Press "Enter" to skip to content

Equity In and Out of the Classroom – The Missing Piece | Jeff Harding | TEDxMountainViewHighSchool


it might not be a surprise to anybody

it might not be a surprise to anybody here that students from higher

here that students from higher

here that students from higher socioeconomic environments score higher

socioeconomic environments score higher

socioeconomic environments score higher on SAT scores than students from low

on SAT scores than students from low

on SAT scores than students from low socio-economic environments take a look

socio-economic environments take a look

socio-economic environments take a look at the chart that’s up here you can see

at the chart that’s up here you can see

at the chart that’s up here you can see that students from higher socio-economic

that students from higher socio-economic

that students from higher socio-economic environment certainly score higher

environment certainly score higher

environment certainly score higher according to the College Board than low

according to the College Board than low

according to the College Board than low socio-economic students in fact the

socio-economic students in fact the

socio-economic students in fact the number one predictor of SAT scores is

number one predictor of SAT scores is

number one predictor of SAT scores is parent income now I’ve been involved in

parent income now I’ve been involved in

parent income now I’ve been involved in public education for more than 34 years

public education for more than 34 years

public education for more than 34 years and so I’m more than well aware of the

and so I’m more than well aware of the

and so I’m more than well aware of the impact of socio-economic diversity on

impact of socio-economic diversity on

impact of socio-economic diversity on things like SAT scores but it’s only

things like SAT scores but it’s only

things like SAT scores but it’s only been the last 18 months that this has

been the last 18 months that this has

been the last 18 months that this has become very obvious to me and the reason

become very obvious to me and the reason

become very obvious to me and the reason for that is I’ve moved from a rural

for that is I’ve moved from a rural

for that is I’ve moved from a rural district in California to right here in

district in California to right here in

district in California to right here in the center of the Silicon Valley to one

the center of the Silicon Valley to one

the center of the Silicon Valley to one of the best school districts in

of the best school districts in

of the best school districts in California this one and that experience

California this one and that experience

California this one and that experience has opened my eyes to the impact of

has opened my eyes to the impact of

has opened my eyes to the impact of socio-economic diversity and the

socio-economic diversity and the

socio-economic diversity and the ultimate influence on things like SAT

ultimate influence on things like SAT

ultimate influence on things like SAT scores I I want it so I I wanted to

scores I I want it so I I wanted to

scores I I want it so I I wanted to offer some thoughts as I’ve examined

offer some thoughts as I’ve examined

offer some thoughts as I’ve examined this phenomenon over the last year and a

this phenomenon over the last year and a

this phenomenon over the last year and a half that have come to my mind and I’ve

half that have come to my mind and I’ve

half that have come to my mind and I’ve noticed that there are three themes that

noticed that there are three themes that

noticed that there are three themes that suggest to me that there’s a

suggest to me that there’s a

suggest to me that there’s a socio-economic advantage that we should

socio-economic advantage that we should

socio-economic advantage that we should all be aware of the first theme I’d like

all be aware of the first theme I’d like

all be aware of the first theme I’d like to talk about is really obvious the next

to talk about is really obvious the next

to talk about is really obvious the next two are not so obvious

two are not so obvious

two are not so obvious the first one is students that have

the first one is students that have

the first one is students that have wealthier parents have parents that

wealthier parents have parents that

wealthier parents have parents that write checks to support their

write checks to support their

write checks to support their socioeconomics we’re all aware of this

socioeconomics we’re all aware of this

socioeconomics we’re all aware of this wealthier parents tend to spend more

wealthier parents tend to spend more

wealthier parents tend to spend more money on academic enrichment than

money on academic enrichment than

money on academic enrichment than parents that don’t have the means

parents that don’t have the means

parents that don’t have the means there’s a way that we can sort of tease

there’s a way that we can sort of tease

there’s a way that we can sort of tease this out I suggest to you

this out I suggest to you

this out I suggest to you by asking students what did they do over

by asking students what did they do over

by asking students what did they do over their summer vacation so students spend

their summer vacation so students spend

their summer vacation so students spend a minute and think about what did you do

a minute and think about what did you do

a minute and think about what did you do over your summer vacation did you go to

over your summer vacation did you go to

over your summer vacation did you go to Europe perhaps you went to the Galapagos

Europe perhaps you went to the Galapagos

Europe perhaps you went to the Galapagos did you have a sports coach that helped

did you have a sports coach that helped

did you have a sports coach that helped you with your training did you have a

you with your training did you have a

you with your training did you have a music coach to help you with your music

music coach to help you with your music

music coach to help you with your music did you visit a college or colleges or

did you visit a college or colleges or

did you visit a college or colleges or museums did you travel to other places

museums did you travel to other places

museums did you travel to other places did you go to sports camp or coding camp

did you go to sports camp or coding camp

did you go to sports camp or coding camp or science camp or students did you have

or science camp or students did you have

or science camp or students did you have to work extra hours while you were

to work extra hours while you were

to work extra hours while you were helping support the family because your

helping support the family because your

helping support the family because your parents don’t have enough money to put

parents don’t have enough money to put

parents don’t have enough money to put food on the table or perhaps you spent

food on the table or perhaps you spent

food on the table or perhaps you spent the summer babysitting for your siblings

the summer babysitting for your siblings

the summer babysitting for your siblings because there’s no one else to babysit

because there’s no one else to babysit

because there’s no one else to babysit while your parents are at work I suggest

while your parents are at work I suggest

while your parents are at work I suggest to you that the difference between the

to you that the difference between the

to you that the difference between the socio-economic groups and how they spend

socio-economic groups and how they spend

socio-economic groups and how they spend their summers indicates how

their summers indicates how

their summers indicates how well-prepared those students will be

well-prepared those students will be

well-prepared those students will be when they enter school and has a major

when they enter school and has a major

when they enter school and has a major impact on their success in school so

impact on their success in school so

impact on their success in school so parents writing checks not a surprise in

parents writing checks not a surprise in

parents writing checks not a surprise in fact the research shows that enrichment

fact the research shows that enrichment

fact the research shows that enrichment expenditures on children are seven times

expenditures on children are seven times

expenditures on children are seven times higher for high socioeconomic parents

higher for high socioeconomic parents

higher for high socioeconomic parents than they are for low socio-economic

than they are for low socio-economic

than they are for low socio-economic parents the low socioeconomic parents

parents the low socioeconomic parents

parents the low socioeconomic parents they don’t have the means and notice the

they don’t have the means and notice the

they don’t have the means and notice the trend lines this gap appears to be

trend lines this gap appears to be

trend lines this gap appears to be getting bigger and I suggest that that’s

getting bigger and I suggest that that’s

getting bigger and I suggest that that’s a major influence on student success

a major influence on student success

a major influence on student success during the school day and in school

during the school day and in school

during the school day and in school experiences but there are two other

experiences but there are two other

experiences but there are two other socio-economic advantages that I want to

socio-economic advantages that I want to

socio-economic advantages that I want to share with you today themes that I’ve

share with you today themes that I’ve

share with you today themes that I’ve discovered over the last year and a half

discovered over the last year and a half

discovered over the last year and a half here’s number two parents and personal

here’s number two parents and personal

here’s number two parents and personal connections

connections

connections parents have an opportunity to help

parents have an opportunity to help

parents have an opportunity to help their students based on the people that

their students based on the people that

their students based on the people that they know it’s a little nebulous but let

they know it’s a little nebulous but let

they know it’s a little nebulous but let me give you an example by talking about

me give you an example by talking about

me give you an example by talking about an experience in my life it was about

an experience in my life it was about

an experience in my life it was about two years ago and my son Dan who’s now

two years ago and my son Dan who’s now

two years ago and my son Dan who’s now in his 20s had returned from a trip in

in his 20s had returned from a trip in

in his 20s had returned from a trip in South America he was staying with us

South America he was staying with us

South America he was staying with us between his travels and I invited some

between his travels and I invited some

between his travels and I invited some friends over to to have dinner with us

friends over to to have dinner with us

friends over to to have dinner with us as we were planning the dinner Dan said

as we were planning the dinner Dan said

as we were planning the dinner Dan said to us he said dad how would you guys

to us he said dad how would you guys

to us he said dad how would you guys like me to make a dish that I learned in

like me to make a dish that I learned in

like me to make a dish that I learned in Chile it’s called ceviche and I would be

Chile it’s called ceviche and I would be

Chile it’s called ceviche and I would be happy to make it for you that’s great so

happy to make it for you that’s great so

happy to make it for you that’s great so Dan went out he bought a fish came back

Dan went out he bought a fish came back

Dan went out he bought a fish came back he cut up the fish he put the citrus on

he cut up the fish he put the citrus on

he cut up the fish he put the citrus on the top he made this beautiful dish and

the top he made this beautiful dish and

the top he made this beautiful dish and he explained how he was making it was

he explained how he was making it was

he explained how he was making it was really quite a showman my son is and at

really quite a showman my son is and at

really quite a showman my son is and at the end of the meal the friends that

the end of the meal the friends that

the end of the meal the friends that were there said to Dan Dan you are so

were there said to Dan Dan you are so

were there said to Dan Dan you are so into traveling and you were so good at

into traveling and you were so good at

into traveling and you were so good at food and wine hospitality what if you

food and wine hospitality what if you

food and wine hospitality what if you sort of parlayed those two experiences

sort of parlayed those two experiences

sort of parlayed those two experiences together and made it a career option he

together and made it a career option he

together and made it a career option he thought that was great and he and their

thought that was great and he and their

thought that was great and he and their friend said not only that but we have

friend said not only that but we have

friend said not only that but we have good friends who own a cruise line and

good friends who own a cruise line and

good friends who own a cruise line and they are always looking for people with

they are always looking for people with

they are always looking for people with your skill set that was two years ago

your skill set that was two years ago

your skill set that was two years ago there’s a picture of Dan last week he’s

there’s a picture of Dan last week he’s

there’s a picture of Dan last week he’s in Panama and he’s in charge of food and

in Panama and he’s in charge of food and

in Panama and he’s in charge of food and wine for a cruise ship in Panama now not

wine for a cruise ship in Panama now not

wine for a cruise ship in Panama now not to take anything away from my son Dan he

to take anything away from my son Dan he

to take anything away from my son Dan he got the job he did a good job he got

got the job he did a good job he got

got the job he did a good job he got promoted everything’s terrific however

promoted everything’s terrific however

promoted everything’s terrific however my son would have not gotten that job

my son would have not gotten that job

my son would have not gotten that job had it not been for friends of mine who

had it not been for friends of mine who

had it not been for friends of mine who happened to be good friends with people

happened to be good friends with people

happened to be good friends with people who owned a cruise line that’s a

who owned a cruise line that’s a

who owned a cruise line that’s a socio-economic advantage I suggest to

socio-economic advantage I suggest to

socio-economic advantage I suggest to you that that happens every day when

you that that happens every day when

you that that happens every day when parents know people that help their

parents know people that help their

parents know people that help their children get internships that help their

children get internships that help their

children get internships that help their children get first jobs in fact I have

children get first jobs in fact I have

children get first jobs in fact I have four sons and three of them are involved

four sons and three of them are involved

four sons and three of them are involved professionally as a result of people

professionally as a result of people

professionally as a result of people that I knew and that happens in this

that I knew and that happens in this

that I knew and that happens in this community all the time

community all the time

community all the time it’s a socio-economic advantage it’s not

it’s a socio-economic advantage it’s not

it’s a socio-economic advantage it’s not a bad thing it’s a good thing I said

a bad thing it’s a good thing I said

a bad thing it’s a good thing I said their their words there were three and

their their words there were three and

their their words there were three and this is the third one exposure to the

this is the third one exposure to the

this is the third one exposure to the professional world as we go through

professional world as we go through

professional world as we go through school the purpose is to prepare our

school the purpose is to prepare our

school the purpose is to prepare our children to enter a professional world

children to enter a professional world

children to enter a professional world how do they learn about it

how do they learn about it

how do they learn about it well that’s what this one is about I

well that’s what this one is about I

well that’s what this one is about I suggest that you learn about what it’s

suggest that you learn about what it’s

suggest that you learn about what it’s like to be a professional students do

like to be a professional students do

like to be a professional students do around the dinner table they watch their

around the dinner table they watch their

around the dinner table they watch their parents students do they watch their

parents students do they watch their

parents students do they watch their parents debrief their work day they meet

parents debrief their work day they meet

parents debrief their work day they meet their friends they see what it’s like to

their friends they see what it’s like to

their friends they see what it’s like to work in a professional environment so

work in a professional environment so

work in a professional environment so that they are prepared and confident to

that they are prepared and confident to

that they are prepared and confident to enter that environment when they get

enter that environment when they get

enter that environment when they get older this number three came to light

older this number three came to light

older this number three came to light for me a year ago when I accompanied a

for me a year ago when I accompanied a

for me a year ago when I accompanied a group of students on a field trip this

group of students on a field trip this

group of students on a field trip this was a field trip to Adobe the high tech

was a field trip to Adobe the high tech

was a field trip to Adobe the high tech company in San Jose and I went on the

company in San Jose and I went on the

company in San Jose and I went on the field trip a group of students from avid

field trip a group of students from avid

field trip a group of students from avid class they tend to be students from

class they tend to be students from

class they tend to be students from lower socio economics first-generation

lower socio economics first-generation

lower socio economics first-generation college going students they were we were

college going students they were we were

college going students they were we were taking them to two Adobe the folks at

taking them to two Adobe the folks at

taking them to two Adobe the folks at Adobe had identified five employees

Adobe had identified five employees

Adobe had identified five employees they’d had also come from avid type

they’d had also come from avid type

they’d had also come from avid type environments low socio-economic some of

environments low socio-economic some of

environments low socio-economic some of them had lived in the inner city and

them had lived in the inner city and

them had lived in the inner city and these five employees had somehow managed

these five employees had somehow managed

these five employees had somehow managed to earn themselves great jobs at Adobe

to earn themselves great jobs at Adobe

to earn themselves great jobs at Adobe they had overcome obstacles and they

they had overcome obstacles and they

they had overcome obstacles and they were very proud of their upward

were very proud of their upward

were very proud of their upward trajectory so we brought our students

trajectory so we brought our students

trajectory so we brought our students there they men in small groups they

there they men in small groups they

there they men in small groups they processed told the story of how those

processed told the story of how those

processed told the story of how those employees got there it was a great day

employees got there it was a great day

employees got there it was a great day afterwards i debriefed with the students

afterwards i debriefed with the students

afterwards i debriefed with the students the avid students and one student said

the avid students and one student said

the avid students and one student said something to me that

something to me that

something to me that I thought was highly significant she

I thought was highly significant she

I thought was highly significant she said dr. Harding I listened to all five

said dr. Harding I listened to all five

said dr. Harding I listened to all five of those employees and they all loved

of those employees and they all loved

of those employees and they all loved their jobs she said I’ve never met an

their jobs she said I’ve never met an

their jobs she said I’ve never met an adult that’s loved their job before and

adult that’s loved their job before and

adult that’s loved their job before and I thought what a significant statement

I thought what a significant statement

I thought what a significant statement to get to be a high school student and

to get to be a high school student and

to get to be a high school student and not know that a professional work

not know that a professional work

not know that a professional work environment is inherently satisfying how

environment is inherently satisfying how

environment is inherently satisfying how would they have known my kids know that

would they have known my kids know that

would they have known my kids know that because I’d come home every day and I

because I’d come home every day and I

because I’d come home every day and I tell them around the dinner table and

tell them around the dinner table and

tell them around the dinner table and they’d see our friends and that was the

they’d see our friends and that was the

they’d see our friends and that was the experience so I suggest that that

experience so I suggest that that

experience so I suggest that that socio-economic advantage is highly

socio-economic advantage is highly

socio-economic advantage is highly significant in the motivation of

significant in the motivation of

significant in the motivation of students from low socio-economic

students from low socio-economic

students from low socio-economic environments compared to high as they go

environments compared to high as they go

environments compared to high as they go through school so these are just three

through school so these are just three

through school so these are just three suggestions there might be others I

suggestions there might be others I

suggestions there might be others I don’t have a scientific study on this

don’t have a scientific study on this

don’t have a scientific study on this this is the world according to me but I

this is the world according to me but I

this is the world according to me but I think that those socio-economic

think that those socio-economic

think that those socio-economic advantages help students be bold helps

advantages help students be bold helps

advantages help students be bold helps them be confident helps them take

them be confident helps them take

them be confident helps them take initiative and helps them be prepared

initiative and helps them be prepared

initiative and helps them be prepared for a professional world that if they

for a professional world that if they

for a professional world that if they don’t have that they don’t have those

don’t have that they don’t have those

don’t have that they don’t have those qualities I think it’s important now

qualities I think it’s important now

qualities I think it’s important now some people would say that’s just the

some people would say that’s just the

some people would say that’s just the luck of the draw some people are born

luck of the draw some people are born

luck of the draw some people are born rich some people are born poor it’s just

rich some people are born poor it’s just

rich some people are born poor it’s just the way it is I disagree I would argue

the way it is I disagree I would argue

the way it is I disagree I would argue that we have a societal moral imperative

that we have a societal moral imperative

that we have a societal moral imperative a moral commitment to those students

a moral commitment to those students

a moral commitment to those students regardless of the means of their parents

regardless of the means of their parents

regardless of the means of their parents to provide the basic experiences so

to provide the basic experiences so

to provide the basic experiences so every student can be successful in a

every student can be successful in a

every student can be successful in a professional world when they leave

professional world when they leave

professional world when they leave school that’s what I believe so what do

school that’s what I believe so what do

school that’s what I believe so what do we do

we do

we do how do we address these issues well I

how do we address these issues well I

how do we address these issues well I think there’s a wide variety of things

think there’s a wide variety of things

think there’s a wide variety of things that we can do but we have to start with

that we can do but we have to start with

that we can do but we have to start with one premise there is a socio-economic

one premise there is a socio-economic

one premise there is a socio-economic advantage and we need to know what it is

advantage and we need to know what it is

advantage and we need to know what it is what do wealthy your parents give to

what do wealthy your parents give to

what do wealthy your parents give to their students outside the school day

their students outside the school day

their students outside the school day that helps those students with their

that helps those students with their

that helps those students with their confidence and with their skillset

confidence and with their skillset

confidence and with their skillset schools do a great job from 8 o’clock to

schools do a great job from 8 o’clock to

schools do a great job from 8 o’clock to 3 o’clock 180 days a year

3 o’clock 180 days a year

3 o’clock 180 days a year but most of that economic advantage

but most of that economic advantage

but most of that economic advantage comes outside the 8 o’clock to 3 o’clock

comes outside the 8 o’clock to 3 o’clock

comes outside the 8 o’clock to 3 o’clock school school day so what can what can

school school day so what can what can

school school day so what can what can we do now one thing we can do is we can

we do now one thing we can do is we can

we do now one thing we can do is we can open our doors at schools beyond the

open our doors at schools beyond the

open our doors at schools beyond the school day so all our students can have

school day so all our students can have

school day so all our students can have a quiet and engaging place to work after

a quiet and engaging place to work after

a quiet and engaging place to work after hours another thing that we can do is we

hours another thing that we can do is we

hours another thing that we can do is we can offer avid classes like avid Lite

can offer avid classes like avid Lite

can offer avid classes like avid Lite classes where students are exposed to

classes where students are exposed to

classes where students are exposed to universities they are taken out and meet

universities they are taken out and meet

universities they are taken out and meet professionals so we can address these

professionals so we can address these

professionals so we can address these socio-economic advantage issues we can

socio-economic advantage issues we can

socio-economic advantage issues we can offer summer programs that are highly

offer summer programs that are highly

offer summer programs that are highly enriching like the wealthy students get

enriching like the wealthy students get

enriching like the wealthy students get but we can offer it for all students not

but we can offer it for all students not

but we can offer it for all students not just remediation but more than that over

just remediation but more than that over

just remediation but more than that over the summer we can offer tutoring

the summer we can offer tutoring

the summer we can offer tutoring programs and mentoring programs and

programs and mentoring programs and

programs and mentoring programs and scholarship programs that bring

scholarship programs that bring

scholarship programs that bring professionals into the school

professionals into the school

professionals into the school environment that help build

environment that help build

environment that help build relationships between our low

relationships between our low

relationships between our low socioeconomic students and professionals

socioeconomic students and professionals

socioeconomic students and professionals out there in the community that are

out there in the community that are

out there in the community that are specifically designed for those students

our country is based on a premise that

our country is based on a premise that upward mobility should be available to

upward mobility should be available to

upward mobility should be available to everyone that anyone who works hard to

everyone that anyone who works hard to

everyone that anyone who works hard to be able to get wherever they want to go

be able to get wherever they want to go

be able to get wherever they want to go and I suggest to you that that notion is

and I suggest to you that that notion is

and I suggest to you that that notion is in jeopardy and that educational equity

in jeopardy and that educational equity

in jeopardy and that educational equity is the key thank you

is the key thank you

is the key thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *