Press "Enter" to skip to content

Empty: Reflecting Child Loss Through Images | Susana Butterworth | TEDxRichland


have you ever been to a funeral have you

have you ever been to a funeral have you ever been to a child’s funeral march 8th

ever been to a child’s funeral march 8th

ever been to a child’s funeral march 8th of this year I had the unfortunate

of this year I had the unfortunate

of this year I had the unfortunate opportunity of experiencing one of the

opportunity of experiencing one of the

opportunity of experiencing one of the most heartbreaking physically demanding

most heartbreaking physically demanding

most heartbreaking physically demanding and inspiring trials a woman could ever

and inspiring trials a woman could ever

and inspiring trials a woman could ever go through I gave birth to my firstborn

go through I gave birth to my firstborn

go through I gave birth to my firstborn baby boy named Walter Thomas Butterworth

baby boy named Walter Thomas Butterworth

baby boy named Walter Thomas Butterworth he was perfect in every way he had lots

he was perfect in every way he had lots

he was perfect in every way he had lots of hair and this cute button nose and

of hair and this cute button nose and

of hair and this cute button nose and the smallest hands and feet that make

the smallest hands and feet that make

the smallest hands and feet that make you want to kiss them over and over

you want to kiss them over and over

you want to kiss them over and over again

again

again unlike other birth stories however

unlike other birth stories however

unlike other birth stories however Walter had trisomy 18 or Edwards

Walter had trisomy 18 or Edwards

Walter had trisomy 18 or Edwards syndrome a chromosomal disorder that

syndrome a chromosomal disorder that

syndrome a chromosomal disorder that causes many ailments because of an extra

causes many ailments because of an extra

causes many ailments because of an extra copy of chromosome 18 because of his

copy of chromosome 18 because of his

copy of chromosome 18 because of his condition he had a congenital

condition he had a congenital

condition he had a congenital diaphragmatic hernia that pushed his

diaphragmatic hernia that pushed his

diaphragmatic hernia that pushed his tiny heart so far to the right that has

tiny heart so far to the right that has

tiny heart so far to the right that has stopped beating in utero a week 17 my

stopped beating in utero a week 17 my

stopped beating in utero a week 17 my husband and I knew from doctor’s visits

husband and I knew from doctor’s visits

husband and I knew from doctor’s visits and ultrasounds that Walter’s life was

and ultrasounds that Walter’s life was

and ultrasounds that Walter’s life was going to be short all we wanted to do

going to be short all we wanted to do

going to be short all we wanted to do was share a small fragment of life with

was share a small fragment of life with

was share a small fragment of life with him an hour 15 minutes just one minute

and unfortunately we did not at 36 weeks

and unfortunately we did not at 36 weeks another doctor’s visit and another

another doctor’s visit and another

another doctor’s visit and another ultrasound in the worst sentence there’s

ultrasound in the worst sentence there’s

ultrasound in the worst sentence there’s no heartbeat

15 hours of labor later his silence when

15 hours of labor later his silence when he was born was piercing my husband sank

he was born was piercing my husband sank

he was born was piercing my husband sank to his knees next to my hospital room

to his knees next to my hospital room

to his knees next to my hospital room bed as we cried together as I held my

bed as we cried together as I held my

bed as we cried together as I held my lifeless little Walter through my

lifeless little Walter through my

lifeless little Walter through my longing and depression I asked myself

longing and depression I asked myself

longing and depression I asked myself why is it the other women and men are

why is it the other women and men are

why is it the other women and men are not talking about similar losses are

not talking about similar losses are

not talking about similar losses are they scared why am I scared

they scared why am I scared

they scared why am I scared and how can I turn this emptiness into

and how can I turn this emptiness into

and how can I turn this emptiness into something meaningful days after the

something meaningful days after the

something meaningful days after the memorial service were blur my husband

memorial service were blur my husband

memorial service were blur my husband and I were fortunate enough to have a

and I were fortunate enough to have a

and I were fortunate enough to have a service prearranged for Walter and a

service prearranged for Walter and a

service prearranged for Walter and a grave plot set aside so that he could

grave plot set aside so that he could

grave plot set aside so that he could sweetly rest next to his great-grandma

sweetly rest next to his great-grandma

sweetly rest next to his great-grandma sue I felt so empty inside physically

sue I felt so empty inside physically

sue I felt so empty inside physically and emotionally my capacity for

and emotionally my capacity for

and emotionally my capacity for happiness joy hope or even rest was shot

happiness joy hope or even rest was shot

happiness joy hope or even rest was shot it’s been most my day lying in bed with

it’s been most my day lying in bed with

it’s been most my day lying in bed with my eyes closed trying not to think about

my eyes closed trying not to think about

my eyes closed trying not to think about the loss ahead just occurred and when I

the loss ahead just occurred and when I

the loss ahead just occurred and when I was up and away call a yearn for was

was up and away call a yearn for was

was up and away call a yearn for was this warm little boy that cuddle him

this warm little boy that cuddle him

this warm little boy that cuddle him hold to fill the void that I felt inside

hold to fill the void that I felt inside

hold to fill the void that I felt inside I would spend lots of time in the tub in

I would spend lots of time in the tub in

I would spend lots of time in the tub in a warm soak or in a long shower trying

a warm soak or in a long shower trying

a warm soak or in a long shower trying to relieve some of the anxiety that I

to relieve some of the anxiety that I

to relieve some of the anxiety that I was feeling in my long showers I was

was feeling in my long showers I was

was feeling in my long showers I was able to formulate empty a series of

able to formulate empty a series of

able to formulate empty a series of portraits of people who have experienced

portraits of people who have experienced

portraits of people who have experienced child loss empty has enabled me to be

child loss empty has enabled me to be

child loss empty has enabled me to be more empathic and to be more authentic

more empathic and to be more authentic

more empathic and to be more authentic with myself it has created a platform

with myself it has created a platform

with myself it has created a platform for women and men to share their stories

for women and men to share their stories

for women and men to share their stories and experiences and has opened up a new

and experiences and has opened up a new

and experiences and has opened up a new perspective on what child loss looks

perspective on what child loss looks

perspective on what child loss looks like because there’s a stigma related to

like because there’s a stigma related to

like because there’s a stigma related to child loss our culture has turned a

child loss our culture has turned a

child loss our culture has turned a blind eye to this live trial many of our

blind eye to this live trial many of our

blind eye to this live trial many of our loved ones face my hope is that we can

loved ones face my hope is that we can

loved ones face my hope is that we can learn more about this so that we can

learn more about this so that we can

learn more about this so that we can learn to heal and learn how to help

learn to heal and learn how to help

learn to heal and learn how to help others heal by learning more about it I

knew from the start that I wanted to get

knew from the start that I wanted to get submissions of stories of people who had

submissions of stories of people who had

submissions of stories of people who had experienced child loss but I couldn’t

experienced child loss but I couldn’t

experienced child loss but I couldn’t just sit with a story as a photographer

just sit with a story as a photographer

just sit with a story as a photographer I naturally wanted to take images of

I naturally wanted to take images of

I naturally wanted to take images of what this pain looks and feels like yeah

what this pain looks and feels like yeah

what this pain looks and feels like yeah I couldn’t

I couldn’t

I couldn’t stop there before this experience before

stop there before this experience before

stop there before this experience before Walter I too was guilty of not talking

Walter I too was guilty of not talking

Walter I too was guilty of not talking about child loss when the topic surfaced

about child loss when the topic surfaced

about child loss when the topic surfaced I felt like I wasn’t qualified to talk

I felt like I wasn’t qualified to talk

I felt like I wasn’t qualified to talk about it because I had never experienced

about it because I had never experienced

about it because I had never experienced it and if I had never experienced it how

it and if I had never experienced it how

it and if I had never experienced it how could I face it this is the face of

could I face it this is the face of

could I face it this is the face of grief this is the face of anger this is

grief this is the face of anger this is

grief this is the face of anger this is the face of wonder and questioning faith

the face of wonder and questioning faith

the face of wonder and questioning faith this is a face of longing this is the

this is a face of longing this is the

this is a face of longing this is the face of someone missing a piece of

face of someone missing a piece of

face of someone missing a piece of themselves let’s take a moment here to

themselves let’s take a moment here to

themselves let’s take a moment here to stare at the face of child loss this is

stare at the face of child loss this is

stare at the face of child loss this is one that has become all too familiar to

one that has become all too familiar to

one that has become all too familiar to me

me

me not because I stare at it in the mirror

not because I stare at it in the mirror

not because I stare at it in the mirror every day but because I have sat down

every day but because I have sat down

every day but because I have sat down with all these women and men and have

with all these women and men and have

with all these women and men and have talked with them shared their sadness

talked with them shared their sadness

talked with them shared their sadness shared their longing and shared their

shared their longing and shared their

shared their longing and shared their grief now replace the face of child loss

grief now replace the face of child loss

grief now replace the face of child loss with someone you love this could be your

with someone you love this could be your

with someone you love this could be your wife your girlfriend your best friend

wife your girlfriend your best friend

wife your girlfriend your best friend your sister your co-worker someone from

your sister your co-worker someone from

your sister your co-worker someone from your church congregation anyone that you

your church congregation anyone that you

your church congregation anyone that you may love even yourself do you feel that

that pit in your stomach that feeling

that pit in your stomach that feeling right there is one that I want you to

right there is one that I want you to

right there is one that I want you to remember children are not supposed to

remember children are not supposed to

remember children are not supposed to die before parents do it’s a fact and we

die before parents do it’s a fact and we

die before parents do it’s a fact and we all know this but is that the only

all know this but is that the only

all know this but is that the only reason why we don’t talk about child

reason why we don’t talk about child

reason why we don’t talk about child loss or do we not talk about it because

loss or do we not talk about it because

loss or do we not talk about it because the mother was 15 weeks along and she

the mother was 15 weeks along and she

the mother was 15 weeks along and she has so much more time to conceive

has so much more time to conceive

has so much more time to conceive another or is it because of 15 weeks

another or is it because of 15 weeks

another or is it because of 15 weeks that child is still considered a fetus

that child is still considered a fetus

that child is still considered a fetus or scientifically a bunch of cells think

or scientifically a bunch of cells think

or scientifically a bunch of cells think about that

about that

about that we are discrediting someone’s pain

we are discrediting someone’s pain

we are discrediting someone’s pain because of discomfort opinion or some

because of discomfort opinion or some

because of discomfort opinion or some other cultural personal belief we are

other cultural personal belief we are

other cultural personal belief we are thinking of ourselves a mean high

thinking of ourselves a mean high

thinking of ourselves a mean high participative MD wrote this this time I

participative MD wrote this this time I

participative MD wrote this this time I was 15 weeks along and I heard the same

was 15 weeks along and I heard the same

was 15 weeks along and I heard the same chilling sentence I’m sorry

chilling sentence I’m sorry

chilling sentence I’m sorry there’s no heartbeat my arms ache every

there’s no heartbeat my arms ache every

there’s no heartbeat my arms ache every day for the two baby boys that I lost

each participant of empty is told to do

each participant of empty is told to do the same thing they are told to choose

the same thing they are told to choose

the same thing they are told to choose the location this could be their home or

the location this could be their home or

the location this could be their home or a field a hospital room it could be

a field a hospital room it could be

a field a hospital room it could be their workplace anywhere that’s

their workplace anywhere that’s

their workplace anywhere that’s significant to their story and once

significant to their story and once

significant to their story and once we’re there once we’re taking the image

we’re there once we’re taking the image

we’re there once we’re taking the image and we’re in that location

and we’re in that location

and we’re in that location I have them pause and have them reflect

I have them pause and have them reflect

I have them pause and have them reflect on the feelings of the loss and the

on the feelings of the loss and the

on the feelings of the loss and the experience and I tell them to feel after

experience and I tell them to feel after

experience and I tell them to feel after a few moments of calm pause I hand over

a few moments of calm pause I hand over

a few moments of calm pause I hand over this mirror and it’s a simple mirror

this mirror and it’s a simple mirror

this mirror and it’s a simple mirror nothing more than you can pick up at

nothing more than you can pick up at

nothing more than you can pick up at your local home goods but this mirror

your local home goods but this mirror

your local home goods but this mirror has weight and so when I hand over this

has weight and so when I hand over this

has weight and so when I hand over this mirror I have them feel the weight I

mirror I have them feel the weight I

mirror I have them feel the weight I pause a little more Hudson still reflect

and after a few moments I then asked

and after a few moments I then asked them to hold the mirror as if they’re

them to hold the mirror as if they’re

them to hold the mirror as if they’re holding their child once again and

holding their child once again and

holding their child once again and that’s when I take the photo

the mirror is a symbolic reflection of

the mirror is a symbolic reflection of myself in my grief when talking to my

myself in my grief when talking to my

myself in my grief when talking to my participants I noticed that there was a

participants I noticed that there was a

participants I noticed that there was a commonality and all of our stories we

commonality and all of our stories we

commonality and all of our stories we all spoke of this similar sadness in the

all spoke of this similar sadness in the

all spoke of this similar sadness in the similar pain in the similar grief but I

similar pain in the similar grief but I

similar pain in the similar grief but I also noticed that we all spoke of a

also noticed that we all spoke of a

also noticed that we all spoke of a piece of ourselves missing so as you can

piece of ourselves missing so as you can

piece of ourselves missing so as you can see in all the photos I actually edited

see in all the photos I actually edited

see in all the photos I actually edited out a portion of the mirror and this was

out a portion of the mirror and this was

out a portion of the mirror and this was to reflect the fact that with grief with

to reflect the fact that with grief with

to reflect the fact that with grief with the loss of a child we truly are missing

the loss of a child we truly are missing

the loss of a child we truly are missing a piece of ourselves and so something

a piece of ourselves and so something

a piece of ourselves and so something that was metaphorically felt is now

that was metaphorically felt is now

that was metaphorically felt is now physically seen when people actively

physically seen when people actively

physically seen when people actively view these images I want them to feel

view these images I want them to feel

view these images I want them to feel what the participant is feeling I invite

what the participant is feeling I invite

what the participant is feeling I invite them to do so I want them to understand

them to do so I want them to understand

them to do so I want them to understand that this person that’s in this image is

that this person that’s in this image is

that this person that’s in this image is not just someone that lives in a close

not just someone that lives in a close

not just someone that lives in a close proximity to their home because they’re

proximity to their home because they’re

proximity to their home because they’re in the community that this person in the

in the community that this person in the

in the community that this person in the image could be someone that they love it

image could be someone that they love it

image could be someone that they love it could be someone that’s in their home

so Austin does it feel like time is just

so Austin does it feel like time is just going and going and going

so deeply feels that way and when I’ve

so deeply feels that way and when I’ve talked to my participants they all

talked to my participants they all

talked to my participants they all agreed that we just want people to

agreed that we just want people to

agreed that we just want people to realize and acknowledge the fact that we

realize and acknowledge the fact that we

realize and acknowledge the fact that we are stuck that life has stopped and time

are stuck that life has stopped and time

are stuck that life has stopped and time has Stood Still losing her baby boy at

has Stood Still losing her baby boy at

has Stood Still losing her baby boy at 38 and a half weeks

38 and a half weeks

38 and a half weeks Brenda wrote as children of friends past

Brenda wrote as children of friends past

Brenda wrote as children of friends past milestones that Joseph will never get to

milestones that Joseph will never get to

milestones that Joseph will never get to experience grief still sneaks up

experience grief still sneaks up

experience grief still sneaks up catching me unaware and it washes over

catching me unaware and it washes over

catching me unaware and it washes over me empty has been a harsh reality a

me empty has been a harsh reality a

me empty has been a harsh reality a gateway to a harsh reality it has

gateway to a harsh reality it has

gateway to a harsh reality it has provided a platform for women and men to

provided a platform for women and men to

provided a platform for women and men to share their stories and their

share their stories and their

share their stories and their experiences and the stories that they

experiences and the stories that they

experiences and the stories that they share are raw some tell of the story of

share are raw some tell of the story of

share are raw some tell of the story of losing their child and realizing that

losing their child and realizing that

losing their child and realizing that that child is no longer with them in his

that child is no longer with them in his

that child is no longer with them in his past others scream of wanting answers

past others scream of wanting answers

past others scream of wanting answers from an absent God while others speak to

from an absent God while others speak to

from an absent God while others speak to losing an abortion adoption excuse me

losing an abortion adoption excuse me

losing an abortion adoption excuse me losing an adoption knowing that they

losing an adoption knowing that they

losing an adoption knowing that they have empty arms but a full heart empty

have empty arms but a full heart empty

have empty arms but a full heart empty not has not only been the gateway to a

not has not only been the gateway to a

not has not only been the gateway to a harsh reality but it has also been a way

harsh reality but it has also been a way

harsh reality but it has also been a way for me to heal

has been a way for me to relate to other

has been a way for me to relate to other parents who didn’t who’ve endured this

parents who didn’t who’ve endured this

parents who didn’t who’ve endured this awful circumstance Taylor participants

awful circumstance Taylor participants

awful circumstance Taylor participants of empty she recently shared with me

of empty she recently shared with me

of empty she recently shared with me that she’s expecting twins she said that

that she’s expecting twins she said that

that she’s expecting twins she said that in no way did she realize that by

in no way did she realize that by

in no way did she realize that by sharing her story they would help her

sharing her story they would help her

sharing her story they would help her heal and in no way did she realize that

heal and in no way did she realize that

heal and in no way did she realize that by sharing her story they would actually

by sharing her story they would actually

by sharing her story they would actually help her transition into this new life

help her transition into this new life

help her transition into this new life with her new children how great is that

empty has created a conversation what

empty has created a conversation what will you do next time someone you love

will you do next time someone you love

will you do next time someone you love faces child loss take a step forward

faces child loss take a step forward

faces child loss take a step forward instead of taking a step back be a

instead of taking a step back be a

instead of taking a step back be a friend and lend a hand say nothing and

friend and lend a hand say nothing and

friend and lend a hand say nothing and listen you will learn so much from the

listen you will learn so much from the

listen you will learn so much from the strong and courageous individuals who

strong and courageous individuals who

strong and courageous individuals who are willing to share their empty thank

are willing to share their empty thank

are willing to share their empty thank you

you

you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *