Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dogmatic Science and Pragmatic Spirituality | Dr. Goutam Paul | TEDxIIESTShibpur


there is a subtle difference between the

there is a subtle difference between the two terms religion and spirituality

two terms religion and spirituality

two terms religion and spirituality spirituality deals with principles and

spirituality deals with principles and

spirituality deals with principles and religion deals with formal expression of

religion deals with formal expression of

religion deals with formal expression of those principles but in this talk I will

those principles but in this talk I will

those principles but in this talk I will not make any distinction between

not make any distinction between

not make any distinction between religion and spirituality a common

religion and spirituality a common

religion and spirituality a common perception of religion or spirituality

perception of religion or spirituality

perception of religion or spirituality is that it is very dogmatic and a common

is that it is very dogmatic and a common

is that it is very dogmatic and a common view of science is that it is very

view of science is that it is very

view of science is that it is very pragmatic now I want to argue that

pragmatic now I want to argue that

pragmatic now I want to argue that science is at least as dogmatic as

science is at least as dogmatic as

science is at least as dogmatic as so-called spirituality and spirituality

so-called spirituality and spirituality

so-called spirituality and spirituality is no less pragmatic than science the

is no less pragmatic than science the

is no less pragmatic than science the features based on which religion or

features based on which religion or

features based on which religion or spirituality is termed to be dogmatic

spirituality is termed to be dogmatic

spirituality is termed to be dogmatic can be classified mainly into three

can be classified mainly into three

can be classified mainly into three categories number one unquestionable

categories number one unquestionable

categories number one unquestionable faith on the scriptures you are not

faith on the scriptures you are not

faith on the scriptures you are not allowed to question you have to accept

allowed to question you have to accept

allowed to question you have to accept them as they are

them as they are

them as they are second strict adherence to the rituals

second strict adherence to the rituals

second strict adherence to the rituals prescribed by any particular religion

prescribed by any particular religion

prescribed by any particular religion and third unflinching faith in the

and third unflinching faith in the

and third unflinching faith in the preachers and the saints of any

preachers and the saints of any

preachers and the saints of any particular religion now let us look at

particular religion now let us look at

particular religion now let us look at science is the science free from all

science is the science free from all

science is the science free from all these things I say no the textbooks and

these things I say no the textbooks and

these things I say no the textbooks and the journals and the conference papers

the journals and the conference papers

the journals and the conference papers those are like the scriptures of science

those are like the scriptures of science

those are like the scriptures of science often people say that because this

often people say that because this

often people say that because this article has been published in you know

article has been published in you know

article has been published in you know so-and-so journal therefore it must be

so-and-so journal therefore it must be

so-and-so journal therefore it must be correct

correct

correct similarly every University every college

similarly every University every college

similarly every University every college has its own rituals rituals in the form

has its own rituals rituals in the form

has its own rituals rituals in the form of mode of teaching mode of interaction

of mode of teaching mode of interaction

of mode of teaching mode of interaction between students and teachers the format

between students and teachers the format

between students and teachers the format in which you do experiments you present

in which you do experiments you present

in which you do experiments you present results you

results you

results you create your dissertation everywhere

create your dissertation everywhere

create your dissertation everywhere there is ritual and hard we have faith

there is ritual and hard we have faith

there is ritual and hard we have faith in our teachers faith in the scientists

in our teachers faith in the scientists

in our teachers faith in the scientists whose work we study without which we

whose work we study without which we

whose work we study without which we cannot progress now let us look at

cannot progress now let us look at

cannot progress now let us look at science how it is pragmatic the

science how it is pragmatic the

science how it is pragmatic the pragmatism of science mainly can be

pragmatism of science mainly can be

pragmatism of science mainly can be classified into three categories again

classified into three categories again

classified into three categories again first science tries to solve practical

first science tries to solve practical

first science tries to solve practical problems it tries to make our life more

problems it tries to make our life more

problems it tries to make our life more comfortable number two science is based

comfortable number two science is based

comfortable number two science is based on logic and reasoning cause-and-effect

on logic and reasoning cause-and-effect

on logic and reasoning cause-and-effect and number three science is verifiable

and number three science is verifiable

and number three science is verifiable whatever claim you make either that can

whatever claim you make either that can

whatever claim you make either that can be proved or that can be experimentally

be proved or that can be experimentally

be proved or that can be experimentally verified now I would like to argue that

verified now I would like to argue that

verified now I would like to argue that religion or spirituality also has the

religion or spirituality also has the

religion or spirituality also has the same features how science tries to solve

same features how science tries to solve

same features how science tries to solve problems of the outside world let’s say

problems of the outside world let’s say

problems of the outside world let’s say you are in an air-conditioned room and

you are in an air-conditioned room and

you are in an air-conditioned room and you hear the news of someone beloved

you hear the news of someone beloved

you hear the news of someone beloved just passed away so can you enjoy the

just passed away so can you enjoy the

just passed away so can you enjoy the soothing breeze of the air-conditioner

soothing breeze of the air-conditioner

soothing breeze of the air-conditioner at that moment I bet not if the outside

at that moment I bet not if the outside

at that moment I bet not if the outside world is in perfect shape but your

world is in perfect shape but your

world is in perfect shape but your inside is in mess then that perfection

inside is in mess then that perfection

inside is in mess then that perfection of the outside wall has no meaning on

of the outside wall has no meaning on

of the outside wall has no meaning on the other hand even if the outside wall

the other hand even if the outside wall

the other hand even if the outside wall is in perfect mess but your inside world

is in perfect mess but your inside world

is in perfect mess but your inside world is calm and composed there is hope for

is calm and composed there is hope for

is calm and composed there is hope for survival so science and spirituality

survival so science and spirituality

survival so science and spirituality work at a different level our well-being

work at a different level our well-being

work at a different level our well-being our happiness ultimately depends on a

our happiness ultimately depends on a

our happiness ultimately depends on a perfect balance between the inside world

perfect balance between the inside world

perfect balance between the inside world and the outside world science addresses

and the outside world science addresses

and the outside world science addresses how to solve the problems in the outside

how to solve the problems in the outside

how to solve the problems in the outside world and spirituality addresses how to

world and spirituality addresses how to

world and spirituality addresses how to solve problems in the inside world next

solve problems in the inside world next

solve problems in the inside world next like science all the spiritual texts

like science all the spiritual texts

like science all the spiritual texts of all religion if you deeply study you

of all religion if you deeply study you

of all religion if you deeply study you can find that they are based on absolute

can find that they are based on absolute

can find that they are based on absolute logic every verse followed from the

logic every verse followed from the

logic every verse followed from the previous verse logically though often in

previous verse logically though often in

previous verse logically though often in public those things are not discussed

public those things are not discussed

public those things are not discussed for other reasons for example if you

for other reasons for example if you

for other reasons for example if you look at bhagavad-gita the Indian

look at bhagavad-gita the Indian

look at bhagavad-gita the Indian philosophy is developed based on

philosophy is developed based on

philosophy is developed based on questions and answers arguments and

questions and answers arguments and

questions and answers arguments and counter-arguments in science we have

counter-arguments in science we have

counter-arguments in science we have good teachers and bad teachers in

good teachers and bad teachers in

good teachers and bad teachers in spirituality also we have good teachers

spirituality also we have good teachers

spirituality also we have good teachers and bad teachers so a good teacher in

and bad teachers so a good teacher in

and bad teachers so a good teacher in science can explain new things can

science can explain new things can

science can explain new things can entertain questions

entertain questions

entertain questions similarly in spirituality also a good a

similarly in spirituality also a good a

similarly in spirituality also a good a spiritual master will encourage

spiritual master will encourage

spiritual master will encourage questions and arguments from you the

questions and arguments from you the

questions and arguments from you the third category that verifiability

third category that verifiability

third category that verifiability spirituality also has verifiability

spirituality also has verifiability

spirituality also has verifiability if you follow a particular spiritual

if you follow a particular spiritual

if you follow a particular spiritual practice as per the specification under

practice as per the specification under

practice as per the specification under the guidance of a proper teacher then

the guidance of a proper teacher then

the guidance of a proper teacher then you can feel whatever theory is proposed

you can feel whatever theory is proposed

you can feel whatever theory is proposed whether that is true or not

whether that is true or not

whether that is true or not so in science we do experiments and

so in science we do experiments and

so in science we do experiments and after the experimental results will

after the experimental results will

after the experimental results will claim yes my original hypothesis was

claim yes my original hypothesis was

claim yes my original hypothesis was correct or wrong similarly in

correct or wrong similarly in

correct or wrong similarly in spirituality after we do the experiment

spirituality after we do the experiment

spirituality after we do the experiment we have the right to say yes it is

we have the right to say yes it is

we have the right to say yes it is acceptable or it is not okay now let us

acceptable or it is not okay now let us

acceptable or it is not okay now let us turn into two broad approaches that is

turn into two broad approaches that is

turn into two broad approaches that is followed in science

followed in science

followed in science the first one is deductive approach the

the first one is deductive approach the

the first one is deductive approach the second one is inductive approach the

second one is inductive approach the

second one is inductive approach the deductive approach consists of axioms

deductive approach consists of axioms

deductive approach consists of axioms rules of inference theorems and proofs

rules of inference theorems and proofs

rules of inference theorems and proofs axioms are like statements assumptions

axioms are like statements assumptions

axioms are like statements assumptions which you cannot prove for example you

which you cannot prove for example you

which you cannot prove for example you have Euclid’s axioms for the subject of

have Euclid’s axioms for the subject of

have Euclid’s axioms for the subject of geometry you have postulates for the

geometry you have postulates for the

geometry you have postulates for the subject of quantum mechanics etc rules

subject of quantum mechanics etc rules

subject of quantum mechanics etc rules of inference tell you how to derive one

of inference tell you how to derive one

of inference tell you how to derive one step from the previous step in a

step from the previous step in a

step from the previous step in a mathematical argument

mathematical argument

mathematical argument theorems of statements which are either

theorems of statements which are either

theorems of statements which are either true or false and a proof is a sequence

true or false and a proof is a sequence

true or false and a proof is a sequence of steps starting from some axioms and

of steps starting from some axioms and

of steps starting from some axioms and ending in the theorem statement

ending in the theorem statement

ending in the theorem statement following the rules of inference most of

following the rules of inference most of

following the rules of inference most of the disciplines under the broad category

the disciplines under the broad category

the disciplines under the broad category of mathematics try to follow this

of mathematics try to follow this

of mathematics try to follow this approach the deductive approach but

approach the deductive approach but

approach the deductive approach but there are other sciences as well like

there are other sciences as well like

there are other sciences as well like biology chemistry psychology sociology

biology chemistry psychology sociology

biology chemistry psychology sociology that take another approach which is

that take another approach which is

that take another approach which is called the inductive approach where we

called the inductive approach where we

called the inductive approach where we have axioms we have hypotheses that

have axioms we have hypotheses that

have axioms we have hypotheses that means some statements which can be

means some statements which can be

means some statements which can be either true or false but then instead of

either true or false but then instead of

either true or false but then instead of proof we have experiments and

proof we have experiments and

proof we have experiments and observation and based on the observation

observation and based on the observation

observation and based on the observation we conclude whether the hypothesis was

we conclude whether the hypothesis was

we conclude whether the hypothesis was correct or wrong

correct or wrong

correct or wrong now there are many people who believe

now there are many people who believe

now there are many people who believe that eventually all the inductive

that eventually all the inductive

that eventually all the inductive sciences can be converted to deductive

sciences can be converted to deductive

sciences can be converted to deductive science and ultimately we can explain

science and ultimately we can explain

science and ultimately we can explain everything in the form of mathematical

everything in the form of mathematical

everything in the form of mathematical equations but actually that is wrong

equations but actually that is wrong

equations but actually that is wrong because the deductive system itself has

because the deductive system itself has

because the deductive system itself has its inherent limitations to summarize

its inherent limitations to summarize

its inherent limitations to summarize there are two famous results by

there are two famous results by

there are two famous results by mathematician card gödel the first one

mathematician card gödel the first one

mathematician card gödel the first one says that in any deductive system there

says that in any deductive system there

says that in any deductive system there will always be some statements which are

will always be some statements which are

will always be some statements which are true but which cannot be proved within

true but which cannot be proved within

true but which cannot be proved within the system you can prove those

the system you can prove those

the system you can prove those statements provided you add more axioms

statements provided you add more axioms

statements provided you add more axioms you add more rules to the system to

you add more rules to the system to

you add more rules to the system to create a larger system but in that

create a larger system but in that

create a larger system but in that larger system itself you will have new

larger system itself you will have new

larger system itself you will have new statements which are true and not

statements which are true and not

statements which are true and not provable in the larger system so you can

provable in the larger system so you can

provable in the larger system so you can build on and on and on and go ad

build on and on and on and go ad

build on and on and on and go ad infinitum at each stage you can prove

infinitum at each stage you can prove

infinitum at each stage you can prove lower system but you cannot prove the

lower system but you cannot prove the

lower system but you cannot prove the system that you build in so there will

system that you build in so there will

system that you build in so there will always remain some truths out there in

always remain some truths out there in

always remain some truths out there in the universe which will not be covered

the universe which will not be covered

the universe which will not be covered by any mathematical theory the second

by any mathematical theory the second

by any mathematical theory the second result says that no axiomatic system or

result says that no axiomatic system or

result says that no axiomatic system or deductive system can verify its own

deductive system can verify its own

deductive system can verify its own consistency now consistency is a very

consistency now consistency is a very

consistency now consistency is a very simple thing it means that you cannot

simple thing it means that you cannot

simple thing it means that you cannot say a statement is both

say a statement is both

say a statement is both true and false at the same time for

true and false at the same time for

true and false at the same time for example I cannot claim that right now

example I cannot claim that right now

example I cannot claim that right now right here it is raining as well as not

right here it is raining as well as not

right here it is raining as well as not raining right now what this result says

raining right now what this result says

raining right now what this result says is is that no axiom system can prove or

is is that no axiom system can prove or

is is that no axiom system can prove or verify its own consistency but we have

verify its own consistency but we have

verify its own consistency but we have an inherent assumption that an exam

an inherent assumption that an exam

an inherent assumption that an exam system is consistent otherwise the whole

system is consistent otherwise the whole

system is consistent otherwise the whole paradigm the whole science will pull ups

paradigm the whole science will pull ups

paradigm the whole science will pull ups but the problem is we cannot prove it we

but the problem is we cannot prove it we

but the problem is we cannot prove it we have to assume so that is a strong faith

have to assume so that is a strong faith

have to assume so that is a strong faith of course we can add more axioms we can

of course we can add more axioms we can

of course we can add more axioms we can extend a system in order to prove

extend a system in order to prove

extend a system in order to prove consistency of the lower system but

consistency of the lower system but

consistency of the lower system but again the larger system becomes devoid

again the larger system becomes devoid

again the larger system becomes devoid of any proof of consistency so there

of any proof of consistency so there

of any proof of consistency so there lies a big question of faith and

lies a big question of faith and

lies a big question of faith and assumption in the correctness of any

assumption in the correctness of any

assumption in the correctness of any theory that we can make I claim that

theory that we can make I claim that

theory that we can make I claim that spirituality is an inductive science

spirituality is an inductive science

spirituality is an inductive science like the other inductive sciences is the

like the other inductive sciences is the

like the other inductive sciences is the example I have given so an example of

example I have given so an example of

example I have given so an example of axiom could be existence of soul or

axiom could be existence of soul or

axiom could be existence of soul or existence of God an example of

existence of God an example of

existence of God an example of hypothesis could be for example if you

hypothesis could be for example if you

hypothesis could be for example if you connect soul to God then the soul

connect soul to God then the soul

connect soul to God then the soul becomes happy example of experiments and

becomes happy example of experiments and

becomes happy example of experiments and observation could be prayers meditation

observation could be prayers meditation

observation could be prayers meditation chanting etc and after you perform the

chanting etc and after you perform the

chanting etc and after you perform the experiment you see the effect you have

experiment you see the effect you have

experiment you see the effect you have the right to deny the hypothesis or

the right to deny the hypothesis or

the right to deny the hypothesis or accept the hypothesis in the form of

accept the hypothesis in the form of

accept the hypothesis in the form of conclusion now I would talk about five

conclusion now I would talk about five

conclusion now I would talk about five major blames that science puts on

major blames that science puts on

major blames that science puts on spirituality and I would like to show

spirituality and I would like to show

spirituality and I would like to show that science itself is not free from

that science itself is not free from

that science itself is not free from those blames number ones religions are

those blames number ones religions are

those blames number ones religions are the root of all riots and fights that is

the root of all riots and fights that is

the root of all riots and fights that is happening in the world should not all

happening in the world should not all

happening in the world should not all religions be banned my argument would be

religions be banned my argument would be

religions be banned my argument would be physics and chemistry are the source of

physics and chemistry are the source of

physics and chemistry are the source of all bombs and all nuclear weapons and

all bombs and all nuclear weapons and

all bombs and all nuclear weapons and all the disaster all guns that is

all the disaster all guns that is

all the disaster all guns that is happening in the world so should not

happening in the world so should not

happening in the world so should not physics and chemistry be banned

physics and chemistry be banned

physics and chemistry be banned altogether should not I instantly blamed

altogether should not I instantly blamed

altogether should not I instantly blamed for his equal to MC square because that

for his equal to MC square because that

for his equal to MC square because that was responsible for the atomic explosion

was responsible for the atomic explosion

was responsible for the atomic explosion in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

in Hiroshima and Nagasaki so our mode of thinking is of course

so our mode of thinking is of course

so our mode of thinking is of course wrong

wrong

wrong the same knife in the hand of a surgeon

the same knife in the hand of a surgeon

the same knife in the hand of a surgeon can save a life and the same knife in

can save a life and the same knife in

can save a life and the same knife in the hand of a murderer can take a life

the hand of a murderer can take a life

the hand of a murderer can take a life so it is not the problem of religion or

so it is not the problem of religion or

so it is not the problem of religion or science parts say it is how we use them

science parts say it is how we use them

science parts say it is how we use them it is our intention second point this is

it is our intention second point this is

it is our intention second point this is a picture of a child born of the nuclear

a picture of a child born of the nuclear

a picture of a child born of the nuclear disaster so you can see how much role a

disaster so you can see how much role a

disaster so you can see how much role a science can play the second point is why

science can play the second point is why

science can play the second point is why follow a particular path cannot everyone

follow a particular path cannot everyone

follow a particular path cannot everyone invent one’s own spiritual path or you

invent one’s own spiritual path or you

invent one’s own spiritual path or you don’t have to call it a spiritual path

don’t have to call it a spiritual path

don’t have to call it a spiritual path you say the path of your own life from

you say the path of your own life from

you say the path of your own life from your own experience and then leave your

your own experience and then leave your

your own experience and then leave your life according to it well in science

life according to it well in science

life according to it well in science does everyone reinvent the will when you

does everyone reinvent the will when you

does everyone reinvent the will when you go to a new apartment before taking your

go to a new apartment before taking your

go to a new apartment before taking your electricity connection do you decide to

electricity connection do you decide to

electricity connection do you decide to do research on your own to find out the

do research on your own to find out the

do research on your own to find out the best mode of power generation and then

best mode of power generation and then

best mode of power generation and then subscribe to electric supply corporation

subscribe to electric supply corporation

subscribe to electric supply corporation or whatsoever know both in science and

or whatsoever know both in science and

or whatsoever know both in science and in spirituality anyone is welcome to try

in spirituality anyone is welcome to try

in spirituality anyone is welcome to try invent new paths to create new ideas

invent new paths to create new ideas

invent new paths to create new ideas however one cannot do everything in one

however one cannot do everything in one

however one cannot do everything in one lifetime so you have to begin somewhere

lifetime so you have to begin somewhere

lifetime so you have to begin somewhere you have to take some things which

you have to take some things which

you have to take some things which others have done research on in both the

others have done research on in both the

others have done research on in both the disciplines next science says that why

disciplines next science says that why

disciplines next science says that why you should follow a particular a guru or

you should follow a particular a guru or

you should follow a particular a guru or a spiritual master one can read and

a spiritual master one can read and

a spiritual master one can read and understand and practice on one’s own if

understand and practice on one’s own if

understand and practice on one’s own if at all one wishes to follow a spiritual

at all one wishes to follow a spiritual

at all one wishes to follow a spiritual path in science don’t we have PhD

path in science don’t we have PhD

path in science don’t we have PhD supervisors don’t we have lab

supervisors don’t we have lab

supervisors don’t we have lab instructors of course few geniuses are

instructors of course few geniuses are

instructors of course few geniuses are out there who may not need any guidance

out there who may not need any guidance

out there who may not need any guidance so in spirituality also we might have

so in spirituality also we might have

so in spirituality also we might have some geniuses who may not need any a

some geniuses who may not need any a

some geniuses who may not need any a guru but for the common mass we need a

guru but for the common mass we need a

guru but for the common mass we need a guide we need a supervisor in both the

guide we need a supervisor in both the

guide we need a supervisor in both the discipline it’s not spirituality and

discipline it’s not spirituality and

discipline it’s not spirituality and religion the source of all superstition

religion the source of all superstition

religion the source of all superstition for example the untouchability that has

for example the untouchability that has

for example the untouchability that has been talked about other vulnerabilities

been talked about other vulnerabilities

been talked about other vulnerabilities well the answer to that is is not say

well the answer to that is is not say

well the answer to that is is not say mobile phone the source of all MMA

mobile phone the source of all MMA

mobile phone the source of all MMA scandals so should we all throw away our

scandals so should we all throw away our

scandals so should we all throw away our Mobile’s is not credit card the source

Mobile’s is not credit card the source

Mobile’s is not credit card the source of all the fraud that is happening in

of all the fraud that is happening in

of all the fraud that is happening in the digital banking industry should you

the digital banking industry should you

the digital banking industry should you go back to our cash based banking system

go back to our cash based banking system

go back to our cash based banking system of course not so in science what we try

of course not so in science what we try

of course not so in science what we try to do we try to build protection

to do we try to build protection

to do we try to build protection mechanism we try to educate people about

mechanism we try to educate people about

mechanism we try to educate people about the potential vulnerabilities so

the potential vulnerabilities so

the potential vulnerabilities so similarly if you go deep into any

similarly if you go deep into any

similarly if you go deep into any religion or any spirituality you will

religion or any spirituality you will

religion or any spirituality you will find that those blames are actually

find that those blames are actually

find that those blames are actually baseless just like people misuse these

baseless just like people misuse these

baseless just like people misuse these technologies for their own benefit

technologies for their own benefit

technologies for their own benefit similarly there are people who misuse

similarly there are people who misuse

similarly there are people who misuse spirituality and religion for their own

spirituality and religion for their own

spirituality and religion for their own benefit just to make money or to make

benefit just to make money or to make

benefit just to make money or to make votes no spiritual principle talks about

votes no spiritual principle talks about

votes no spiritual principle talks about these things so we have to educate

these things so we have to educate

these things so we have to educate people we have to spread the awareness

people we have to spread the awareness

people we have to spread the awareness and then there will be the same

and then there will be the same

and then there will be the same protection mechanism just like in the

protection mechanism just like in the

protection mechanism just like in the mobile phone or in the credit card the

mobile phone or in the credit card the

mobile phone or in the credit card the last one is not spirituality intangible

last one is not spirituality intangible

last one is not spirituality intangible is not the result produced by

is not the result produced by

is not the result produced by spirituality intangible well yes science

spirituality intangible well yes science

spirituality intangible well yes science do produce tangible result for example a

do produce tangible result for example a

do produce tangible result for example a sea in the summer but spirituality as I

sea in the summer but spirituality as I

sea in the summer but spirituality as I have already described is an EC for the

have already described is an EC for the

have already described is an EC for the summer of the mind we see that in

summer of the mind we see that in

summer of the mind we see that in schools and colleges in universities we

schools and colleges in universities we

schools and colleges in universities we have formal education of the so-called

have formal education of the so-called

have formal education of the so-called science however proper formal teaching

science however proper formal teaching

science however proper formal teaching and formal education on the logical

and formal education on the logical

and formal education on the logical reasoning about spirituality and

reasoning about spirituality and

reasoning about spirituality and religion is missing as we have seen that

religion is missing as we have seen that

religion is missing as we have seen that spirituality is no less science than

spirituality is no less science than

spirituality is no less science than science itself

science itself

science itself so either we accept both or reject both

so either we accept both or reject both

so either we accept both or reject both thank you very much

thank you very much

thank you very much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *