland to have

enough as we are in Ireland to have access to treatment is normal so as

access to treatment is normal so as

access to treatment is normal so as chronic diseases go it’s worn with a

chronic diseases go it’s worn with a

chronic diseases go it’s worn with a fantastic outlook but the one thing that

fantastic outlook but the one thing that

fantastic outlook but the one thing that does happen and when I do give the news

does happen and when I do give the news

does happen and when I do give the news to people that they’re HIV positive

to people that they’re HIV positive

to people that they’re HIV positive they’re a bit devastated like anyone is

they’re a bit devastated like anyone is

they’re a bit devastated like anyone is with new disease but the problem still

with new disease but the problem still

with new disease but the problem still is the stigma surrounding us

is the stigma surrounding us

is the stigma surrounding us it’s our response as society’s saying oh

it’s our response as society’s saying oh

it’s our response as society’s saying oh they must have done something like drugs

they must have done something like drugs

they must have done something like drugs or they must have slept around and

or they must have slept around and

or they must have slept around and that’s the one thing that needs to go so

that’s the one thing that needs to go so

that’s the one thing that needs to go so I suppose looking at the title of my

I suppose looking at the title of my

I suppose looking at the title of my talk HIV and the virus that made me a

talk HIV and the virus that made me a

talk HIV and the virus that made me a better doctor it really wasn’t the virus

better doctor it really wasn’t the virus

better doctor it really wasn’t the virus that made me a better doctor it was the

that made me a better doctor it was the

that made me a better doctor it was the people who were infected with the virus

people who were infected with the virus

people who were infected with the virus who made me a better doctor and what did

who made me a better doctor and what did

who made me a better doctor and what did they teach me they taught me that being

they teach me they taught me that being

they teach me they taught me that being a doctor is not just about tests and

a doctor is not just about tests and

a doctor is not just about tests and tablets it’s about being compassionate

tablets it’s about being compassionate

tablets it’s about being compassionate about being non-judgmental about

about being non-judgmental about

about being non-judgmental about listening about the healing touch

listening about the healing touch

listening about the healing touch shaking their hands and understanding

shaking their hands and understanding

shaking their hands and understanding that frequently they do this journey

that frequently they do this journey

that frequently they do this journey alone because of fear of stigma they

alone because of fear of stigma they

alone because of fear of stigma they also taught me the importance of

also taught me the importance of

also taught me the importance of research scientific research thirty

research scientific research thirty

research scientific research thirty years ago there was no hope with this

years ago there was no hope with this

years ago there was no hope with this infection even 20 years ago no hope at

infection even 20 years ago no hope at

infection even 20 years ago no hope at all and with proper investment in

all and with proper investment in

all and with proper investment in science and interest as researchers but

science and interest as researchers but

science and interest as researchers but also the advocacy that people and

also the advocacy that people and

also the advocacy that people and support groups had pushing that agenda

support groups had pushing that agenda

support groups had pushing that agenda now leads to a chronic disease that is

now leads to a chronic disease that is

now leads to a chronic disease that is treated with one tablet a day so yes I

treated with one tablet a day so yes I

treated with one tablet a day so yes I have learnt a lot from my patients and I

have learnt a lot from my patients and I

have learnt a lot from my patients and I will continue to learn so that when the

will continue to learn so that when the

will continue to learn so that when the next new infectious disease comes along

next new infectious disease comes along

next new infectious disease comes along I hope to have this better outlook thank

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *